Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-100

1983-100Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

June 29, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 100
John O'Leary, Jr.
State Bank Commissioner
700 Jackson, Suite 300
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Banks and Banking -- Banking Code; Powers -- Branch
Banking Prohibition; Interstate Contract for Use
of Remote Service Units
Synopsis: K.S.A. 9-1111(f) provides that any state bank or
national banking association located in Kansas may
operate remote service units, by means of which
banking transactions may take place. Such facili-
ties may be located anywhere within the state, in-
cluding at the place of business specified in the
bank's certificate of authority. Any state bank
or national banking association located in Kansas
may enter into agreements with any other banks
having their principal place of business in this
state for the joint operation of such facilities.
In the absence of statutory authority, however,
Kansas banks may not enter into such contracts with
state or national banks located in other states.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 9-1111, K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
17-5565, 12 U.S.C. §36.
*
Dear Commissioner O'Leary:
As Bank Commissioner for the State of Kansas, you have re-
quested the opinion of this office on a matter concerning
the operation of remote service units, as that term is used
in K.S.A. 9-1111. This statute, the so-called branch bank-
ing statute, allows a state or national bank to operate re-
mote service units in this state, and does not consider such
units to be branches, the operation of which is prohibited.
Your inquiry stems from a situation involving a Kansas state
bank and a national bank located in Missouri, and raises the
question of whether two banks so situated may jointly operate
remote service units.
Prior to examining the legal issues involved, a brief summary
of the facts set out in your letter and the accompanying
materials would be helpful. United Missouri Bank of Kansas
City, N.A., (UMB) is a national banking association organized
and doing business in Kansas City, Missouri. Almost 100% of
its stock is owned by United Missouri Bancshares, a Missouri
bank holding company that also owns a controlling interest
in 19 other Missouri banking corporations. UMB has obtained
the right to use the name "Ultra" in connection with automa-
tic teller machines and the encoded plastic cards used to
activate such machines. It has entered into contracts with 7
other banks in the Kansas City metropolitan area whereby the
banks, referred to as correspondent banks, may use the Ultra
name in connection with automatic teller machines located on
their premises. While 5 of the 7 banks are controlled by
United Missouri Bancshares, one of the others is a Kansas
bank located in Overland Park, Kansas. The contracts have
resulted in a network of automatic teller machines operating
at 15 locations, each of which is tied in to the central com-
puter at UMB. Each correspondent bank either owns or leases
the machines located on its premises.
As part of the contract, the correspondent bank permits custo-
mers of UMB, as well as all other banks who have signed con-
tracts with UMB, to have access to its Ultra machine. The
Ultra card activates the machine, and allows the customer to
perform six different transactions: withdrawal of cash from
a checking account; transfer of money from a checking account
to a savings account; transfer of money from a savings account
to a checking account; withdrawal of cash from a MasterCard
line of credit; transfer of money from a MasterCard line of
credit to a checking account; and inquiries concerning account
balances. Therefore, a UMB customer with an Ultra card may
enter into any of the above transactions at any of the 15
locations, including those in Kansas. Likewise, a customer
of the Overland Park bank may use both the Kansas and Missouri
machines for his or her banking transactions. Each transac-
tion is reflected in the computer record at UMB, and the
changed balance in a customer's account will subsequently
show in all 15 of the outlets.
The legal question presented by this fact situation concerns
the authority of the Overland Park bank to enter into such
an agreement with a bank in another state. The fact that UMB
is a national association is not determintive, for in ques-
tions regarding branch banking, state law controls when, where,
and how a national bank may branch, if indeed it may do so at all.
State ex rel. Edwards v. Heimann, 633 F.2d 886 (9th Cir. 1980),
applying 12 U.S.C. §36. Accordingly, reference must be had to the
applicable provision of the Kansas Banking Code, specifically,
K.S.A. 9-1111. We further note that, in the interest of main-
taining competitive equality between state and national banks
[First National Bank v. Walker Bank & Trust Co., 385 U.S. 252,
17 L.Ed.2d 343 (1966)], remote service units have been held by
federal courts to constitute branch banks. State of Colorado v.
First National Bank of Fort Collins, 540 F.2d 497 (10th Cir.
1976), and cases cited at 499.
Initially, K.S.A. 9-1111 contains a general prohibition against
establishment of any branch bank, office, agency or place of
business by a bank doing business in this state. Three excep-
tions are then made to this general prohibition, e.g. for
attached auxiliary teller facilities, detached auxiliary bank-
ing service facilities, and remote service units. Remote
service units are defined at K.S.A. 9-1111(h) to mean the
following:
"an electronic information processing device,
including associated equipment, structures
and systems, through or by means of which in-
formation relating to financial services ren-
dered to the public is stored and transmitted,
whether instantaneously or otherwise, to a
bank and which, for activation and account
access, is dependent upon the use of a machine-
readable instrument in the possession and con-
trol of the holder of an account with a bank.
The term shall include 'online' computer ter-
minals and 'offline' automated cash dispensing
machines and automated teller machines, but
shall not include computer terminals or auto-
mated teller machines . . ."
From the above, there can be no question that the automatic
teller machines described above fall within the class of remote
service units for purposes of Kansas law.
Authorization for operation of remote service units is con-
tained in subsection (f) of the statute, which states:
"any state bank or national banking associa-
tion having its principal office and main
banking house in this state, individually or
jointly with one or more state banks or
national banking associations having their
principal offices and main banking houses in
this state, may provide, and engage in bank-
ing transactions by means of remote service
units located anywhere within the state of
Kansas, which remote service units shall not
be considered to be branch banks, or branch
offices, agencies or places of business, or
detached auxiliary services facilities autho-
rized herein. Any banking transaction ef-
fected by use of a remote service unit shall
be deemed to be transacted at a bank and not
at a remote service unit;" (Emphasis added.)
It is important to note that while the subsection allows the
joint operation of remote service units by two or more state
or national banks, the grant of authority is explicitly limited
to those banks "having their principal offices and main bank-
ing houses in this state." While subsection (g) permits the
type of unit sharing which was described above, i.e., a bank
with a remote service unit must allow customers of another
bank to use the facility, subsection (f) controls the type
of agreements which can be made initially for the joint opera-
tion of such facilities, and is silent as to the type of
agreement entered into in the above scenario.
Also relevant is the recent action of the 1982 Kansas Legisla-
ture in amending K.S.A. 17-5565. L. 1982, ch. 106. As amended,
this statute now allows savings and loan associations to con-
tract with other such associations for the operation of re-
mote service units in Kansas or in other states. There is
no requirement that all of the associations have their princi-
pal place of business in this state, for indeed the statute
expressly permits "foreign" savings and loan associations to
operate such units in Kansas, provided that reciprocal privi-
leges are afforded to Kansas associations in the other state.
Accordingly, it is clear that the legislature, when it desires
to do so, is capable of opening the door for out-of-state
financial institutions to operate remote service units in
Kansas. To date, it has not seen fit to amend K.S.A. 9-1111
in the Banking Code in the same way as K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
17-5565 of the Savings and Loan Code, and we are not prepared
to read into the former statute by implication what the leg-
islature has declined to put there expressly.
Therefore, in our opinion a Kansas bank is without authority
to enter into an agreement for the joint operation of remote
service units, such as automatic teller machines, with another
bank which does not have its principal place of business
located in this state.
Very truly yours,;
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey	S.S	outhard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.