Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-061

1983-061Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

April 22, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 61
The Honorable Mike Hayden
Speaker
House of Representatives
Room 377-W, Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas -- Finance
and Taxation -- Internal Improvements; Railroad
Loan Guarantee Fund
Synopsis: Article 11, §9 of the Kansas Constitution prohi-
bits the state of Kansas from expending state
moneys to guarantee loans made by the federal
government for railroad rehabilitation where the
federal government will be fully reimbursed on
the loans by the state. However, Article 11, §9
does not prohibit the legislature from providing
payment of state moneys in an amount not to exceed
one-half of the loss assumed by the federal govern-
ment in the event of default on any loan made for
a railroad project. Cited herein: Kan. Const.,
Art. 11, §9.
Dear Speaker Hayden:
You inquire by telephone today regarding a draft bill (attached)
establishing a railroad rehabilitation loan guarantee fund.
You ask if the proposed bill would violate Article 11, §9 of the
Kansas Constitution which provides:
"The state shall never be a party in carrying
on any work of internal improvement except
that: (1) It may adopt, construct, recon-
struct and maintain a state system of highways,
but no general property tax shall ever be laid
nor general obligation bonds issued by the
state for such highways; (2) it may be a party
to flood control works and works for the con-
servation or development of water resources;
(3) it may, whenever any work of internal im-
provement not authorized by (1) or (2) is once
authorized by a separate bill passed by the
affirmative vote of not less than two-thirds
of all members then elected (or appointed) and
qualified to each house, expend or distribute
funds received from the federal government
therefor and may participate with the federal
government therein by contributing any state
funds appropriated in accordance with law for
such purpose in any amount not exceeding the
amount received from the federal government
for such improvement, but no general property
tax shall ever be laid nor general obligation
bonds be issued by the state therefor; and (4)
it may expend funds received from the federal
government for any public purpose in accord-
ance with the federal law authorizing the
same."
First, we note that in our judgment the expenditure of state
moneys for the support of railroads makes the state a party
to a work of internal improvement. Thus, Art. 11, 59 is
applicable.
Second, if the proposed bill is to be effective, two proce-
dural requirements must be met: The bill must be passed by
a 2/3 vote of each house of the legislature since this pro-
posal could only proceed pursuant to Art. 11, §9(3), and
the federal contribution must have been "received" by the
state of Kansas for disbursement on any project. See Kan.
Att'y Gen. Op. No. 82-257, enclosed.
The proposal contemplates that the federal government will
loan some $18 million to a Kansas port authority. In the
event of default, the federal government will be repaid in
full with interest from assets of the defunct railroads and
the moneys appropriated from the proposed railroad rehabili-
tation loan guarantee fund. While there is some confusing
language in the bill which makes Sections 1 and 2 difficult
to construe together, we have attempted to address the in-
tent and general purpose of the bill in expressing our opinion.
In our opinion, the bill as drafted would contravene Article
11, 59. Without belaboring this opinion with detail, we
note that such a procedure means that in the event of a de-
fault on the loan, the State of Kansas would pay an amount
exceeding the amount ultimately expended by the federal govern-
ment. In short, if there is no default on the loan the State
pays nothing. If there is a default, the federal government
pays nothing and the State pays for any loss beyond the
assets of the railroads involved. We believe such proposal
to be unconsitutitional.
Being cognizant of the needs of Kansans for rail service
and the desire of the Kansas Legislature to respond to those
needs, we are happy to suggest an alternative method of pro-
moting the federal loan proposal. In our judgment, Article
11, §9 would not prohibit the legislature from amending the
proposed bill to provide for the payment by the State of
Kansas of an amount not to exceed one-half the loss assumed
by the federal government in the event of default on any
loan for a particular railroad project. Thus, in the event
of a default, both the federal and state governments would
absorb equal portions of the loss on the principal and in-
terest of the loans.
We cannot speculate on what response this proposal will re-
ceive in Washington, but it seems most fair and responsible
to us. More importantly, however, this latter suggestion
represents the limits to which the state of Kansas may con-
stitutionally participate in works of internal improvements
such as railroad rehabilitation.
In summary, it is our opinion that Article 11, §9 of the
Kansas Constitution prohibits the state of Kansas from ex-
pending state moneys to guarantee loans made by the federal
government for railroad rehabilitation where the federal
government will be fully reimbursed on the loans by the state.
However, Article 11, §9 does not prohibit the legislature
from providing payment of state moneys in an amount not to
exceed one-half of the loss assumed by the federal government
in the event of default on any loan made for a railroad project.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
BradleyJ.Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:hle
Enc.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.