Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-221

1982-221Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

October 21, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 221
Alan F. Alderson
General Counsel
Kansas Department of Revenue
State Office Building
Topeka, Kansas 66625
Re: Crimes and Punishments--Crimes Against the
Public Morals--Illegal Bingo Operation
Synopsis: The provisions of K.S.A. 79-4701 et seq., and
amendments thereto, which provide for the licensing,
regulation and taxing of bingo games conducted
by certain bona fide nonprofit organizations, may
not be enforced against Indians conducting bingo
games upon Indian reservations within the territorial
boundaries of the state of Kansas. However, other
state gambling statutes, which restrict gambling
activities other than games of bingo, may be enforced
upon Indian reservations. Cited herein: K.S.A.
21-4302, 21-4303, 21-4303a, 21-4304, 79-4701,
79-4702, 79-4703, 79-4704, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-4705,
79-4706, K.S.A. 79-4708, L. 1982, ch. 425, §§1-3,
Kan. Const., Art.. 15, §§3, 3a, 18 U.S.C. §1162,
18 U.S.C. §3243, 28 U.S.C. §1360.
* *
Dear Mr. Alderson:
You request our opinion as to whether the provisions of K.S.A.
79-4701 et seq., and amendments thereto, hereinafter referred
to as "the bingo act," apply on Indian reservations located in
the state of Kansas. Said act provides for the regulation,
licensing and taxing of games of bingo, and your questions
concerning the same are as follows:
"(1) Does the Bingo Tax Act, K.S.A. 79-4701
et seq., as amended, apply in its entirety,
to games conducted on Indian reservations?
"(2) If not, do any of the provisions of the Bingo
Tax Act apply and, if so, which ones?
"(3) Can we validly collect the enforcement tax
under provisions of the Act if the regulatory
provisions of the Act do not apply?
"(4) Can we validly contract with the Tribal
Councils of the respective tribes for purposes
of obtaining 6% of the gross proceeds generated
by bingo if the enforcement provisions and
regulatory provisions of the Act do not apply?
"(5) Can this department enforce the provisions of
the Act as to non-Indians playing on the reservations?
"(6) Would the use of 'pull tabs' be illegal?"
In order to construe the provisions of the bingo act, and determine
whether such provisions are applicable on Indian reservations,
it is necessary to consider the history of said act and state
laws relating to gambling and lotteries.
Prior to 1974, the operation of all forms of lotteries (including
bingo) was expressly prohibited under the provisions of Article 15,
Section 3 of the Kansas Constitution. State, ex rel., v. Kalb,
218 Kan. 459, 465 (1975). In 1974, the Kansas Constitution was
amended to permit the playing of bingo by certain specified
organizations, as follows:
"Notwithstanding the provisions of section
3 of article 15 of the constitution of the
state of Kansas the legislature may regulate,
license and tax the operation or conduct of
games of 'bingo,' as defined by law, by bona
fide nonprofit religious, charitable, fraternal,
educational and veterans organizations."
Kan. Const., Art. 15, §3a.
Pursuant to authority granted by this amendment, the Kansas
Legislature enacted K.S.A. 79-4701 et seq., providing for the
licensing, regulation and taxing of bingo games conducted by
bona fide nonprofit religious, charitable, fraternal, educational
and veterans' organizations. The bingo act defines the types
of organizations which are eligible for a license [K.S.A. 79-4701
(as amended by L. 1982, ch. 425, §1)] and prescribes procedures
for applying for licenses. [K.S.A. 79-4703 (as amended by L. 1982,
ch. 425, §2).] A license application fee in the amount of $25
is imposed [K.S.A. 79-4703 (as amended)], and a tax at the rate
of 3% of the gross receipts received is levied upon (and must be
collected and paid by) licensees (K.S.A. 79-4704). K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 79-4705 provides for the filing of returns and payment
of taxes by licensed organizations, and K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-4706
(as amended by L. 1982, ch. 425, §3) prescribes numerous restric-
tions relating to the management, operation and conduct of bingo
games by said organizations. Said restrictions include limitations
upon the aggregate value of prizes awarded or offered in any
single day [subsection (b)], number of games conducted per day
[subsection (g)], amount of prizes awarded for each game [subsection
(h)], amounts charged for bingo cards [subsection (i)], and
number of calendar days per week upon which bingo games may be
conducted [subsection (j)]. Additionally, K.S.A. 79-4702 provides
that "the power to regulate, license and tax the management,
operation and conduct of and participation in games of bingo
is hereby vested exclusively in the state," and K.S.A. 79-4708
stipulates that the secretary of revenue shall administer the
provisions of the bingo act and adopt and enforce rules and
regulations relative thereto.
The Kansas Criminal Code prescribes penalties for entering
or remaining in a gambling place with an intent to participate
in a lottery (K.S.A. 21-4303), and for conducting a lottery
[K.S.A. 21-4304(d)]. The term "lottery" is defined in sub-
sections (2) and (3) of K.S.A. 21-4302, as follows:
"(2) A 'lottery' is an enterprise where-
in for a consideration the participants
are given an opportunity to win a prize,
the award of which is determined by chance.
"(3) 'Consideration' as used in this section
means anything which is a commercial or financial
advantage to the promoter or a disadvantage
to any participant.
"Mere registration without purchase of goods
or services; personal attendance at places
or events, without payment of an admission
price or fee; listening to or watching radio
and television programs; answering the telephone
or making a telephone call and acts of like
nature are not consideration.
"As used in this subsection, the term 'con-
sideration' shall not include sums of money
paid by or for participants in any bingo game
managed, operated, or conducted in accordance
with the laws of the state of Kansas by any bona
fide nonprofit religious, charitable, fraternal,
educational or veteran organization licensed to
manage, operate, or conduct bingo games under
the laws of the state of Kansas and it shall be
conclusively presumed that such sums paid by or
for said participants were intended by said
participants to be for the benefit of the
sponsoring organizations for the use of such
sponsoring organizations in furthering the
purposes of such sponsoring organizations, as
set forth in the appropriate paragraphs of sub-
section (c) or in subsection (d) of section 501
of the internal revenue code of 1954, as amended,
and as set forth in K.S.A. 79-4701." (Emphasis
added.)
K.S.A. 21-4303a prohibits illegal bingo operations, and provides
as follows:
"(1) Illegal bingo operation is the manage-
ment, operation or conduct of games of bingo
in violation of the laws of the state of
Kansas pertaining to the regulation, licensing
and taxing of games of bingo or rules and
regulations adopted pursuant thereto. Illegal
bingo operation is a class A misdemeanor.
"(2) This section shall be a part of and
supplemental to the Kansas criminal code."
The last-cited statutes are part of the Kansas Criminal Code,
and the Kansas Supreme Court has recently held that the state
of Kansas has jurisdiction, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §3243, over
offenses committed by or against Indians on Indian reservations,
except as to certain major offenses (not including violation
of gambling laws). See State v. Mitchell, 231 Kan. 144 (1982).
On first glance, one might conclude that the decision in the
Mitchell case is dispositive of the questions which have been
posed. However, in order to determine whether penal provisions
related to violation of state bingo laws apply on Indian reservations,
it is necessary to consider two recent cases from other juris-
dictions.
In Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Butterworth, 658 F.2d 310 (5th
Circuit, 1981; U.S. cert. denied, 102 S.C. 1717) the Fifth Circuit
Court of Appeals considered the application of Florida bingo
laws upon the Seminole Indian Reservation. The state of Florida
had assumed criminal jurisdiction over reservation Indians pursuant
to Section 7 of former Public Law 83-280 (commonly referred to
as Public Law 280), 67 Stat. 588, 590 (1953) [repealed by Pub.L.
90-284, Title IV, §403, 82 Stat. 79 (1968)] and the state contended
that the penal provisions provided for violation of its bingo law
were enforceable upon the Indian reservation. The court, citing
Bryan v. Itasca County, 426 U.S. 373 (1976), concluded that the
assumption of jurisdiction under Public Law 280 did not give the
state general civil regulatory power over reservation Indians,
and stated that the question which the case turned upon was
whether the bingo law represented an exercise of the state's
regulatory (civil) or prohibitory (criminal) authority. After
stating that a state's public policy determines whether an activity
is prohibited or regulated, the court concluded as follows:
"Although the Florida Constitution, the
Florida Supreme Court, and the Florida
legislature have in various forms denounced
the 'evils of gambling,' it is clear from the
provisions of the bingo statute in question
and the statutory scheme of the Florida
gambling provisions considered as a whole
that the playing of bingo and operation
of bingo halls is not contrary to the public
policy of the state. Other courts prohibiting
other forms of gambling have found those forms
of gambling contrary to the public policy of
the state." (Emphasis added.) 658 F.2d at 316.
In Butterworth, the state had also petitioned the court for
a ruling that, even if the Florida bingo statute could not be
enforced against the Seminole Indian Tribe, the Indians must
distinguish between Indians and non-Indians and abide by the
restrictions of the bingo statute as to non-Indians. The court
rejected said petition, stating as follows:
"[W]e note that the statute in question,
Fla.Stat. §849.093, makes no reference to
violations of its restrictions by the players
of bingo. Sheriff Butterworth suggests that
several general lottery prohibition statutes,
such as Fla.Stat. §§849.08, 849.09(1) (b) , and
849.09(2), permit the arrest of bingo players
as players of illegal lotteries; however,
we refuse to recognize in one breath that
bingo is excluded from the general lottery
prohibition and in the next permit the arrest
of bingo players as players of illegal lotteries.
The statutes cited must be considered in pari
materia with the bingo statute permitting the
operation of bingo games. The bingo statute
does not prohibit the playing of bingo games
in violation of its restrictions, and if the
legislature of the state of Florida desires to
prohibit such, then it must act accordingly.
The courts that have prohibited Indians or non-
Indians from gambling on reservations have done
so in light of a statute that specifically
prohibits the act of gambling." (Emphasis by
court.) 658 F.2d at 316.
The second case which concerns the application of state bingo
laws upon an Indian reservation is . Oneida Tribe of Indians
of Wis. v. State of Wisconsin, 518 F.Supp. 712 (1981). In
said case, the Oneida Tribe sought a declaratory judgment that
Wisconsin statutes, relating to bingo operations, could not be
enforced on the Indian reservation. The case came before the
court on the state's motion to dismiss.
The court noted that the state had acquired limited civil
(adjudicatory) and general criminal jurisdiction upon Indian
reservations by virtue of Public Law 280, 18 U.S.C. 51162,
28 U.S.C. §1360, and determined that the applicability of the
bingo law on the Oneida Reservation depended upon whether said
law was criminal-prohibitory or civil-regulatory. The court
described the history of Wisconsin constitutional and statutory
provisions relating to bingo, as follows:
"Prior to 1973, the Wisconsin constitution
and Wisconsin statutes forbade the conduct
of any lottery, including bingo. In 1973,
the state's constitution was amended and
now provides:
"The legislature shall never authorize any
lottery, or grant any divorce.
"(1) The legislature may authorize bingo
games licensed by the state, and operated
by religious, charitable, service, fraternal
or veterans' organizations or those to which
contributions are deductible for federal or
state income tax purposes. All profits must
inure to the licensed organization and no
salaries, fees or profits shall be paid to
any other organization or person.
"Wis.Const., Art. IV, §24.
"Pursuant to this change in the state's
constitution, the Wisconsin legislature en-
acted Wis.Stats. Chapter 163, which governs
the conduct of bingo in the state, and amended
Wis.Stat. §945.01, pertaining to definitions
relating to gambling, to provide: '"Lottery"
does not include bingo or a raffle as defined
in s. 163.03 if conducted under ch. 163.'
Wis.Stat. §945.01(2)am)." 518 F.Supp. at 717.
The state of Wisconsin urged the court to adopt the following
construction of the state bingo laws:
"When chs. 945 and 163 Stats., and Wis-
consin Constitution art. IV, sec. 24 are
considered together, it is clear that the
laws applicable to persons engaged in un-
licensed bingo are primarily criminal rather
than civil regulatory. It is only after an
entity applies for and is granted a state
license to conduct bingo that the regulatory
provisions of ch. 163 become effective . . .
[S]ince, under the Wisconsin statutory
scheme, the state laws being applied are
primarily criminal in nature, the state
does have authorization under Public Law
280 to enforce those statutes against un-
authorized bingo activities conducted by
Oneida Tribe members on the Oneida Reservation."
518 F.Supp. at 717.
The court in Oneida rejected the state's position, stating as
follows:
"As noted earlier, defendants attempt to
demonstrate that Wisconsin's bingo laws
are prohibitory because only those organiza-
tions defined in the constitution and stat-
utes of the state are allowed to conduct
bingo games, and only under regulated cir-
cumstances. Defendants' argument misses
one important point: the general populace
of the state of Wisconsin is allowed to play
bingo. Moreover, the state law governing
bingo appears to provide penalties for those
who illegally conduct bingo games rather than
for those who merely play in such games. See
Wis.Stat. §163.54. Thus, because it
appears that Wisconsin's bingo laws are not
designed to prohibit the general populace
from playing bingo, it seems that those laws
are regulatory rather than prohibitory, at
least under the analysis employed by the
court in United States v. Marcyes.
"I conclude that when Congress conferred
jurisdiction on the State of Wisconsin to
enforce its criminal laws on the Oneida
Reservation, Congress intended to limit the
exercise of that jurisdiction to enforcement
of laws generally prohibiting activities that
the state determined are too dangerous, un-
healthy, or otherwise detrimental to the well-
being of the state's citizens. I conclude
also that Congress did not intend to allow
states to use licensing requirements in an
attempt to create jurisdiction to enforce
otherwise civil regulations on Indian reservations."
(Emphasis added.) 518 F.Supp. at 719-720.
Subsequent to the above ruling on the state's motion to dismiss,
the Oneida Tribe and the state of Wisconsin entered into a
stipulated judgment against the state in the Oneida case. 1
Although the state of Kansas has acquired criminal jurisdiction
over offenses committed on Indian reservations by a different
federal grant, i.e. 18 U.S.C. §3243, than that under which the
states of Florida and Wisconsin have acquired similar jurisdiction,
such fact is, in our opinion, irrelevant in considering whether
penal provisions related to violations of state bingo laws are
enforceable on Indian reservations. We are compelled by the
ruling in the Oneida case, and, to a lesser degree, by the
judgment in the Butterworth case, to conclude that the Kansas
bingo law may not be enforced against Indians conducting bingo
games upon Indian reservations within the territorial boundaries
of the state of Kansas. Accordingly, our responses to the
specific questions which have been posed are as follows:
"(1) Does the Bingo Tax Act, K.S.A. 79-4701
et seq., as amended, apply in its entirety,
to games conducted on Indian reservations?"
ANSWER: No
"(2) If not, do any of the provisions of the
Bingo Tax Act apply and, if so, which ones?"
l Information supplied by John Niemisto, Wisconsin Asst.
Att'y Gen.
ANSWER: None of the provisions of the act
apply to bingo games conducted by Indians
on Indian reservations.
"(3) Can we validly collect the enforcement tax
under provisions of the Act if the regulatory
provisions of the Act do not apply?"
ANSWER: The 3% tax upon gross receipts received
for participation in bingo games, or admission
fees connected therewith, is imposed upon licensees.
As Indians conducting bingo games on a reservation
need not, in our opinion, comply with the licensure
requirements or become "licensees," it is our
judgment that the Department of Revenue may not
collect the tax with respect to bingo games
conducted by Indians on Indian reservations.
"(4) Can we validly contract with the Tribal Councils
of the respective tribes for purposes of obtaining
6% of the gross proceeds generated by bingo if
the enforcement provisions and regulatory provisions
of the Act do not apply?"
ANSWER: The powers of a public officer or agency
are "those and only those which the law confers."
State ex rel. v. Younkin, 108 Kan. 634, 638 (1921).
In this regard, we are unaware of any statutory
provision which would expressly or impliedly
authorize the Department of Revenue to enter into
such a contract.
"(5) Can this department enforce the provisions of
the Act as to non-Indians playing on the reservations?"
ANSWER: No. See Seminole Tribe of Florida v.
Butterworth, supra.
"(6) Would the use of 'pull tabs' be illegal?"
ANSWER: As stated above, the state of Kansas
has jurisdication over criminal offenses committed
by or against Indians on Indian reservations.
Although penal provisions related to the conduct
of bingo games by Indians on reservations cannot,
in our judgment, be enforced, it is our opinion
that all other state gambling laws may be enforced
upon Indian reservations, since such laws are
prohibitory in nature (unlike the bingo laws).
Therefore, in our judgment, the use of "pull tabs"
by Indians or non-Indians upon an Indian
reservation may, where the elements of a
criminal offense are present, be prosecuted
under state gambling statutes.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.