Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-178

1982-178Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

August 19, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 178
Dwaine Waite
Route 2, Box 250
Winfield, Kansas 67156
Re: Drainage and Levies--Watershed Districts--
Meetings of Directors; Proxy Voting
Synopsis: In that a watershed district organized pursuant
to K.S.A. 24-2101 et seq., is a quasi-municipal
corporation, a quorum may be established, and
any votes taken by the board of directors, only
with those directors who are present, thus pre-
cluding the use of voting by proxy. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 24-1201, 24-1209, 24-1210.
Dear Mr. Waite:
As Secretary of the Middle Walnut Joint Watershed District No. 60,
you request our opinion on behalf of the board of directors
regarding proxy voting. Specifically, you inquire whether such
voting is permitted in the absence of any by-law or rule of
the district on the subject. You inform us that directors have
on occasion attempted to vote for an absent member who has
authorized the practice by letter.
The Watershed District Act, K.S.A. 24-1201 et seq., was enacted
"for the purpose of alleviating (water) damages and furthering
the conservation, development, utilization, and disposal of
water and thereby protecting the state's land and water resources."
To further those purposes, the act provides for the establish-
ment of watershed districts which are considered bodies politic
and corporate. K.S.A. 24-1209. The corporate powers and duties
of such districts, as set out therein, include the power to
sue and be sued; to execute contracts; to acquire, purchase,
hold, sell and convey land and personal property; to construct,
improve, maintain and operate works of improvement; to employ
professional services; to levy taxes and assessments; and to
issue bonds and incur indebtedness within the limits of the Act.
K.S.A. 24-1210 grants the board of directors the power to act
as the governing body of the watershed district carrying out
the provisions of the act.
In general, improvement districts such as Middle Walnut Creek
Joint Watershed District are classified as either a municipal
or a quasi-municipal corporation. McQuillin, Municipal Corporations,
§2.07a (3rd Ed. 1971). Some states consider a watershed district
as a municipal corporation. Levy v. Coon Creek Watershed District,
153 N.W.2d 209, 221 (Minn. 1967). In reviewing the validity of
a watershed district improvement project, the Supreme Court of
Minnesota held that "municipal corporation" in its broadest sense
applies to watershed districts. However, two opinions of this
office (Attorney General Opinion Nos. 81-279 and 80-147) have
stated that a watershed district has the character of a quasi-
municipal corporation. [McQuillin, Municipal Corporations,
§§2.23, 2.29 (3rd Ed. 1921).] As a creature of statute, a quasi-
municipal corporation has only those powers expressly authorized
by statute or clearly implied therefrom. State v. Kansas City,
60 Kan. 518 (1899); State ex rel., Griffith v. Board of Trustees ,
114 Kan. 485 (1923); Kaw Valley Drainage District v. Kansas City ,
119 Kan. 368 (1925).
As the act nowhere authorizes the use of voting by proxy at
meetings of the board of directors, judicial authority may be
consulted in determining whether the power to do so has been
implied for municipal or quasi-municipal corporations. A
general rule of corporate law precludes the use of voting by
proxy at board meetings. 19 Am.Jur.2d Corporations, §1131.
This is grounded in the duty of the directors to exercise
deliberative control of the business of the corporation, thereby
requiring their physical presence. The same has been held for
municipal corporations, where a quorum necessary to conduct
business can only be made up of directors or officials actually
present. 62 C.J.S. Municipal Corporations, §399(a) (1949).
While this office has previously issued opinions concerning the
propriety of meetings conducted entirely by means of telephone
conference calls (Nos. 80-159, 80-173), an official whose vote
is cast by proxy is totally without input into the course of
the meeting, as well as being without the benefit of the general
discussion.
In our opinion, the directors of a watershed district are
elected for the purpose of expressing their views on matters
of importance to the district, thereby representing those
voters who selected them. The presence of a director allows
him or her to assist in the decision-making process by offering
comments, listening to the statements of other directors and
the public, and examining material prepared for the meeting
by district employees. In light of the above, and in the
absence of any express statutory authority, we are not pre-
pared to conclude that the use of proxy voting is necessary to
effectuate the express authority of the board of directors to
conduct meetings.
In conclusion, a watershed district organized pursuant to K.S.A.
24-1201 et seq. is governed by a board of directors elected by
eligible voters of the district at the annual meeting. The
directors exercise the powers granted to the district at regular
meetings held quarterly as well as at special meetings. At such
meetings, the business of the district is discussed and acted
upon, with a majority of the directors necessary for a quorum.
In that a watershed district is a quasi-municipal corporation,
a quorum may be established, and any votes taken, only with those
directors who are present, thus precluding the use of voting by
proxy.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.