Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-146

1982-146Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

July 2, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 146
Robert E. Blue
Rawlins County Attorney
Rawlins County Courthouse
Atwood, Kansas 67730
Re: Counties and County Officers -- General Provisions --
Elections; Private Hospital Corporations
Synopsis: A county may agree to terms and conditions in a
hospital lease agreement between the county and a
private corporation which establish requirements
for the selection of the board of directors of the
private corporation. However, the county may not
conduct an election at public expense utilizing
the state and local election machinery to select
the members of the board of directors of the pri-
vate corporation. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101a,
19-1846.
*
Dear Mr. Blue:
In your capacity as Rawlins County Attorney you request the
Attorney General's opinion concerning the Rawlins County
Hospital Board of Directors. Specifically you ask:
"a. Does the Board of County Commissioners
have the authority to provide for the election
of the Board of Directors of Rawlins County
Hospital Inc.?
"b. If hospital board members can be elected,
could a geographic distribution of board mem-
bers be used in lieu of apportionment accord-
ing to population of the county?"
In your letter of April 22, 1982, you advise us that the
County Commission has opted to lease the hospital pursuant
to K.S.A. 19-1346 to Rawlins County Hospital, Inc., a private
non-profit corporation. This enabling statute provides in
pertinent part:
"[s]uch board of county commissioners may in
its discretion . . . lease unto any . . . cor-
poration . . . for the purpose of maintaining
and operating said county hospital upon such
terms and conditions as the commissioners deem
to the best interests of said county." (Em-
phasis added.)
In addition to the broad grant of authority contained in the
above-quoted statute, counties derive much power from their
use of home-rule. Pursuant to K.S.A. 19-101a, counties are
empowered to "transact all county business and perform such
powers of local legislation as they deem appropriate." How-
ever, in regard to elections, clause seven (7) of K.S.A.
19-101a provides that counties are subject to "all acts of
the legislature concerning elections, election commissioners
and officers and their duties as such officers and the elec-
tion of county officers."
As a general rule of law relevant to your inquiry, it is
stated in 26 Am. Jur. 2d, Elections, §183:
"It is fundamental that a valid election can-
not be called and held except by authority of
the law. There is no inherent right in the
people, whether of the state or of some par-
ticular subdivision thereof, to hold an elec-
tion for any purpose. Accordingly, an election
held without affirmative constitutional or
statutory authority, or contrary to a material
provision of the law, is a nullity, notwith-
standing the fact that such election was fairly
and honestly conducted." (Footnotes omitted.)
(Emphasis added.)
This general rule of law has been followed in Kansas. Mathews
v. Commissioners of Shawnee County, 34 Kan. 606 (1886); State,
ex rel., v. Deck, 106 Kan. 518 (1920). In State, ex rel., v.
Deck, supra, the Kansas Supreme Court was asked to decide if
county commissioners were empowered to call a special election
concerning the recall of a county commissioner. In deciding
that such an election could not be held, the Court stated:
"The board of county commissioners is author-
ized to call special elections on various pro-
positions, but each specific instance is under
a special grant of statutory power . . . .
These instances may not exhaust the list, but
in each of such special elections, positive,
complete, and specific authority is granted to
the board of county commissioners. Where such
authority is not expressly conferred, it would
not exist." (Emphasis added.) Id. at 522,
523.
More recently, though, this office concluded that a county
may, in the exercise of its statutory home rule powers, con-
duct an advisory election which was not otherwise authorized
by law. See Kansas. Attorney General Opinion No. 79-44. Such
authority is limited, however. As noted in the Attorney
General's opinion, the election must be for a public purpose
and must be held independently of statutorily authorized elec-
tions, since such additional elections interfere with state
elections and the duties of election officers contrary to
K.S.A. 19-101a Seventh, quoted supra. In this context we
return to your specific inquiry.
We have little question that the county commission might re-
quire as a "term" or "condition" of the lease, that a corpora-
tion provide in its by-laws for the election of its own board
of directors upon almost any terms that are agreeable to the
corporation and where corporate funds would be used to con-
duct the election. However, it does not follow that the
county commission, pursuant to either K.S.A. 19-101a or
19-1846, may authorize an expenditure of public funds to
conduct the election of the board of directors of a private
corporation utilizing the state and local election machinery.
No such election is authorized by the Kansas Constitution or
by statute. Moreover, we have been unable to find any au-
thority whereby state or local officials have ever been granted
the authority to provide for the election of the governing
body of a private corporation, as would be the case in the
situation you decribe.
We must conclude from the foregoing that a public election
at taxpayer expense cannot be called and held absent express
constitutional or statutory authority. Accordingly, we be-
lieve the County Commission to be without authority to pro-
vide by resolution or agreement for the public election of
the governing body of a private corporation absent express
statutory authorization.
In view of our response to your first question, your second
question is easily answered. To the extent that the county
and the private corporation, which is to manage the hospital,
can agree on the terms for the selection of the corporate
directors, the corporate bylaws may be changed in accordance
therewith. We are aware of no constitutional or statutory
mandate that private corporations doing business with county
government must select their governing boards by the consti-
tutional standards concerning elections applicable , to govern-
mental units.
Therefore, in our opinion a county may agree to terms and
conditions in a hospital lease agreement between the county
and a private corporation which establish requirements for
the selection of the board of directors of the private cor-
poration. However, the county may not conduct an election
at public expense utilizing the state and local election
machinery to select the members of the board of directors of
the private corporation.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
BradleyJ	.	Smoot DeputyAttorneyGeneral
RTS:BJS:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.