1982-099•Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-099
Texto completo
April 29, 1982 ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 99 Mr. Marshall Crowther Executive Secretary Kansas Public Employees' Retirement System 400 First National Bank Tower One Townsite Plaza Topeka, Kansas 66603 Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities -- Public Employees' Retirement System -- Board Members' Terms of Office Synopsis: When the terms of office of current members of the Board of Trustees of the Kansas Public Employees' Retirement System expire on May 1, 1982, vacancies will exist in these offices, but incumbents are entitled to hold over beyond that date as de facto officers until their successors are appointed and qualified. Any such successor appointed subsequent to May 1, 1982, shall be appointed to fill the re- mainder of the term of office expiring four years from May 1, 1982. Cited herein: K.S.A. 74-4905. Dear Mr. Crowther: You have requested our opinion regarding certain provisions of K.S.A. 74-4905, which establishes the board of trustees of the Kansas Public Employees' Retirement System and pre- scribes a four-year term of office for each member thereof. You indicate that the terms of office of all members of the board will expire on May 1, 1982, and you have inquired whether the incumbent members continue in office beyond that date, if successors have not been appointed and qualified at the expiration of their terms.
Even though K.S.A. 74-4905 prescribes four-year terms of office for members of the board and is silent as to whether such members continue in office until their successors are appointed and qualified, we believe the law recognizes the right of these officers to "hold over" in office until their successors are appointed and qualified. Pertinent to our conclusion is the long-established general rule that "[s]ince the public interest ordinarily requires that public offices should be filled at all times without interruption . . . in the absence of an express or implied constitutional provi- sion to the contrary, an officer is entitled to hold office until his successor is appointed or chosen and has qualified." 67 C.J.S. Officers, S71. - The Kansas Supreme Court has affirmed this principle, noting that it is "[t]he prevailing rule in the United States." Murray v. Payne, 137 Kan. 685, 690 (1933) At issue in Murray v. Payne, supra, was a legislative enact- ment which cancelled city elections in Kansas City, Kansas in 1933, and (in section 2 of the act) extended the terms of office of the incumbent city officers. The act was adopted as an economy measure, to avoid the "'expense of unnecessary elections'" (137 Kan. at 686) and to provide for uniformity in the commencement of terms of office. The act was challenged on several constitutional and statutory grounds. Plaintiff contrasted the Kansas City, Kansas statutes establishing the terms of city offices with other statutes applicable to cities of the first class generally, as noted in the follow- ing: "The general law relating to cities of the first class provides that the term of all elective officers shall be two years and un- til their successors are elected and quali- fied. (R.S. 13-307.) The general commission form of government law provides for the elec- tion of a mayor and commissioners who shall hold their offices for a term of two years and until their successors are elected and qualified. The commission form of government statute specially applying to Kansas City (R.S. 13-1707) says 'All commissioners elected shall hold their offices for a term of four years.' Plaintiff makes much of the omission of the usual provision for holding over." (Emphasis added.) 137 Kan. at 690. But the Court was not persuaded that the absence of the hold- over language in 13-1707 (repealed L. 1953, ch. 97), the Kansas City statute, was a conspicuous omission. The Court said:
"There is no implication here that the legis- lature thought anything about holding over, much less that it intentionally added another specialty to the act, abrogated the rule re- lating to public officers generally, and pro- hibited holding over in Kansas City. "The result of the foregoing is that if sec- tion 2 [of the act in question] had not been inserted in the act, incumbents would hold over until the next election in 1935." (Em- phasis added.) 137 Kan. at 690. In short, in the absence of specific language in a statute authorizing city officers to hold over pending the selection and qualification of successors, the Court affirmed that the above-mentioned general rule, the holdover rule, would have application. In the Murray case, as the Court recognized in the above quotation, the legislature obviated the need for application of the general rule by its insertion of section 2 in the act in question, which section expressly authorized city officers to hold over. But, the Court emphasized that had the legislature not inserted said section 2 the holdover rule would apply. Other jurisdictions have recognized the holdover rule. In Grooms v. La Vale Zoning Board, 340 A.2d 385 (1975), for example, the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland stated the rule thus: "It has long been recognized in this State, as elsewhere, that the public interest re- quires, in the absence of any provisions to the contrary, that public offices should be filled at all times, without interruption . . . . In accord with this principle, the [Maryland] Court of Appeals has recognized that an elected or appointed officer may re- main in office at the expiration of his term and is entitled to exercise the powers of his office until his successor qualifies, whether or not 'the statute creating the office so pro- vides." (Citations omitted.) 340 A.2d at 391. We think the foregoing authorities compel the conclusion that, at the expiration of their terms of office, members of the KPERS Board of Trustees hold over in office until such time as their successors are appointed and qualified. However, because of the absence of any constitutional or statutory provision specifically providing for such holding over, we believe the incumbent board members hold over only
as de facto officers. Grooms v. La Vale Zoning Board, supra; 67 C.J.S. Officers, §271 (1978). The legal principles giving rise to this conclusion are best enunciated in State of Connecticut ex rel., v. Watson, 132 Conn. 518, 45 A.2d 716, 164 A.C.R. 1238 (1946), wherein the court stated: "If by constitutional provision or valid sta- tute a definite term is established for an office without provision that the incumbent shall continue in office after its expiration, he will, in holding over, be a de facto and not a de jure officer, and a vacancy will re- sult which may be filled by the appointment, under proper authority, of a successor; if, however, the term of office is not only for a definite time but until a successor is ap- pointed and qualified, an incumbent holding over is a de jure officer and unless, from the particular language of the statute or the particular circumstances of the case, a dif- ferent legislative intent appears, there is no vacancy in the office within a provision authorizing an appointment in such a contin- gency." (Emphasis added.) Therefore, because K.S.A. 74-4905 does not specifically pro- vide for a board member to hold over, at the expiration of a member's term there exists a vacancy to be filled by appoint- ment of the governor, subject to confirmation of the senate, and the person so appointed is legally entitled to the office. For this reason, a board member holding over in office until a successor has been so appointed lacks all of the legal re- quisites to the office and cannot be regarded as a de jure officer. However, the distinction between officers dejure and de facto has relevance primarily with reference to the claim each has upon the office, and has little significance with respect to third persons. As stated in State v. Roberts, 130 Kan. 754 (1930): "'The acts of an officer de facto are as valid and effectual where they concern the public or the rights of third persons, until his title to the office is judged insufficient, as though he were an officer de jure, and the legality of the acts of such an officer can- not be collaterally attacked in a proceeding to which he is not a party.' (46 C.J. 1060, 1061.)" Id. at 756, 757. Finally, you have inquired as to the length of the terms of office of persons appointed as successors to the incumbent board members. Specifically, you ask whether the persons so
appointed serve for terms of four years, commencing at the
respective times they are appointed and qualified, or whether
these persons serve until the expiration of four years from
May 1, 1982. In our judgment, the latter correctly defines
the terms of office.
As previously noted, the incumbents' terms of office expire
on May 1, 1982, and successors are legally entitled to be
appointed as of that date, to serve for terms of four years.
Thus, the new terms of office legally commence on this date.
If successors are not appointed at that time, vacancies exist
in these offices, and any incumbents holding over as de facto
officers until their successors are appointed and qualified
are serving portions of the new terms of office.
Here, we note that K.S.A. 74-4905 provides that, "[i]n case
of a vacancy in the membership of the board a person to fill
such vacancy for the remainder of the unexpired term shall
be appointed in like manner as appointments for regular
terms are made." In our opinion, then, if persons are ap-
pointed and qualified as members of the KPERS Board of
Trustees subsequent to May 1, 1982, such persons are appointed
to fill vacancies in these offices and will serve for the
remainder of the terms which commenced on May 1, 1982.
summary, therefore, it is our opinion that, when the terms
of office of current members of the Board of Trustees of the
Kansas Public Employees' Retirement System expire on May 1,
1982, vacancies will exist in these offices, but incumbents
are entitled to hold over beyond that date as de facto offi-
cers until their successors are appointed and qualified.
Any such successor appointed subsequent to May 1, 1982, shall
be appointed to fill the remainder of the term of office ex-
piring four years from May 1, 1982.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T.
ATTORR ("TEPHAST
G NERAL OF ANSAS
W. RoRTS:WRn
First DeATTORNEYtSTEPHANneral
RTS:WRKANSASContinue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.