Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-091

1982-091Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

April 21, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 91
Daniel L. Love
Ford County Attorney
P. 0. Box 1057
Dodge City, Kansas 67801
Re: Taxation--Mortgage Registration Fee--Computation
of Amount Due
Synopsis: The mortgage registration fee is measured by the
principal debt or obligation secured by a mortgage
of real property. If the initial amount of the
principal debt or obligation secured by a mortgage
of real property is increased, an additional mortgage
registration fee is due. In such circumstances,
however, such fee nprincipalid only upon the difference
between the initial amount of prinicpal debt or obli-
gation secured by the mortgage and the amount of
principal debt or obligation subsequently secured
by the mortgage. Attorney General Opinion No. 73-191
is withdrawn. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-3102.
* *
Dear Mr. Love:
You seek an opinion of this office concerning the provisions of
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-3102, under which the mortgage registration
fee is imposed. In reviewing the files of this office, we find
no tax statute that has prompted as many inquiries as has this
one. Given the number of requests this office has received for
assistance in construing the provisions of this statute, we think
the following observation of the Kansas Supreme Court concerning
another tax statute is equally applicable to K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
79-3102: "The confusion of thought and inaccuracy of expression
so frequently exhibited in legislative enactments are quite
apparent in this one, and the precise purpose to be accomplished
is somewhat difficult of discernment." Gas Co. v. Neosho County,
83 Kan. 335, 337 (1907).
On this occasion, you explain that a lending institution has
tendered for - filing a mortgage of real property covering real
estate upon which the lending institution already has an existing
mortgage which has been recorded in the office of the register
of deeds. The existing mortgage was filed a number of years ago,
and the mortgage registration fee due thereon was paid, based
upon the total amount of the debt stated in and secured by that
mortgage. Over the years, the debt owed to the lending institution
has been reduced. Recently, however, the owners of the property
borrowed additional money from the lending institution. The amount
borrowed exceeds the amount stated in and secured by the mortgage
of real property currently on file. Based upon this fact, the
lending institution was granted a "new" mortgage on the real
property which secures the total amount of indebtedness now owed
to the lending institution by these borrowers.
At the time the lending institution tendered this new mortgage
for filing, it also submitted an affidavit stating that this
mortgage included principal indebtedness covered by the previously
recorded mortgage, and that the mortgage registration fee had
been paid on that mortgage. In addition, it offered to pay
a mortgage registration fee based upon the difference between
the total indebtedness secured by the new mortgage and the total
indebtedness secured by the previously recorded mortgage. The
register of deeds refused to receive the new mortgage, contend-
ing that the proper amount of mortgage registration fee due
on the new mortgage should be based upon the total indebtedness
secured by the new mortgage and the balance of the indebtedness
that was owing immediately prior to the time the new mortgage
was given to the lending institution. You ask us to decide which
is the proper method of determining the amount of the mortgage
registration fee due on the new mortgage.
Your inquiry concerns that portion of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-3102
in which it is provided:
"Before any mortgage of real property, or
renewal or extension of the same shall be
received and filed for record there shall
be paid to the register of deeds of the
county in which such property or any part
thereof is situated, a registration fee
of twenty-five cents (250) for each one
hundred dollars ($100) and major fraction
thereof, of the principal debt or obligation
which is secured by such mortgage, and upon
which no prior registration fee has been
paid. . . . No registration fee whatsoever
shall be paid, collected or required . . .
(3) upon that portion of the consideration
stated in the mortgage tendered for filing
which is verified by affidavit to be prin-
cipal indebtedness covered or included in a
previously recorded mortgage or other instru-
ment with the same lender upon which the
registration fee herein provided for has
been paid . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
The above-emphasized language was added to the statute in 1973,
apparently in response to the decision of the Kansas Supreme
Court in Meadowlark Hills, Inc. v. Kearns, 211 Kan. 35 (1973).
As explained in Attorney General Opinion No. 76-191:
"There had always been legal problems with
the law as written when a new mortgage was
filed and claim made that no fee was due
because the new mortgage was 'solely' to
secure the 'same indebtedness'. First Nat'l
Bank v. Lovitt, [158 Kan.] 535, 540, 148 P.2d
738 (1944). This problem came to a head in
Meadowlark Hill, Inc. v. Kearns, 211 Kan. 35,
505 P.2d 1127 (1973). The Supreme Court
upheld the imposition of a second fee on a
mortgage debt when the new 'mortgage and
Note Revision Agreement' was filed. But the
Court called attention to the fact that other
states had laws which provide that a mortgage
may be increased or added to and the regis-
tration fee shall be taxable only on such
increase or addition. Then, the Court pointedly
stated: 'The legislature has not seen fit to
provide a similar exemption in the Kansas Act.'
(P. 44)
"Meadowlark was handed down in the January,
1973 term. The Kansas legislature in session
then passed Chapter 395, Section 1 amending
K.S.A. 79-3102 by adding a third exemption . .
Id. at 3.
We believe the intent of the legislature in enacting the third
exemption clause of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-3102 was to establish
a procedure whereby a mortgage could be "increased or added
to" and the registration fee imposed only on such increase or
addition. Therefore, we must conclude that in situations where
the initial amount of the principal debt or obligation secured
by a mortgage of real property is increased, an additional
mortgage registration fee must be paid only upon the difference
between the initial amount of principal debt or obligation secured
by the mortgage and the amount of principal debt or obligation
subsequently secured by the mortgage, as renewed or extended, or
both.
In reaching the above conclusions, we have not overlooked
Attorney General Opinion No. 73-191, in which an opposite
conclusion was reached. In that opinion, however, Meadowlark
Hill, Inc. v. Kearns, supra, is not cited or discussed. We
believe the failure to consider that case produced an erroneous
conclusion. Therefore, Attorney General Opinion No. 73-191
is withdrawn.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.