Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-020

1982-020Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

February 3, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-20
The Honorable David G. Miller
State Representative, Forty-Third District
House of Representatives
3rd Floor, Statehouse
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Department of Administration -- Inclusion of State
Agencies' Budget Requests in Governor's Budget
Report
Synopsis: While the governor has the power to make recommen-
dations regarding budget requests of state agencies,
and the director of the budget has the authority
to prescribe the format of such requests, neither
has the power to predetermine and circumscribe the
amount which may be requested. However, the gov-
ernor may require executive department agencies to
submit to him expenditure estimates within speci-
fied allocations of expected revenues, as long as
these agencies are not limited by such allocations
in making their requests for appropriations.
It is contrary to the requirements of law to omit
from the governor's budget report the itemized
budget request submitted by any state agency.
Where an agency has submitted an itemized budget
estimate which has been omitted from the budget
report, or where the budget request included in
the budget report for any state agency does not
represent that agency's actual budget estimate,
the governor should amend the budget report so as
to include these agencies' actual, itemized re-
quests for appropriations. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-3714a (as amended by L. 1981, ch. 341, §1),
75-3715, 75-3716, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3717, 75-3718,
75-3721, Kan. Const., Art. 1, §§3,4.
Dear Representative Miller:
You have posed several questions regarding the preparation of
Governor Carlin's Fiscal Year 1983 Budget Report, recently sub-
mitted to the 1982 Legislature. Although you have requested
our opinion on six specific questions, it is apparent from
our review of these questions that there are two central
issues underlying your inquiries, i.e., can the governor or
the director of the budget limit the amount of a state agency's
budget request, and must the governor and the director of
the budget include each state agency's budget request in the
governor's budget report.
Our review of the instructions given to each state agency
regarding the preparation of agencies' budget requests for
fiscal year 1983 confirms your understanding that a new pro-
cedure was instituted in 1981. Of pertinence are the new
budgeting concepts which were introduced by Governor Carlin
in his memorandum of March 9, 1981, to all agency heads. In
that memorandum, Governor Carlin stated that a "balanced
base" budget would be adopted for use in fiscal 1983 budget
preparation. He explained this concept, as follows:
"In May I will ask for an estimate of revenues
available for expenditure in fiscal year 1983
and will allocate those expected revenues on
an agency-by-agency basis. That allocation
will constitute the balanced base from which
further budgetary adjustments will be made as
I prepare final budget recommendations. Note
that the balanced base allocations will be at
the agency level and not at the program level.Itwillremainthetaskofagencyheadsto
distribute the agency allocation across pro-
grams within their agency so as to satisfy
public service needs with maximum efficiency
and effectiveness." (Emphasis in original.)
Another significant conceptual change is that of "alternative
service levels." Governor Carlin's memorandum explained this
concept as follows:
"For most state programs, the Division of the
Budget will require the submission of line
item information for each of three ('A,"B,'
and 'C') levels. The B level budget will
correspond to the balanced base allocation;
that is, the total of all B level program re-
quests for an agency will equal that agency's
total allocation as announced on June 1. The
A level budget will represent a reduction of
funding below the base level by an amount spe-
cified in detailed instructions issued from
the Division of the Budget. The C level bud-
get will represent additional funds beyond
the balanced base in an amount specified in
Division of the Budget detailed instructions.
The information contained in the three-level
submissions, together with agency explanations
of the difference in services that would re-
sult from adopting alternative service levels,
will be the basis for my final FY 1983 bud-
get recommendations. As has been the case in
past years, differences between Division of
the Budget recommendations about the distribu-
tion of the agency allocation across programs
and agency budget requests will be grounds
for the appeal and restoration process pro-
vided for in Kansas statute."
Subsequent to the Governor's memorandum, the director of the
budget issued numerous memorandums to all state agency heads,
providing detailed instructions as to the preparation of
agencies' FY 1983 budget requests. The culmination of these
procedures was capsulized by the following excerpt from the
"Introduction to the Budget," prepared by the director of the
budget and included in Governor Carlin's FY 1983 Budget Report:
"On June 1, 1981, after studying the impor-
tant issues submitted by department adminis-
trators, Governor Carlin allocated expected
1983 revenues among state agencies. These
allocations were the foundation on which agen-
cies were instructed to build their financial
plans for 1983. Agencies made expenditure
proposals based on their allocation. These
proposals are termed 'B level budgets.' The
B level proposals are shown for each program
and agency, except for those cases where agen-
cies failed to comply with instructions."
The foregoing quotations from Governor Carlin's memorandum
and the budget report itself reveal that the Governor and
the director of the budget did, in fact, issue directives to
all state agencies that would limit each state agency's bud-
get request to the amount of the expected 1983 revenues allo-
cated to that agency by the Governor. These quoted excerpts
also indicate that some state agencies did not comply with
these directives, and a review of the budget document dis-
closes that the budget requests by some of these state agencies
were omitted from the governor's budget report. For example,
with respect to the budget information regarding the Judicial
Department, the budget report contains no "B level" budget.
On each of the pages of the budget report pertaining to the
line item budget of the judiciary, there is the following
notation: "This agency did not comply with the Division of
the Budget instructions." Although each such notation is
followed by a statement as to the total amount of money re-
quested by the judicial department for a particular "program"
function, the budget report contains no itemization of the
judiciary's request for funding. Similar treatment is afforded
the budget requests of the State Board of Regents and each of
the educational institutions under the Board's jurisdiction.
From our review of these facts, we have discerned that the
budget request of each state agency complying with the in-
structions of the director of the budget has been presented
in the budget report as the "B Level Budget," which reflects
a request that has been circumscribed by the governor's allo-
cation of expected 1983 revenues to that agency. It also is
apparent that no itemized funding request has been included
in the budget report for some of the state agencies which did
not submit a request within the amount so allocated to that
agency. Essentially, you have requested our opinion as to the
propriety of these procedures.
Our opinion must be predicated, in part, on the statutory
provisions pertinent to the budgetary process. Initially,
we note that the legislature has assigned certain budgeting re-
sponsibilities to the director of the budget, who supervises
the division of the budget under the direct supervision of
the secretary of administration (K.S.A. 75-3714a, as amended
by L. 1981, ch. 341, §1.). K.S.A. 75-3715 prescribes the gen-
eral powers and duties of the director of the budget, as
follows:
"The director of the budget shall:
"(1) Keep in continuous touch with the opera-
tions, plans and needs of state agencies, and
with the sources and amounts of revenue and
other receipts of the state.
"(2) Analyze the quantity and quality of ser-
vices rendered by each agency, and the needs
for such services and for any new services.
"(3) Prepare under the supervision of the in-
coming governor, the budget report for submis-
sion to the legislature.
"(4) Prepare a legislative measure or mea-
sures reflecting the incoming governor's bud-
get.
"(5) Consider and act on applications for
transfers between appropriations of the same
agency as provided by law.
"(6) Survey such work programs and periodical
allotment requests submitted by state agencies
as are required by this act.
"(7) Report to the governor and to the incom-
ing governor on the operation of the budget
system and advise and assist the governor, in-
coming governor, state finance council, legis-
lature and its ways and means committees on
request, concerning any matters relating to
the budget.
"(8) Provide management analysis service to
state agencies."
We also note the provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3718(a),
which state:
"(a) The director of the budget shall have in
continuous process and revision a tentative
budget for the coming years, in the light of
direct studies of the operations, plans and
needs of the state agencies and of the exist-
ing and prospective sources of revenue. Af-
ter summarizing estimates of funds which may
be available and the estimated requirements
for the several state agencies, the director
shall cause them to be reviewed in relation
to the general financial condition and needs
of the state and shall cause to be made such
further inquiries and investigations, and
such revision of the tentative budget, as the
director may deem necessary."
In light of the foregoing general responsibility imposed on
the director of the budget regarding the budgeting process,
we can appreciate the director's desire to obtain the infor-
mation which each state agency was instructed to provide in
the form of its FY 1983 budget request. Such information
undoubtedly is of assistance to the director of the budget
in fulfilling his statutory obligations, and we can certainly
appreciate how such data can be of value to the governor in
developing his fiscal policies. However, notwithstanding the
value of such information, the question remains whether the
authority exists to acquire the desired information by limit-
ing the amount of a state agency's budget request. To this
end, we have reviewed some of the fundamental principles
underlying our constitutional government.
Early in our state's judicial history, the Kansas Supreme
Court had occasion to consider the fundamentals of our sys-
tem of government in Coleman v. Newby, 7 Kan. 82 (1871). We
have found particularly instructive the following excerpt
from the separate opinion of Justice Valentine:
"In this country it is universally acknowl-
edged and insisted upon that the people are
the original source and fountain of all civil
and political power; that neither the whole
government, nor any department thereof, pos-
sesses any inherent power; that the people
are sovereign, and the different departments
of the government are simply agencies through
which the people exercise that sovereignty; and
that all the power that can be exercised by
any department of the government is merely
delegated power which it derives from the
people. The state government derives its
powers from the people solely by virtue of
the state constitution. This constitution is
the letter of attorney or chart of authority
from the people to the government, and to the
different departments thereof. Hence, in or-
der to ascertain what power is delegated to
the government, and to each of its departments,
we must look to the constitution itself."
(Emphasis added.) Id. at 86.
After quoting with approval a portion of the foregoing and
noting that similar language is found in The State, ex rel.,
v. City of Topeka, 31 Kan. 452 (1884), the Court in Leek v.
Theis, 217 Kan. 784 (1974), reiterated the principle that
all governmental power under our system of government is in-
herent in the people of our state, who exercise such power
through the legislative branch of government. Id. at 802.
Accordingly, the legislature is free to act, except as it
is restricted by the state and federal constitutions. Id.
These principles have given rise to the oft-repeated propo-
sition that our constitution limits rather than confers
powers, and any power not limited by the constitution remains
with the people and their legislators. See, e.g., NEA-Fort
Scott v. U.S.D. No. 234, 225 Kan. 607, 609 (1979).
One such limitation on the legislative power is found in
Article 1, Section 3 of the Kansas Constitution, which states:
"The supreme executive power of this state shall be vested in
a governor, who shall be responsible for the enforcement of the
laws of this state." The extent of this power was considered
in The State, ex rel., v. Dawson, 86 Kan. 180 (1911), where
the court said:
"We do not find that the meaning of the phrase
'The supreme executive power,' as contained in
our constitution and the constitutions of many
other states of this Union, has ever been pre-
cisely defined, although the matter is referred
to in some decisions. Perhaps the term itself
taken in connection with the context is suffi-
ciently explicit. An executive department is
created consisting of a governor and the other
officers named, and he is designated as the
one having the supreme executive power, that
is, the highest in authority in that depart-
ment. In the same connection it will be no-
ticed that the other executive officers are
required to furnish information upon subjects
relating to their duties, and to make annual
reports to him, and withal he is charged with
the duty of seeing that the laws are faith-
fully executed. It is manifest from these
various provisions that the term 'supreme
executive power' is something more than a ver-
bal adornment of the office, and implies such
power as will secure an efficient execution of
the laws, which is the peculiar province of
that department, to be accomplished however
in the manner and by the methods and within
the limitations prescribed by the constitu-
tion and statutes enacted in harmony with
that instrument.
"'When a constitution gives a general power,
or enjoins a duty, it also gives, by implica-
tion, every particular power necessary for
the exercise of the one, or the performance
of the other. The implication under this rule,
however, must be a necessary, not a conjectural
or argumentative one. And it is further mod-
ified by another rule, that where the means
for the exercise of a granted power are given,
no other or different means can be implied, as
being more effectual or convenient.' (Field v.
The People, 3 Ill. 79, 83.)" (Emphasis added.)
Id. at 187, 188.
This constitutional provision has been considered with respect
to specific gubernatorial acts. For example, the Court in
Barrett v. Duff, 114 Kan. 220 (1923), was considering whether
Article 1, Section 3 provided the governor with power to
appoint persons to fill vacancies in public offices, when
it stated:
"But the authorities uniformly hold that such
constitutional provision does not confer upon
the governor the power to appoint officers,
either for full terms or to fill vacancies.
The only power the governor has to make offi-
cial appointments is that conferred upon him
by specific constitutional or statutory pro-
visions, and that has been repeatedly recog-
nized, both in our constitution and in our
statutes." Id. at 241.
Regarding the power to pardon, the Court has held that, since
the power to pardon for crimes is inherent in the people, who
may vest such power in any of the three branches of govern-
ment, such power no more inheres in the governor by virtue
of his office than it does in the judicial branch when the
constitution is silent. Jamison v. Flanner, Sheriff, 116
Kan. 624, 634, 635 (1924), and cases cited therein.
We also believe the following statement in Martin, Governor,
v. Ingham, 38 Kan. 641 (1888), to be relevant to our considera-
tion:
"Perhaps we should say something further with
respect to the claim that the three great
branches of the government, the legislative,
the judicial, and the executive, are coequal
and coordinate, and that one cannot control
or direct the others. This may be true to
some extent, and yet, as we have already seen,
it is not true in many cases. For the purpose
of passing laws the legislature is supreme,
and the other departments must obey. For the
purpose of construing the laws, and of deter-
mining controversies, the courts are supreme,
and the other departments must obey. And for
the purpose of ultimately enforcing the laws
the executive department is supreme, and the
other departments must obey. But the execu-
tive department can enforce the statutory laws
only as the legislature has enacted them, and
where the courts have construed the laws (sta-
tutory or constitutional) in the determination
of controversies, the executive department can
enforce them only as thus construed, and is
bound to see that the laws as thus construed,
and the judgments and orders of the courts
rendered or made in the determination of con-
troversies, are respected and obeyed." Id.
at 656, 657.
From these authorities it is clear that, while the supreme
executive power of the state is vested in the governor, the
governor's authority to act must emanate from the constitution
and statutes of this state. Unlike the legislature which
possesses all legislative power not limited by the constitu-
tion, the governor has only such authority as is granted by
the constitution and statutes. Separate and apart from these
bodies of law the governor has no inherent power. As the
chief executive officer, the governor possesses "such power
as will secure an efficient execution of the laws" (The State,
ex rel., v. Dawson, supra), and even though general grants
of power by the constitution and statutes may give rise to
implied powers to secure efficient execution of the laws,
any such implied power "must be a necessary, not a conjec-
tural or argumentative one." Id.
Before measuring the governor's authority by the statutory
budget procedures, we think it important to recognize that
"[t]he power to appropriate money belonging
to the state and rightfully in the state
treasury and over which the legislature has
the rightful control is a legislative power,
and, except as is restricted by the consti-
tution, the legislature has the exclusive pow-
er to direct how, when and for what purpose
the public funds shall be applied in carrying
out the objects of the state government."
State, ex rel., v. Fadely, 180 Kan. 652, Syl.
114 (1957).
We think there can be little question that the submission of
budget requests by state agencies and the presentation of
the governor's budget report to the legislature are part of
the appropriation process. This was recognized in Attorney
General Opinion No. 74-11, wherein it was stated:
"An initial budget document is a declaration
of an agency's intended use of funds for which
they request appropriation. Nevertheless, bud-
get documents accordingly, from the time of
initiation to the time they are presented to
the legislature in the form of the Governor's
budget report, as required by K.S.A. 75-3721,
never materialize, except through cognizable
legislative action, beyond recomendations."
VIII Op. Att'y Gen. 1105.
By the various provisions of K.S.A. 75-3715 to 75-3721, and
amendments thereto, the legislature has prescribed the general
procedures for the submission of funding requests to the legis-
lature, and has set forth the respective powers and duties of
the governor, director of the budget and the various state
agencies as regards the budgeting process. Pertinent among
these are the provisions of K.S.A. 75-3716, which states:
"The director of the budget shall prepare the
budget report, with the related legislative
measure or measures, for the incoming governor's
approval and submission to the legislature.
The director of the budget shall, on or before
September first of each year, furnish to every
state agency or person authorized to spend or
receive state funds a sufficient number of
budget estimate forms. The forms shall be pre-
pared by the director of the budget and shall
be so designed as to show actual expenditures
for at least the last preceding completed fis-
cal year, estimated expenditures for the cur-
rent fiscal year, and requests for each suc-
ceeding fiscal year, and data for like periods
with respect to receipts and actual or esti-
mated balances at the end of such fiscal years.
"The director of the budget may require the
estimated expenditures to be classified so as
to set forth the data by funds, state agencies,
character and objects of expenditures, which
V
expenditures may also be required to be classi-
fied by functions and activities. The direc-
tor of the budget may require the revenue es-
timates to show the basis upon which the esti-
mates were made and the factors involved in
the same, and to be classified so as to show
receipts by funds, and sources and types of
income. The director of the budget may re-
quire such further detail, work programs,
supplemental and supporting data, and such
information as may be necessary to carry out
the provisions of this act." (Emphasis added.)
Also relevant is K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3717, which states in
pertinent part:
"(a) As provided in this section, each state
agency, not later than October first of each
year, shall file with the division of the bud-
get its budget estimates, and all amendments
and revisions thereof, in the form provided
by the director of the budget, including a
full explanation of its requests for any ap-
propriations for the expansion of present ser-
vices and the addition of new services. . . .
At the same time as each state agency submits
to the division of the budget a copy of its
budget estimate, and all amendments and revi-
sions thereof, each such state agency shall
submit a copy of such estimate, and all amend-
ments and revisions thereof, directly to the
legislative research department for legisla-
tive use.
"(c) The director of the budget may prepare
budget estimates for any state agency failing
to file a request." (Emphasis added.)
We also have noted the following provisions of K.S.A. 1980
Supp. 75-3718(b):
"Not later than November tenth of each
year, the director of the budget shall notify
each state agency in writing of any revision
of its requests and the agency affected may
request a hearing thereon which request may
be filed within ten (10) days after receipt
of notice but, in any case, not later than
November twentieth of such year."
And, finally, we have considered K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3721,
which provides for the submission of the governor's budget
report to the legislature. Subsection (b) thereof requires
the budget report to be "set up in three parts," and the con-
tents of the second part are relevant here, the pertinent
requirements being as follows:
"(B) Part two shall embrace the detailed bud-
get estimates, both of expenditures and rev-
enues, showing the requests of the state agen-
cies, if any, and the incoming governor's re-
commendations thereon." (Emphasis added.)
In reaching our conclusions as to the requirements of the
foregoing statutory provisions, we have been guided by well-
established rules of statutory construction. Of principal
significance is the following statement in Southeast Kansas
Landowners Ass'n v. Kansas Turnpike Auth., 224 Kan. 357 (1978):
"The fundamental rule of statutory construc-
tion, to which all others are subordinate, is
that the purpose and intent of the legislature
governs when that intent can be ascertained
from the statutes. Easom v. Farmers Insurance
Co., 221 Kan. 415, Syl. 2, 560 P.2d 117 (1977);
Thomas County Taxpayers Ass'n v. Finney, 223
Kan. 434, 573 P.2d 1073 (1978); Brinkmeyer v.
City of Wichita, 223 Kan. 393, 573 P.2d 1044
(1978)." 224 Kan. at 357.
Supporting this principle is the rule that, "[i]n order to
ascertain the legislative intent, courts are not permitted
to consider only a certain isolated part or parts of an act
but are required to consider and construe together all parts
thereof in pari materia." Brown v. Keill, 224 Kan. 195, 200
(1978).
Neither our constitution nor the statutes prescribing the
budgetary procedure vest in the governor an express grant of
authority to limit the amount of a state agency's budget re-
quest. Moreover, we find no basis for implying such power
from these statutes. Rather, by applying the rules of con-
struction cited above, we believe there is a manifest legis-
lative intent that the governor's power be limited to recom-
mending changes in budget requests made by state agencies.
In our judgment, the legislative purpose underlying these
statutes is to have submitted to the legislature, in the form
of the governor's budget report, independent requests for
appropriations from the various state agencies, together
with the governor's recommendations thereon. The statutes
quoted above reflect a desire by the legislature to obtain
two independent statements -- the collective budget requests
of the state agencies and the governor's recommended changes
in these requests.
In our judgment, even though to limit the amount of state
agencies' budget requests may be determined by the governor
to be more "effectual or convenient" to the exercise of his
statutory duties, such determination provides no basis for
the implication of powers beyond those expressly granted to
the governor, i.e., to submit a budget report containing re-
quests for appropriations by state agencies, together with
the governor's recommended changes therein. (See State, ex
rel., v. Dawson, supra.) It can scarcely be suggested that
limiting the amount of a state agency's request for funding
does not affect the substance of the agency's request, and if
we presume the governor possesses authority to dictate the
total amount of an agency's request to fund its proposed
budget, could it logically be argued that the governor lacked
authority to alter some or all of the various line item com-
ponents of the agency's budget request? We think not; but
neither could it be reasoned that such proposed budget then
represents the agency's request for appropriations. If the
governor possesses the authority in the first instance to
determine the substance of state agencies' funding requests,
what is the purpose of the statutory requirement that agencies
be afforded a hearing with respect to changes proposed by the
governor in their budgets after their submission? If the
governor can predetermine agencies' budget requests, what is
the purpose of the legislature's requirement that the budget
report contain the agencies' requests and the governor's
recommendations? If we assume the governor's power to alter
the substance of state agencies' budget requests prior to
their submission, then both such legislative purposes are
defeated, and in our judgment, the implication of such power
is unwarranted as being contrary to expressed legislative
intent.
Similarly, the director of the budget is given clear author-
ity to devise and prescribe for use by state agencies the
format in which their appropriation requests are to be sub-
mitted. Such authority, however, does not carry with it the
power to affect the substance of such requests. As an admin-
istrative officer, the director can exercise only such powers
as are expressly conferred upon him by law or which are neces-
sary to effectuate such express powers. See, e.g., Murray v.
State Board of Regents, 194 Kan. 686, 689, 690 (1965). And
courts have consistently limited the determination of implied
powers to situations where, without them, the governmental
officer or agency would have no way to carry out the express
statutory powers. See, e.g., Edwards County Commissioners v.
Simmons, 159 Kan. 41 (1944); Womer v. Aldridge, 155 Kan. 446
(1942); State, ex rel., v. Davis, 114 Kan. 270 (1923); The
State, ex rel., v. Wooster, 111 Kan. 830 (1922); The State,
ex rel., v. Younkin, 108 Kan. 634 (1921); Young v. Regents
of State University, 87 Kan. 239 (1912); and Brown County v.
Barnett, 14 Kan. 627 (1875).
In this instance, we can find no necessity for implying pow-
ers in the director of the budget beyond those expressly
granted to that office by statute. We note, in fact, that
for a substantial number of years the director of the budget
has been able to accomplish his statutory duties with respect
to the budgetary process without the necessity of implying
authority beyond the express statutory provisions.
We also have concluded that the omission of state agencies'
detailed funding requests from the governor's budget report
contravenes statutory requirements. As previously noted,
the director of the budget is vested with the authority to
prescribe the format of agencies' budget requests, and pur-
suant to that authority, agencies have been required to pro-
vide an itemized proposal of their total requests for appro-
priations. Thus, such itemized requests must be considered
as the agencies' "detailed budget estimates" that are re-
quired by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3721(b)(B) to be included in
part two of the governor's budget report. Accordingly, to
omit from the budget report the funding request of any agency
that is in the format prescribed by the director of the bud-
get contravenes this statutory requirement, particularly
where the stated reason for omitting such request is the
agency's failure to comply with the directives which we pre-
viously found to be without lawful authority.
At this point, the conclusions we have reached respond to all
of the issues you have raised, except one. You have noted
that most state agencies have complied with the governor's
directive to submit alternative budget estimates (A, B and C
level budgets), but for those agencies the governor has in-
cluded only one of these alternatives (B level) in his bud-
get report. As a result, you have asked whether the governor
is required to include in the budget report all of the alter-
native budget estimates by each such agency. In our judgment
he is not.
As previously noted, the statutes setting forth the budgeting
procedure do not contemplate the submission of alternative
budget requests based on varying projections as to expected
revenues. Each state agency is required to submit a single
request for appropriations, and it is that request which the
governor is required to include in the budget report for sub-
mission to the legislature. If, in fact, the B level budgets
included in the budget report for the various state agencies
represent these agencies' requests for appropriations, irre-
spective of the limitation imposed by the governor's alloca-
tion of expected revenues, the governor has complied with
the statutory requirements. However, because of the poten-
tial limiting effect the governor's allocation of expected
revenues has on the agencies' budget requests, it is possi-
ble that none of the alternative budget estimates for any
particular state agency represents that agency's request for
appropriations, and in that event, not even the inclusion of
all three alternative budget levels would satisfy the statutory
requirements.
From the factual information available to us, we are limited
in reaching a conclusion as to the validity of the vast ma-
jority of the budget requests set forth in the budget report.
However, it is apparent, as we noted above, that the itemized
budget requests for certain state agencies (i.e., the Judi-
cial Department, State Board of Regents and the institutions
of higher education under the Board's jurisdiction) have not
been included in the budget report. Thus, it is our further
opinion that, in order to comply with statutory requirements,
the governor should amend the budget report so as to include
the itemized requests of those agencies.
As to the other agencies, we believe it is incumbent on the
governor to determine whether the B level budgets included in
the budget report for the various state agencies represent
the actual requests for appropriations by those agencies,
and in the event they do not, the budget report should be
further amended to provide the actual requests.
In summary, then, it is our opinion that, while the governor
has the power to make recommendations regarding budget re-
quests of state agencies, and the director of the budget has
the authority to prescribe the format of such requests,
neither has the power to predetermine and circumscribe the
amount which may be requested. Neither the Kansas Constitu-
tion nor the relevant statutes of this state expressly vest
such power in either officer, and the implication of such
power is unwarranted, in light of the manifest legislative
intent that requests for appropriations to operate state
agencies be made by the agencies themselves. In addition,
it is contrary to the requirements of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-3721
to omit from the governor's budget report the itemized budget
request submitted by any state agency. Finally, it is our
further opinion that, where an agency has submitted an itemized
budget estimate which has been omitted from the budget report,
or where the B level budget included in the budget report for
any state agency does not represent that agency's actual budget
estimate, the governor should amend the budget report so as
to include these agencies' actual, itemized requests for
appropriations.
Before concluding, one caveat is in order. This opinion
should not be construed as suggesting that the governor may
not request from all state agencies the type of information
requested of them in 1981 in connection with the preparation
and submission of their FY 1983 budget requests. In fact,
we believe the governor, in pursuance of his responsibility
to make recommendations on state agencies' budget requests,
has the authority to require the submission to him of such
data and information from executive department agencies. Our
belief in this regard is prompted not only by the fact that
the governor is the chief executive officer of the state
(Kan. Const., Art. 1, §3), but also because of the constitu-
tional authority of the governor to "require information in
writing from the officers of the executive department, upon
any subject relating to their respective duties" (Kan. Const.,
Art. 1, §4). Supporting these constitutional provisions is
the significant recognition given by the legislature, through
its approval of numerous executive department reorganization
measures in the past decade, that the governor is ultimately
to be held accountable for the management of various execu-
tive department agencies. However, the thrust of our opinions
previously expressed herein is that the governor's exercise
of these powers must be consonant with specific statutory
mandates regarding the budgetary process. Hence, while we
believe the governor may require from executive department
agencies the submission to him of expenditure estimates with-
in specified allocations of expected revenues, it is our
opinion that the exercise of such gubernatorial power may
not be extended, so as to require that agencies submit these
proposals in lieu of their policy determinations as to their
respective budgetary requirements.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
KANSAS ATTORNEY GENERAL,
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.