Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-012

1982-012Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

January 20, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-12
Gayle Mollenkamp, Commissioner
Logan County Commission
Box 5, Star Route
Russell Springs, Kansas 67755
Re: Oil and Gas -- Cementing Surface Pipe -- Avoidance
of Water Pollution; Criminal Penalties for Non-
Observance
Synopsis: K.S.A. 55-136 et seq. require the surface pipe of
any oil or gas well to be cemented below the fresh
water strata, in order to protect such strata from
pollution, and apply both to wells drilled with
rotary equipment or cable tools. The act is supple-
mented by rules and regulations adopted by the
Kansas Corporation Commission, and contains crim-
inal penalties for any person, firm, association
or corporation who violates any of the sections
thereof. While responsibility for the enforcement
of such criminal penalties lies with district and
county attorneys, insofar as the act is uniformly
applicable to all counties, a county may not employ
its home rule authority to enact a resolution on
this same subject. Cited herein: K.S.A. 55-136,
55-137, 55-138, K.A.R. 82-2-123, Kansas Constitu-
tion, Article 12, Section 5.
Dear Commissioner Mollenkamp:
As County Commissioner for the Third District in Logan County,
you request our opinion on a question involving pollution
caused by the drilling of oil and gas wells. Specifically,
you inquire whether the county may establish its own standards
to avoid pollution of fresh water sources.
As you note, K.S.A. 55-316 et seq. does speak to this same
subject matter, K.S.A. 55-136 providing that:
"It shall be unlawful for any person, firm,
association or corporation having possession
or control of any well being drilled with ro-
tary tools or equipment, for oil or gas,
either as contractor, owner, lessee or mana-
ger or in any other capacity, to test, com-
plete or abandon such well, unless such person,
firm, association or corporation shall have
cemented in the surface or drive pipe below
the fresh water strata and shall have cemented
in additional pipe as shall be necessary to
protect from pollution such fresh water stra-
ta or any usable water strata in conformance
with rules and regulations which the state cor-
poration commission shall adopt and promulgate
in accordance with the joint recommendations
of the secretary of health and environment,
state geological survey, and state water re-
sources board. The casing of any well shall
be subject to inspection by the state corpora-
tion commission and shall be of proper weight
and of good quality.
"As used in this section, 'fresh water' shall
mean water containing not more than five hun-
dred (500) parts per million, chlorides, and
'usable water' shall mean water containing
more than five hundred (500) parts per million,
and not more than five thousand {5,000) parts
per million chlorides.
"Any person, firm, association or corporation
who violates any of the provisions of this
section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and
upon conviction thereof shall be punished by a
fine of not less than three hundred dollars
($300) nor more than one thousand dollars
($1,000), in the discretion of the court."
K.S.A. 55-137 is identical, except for the drilling method
(use of cable tools) that is specified. K.S.A. 55-138 re-
quires the filing of affidavits of compliance with the Kansas
Corporation Commission (KCC) and prescribes criminal penal-
ties for a failure to do so.
In your letter, you indicate that the only source of fresh
water underlying southern Logan County is a rock strata known
as the Dakota Formation. You believe that this formation is
being imperiled by the activities of oil companies who are
failing to cement the surface pipe (i.e., that casing which
is closest to the bore wall) down to a level of 1,500 feet
so as to protect the fresh-water bearing strata. Furthermore,
you indicate that while the KCC and the Department of Health
and Environment have been contacted, to date the problem per-
sists. Accordingly, you inquire concerning the home rule
authority of Logan County to require the drillers of oil
wells to set 1,500 feet of 8 3/4 inch surface pipe .so as to
safeguard the Dakota Formation from pollution.
In our opinion, such a course of action is not open to the
county under the home rule power granted by K.S.A. 19-101 et
seq. We base this result on the wording of K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
19-101a, wherein counties are made subject "to all acts of
the legislature which apply uniformly to all counties." While
the effect of similar language applicable to cities (contained
in Article 12, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution) has been
held to render entire acts non-uniform on the basis of a
single section [City of Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan.
332 (1980)], no such non-uniform language appears in this
act. Nor can it somehow be argued that the type of regula-
tion contemplated by the county commission is outside the
scope of the act. The language of K.S.A. 55-136 and 55-137
is explicit in empowering the KCC to adopt rules and regula-
tions which govern which strata are to be protected. K.A.R.
82-2-123. This regulation, it may be noted, prescribes depths
to which cement must be poured which were determined follow-
ing consultation with the Department of Health and Environ-
ment, the Kansas Geological Survey and the Kansas Water Re-
sources Board (now the Kansas Water Office). This is a fur-
ther indication of the statewide nature of the problem, and
of the resulting inapplicability of county home rule.
However, we should note that local authorities are not entirely
powerless. As mentioned earlier, the act establishes crim-
inal penalties for violations, which penalties consist of
fines from $300 up to $1,000. As is the case for all criminal
statutes of this state, enforcement is primarily the responsi-
bility of the county or district attorney. K.S.A. 19-702,
State ex rel. v. Baird, 117 Kan. 549 (1925). Accordingly,
while the county commission is without the power to set limits
to which oil companies must cement the surface pipe in oil
wells, the county attorney may enforce K.S.A. 55-136 et seq.
if standards set by the KCC are ignored or not fully met.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 55-136 et seq. require the surface pipe
of any oil or gas well to be cemented below the fresh water
strata, in order to protect such strata from pollution, and
apply both to wells drilled with rotary equipment or cable
tools. The act is supplemented by rules and regulations
adopted by the Kansas Corporation Commission, and contains
criminal penalties for any person, firm, association or cor-
poration who violates any of the sections thereof. While
responsibility for the enforcement of such criminal penalties
lies with district and county attorneys, insofar as the act
is uniformly applicable to all counties, a county may not
employ its home rule authority to enact a resolution on this
same subject.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.