Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-018

1981-018Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

January 22, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 18
Ray A. Neale
Coffeyville City Attorney
Municipal Building
Coffeyville, Kansas 67337
Re: Cities of the First Class--Commission Form of Government--
Filling Vacancies in Board of Commissioners
Synopsis: The provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 13-1806 require that a
vacancy occurring in the office of the city commissioner be
filled by the remaining commissioners selecting a successor
to serve until the next city general election. Even though
said statute is silent as to the election procedure to be
followed where such vacancy occurs during a term of office
that otherwise would not have expired at such election, the
apparent underlying legislative intent is that, at said
election, the qualified electors of the city elect a successor
to fill the balance of the unexpired term.
In the event that a successor is not elected, a vacancy
exists in such office, to be filled in the manner prescribed,.
by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 13-1806, but until the remaining members
of the city commission select someone to fill the vacancy,
the incumbent holds over in office as a de facto officer
until a successor has been selected and has qualified.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-1005k, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 13-1806.
*
Dear Mr. Neale:
As city attorney for the City of Coffeyville you have submitted a request
for our opinion in which you indicate that there are four city commis-
sioner positions to be filled at the forthcoming city general election--
three for regular terms of office and one for the balance of an unexpired
term. You have expressed the concern of the Coffeyville City Commission
that there might not be a candidate for the position having the unexpired
term, and your questions are directed toward that eventuality.
It is our understanding that Coffeyville is a city of the first class
having a city manager-commission form of government, and that, pursuant
to K.S.A. 12-1005k, the city commission is composed of five members
having staggered terms of office, three of whom are elected at each city
general election. You advise that presently one of the commissioners
holds office by virtue of an appointment to fill a vacancy in a commis-
sioner position having a term of office which extends beyond the next
city election, and although you did not so state in your letter of request ;
we assume that such vacancy was filled pursuant to K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
13-1806, the pertinent portion of which states:
"In case of any vacancy from any cause in the offices of
mayor or any commissioner, the board of commissioners shall,
by a majority vote of all the remaining members thereof,
elect some eligible person to serve in such capacity
until the next city general election." (Emphasis added.)
We recently had the occasion to construe the foregoing provisions in
Attorney General Opinion No. 81-16, and we are enclosing a copy, -
of that opinion for your consideration. Also, since that opinion quoted
at length from Attorney General Opinion No. 79-92, we also are enclosing
a copy of the latter opinion, as well. Please note that Opinion
No. 79-92 involved a factual situation nearly identical to the one
you have presented for our review.
In both of the enclosed opinions, we noted that the above-quoted portion
of 13-1806 is confusing and ambiguous, to the extent that it has
created a hiatus in the election procedure. However, we concluded that
the manifest purpose of the legislature underlying these provisions is
that "a person chosen by the remaining commissioners to fill a vacancy
should serve only until the next regularly-scheduled opportunity for
the city's electors to elect a successor" (Att'y Gen. Op. No. 81-16),
and we also concluded that the previously-quoted provisions of 13-1806
"must be construed as requiring the election of a successor to fill
the remainder of the unexpired term." Id. We state these conclusions
only by way of background, since we are not called upon here to recon-
sider them, and we note an implicit agreement with those opinions in
your letter of request.
In requesting our advice, you have suggested three possible alternatives
in the event there is not someone elected to fill the remainder of
the unexpired term: (1) The incumbent would hold over in office; or
(2) the remaining commissioners would appoint someone to fill the balance
of the term; or (3) the position would be "filled by the person getting
the fourth most votes," in the election to fill the three regular
positions.
As to the last alternative, we note that similar propositions were
rejected in both of the enclosed opinions, and in order to avoid
unduly burdening this opinion with the same type of discussion of
legal principles upon which we predicated those prior opinions, suffice
it to state that such alternative has no basis in any of the statutes
relevant to this issue. In particular, the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1005k
are plain and unambiguous in requiring that three commissioners be
elected at each city general election, with "[t]he candidates receiving
the largest and second largest number of votes, respectively, . . .
[being] elected for a four-year term and the candidate receiving the
third largest number of votes . . . [being] elected for the two-year
term." To also find that the legislature intended that the candidate
receiving the fourth largest number of votes be elected to fill a
commissioner position having an unexpired term would require mental
gymnastics of untold proportions. It would require a leap of faith
and logic which we are not prepared to make, particularly since it
would require the amendment of 12-1005k by implication, a result that
is never favored in the law. Tague v. Hudspeth, Warden, et al., 171
Kan. 225, 229 (1951).
Instead, it is our judgment that a combination of the other two alter-
natives provides the legally justifiable resolution of your inquiry.
As can be seen from the provisions of 13-1806 previously quoted herein,
the person selected by the remaining commissioners to fill a vacancy
on the commission serves only "until the next city general election."
This statute prescribes a very precise ending to the term of office
to be served by a person so selected. It does not authorize a
person to continue beyond such term, as for example, by serving until
such person's successor is elected and qualified. Notwithstanding
the absence of such language, however, it is our opinion that the
incumbent would hold over in office, but only until a successor shall
have been chosen by the remaining members of the city commission in the
manner prescribed by 13-1806.
Our conclusion is predicated, in part, on the fact that "the law
abhors vacancies in public offices." 67 C.J.S. Officers, §74a. As
was recognized in Attorney General Opinion No. 80-126, even in the
absence of specific constitutional or statutory provisions establishing
the right of an incumbent to hold over in office until his or her
successor is elected or appointed and qualified, such right is well-
established throughout the various jurisdictions. "Since the public
interest ordinarily requires that public offices should be filled at
all times without interruption . . . in the absence of an express or
implied constitutional provision to the contrary, an officer is entitled
to hold office until his successor is appointed or chosen and has
qualified." (Footnotes omitted.) 67 C.J.S. Officers, §71. The
foregoing has been affirmed in Kansas as "[t]he prevailing rule in the
United States." Murray v. Payne, 137 Kan. 685, 690 (1933). In Murray,
the Kansas Supreme Court construed a statute containing a holdover
provision, but it noted that even if such provision had not been present,
the holdover rule would apply. Id.
The Murray case was quoted and discussed at length in Attorney General
Opinion No. 80-126, in which it also was noted that "[o]ther juris-
dictions have recognized the holdover rule. In Grooms v. LaVale
Zoning Board, 27 Md. App. 266, 340 A.2d 385 (1975), for example, the
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland stated the rule thus:
"'It has long been recognized in this State, as
elsewhere, that the public interest requires, in
the absence of any provisions to the contrary,
that public offices should be filled at all times,
without interruption . . . . In accord with this
principle, the [Maryland] Court of Appeals has recog-
nized that an elected or appointed officer may remain
in office at the expiration of his term and is entitled
to exercise the powers of his office until his successor
qualifies, whether or not the statute creating the
office so provides.' (Citations omitted.) 340 A.2d
at 391." Atty Gen. Op. No. 80-126, at p. 4.
Thus, it is our opinion that, in the event there is no one elected
to the commissioner position having an unexpired term of office, the
incumbent holds over in such office, even though not specifically
authorized by statute to do so. However, it is our further opinion
that such failure to elect someone to fill the unexpired term creates
a vacancy in that position, to be filled as prescribed by K.S.A. 1980
Supp. 13-1806, and the incumbent holds over only as a de facto officer
until a successor to fill the vacancy has been so selected and has
qualified. 67 C.J.S. Officers, §271; Grooms v. LaVale Zoning Board,
supra. Upon such successor qualifying for office, the incumbent would
no longer hold or be entitled to exercise the powers of the office.
This proposition was discussed in State of Conneticut, ex rel. v. Watson,
132 Conn. 518, 45 A.2d 716, 164 A.L.R. 1238 (1946), as follows:
'If by constitutional provision or valid statute,
a definite term is established for an office
without provision that the incumbent shall continue
in office after its expiration, he will, in holding
over, be a de facto and not a de jure officer, and
a vacancy will result which may be filled by the
appointment, under proper authority, of a successor.
If, however, the term of office is not only for a
definite time but until a successor is appointed
and qualified, an incumbent holding over is a de jure
officer and unless, from the particular language of the
statute or the particular circumstances of the case,
a different legislative intent appears, there is no
vacancy in the office within a provision authorizing
an appointment in such a contingency." 45 A.2d at 720, 721.
In our opinion, the foregoing rules would have application to the
eventuality you have posed. Although such rules have not been expressly
considered by the Kansas Supreme Court, we believe the logic thereof
is compelling, and we believe they are to be regarded as dispositive
of the issue you have raised.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:phf
Enclosures: Attorney General Opinion Nos. 79-92 and 81-16

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.