King D'Arezzo v. Guild Mortgage

 	
'%'."!$R'//%
 	&=2:?E:77 	
+(  	2D6$@  + 	 (,(

*"#%')%#&$.
 	676?52?E 	


  	/  	  	
  	 	/  	

&=2:?E:77RC6KK@3C:?8DE9:D24E:@?D66<:?8C6=:677C@>E96=@2?96E@@<@FEE@
AFC492D69:D9@>6:?@F8=2D,J@>:?8 676?52?EF:=527E6CAFC492D:?8E96=@2?
7C@>E96@C:8:?2=4C62E@C:D?@HE96AC6D6?E@H?6C@7E96=@2? E:ED4@C6E9:D24E:@?
492==6?86DH96E96C676?52?EF:=592D2=682==J6?7@C4623=6:?E6C6DE:?E96=@2?DF49
E92EF:=542?6?7@C4627@C64=@DFC624E:@?282:?DERC6KK@7@C36:?8:?5672F=E@?E96
=@2? &C6D6?E=J367@C6E96@FCE2C63@E9A2CE:6DR4C@DD>@E:@?D7@CDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E
$@  	  2G:?84@?D:56C65E96A2CE:6DR3C:67DC6DA@?D6D2?5E96C64@C5:?E9:D
42D6E96@FCE8C2?ED676?52?EF:=5#@CE8286RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F58>6?E2?5
56?:6D&=2:?E:77C68@CJ"66!:?8RC6KK@RDAC@D6#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F58>6?E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 1 of 23

 	
%? $@G6>36C 	 	 C68@CJ "66 !:?8 RC6KK@ 3@CC@H65  	  7C@>
96CCJC66<#@CE8286""P96CCJC66<QE@AFC492D6C62=AC@A6CEJ=@42E652E
(@FE9'FDD6==G6?F6@F8=2D,J@>:?8PE96&C@A6CEJQ $@  M 	$@
2E )96=@2?P"@2?Q:D6G:56?4653J2AC@>:DD@CJ?@E6P$@E6QD:8?653J
RC6KK@ $@  	 2E )@D64FC6E96$@E6RC6KK@6I64FE652?5D:8?652
#@CE8286 @? E96 &C@A6CEJ :? 72G@C @7 #@CE8286 =64EC@?:4 '68:DEC2E:@? (JDE6>D ?4
P#'(Q2D?@>:?667@C96CCJC66<2?5:EDDF446DD@CD2?52DD:8?66D + 2E
,2CC2?EJ6652?5E96#@CE8286H6C6AC@A6C=JC64@C565:?E96C62=AC@A6CEJC64@C5D@7
@?G6CD6@F?EJ@?$@G6>36C  	 $@  	2E $@  	 2E
)96 E6C>D @7 E96 $@E6 C6BF:C65 RC6KK@ E@ >2<6 9:D 7:CDE >@?E9=J >@CE8286
A2J>6?E @? 2?F2CJ 	 	   $@  	  2E   E 2=D@ AC@G:565 E92E :7 RC6KK@
5672F=E65@?9:DA2J>6?E@3=:82E:@?DE96$@E69@=56C4@F=5C6BF:C6:>>65:2E6A2J>6?E:?
7F== + 2E
4 '-1(6- $#%,)306/& 5' !'/5* +3%6+5 #/,3615%: 11'--#5' #/'- #4 &'4%3+$'&   #/& +54 (6/%5+0/ #4
(0--084
+4 # 13+7#5' %03103#5+0/ 5#5 #&.+/+45'34 5*'   :45'. # /#5+0/#- '-'%530/+%
3')+453:5*#553#%,45*'53#/4('30(08/'34*+1+/5'3'454#/&4'37+%+/)3+)54+/.035)#)'-0#/4
!306) 5'   	:45'.   $'%0.'4 5*' .035)#)'' 0( 3'%03& (03 1#35+%+1#5+/)
.'.$'345306)#44+)/.'/50(5*'.'.$'34+/5'3'45450  +4-+45'&#45*')3#/5''
+/5*'0((+%+#-3'%03&4.#+/5#+/'&#5%06/5:3')+45'30(&''&40((+%'4!'-'/&'343'5#+/5'
130.+4403:/05'4#48'--#45*'4'37+%+/)3+)54505'.035)#)'4!'-'/&'34%#/5'/4'--
5*'4'+/5'3'45450+/7'450348+5065#7+/)503'%03&5*'53#/4#%5+0/+/5*'16$-+%3'%03&
+4%0.1'/4#5'&(03+544'37+%'45306)(''4%#3)'&501#35+%+1#5+/) .'.$'34
!    5+3
"   	 #       " &     '$   (005/05'4
0.+55'&
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 2 of 23

 	
(9@CE=J 27E6C RC6KK@ 6I64FE65 E96 $@E6 2?5 #@CE8286 96CCJ C66< D@=5 2?5
EC2?D76CC65E96$@E6E@,J@>:?8@>>F?:EJ6G6=@A>6?EFE9@C:EJ, $@
2E  M 	  $@  	  2E   M 	  RC6KK@ C646:G65 2?5 D:8?65 2 =6EE6C
24<?@H=658:?8 E9:D EC2?D76C 2?5 E92E 9:D 7:CDE >@CE8286 A2J>6?E H2D ?@H A2J23=6 E@
,   $@  	 2E 	  #'( E96? 2DD:8?65 E96 #@CE8286 E@ , 2?5 E96
2DD:8?>6?EH2DAC@A6C=JC64@C565:?E96@?G6CD6@F?EJC62=AC@A6CEJC64@C5D $@
2E

?63CF2CJ 	@?6>@?E927E6CE967:CDEA2J>6?EH2D5F6RC6KK@D6?E,
@?6D:=G6C5@==2C:?2?2EE6>AEE@A2J7@CE96"@2?:?7F== $@  	2E  ,
C6DA@?5653JC6EFC?:?8E96D:=G6C5@==2CE@RC6KK@2?5:?7@C>659:>E92E:EH@F=5?@E
2446AE2D:=G6C5@==2C2DA2J>6?E:?7F==7@CE96"@2? + DDF49RC6KK@5:5?@E>2<6
E967:CDE>@?E9=J>@CE8286A2J>6?E?@C2?JA2J>6?EDE96C627E6C $@   2EM
$@  	 2EM
?:>A@CE2?EAC@G:D:@?:?,RD28C66>6?EE@AFC492D6RC6KK@RD"@2?7C@>
96CCJ C66< H2D 2 4@?5:E:@? E92E :7 E96C6 H2D 2? 62C=J A2J>6?E 5672F=E @? E96 $@E6
96CCJ C66< H@F=5 C6AFC492D6 E96 "@2? 7C@> ,   $@  	  2E  M
)96C67@C65F6E@RC6KK@RD72:=FC6E@>2<62?JA2J>6?ED@?E96"@2?,C6BF:C65
96CCJC66<E@C6AFC492D6E96"@2? + 2EM

7E6CC6AFC492D:?8E96"@2?96CCJC66<7@C>2==JD@=52?5EC2?D76CC65E96"@2?
E@F:=5 $@  	2EM $@  	 2EM 	,E96?2DD:8?65E96
>@CE8286 E@ F:=5 2?5 AC@>AE=J C64@C565 E9:D 2DD:8?>6?E :? E96 @?G6CD6 @F?EJ C62=
AC@A6CEJ C64@C5D @? $@G6>36C 	 	   $@  	 2E   	 7E6C AFC492D:?8 E96
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 3 of 23

 	
"@2?F:=5?@E:7:65RC6KK@E92EE96$@E6H2DEC2?D76CC65E@F:=5E92EE96"@2?H2D:?
5672F=E2?5E92E2==7FEFC64@CC6DA@?56?462?5A2J>6?EDD9@F=5365:C64E65E@F:=5
$@  	 2EM

@H6G6C 2E E9:D E:>6 2? :DDF6 2C@D6 5FC:?8 F:=5RD AC@46DD:?8 @7 E96 "@2?
5@4F>6?ED C646:G65 7C@> 96CCJ C66<  FC:?8 F:=5RD D42??:?8 AC@46DD E96 @C:8:?2=
$@E6H2D:?25G6CE6?E=J=@DE@C56DEC@J65 $@  	 2EMM   )9@F89F:=5
4@?E6?5DE96=@DE@C56DEC@J65$@E6:DDE:==6?7@C4623=6F?56C,J@ (E2E L
$@  2E F:=5AC676CC65E@A@DD6DD2?@C:8:?2==JD:8?65AC@>:DD@CJ?@E62?52CC2?865
7@C96CCJC66<E96"@2?@C:8:?2E@CE@C6BF6DERC6KK@D:8?2C6A=246>6?E?@E6
$@  	  2E  M 	  96CCJ C66< 4@?E24E65 RC6KK@ 3J A9@?6 >6DD286 6>2:= 2?5
65IC6BF6DE:?896D:8?2C6A=246>6?E?@E63FERC6KK@C67FD65 + MM
$@ 2E  RC6KK@36=:6G65E9656DECF4E:@?@C>:DA=246>6?E@7E96$@E6C6?56C65
E96"@2?F?6?7@C4623=6 $@ 2E
?2D6C:6D@7=6EE6CDE@F:=596CCJC66<2?5E96=2H7:C>C6AC6D6?E:?8F:=5
RC6KK@2DD6CE65E96$@E62?5 @C"@2?H2DF?6?7@C4623=6?@?6I:DE6?E@CG@:5
$@ 2E $@ M 	RC6KK@56>2?565F:=5AC@G:569:>H:E9G2C:@FD'(
7@C>D2#@?6J$6E2:=J"@8'6A@CE 	2?5C6>@G62?JC6A@CED7C@>F:=52?5,
@?9:D4C65:EC6A@CE $@ 2E $@ 2E $@ 2E $@
2E 	 F:=5 C6DA@?565 E@ RC6KK@RD =6EE6CD 6IA=2:?:?8 E96 $@E6 H2D G2=:5 2?5
6?7@C4623=6E96'(7@C>D4@F=536@3E2:?655:C64E=J7C@>E96'(2?5E92EF:=5925
244FC2E6=JC6A@CE65RC6KK@RD9:DE@CJ@7?@?A2J>6?EE@E964C65:E3FC62F $@
D662=D@$@ 2E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 4 of 23

 	
642FD6RC6KK@925DE:==?@E>2562?JA2J>6?ED@?E96"@2?F:=54@>>6?465
2?@?;F5:4:2=7@C64=@DFC6@?E96&C@A6CEJ@?$@G6>36C 	 	 $@  	 2E
(9@CE=JE96C627E6CRC6KK@7:=65E9:D24E:@?
)9C@F89E96>6?565@>A=2:?E96C627E6CP@>A=2:?EQRC6KK@2DD6CED?:?6
4=2:>D282:?DEF:=5 )96@>A=2:?E2==686D F:=5=24<DDE2?5:?8E@7@C64=@D6@?E96
&C@A6CEJ F:=5G:@=2E65E96C2>>"6249=:=6J4E3J5:D4=@D:?8?@?AF3=:4A6CD@?2=
:?7@C>2E:@?E@?@?277:=:2E65E9:C5A2CE:6DRC6KK@H2D56?:65E96C:89EE@C6D4:?5E96
>@CE8286EC2?D24E:@?RC6KK@H2D56?:65E96C:89EE@A2J9:D>@CE8286A2J>6?E:?
2 D:=G6C 4@:?  F:=5 D=2?56C65 RC6KK@RD E:E=6 E@ E96 &C@A6CEJ 3J A@DE:?8 2?5
AF3=:D9:?82$@E:46@7672F=E2?5)CFDE66RD665RC6KK@D66<DBF:6EE:E=6E@E96
&C@A6CEJRC6KK@C6BF6DED564=2C2E@CJC6=:6724:G:='%4=2:>F?56C * (

L  6ED6B 282:?DEF:=52?52G:@=2E:@?@7E96'62=DE2E6(6EE=6>6?E&C@465FC6D
4E'(& $@  2E  F:=5E:>6=J7:=65:ED?DH6C $@
RC6KK@AC6G:@FD=J3C@F89E2(F>>2CJ F586>6?E#@E:@?2==68:?8E92EF:=5
72:=65E@>66E2G2C:6EJ@7AC@465FC2=C6BF:C6>6?ED:?:ED?DH6C $@  )9:D@FCE
56?:65E96>@E:@?3642FD6RC6KK@72:=65E@D9@HE92E2?2H2C5@7DF>>2CJ;F586>6?E
H2D2AAC@AC:2E62D2>2EE6C@7=2H $@

$@H367@C6E96@FCE2C63@E9A2CE:6DR>@E:@?D7@CDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E $@
? 255:E:@? &=2:?E:77 92D 7:=65 2 #@E:@? 7@C &C6=:>:?2CJ ?;F?4E:@? 2?5 #@E:@?
$@   2?5 #@E:@? 7@C 2? >6C86?4J 62C:?8  $@   @? 9:D C6BF6DE 7@C
AC6=:>:?2CJ :?;F?4E:@?  D 56E2:=65 36=@H E96 @FCE H:== 8C2?E 676?52?ERD >@E:@? 7@C
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 5 of 23

 	
DF>>2CJ ;F58>6?E 2?5 56?J &=2:?E:77RD >@E:@? 2D H6== 2D 9:D C6BF6DE 7@C AC6=:>:?2CJ
:?;F?4E:@? 2?5 6>6C86?4J 962C:?8   )96 F?5:DAFE65 724ED 6DE23=:D9 E92E 676?52?E :D
6?E:E=65E@DF>>2CJ;F58>6?E@?&=2:?E:77RD4=2:>D2?5:D=682==J6?E:E=65E@6?7@C46E96
$@E62?5#@CE8286:?E@H9:49E96A2CE:6D6?E6C65
PC@DD>@E:@?D7@CDF>>2CJ;F58>6?E2C6EC62E652DEH@:?5:G:5F2=>@E:@?D2?5
96=5E@E96D2>6DE2?52C5 Q(44,8(41< 089:3,80*(4$0:2,49;8(4*,536(4?
+ 	 	 	E9:C  	 4@FCED92==8C2?EDF>>2CJ;F586>6?EP:7E96
>@G2?ED9@HDE92EE96C6:D?@86?F:?65:DAFE62DE@2?J>2E6C:2=724E2?5E96>@G2?E:D
6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H Q65 ' :G & 2 724E:D>2E6C:2=:7:E:D
?646DD2CJE@56E6C>:?6E96@FE4@>6@7E9642D6 "5),8:9< (195452,5;4:(04
",958:58658(:054 5  	E9:C  	 5:DAFE6:D86?F:?6:76G:56?46
6I:DEDE92E:E>2J=6252C62D@?23=6EC:6C@7724EE@C6EFC?2G6C5:4E7@CE96?@?>@G:?8
A2CEJ  	20<,85< $8,10?*2,58658(:054   (FAA 5 	 	 @=@
?4@?D:56C:?8E96>@E:@?E96@FCEG:6HDE96C64@C52?52==C62D@?23=6:?76C6?46D:?
72G@C@7E96?@?>@G:?8A2CEJ (/2< /(82,9 (/2  !  ,-04,+,4
!,49054$8;9: 5   	E9:C
)96>@G:?8A2CEJ42CC:6DE963FC56?@76DE23=:D9:?8E92E?@86?F:?65:DAFE66I:DED
2?5E92EDF>>2CJ;F58>6?E:D2AAC@AC:2E62D2>2EE6C@7=2H (44(+?< 0:?5-05=(
+ 	  	 	E9:C  	 7E96>@G:?8A2CEJ42CC:6DE9:D:?:E:2=3FC56?E96?
E96?@?>@G:?8A2CEJ>FDEDF3>:EDF77:4:6?E6G:56?46:?DA64:7:4724EF2=7@C>D9@H:?8
E92E286?F:?6>2E6C:2=5:DAFE66I:DED (/2 52E  )6DE:>@?J@C@E96C
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 6 of 23

 	
6G:56?467@F?565@?DA64F=2E:@?:D:?DF77:4:6?EE@4C62E6286?F:?65:DAFE6@7>2E6C:2=
724E 54,9< 54,?=,224:A24*  5 	E9:C
67@C6E96@FCE2C63@E9A2CE:6DR>@E:@?D7@CDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E )9@F89
RC6KK@RD7:=:?8D2C6?@EE96:>286@74=2C:EJE96@FCE=:36C2==J4@?DECF6D9:DAC@D6
>@E:@?E@2DD6CEE92E32D65FA@?E96724ED@7E9642D6RC6KK@:D6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?E
2D2>2EE6C@7=2H $@   	2?5 	?4@>A2C:D@?F:=52C8F6DE92E:E:D
6?E:E=65E@DF>>2CJ;F586>6?E3642FD632D65@?E96F?5:DAFE65724EDRC6KK@RD4=2:>D
=24<=682=>6C:E2?5D9@F=5365:D>:DD65 $@  2E
249@7RC6KK@RD4=2:>DDE6>7C@>E96"@2?96E@@<@FEE@AFC492D6E96
&C@A6CEJ $@  	  )96C67@C66DD6?E:2=E@E9:D24E:@?:DE96"@2?RD492:?@7
EC2?D76C D5:D4FDD6523@G6E96"@2?RD492:?@7EC2?D76C:D6G:56?4653J6I9:3:ED2?5
277:52G:EDDF3>:EE653JF:=5 642FD6RC6KK@92D?@EAC@5F4656G:56?46@C2==6865
724EDE92E492==6?86E96=68:E:>24J@7E96D65@4F>6?EDE96@FCE7:?5D2D724EE92EE96
"@2?RD492:?@7EC2?D76CH2D7C@>96CCJC66<E@,324<E@96CCJC66<2?5
E96?E@F:=5 ,:E9E96D6724ED6DE23=:D965E96@FCE2DD6DD6D6249@7RC6KK@RD4=2:>
:?EFC?
,#%/+'#'!+( 	()%(
RC6KK@RD7:CDE4=2:>2DD6CEDE92EF:=55@6D?@E92G6DE2?5:?8E@7@C64=@D6@?
E96&C@A6CEJ (A64:7:42==J962C8F6DE92EF:=55@6D?@E92G6DE2?5:?83642FD6:E5@6D?@E
92G6E96@C:8:?2==@2?5@4F>6?E $@  2EMM  ?DFAA@CE@7E9:D2C8F>6?E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 7 of 23

 	
RC6KK@4:E6DE@656C2='F=6@7G:56?46 	3FE5@6D?@EAC@G:562?J2?2=JD:D7@C
9@HE9:DCF=6DFAA@CED9:D4=2:> +
'F=6 	C6BF:C6D2A2CEJE@@776C2?@C:8:?2=HC:E:?8H96?E964@?E6?ED@7E96
HC:E:?82C62E:DDF6F?=6DD2?@E96CCF=6@C7656C2=DE2EFE6AC@G:56D@E96CH:D6 65 ' G:5
G6?2DDF>:?8E964@?E6?ED@7E96"@2?2C62E:DDF6F:=52AE=J2C8F6DE92E
,J@>:?8(E2EFE6L 	 4@?EC@=D )9:DDE2EFE6AC@G:56DE92E
A6CD@??@E:?A@DD6DD:@?@72?:?DECF>6?E:D6?E:E=65E@6?7@C46E96:?DECF>6?E:7
E96A6CD@?H2D:?A@DD6DD:@?@7E96:?DECF>6?E2?56?E:E=65E@6?7@C46:EH96?
=@DD@7A@DD6DD:@?@44FCC65 E96=@DD@7A@DD6DD:@?H2D?@EE96C6DF=E@72
EC2?D76C3JE96A6CD@?@C2=2H7F=D6:KFC62?5E96A6CD@?42??@EC62D@?23=J
@3E2:?A@DD6DD:@?@7E96:?DECF>6?E3642FD6E96:?DECF>6?EH2D56DEC@J65:ED
H96C623@FED42??@E3656E6C>:?65@C:E:D:?E96HC@?87F=A@DD6DD:@?@72?
F?<?@H?A6CD@?@C2A6CD@?E92E42??@E367@F?5@C:D?@E2>6?23=6E@D6CG:46@7
AC@46DD
, (  L 	 2
7E96D6C6BF:C6>6?ED2C6>6EE96A6CD@?D66<:?86?7@C46>6?E@7E96:?DECF>6?E>FDE
PAC@G6E96E6C>D@7E96:?DECF>6?E2?5E96A6CD@?RDC:89EE@6?7@C46E96:?DECF>6?EQ2?5
>FDE256BF2E6=JAC@E64EE96A2J@C282:?DE2E9:C5A2CEJ4=2:>D66<:?8E@6?7@C46E96
:?DECF>6?E L 	 3 )9FDH96E96CF:=542?6?7@C46E96"@2?9:?86D@?:ED
23:=:EJE@>66EL 	 RDC6BF:C6>6?ED
:CDEF:=592DDF3>:EE652?77:52G:E@7"@DE&C@>:DD@CJ$@E63JC:2?%CD:?@
2EE6DE:?8E92EE96D6E9C66C6BF:C6>6?ED2C6>6E $@  	 2E  )96)6?E9:C4F:E
92D277:C>65E92E2?77:52G:E@7"@DE&C@>:DD@CJ$@E6D2E:D7:6DL 	 RD:?:E:2=
E9C66C6BF:C6>6?ED ",952;:054$8;9:586 < 5<, 5  	E9:C

(64@?5E96E6C>D@7E96:?DECF>6?E2C66DE23=:D9653JE964@AJ@7E96$@E62?5
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 8 of 23

 	
RC6KK@RD24<?@H=6586>6?E@7E966I64FE:@?@7E96$@E6 $@  	 2E$@
2EM ",952;:054$8;9:586 2EDE2E:?8E92E24@AJ@7E96?@E62?5
5676?52?ERD24<?@H=6586>6?E@7E966I64FE:@?@7?@E66DE23=:D9E96E6C>D@7E96?@E6
?5E9:C5=JF:=52DD6CEDE92ERC6KK@:DAC@E64E657C@>E9:C5A2CEJ4=2:>D3642FD6
F:=5<?@HDE92EE96$@E6H2D56DEC@J65 $@  2E 9,,(29548,03
65 AARI  	:C AC:=  	5:D4FDD:?8:56?E:42=C6BF:C6>6?ED
F?56C@=@C25@RD=@DE:?DECF>6?EDE2EFE6
>A@CE2?E=JRC6KK@92D?@E2==6865724ED@CAC@G:5656G:56?46E92E5:DAFE6DE96
77:52G:E2?5@C@E96C6G:56?46AC@G:5653JF:=52DE@E96#@CE82862?5$@E6 '2E96C
RC6KK@RD@>A=2:?E#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E2?5DF3D6BF6?E3C:67DC6=J@?=J
@?4@?4=FD@CJDE2E6>6?EDE92EF:=55@6D?@E92G62?:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ E5@6D @C
E96D6C62D@?DE96@FCE7:?5DE92ERC6KK@92D72:=65E@6DE23=:D9E92EF:=5=24<D
DE2?5:?8E@7@C64=@D6@?E96&C@A6CEJ2?5E96C67@C656?:6DRC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C
(F>>2CJ F586>6?E@?E9:D:DDF6 55:E:@?2==J3642FD6F:=592DAC6D6?E656G:56?46
6DE23=:D9:?8:EDDE2?5:?8E@6?7@C46E967@C64=@DFC624E:@?2?5RC6KK@92D?@E@776C65
6G:56?465:DAFE:?8E96D6724EDE96@FCE8C2?EDF:=5RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E
@?E9:D:DDF6
)&&"%#%.+
RC6KK@RDD64@?542FD6@724E:@?2DD6CED2G:@=2E:@?@7E96C2>>"6249=:=6J
4E P"Q 	 * (   L  	 ,: 9,7   $@  	 2E   )96 " :>A@D6D FA@?
7:?2?4:2= :?DE:EFE:@?D E96 P@3=:82E:@? E@ C6DA64E E96 AC:G24J @7 0E96:C1 4FDE@>6CD 2?5 E@
AC@E64E E96 D64FC:EJ 2?5 4@?7:56?E:2=:EJ @7 E9@D6 4FDE@>6CDR ?@?AF3=:4 A6CD@?2=
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 9 of 23

 	
:?7@C>2E:@? Q * (  L 	2 )@E92E6?5RC6KK@2DD6CEDE92EF:=5HC@?87F==J
5:D4=@D65P?@?AF3=:4A6CD@?2=:?7@C>2E:@?E@?@?277:=:2E65E9:C5A2CE:6DQ$@  2E
2?572:=65E@5:D4=@D67@C>DC6BF:C653J" $@  	2EM 	RC6KK@D:>A=J
>2<6D 4@?4=FD@CJ DE2E6>6?ED 7@==@H65 3J 2 4:E2E:@? E@ E96 " E@ DFAA@CE 9:D 4=2:>
$@  2EM$@  	2EM 	?4@?EC2DEF:=52C8F6DE92E:E5:5?@E
:?2AAC@AC:2E6=J D92C6 RC6KK@RD AC:G2E6 :?7@C>2E:@? 2?5 >@C6 :>A@CE2?E=J E92E
RC6KK@ =24<D DE2?5:?8 E@ 2DD6CE E9:D 4=2:> 3642FD6 E96C6 :D ?@ AC:G2E6 C:89E @7 24E:@?
F?56CE96" $@  2E $@  	2E
)96=2?8F286@7"5@6D?@E4C62E62AC:G2E642FD6@724E:@? 48,(<09
'  	 2?<C  @=@  	;4308,< 58.(4#:(42,?&4*  5
E9 :C  	 P$@ AC:G2E6 C:89E @7 24E:@? 6I:DED 7@C 2? 2==6865 G:@=2E:@? @7 E96
" Q  @FCED 92G6 2=D@ C67FD65 E@ C625 2? :>A=:65 AC:G2E6 42FD6 @7 24E:@? :?E@ E96
"3642FD6E96C6:D?@6G:56?46E92E@?8C6DD:?E6?565E@4C62E6DF492?24E:@? 80..9
< 36580(#:(:,(41$8 5   	& 	& 	 	(:   (4 ;.
#@C6@G6CC6KK@92D72:=65E@3C:?8E@E96@FCERD2EE6?E:@?2?JDE2EFE6@C
42D6=2HAC@G:5:?8@E96CH:D6
44@C5:?8=J6G6?2DDF>:?87@CE96D2<6@72C8F>6?EE92EF:=5RD4@?5F4EG:@=2E65
E96 " RC6KK@ 42??@E >2:?E2:? 2 AC:G2E6 42FD6 @7 24E:@? 7@C 2? 2==6865 "
G:@=2E:@?  @C E92E C62D@? E96 A2CE:6D 5:DAFE6 @? H96E96C F:=5 :?2AAC@AC:2E6=J D92C65
RC6KK@RDAC:G2E6A6CD@?2=:?7@C>2E:@?:D:>>2E6C:2= RC6KK@RD4=2:>72:=D2D2>2EE6C
@7=2H 44@C5:?8=JE96@FCE56?:6DRC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F58>6?E )@E92E
6?5E96@FCE7:?5DE92EF:=592D>6E:ED3FC56?@7AC@G:?8E92E:E:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 10 of 23

 	
2D2>2EE6C@7=2H@?E9:D4=2:>3642FD6"5@6D?@E2==@HRC6KK@E@3C:?82AC:G2E6
42FD6 @7 24E:@?  )96 @FCE 8C2?ED DF>>2CJ ;F58>6?E :? 72G@C @7 F:=5 @? RC6KK@RD
"4=2:>
#!"++(*#'
RC6KK@RDE9:C54=2:>2DD6CED2G:@=2E:@?@7E96)CFE9:?"6?5:?84EP)"Q
)"AC@G:56D4@?DF>6CD2C:89EE@C6D4:?524@?DF>6C4C65:EEC2?D24E:@?H96C62D64FC:EJ
:?E6C6DE:DC6E2:?65:?E96@3=:8@CRDAC:?4:A2=5H6==:?8  * (  L 2 ?56CE9:D4E
RC6KK@2C8F6DE92EF:=5RDAC65646DD@C96CCJC66<#@CE828672:=65E@?@E:7J9:>@7
9:DDE2EFE@CJC:89EE@C6D4:?5E96>@CE8286EC2?D24E:@? $@  2EM 9,, * (

L 	2  RC6KK@ 7FCE96C 2==686D E92E 96 ?@E:7:65 96CCJ C66< @7 9:D :?E6?E:@? E@
6I6C4:D6 9:D C:89E E@ C6D4:?5 E96 EC2?D24E:@? :? AC:= 2?5 %4E@36C @7 	 3FE 96CCJ
:8?@C65E964@CC6DA@?56?462?55:5?@EC6D4:?5E96EC2?D24E:@? $@  2EM ?
4@>A2C:D@? F:=5 4@?E6?5D E92E RC6KK@RD 4=2:> 72:=D 3642FD6 96 :D ?@E 6?E:E=65 E@ 2
DE2EFE@CJC:89E@7C6D4:DD:@?5F6E@2?6IAC6DD6I46AE:@?H:E9:?)" $@  	2E
,9:=6 )" 5@6D AC@G:56 4@?DF>6CD 2 DE2EFE@CJ C:89E E@ C6D4:?5 46CE2:? 4C65:E
EC2?D24E:@?D * (  L 2)"5@6D45:6IE6?5E9:DC:89EE@PC6D:56?E:2=>@CE8286
EC2?D24E:@?0D1 Q * (  L 6 9,,#04./< % # (41(:054(2995 65
AARI 	 	  	E9:C #2J  	277:C>:?85:D>:DD2=@7A=2:?E:77RD)"4=2:>
32D65FA@?)"RD:?2AA=:423:=:EJE@2C6D:56?E:2=>@CE8286EC2?D24E:@? )"567:?6D2
PC6D:56?E:2= >@CE8286 EC2?D24E:@?Q 2D P2 EC2?D24E:@? :? H9:49 2 >@CE8286 5665 @7 ECFDE
AFC492D6>@?6JD64FC:EJ:?E6C6DE2C:D:?8F?56C2?:?DE2==>6?ED2=6D4@?EC24E@C6BF:G2=6?E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 11 of 23

 	
4@?D6?DF2= D64FC:EJ :?E6C6DE :D 4C62E65 @C C6E2:?65 282:?DE E96 4@?DF>6CD 5H6==:?8 E@
7:?2?46E9624BF:D:E:@?@C:?:E:2=4@?DECF4E:@?@7DF495H6==:?8 Q * (  L  	I
6C6 E96 F?5:DAFE65 724ED 6DE23=:D9 E92E RC6KK@RD EC2?D24E:@? :D 2 C6D:56?E:2=
>@CE8286 EC2?D24E:@? 3642FD6 E96 "@2? H2D @3E2:?65 E@ 7:?2?46 E96 AFC492D6 2?5
24BF:D:E:@?@7RC6KK@RDA6CD@?2=C6D:56?46 $@  2EM 	P=2:>2?E6?E6C65
:?E@24@?DF>6CEC2?D24E:@?   E@@3E2:?2 	 	>@CE8286=@2?D64FC653J=2:>2?ED
AC:?4:A2=C6D:56?46   Q$@  	 2E 44@C5:?8=JF?56C)"RD6I46AE:@?7@C
C6D:56?E:2=>@CE8286EC2?D24E:@?DRC6KK@92D?@DE2EFE@CJC:89EE@C6D4:?5E96EC2?D24E:@?
2?5 96CCJ C66< 2?5 :ED DF446DD@C F:=5 5:5 ?@E G:@=2E6 )" 3J 72:=:?8 E@ :?7@C>
RC6KK@@72C:89E965:5?@EA@DD6DD
@CE96D6C62D@?DRC6KK@92D72:=65E@6DE23=:D9E92E96:D6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?E
2D2>2EE6C@7=2H2?5E96@FCE56?:6DRC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E@?
E9:D4=2:> FCE96C>@C6E96@FCE8C2?EDDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E:?72G@CF:=53642FD6F:=5
92D6DE23=:D965E92E:E@H65?@5FEJE@RC6KK@F?56C)"
'#%-)(%%)*.&'+#' 	,%%
?9:D7@FCE94=2:>RC6KK@2DD6CED96H2D56?:659:DPC:89EE@A2J:?D:=G6C4@:? Q
$@  2E 	M 	?63CF2CJ 	RC6KK@E6?56C652D@=6D:=G6C5@==2CE@,
:?2?2EE6>AEE@A2JE96"@2?:?7F== $@   2EM  %?#2C49  	,
C6EFC?65E96D:=G6C5@==2CE@RC6KK@:?2=6EE6CDE2E:?8P,62C6?@E23=6E@2446AEJ@FC
D:=G6C5@==2C2DA2J>6?E:?7F==@?0E961=@2?N ,62C6C6EFC?:?8E96D:=G6C5@==2C Q
!'45#56503:&'(+/+5+0/(03=3'4+&'/5+#-.035)#)'53#/4#%5+0/>#4$''/3'&'4+)/#5'&(30.<  850<  9
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 12 of 23

 	
$@  	2E 	?C6DA@?D6E@#C RC6KK@RDAC:=  	4@CC6DA@?56?46E@96CCJ
C66<E96,5:DAFE659:D2DD6CE:@?E92EE96=@2?2?5>@CE8286925366?42?46=65
$@  	2E  )@E964@?EC2CJE96,25G:D65#C RC6KK@E92E:EC6>2:?65
:?E24E2?596C6>2:?65@3=:82E65E@>2<69:DA2J>6?ED + 6H2D2=D@:?G:E65282:?E@
G:6HE96@C:8:?2=AC@>:DD@CJ?@E62E,RD2DA6C@77:46 +
RC6KK@ 2C8F6D E9:D C67FD2= E@ 2446AE 9:D D:=G6C 5@==2C A2J@77 G:@=2E65 2?
F?DA64:7:65AC@G:D:@?@7E96,J@>:?8@?DE:EFE:@?E96,J@>:?8RDP4@:?28624EQ2?5E96
:CDE>6?5>6?E2?5CE:4=6%?6(64E:@? 	@7E96*?:E65(E2E6D@?DE:EFE:@? + 82:?
RC6KK@5@6D?@EAC@G:562?J2?2=JD:D7@C9:D4=2:>C2E96C96D:>A=J>2<6D4@?4=FD@CJ
DE2E6>6?EDE92E96:D6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?EF?56CE96=2H + G6?4@?DECF:?8E9:D4=2:>
=:36C2==JRC6KK@RD4=2:>E92EF:=5HC@?87F==J56?:65E96D:=G6C4@:?2D7F==A2J>6?E
7@CE96"@2?72:=D7@C>2?JC62D@?D
:CDERC6KK@5@6D?@EDA64:7JH92EAC@G:D:@?@7E96,J@>:?8@?DE:EFE:@?H2D
2==6865=JG:@=2E65 '682C5=6DD,J@>:?85@6D?@EC64@8?:K6242FD6@724E:@?32D65@?2?
2==6865 G:@=2E:@? @7 :ED @?DE:EFE:@? F?=6DD E96C6 :D :>A=6>6?E:?8 =68:D=2E:@? DE2E:?8
@E96CH:D6  (? <  #5;:/,(9: &?5  ,4:(2 ,(2:/ :8   & 	5    ,J@
9@=5:?8 P4:G:= C:89ED 4=2:>D 32D65 @? E96 ,J@>:?8 @?DE:EFE:@? 72:= 3642FD6 @7 ?@
:>A=6>6?E:?8=68:D=2E:@?Q,9,239<  	**0+,4:(2!,:85 586 $@  +  	* (
:DE "-(  2E  	 ,J@  	#:54,< #0354,$@  +

( :DE "-( 2E  	 ,J@  	 642FD6RC6KK@72:=DE@4:E6E96
DA64:7:4AC@G:D:@?F:=52==6865=JG:@=2E652?53642FD6RC6KK@92D?@EAC6D6?E652?J
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 13 of 23

 	
=682=2FE9@C:EJE92EDF886DEDDF492AC:G2E642FD6@724E:@?7@CE9:D4=2:>E96@FCE7:?5D
E92E965:5?@E>66E9:D3FC56?D9@H:?8E92E96:D6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H
(64@?52=E9@F89RC6KK@5@6D?@E:56?E:7JH9:49DE2EFE6D96492C24E6C:K6D2D
,J@>:?8RDP4@:?28624EQE@E966IE6?E96:?E6?5DE@C676CE@E96,J@>:?8"682=)6?56C
4E,J@ (E2E L  	,:9,7 E92E4E4@?EC25:4ED9:DA@D:E:@? )964EAC@9:3:ED2
A6CD@?7C@>4@>A6==:?82?J@E96CA6CD@?@C=682=6?E:EJE@2446AE8@=5@CD:=G6C4@:?2D
=682= E6?56C  ,J@  (E2E  L    9,, (295 L   	 D DF49 E96 4E AC@9:3:ED
RC6KK@ 7C@> 4@>A6==:?8 , E@ 2446AE E96 D:=G6C 5@==2C 2D A2J>6?E 2?5 96 :D
E96C67@C6?@E6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H7@CE9:D4=2:>
)9:C5RC6KK@RD4=2:>7@C2G:@=2E:@?@7E96*?:E65(E2E6D@?DE:EFE:@?72:=DE@
DFAA@CE2 * (  L 24E:@? (64E:@? 5@6D?@E4C62E62?JDF3DE2?E:G6C:89ED@C
2?:?56A6?56?E42FD6@724E:@? #,,85=4< ;/3(4 	 5 	  	 ?  	E9:C
? 255:E:@? 2 4=2:> F?56C L 	 C6BF:C6D DE2E6 24E:@?OAC:G2E6 24E@CD 2C6 ?@E
DF3;64EE@=:23:=:EJ #,,(22(./,8< ,02'5;4.8,,+5354*,8: 5    	E9
:C  L =:23:=:EJ@?=J2EE2496DE@4@?5F4EH9:49@44FCDF?56CDE2E6=2H?@EAC:G2E6
4@?5F4E #@C6@G6C2C6BF:C6>6?E@76G6CJL 4=2:>:DE92EE96A=2:?E:77>FDEDA64:7J
E965676?52?ERDA6CD@?2=:?G@=G6>6?E:?E962==68654@?DE:EFE:@?2=G:@=2E:@? #/4,0+,8<
0:?5-8(4+;4:054!520*,,6A:  5  	E9:C  	 RC6KK@4=2:>D
,56?:659:D2EE6>AEE@A2J:?D:=G6C4@:?$@  2E 	M 3FE,:D?@E
2A2CEJE@E9:D42D62?5:D?@E?2>652D25676?52?E:?E96@>A=2:?E 642FD6RC6KK@
5@6D?@E2==686724EDD9@H:?8F:=5RDA6CD@?2=:?G@=G6>6?E:?E962==68654@?DE:EFE:@?2=
56AC:G2E:@?9:D4=2:>72:=D2D2>2EE6C@7=2H
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 14 of 23

 	
RC6KK@42??@E>2<6@FE24=2:>32D65@?,RDC6;64E:@?@7@?6D:=G6C5@==2C
@776C65:?7F==D2E:D724E:@?@7E96"@2? RC6KK@:D?@E6?E:E=65E@DF>>2CJ;F58>6?E@?
E9:D4=2:> 55:E:@?2==JF:=52C8F6DE92E:E:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H7@C
E9:D4=2:>3642FD6RC6KK@@776C65E96D:=G6C5@==2C2DA2J>6?E7@CE96"@2?04-;22O
H9:49,AC@>AE=JC6;64E652?5C6EFC?65E@RC6KK@ $@  2E  RC6KK@
92D72:=65E@D6E7@CE99@H,RDC6;64E:@?6?E:E=6D9:>E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H
282:?DEF:=52?592D72:=65E@5:DAFE6F:=5RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E@?E9:D
4=2:> DDF49E96@FCE8C2?EDF:=5RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E
%')( #+%
RC6KK@RD7:7E94=2:>DE2E6DE92EF:=55:DA2C2865D=2?56C652?54=@F565
RC6KK@RDE:E=6E@E96&C@A6CEJ3JPAC6A2C:?8A@DE:?8AF3=:D9:?82?5C64@C5:?8Q
5@4F>6?EDE@6?7@C46E96"@2?282:?DERC6KK@ $@  2E 	MM
55:E:@?2==J962DD6CEDF:=5<?6H@CD9@F=592G6<?@H?E92EE96D65@4F>6?EDH6C6
:>AC@A6C3642FD6F:=592D?@C:89EE:E=6@C:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ + 2EM
$@E23=JRC6KK@5@6D?@E4:E6E@2?J=682=2FE9@C:EJE@DFAA@CEE96D62==682E:@?D ?
4@?EC2DEF:=52C8F6DE92E:E92DE96=682=C:89EE@6?7@C46E96"@2?2?54@?D6BF6?E=J
E96C6H2D?@E9:?872=D6@C>2=:4:@FD23@FEF:=5RD24E:@?D $@  2E

(=2?56C:D567:?65:?,J@>:?82DP272=D62?5>2=:4:@FDDE2E6>6?E>256:?
5:DA2C286>6?E@72A6CD@?RDE:E=6E@C62=@CA6CD@?2=AC@A6CEJ@C@7D@>6C:89E@79:D
42FD:?89:>DA64:2=52>286 Q05+,3;9< %4054!( 586   5 	 	?
E9:C  	 2D65FA@?E9:D567:?:E:@?RC6KK@RD4=2:>@?=JDF44665D:796
6DE23=:D96DE92EF:=5RDDE2E6>6?ED2C63@E972=D62?5>2=:4:@FDO>62?:?8E964CFI@7E96
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 15 of 23

 	
:DDF6:DH96E96CF:=592DE96C:89EE@6?7@C46E96"@2? )9@F89?@E@3G:@FD=J4=62C7C@>
9:D3C:67DE96@FCE=:36C2==J4@?DECF6DRC6KK@E@E2<6:DDF6H:E9F:=5RD6?7@C46>6?E
@7E96=@2? :CDE:DE96"@2?RD492:?@7EC2?D76C2?5D64@?5:DF:=5?@E36:?8:?
A@DD6DD:@?@7E96@C:8:?2==@2?5@4F>6?E
DAC6G:@FD=J6IA=2:?65E96"@2?RD492:?@7EC2?D76C:D4=62C RC6KK@E@@<@FE2
"@2?7@CE96&C@A6CEJ7C@>96CCJC66<H9@E96?EC2?D76CC65E96"@2?2?5:ED
244@>A2?J:?8$@E62?5#@CE8286E@, $@  	 2E$@  	2E
M  C@>E96C6,EC2?D76CC65E96"@2?324<E@96CCJC66<H9@E96?AC@466565
E@EC2?D76CE96"@2?E@F:=5H9@:DE964FCC6?E@H?6C@7E96"@2? $@   2EM
$@  	2E 	F:=5RD@H?6CD9:A@7E96"@2?:D6G:56?4653JE96DD:8?>6?E
@7#@CE8286E92E:DC64@C565:?@?G6CD6@F?EJRDC64@C5D $@  	2E
55:E:@?2==JE96"@2?RD492:?@7EC2?D76C:DF?5:DAFE652DRC6KK@92D72:=65E@AC@G:56
2?J5@4F>6?EDE92EBF6DE:@?E96G2=:5:EJ@7E96D6C64@C5D
)96724EE92EE96@C:8:?2="@2?H2D6:E96C=@DE2C656DEC@J65:D:>>2E6C:2=96C6
3642FD6,J@>:?82==@HD2=@DE@C56DEC@J65=@2?E@366?7@C465:746CE2:?C6BF:C6>6?ED
2C6>6E ,J@ (E2E L 	  D5:D4FDD65AC6G:@FD=JE96F?5:DAFE65724ED
6DE23=:D9O2?5RC6KK@92D72:=65E@5:DAFE6OE92EF:=5>66EDE96D6C6BF:C6>6?ED
)9FD2D=682=@H?6C@7E96"@2?2?J5@4F>6?EDF:=5AC6A2C65E@6?7@C46E92E"@2?2C6
?@E72=D6@C>2=:4:@FD3642FD6F:=5>2:?E2:?DE96C:89EE@E2<6DF496?7@C46>6?E24E:@?
/+4 63'1-:?3';;0#-40#11'#345026'45+0/5'7#-+&+5:0(5*'0#/$'%#64'5*'05'-#%,4#/--0/)'
#55#%'&50+50 	 #5 08'7'3?3';;0&0'4/05%+5'#/:-')#-#6503+5:5*#545#5'4#/--0/)'+4
3'26+3'&50.#,'#0#/#/&+5405''/(03%'#$-'035*'4'3'#40/45*'0635&0'4/05(+/&5*+4#3)6.'/550*#7'
-')#-.'3+5
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 16 of 23

 	
?DF>RC6KK@92D72:=65AC@G:566G:56?46E92E5:DAFE6D@C4C62E6D286?F:?6
:DDF6@7>2E6C:2=724E2DE@F:=5RD=682=@H?6CD9:A@7E96"@2?2?5F:=5RD6?E:E=6>6?EE@
D66<6?7@C46>6?E@7E96"@2? $6:E96C92DRC6KK@AC6D6?E652?J724EDE92ED9@H
F:=5RDDE2E6>6?EDH6C672=D62?5>2=:4:@FD ?57@CE96D6C62D@?DE96@FCE7:?5DE92E
RC6KK@92D72:=65E@6DE23=:D9F:=54@>>:EE65D=2?56C@7E:E=62?556?:6DRC6KK@RD
#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E )96@FCE8C2?EDF:=5RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ
F586>6?E@?E9:D:DDF63642FD6F:=592D6DE23=:D965E92ERC6KK@RD4=2:>72:=D2D2
>2EE6C@7=2H
,#+#+%
RC6KK@RDD:IE942FD6@724E:@?D66<DE@BF:6EE:E=6E@E96&C@A6CEJ:?9:>D6=7 6
2DD6CEDF:=55@6D?@EP9@=52A6C764E652?5D64FC654=2:>:?E96AC@A6CEJQ2?592DP?@
C:89E6DE2E6E:E=6=:6?@C:?E6C6DE:?@CE@E96AC@A6CEJ@CA2CE@7E96AC@A6CEJ Q$@
2E 	M 82:?RC6KK@2C8F6DE92EF:=592D?@:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ5F6
E@E96724EE92EF:=5:D?@E:?A@DD6DD:@?@7E96%C:8:?2=$@E6 + FE2DE96@FCE92D
2=C625J255C6DD65F:=5RD77:52G:E@7"@DE&C@>:DD@CJ$@E63JC:2?%CD:?@6DE23=:D96D
F:=5RD:?E6C6DE:?E96"@2?2?5:ED23:=:EJE@6?7@C46:EAFCDF2?EE@,J@>:?8(E2EFE6L
FCE96CC682C5=6DD@7F:=5RD:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJRC6KK@RDBF:6EE:E=64=2:>
72:=D3642FD69632D65E964=2:>@?E96H62<?6DD@7F:=5RDE:E=6C2E96CE92?E96DEC6?8E9
@7RC6KK@RDE:E=6E@E96&C@A6CEJ ?2BF:6EE:E=624E:@?E96A=2:?E:77362CDE96P3FC56?
@7AC@@72?5>FDEDE2?5@?E96DEC6?8E9@709:D1@H?E:E=62?5?@E@?E96H62<?6DD@7E96
E:E=6@75676?52?ED Q08)?"5?(2:0,94* < $,>(54 & 	5 	 	,J@

Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 17 of 23

 	
)96)6?E9:C4F:E277:C>65E9:DDE2?52C5:?#68,0:@,8DE2E:?8E92EE96A=2:?E:77RD4=2:>
72:=D3642FD696?6G6C2DD6CE65E92E96925DFA6C:@CE:E=6 #68,0:@,8< ,;:9*/,(41(:
$8 5  	65 AARI 	E9:C  	 (A64:7:42==JE96@FCE5C6H2EE6?E:@?
E@E96724EE92EE96A=2:?E:77?6G6C4=2:>65E92E96925D2E:D7:65E96?@E6@CH2D?@E:?
5672F=E2?5E9FD925DFA6C:@CE:E=6 +
(:>:=2C=JRC6KK@92D72:=65E@4=2:>E92E9692DD2E:D7:65E96"@2?@C:D?@E:?
5672F=E )9FD9:D4=2:>72:=D3642FD69692D?@E2DD6CE659:DBF:6EE:E=624E:@?32D65FA@?
E96DFA6C:@C:EJ@79:D@H?E:E=63FEC2E96CFA@?E96H62<?6DD@7F:=5RDE:E=6E@E96
&C@A6CEJ )96C67@C6E96@FCE7:?5DE92ERC6KK@92D?@E6DE23=:D965E92E96:D6?E:E=65
E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H2?59:D#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F586>6?E@?E9:D4=2:>:D
56?:65
FCE96C>@C6F:=52C8F6DE92ERC6KK@RDBF:6EE:E=64=2:>72:=D2D2>2EE6C@7=2H
3642FD6965@6D?@E92G62G2=:532D:DE@5:DAFE6F:=5RD4=2:>E@E96&C@A6CEJ $@
2E  DAC6G:@FD=JDE2E65RC6KK@92D?@EAC6D6?E652?J6G:56?46E@D9@H2
>2E6C:2=5:DAFE62DE@F:=5RD:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ@CE@6DE23=:D9E92E9692DDFA6C:@C
E:E=6@G6CF:=5RD:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ @CE96D6C62D@?DRC6KK@RDBF:6EE:E=624E:@?
72:=D2?5E96@FCE8C2?EDF:=5RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F58>6?E@?E9:D4=2:>
%)+().%#
RC6KK@RDD6G6?E94=2:>6?4@>A2DD6DE96@G6C2C49:?8E96>6@7E9:D24E:@?OE92E
RC6KK@C6BF6DEDE96@FCEE@9@=5E92EF:=592D?@:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ2?5E@
C6=:6G6RC6KK@@79:D"@2? $@  2E 	MM  82:?RC6KK@5@6D?@E
AC@G:562?J=682=2FE9@C:EJ@C2?2=JD:DE@DFAA@CE9:D4=2:> + F:=52C8F6DE92E3642FD6
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 18 of 23

 	
RC6KK@92D72:=65E@AC6D6?E6G:56?46E92E5:DAFE6DF:=5RD:?E6C6DE:?E96&C@A6CEJ2?5
92D72:=65E@2DD6CE2G:23=6=682=4=2:>282:?DEF:=5RC6KK@RD4=2:>72:=D2D2>2EE6C
@7=2H $@  2E

G6?E9@F89E96@FCE>FDE=:36C2==J4@?DECF6AC@D62C8F>6?EDE96@FCE>2J
?@E4C62E62C8F>6?ED7@CE96=:E:82?E 08)?<  	=,45(4#,8<004. 65
AARI   ? 	 	E9:C  	 ?3@E9E96@>A=2:?E2?5RC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C
(F>>2CJ F586>6?E9672:=DE@D9@HH9J2D2>2EE6C@7=2H96:D6?E:E=65E@
564=2C2E@CJC6=:67 @CE96D6C62D@?DE96@FCE7:?5DE92ERC6KK@92D72:=65E@6DE23=:D9
E92E96:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H )9FD9:D#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ
F586>6?E:D56?:65 FCE96CE96@FCE7:?5DE92EF:=592D6DE23=:D965:E:D6?E:E=65E@
;F586>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H@?E9:D4=2:>
$6IERC6KK@2DD6CEDE92EF:=5G:@=2E65E96'24<6E66C?7=F6?4652?5@CCFAE
%C82?:K2E:@?4EP'%Q $@  2E MM  RC6KK@4=2:>DE92EF:=5
G:@=2E65'%3JP6?828:?8:?AC65:42E624ED@7>2:=7C2F5>2?F724EFC:?872=D66G:56?46
@7:?563E65?6DD2?56?828:?8:?>@?6E2CJEC2?D24E:@?D:>AC@A6C=J56C:G657C@>
F?=2H7F=24E:G:EJ    Q+ F:=54@F?E6CDE92ERC6KK@92D72:=65E@DF77:4:6?E=J2==6862
'%4=2:>2?5:D?@E6?E:E=65E@;F586>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H $@  2E

)@3C:?82DF446DD7F='%4=2:>RC6KK@>FDE2DD6CEH:E9A2CE:4F=2C:EJE96
4@?5F4E@72?6?E6CAC:D6E9C@F892A2EE6C?@7C24<6E66C:?824E:G:EJ $(2< 5.(4
5 	 	  	E9:C  	 )96A2CE:4F=2C:EJC6BF:C6>6?E@7656C2='F=6@7:G:=
&C@465FC632AA=:6DE@'%4=2:>D2?5C6BF:C6DE964@>A=2:?EE@:56?E:EJE96A2CEJ
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 19 of 23

 	
>2<:?872=D6DE2E6>6?ED2?5E96E:>6A=2462?54@?E6?ED@7E9672=D6C6AC6D6?E2E:@? +
2E 	BF@E:?85*/< 5*/4+;9  	 5 	 	 	E9:C
6DA:E6E96D6D6C:@FD2==682E:@?DRC6KK@72:=DE@>66EE96A2CE:4F=2C:EJ
C6BF:C6>6?E 65@6D?@EDE2E6DA64:7:4:?DE2?46D@7F:=54@>>:EE:?8>2:=7C2F5
>2?F724EFC:?872=D66G:56?46@7:?563E65?6DD@C6?828:?8:?>@?6E2CJEC2?D24E:@?D
:>AC@A6C=J56C:G657C@>F?=2H7F=24E:G:EJ #,,$8549.(8+< 04(40(285;64
(FAA 5   !2?D2D 	5:D4FDD:?8C6BF:C6>6?EDE@D2E:D7J'F=6
2?5567:4:6?4:6D:?DE2E:?8'%4=2:> FCE96CRC6KK@72:=DE@@FE=:?6E96>F=E:A=6
24ED@7F:=5E92EH@F=54@?DE:EFE62PA2EE6C?Q@7C24<6E66C:?824E:G:EJ E>@DE
RC6KK@>2<6D4@?4=FD@CJDE2E6>6?EDE92EF:=5>25672<6563E5@4F>6?E2E:@?2?5
F?=2H7F==JD@=52?5EC2?D76CC65@H?6CD9:A@7E96"@2?2?5$@E6$@  2EM
FE4@?4=FD@CJDE2E6>6?EDH:E9@FEDA64:7:4724EF2=2==682E:@?D2C6:?DF77:4:6?EE@
DF446DD7F==J2==6862'%G:@=2E:@? #;220<(4< %40< 5-(4 596 ;:/ 65
AARI  	E9:C  	C6BF:C:?8>@C6E92?4@?4=FD@CJ2==682E:@?D@74C:>:?2=
4@?5F4EE@DF77:4:6?E=JA=6252'%G:@=2E:@?
)96@FCE7:?5DE92ERC6KK@92D72:=65E@>66EE96A2CE:4F=2C:EJC6BF:C6>6?E
DE2E62A=2FD:3=6'%4=2:>>F49=6DD6DE23=:D9E92E96:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2
>2EE6C@7=2H@?E9:D4=2:> DDF49RC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ F58>6?E72:=D
)96@FCE2=D@7:?5DE92EF:=592D6DE23=:D965E92E:E:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C
@7=2H2?58C2?EDDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E:?:ED72G@C@?RC6KK@RD'%4=2:>
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 20 of 23

 	
RC6KK@RD7:?2=4=2:>2DD6CEDE92EF:=5G:@=2E65E96'62=DE2E6(6EE=6>6?E
&C@465FC6D4E3642FD6PE96A2J>6?ED36EH66?E96676?52?EDH6C6>:D=625:?82?5
56D:8?65E@4C62E62H:?572== Q$@  2E M 	)9@F89:E:D?@E6I24E=J4=62C
H92EAC@G:D:@?RC6KK@4=2:>DF:=5G:@=2E653642FD696C676C6?46DE96@FD:?82?5
*C32?6G6=@A>6?ERDE6DE7@C56E6C>:?:?8E96=682=:EJ@7=6?56CA2J>6?EDE@>@CE8286
3C@<6CDE96@FCEF?56CDE2?5DRC6KK@E@4=2:>F:=5G:@=2E65 	* (  ( L  2
AC@9:3:E:@?282:?DE<:4<324<D2?5F?62C?65766D $@  2E M %?46>@C6
F:=52C8F6DE92ERC6KK@RD72:=FC6E@AC@G:562?J724ED@C6G:56?46E@DFAA@CE9:D
2==682E:@?DC6DF=ED:?RC6KK@RD'(&4=2:>72:=:?82D2>2EE6C@7=2H $@  2E
)96@FCE28C66D
'(&AC@G:D:@?L  AC@9:3:ED2A6CD@?7C@>8:G:?8@C2446AE:?82?JP766
<:4<324<@CE9:?8@7G2=F6Q:?A2CE@72C62=6DE2E6EC2?D24E:@?:?G@=G:?82>@CE8286=@2?

(  ( L  2 )@D9@H96:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2HF?56CE9:D
4=2:>RC6KK@>FDEAC@G:56D@>66G:56?46E92EE96C6H2D2<:4<324<7666:E96C8:G6?
@C2446AE653JF:=5 #30:/< 8.,4:58:. 5  65 AARI 	E9
:C  	277:C>:?8E968C2?E@7DF>>2CJ;F58>6?E7@CE965676?52?ED3642FD6E96
A=2:?E:7772:=65E@AC@G:562?J6G:56?46@72<:4<324<A2J>6?E @H6G6CRC6KK@5@6D
?@EDA64:7J724EF2=2==682E:@?DE@244@>A2?J9:D3C@254@?4=FD@CJDE2E6>6?ED
642FD6RC6KK@92D72:=65E@AC@G:562?JD@CE@76G:56?46@C724EF2=2==682E:@?D
C682C5:?8F:=5RD:?G@=G6>6?EH:E92<:4<324<7669:D'(&4=2:>72:=D2D2>2EE6C@7
=2H2?59:D>@E:@?7@CDF>>2CJ;F586>6?E:D56?:65 ":<6H:D6E96@FCE7:?5DE92E
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 21 of 23

 	
F:=592D6DE23=:D965:E:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E2D2>2EE6C@7=2H:?:ED72G@C@?E96
'(&4=2:>
(+#(' 	())%#&#'). '$,'+#(''&)!'. 	)#'!
RC6KK@92D7:=652#@E:@?7@C&C6=:>:?2CJ?;F?4E:@?$@ 2?52
#@E:@?7@C>6C86?4J62C:?8$@ @7E96D2>6 RC6KK@2DD6CEDE92EF:=5:D
2EE6>AE:?8E@@CAC@4665:?8H:E97@C64=@DFC6@?E96AC@A6CEJ )96@FCEH:==56?J
RC6KK@RDC6BF6DE
?@C56CE@366?E:E=65E@2AC6=:>:?2CJ:?;F?4E:@?RC6KK@92DE963FC56?E@
D9@HP 2DF3DE2?E:2==:<6=:9@@5@7AC6G2:=:?8@?E96>6C:ED :CC6A2C23=692C>F?=6DD
E96:?;F?4E:@?:D:DDF65E92EE96E9C62E6?65:?;FCJ@FEH6:89DE9692C>E92E
E96AC6=:>:?2CJ:?;F?4E:@?>2J42FD6E96@AA@D:?8A2CEJ2?5E92EE96:?;F?4E:@?:7
:DDF65H:==?@E25G6CD6=J27764EE96AF3=:4:?E6C6DE Q04,0:0@,49.(049:";0404. 	;8
4<:< ,=,22 5 	 	  	E9:C  	 DD6E7@CE923@G6RC6KK@92D
72:=65E@D9@H2DF3DE2?E:2==:<6=:9@@5@7AC6G2:=:?8@?E96>6C:ED )@E964@?EC2CJF:=5
92D56>@?DEC2E65:E:D6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E:?:ED72G@C2?5282:?DERC6KK@@?2==
4=2:>D )96C67@C6&=2:?E:77RD#@E:@?7@C&C6=:>:?2CJ?;F?4E:@?H:==3656?:65
@CE9@D6C62D@?D2DD6E7@CE923@G6E96F?5:DAFE65724ED6DE23=:D9E92EF:=5:D

6?E:E=65E@;F58>6?E:?:ED72G@C@?RC6KK@RD4=2:>D ?255:E:@?RC6KK@RD92D72:=65
E@6DE23=:D99:D6?E:E=6>6?EE@2AC6=:>:?2CJ:?;F?4E:@?2?59:D>@E:@?H:==3656?:65
!'0635(+/&45#5#/'7+&'/5+#3:'#3+/)0/?3';;0?405+0/806-&/05.#5'3+#--:#44+455'%0635+/
3'40-7+/)5*'.05+0/)+7'/5*'(+/&+/)4#44'5(035*#$07'
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 22 of 23

   
 	 	   EE92E&=2:?E:77 RC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ
F58>6?E$@  	:D 96C63J$
  	 	E E92E676?52?EF:=5RDC@DD#@E:@?7@C(F>>2CJ
F58>6?E $@ 	8 :D96C63J'$)
  	 	E E92E&=2:?E:77RC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C&C6=:>:?2CJ
?;F?4E:@?$@ :D 96C63J$
  	 	E E92E&=2:?E:77RC6KK@RD#@E:@?7@C2?>6C86?4J
62C:?8 @? &C6=:>:?2CJ ?;F?4E:@?  $@  :D 96C63J$2?5
  E92EE96=6C<:D5:C64E65E@6?E6C2;F58>6?E:?676?52?E F:=5RD
72G@C 2?5282:?DE&=2:?E:77RC6KK@ @?2== 4=2:>DE6C>:?2E:?8E9:D42D6:?72G@C@7
676?52?E F:=5
2E65E9:D E9 52J@7(6AE6>36C 	
(4@EE, (<2G529=
*?:E65(E2E6D:DEC:4E F586
(4@EE , (<2G529=
Case 1:23-cv-00242-SWS Document 45 Filed 09/24/24 Page 23 of 23