Gray et al v. Ericsson Inc.

4:26-cv-00266Txed28 de abr. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
CHRISTOPHER GRAY, ET AL.
v.
ERICSSON INC.
§
§
§
§
§
§
CIVIL NO. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ
LEAD CASE
SISY OROBITG
v.
ERICSSON INC.
§
§
§
§
§
§
CIVIL NO. 4:26-CV-340-SDJ
MEMORANDUM ORDER GRANTING IN PART PLAINTIFFS’ JOINT
MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE RELATED ACTIONS AND APPOINT
INTERIM CO-LEAD CLASS COUNSEL
Plaintiffs in the two above-captioned cases seek consolidation under Federal
Rule of Civil Procedure 42. They have done so through an identical motion filed in
each case. See Gray v. Ericsson Inc., No. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ, (Dkt. #10); Orobitg v.
Ericsson 	Inc., 	No. 	4:26-CV-340-SDJ, 	(Dkt. 	#4) 	(the 	“Consolidation 	Motion”).1
Specifically, Plaintiffs request that the Court: (1) consolidate the Related Actions
pursuant to Rule 42(a) under the title “In re Ericsson Inc. Data Breach Litigation,”
(2) appoint William B. Federman of Federman & Sherwood and Raina C. Borrelli of
Strauss Borrelli PLLC as Interim Co-Lead Class Counsel pursuant to Rule 23(g)(3),
(3) allow Plaintiffs to file a consolidated complaint within thirty (30) days of this
Order, and (4) terminate all actions other than the first-filed Gray case. Plaintiffs
affirm that they have conferred with Defendant Ericsson Inc. (“Ericsson”) and that
1 The Court references both actions collectively herein as the “Related Actions.”
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 1 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
2
Defendant “does not oppose consolidation” and “takes no position on the appointment
of Interim Class Counsel.” Gray, No. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ, (Dkt. #10 at 2).
Having reviewed the Consolidation Motion and the record in each case, the
Court concludes that the motion will be granted in part.
I.
Plaintiffs 	Christopher 	Gray 	and 	Anthony 	Ross 	filed 	their 	class 	action
complaint on March 16, 2026, seeking to hold Ericsson liable for the alleged disclosure
of personally identifiable information (“PII”) belonging to them and approximately
15,661 other individuals affected by a data breach incident in April 2025 (the “Data
Breach”). See Gray, No. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ, (Dkt. #1). Thereafter, the other Related
Action was filed by Plaintiff Sisy Orobitg arising from the same Data Breach and
operative 	facts, 	and 	asserting 	substantially 	identical 	claims 	on 	behalf 	of 	an
overlapping putative class. See Orobitg, No. 4:26-CV-340-SDJ, (Dkt. #1). The case
brought by Orobitg has been transferred to this Court. See id., (Dkt. #5).
In the Related Actions, Plaintiffs allege that Ericsson failed to implement
reasonable data security practices to protect Plaintiffs’ and the putative class
members’ PII, including their names and Social Security numbers, resulting in
unauthorized access to this 	information. 	The Related Actions 	seek to remedy
Ericsson’s alleged failures and the consequences arising therefrom. Following their
receipt of letters informing them of the Data Breach, Plaintiffs each filed their
complaints as putative class actions on behalf of themselves and all others affected
by the Data Breach.
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 2 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
3
II.
Rule 42(a) permits a district court to consolidate “actions before the court
involv[ing] a common question of law or fact.” FED . R. CIV. P. 42(a). “A trial court has
broad discretion in determining whether to consolidate a case pending before it.”
Alley v. Chrysler Credit Corp., 767 F.2d 138, 140 (5th Cir. 1985) (quotation marks and
citation omitted). “Consolidating actions in a district court is proper when the cases
involve 	common 	questions 	of 	law 	and 	fact, 	and 	the 	district 	judge 	finds 	that
[consolidation] would avoid unnecessary costs or delay.” St. Bernard Gen. Hosp.,
Inc. v. Hosp. Serv. Ass’n of New Orleans, Inc., 712 F.2d 978, 989 (5th Cir. 1983). The
purpose of consolidation is to allow district courts “to manage their dockets efficiently
while 	providing 	justice 	to the 	parties.” Wilson v. 	Johns-Manville 	Sales Corp.,
107 F.R.D. 250, 252 (S.D. Tex. 1985). “Consolidation is improper if it would prejudice
the rights of the parties.” St. Bernard Gen. Hosp., 712 F.2d at 989.
In their Consolidation Motion, Plaintiffs contend, and the Court agrees, that
the Related Actions are substantially the same and consolidation is appropriate. Each
lawsuit arises from the same common set of alleged operative facts, namely the same
data breach event. And all Plaintiffs assert overlapping claims, on behalf of similarly
defined putative classes, seeking similar relief. Under such circumstances, and in the
specific context of multiple data breach actions, courts have found consolidation
appropriate. See, e.g., Lockhart v. El Centro Del Barrio, No. SA-23-CV-01156-JKP,
2024 WL 303253, at *2 (W.D. Tex. Jan. 25, 2024) (finding consolidation appropriate
where plaintiffs were “asserting causes of action based on the same data breach
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 3 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
4
resulting from the same cyberattack”); Kaplan v. 21st Century Oncology Holdings,
No. 2:16-CV-210, 2016 WL 9383330, at *2 (M.D. Fla. July 21, 2016) (holding that
common questions of law and fact permeated consolidated cases “aris[ing] from the
same alleged data breach”); Ruiz v. Prestige Maint. USA, Ltd., No. 4:25-CV-805-SDJ,
2025 WL 2917097, at *2 (E.D. Tex. Oct. 14, 2025) (similar).
Consolidation here will also avoid the risk of inconsistent judgments in the
Related Actions. See Lockhart, 2024 WL 303253, at *2 (holding that “[c]onsolidation
[would] ensure consistent rulings and promote judicial economy” where three cases
asserted “causes of action based on the same data breach resulting from the same
cyberattack.”); JFP Servs., L.L.C. v. Torans, No. SA-17-CV-00210-FB, 2017 WL
9362704, at *2 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 21, 2017) (“In light of these common questions of law
and fact, the Court finds there is a risk of inconsistent adjudication if the Court were
to allow these cases to be tried separately before different judges[.]”). It will also
reduce the time and costs for all involved by eliminating the need for separate filings,
discovery, settlement negotiations, hearings, and trials for the cases arising from the
Data Breach. See Bayati v. GWG Holdings, Inc., No. 3:22-CV-0410-B, 2023 WL
5925880, at *2–3 (N.D. Tex. Sept. 12, 2023) (explaining that where two actions
“ma[de] nearly identical legal claims based on the same set of facts,” and were “filed
on 	behalf 	of 	the 	same 	proposed 	class,” 	consolidation 	would 	“promote 	judicial
efficiency”); Gate Guard Servs. L.P. v. Solis, No. V-10-91, 2011 WL 2784447, at *15
(S.D. Tex. July 12, 2011) (ordering consolidation where “the same factual and legal
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 4 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
5
issues exist in both cases and consolidating the actions would be more efficient than
litigating the two cases separately”).
Further, the Court finds that any prejudice to the parties resulting from
consolidation will be minimal in comparison to these considerations. See Stoneeagle
Servs., Inc. v. Gillman, No. 3:11-CV-02408-P, 2014 WL 12577069, at *3 (N.D. Tex.
Jan. 28, 2014) (“Given the substantial similarities among the facts and causes of
action, the prospect of confusion incumbent on the fact finder will be nominal at best
because these cases tell the same story[.]”); Zolezzi v. Celadon Trucking Servs., Inc.,
No. H-08-3508, 2009 WL 736057, at *2 (S.D. Tex. Mar. 16, 2009) (approving
consolidation of cases arising from a multi-vehicle collision where the cases shared
common questions of law and fact, the risk of prejudice or confusion was “minimal,”
and such risk was “outweighed by the risk of inconsistent judgments should the cases
be tried separately”).
Finally, the Related Actions are procedurally positioned for consolidated
treatment, as they are all pending before this Court and at the same early stage of
proceedings, with each complaint filed within a three-week period, no discovery under
way, and no dispositive motions pending. See Doe (S.M.A.) v. Salesforce, Inc.,
No. 3:23-CV-915-B, 2023 WL 4108845, at *2 (N.D. Tex. June 20, 2023) (granting
consolidation where “the cases are at the same stage of preparation for trial”); Arnold
& Co., LLC v. David K. Young Consulting, LLC, No. SA-13-CV-00146-DAE, 2013 WL
1411773, at *2 (W.D. Tex. Apr. 8, 2013) (ordering consolidation where “the cases were
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 5 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
6
filed less than one month apart, no dispositive motions have been filed in either case,
and very little discovery has occurred”).
For these reasons, the Related Actions, the parties thereto, and the Court will
be best served in a consolidated proceeding, which will preserve party and judicial
resources.
III.
It is therefore ORDERED that the Consolidated Motion is GRANTED in
part. The Related Actions shall be consolidated for all purposes, including pretrial
proceedings and trial, pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42(a), before this
Court (the “Consolidated Action”). Gray v. Ericsson Inc., No. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ, is
designated the Lead Case.
All parties are instructed to file any future filings in the Lead Case. The Court
will enter one docket control order, one protective order, and one discovery order that
will govern the entire Consolidated Action. The local rules’ page limitations for
motions will apply to the Consolidated Action. To further promote judicial economy
and to conserve the parties’ resources, the Court encourages the parties to file a notice
with the Court in the event that other related cases are filed on the Court’s docket
that may also be appropriate for consolidation with this case.
All papers filed in the Consolidated Action shall be filed under the Lead Case
and shall bear the following caption:
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 6 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
7
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
IN RE ERICSSON INC. DATA
BREACH LITIGATION
This Document Relates To:
Master File No. 4:26-CV-266-SDJ
The case file for the Consolidated Action will be maintained under Master File
No. 4:25-CV-266-SDJ. When a pleading is intended to apply to all actions to which
this Order applies, the words “ALL ACTIONS” shall appear immediately after the
words “This Document Relates To:” in the caption. When a pleading is not intended
to apply to all actions, the docket number for each individual action to which the filing
is intended to apply and the last name of the first-named plaintiff in said action shall
appear immediately after the words “This Document Relates To:” in the caption (e.g.,
“No. 4:25-CV-266-SDJ, Gray”).
All papers previously filed and served to date in the Related Actions are
deemed part of the record in the Consolidated Action.
Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(g), and pending further order
of the Court on this issue, the Court hereby appoints William B. Federman of
Federman & Sherwood and Raina C. Borrelli of Strauss Borrelli PLLC as Interim Co-
Lead Class Counsel to act on behalf of the Plaintiffs and the putative class members
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 7 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
8
in the Consolidated Action.2 Interim Co-Lead Class Counsel shall have the sole
authority to handle the responsibilities set forth below:
• 	Determine and present (in briefs, oral argument, or such other fashion as
may be appropriate, personally or by a designee) to the Court and opposing
parties the position of the Plaintiffs on all matters arising during pretrial
proceedings;
• 	Coordinate the initiation and conduct of discovery on behalf of Plaintiffs
and the putative class consistent with the requirements of the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure;
• 	Convene meetings amongst counsel;
• 	Conduct settlement negotiations on behalf of Plaintiffs and the putative
class;
• 	Delegate specific tasks to plaintiffs’ counsel in a manner to ensure that
pretrial preparation for Plaintiffs and the putative class is conducted
efficiently and effectively;
• 	Negotiate and enter into stipulations with opposing counsel as necessary
for the conduct and efficient advancement of the litigation;
• 	Monitor the activities of all counsel to ensure that schedules are being met
and unnecessary expenditures of time and funds are avoided;
• 	Perform such other duties as may be incidental to the proper coordination
of Plaintiffs’ pretrial activities or authorized by further order of this Court;
• 	Serve as the primary contact for communications between the Court and
other plaintiffs’ counsel;
• 	Ensure that all notices, orders, and material communications are properly
distributed (to the extent that they are not otherwise served on plaintiffs’
counsel via the Court’s electronic filing system);
2 The Court notes that the reference to “putative” class members in this Order is
significant. There are no actual “class members” unless and until a class has been certified.
See Cruson v. Jackson Nat’l Life Ins. Co., 954 F.3d 240, 250 (5th Cir. 2020) (citing Police &
Fire Ret. Sys. of Detroit v. IndyMac MBS, Inc., 721 F.3d 95, 112 n.22 (2d Cir. 2013) for the
proposition that “until certification there is no class action but merely the prospect of one”).
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 8 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
9
• 	Communicate with defense counsel as necessary to promote the efficient
advancement of this litigation;
• 	Make available to other plaintiffs’ counsel documents produced by the
Defendant; and
• 	Allocate attorneys’ fees.
Any other plaintiffs’ counsel will perform work in this litigation only at the
direction of Interim Co-Lead Class Counsel. No motion, request for discovery, or other
pretrial proceedings shall be initiated or filed by any Plaintiff except through Interim
Co-Lead Class Counsel and no other plaintiffs’ counsel or firm shall be authorized to
perform any work in the case without the express authorization of Interim Co-Lead
Class Counsel.
Interim Co-Lead Class Counsel shall have sole authority to communicate with
Defendant’s 	counsel—including 	with 	respect 	to 	settlement 	and 	settlement
negotiations—and the Court on behalf of any Plaintiff unless that authority is
expressly delegated to other counsel. Defendant’s counsel may rely on all agreements
made with Interim Co-Lead Class Counsel, and such agreements shall be binding on
all other plaintiffs’ counsel.
Plaintiffs in the Consolidated Action shall file an operative consolidated class-
action complaint within thirty (30) days of the date of this Order. Defendant shall
answer or otherwise respond to the consolidated pleading within twenty-one (21) days
from the date on which Plaintiffs file the consolidated class-action complaint.
This Order shall apply to the above-captioned matters, any subsequently
consolidated action, any actions consolidated with the above-captioned matters, and
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 9 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>
10
any actions filed in, transferred to, removed to, or otherwise sent to this Court
relating to the alleged facts and the data breach underlying this litigation.
Case 4:26-cv-00266-SDJ Document 13 Filed 04/28/26 Page 10 of 10 PageID #:
<pageID>

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.