STEWMAN et al v. BAUHOF et al

4:22-cv-00080Txed9 de abr. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
RYAN STEWMAN, et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
W. BRADLEY BAUHOF, et al.,
Defendants.
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
CIVIL ACTION NO. 4:22-CV-00080-
SDJ-AGD
MEMORANDUM ADOPTING REPORT AND
RECOMMENDATION OF UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
Before the Court is the Report and Recommendation of the United States
Magistrate Judge (“Report”), this matter having been referred to the Magistrate
Judge pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636. The Report provides proposed findings of fact and
a recommendation that Defendants W. Bradley Bauhof, W. Bradley Bauhof, LLC, and
Bauhof & Buchholz, LLC’s Rule 12(b)(2) Motion to Dismiss (Dkt. #43) be granted as
to the grounds asserted under Rule 12(b)(2); that Plaintiffs Ryan Stewman, Amy
Stewman, and Closer Marketing, LLC’s Amended Complaint (Dkt. #38) be dismissed
without prejudice; and that Plaintiffs’ Request for Jurisdictional Discovery (Dkt. #46)
be denied. See (Dkt. #47).
Plaintiffs timely filed objections to the Report, (Dkt. #48), and Defendants filed
a response, (Dkt. #49). The Court has conducted a de novo review of the objections
and the portions of the Report to which Plaintiffs specifically object. Having done so,
the Court concludes that the findings and conclusions of the Magistrate Judge are
Case 4:22-cv-00080-SDJ-AGD Document 52 Filed 04/09/26 Page 1 of 4 PageID #:
<pageID>
2
correct, and the objections are without merit as to the ultimate recommendation of
the Magistrate Judge.
Plaintiffs’ objections rely on Wien Air Alaska, Inc. v. Brandt, 195 F.3d 208 (5th
Cir. 1999) and Trois v. Apple Tree Auction Center, Inc., 882 F.3d 485 (5th Cir. 2018).
The Court finds that Plaintiffs’ reliance on these cases is misplaced.
In Wien Air, the defendant took an active role in negotiating business deals
and scheduling closing dates for the plaintiffs to purchase a foreign airline; the
defendant admittedly served in an attorney–client relationship with the plaintiffs;
the defendant met with the plaintiffs in Texas; and the defendant made numerous
misrepresentations through “letters, faxes, and phone calls” with the plaintiffs, who
were in Texas, that “contained fraudulent misrepresentations and promises and
whose contents failed to disclose material information. Wien Air, 195 F.3d at 209–14.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit found that this was sufficient
to establish minimum contacts. Id. at 215.
In Trois, the defendant made misrepresentations to the plaintiff over the phone
about the likely outcome of the defendant’s sale of the plaintiff’s goods at auction. 882
F.3d at 490–91. The Fifth Circuit found that “communications relating to the
performance of a contract themselves are insufficient to establish minimum contacts.”
Id. at 489. Citing to Wilson v. Belin, 20 F.3d 644, 649 (5th Cir. 1994), the Fifth Circuit
stated that “personal jurisdiction in a [tort] case could not rest on a nonresident
defendant’s tortious response to one uninitiated, unsolicited phone call.” Trois, 882
F.3d at 491. However, the Fifth Circuit found that the defendant had minimum
Case 4:22-cv-00080-SDJ-AGD Document 52 Filed 04/09/26 Page 2 of 4 PageID #:
<pageID>
3
contacts with the forum state because he “was not a passive participant on the call,”
but “was the key negotiating party who made representations regarding his business
in a call to Texas.” Id.
Both Wien Air and Trois are distinguishable from the instant lawsuit. By
Plaintiffs’ own well-pleaded allegations,1 Defendant W. Bradley Bauhof was more
aligned with the passive participant than the active negotiator (Dkt. #38).2 As noted
in the Report, the limited communication from Defendants included: (1) Defendant
W. Bradley Bauhof introducing himself and his role as an escrow agent on a
conference call initiated by dismissed defendant, Kashif Sarwar; (2) Defendant W.
Bradley Bauhof defending his character; and (3) Defendant W. Bradley Bauhof
relaying information he had been given by Sarwar (Dkt. #47 at p. 12). These
communications are not what make up the tortious conduct alleged by Plaintiffs.
Indeed, as the Report finds, Plaintiffs’ allegations of tortious misrepresentations
came from dismissed defendants Sarwar, Todd Goetz, and Keith Matthews.
In reviewing the Report (Dkt. #47), Plaintiffs’ objections (Dkt. #48), and
Defendants’ response to Plaintiffs’ objections (Dkt. #49), and all other relevant
pleadings, the Court finds that the cases relied upon by Plaintiffs in their objections
1 The Court takes all Plaintiffs’ well-pleaded allegations in the Amended Complaint (Dkt. #38) as true,
disregarding Plaintiffs’ allegations that are refuted by Defendants’ affidavit (Dkt. #43, Exhibit 1).
“When considering a motion to dismiss, allegations in a plaintiff’s complaint are taken as true except
to the extent that they are contradicted by defendant’s affidavits.” United My Funds, LLC v. Perera,
4:19-CV-373, 2020 WL 674364, at *2 (E.D. Tex. 2020) (citing Int’l Truck & Engine Corp. v. Quintana,
259 F. Supp. 2d 553, 557 (N.D. Tex. 2003) (internal quotation marks and alterations omitted).
2 Plaintiff has no direct allegations against Defendants W. Bradley Bauhof, LLC or Bauhof &
Buchholz, LLC.
Case 4:22-cv-00080-SDJ-AGD Document 52 Filed 04/09/26 Page 3 of 4 PageID #:
<pageID>
4
to the Report are inapplicable in the instant lawsuit. Accordingly, the Court adopts
the Magistrate Judge’s Report as the findings and conclusions of the Court.
It is therefore ORDERED that Defendants W. Bradley Bauhof, W. Bradley
Bauhof, LLC, and Bauhof & Buchholz, LLC’s Rule 12(b)(2) Motion to Dismiss (Dkt.
#43) is GRANTED as to the grounds asserted under Rule 12(b)(2); that Plaintiffs
Ryan Stewman, Amy Stewman, and Closer Marketing, LLC’s Amended Complaint
(Dkt. #38) is DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE; and that Plaintiffs’ Request
for Jurisdictional Discovery (Dkt. #46) is DENIED.
Case 4:22-cv-00080-SDJ-AGD Document 52 Filed 04/09/26 Page 4 of 4 PageID #:
<pageID>

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.