Estrella v. Warden, FCI Lewisburg

1:26-cv-00061Pamd23 de mar. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
RONALDO E. ESTRELLA, 	: 	CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:26-CV-61
:
Petitioner 	: 	(Judge Neary)
:
v. 	:
:
WARDEN OF FCI-LEWISBURG, 	:
:
Respondent 	:
MEMORANDUM
This is a habeas corpus case filed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2241. Petitioner,
Ronald E. Estrella, a prisoner confined by the United States Bureau of Prisons
(“BOP”), challenges a disciplinary sanction that purportedly resulted in the loss of
good conduct time and First Step Act (“FSA”) time credits as well as his removal
from the Residential Drug Abuse Program (“RDAP”). The petition will be dismissed
for Estrella’s failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
I. 	Factual Background & Procedural History
Estrella is serving a federal criminal sentence imposed by the United States
District Court for the District of Rhode Island. (Doc. 8-3 at 3). He is housed in
Lewisburg Federal Correctional Institution (“FCI-Lewisburg”). Estrella filed the
instant petition on January 13, 2026. (Doc. 1). He challenges a disciplinary sanction
that resulted in the loss of good conduct time and FSA credits and purportedly led
to his removal from the RDAP. (Id.) Respondent responded to the petition on
February 6, 2026, arguing that it should be dismissed for failure to exhaust
administrative remedies, or, alternatively, denied on its merits. (Doc. 6). Estrella
Case 1:26-cv-00061-KMN-LT Document 8 Filed 03/23/26 Page 1 of 4
2
filed a reply brief in support of the petition on March 3, 2026, making the petition
ripe for review. (Doc. 7).
II. 	Discussion
Although there is no explicit statutory exhaustion requirement for Section
2241 habeas petitions, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has
consistently held that exhaustion applies to such claims. See Callwood v. Enos, 230
F.3d 627, 634 (3d Cir. 2000) (citing Schandelmeier v. Cunningham, 819 F.2d 52, 53
(3d Cir. 1986)); Moscato v. Fed. Bureau of Prisons, 98 F.3d 757, 760 (3d Cir. 1996).
Exhaustion allows the agency to develop a factual record and apply its expertise,
conserves judicial resources, and provides agencies the opportunity to “correct their
own errors” thereby fostering “administrative autonomy.” Id. at 761-62. The BOP
has a specific internal system through which federal prisoners can request review of
nearly any aspect of their imprisonment. See 28 C.F.R. §§ 542.10-.19. That process
begins with an informal request to staff and progresses to formal review by the
warden, appeal with the regional director, and—ultimately—final appeal to the
general counsel. Id. §§ 542.13-.15. No administrative remedy is considered fully
exhausted until reviewed by the general counsel. Id. § 542.15(a). When an inmate
wishes to appeal a disciplinary hearing officer’s appeal, his initial appeal goes
directly to the regional director. Id. § 542.14(d)(2).
Exhaustion is the rule in most cases, and failure to exhaust will generally
preclude habeas review. Moscato, 98 F.3d at 761. Only in rare circumstances is
exhaustion of administrative remedies not required. For example, exhaustion is
Case 1:26-cv-00061-KMN-LT Document 8 Filed 03/23/26 Page 2 of 4
3
unnecessary if the issue presented is one that consists purely of statutory
construction. Vasquez v. Strada, 684 F.3d 431, 433-34 (3d Cir. 2012) (citing
Bradshaw v. Carlson, 682 F.2d 1050, 1052 (3d Cir. 1981)). Exhaustion is likewise
not required when it would be futile. Rose v. Lundy, 455 U.S. 509, 516 n.7 (1982).
Respondent argues that Estrella’s petition should be dismissed for failure to
exhaust administrative remedies because he did not file any administrative remedy
requests regarding his claim prior to filing this case. (Doc. 6 at 14). Respondent has
produced evidence to support this assertion. (Doc. 6-12).
Estrella has not produced any contrary evidence to show that he filed an
administrative remedy request related to this case, but he advances the following
argument in response to respondent’s exhaustion argument:
If the DHO report was delivered on October 10, 2025, but Petitioner did
not receive it timely or was unable to access necessary paperwork, that
delay tolls the appeal period. The government bears the burden of
proving failure to exhaust, and conclusory reliance on a “Generalized
Retrieval 	Document” 	does 	not 	establish 	that 	remedies 	were
meaningfully available.
(Doc. 7 at 2). The court construes this as an argument that his failure to exhaust
should be excused because the respondent has not shown that the administrative
remedy process was available.
Estrella’s argument misunderstands the burden of proof with respect to
exhaustion of administrative remedies. Although the respondent has the initial
burden to establish failure to exhaust administrative remedies, once the respondent
has done so the petitioner generally must demonstrate an exception or excuse that
would allow him to proceed without exhausting administrative remedies. See, e.g.,
Case 1:26-cv-00061-KMN-LT Document 8 Filed 03/23/26 Page 3 of 4
4
Moscato¸98 F.3d at 762 (affirming dismissal of petition because petitioner failed to
present any evidence to excuse his failure to exhaust administrative remedies); cf.,
e.g., Rinaldi v. United States, 904 F.3d at 268 (concluding in context of exhaustion
of administrative remedies for civil rights claim that plaintiff has the burden to
show that exhaustion was unavailable once defendant has met the initial burden of
showing that plaintiff failed to exhaust).
Here, Estrella has not presented any evidence—or even clearly asserted—
that the administrative remedy process was unavailable to him. He simply notes
that unavailability could be an excuse for his failure to exhaust and states that
respondents have not shown that the process was available to him. This vague and
unsupported assertion is not sufficient to excuse his failure to exhaust
administrative remedies.1
III. 	Conclusion
The petition for writ of habeas corpus is dismissed without prejudice for
failure to exhaust administrative remedies. An appropriate order shall issue.
/S/ K ELI M. N EARY
Keli M. Neary
United States District Judge
Middle District of Pennsylvania
Dated: 	March 23, 2026
1 Estrella also asserts that exhaustion is judicially created and not statutorily
mandated and that a failure to exhaust may be excused by the court. (Doc. 7 at 1-2).
These are accurate statements of the law but are ultimately immaterial. The court
does not see any reason to excuse a failure to exhaust administrative remedies in
the instant case.
Case 1:26-cv-00061-KMN-LT Document 8 Filed 03/23/26 Page 4 of 4

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.