SANDOZ INC. vs SAM'S WEST, INC.

3:25-cv-02001Njd26 de jan. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
SANDOZ INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
SAM’S WEST, INC.,
Defendant.
Civil Action No. 25-02001 (GC) (RLS)
MEMORANDUM OPINION
CASTNER, District Judge
THIS MATTER comes before the Court upon Defendant Sam’s West, Inc.’s Motion to
Dismiss Plaintiff Sandoz Inc.’s Complaint pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure (Rule)
12(b)(6). (ECF No. 17.) Sandoz opposed, (ECF No. 22), and Sam’s West, Inc. (Sam’s Club)
replied, (ECF No. 23). The Court has carefully reviewed the parties’ submissions and decides the
matter without oral argument pursuant to Rule 78(b) and Local Civil Rule 78.1(b). For the reasons
set forth below, and other good cause shown, the Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED in part and
DENIED in part.
I. BACKGROUND
A. Factual Background
Sandoz is a pharmaceutical company that “develops, manufactures, and distributes
medicines to wholesalers, pharmacies, hospitals, and other healthcare outlets.”1 (ECF No. 1 ¶ 17.)
1 On a motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), the Court must accept all facts as true, but
courts “are not bound to accept as true a legal conclusion couched as a factual allegation.” Bell
Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555 (2007) (internal citation and quotations omitted).
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 1 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
2
Sam’s Club, which is the name by which Sam’s West, Inc. does business, operates pharmacies that
sell generic medicines produced by Sandoz. (Id. ¶¶ 19, 20.)
In April 2013, Sandoz and Sam’s Club entered into a Purchase Contract allowing Sam’s
Club to purchase pharmaceutical products from Sandoz at discounted prices. (Id. ¶¶ 2, 20 (citing
ECF No. 1-2).) The Purchase Contract includes terms and conditions for the discounted pricing,
as well as a list of agreed-upon products and pricing. (Id. ¶ 21; see also ECF No. 1-2 at 2-29.)2 It
also includes a dispute resolution procedure. (ECF No. 1 ¶ 28; see also ECF No. 1-2 at 7.) The
parties signed a series of amendments to extend the Purchase Contract through April 2023. (ECF
No. 1 ¶¶ 2, 22.)
From 2013 through most of 2018, Sandoz provided Sam’s Club with pharmaceutical
products pursuant to the Purchase Contract, and Sam’s Club paid for those products without
controversy. (Id. ¶ 30.) But from December 2018 to 2021, Sam’s Club allegedly deducted
$1,972,871.24 from payments it allegedly owed to Sandoz. (Id. ¶¶ 5, 31.) Sam’s Club took the
deductions for two reasons: first, because Sandoz “experienced supply issues,” causing Sam’s Club
to purchase the products from another seller at a higher price (referred to as “Failure to Supply” or
FTS), and second, because Sandoz lowered the price of the products included in the Purchase
Contract after Sam’s Club purchased those products from Sandoz (referred to as “Shelf-Stock
Adjustments” or SSA). (Id. ¶ 6 (citing ECF No. 1-4 at 2).) During the period in which Sam’s Club
made these deductions, Sam’s Club sent Sandoz spreadsheets listing how much it was withholding
from Sandoz because of these issues. (Id. ¶ 32.)
2 Page numbers for record cites (i.e., “ECF Nos.”) refer to the page numbers stamped by the
Court’s e-filing system and not the internal pagination of the parties.
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 2 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
3
Sandoz alleges it “repeatedly denied Sam’s Club’s claims,” informed Sam’s Club that the
deductions were improper, and asserted that the Purchase Contract did not contain price
adjustments for FTS or SSA. (Id. ¶ 7, 33-36, 44 (citing ECF No. 1-4 at 2, 5; ECF No. 1-5 at 2-3;
ECF No. 1-7 at 2; ECF No. 1-8 at 2).) As an example, Sandoz alleges that on December 14, 2020,
it “rejected” Sam’s Club’s FTS deductions, stating through email that credit amounts Sam’s Club
sought to deduct from its payments would be “denied” because Sam’s Club was not “eligible” for
FTS under their contract. (Id. ¶ 34 (citing ECF No. 1-5 at 3).) Sam’s Club replied that “[t]he
precedent is set” for it to receive credit for FTS claims because Sandoz has “historically . . .
accepted and paid” those claims. (Id. ¶ 35 (citing ECF No. 1-5 at 3).) In response, Sandoz’s
representative wrote that they have “not issued any credit for Sam’s FTS claims” since starting to
work on the Sam’s Club account in 2017 and reiterated that “Sam’s is not eligible for FTS.” (Id.
¶ 36 (citing ECF No. 1-5 at 2).) Sandoz alleges that Sam’s Club then “conceded” that the
deductions it sought were improper when it said the claims at issue would be “cancelled in full.”
(Id. ¶ 37 (citing ECF No. 1-5 at 2).)
Later, on April 21, 2021, Sandoz emailed Sam’s Club “requesting payback” for deductions
Sam’s Club had claimed, stating that the claims were “denied in the past due to the lack of FTS
language in the Sam’s Club contract” and noting that “[t]hese and any future Sam’s Club FTS
claims will continue to be denied for the same reason.” (Id. ¶ 38 (citing ECF No. 1-6 at 2).) That
day, “Sandoz denied additional FTS and SSA [d]eductions” because the Purchase Contract “does
not have any SSA and FTS language.” (Id. ¶ 39 (citing ECF No. 1-4 at 5).) Sandoz alleges that
Sam’s Club claimed approximately 40 FTS and SSA deductions that the Purchase Contract does
not permit and continues to knowingly, intentionally, and wrongfully withhold such payments now
in a “continuing scheme to take improper deductions.” (Id. ¶¶ 8-9, 42-43, 45, 56, 60.)
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 3 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
4
In 2023, the parties entered into a new contract. (Id. ¶ 46.) Unlike the original Purchase
Contract, the 2023 contract contains provisions explicitly permitting deductions for FTS and SSA.
(Id. ¶ 47.) Sandoz alleges Sam’s Club “insisted” that the new agreement include these provisions.
(Id.)
B. Procedural Background
Sandoz filed a Complaint against Sam’s Club on March 20, 2025.3 (ECF No. 1.) The
Complaint asserts one cause of action for breach of contract. (ECF No. 1 at 9-11.) On June 17,
2025, Sam’s Club filed the instant Motion to Dismiss the Complaint. (ECF No. 17.) Sam’s Club
filed an opposition on July 11, 2025, and Sandoz filed its reply on July 18, 2025. (ECF Nos. 22,
23.)
II. LEGAL STANDARD
On a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, courts “accept the factual allegations in
the complaint as true, draw all reasonable inferences in favor of the plaintiff, and assess whether
the complaint and the exhibits attached to it ‘contain enough facts to state a claim to relief that is
plausible on its face.’” Wilson v. USI Ins. Serv. LLC, 57 F.4th 131, 140 (3d Cir. 2023) (quoting
Watters v. Bd. of Sch. Dirs. of City of Scranton, 975 F.3d 406, 412 (3d Cir. 2020)). “A claim is
facially plausible ‘when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw the
reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.’” Clark v. Coupe, 55
F.4th 167, 178 (3d Cir. 2022) (quoting Mammana v. Fed. Bureau of Prisons, 934 F.3d 368, 372 (3d
Cir. 2019)). When assessing the factual allegations in a complaint, courts “disregard legal
conclusions and recitals of the elements of a cause of action that are supported only by mere
3 This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332
because the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000 and the parties are citizens of different states.
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 4 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
5
conclusory statements.” Wilson, 57 F.4th at 140 (citing Oakwood Lab’ys LLC v. Thanoo, 999 F.3d
892, 904 (3d Cir. 2021)). The defendant bringing a Rule 12(b)(6) motion bears the burden of
“showing that a complaint fails to state a claim.” In re Plavix Mktg., Sales Pracs. & Prod. Liab.
Litig. (No. II), 974 F.3d 228, 231 (3d Cir. 2020) (citing Davis v. Wells Fargo, 824 F.3d 333, 349
(3d Cir. 2016)).
In deciding a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, the court can only consider “the complaint, exhibits
attached to the complaint, matters of the public record, as well as undisputedly authentic
documents if the complainant's claims are based upon these documents.” Mayer v. Belichick, 605
F.3d 223, 230 (3d Cir. 2010). A court may also consider any document “integral to or explicitly
relied upon in the complaint” when ruling on a motion to dismiss. In re Burlington Coat Factory
Sec. Litig., 114 F.3d 1410, 1426 (3d Cir. 1997).
III. DISCUSSION
Sandoz brings one cause of action for breach of contract. In its Motion to Dismiss, Sam’s
Club argues (1) that it is “clear from the face of the [C]omplaint” that Sandoz’s claims are time-
barred; and (2) that the Complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted as to the
alleged FTS deductions. (ECF No. 17-1 at 12, 14.) The Court considers each argument in turn.
A. Statute of Limitations
The parties agree that, under New Jersey law,4 a four-year statute of limitations applies to
Sandoz’s breach of contract claim. (See ECF No. 17-1 at 5 (“Sandoz’s Complaint should be
4 In diversity actions, “a federal court must apply the substantive laws of its forum state[.]”
Lafferty v. St. Riel, 495 F.3d 72, 76 (3d Cir. 2007) (citing Erie R.R. Co. v. Tompkins, 304 U.S. 64,
78 (1938)). Substantive laws “include state statutes of limitations.” Id. The parties do not dispute
the application of New Jersey substantive law; both exclusively discuss and apply New Jersey law
in their papers, and the Purchase Contract includes a choice-of-law provision stating that it “shall
be construed in accordance with New Jersey law.” (ECF No. 1-2 at 6.)
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 5 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
6
dismissed because it is barred by the four-year statute of limitations under New Jersey’s Uniform
Commercial Code[.]”); ECF No. 22 at 12 (“The statute of limitations applicable to Sandoz’s breach
of contract claim is four years.” (citing N.J. Rev. Stat. 12A:2-725(1)).) And the “cause of action
accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the
breach.”5 N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-725(2). However, the statute of limitations may be subject to
tolling. Id. § 12A:2-725(4).
Sam’s Club argues that “any alleged breach [of contract]” that occurred prior to March 20,
2021—four years prior to when Sandoz filed its Complaint—is time-barred. (ECF No. 17-1 at 12-
14.) It argues that the entire Complaint should be dismissed because exhibits attached to the
Complaint show that the claims at issue “relate to purchases made, and amounts that would have
become due, by no later than sometime in 2020.” (Id. at 12.) It also argues that the continuing
violation doctrine should not apply because the alleged breaches were “separate and independent”
and apparent at the time they occurred. (Id. at 13-14.)
In response, Sandoz argues that the statute of limitations should not bar its claims because
Sam’s Club engaged in a “years-long continuous scheme to improperly withhold payment owed
to Sandoz,” and where “‘any act integral to the scheme’ occurs within the limitations period, ‘it is
not time-barred.’” (ECF No. 22 at 13 (quoting United States v. Daugerdas, 2011 WL 666170, at
*2 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 7, 2011)).) Sandoz argues that all claims are part of the alleged continuous
scheme—including the ones that occurred outside of the limitations period—and should survive
the Motion to Dismiss. (Id. at 13-14.) It also argues that “at a minimum,” the Complaint should
5 Under New Jersey law, “‘[a]ccrual’ is a technical term found in statutes of limitation to
denote the date on which the statutory clock begins to run.” Ali v. Rutgers, 765 A.2d 714, 717
(N.J. 2000).
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 6 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
7
proceed on alleged breaches that occurred after March 20, 2021, noting that the Exhibits attached
to the Complaint are only “examples” of breaches and are not exhaustive. (Id. at 12-14.)
While a statute of limitations must technically be pled as an affirmative defense in the
answer, the Third Circuit, “permit[s] a limitations defense to be raised by a motion under Rule
12(b)(6),” but “only if the time alleged in the statement of a claim shows that the cause of action
has not been brought within the statute of limitations.” Schmidt v. Skolas, 770 F.3d 241, 249 (3d
Cir. 2014) (citation modified). Accordingly, “if the bar is not apparent on the face of the complaint,
then it may not afford the basis for a dismissal of the complaint under Rule 12(b)(6).” Schmidt,
770 F.3d at 249 (citation modified).
Looking to Sandoz’s Complaint, Sandoz alleges that “[b]etween 2018 and 2021, in breach
of the plain terms of the [Purchase Contract], Sam’s Club unilaterally and improperly deducted
$1,972,871.24 from payments owed to Sandoz.” (ECF No. 1 ¶ 5.) Further, it alleges that “[i]n
December 2018, Sam’s Club began unilaterally withholding money from Sandoz for [p]roducts
that it purchased, claiming it was entitled to deductions because of Sandoz’s ‘failure to supply’ or
‘shelf stock adjustments.’ Over the next three years, Sam’s Club sent Sandoz spreadsheets with
amounts that it was withholding from Sandoz, claiming these were ‘FTS’ and ‘SSA’ deductions.
Sandoz repeatedly disputed Sam’s Club’s [d]eductions, stating that such deductions were not
permitted under the [Purchase Contract].” (Id. ¶¶ 31-33.) As such, Sandoz’s own allegations state
that it was aware of Sam’s Club’s deductions, which it alleges “were not permitted.” Therefore,
“unless some basis for tolling applies,” Plaintiff’s action is untimely to the extent that it seeks relief
for the time period prior to March 20, 2021.6 Calabria Ristorante, Inc. v. Ruggiero Seafood, Inc.,
6 Sam’s Club argues that the Exhibits attached to the Complaint indicate that the entire
period for which Sandoz seeks relief is time-barred, as the deductions referenced in the Exhibits
occur prior to March 20, 2021. However, the Court agrees with Sandoz that the Exhibits are
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 7 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
8
706 F. Supp. 3d 489, 512 (D.N.J. 2023) (citation omitted); see Cambridge Mobile Telmatics, Inc.
v. Sfara, Inc., Civ. No. 23-1368, 2024 WL 3879087, at *4 n.2 (D.N.J. Aug. 20, 2024) (finding
breach of contract claim time-barred after “simply reviewing [the counterclaimant’s] own
allegations”); see also S. Cross Overseas Agencies, Inc. v. Wah Kwong Shipping Grp. Ltd., 181
F.3d 410, 425 (3d Cir. 1999) (“If the complaint’s allegations, taken as true, allege facts sufficient
to toll the statute of limitations, it must survive a motion to dismiss.”).
Plaintiff seeks to invoke the continuing violation doctrine to toll the statute of limitations.
The continuing violation doctrine “developed as an equitable exception to the statute of
limitations.” Roa v. Roa, 985 A.2d 1225, 1231 (N.J. 2010) (quoting Bolinger v. Bell Atl., 749 A.2d
857, 860 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 2000)). This doctrine has primarily been applied by federal
and state courts in the discrimination context. See Hall v. St. Joseph’s Hosp., 777 A.2d 1002, 1010
(N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 2001); see also Wilson v. Wal-Mart Stores, 729 A.2d 1006, 1010-11 (N.J.
1999) (applying continuing violation doctrine to alleged tortious conduct); Evans v. Gloucester
Twp., 124 F. Supp. 3d 340, 349 (D.N.J. 2015) (“[V]irtually all of the precedent discussing the
continuing violation doctrine involves workplace discrimination suits.”). In that context, the
doctrine “was developed to allow for the aggregation of acts, each of which, in itself, might not
have alerted the employee of the existence of a claim, but which together show a pattern of
discrimination.” Roa, 985 A.2d at 1233. Accordingly, “[t]he premise underlying the [continuing
violation] doctrine is that the conduct becomes actionable because of its ‘continuous, cumulative,
synergistic nature.’” Id. at 1231 (quoting Wilson, 729 A.2d at 1011). Indeed, “individually
provided as examples and are not meant to represent the full scope of deductions at issue. Sandoz
uses the terms “[f]or example” and “e.g.” to set off its discussion of and citation to these emails,
communicating that they are intended only as examples. (See ECF No. 1 ¶¶ 6-7, 33-34.)
Moreover, the Complaint clearly states that the deductions at issue occurred as late as November
2021. (See id. ¶ 56.)
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 8 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
9
actionable allegations cannot be aggregated.” Id. at 1232 (quoting O’Connor v. City of Newark,
440 F.3d 125, 127 (3d Cir. 2006)); cf. Mattiaccio v. Scharfenberg, Civ. No. 23-23037, 2025 WL
1879226, at *2, *11 (D.N.J. July 8, 2025) (declining to apply continuing violation doctrine where
Plaintiffs “allege[d] a series of discrete acts which, by themselves, each constitute a separate
actionable claim” under 42 U.S.C. § 1983).
The Court finds that the continuing violation doctrine does not toll Sandoz’s breach of
contract claim for acts preceding March 20, 2021. Sandoz’s claim, as pled in its Complaint, is
based on “approximately 40 Deductions based on FTS and/or SSA price adjustments that were not
permitted under the [Purchase Contract].” (ECF No. 1 ¶ 43.) And in its briefing, Sandoz states
that it “alleges that Sam’s Club violated the [Purchase Contract] more than 40 times.” (ECF No.
22 at 13.) The Court construes Sandoz’s allegations and the deductions at issue as separate and
discrete violations of the Purchase Contract, rather than a continuing or “cumulative” violation as
argued by Sandoz. (ECF No. 22 at 13.) See also Wilson, 729 A.2d at 1011. And “individually
actionable allegations cannot be aggregated” under the continuing violation doctrine. Roa, 985
A.2d at 1232.
Indeed, in Stark v. Maraventano, the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division,
affirmed the trial court’s decision not to extend the continuing violation doctrine to contract-based
claims where an agreement was consistently breached for eight years. No. A-4801-18, 2021 WL
4898501, at *7 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Oct. 21, 2021). It concluded that even though the
defendant was “consistent” in violating its agreement with plaintiff, that “[did] not mean plaintiff’s
claim for breach of contract accrued each year.” Id. Similarly, here, Sandoz alleges that Sam’s
Club consistently violated the Purchase Contract from 2018 through 2021. As such, Stark instructs
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 9 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
10
that this Court should not extend the continuing violation doctrine to Sandoz’s breach of contract
claim.
Moreover, Sandoz does not point to any case that applies New Jersey law in a way
favorable to its position. Instead, Sandoz relies on United States v. Daugerdas, an out-of-circuit
criminal case interpreting a federal statute of limitations. Sandoz cites this case for the proposition
that allegations of a “single continuous scheme” are “not time-barred” as long as “any act integral
to the scheme” occurs within the limitations period. (ECF No. 22 at 13.) But the facts in
Daugerdas involve “a Corrupt Endeavor to Obstruct and Impede the Internal Revenue Laws,”
rather than a civil breach of contract claim. Daugerdas, 2011 WL 666170, at *1. The Court is not
persuaded by the Daugerdas case. Taken together, the Court declines to apply the continuing
violation doctrine to Sandoz’s breach of contract claim.7 See Deluxe Sales & Service, Inc. v.
Hyundai Eng. & Const. Co., Ltd., 603 A.2d 552, 557 (N.J. Sup. Ct. App. Div. 1992) (finding the
statute of limitations had run where “[a]side from several brief exchanges, in which Deluxe
vacillated respecting the number of invoices that remained unpaid, Deluxe did little or nothing to
press its claim until November 15, 1989, at which time the statute had run as to the remaining
invoices”). As such, the Court dismisses Sandoz’s breach of contract claim with prejudice to the
7 Sandoz’s briefing argues that “[w]here a contract has ‘divisible, installment-type payment
requirements, . . . a new cause of action arises from the date each payment is missed or an
underpayment occurs.’” (ECF No. 22 at 14 (citing Angelo v. Fidelity & Guar. Life Ins. Co., No.
18-3224, 2019 WL 330521, at *2 (D.N.J. Jan. 25, 2019)).) As such, Sandoz seems to concede that
the payments at issue are distinct and that each disputed deduction created “a new cause of action.”
Id. Moreover, when the New Jersey Supreme Court interpreted an installment contract to evaluate
a breach of contract claim, it found that the statute of limitations runs against each installment “as
it falls due.” Metromedia Co. v. Hartz Mtn. Assocs., 655 A.2d 1379, 1381 (N.J. 1995) (emphasis
added) (citation omitted). It found that the plaintiff was entitled to recover only for installments
due within six years of when the suit was filed (per the statute of limitations applicable for breaches
of contract not related to the sale of goods), and it barred older claims. Id. As such, insofar as
Sandoz analogizes the breach to installment contracts, its claims from before March 20, 2021, are
similarly barred.
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 10 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
11
extent it seeks to recover for alleged violations of the Purchase Contract that occurred outside of
the applicable four-year statute of limitations, or before March 20, 2021.8
B. Failure to State a Claim
Sam’s Club next argues that the Complaint must be dismissed because it did not breach the
contract, as the Purchase Contract “does not preclude Sam’s Club from taking FTS deductions
resulting from Sandoz’s failure to supply.”9 (ECF No. 17-1 at 15; see also id. at 9.) Because the
Purchase Contract does not preclude deductions or otherwise contain “contrary terms,” it argues,
the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) as adopted in New Jersey applies and permits such
deductions.10 (Id. at 15.) Indeed, Sam’s Club asks the Court to read multiple provisions of the
UCC into the Purchase Contract including: (1) Section 12A:2-711(1), which allows for cover
“[w]here the seller fails to make delivery or repudiates or the buyer rightfully rejects or justifiably
revokes acceptance” and refers to such a situation as “breach,” N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-711(1); (2)
Section 12A:2-712(1), which provides that “[a]fter a breach within the preceding section the buyer
8 The Court also notes that the equities do not favor tolling the statute of limitations. Not
only is Sandoz a sophisticated entity, but it was aware of the alleged breaches, as it avers to
receiving “spreadsheets with amounts [Sam’s Club] was withholding” during the time period at
issue. (ECF No. 1 ¶ 32.) Despite possessing such spreadsheets, Sandoz chose not to pursue a
claim. Moreover, Sandoz entered into a new contract with Sam’s Club in 2023 that was explicit
about the rights at issue in this dispute. (Id. ¶¶ 46-47.) However, Sandoz still waited nearly 18
months from when that contract was signed to file the instant Complaint for breach of contract.
And since “[a] statute of limitations may be equitably tolled under very limited circumstances,”
the Court finds that the aforementioned circumstances do not demand such relief. Barron v.
Gersten, 277 A.3d 502, 504 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 2022).
9 Sam’s Club’s arguments regarding failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted
pertain exclusively to its FTS deductions. It includes a footnote purporting to preserve “its right
to argue that the SSA deductions were likewise permissible under the Purchase Contract.” (ECF
No. 17-1 at 15 n.4.)
10 The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) as adopted in New Jersey is available at N.J. Rev.
Stat. § 12A:2–101, et. seq.
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 11 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
12
may ‘cover’ by making in good faith and without unreasonable delay any reasonable purchase of
or contract to purchase goods in substitution for those due from the seller,” N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-
712(1); (3) Section 12A:2-712(2), which provides that the buyer “may recover from the seller as
damages the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price together with any
incidental or consequential damages,” N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-712(2); and finally (4) Section
12A:2-717, which provides that upon notification to the seller, a buyer can “deduct all or any part
of the damages resulting from any breach of the contract from any part of the price still due under
the same contract,” N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-717. (See ECF No. 17-1 at 15-16.) Sam’s Club also
adds that the Purchase Contract itself contemplates a “deduction or set off” in the dispute resolution
provision. (Id. at 17-18.) Finally, it contends that because it properly complied with the dispute
resolution provision prior to taking any deductions, it did not breach the agreement. (Id. at 17;
ECF No. 23 at 13-14; see also ECF No. 1-2 at 7.)
In response, Sandoz argues that it could not have triggered the UCC provisions permitting
deductions for a failure to supply because it “had no supply obligations”—and Sam’s Club had no
purchase obligations—under the Purchase Contract. (ECF No. 22 at 8, 15-17 (citing ECF No. 1-
2).) Rather, the Purchase Contract merely established “discounted prices that Sam’s Club agreed
to pay Sandoz if it purchased any of the products” listed in Exhibit A of the agreement. (Id. at 16.)
Sandoz also argues that the dispute resolution provision contemplated the deductions by
contending that it is “simply and only, a dispute resolution provision” that “does not give
Defendant the right to unilaterally deduct payment for FTS.” (Id. at 19.)
Under New Jersey law, a plaintiff must allege four elements to state a breach of contract
claim: (1) a valid contract between the parties; (2) performance by the plaintiff; (3) lack of
performance by the defendant, or breach of contract; and (4) damages. Globe Motor Co. v. Igdalev,
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 12 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
13
139 A.3d 57, 64 (N.J. 2016). When determining whether a breach has been adequately alleged,
the Court may dismiss the Complaint if the contract in question “unambiguously contradicts or
fails to support the plaintiff’s allegations of breach.” Burns v. TD Bank, N.A., Civ. No. 21-18194,
2022 WL 17547258, at *5 (D.N.J. Dec. 8, 2022); see also Abramson v. Affinity Fed. Credit Union,
Civ. No. 20-13104, 2021 WL 3885325, at *5 (D.N.J. Aug. 31, 2021) (“[T]he Court may dismiss a
breach of contract claim for failure to state a claim if the ‘plain language’ of the contract contradicts
or fails to support the plaintiff's allegations of breach.”); Yerkes v. Cessna Aircraft Co., Civ. No.
14-5925, 2015 WL 3903569, at *7 (D.N.J. June 25, 2015) (dismissing alleged breach of contract
for this reason). “Generally, questions of contract interpretation should not be decided without the
benefit of discovery and a full evidentiary record.” Atlas Commc’ns Tech., Inc. v. DXC Tech.
Servs., Civ. No. 19-19033, 2020 WL 5105197, at *4 (D.N.J. Aug. 31, 2020).
Sam’s Club’s argument that the UCC provisions purportedly allowed its deductions is
premature. (ECF No. 17-1 at 15.) The Purchase Contract does not contain any provisions plainly
discussing the application of deductions. It states that it “sets forth the entire agreement” between
Sandoz and Sam’s Club and that it “may be modified only by a written agreement.” (ECF No. 1-
2 at 6.) The only reference to a deduction is within the dispute resolution provision: “Customer
shall not make any deduction or set off against amounts owed to [Sandoz] without first following
the dispute resolution procedures set forth above.”11 (Id. at 7.) While this provision provides a
mechanism in which deductions may be permitted, it is not yet clear that the provision applies or
that Sam’s Club complied with the dispute resolution procedures. Sam’s Club’s argument is better
11 The dispute resolution procedures included providing written notice of the dispute, after
which the parties had 60 days to seek resolution. (See ECF No. 1-2 at 7.) If the parties could not
resolve the dispute after 60 days, each party was permitted to “pursue whatever rights and remedies
it has under this Purchase Contract and applicable law.” (Id.)
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 13 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
14
suited for summary judgment. Therefore, the Purchase Contract does not “unambiguously
contradict” Sandoz’s allegations to warrant dismissal. See Buchmiller v. Suntuity Solar, LLC, Civ.
No. 21-20412, 2022 WL 3908070, at *3 (D.N.J. Aug. 30, 2022) (declining to grant a motion to
dismiss where, as a preliminary ruling, the court concluded that a contract provision warranted
additional factfinding); Klein v. Budget Rent a Car Sys., Inc., Civ. No. 12-7300, 2013 WL 1760557,
at *6 (D.N.J. Apr. 24, 2013) (declining to dismiss the plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim because
“ambiguous contractual provisions raise questions of fact that are not appropriately decided on a
motion to dismiss”).
Next, for this Court to rely on the UCC provisions cited by Sam’s Club, the Court must
find that the Purchase Contract: (1) required Sandoz to supply goods to Sam’s Club, and (2) that
Sandoz breached the Purchase Contract. For example, Section 12A:2-712(1) provides that “[a]fter
a breach within the preceding section the buyer may ‘cover’ by making in good faith and without
unreasonable delay any reasonable purchase of or contract to purchase goods in substitution for
those due from the seller.” N.J. Rev. Stat. § 12A:2-712(1) (emphasis added). The Court notes at
the outset that Sam’s Club does not identify any provision in the Purchase Contract that obligated
Sandoz to provide product, as opposed to obligating it to provide discounted pricing on purchases
made by Sam’s Club. Indeed, Sandoz argues that it had no such supply obligation (and that Sam’s
Club had no purchase obligation). (ECF No. 22 at 8, 16-17.) Discovery will shed light on the
extent of any breach.
Because at this early stage the Purchase Contract attached to the Complaint does not
“unambiguously contradict” or otherwise fail to support Sandoz’s allegations that Sam’s Club
breached the Purchase Contract when it took deductions for FTS, the Court declines to grant Sam’s
Club’s Motion to Dismiss for failure to state a claim.
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 14 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
15
IV. CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, and other good cause shown, Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss
(ECF No. 17) is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. An appropriate Order follows.
Dated: January 26, 2026
______________________________
GEORGETTE CASTNER
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
Case 3:25-cv-02001-GC-RLS Document 25 Filed 01/26/26 Page 15 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.