ORTIZ DE LA HOZ v. RR ENTERTAINMENT MUSIC CORP. et al

2:25-cv-04231Njd5 de jan. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 Filed 01/05/26 Page 1 of 4 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 Filed 01/05/26 Page 2 of 4 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 Filed 01/05/26 Page 3 of 4 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 Filed 01/05/26 Page 4 of 4 PageID:
<pageID>

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 _ Filed 01/05/26 Page 1 of 4 PagelD:
<pagelD>

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

ORTIZ DE LA HOZ, No, 2:25-cv-0423 1-WJM-MAH
Plaintiff, OPINION

¥.

RR ENTERTAINMENT MUSIC
CORP. et al,

Defendants.

WILLIAM J. MARTINLE U.S.D.J.

This matter is before the Court on a pro se motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rules
of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(6). ECF No. 25 (“Motion”). The Court decides the
matters without oral argument. Fed. R. Civ. P. 78(b). After careful consideration of the
briefs, and for the reasons set forth below, the Motion is GRANTED WITH PREJUDICE
for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, and the remainder of the Motion is DENIED as
moot.

I. BACKGROUND

This copyright case arises out of a dispute over the artistic works of the decedent and
original Plaintiff, Dario Evangelista Ortiz De La Hoz, also known as Dhario Primero.
Compl. f7/2, 6. Mr. De La Hoz originally filed suit on May 14, 2025, naming as
Defendants Ranphys Dario Ortiz de Leon, Raphael Dario Ortiz de Leon, and RR
Entertainment Music Corp. /d. 7-9. However, Mr. De La Hoz passed away one day
before, on May 13, 2025. ECF No. 10. Counsel for the Plaintiff filed a notice of death on
August 25, 2025. Jd. Several weeks later, counsel for Plaintiff moved to substitute the
personal representative of Mr. De La Hoz’s estate, his son Robert Dario Ortiz Lopez, as
Plaintiff, ECF No. 11-1, at 2. The Court granted the unopposed substitution motion on
October 21, 2025. ECF No. 12.

On November 24, 2025, Defendants! Ranphys Dario Ortiz de Leon and Raphael Dario
Ortiz de Leon moved to dismiss, arguing that the Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction

' Defendant RR Entertainment Music Corp. is a corporation and has not yet appeared in
this action, so a default has been entered pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 55(a).

1

Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 _ Filed 01/05/26 Page 2 of 4 PagelD:
<pagelD>

and that Plaintiff failed to state a claim. Plaintiff opposes the Motion, ECF No. 29
(“Opposition”),” which is now fully briefed.

Il. LEGAL STANDARD

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) provides for the dismissal of a complaint for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction. There are two types of challenges to subject matter
jurisdiction: (1) facial attacks, which challenge the allegations of the complaint on their
face; and (2) factual attacks, which challenge the existence of subject matter jurisdiction,
quite apart from any pleadings. Mortensen v. First Fed. Sav. & Loan Ass’n, 549 F.2d 884,
891 (3d Cir. 1977). Here, Defendant brings a factual attack, Mot. 7, so the court may
consider evidence outside the pleadings, and no presumptive truthfulness attaches to the
plaintiffs allegations. Davis v. Wells Fargo, 824 F.3d 333, 346 (3d Cir. 2016). The
plaintiff bears the burden of proving that jurisdiction exists. Gowuld Elecs. Inc. v. United
States, 220 F.3d 169, 178 Gd Cir, 2000). As the Motion was filed pro se, the Court
construes it liberally. Vogt v. Wetzel, 8 F.4th 182, 185 (3d Cir. 2021).

Ti. DISCUSSION

Before reaching the merits, the Court must first address whether this action is void ab
initio, or void as of the date of filing, because Mr. Ortiz De La Hoz died before the
Complaint was filed. See Void, Black’s Law Dictionary (12th ed, 2024) (defining “void ab
initio” as being “[n]ull from the beginning, as from the first moment”).

A plaintiff who does not exist in a legal sense cannot sue or be sued, See Fund
Liquidation Holdings LLC y. Bank of Am. Corp., 991 F.3d 370, 384 Qd Cir. 2021)
(“[Without legal existence, the [Plaintiffs] lacked standing to sue.”). Deceased plaintiffs
do not exist under the law. See Pasos v. FE. SS. Co., 9 F.R.D. 279 (D. Del. 1949)
(dismissing for lack of jurisdiction where the plaintiff had predeceased and therefore “had
no legal existence”). Therefore, federal courts lack subject matter jurisdiction over a party
that does not legally exist. See In re Plavix Mktg., Sales Pracs, & Prods, Liab, Litig., No.
CV 11-6476, 2021 WL 5002715, at *14 (D.NJ. Oct. 28, 2021) (collecting cases).

Indeed, Rule 25 exists in part to permit substitution of a deceased plaintiff with the
correct surviving entity “[i]fa party dies and the claim is not extinguished.” Fed. R. Civ.

See Rowland v. Cal. Men’s Colony, Unit I Men’s Advisory Council, 506 U.S. 194, 202
(1993) (“[A] corporation may appear in the federal courts only through licensed counsel.”).

2 Although Mr. Ranphys Dario Ortiz de Leon filed a letter asserting that the Plaintiff did
not file a timely opposition, ECF No, 27, because the Motion was filed on November 24,
2025, the Motion was set for January 5, 2026, and the corresponding deadline for
opposition papers was December 22, 2025, See 2026 Motion Calendar, U.S. Dist. Ct. for
the Dist. of NJ. https:/Avww.njd.uscourts.gov/sites/njd/files/2026Motions.pdf
(https://perma.cc/N3 XM-FFE3) (last visited January 5, 2025); L. Civ. R. 78.1(a).

Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 _ Filed 01/05/26 Page 3 of 4 PagelD:
<pagelD>

P. 25(a)(1). Rule 25 uses the present tense “dies” and not the past or present perfect “died”
or “has died.” See Carr v. United States, 560 U.S. 438, 447-48 (2010) (interpreting a
present tense verb and applying the Dictionary Act, | U.S.C. § 1). Therefore, the plain
language suggests that Rule 25 is prospective, applying only to parties who die during
litigation, not those who pass away before litigation commences. See 7C Wright & Miller’s
Federal Practice & Procedure § 1951 (3d ed. 1998) (“Substitution is not possible if one
who was named as a party in fact died before the commencement of the action.”).

Contrary to Plaintiff's position, the prevailing view in the federal courts is that Rule 25
cannot cure a complaint void ab initio. See Mizukami v. Buras, 419 F.2d 1319, 1320 (Sth
Cir. 1969) (per curiam) (holding that Rule 25 substitution is unavailable when the deceased
party died before the initiation of litigation); Chorney v. Callahan, 135 F. Supp. 35, 36 (D.
Mass. 1955) (holding that Rule 25 “clearly contemplates substitution for a party, Le., for
someone who had been made a party to the action before his death.”); [nm re Asbestos Prods.
Liab. Litig. (No. VI), 311 F. RD. 152, 156 (ELD. Pa, 2015) (recognizing that “the majority
of federal and state courts that have considered the issue agree that an action filed in the
name of'a pre-deceased plaintiff is not viable” and concluding that the complaints “are null
ab initio and cannot be amended to rectify the fatal flaw”). Accordingly, even though
Plaintiff passed away only one day before the Complaint was filed, Opp’n 3, other courts
have dismissed cases involving predeceased plaintiffs under similar timelines. See
Banakus v. United Aircraft Corp., 290 F. Supp. 259, 260 (S.D.N.Y. 1968) (dismissing a
lawsuit filed several hours after the plaintiff passed away); In re Aredia & Zometa Prods.
Liab, Litig., No. 03-11-0327, 2012 WL 2015791, at *1-2 (M.D. Tenn, June 5, 2012)
(dismissing for lack of jurisdiction where the lawsuit was filed a day before the suit was
commenced).

Furthermore, Rule 17 does not save Plaintiff's complaint because there is a distinction
between legal existence, which substitution cannot cure, and legal capacity governed by
Rule 17, which substitution can remedy, See Jn re Proton-Pump Inhibitor Prods. Liab,
Litig., No. 17-MD-02789, 2022 WL 17850260, at *4 (D.N.J. Dec. 22, 2022) (holding that
“Rule {7 cannot overcome plaintiffs[’] lack of legal existence” where several plaintiffs’
complaints were filed after they had passed away); Jn re Asbestos Prods. Liab. Litig., 311
F.R.D. at 155 (concluding that “Rule 17 never becomes relevant” when the complaint is
void ab initio because “Rule 17 only contemplates the capacity fo sue, not the prerequisite
of legal existence”); House v. Mitra OSR KNE LLC, 796 F. App’x 783, 790 (4th Cir. 2019)
(holding that Rules 17 and 25 do not permit substitution of a predeceased plaintiff), Indeed,
Rule 17 applies to substitution of an initial plaintiff only “as a result of an understandable
mistake, because the determination of the correct party to bring the action is difficult.” Jn
re Engle Cases, 767 F.3d 1082, 1109 (11th Cir, 2014) (quoting Wieburg vy. GT Sw.
Ine., 272 F.3d 302, 308 (Sth Cir. 2001)).

Across the country, courts routinely dismiss cases brought by a predeceased plaintiff
with prejudice. See, e.g., dare Engle Cases, No. 09-cv-10000-J-32JBT, 2013 WL 8115442,
at *2 (M.D. Fla. Jan. 22, 2013), aff'd, 767 F.3d 1082 (Lith Cir. 2014) (dismissing with
prejudice and concluding that “a lawsuit filed in the name of a deceased individual is a

3

Case 2:25-cv-04231-WJM-MAH Document 30 _ Filed 01/05/26 Page 4 of 4 PagelD:
<pagelD>

nullity over which this Court has no jurisdiction”); Lacy v. Tyson, No. 07-CV-00381, 2012
WL 4343837, at *2-3 (E.D. Cal. Sept. 20, 2012), report and recommendation adopted, No.
07-CV-00381, 2012 WL 5421230 (E.D. Cal. Nov. 5, 2012) (recommending dismissal of a
predeceased party be dismissed with prejudice); ef In re Asbestos Prods. Liab. Litig., 311
F.R.D, at 156 (“[S]ince the deceased Plaintiffs had no legal existence when their
complaints were filed, their suits are nullities with no legal effect.”).

IV. CONCLUSION

The Motion to Dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction is GRANTED WITH
PREJUDICE, and the remainder of the Motion is DENIED as moot.? The Clerk is
directed to close this case.

DATE: J anuaty , 2026

Dismissal here does not preclude a new action. See Adelsberger vy. United States, 58 Fed.
CL. 616, 619 n.3 (2003) (concluding that dismissal with prejudice “would not preclude a
new action by the personal representative, assuming the claim survives, and assuming
proof of appointment”).

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.