IN RE: Bair Hugger Forced Air Warming Devices Products Liability Litigation

1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA
In re: BAIR HUGGER FORCED AIR 	MDL No. 15-2666 (JNE/DTS)
WARMING DEVICES PRODUCTS 	ORDER
LIABILITY LITIGATION
This Document Relates to:
1. 	Case No. 15-cv-03142 (Schackmann v. 3M Company et al)
2. 	Case No. 15-cv-03899 (Hardison v. 3M Company et al)
3. 	Case No. 15-cv-03992 (Bray v. 3M Company)
4. 	Case No. 15-cv-04497 (Wainner v. 3M Company et al)
5. 	Case No. 16-cv-00214 (Taylor v. 3M Company)
6. 	Case No. 16-cv-00511 (Stone v. 3M Company et al)
7. 	Case No. 16-cv-02005 (Siddens v. 3M Company)
8. 	Case No. 16-cv-02123 (Trice v. 3M Company and Arizant Healthcare, Inc.)
9. 	Case No. 16-cv-02205 (Soens v. 3M Company et al)
10. 	Case No. 16-cv-02298 (Dandrea et al v. 3M Company et al)
11. 	Case No. 16-cv-02353 (Helmick v. 3M Company)
12. 	Case No. 16-cv-02596 (White v. 3M Company et al)
13. 	Case No. 16-cv-02743 (DeSimone v. 3M Company et al)
14. 	Case No. 16-cv-02901 (Helton et al v. 3M Company et al)
15. 	Case No. 16-cv-03121 (Wingler v. 3M Company et al)
16. 	Case No. 16-cv-03277 (Turk v. 3M Company et al)
17. 	Case No. 16-cv-03471 (Winebrenner v. 3M Company)
18. 	Case No. 16-cv-03493 (Dukes v. 3M Company et al)
19. 	Case No. 16-cv-03708 (Goodson v. 3M Company et al)
20. 	Case No. 16-cv-03822 (Stinson v. 3M Company et al)
21. 	Case No. 16-cv-03923 (Moak v. 3M Company)
22. 	Case No. 16-cv-03950 (Spiker v. 3M Company et al)
23. 	Case No. 16-cv-04040 (Lukenbach v. 3M Company et al)
24. 	Case No. 16-cv-04205 (Wilson v. 3M Company)
25. 	Case No. 16-cv-04352 (Stephens v. 3M Company et al)
26. 	Case No. 16-cv-04376 (Ford et al v. 3M Company et al)
27. 	Case No. 17-cv-00093 (Roberts v. 3M Company et al)
28. 	Case No. 17-cv-00225 (Narens et al v. 3M Company et al)
29. 	Case No. 17-cv-00344 (Hord v. 3M Company et al)
30. 	Case No. 17-cv-00981 (Thomas v. 3M Company et al)
31. 	Case No. 17-cv-01006 (Shaft v. 3M Company et al)
32. 	Case No. 17-cv-01057 (Snyder v. 3M Company et al)
33. 	Case No. 17-cv-01244 (Thomas et al v. 3M Company et al)
34. 	Case No. 17-cv-01252 (Young v. 3M Company)
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 1 of 30

2
35. 	Case No. 17-cv-01296 (Rainez v. 3M Company)
36. 	Case No. 17-cv-01337 (Foss v. 3M Company)
37. 	Case No. 17-cv-01363 (Sines v. 3M Company et al)
38. 	Case No. 17-cv-01616 (Carter v. 3M Company et al)
39. 	Case No. 17-cv-01658 (Willis v. 3M Company)
40. 	Case No. 17-cv-01933 (Harris v. 3M Company et al)
41. 	Case No. 17-cv-02100 (Broyles v. 3M Company et al)
42. 	Case No. 17-cv-02104 (Watson v. 3M Company et al)
43. 	Case No. 17-cv-02165 (Cameron v. 3M Company)
44. 	Case No. 17-cv-02233 (Stevenson v. 3M Company et al)
45. 	Case No. 17-cv-02281 (Escobedo v. 3M Company et al)
46. 	Case No. 17-cv-02424 (Jeffers v. 3M Company et al)
47. 	Case No. 17-cv-02552 (Dubose v. 3M Company et al)
48. 	Case No. 17-cv-02632 (Wills v. 3M Company et al)
49. 	Case No. 17-cv-02643 (Shepherd v. 3M Company et al)
50. 	Case No. 17-cv-02750 (Godfrey v. 3M Company et al)
51. 	Case No. 17-cv-02836 (Norman v. 3M Company et al)
52. 	Case No. 17-cv-02910 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
53. 	Case No. 17-cv-03009 (Christenson v. 3M Company et al)
54. 	Case No. 17-cv-03036 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
55. 	Case No. 17-cv-03039 (Smithey v. 3M Company et al)
56. 	Case No. 17-cv-03073 (Forsstrom et al v. 3M Company et al)
57. 	Case No. 17-cv-03091 (Brooks v. 3M Company et al)
58. 	Case No. 17-cv-03097 (Key v. 3M Company et al)
59. 	Case No. 17-cv-03290 (Herbeck v. 3M Company et al)
60. 	Case No. 17-cv-03348 (Bethea et al v. 3M Company et al)
61. 	Case No. 17-cv-03468 (Wimbley v. 3M Company et al)
62. 	Case No. 17-cv-03493 (Roberts v. 3M Company et al)
63. 	Case No. 17-cv-03495 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
64. 	Case No. 17-cv-03546 (Wells v. 3M Company et al)
65. 	Case No. 17-cv-03762 (Soltis v. 3M Company et al)
66. 	Case No. 17-cv-03763 (Washington v. 3M Company et al)
67. 	Case No. 17-cv-03887 (Kimbrow v. 3M Company et al)
68. 	Case No. 17-cv-03934 (Straussner v. 3M Company et al)
69. 	Case No. 17-cv-04073 (Thornton v. 3M Company et al)
70. 	Case No. 17-cv-04152 (Vis et al v. 3M Company et al)
71. 	Case No. 17-cv-04239 (Wegner v. 3M Company et al)
72. 	Case No. 17-cv-04255 (Varner v. 3M Company et al)
73. 	Case No. 17-cv-04371 (Davis et al v. 3M Company et al)
74. 	Case No. 17-cv-04432 (Egdorf v. 3M Company)
75. 	Case No. 17-cv-04470 (Ingram v. 3M Company et al)
76. 	Case No. 17-cv-04645 (Suggs v. 3M Company et al)
77. 	Case No. 17-cv-04706 (Owen v. 3M Company et al)
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 2 of 30

3
78. 	Case No. 17-cv-04889 (Thornton v. 3M Company et al)
79. 	Case No. 17-cv-04941 (Simmons v. 3M Company et al)
80. 	Case No. 18-cv-00478 (Hall-Davis v. 3M Company et al)
81. 	Case No. 18-cv-00516 (Wright v. 3M Company et al)
82. 	Case No. 18-cv-00554 (Williams et al v. 3M Company et al)
83. 	Case No. 18-cv-00600 (Trude v. 3M Company)
84. 	Case No. 18-cv-01089 (Murphy v. 3M Company et al)
85. 	Case No. 18-cv-01124 (Yost v. 3M Company)
86. 	Case No. 18-cv-01137 (Chapman v. 3M Company)
87. 	Case No. 18-cv-01363 (Williams v. 3M Company et al)
88. 	Case No. 18-cv-01511 (Hunt v. 3M Company)
89. 	Case No. 18-cv-01521 (Pennington v. 3M Company)
90. 	Case No. 18-cv-01729 (Turner v. 3M Company et al)
91. 	Case No. 18-cv-01771 (Royal v. 3M Company)
92. 	Case No. 18-cv-01910 (Williams v. 3M Company et al)
93. 	Case No. 18-cv-01938 (Porter v. 3M Company et al)
94. 	Case No. 18-cv-01940 (Tresnan v. 3M Company et al)
95. 	Case No. 18-cv-01976 (Wedding v. 3M Company et al)
96. 	Case No. 18-cv-01983 (Womack v. 3M Company)
97. 	Case No. 18-cv-02048 (White v. 3M Company et al)
98. 	Case No. 18-cv-02097 (Rogers v. 3M Company et al)
99. 	Case No. 18-cv-02265 (Wynegar v. 3M Company et al)
100. 	Case No. 18-cv-02441 (Savage v. 3M Company et al)
101. 	Case No. 18-cv-02585 (Ostrander v. 3M Company et al)
102. 	Case No. 18-cv-02727 (Letcher v. 3M Company et al)
103. 	Case No. 18-cv-02909 (Kueck v. 3M Company et al)
104. 	Case No. 19-cv-00211 (Blackburn et al v. 3M Company et al)
105. 	Case No. 19-cv-00830 (Hendricks et al v. 3M Company et al)
106. 	Case No. 23-cv-01339 (English v. 3M Company et al)
107. 	Case No. 23-cv-01362 (Buffington v. 3M Company et al)
108. 	Case No. 23-cv-01634 (Scott v. 3M Company et al)
109. 	Case No. 23-cv-01707 (Ballard v. 3M Company et al)
110. 	Case No. 23-cv-01712 (Waldron v. 3M Company et al)
111. 	Case No. 23-cv-01748 (Slone v. 3M Company et al)
112. 	Case No. 23-cv-01810 (Love v. 3M Company et al)
113. 	Case No. 23-cv-01884 (Rowe v. 3M Company et al)
114. 	Case No. 23-cv-02428 (Peters v. 3M Company et al)
115. 	Case No. 23-cv-03104 (Baskett, Sr. v. 3M Company et al)
116. 	Case No. 23-cv-03361 (Henry et al v. 3M Company et al)
117. 	Case No. 23-cv-03394 (Whoolery v. 3M Company et al)
118. 	Case No. 23-cv-03573 (Lemerond v. 3M Company et al)
119. 	Case No. 24-cv-00377 (Cole v. 3M Company et al)
120. 	Case No. 24-cv-00814 (Haney v. 3M Company et al)
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 3 of 30

4
121. 	Case No. 24-cv-01045 (White v. 3M Company et al)
122. 	Case No. 24-cv-01155 (Green v. 3M Company et al)
123. 	Case No. 24-cv-01710 (Peterson et al v. 3M Company et al)
124. 	Case No. 24-cv-01915 (Gray v. 3M Company et al)
125. 	Case No. 24-cv-02201 (Fort v. 3M Company et al)
126. 	Case No. 24-cv-02505 (Hitch v. 3M Company et al)
127. 	Case No. 24-cv-03175 (Carani v. 3M Company et al)
128. 	Case No. 24-cv-03370 (Green, Sr. v. 3M Company et al)
129. 	Case No. 24-cv-04626 (Idleman v. 3M Company et al)
130. 	Case No. 25-cv-00201 (Orr et al v. 3M Company et al)
Asserting that the plaintiffs in many actions failed to comply with Pretrial Order
No. 23 (“PTO 23”) and Rules 25(a) and 41(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,
Defendants 3M Company and Arizant Healthcare, Inc., moved to dismiss the actions or
the claims of the lead plaintiff.1 For the reasons set forth below, the Court grants in part
and denies in part the motion.
I. 	Background
“If a party dies and the claim is not extinguished, the court may order substitution
of the proper party. A motion for substitution may be made by any party or by the
decedent’s successor or representative.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 25(a)(1). PTO 23, issued in
January 2018, expands on the procedures for substitution. MDL ECF No. 1039. It
instructs plaintiffs as to the filing and content of both the motion for substitution and a
“suggestion of death.” Id. It warns that noncompliance with these directives “will entitle
Defendants to request a dismissal of plaintiff’s action with prejudice in accordance with
Fed. R. Civ. P. 25(a).” Id.
1 	Defendants listed 142 actions in their motion. Actions withdrawn by Defendants
from their motion or dismissed after they filed their motion are not listed above.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 4 of 30

5
In relevant part, PTO 23 requires plaintiff’s counsel to file a suggestion of death
“[w]ithin ninety days of [its] entry . . . or the death of a plaintiff, whichever is later.” Id.
The suggestion of death must identify “the plaintiff and describe[] the time, date, and
circumstances of the plaintiff’s death.” Id. PTO 23 and Rule 25 require that a motion for
substitution be filed within ninety days of the filing of the suggestion of death. A motion
for substitution must (1) identify the proposed substitute, (2) explain why the proposed
substitute is a proper party, and (3) explain why the death of the named plaintiff did not
extinguish the claim under the applicable state laws.
Plaintiffs moved to eliminate the ninety-day deadline for filing the suggestion of
death, arguing that compliance with PTO 23 is sometimes impossible when a plaintiff
relocates or experiences health issues and fails to respond to counsel’s communications.
Pls.’ Mot. to Amend, Sept. 19, 2018, MDL ECF No. 1517. The Court denied Plaintiffs’
motion to amend PTO 23. Order, Dec. 4, 2018, MDL ECF No. 1614. The Court
acknowledged, however, that it “excuses noncompliance with PTO 23 when compliance
is impossible” or where a plaintiff provides “detailed diligent and good faith efforts to
comply with the deadlines in PTO 23.” Id. at 1-2.
In July 2019, the Court entered summary judgment in Defendants’ favor. In
August 2021, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit “reverse[d] the
grant of summary judgment in favor of 3M.” In re Bair Hugger Forced Air Warming
Devices Prods. Liab. Litig., 9 F.4th 768, 773 (8th Cir. 2021). The Eighth Circuit issued
the mandate in November 2021. The parties subsequently “agree[d] that the substitution
requirements set forth on PTO No. 23 will resume as of February 18, 2022. Specifically,
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 5 of 30

6
within 90 days of a plaintiff’s death or February 18, 2022, whichever is later, Plaintiffs
shall file suggestions of death.”
II. 	Legal Standard
If a plaintiff fails to prosecute or comply with PTO 23, the Court may dismiss the
case. Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(b). Such dismissal may be with prejudice “in cases of willful
disobedience of a court order or where a litigant exhibits a pattern of intentional delay.”
Hunt v. City of Minneapolis, 203 F.3d 524, 527 (8th Cir. 2000). This does not require a
“find[ing] that the [plaintiff] acted in bad faith, but requires ‘only that he acted
intentionally as opposed to accidentally or involuntarily.’” Id. (citation omitted). The
Court excuses noncompliance where plaintiffs have demonstrated excusable neglect or
impossibility to comply with PTO 23’s deadline. Order 7, Oct. 26, 2018, MDL ECF No.
1566 (“Without evidence of a reasonable and good faith process for ascertaining whether
or not a client is alive, the Court cannot find that either excusable neglect or impossibility
justify noncompliance with PTO 23.”).
III. 	Discussion
Defendants asserted that the plaintiffs in many actions failed to file timely
suggestions of death or motions to substitute. Defendants moved to dismiss the actions
or the claims of the lead plaintiff. The plaintiffs in 24 actions jointly responded to
Defendants’ motion. They raised arguments that the Court has previously rejected, they
have not demonstrated a different conclusion is warranted, and they have not
demonstrated good cause for their failure to comply with PTO 23. E.g., MDL ECF Nos.
2448, 2455.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 6 of 30

7
Case No. 15-cv-3142—Plaintiff Schackmann died in November 2024.
Defendants filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been
filed. The Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 15-cv-3899—Plaintiff Hardison died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 15-cv-3992—Plaintiff Bray died in October 2024. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 15-cv-4497—Plaintiff Wainner died in February 2022. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-214—Plaintiff Taylor died in August 2019. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-511—Plaintiff Stone died in February 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2005—Plaintiff Siddens died in November 2018. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 7 of 30

8
Case No. 16-cv-2123—Plaintiff Trice died in April 2019. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2205—Plaintiff Soens died in October 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2298—Plaintiff Mario Dandrea died in February 2025. His
attorney filed a suggestion of death in May 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed.
The Court dismisses the claims of Mario Dandrea. Defendants did not move to dismiss
the claims of Plaintiff Sarah Dandrea.
Case No. 16-cv-2353—Plaintiff Helmick died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2596—Plaintiff White died in November 2020. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2743—Plaintiff DeSimone died in March 2023. Her attorney
filed a suggestion of death in September 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed.
The Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-2901—Plaintiff William Helton died in April 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 8 of 30

9
Court dismisses the claims of William Helton. Defendants did not address the claims of
Plaintiff Rita Helton. The Court denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss her claims.
Case No. 16-cv-3121—Plaintiff Wingler died in October 2022. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3277—Plaintiff Turk died in June 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3471—Plaintiff Winebrenner died in July 2022. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3493—Plaintiff Dukes died in March 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3708—Plaintiff Goodson died in April 2022. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3822—Plaintiff Stinson died in February 2023. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 9 of 30

10
Case No. 16-cv-3923—Plaintiff Moak died in May 2024. 3M filed a suggestion
of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses
the action.
Case No. 16-cv-3950—Plaintiff Spiker died in September 2021. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-4040—Plaintiff Lukenbach died in January 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-4205—Plaintiff Wilson died in April 2021. 3M filed a suggestion
of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses
the action.
Case No. 16-cv-4352—Plaintiff Stephens died in February 2022. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 16-cv-4376—Plaintiff Rhonda Ford died in November 2024.
Defendants filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been
filed. The Court dismisses the claims of Rhonda Ford. Defendants did not move to
dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Bobby Ford.
Case No. 17-cv-93—Plaintiff Roberts died in October 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 10 of 30

11
Case No. 17-cv-225—Plaintiff Patricia Williams died in December 2024. Her
attorney filed a suggestion of death in September 2025. No motion to substitute has been
filed. The Court dismisses the claims of Patricia Williams. Defendants did not move to
dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Glenn Williams.
Case No. 17-cv-344—Plaintiff Hord died in June 2019. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-981—Plaintiff Thomas died in February 2022. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1006—Plaintiff Shaft died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1057—Plaintiff Snyder died in August 2022. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1244—Plaintiff Leander Thomas died in May 2024. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Leander Thomas.
Defendants moved to dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Mikitra Thomas because they
“are derivative of and dependent on the lead plaintiff’s claim.” The Court dismisses her
claims. See Ramirez v. City of Chicago, 129 N.E.3d 612, 619–20 (Ill. App. Ct. 2019).
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 11 of 30

12
Case No. 17-cv-1252—Plaintiff Young died in October 2020. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1296—Plaintiff Rainez died in March 2025. His attorney filed a
suggestion of death in June 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1337—Plaintiff Foss died in August 2022. 3M filed a suggestion
of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses
the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1363—Plaintiff Sines died in September 2019. Her attorney filed
a suggestion of death in February 2022. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1616—Plaintiff Carter died in August 2021. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1658—Plaintiff Willis died in August 2022. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-1933—Plaintiff Harris died in October 2023. His attorney filed a
suggestion of death in August 2024. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 12 of 30

13
Case No. 17-cv-2100—Plaintiff Broyles died in January 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2104—Plaintiff Watson died in March 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2165—Plaintiff Cameron died in March 2025. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2233—Plaintiff Stevenson died in March 2022. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2281—Plaintiff Escobedo died in February 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2424—Plaintiff Jeffers died in November 2024. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2552—Plaintiff Dubose died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 13 of 30

14
Case No. 17-cv-2632—Plaintiff Wills died in January 2020. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2643—Plaintiff Shepherd died in September 2023. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2750—No suggestion of death was filed in Case No. 17-cv-2750
when Defendants filed their motion.2 They did not address the spousal claims. Insofar as
Defendants moved to dismiss Case No. 17-cv-2750, the Court denies their motion.
Case No. 17-cv-2836—Plaintiff Norman died in November 2019. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-2910—Plaintiff Smith died in January 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3009—Plaintiff Christenson died in June 2025. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
2 	Under similar circumstances, Defendants withdrew their motion as to a separate
action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 14 of 30

15
Case No. 17-cv-3036—Plaintiff Smith died in November 2024. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3039—Plaintiff Smithey died in October 2023. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3073—Plaintiff Billie Forsstrom died in October 2024.
Defendants filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been
filed. The Court dismisses the claims of Billie Forsstrom. Defendants did not address
the claims of Plaintiff Eric Forsstrom. The Court denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss
his claims.
Case No. 17-cv-3091—Plaintiff Brooks died in February 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3097—Plaintiff Key died in June 2025. Her attorney filed a
suggestion of death in September 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3290—Plaintiff Herbeck died in March 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 15 of 30

16
Case No. 17-cv-3348—Plaintiff Bethea died in April 2025. Her attorney filed a
suggestion of death in September 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3468—Plaintiff Wimbley died in November 2024. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3493—Plaintiff Roberts died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3495—Plaintiff Smith died in November 2022. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3546—Plaintiff Wells died in September 2021. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3762—Plaintiff Soltis died in June 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3763—Plaintiff Washington died in September 2021. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 16 of 30

17
Case No. 17-cv-3887—Plaintiff Kimbrow died in April 2019. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-3934—Plaintiff Straussner died in May 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4073—Plaintiff Thornton died in October 2021. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4152—Plaintiff Larry Vis died in October 2022. His attorney
filed a suggestion of death in June 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Larry Vis.
Defendants moved to dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Donna Vis because they “are
derivative of and dependent on the lead plaintiff’s claim.” The Court dismisses her
claims. See Ramirez, 129 N.E.3d at 619–20.
Case No. 17-cv-4239—Plaintiff Wegner died in January 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4255—Plaintiff Varner died in March 2019. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 17 of 30

18
Case No. 17-cv-4371—Plaintiff José Davis died in February 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of José Davis. Defendants did not address the claims of
Plaintiff Angie Davis. The Court denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss her claims.
Case No. 17-cv-4432—Plaintiff Egdorf died in January 2024. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4470—Plaintiff Ingram died in December 2020. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4645—Plaintiff Suggs died in February 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4706—Plaintiff Owen died in November 2024. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4889—Plaintiff Thornton died in April 2021. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 17-cv-4941—Plaintiff Simmons died in January 2020. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 18 of 30

19
Case No. 18-cv-478—Plaintiff Hall-Davis died in October 2021. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-516—Plaintiff Gerald Wright died in March 2024. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Gerald Wright.
Defendants moved to dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Octive Wright because they
“are derivative of and dependent on the lead plaintiff’s claim.” The Court dismisses her
claims. See Lewis v. Dust Bowl Tulsa, LLC, 377 P.3d 166, 170 n.2 (Okla. Civ. App.
2016).
Case No. 18-cv-554—Plaintiff Arta Williams died in June 2024. Her attorney
filed a suggestion of death in September 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed.
The Court dismisses the claims of Arta Williams. Defendants did not move to dismiss the
claims of Plaintiff Jack Williams.
Case No. 18-cv-600—Plaintiff Trude died in April 2022. 3M filed a suggestion of
death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses the
action.
Case No. 18-cv-1089—Plaintiff Murphy died in March 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 19 of 30

20
Case No. 18-cv-1124—Plaintiff Yost died in April 2023. 3M filed a suggestion of
death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses the
action.
Case No. 18-cv-1137—Plaintiff Chapman died in March 2023. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1363—Plaintiff Williams died in January 2022. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1511—Plaintiff Hunt died in April 2025. 3M filed a suggestion of
death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court dismisses the
action.
Case No. 18-cv-1521—Plaintiff Pennington died in October 2024. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1729—Plaintiff Turner died in April 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1771—Plaintiff Royal died in August 2021. Her attorney filed a
suggestion of death in February 2022. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 20 of 30

21
Case No. 18-cv-1910—Plaintiff Williams died in July 2022. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1938—Plaintiff Porter died in October 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1940—Plaintiff Tresnan died in July 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1976—Plaintiff Wedding died in November 2022. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-1983—Plaintiff Womack died in March 2023. 3M filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2048—Plaintiff White died in November 2024. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2097—Plaintiff Rogers died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 21 of 30

22
Case No. 18-cv-2265—Plaintiff Wynegar died in January 2022. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2441—Plaintiff Savage died in July 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2585—Plaintiff Ostrander died in February 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2727—Plaintiff Letcher died in November 2024. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 18-cv-2909—Plaintiff Kueck died in January 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 19-cv-211—Plaintiff Jean Blackburn died in May 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Jean Blackburn. Defendants did not move to dismiss the
claims of Plaintiff Robert Blackburn.
Case No. 19-cv-830—Plaintiff Joseph Hendricks died in March 2025. His
attorney filed a suggestion of death in May 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 22 of 30

23
The Court dismisses the claims of Joseph Hendricks. Defendants did not move to
dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Lillian Hendricks.
Case No. 23-cv-1339—Plaintiff English died in October 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1362—Plaintiff Buffington died in February 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1634—Plaintiff Scott died in March 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1707—Plaintiff Ballard died in June 2023. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1712—Plaintiff Waldron died in July 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1748—Plaintiff Slone died in May 2024. His attorney filed a
suggestion of death in August 2024. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 23 of 30

24
Case No. 23-cv-1810—Plaintiff Love died in January 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-1884—Plaintiff Rowe died in February 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-2428—Plaintiff Peters died in February 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-3104—Plaintiff Baskett died in November 2024. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 23-cv-3361—Plaintiff Nancy Henry died in January 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Nancy Henry.
Defendants moved to dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Greggory Henry because they
“are derivative of and dependent on the lead plaintiff’s claim.” The Court dismisses his
claims. See Moss v. Pacquing, 455 N.W.2d 339, 343 (Mich. Ct. App. 1990).
Case No. 23-cv-3394—Plaintiff Whoolery died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 24 of 30

25
Case No. 23-cv-3573—Plaintiff Lemerond died in February 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-377—Plaintiff Cole died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-814—Plaintiff Haney died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-1045—Plaintiff White died in May 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-1155—Plaintiff Green died in November 2024. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-1710—Plaintiff Harold Peterson died in April 2025. Defendants
filed a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Harold Peterson. Defendants did not address the claims of
Plaintiff Lindsey Peterson. The Court denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss her claims.
Case No. 24-cv-1915—Plaintiff Gray died in December 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 25 of 30

26
Case No. 24-cv-2201—Plaintiff Fort died in August 2024. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-2505—Plaintiff Hitch died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-3175—Plaintiff Carani died in March 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-3370—Plaintiff Green died in June 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 24-cv-4626—Plaintiff Idleman died in March 2025. Defendants filed a
suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The Court
dismisses the action.
Case No. 25-cv-201—Plaintiff Douglas Orr died in March 2025. Defendants filed
a suggestion of death in October 2025. No motion to substitute has been filed. The
Court dismisses the claims of Douglas Orr.
Defendants moved to dismiss the claims of Plaintiff Marsha Orr because they “are
derivative of and dependent on the lead plaintiff’s claim.” The Court dismisses her
claims. See Ramirez, 129 N.E.3d at 619–20.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 26 of 30

27
IV. 	Conclusion
Based on the files, records, and proceedings herein, and for the reasons stated
above, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. 	Defendants’ Sixteenth Motion to Dismiss for Failure to Comply with
Pretrial Order No. 23, Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(b) and 25(a), or for Failure to
Prosecute [Docket No. 3120] is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN
PART.
2. 	The Clerk of Court is directed to enter a copy of this Order in the 130
actions to which it relates.
3. 	In Case No. 16-cv-2298, the claims of Mario Dandrea are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
4. 	In Case No. 16-cv-2901, the claims of William Helton are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
5. 	In Case No. 16-cv-4376, the claims of Rhonda Ford are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
6. 	In Case No. 17-cv-225, the claims of Patricia Williams are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
7. 	In Case No. 17-cv-3073, the claims of Billie Forsstrom are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
8. 	In Case No. 17-cv-4371, the claims of José Davis are DISMISSED WITH
PREJUDICE.
9. 	In Case No. 18-cv-554, the claims of Arta Williams are DISMISSED WITH
PREJUDICE.
10. 	In Case No. 19-cv-211, the claims of Jean Blackburn are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
11. 	In Case No. 19-cv-830, the claims of Joseph Hendricks are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
12. 	In Case No. 24-cv-1710, the claims of Harold Peterson are DISMISSED
WITH PREJUDICE.
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 27 of 30

28
13. 	Each action listed below is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. In each
action, the Clerk of Court is directed to enter judgment.
1) 	Case No. 15-cv-03142 (Schackmann v. 3M Company et al)
2) 	Case No. 15-cv-03899 (Hardison v. 3M Company et al)
3) 	Case No. 15-cv-03992 (Bray v. 3M Company)
4) 	Case No. 15-cv-04497 (Wainner v. 3M Company et al)
5) 	Case No. 16-cv-00214 (Taylor v. 3M Company)
6) 	Case No. 16-cv-00511 (Stone v. 3M Company et al)
7) 	Case No. 16-cv-02005 (Siddens v. 3M Company)
8) 	Case No. 16-cv-02123 (Trice v. 3M Company and Arizant
Healthcare, Inc.)
9) 	Case No. 16-cv-02205 (Soens v. 3M Company et al)
10) 	Case No. 16-cv-02353 (Helmick v. 3M Company)
11) 	Case No. 16-cv-02596 (White v. 3M Company et al)
12) 	Case No. 16-cv-02743 (DeSimone v. 3M Company et al)
13) 	Case No. 16-cv-03121 (Wingler v. 3M Company et al)
14) 	Case No. 16-cv-03277 (Turk v. 3M Company et al)
15) 	Case No. 16-cv-03471 (Winebrenner v. 3M Company)
16) 	Case No. 16-cv-03493 (Dukes v. 3M Company et al)
17) 	Case No. 16-cv-03708 (Goodson v. 3M Company et al)
18) 	Case No. 16-cv-03822 (Stinson v. 3M Company et al)
19) 	Case No. 16-cv-03923 (Moak v. 3M Company)
20) 	Case No. 16-cv-03950 (Spiker v. 3M Company et al)
21) 	Case No. 16-cv-04040 (Lukenbach v. 3M Company et al)
22) 	Case No. 16-cv-04205 (Wilson v. 3M Company)
23) 	Case No. 16-cv-04352 (Stephens v. 3M Company et al)
24) 	Case No. 17-cv-00093 (Roberts v. 3M Company et al)
25) 	Case No. 17-cv-00344 (Hord v. 3M Company et al)
26) 	Case No. 17-cv-00981 (Thomas v. 3M Company et al)
27) 	Case No. 17-cv-01006 (Shaft v. 3M Company et al)
28) 	Case No. 17-cv-01057 (Snyder v. 3M Company et al)
29) 	Case No. 17-cv-01244 (Thomas et al v. 3M Company et al)
30) 	Case No. 17-cv-01252 (Young v. 3M Company)
31) 	Case No. 17-cv-01296 (Rainez v. 3M Company)
32) 	Case No. 17-cv-01337 (Foss v. 3M Company)
33) 	Case No. 17-cv-01363 (Sines v. 3M Company et al)
34) 	Case No. 17-cv-01616 (Carter v. 3M Company et al)
35) 	Case No. 17-cv-01658 (Willis v. 3M Company)
36) 	Case No. 17-cv-01933 (Harris v. 3M Company et al)
37) 	Case No. 17-cv-02100 (Broyles v. 3M Company et al)
38) 	Case No. 17-cv-02104 (Watson v. 3M Company et al)
39) 	Case No. 17-cv-02165 (Cameron v. 3M Company)
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 28 of 30

29
40) 	Case No. 17-cv-02233 (Stevenson v. 3M Company et al)
41) 	Case No. 17-cv-02281 (Escobedo v. 3M Company et al)
42) 	Case No. 17-cv-02424 (Jeffers v. 3M Company et al)
43) 	Case No. 17-cv-02552 (Dubose v. 3M Company et al)
44) 	Case No. 17-cv-02632 (Wills v. 3M Company et al)
45) 	Case No. 17-cv-02643 (Shepherd v. 3M Company et al)
46) 	Case No. 17-cv-02836 (Norman v. 3M Company et al)
47) 	Case No. 17-cv-02910 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
48) 	Case No. 17-cv-03009 (Christenson v. 3M Company et al)
49) 	Case No. 17-cv-03036 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
50) 	Case No. 17-cv-03039 (Smithey v. 3M Company et al)
51) 	Case No. 17-cv-03091 (Brooks v. 3M Company et al)
52) 	Case No. 17-cv-03097 (Key v. 3M Company et al)
53) 	Case No. 17-cv-03290 (Herbeck v. 3M Company et al)
54) 	Case No. 17-cv-03348 (Bethea et al v. 3M Company et al)
55) 	Case No. 17-cv-03468 (Wimbley v. 3M Company et al)
56) 	Case No. 17-cv-03493 (Roberts v. 3M Company et al)
57) 	Case No. 17-cv-03495 (Smith v. 3M Company et al)
58) 	Case No. 17-cv-03546 (Wells v. 3M Company et al)
59) 	Case No. 17-cv-03762 (Soltis v. 3M Company et al)
60) 	Case No. 17-cv-03763 (Washington v. 3M Company et al)
61) 	Case No. 17-cv-03887 (Kimbrow v. 3M Company et al)
62) 	Case No. 17-cv-03934 (Straussner v. 3M Company et al)
63) 	Case No. 17-cv-04073 (Thornton v. 3M Company et al)
64) 	Case No. 17-cv-04152 (Vis et al v. 3M Company et al)
65) 	Case No. 17-cv-04239 (Wegner v. 3M Company et al)
66) 	Case No. 17-cv-04255 (Varner v. 3M Company et al)
67) 	Case No. 17-cv-04432 (Egdorf v. 3M Company)
68) 	Case No. 17-cv-04470 (Ingram v. 3M Company et al)
69) 	Case No. 17-cv-04645 (Suggs v. 3M Company et al)
70) 	Case No. 17-cv-04706 (Owen v. 3M Company et al)
71) 	Case No. 17-cv-04889 (Thornton v. 3M Company et al)
72) 	Case No. 17-cv-04941 (Simmons v. 3M Company et al)
73) 	Case No. 18-cv-00478 (Hall-Davis v. 3M Company et al)
74) 	Case No. 18-cv-00516 (Wright v. 3M Company et al)
75) 	Case No. 18-cv-00600 (Trude v. 3M Company)
76) 	Case No. 18-cv-01089 (Murphy v. 3M Company et al)
77) 	Case No. 18-cv-01124 (Yost v. 3M Company)
78) 	Case No. 18-cv-01137 (Chapman v. 3M Company)
79) 	Case No. 18-cv-01363 (Williams v. 3M Company et al)
80) 	Case No. 18-cv-01511 (Hunt v. 3M Company)
81) 	Case No. 18-cv-01521 (Pennington v. 3M Company)
82) 	Case No. 18-cv-01729 (Turner v. 3M Company et al)
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 29 of 30

30
83) 	Case No. 18-cv-01771 (Royal v. 3M Company)
84) 	Case No. 18-cv-01910 (Williams v. 3M Company et al)
85) 	Case No. 18-cv-01938 (Porter v. 3M Company et al)
86) 	Case No. 18-cv-01940 (Tresnan v. 3M Company et al)
87) 	Case No. 18-cv-01976 (Wedding v. 3M Company et al)
88) 	Case No. 18-cv-01983 (Womack v. 3M Company)
89) 	Case No. 18-cv-02048 (White v. 3M Company et al)
90) 	Case No. 18-cv-02097 (Rogers v. 3M Company et al)
91) 	Case No. 18-cv-02265 (Wynegar v. 3M Company et al)
92) 	Case No. 18-cv-02441 (Savage v. 3M Company et al)
93) 	Case No. 18-cv-02585 (Ostrander v. 3M Company et al)
94) 	Case No. 18-cv-02727 (Letcher v. 3M Company et al)
95) 	Case No. 18-cv-02909 (Kueck v. 3M Company et al)
96) 	Case No. 23-cv-01339 (English v. 3M Company et al)
97) 	Case No. 23-cv-01362 (Buffington v. 3M Company et al)
98) 	Case No. 23-cv-01634 (Scott v. 3M Company et al)
99) 	Case No. 23-cv-01707 (Ballard v. 3M Company et al)
100) 	Case No. 23-cv-01712 (Waldron v. 3M Company et al)
101) 	Case No. 23-cv-01748 (Slone v. 3M Company et al)
102) 	Case No. 23-cv-01810 (Love v. 3M Company et al)
103) 	Case No. 23-cv-01884 (Rowe v. 3M Company et al)
104) 	Case No. 23-cv-02428 (Peters v. 3M Company et al)
105) 	Case No. 23-cv-03104 (Baskett, Sr. v. 3M Company et al)
106) 	Case No. 23-cv-03361 (Henry et al v. 3M Company et al)
107) 	Case No. 23-cv-03394 (Whoolery v. 3M Company et al)
108) 	Case No. 23-cv-03573 (Lemerond v. 3M Company et al)
109) 	Case No. 24-cv-00377 (Cole v. 3M Company et al)
110) 	Case No. 24-cv-00814 (Haney v. 3M Company et al)
111) 	Case No. 24-cv-01045 (White v. 3M Company et al)
112) 	Case No. 24-cv-01155 (Green v. 3M Company et al)
113) 	Case No. 24-cv-01915 (Gray v. 3M Company et al)
114) 	Case No. 24-cv-02201 (Fort v. 3M Company et al)
115) 	Case No. 24-cv-02505 (Hitch v. 3M Company et al)
116) 	Case No. 24-cv-03175 (Carani v. 3M Company et al)
117) 	Case No. 24-cv-03370 (Green, Sr. v. 3M Company et al)
118) 	Case No. 24-cv-04626 (Idleman v. 3M Company et al)
119) 	Case No. 25-cv-00201 (Orr et al v. 3M Company et al)
Dated: April 21, 2026
s/Joan N. Ericksen
JOAN N. ERICKSEN
United States District Judge
CASE 0:15-md-02666-JNE-DTS Doc. 3393 Filed 04/22/26 Page 30 of 30