Milton v. The National Center for Children and Families, Inc.

8:24-cv-01321Mdd23 de dez. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
:
LISA MILTON
:
v. 	: 	Civil Action No. DKC 24-1321
:
THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR
CHILDREN AND FAMILIES, INC. 	:
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Lisa 	Milton 	(“Plaintiff”) 	and 	The 	National 	Center 	for
Children 	and 	Families, 	Inc. 	(“Defendant”) 	filed 	a 	joint 	motion
seeking 	the 	court’s 	approval 	of 	their 	settlement 	agreement 	on
December 	20, 	2025. 	(ECF 	No. 	34). 	The 	issues 	have 	been 	briefed,
and the court now rules, no hearing being deemed necessary. 	Local
Rule 105.6. 	For the following reasons, the motion will be granted.
I. 	Background
The 	relevant 	factual 	background 	in 	this 	case 	is 	set 	out 	in
prior opinions. 	(ECF Nos. 16, 24). 	Plaintiff’s Amended Complaint
asserts 	violations 	of 	the 	Fair 	Labor 	Standards 	Act 	(“FLSA”), 	29
U.S.C. 	§ 	203, 	et 	seq. 	(Counts 	I, 	IV), 	the 	Maryland 	Wage 	and 	Hour
Law (“MWHL”), Md.Code Ann., Lab. & Empl. § 3-401, et seq. (Counts
II, 	V); 	the 	Maryland 	Wage 	Payment 	and 	Collection 	Law 	(“MWPCL”),
Md. 	Code 	Ann., 	Lab. 	& 	Empl. 	§ 	3-501, 	et 	seq. 	(Count 	III), 	the
Maryland False Claims Act (“MFCA”), Md. Code, Gen. Provisions § 8-
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 1 of 8
2
101, et seq. (Count VIII), and a claim for unjust enrichment (Count
VII).1
The 	parties’ 	proposed 	settlement 	agreement 	provides 	that,
upon 	court 	approval, 	Defendant 	will 	pay 	Plaintiff 	$75,000, 	minus
applicable 	withholding 	taxes 	for 	alleged 	unpaid 	wages. 	In
addition, Defendant, or a third party on Defendant’s behalf, will
pay 	Plaintiff 	$125,000 	for 	alleged 	non-wage 	damages, 	from 	which
there will be no withholdings and for which Plaintiff will receive
an IRS Form 1099. 	Defendant, or an unnamed third party, will also
pay 	Plaintiff’s 	attorney 	$35,000, 	for 	all 	attorneys’ 	fees 	and
costs.
II. 	Analysis
Because Congress enacted the FLSA to protect workers from the
poor 	wages 	and 	long 	hours 	that 	can 	result 	from 	significant
inequalities in bargaining power between employers and employees,
the provisions of the FLSA are mandatory and, except in two narrow
circumstances, are generally not subject to bargaining, waiver, or
modification by contract or settlement. 	See Brooklyn Sav. Bank v.
O’Neil, 	324 	U.S. 	697, 	706-07 	(1945). 	Under 	the 	first 	exception,
the Secretary of Labor may supervise the payment of back wages to
employees, who waive their rights to seek liquidated damages upon
1 	The 	court 	issued 	a 	Memorandum 	Opinion 	and 	Order 	on 	May 	15,
2025, precluding Plaintiff from proceeding on Count VI, Breach of
Contract. 	(See ECF Nos. 24, 25).
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 2 of 8
3
accepting 	the 	full 	amount 	of 	the 	wages 	owed. 	See 	29 	U.S.C. 	§
216(c). 	Under the second exception, a district court can approve
a 	settlement 	between 	an 	employer 	and 	an 	employee 	who 	has 	brought
a 	private 	action 	for 	unpaid 	wages 	pursuant 	to 	Section 	216(b),
provided that the settlement reflects a “reasonable compromise of
disputed 	issues” 	rather 	than 	“a 	mere 	waiver 	of 	statutory 	rights
brought about by an employer’s overreaching.” 	Lynn’s Food Stores,
Inc. 	v. 	United 	States, 	679 	F.2d 	1350, 	1354 	(11 th 	Cir. 	1982); 	see
also Duprey v. Scotts Co., 30 F.Supp.3d 404, 407 (D.Md. 2014).
Although 	the 	United 	States 	Court 	of 	Appeals 	for 	the 	Fourth
Circuit has not directly addressed the factors to be considered in
deciding 	whether 	to 	approve 	such 	settlements, 	district 	courts 	in
this circuit typically employ the considerations set forth by the
United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit in Lynn’s
Food Stores. 	See, e.g., Duprey, 30 F.Supp.3d at 407-08; Lopez v.
NTI, LLC, 748 F.Supp.2d 471, 478 (D.Md. 2010). 	An FLSA settlement
generally should be approved if it reflects “a fair and reasonable
resolution 	of 	a 	bona 	fide 	dispute 	over 	FLSA 	provisions.” 	Lynn’s
Food 	Stores, 	679 	F.2d 	at 	1355. 	Thus, 	as 	a 	first 	step, 	the 	bona
fides 	of 	the 	parties’ 	dispute 	must 	be 	examined 	to 	determine 	if
there are FLSA issues that are “actually in dispute.” 	Id. at 1354.
Then, 	as 	a 	second 	step, 	the 	terms 	of 	the 	proposed 	settlement
agreement must be assessed for fairness and reasonableness, which
requires weighing a number of factors, including: 	“(1) the extent
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 3 of 8
4
of 	discovery 	that 	has 	taken 	place; 	(2) 	the 	stage 	of 	the
proceedings, including the complexity, expense and likely duration
of 	the 	litigation; 	(3) 	the 	absence 	of 	fraud 	or 	collusion 	in 	the
settlement; (4) the experience of counsel who have represented the
plaintiffs; 	(5) 	the 	opinions 	of 	. 	. 	. 	counsel 	. 	. 	.; 	and 	(6) 	the
probability of plaintiffs’ success on the merits and the amount of
the settlement in relation to the potential recovery.” 	Lomascolo
v. Parsons Brinckerhoff, Inc., No. 08–cv–1310, 2009 WL 3094955, at
*10 	(E.D.Va. 	Sep. 	28, 	2009) 	(citing 	Flinn 	v. 	FMC 	Corp., 	528 	F.2d
1169, 	1173-74 	(4 th 	Cir. 	1975)); 	see 	also 	Duprey, 	30 	F.Supp.3d 	at
408, 	409. 	Finally, 	where 	a 	proposed 	settlement 	of 	FLSA 	claims
includes a provision regarding attorneys’ fees, the reasonableness
of 	the 	award 	must 	also 	“be 	independently 	assessed, 	regardless 	of
whether there is any suggestion that a ‘conflict of interest taints
the 	amount 	the 	wronged 	employee 	recovers 	under 	a 	settlement
agreement.’” 	Lane 	v. 	Ko–Me, 	LLC, 	No. 	10-CV-2261-DKC, 	2011 	WL
3880427, at *3 (Aug. 31, 2011) (citation omitted).
A. 	Bona Fide Dispute
“In 	deciding 	whether 	a 	bona 	fide 	dispute 	exists 	as 	to 	a
defendant’s liability under the FLSA, courts examine the pleadings
in 	the 	case, 	along 	with 	the 	representations 	and 	recitals 	in 	the
proposed 	settlement 	agreement.” 	Duprey, 	30 	F.Supp.3d 	at 	408.
Here, 	there 	is 	a 	bona 	fide 	dispute. 	In 	the 	Amended 	Complaint,
Plaintiff 	alleged 	that 	she 	worked 	for 	Defendant 	from 	March 	2021
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 4 of 8
5
through 	March 	2024 	under 	a 	series 	of 	Purchase 	of 	Services
Agreements (“POSAs”). 	The first POSA was from February 27, 2021,
through 	June 	30, 	2021. 	Her 	title 	was 	Clinical 	Liaison 	for 	AAHP.
She was paid $70 per hour, not to exceed $72,000 (or approximately
1,029 	hours). 	Although 	Plaintiff 	worked 	substantially 	more 	than
1,029 	hours 	during 	the 	contract 	period, 	she 	alleges 	that 	she 	was
told 	by 	Defendant’s 	management 	not 	to 	submit 	time 	sheets 	for 	any
hours over 40 in a week.
The 	second 	POSA 	was 	for 	the 	period 	from 	July 	1, 	2021, 	to
December 	31, 	2021. 	Her 	title 	was 	COVID 	Response 	Clinical
Coordinator, 	and 	she 	was 	paid 	at 	the 	same 	rate, 	$70 	per 	hour.
Compensation was limited to $75,600 or $70 per hour x 40 hours per
week 	for 	27 	weeks. 	Plaintiff 	performed 	the 	same 	job
responsibilities as the first POSA, which often exceeded 40 hours
in a week. 	She again complained but alleges that she was directed
to 	limit 	her 	timesheets 	to 	40 	hours 	per 	week 	by 	Defendant’s
management.
The 	third 	POSA 	was 	for 	the 	term 	from 	January 	1, 	2022, 	until
June 	30, 	2022. 	Plaintiff 	performed 	the 	same 	duties, 	working 	the
same 	hours 	as 	under 	the 	first 	and 	second 	POSAs, 	but 	was 	paid 	for
40 hours per week.
The 	fourth 	POSA 	was 	for 	the 	period 	from 	early 	July 	2022
through 	late 	June 	2023. 	Plaintiff’s 	title 	was 	Program 	Network
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 5 of 8
6
Coordinator. 	Under 	this 	POSA, 	her 	workload 	doubled, 	but 	her 	pay
rate was reduced to $56.57 per hour.
In 	July 	2023, 	Plaintiff 	signed 	a 	fifth 	POSA 	reassigning 	her
to 	the 	position 	of 	Health 	Provider 	Recruiter. 	The 	term 	for 	this
POSA 	was 	from 	July 	10, 	2023, 	to 	June 	30, 	2024. 	She 	was 	paid 	$57
per hour for a maximum of 40 hours per week. 	Although she regularly
worked more than 40 hours per week, she alleges that she was told
that 	she 	must 	report 	no 	more 	than 	40 	hours 	per 	week 	on 	her
timesheet.
Plaintiff asserts that she worked an average of 14 hours per
day, six days per week and an average of six hours per day on the
seventh 	day 	from 	March 	1, 	2021, 	through 	March 	7, 	2024. 	(ECF 	No.
26 	¶ 	127). 	As 	an 	example, 	Plaintiff 	asserts 	that 	in 	2023, 	she
should 	have 	been 	paid 	$121,410 	in 	overtime 	wages. 	(ECF 	No. 	26
¶ 155).
Defendant 	denies 	any 	liability. 	Rather 	Defendant 	contends
that 	Plaintiff 	was 	an 	independent 	contractor 	who 	was 	paid 	under
the 	contractual 	terms 	of 	the 	POSAs. 	Thus, 	a 	bona 	fide 	dispute
exists.
B. 	Fairness & Reasonableness
Upon review of the parties’ submissions and after considering
the 	relevant 	factors, 	see 	Duprey, 	30 	F.Supp.3d 	at 	409, 	the
Agreement 	appears 	to 	be 	a 	fair 	and 	reasonable 	compromise 	of 	the
parties’ 	bona 	fide 	dispute. 	The 	parties 	agreed 	to 	settle 	after
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 6 of 8
7
conducting written and documentary discovery and participating in
a ten-hour settlement conference. 	Thus, the parties had sufficient
opportunity 	to 	analyze 	Plaintiff’s 	claims 	and 	to 	engage 	in
settlement negotiations with the understanding that it would be a
difficult 	and 	costly 	undertaking 	to 	proceed 	to 	the 	trial 	of 	this
case.” 	Lomascolo, 	2009 	WL 	3094955, 	at 	*11. 	Moreover, 	counsel
state 	that 	the 	settlement 	“. 	. 	. 	is 	not 	the 	product 	of 	fraud 	or
collusion.” 	(ECF No. 34, at 5).
Although the settlement amount is a departure from the amount
Plaintiff requested, the amount appears to be a fair and reasonable
resolution 	because 	the 	parties 	engaged 	in 	informal 	discovery 	and
settlement 	discussions. 	Defendant 	disputed 	owing 	any 	overtime
wages. 	Plaintiff 	states 	that 	the 	settlement 	reflects 	her 	“more
complete 	understanding 	of 	her 	reported 	hours 	and 	monies 	received
based 	on 	invoices 	submitted.” 	(ECF 	No. 	34, 	at 	6). 	Thus, 	the
settlement represents compromises by both parties to resolve this
matter.
C. 	Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
The 	attorneys’ 	fees 	and 	costs 	requested 	are 	reasonable.
Joseph Creed, counsel for Plaintiff and an attorney with at least
twenty 	years’ 	experience, 	agreed 	to 	accept 	$35,000 	as
compensation, which includes $1,129.45 in costs. 	He attests that
he 	spent 	90 	hours 	in 	representing 	Plaintiff 	and 	his 	fees 	are
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 7 of 8
8
consistent with this court’s guidelines. 	The amount appears to be
reasonable.
III. Conclusion
For 	the 	foregoing 	reasons, 	the 	joint 	motion 	to 	approve 	the
parties’ 	settlement 	agreement 	will 	be 	granted. 	A 	separate 	order
will follow.
/s/
DEBORAH K. CHASANOW
United States District Judge
Case 8:24-cv-01321-DKC Document 35 Filed 12/23/25 Page 8 of 8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.