Hammond et al v. Leopold et al

1:25-cv-00336Mdd1 de dez. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
KIM HAMMOND and 	*
MILNEL FOUNDATION, INC.,
*
Plaintiffs,
*
v. 	Civil Action No. RDB-25-336
*
IAN S. LEOPOLD,
PRIDEWEAR LLC, and 	*
AMERICAN COLLEGIATE SPORTS LLC,
*
Defendants.
*
* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	*
MEMORANDUM OPINION
On 	February 	4, 	2025, 	Plaintiffs 	Kim 	Hammond 	and 	the 	Milnel 	Foundation,
Incorporated, filed an eight-count Complaint (ECF No. 1) against Defendants Ian S. Leopold,
Pridewear LLC, and American Collegiate Sports LLC. The crux of this case is that, from
February 2015 to March 2020, Plaintiffs allegedly invested upwards of one million dollars in
Defendant Pridewear, a clothing company aimed at first responders. Plaintiffs allege that
Leopold, 	Pridewear’s 	principal, 	induced 	them 	to 	invest 	and 	then 	mismanaged 	and
misappropriated the funds, causing them to suffer actual damages in excess of one million
dollars, plus further consequential damages.
As relevant here, Plaintiffs invested in increments, with at least twelve transfers made
over the six-year frame. One of those investments came in the form of Hammond’s purchase
of $100,000.00 worth of equity in Pridewear via a Common Unit and Warrant Purchase
Agreement (the “Agreement”) executed April 29, 2019. Among its other terms, the Agreement
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 1 of 19
2
included a forum-selection clause setting exclusive jurisdiction in the state courts of New York
and the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York for all cases
“arising out of or based upon” the Agreement. (ECF No. 17-4 at 9 § 6.12)
Presently pending is Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for improper venue or, in the
alternative, to transfer this case to the United States District Court for the Southern District
of New York. (ECF No. 17) Specifically, Defendants seek dismissal under three theories. First,
they argue that this Court is an improper venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b), making dismissal
proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1406(a). (ECF No. 17-1 at 11–12) Second, they argue that the forum-
selection clause in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement is valid and
enforceable by dismissing the case. (Id. at 12–19) Third, they assert that dismissal is proper
because of the doctrine of forum non conveniens. (Id. at 19–20) Defendants also seek the
alternative relief of transfer to the United States District Court for the Southern District of
New York under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a).
The Court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a).1 The Court has reviewed
the parties’ submissions; no hearing is necessary. See Loc. R. 105.6 (D. Md. 2025). Clear
precedent from the United States Supreme Court controls this case. See Atl. Marine Const. Co.
v. U.S. Dist. Ct. for the W. Dist. of Tex., 571 U.S. 49, 52 (2013). The forum-selection clause in
the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement is valid, enforceable, and covers the
1 Plaintiff Hammond is a Maryland citizen. (ECF No. 18-1 ¶ 2) Plaintiff the Milnel
Foundation, Incorporated, is a Maryland charitable foundation incorporated and with its
principal office in Maryland. (ECF No. 1 ¶ 4) Hammond is Milnel’s principal. (ECF No. 18-1
¶ 3) Defendant Leopold is a citizen of California. (Id. ¶ 1) Defendants Pridewear LLC and
American Collegiate Sports LLC are limited liability companies incorporated in Delaware; each
company’s principal place of business is in California. (Id. ¶ 2) The amount in controversy
exceeds $75,000. See 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a). (Id. at 15)
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 2 of 19
3
entirety of Plaintiffs’ Complaint (ECF No. 1). Nevertheless, Atlantic Marine instructs that this
case should be transferred and not dismissed. See 571 U.S. at 52. Accordingly, Defendants’
Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 17) is DENIED. This Court TRANSFERS this case to the
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
BACKGROUND
A federal court ruling on a motion to dismiss for improper venue need not accept the
pleadings as true. Sucampo Pharms., Inc. v. Astellas Pharma, Inc., 471 F.3d 544, 549–50 (4th Cir.
2006) (quoting Argueta v. Banco Mexicano, S.A., 87 F.3d 320, 324 (4th Cir. 1996)). Rather, a
court may “freely consider” outside evidence. Id. at 549. Nevertheless, a court “must still draw
all reasonable inferences in the light most favorable to the plaintiff.” CoStar Realty Info., Inc. v.
Field, 612 F. Supp. 2d 660, 672 (D. Md. 2009).
I. 	General Factual Background
This case arises out of a series of investments that Plaintiffs, Kim Hammond and the
Milnel Foundation, Incorporated,2 made in Defendant Pridewear LLC from February 2015 to
March 2020. (ECF No. 1 ¶¶ 7–9) Plaintiffs allege that Defendant Leopold made false
misrepresentations which induced them to invest. (Id.) The Complaint asserts that on or about
January 1, 2015, Leopold initiated discussions with Plaintiffs in which he encouraged them to
invest in Pridewear, an apparel company aimed at first responders. (Id. ¶ 7) Plaintiffs assert
that because of Leopold’s false misrepresentations about the use of the funds, they invested a
2 The Complaint (ECF No. 1) does not make clear what the Milnel Foundation’s
charitable aims are. It states only that Milnel is Maryland a charitable foundation and that
Hammond is a trustee and beneficiary. (Id. ¶¶ 3–4) In his affidavit, Hammond asserts that he
is Milnel’s principal. (ECF No. 18-1 ¶ 3)
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 3 of 19
4
total $945,075.00 in Pridewear. (Id. ¶ 9) Specifically, the Complaint alleges that Plaintiffs
invested $333,427.00 to receive convertible debt shares with an annual interest rate and rate
of return of eight percent. (Id.) They claim that they invested another $611,648.00 to purchase
equity in Pridewear. (Id.)
The Complaint alleges that Leopold has failed to manage the investments in a
reasonable manner and failed to utilize them for their proper purposes. (Id. ¶ 10) Instead,
Plaintiffs assert, Leopold converted the invested monies, diverting them from their intended
uses to the benefit of Defendant American Collegiate Sports LLC, Leopold’s personal use,
and for the personal uses of other persons associated with Pridewear. (Id.) They claim that
Defendants have failed to provide any payments of interest on the convertible debt shares or
in the form of distributions on the shares of equity. (Id.) Finally, Plaintiffs assert that
Defendants have failed to keep them apprised of the status of their investments and have
refused to return the invested monies as requested by Plaintiffs on January 30, 2025. (Id.)
The parties seriously contest the provenance, timing, dollar amount, and number of
investments. Both Leopold and Hammond attach affidavits to their pleadings that purport to
set out an exact accounting of the monies transferred by Hammond to Pridewear from as early
as February 2015 to as late as January 2021.3 For the purposes of deciding this Motion to
3 Leopold’s affidavit asserts that Hammond invested a total of $945,075.00 over twelve
payments from February 2015 to March 2020. (ECF No. 17-2 ¶ 19) Both the timing of the
investments and the total investment amount are consistent with the Complaint, see (ECF No.
1 ¶ 9 (“Over the period of February 2015 through March 2020, . . . Plaintiffs made investments
totaling [$945,075.00].”). Nevertheless, Hammond’s affidavit, which he attached to the
Plaintiffs’ Response (ECF No. 18), attests that he personally invested a total of $1,065,075.00
over thirteen discrete payments from August 2017 to January 2021. (ECF No. 18-1 ¶ 10) He
also attests that Milnel had separately provided funds to Pridewear “for charitable purposes.”
(Id. ¶ 14)
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 4 of 19
5
Dismiss for improper venue (ECF No. 17), however, which does not reach the merits of
Plaintiffs’ claims, the Court focuses solely on the contract at the heart of the Motion.
II. 	The April 29, 2019, Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement
On April 29, 2019, at least eighteen months and at most four years into the ongoing
investment relationship between Plaintiffs and Pridewear, Hammond executed a Common
Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement (the “Agreement”) with Pridewear. (ECF No. 17-4 at
1–13) To be clear, the Agreement memorializes one investment in a series made over many
years.
In the Agreement, Hammond contracted to purchase $100,000.00 worth of equity
shares in Pridewear.4 In exchange, the company represented that it would use the proceeds
from the contract to cover business operations, corporate expenses, and working capital needs.
(Id. at 2, § 1.4) The contract contained a forum selection clause, titled “Dispute Resolution.”
(Id. at 9, § 6.12) That clause dictates unequivocally that the parties “irrevocably and
unconditionally submit to the jurisdiction of the state courts of New York and to the
jurisdiction of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York for the
purpose of any suit, action or other proceeding arising out of or based upon this Agreement.”
(Id.) It also states that the parties “agree not to commence any suit, action or other proceeding
arising out of or based upon this Agreement” except in those courts. (Id.) Finally, the clause
dictates that the parties waive any claim of a lack of personal jurisdiction, inconvenient forum,
4 In his affidavit, Leopold attests that the April 29, 2019 Common Unit and Warrant
Purchase Agreement was in fact a surrender of one of Hammond’s $100,000.00 convertible
debt notes; and that Hammond surrendered the debt for an equally-valued equity interest in
Pridewear. (ECF No. 17-2 ¶ 25) This point goes to the merits and, if at some future point
appropriate, damages of the case; it is not necessary to decide this Motion.
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 5 of 19
6
or improper venue in the state courts of New York or the Southern District of New York.
(Id.) The Agreement also contains “Governing Law” clause, which states that the Agreement
shall be governed under Delaware law “without regard to the conflict of law principles
thereof.” (Id. at 8 § 6.3)
III. 	Procedural History
On February 4, 2025, Plaintiffs brought this eight-count Complaint. They allege
common-law claims of (I) breach of fiduciary duty, (II) negligence, (III) breach of contract,
(IV) intentional misrepresentation, (V) negligent misrepresentation, (VI) unjust enrichment,
(VII) tortious interference with contractual relations, and (VIII) fraudulent misrepresentation
by a fiduciary. See generally (ECF No. 1). They seek compensatory damages of $1,130,993.16
plus consequential damages of $500,000.00, for a total of $1,630,993.16. (Id. at 15)
By process server, Plaintiffs served the Complaint and Summons on all Defendants on
February 5, 2025. (ECF No. 2) They returned those Summons, executed, to the Clerk of Court
on May 7, 2025. (ECF No. 4) Because Defendants failed to answer or enter any appearance,
Plaintiffs sought an entry of default as to each Defendant. (ECF No. 5) The Clerk of this
Court entered default judgment as to all three Defendants on May 8, 2025. (ECF No. 6
(Leopold); ECF No. 8 (Pridewear); ECF No. 10 (American Collegiate)) On May 20, 2025, the
Clerk of Court received the undeliverable, returned mail of the Notice of Entry of Default
sent to Pridewear and American Collegiate. (ECF No. 12; ECF No. 13) On May 30, 2025,
counsel for Defendants entered his appearance. (ECF No. 14) The same day, parties moved
jointly to vacate the entries of default judgment. (ECF No. 15) On June 2, 2025, this Court
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 6 of 19
7
ordered that the default judgments be vacated, and that Defendants file their defenses and
objections under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 by June 16, 2025. (ECF No. 16)
On June 16, 2025, Defendants filed the pending Motion to Dismiss for improper venue
under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)5 and 28 U.S.C. § 1406(a). (ECF No. 17) They
seek, alternatively, to transfer the case to the United States District Court for the Southern
District of New York pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404. (Id.) Defendants argue, first, that the
District of Maryland is an improper venue under § 1406(a). (ECF No. 17-1 at 11–12) Second,
they argue that the Court should enforce the forum selection clause and dismiss the action
under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1). (Id. at 12–19) Third, they argue that the Court
should dismiss on the grounds of forum non conveniens. (Id. at 19) Fourth, they assert that even
if dismissal is not awarded, the Court should nevertheless transfer the action to the Southern
District of New York under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a). (Id. at 19–20)
In their Response, Plaintiffs assert that the United States Court for the District of
Maryland is a proper venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b). (ECF No. 18 at 2) They also argue that
the forum selection clause is either inapplicable or unenforceable as to the claims in the case.
5 Defendants are neither clear nor consistent as to which provision of Rule 12(b) they
invoke to seek dismissal. In the Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 17), they simply invoke “Rule
12.” The Memorandum of Law in Support of the Motion to Dismiss is slightly more exacting
and seeks relief under “[Federal Rule of Civil Procedure] 12(b)(1), (3), or (6) and/or 28 U.S.C.
§ 1406(a).” (ECF No. 17-1 at 4). The standard of review in the Memorandum of Law discusses
Rule 12(b)(3). (Id. at 9) Later, in the argument section of the Memorandum of Law, Defendants
ask the Court to “decline to exercise” jurisdiction over the case and dismiss pursuant to
Rule(b)(1) because of the forum-selection clause. (Id. at 15) As explained later in this Opinion,
the correct procedural vehicle for a motion to dismiss for improper venue is Rule 12(b)(3),
not 12(b)(1) or 12(b)(6). See Sucampo Pharms., Inc. v. Astellas Pharma, Inc., 471 F.3d 544, 549 (4th
Cir. 2006). Nevertheless, that distinction has little practical meaning in this case because
dismissal is an improper way to enforce a forum-selection clause, for the reasons the Court
enunciates below.
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 7 of 19
8
(Id. at 2–3) Finally, they argue that transfer to the Southern District of New York is neither
required nor warranted under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a).6 (Id. at 3–4) The matter is ripe for review.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
This Court’s jurisdiction is based in diversity of citizenship under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.
Therefore, the Court follows Maryland’s choice-of-law rules to the threshold question of
whether the choice-of-law provision in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement
applies. Wells v. Liddy, 186 F.3d 505, 521 (4th Cir. 1999) (citing Klaxon v. Stentor Elec. Mfg. Co.,
313 U.S. 487, 496–97 (1941)) (“A federal court sitting in diversity must apply the choice-of-
law rules from the forum state.”); accord Three M Ents., Inc. v. Texas D.A.R. Ents., Inc., 368 F.
Supp. 2d 450, 457 (D. Md. 2005). Under Maryland’s rules, “it is generally accepted that the
parties to a contract may agree as to the law which will govern their transaction, even as to
issues going to the validity of the contract.” Nat’l Glass, Inc. v. J. C. Penney Props., Inc., 650 A.2d
246, 248 (Md. 1994). The Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement sets Delaware law
as its governing law. (ECF No. 17-4 at 8 § 6.3) The parties do not argue that the choice-of-
6 Plaintiffs also filed a surreply, titled Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendents’ [sic] Reply in
Further Support of Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss. (ECF No. 20) This Court’s Local Rules
dictate that surreply memoranda are not permitted except by order of the Court. Loc. R.
105.2(a) (D. Md. 2025). Nevertheless, the Court has discretion to permit surreplies “‘when the
moving party would be unable to contest matters presented to the court for the first time in
the opposing party’s reply.’” Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc. v. Mayor & City Council of Balt., 22 F.
Supp. 3d 519, 529 (D. Md. 2014) (quoting EEOC v. Freeman, 961 F. Supp. 2d 783, 801 (D. Md.
2013)). A surreply is inappropriate when the moving party’s reply does not raise new
arguments, but rather answers the arguments made by the nonmoving party in their response.
Id. (quoting Freeman, 961 F. Supp. 2d at 801). Here, Plaintiffs did not move for an order from
the Court seeking permission to file a surreply. Additionally, following Clear Channel, leave to
file a surreply would have been inappropriate here because Defendants’ Reply (ECF No. 19)
does not raise new arguments. See 22 F. Supp. 3d at 529 (quoting Freeman, 961 F. Supp. 2d at
801). Nevertheless, even if considered, the surreply (ECF No. 20) would not alter the analysis
in this case.
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 8 of 19
9
law provision is binding. Therefore, the parties’ choice-of-law provision applies. As such, the
Court evaluates the validity and enforceability of the Agreement’s forum-selection clause
under Delaware law. In this respect, Delaware law explicitly tracks federal law, instructing that
forum-selection clauses are “presumptively valid” and should be enforced unless enforcement
would be unreasonable or unjust. Ingres Corp. v. CA, Inc., 8 A.3d 1143, 1146 (Del. 2010)
(quoting The Bremen v. Zapata Off-Shore Co., 407 U.S. 1, 15 (1972), in a footnote and mirroring
its language). The Court also follows Delaware law on question of the applicability of the
forum-selection clause to the whole of Plaintiffs’ claims. The Court applies federal law when
considering Defendants’ requested relief, which they seek under Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 12 and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1404(a) and 1406(a).
ANALYSIS
Defendants seek dismissal of Plaintiffs’ Complaint (ECF No. 1) under three theories.
(ECF No. 17-1) First, they allege that dismissal is proper because this Court is an improper
forum under 28 U.S.C. § 1406(a). (Id. at 11–12) Second, they argue that the forum-selection
clause in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement is valid and should be enforced
by dismissing the action. (Id. at 12–19) Third, they argue that the Court should dismiss the
case due to the doctrine of forum non conveniens. (Id. at 19) Alternatively, Defendants invoke the
forum-selection clause to seek transfer of this case to the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a). (Id. at 19–20)
The Supreme Court’s unanimous holding in Atlantic Marine Construction Co. v. United
States District Court for the Western District of Texas, 571 U.S. 49, 52 (2013), forecloses all of
Defendants’ arguments. In that case, a subcontractor sued its general contractor, alleging that
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 9 of 19
10
the general contractor failed to pay for work performed on the construction of a child-
development center at United States Army Fort Hood in Texas. Id. at 53. The subcontractor
sued in the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas. Id. The general
contractor moved to dismiss the suit based on a forum-selection clause in the subcontract
which had elected the Eastern District of Virginia. Id. In the alternative, the general contractor
sought a transfer. Id. On appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, the general
contractor argued that a party may enforce a forum-selection clause through dismissal under
either 28 U.S.C. § 1406 or Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(3). Id. at 55.
The Court disagreed. It held that, in the absence of “extraordinary circumstances
unrelated to the convenience of the parties,” the proper way for a district court to enforce a
valid forum-selection clause is through transfer to the bargained-for jurisdiction. Id. Therefore,
as explained further below, Atlantic Marine mandates that this Court DENY the Motion to
Dismiss (ECF No. 17) and instead TRANSFER the action to the United States District Court
for the Southern District of New York. The Court begins its analysis by discussing why
dismissal is improper, a decision for which it need not determine the validity and enforceability
of the forum-selection clause. Then the Court proceeds to discuss the propriety of transfer
under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), which requires threshold determinations as to the validity,
enforceability, and scope of the clause.
I. 	Dismissal
a. 	Venue Under 28 U.S.C. § 1406
Defendants’ first argument for dismissal is that this Court is an improper venue under
28 U.S.C. § 1406(a). Section 1406(a) states that when a case is brought in the “wrong” venue,
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 10 of 19
11
the district court “shall dismiss, or if it be in the interest of justice, transfer such case to any
district or division in which it could have been brought.” Whether venue is “wrong” for the
purposes of § 1406(a) is a question “governed by 28 U.S.C. § 1391.” Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at
55. Section 1391(b) states that venue is proper in any federal district court in which: (1) one
of the defendants resides, if all defendants resides in the same State; (2) a substantial part of
the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of the property
that is the subject of the action is situated; or (3) if there is no other district providing proper
venue under § 1391(b), then in any judicial district in which any defendant is subject to
personal jurisdiction for that case. Id. § 1391(b)(1)–(3). “When venue is challenged, the court
must determine whether the case falls within one of the three categories set out in § 1391(b).”
Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at 56. “If it does, venue is proper; if it does not, venue is improper, and
the case must be dismissed or transferred under § 1406(a).” Id.
Defendants urge that this Court is an improper venue under § 1391(b) because none
of the Defendants resides in Maryland, none of the events or omissions giving rise to the
claims occurred in Maryland, and none of the Defendants is subject to this Court’s personal
jurisdiction. (ECF No. 17-1 at 11) However, § 1391(b)(2) states, in essence, that venue is
proper in any district where a substantial portion of the facts creating the claim occurred. The
Complaint alleges that, at all relevant times in this case, Hammond was a resident of Maryland
and made his investments from Maryland. (ECF No. 1 ¶ 9) Further, Plaintiffs assert that
Leopold solicited investments in Maryland. (Id.) Finally, Hammond testifies in his affidavit
that all his investments were routed through Hammond’s Maryland accounting firm, Gorfine,
Schiller, and Gardyn. (ECF No. 18-1 at 2) A substantial part of the events giving rise to this
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 11 of 19
12
claim clearly occurred in Maryland, making venue in this Court proper under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1391(b)(2). Accordingly, Defendants’ argument with respect to improper venue under § 1406
is without merit.
b. Forum-Selection Clause Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12
Defendants’ second argument for dismissal is that the Common Unit and Warrant
Purchase Agreement contains a valid forum-selection clause that the Court should enforce by
dismissing the case under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1). (ECF No. 17-1 at 12–19)
Almost twenty years ago, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled that
motions to dismiss for improper venue are properly considered under Federal Rule 12(b)(3),
not Rule 12(b)(1). Sucampo Pharms., Inc. v. Astellas Pharma, Inc., 471 F.3d 544, 549 (4th Cir. 2006).
Therefore, Defendants’ request for the Court to “decline to exercise” jurisdiction and dismiss
“under Rule 12(b)(1),” see (ECF No. 17-1 at 15), is improper as it invokes the wrong procedural
vehicle.
Even properly sought under Rule 12(b)(3), however, dismissal is not an appropriate
method of enforcement of a forum-selection clause. See Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at 61. “When a
defendant files [a motion to dismiss based on a forum-selection clause], a district court should
transfer the case unless extraordinary circumstances unrelated to the convenience of the
parties clearly disfavor a transfer.” Id. at 52. Defendants offer no extraordinary circumstances
to show why a transfer would be unjust here. Indeed, Defendants seek transfer as an alternative
form of relief to dismissal. (ECF No. 17-1 at 19–20). Accordingly, the Court denies
Defendants’ request to dismiss the case on the basis of the forum-selection clause.
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 12 of 19
13
c.	
Forum Non Conveniens
Defendants’ third argument is that dismissal is proper under the doctrine of forum non
conveniens. That argument suffers from a legal error in that the doctrine of forum non conveniens is
“the appropriate way to enforce a forum-selection clause pointing to a state or foreign forum”
as transferee. Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at 60 (emphasis added). When, as here, the transferee forum
is another federal court, the doctrine does not apply. Id. Instead, it is replaced by 28 U.S.C. §
1404, which the Atlantic Marine court called Congress’s codification of the forum non conveniens
doctrine for that subset of cases. Because there are two federal venues at issue here, the
doctrine is not a valid basis for dismissal. In sum, dismissal is not an appropriate remedy here.
The Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 17) for improper venue is DENIED.
II. 	Transfer
Finally, Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss seeks the alternative relief of transfer to the
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §
1404(a). (ECF No. 17-1 at 19–20) In ruling on this request, the Court must first determine
whether there is a valid and enforceable forum-selection clause. Second, the Court considers
whether the clause’s scope extends to the whole of Plaintiffs’ Complaint (ECF No. 1) As
explained below, the forum-selection clause is valid and reaches the entirety of the Complaint.
The request for transfer to the parties’ bargained-for forum, the Southern District of New
York, is GRANTED.
a. 	Validity and Enforceability of the Forum-Selection Clause
As discussed above, Delaware follows federal law on the validity and enforceability of
forum-selection clauses. See Ingres Corp., 8 A.3d at 1146. As such, the Court analyzes the forum-
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 13 of 19
14
selection clause in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement under federal law.7
The Supreme Court has long held that forum-selection clauses “are prima facie valid and should
be enforced unless enforcement is shown by the resisting party to be ‘unreasonable’ under the
circumstances.” The Bremen v. Zapata Off-Shore Co., 407 U.S. 1, 10 (1972). The Bremen’s
presumption of validity and enforceability “applies only if the forum-selection clause is
mandatory rather than permissive.” BAE Sys. Tech. Sol. & Servs., Inc. v. Republic of Korea’s Def.
Acquisition Program Admin., 884 F.3d 463, 470 (4th Cir. 2018) (citing Albemarle Corp. v.
AstraZeneca UK Ltd., 628 F.3d 643, 650–51 (4th Cir. 2010)). “A mandatory clause requires
litigation to occur in a specified forum.” Id.
Mandatory forum-selection provisions may nevertheless “be found unreasonable,” and
thus unenforceable, “if (1) their formation was induced by fraud or overreaching; (2) the
complaining party ‘will for all practical purposes be deprived of his day in court’ because of
the grave inconvenience or unfairness of the selected forum; (3) the fundamental unfairness
of the chosen law may deprive the plaintiff of a remedy; or (4) their enforcement would
contravene a strong public policy of the forum state.” Allen v. Lloyd’s of London, 94 F.3d 923,
928 (4th Cir. 1996) (quoting The Bremen, 407 U.S. at 10).
Applied here, this is a mandatory forum-selection clause, as it clearly requires litigation
to be brought in one of two specified fora. (ECF No. 17-4 at 9 § 6.12) In the Common Unit
and Warrant Purchase Agreement, the parties “agree[d] not to commence any suit, action or
other proceeding arising out of or based upon this Agreement except in the state courts of
7 The parties do not dispute this approach and it is reflected in their briefing. (ECF No.
17-1 at 9; ECF No. 18 at 3)
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 14 of 19
15
New York or the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.” (Id.)
Therefore, the presumption of validity and enforceability applies to this mandatory clause.
As concerns reasonableness, Plaintiffs do not argue that enforcing the forum-selection
clause would be unreasonable under any of the four grounds listed in Lloyd’s of London. Instead,
Plaintiffs argue, without any supporting caselaw, that the enforcement of this forum-selection
provision would be “patently unreasonable and unfair” because it comes from a contract
covering $100,000.00 of a series of investments approaching $1 million. (ECF No. 18 ¶ 8)
This clause was part of a negotiated contract by the parties for the purchase of equity in a
business. As noted above, by the time this contract was executed on April 29, 2019, the parties
had been engaged in an investment relationship for at least eighteen months and perhaps as
long as four years. Plaintiffs agreed to be bound by those terms, including the forum-selection
clause, as the Agreement includes a merger clause setting its terms as the “full and entire
understanding and agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof.”
(ECF No. 17-4 at 9, § 6.11) In sum, this mandatory forum-selection clause is valid and
reasonable.
b. Scope of Forum-Selection Clause
The forum-selection clause at issue comes from the April 29, 2019, Common Unit and
Warrant Purchase Agreement. See generally (ECF No. 17-4). The Agreement is a contract for
the one-time investment of $100,000.00. Defendants argue, nevertheless, that the forum-
selection clause in the Agreement “encompasses all claims and all parties to the action.” (ECF
No. 17-1 at 15) In support of their claim, they point to the forum-selection clause itself, which
says that the state courts of New York and the United States District Court for the Southern
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 15 of 19
16
District of New York are the proper fora “for the purpose of any suit, action or other
proceeding arising out of or based upon this Agreement.” (ECF No. 17-1 at 15 (quoting ECF
No. 17-4 at 9 § 6.12)). In Response, Plaintiffs contend that the forum-selection clause cannot
sweep in all the claims and parties because it relates only to “$100,000.00 of the over
$1,000,000[.00]” they claim is at issue in the case. (ECF No. 18 at 3) As noted above, the Court
applies Delaware law here because the parties’ choice-of-law clause in the Agreement governs.
See Nat’l Glass, 650 A.2d at 248.
Delaware courts read contract language like “arising out of or based upon” broadly.
See, e.g., Fairstead Cap. Mgmt. LLC v. Blodgett, 288 A.3d 729, 757 (Del. Ch. 2023); Fla. Chem. Co.,
LLC v. Flotek Indus., Inc., 262 A.3d 1066, 1081 (Del. Ch. 2021); CA, Inc. v. Ingres Corp., No.
4300-VCS, 2009 WL 4575009, at *46 n.290 (Del. Ch. Dec. 7, 2009); Elf Atochem N. Am., Inc.
v. Jaffari, 727 A.2d 286, 294–95 (Del. 1999). In Elf Atochem, a shareholder in an aerospace and
aviation chemicals manufacturer sued the manufacturer and its chief executive for breach of
fiduciary duty and mismanagement of funds, among other alleged harms, in the Delaware
Court of Chancery. Id. at 288–89. The plaintiff based its claims in the company’s LLC
agreement. Id. at 289. The Court of Chancery granted defendants’ motion to dismiss for lack
of subject matter jurisdiction because, as relevant here, the forum-selection clause in the LLC
agreement set exclusive jurisdiction in the state and federal courts of California for “any action
on a claim arising out of, under or in connection with” the contract in that case. Id. On appeal,
the Supreme Court of Delaware concluded that the clause’s language had broad meaning and
therefore found that all the claims in the case, even those not arising under the contract
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 16 of 19
17
containing the forum-selection clause, were bound by the clause’s placement of jurisdiction in
the federal and state courts of California. Id. at 294–95.
Applied here, the forum-selection clause in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase
Agreement clearly encompasses all claims and parties in this action. Though Plaintiffs bring
eight different counts in the Complaint, each count either directly arises out of the Agreement
or is based upon it. All the claims in this case center on the investment relationship between
Plaintiffs and Defendants. Just as in Elf Atochem, the parties’ bargained-for forum-selection
clause covers the entirety of this case.
c. 	Transfer Under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a)
Having determined that the forum-selection clause is valid, enforceable, and applies to
all of the claims and parties in this case, the Court next analyzes Defendants’ alternative request
of transfer to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. (ECF
No. 17-1 at 19–20) “For the convenience of the parties and witnesses, in the interest of justice,
a district court may transfer any civil action to any other district or division where it might
have been brought.” 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a). A court may also transfer a case to “any other district
to which the parties have agreed by contract or stipulation.” Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at 59.
As noted above, Atlantic Marine creates a clear rule that a valid forum-selection clause
must be enforced by transfer under § 1404(a) “to the forum specified in that clause” in all but
“extraordinary circumstances.” Id. at 62. Id. at 52. Though federal district courts normally have
broad discretion to rule on motions to transfer, see Van Dusen v. Barrack, 376 U.S. 612, 622
(1964), that discretion is limited in cases where there is an enforceable forum-selection clause.
See Atl. Marine, 571 U.S. at 62. Such a clause “‘represents the parties’ agreement as to the most
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 17 of 19
18
proper forum.’” Id. at 63 (quoting Stewart Org. v. Ricoh Corp., 487 U.S. 22, 31 (1988)). Therefore,
“‘a valid forum selection clause [should be] given controlling weight in all but the most
exceptional cases.’” Id. at 63 (alteration in original) (quoting Stewart, 487 U.S. at 33 (Kennedy,
J., concurring)).
In a typical case seeking transfer under § 1404(a) and which does not involve a forum-
selection clause, a district court applies a balancing test of fact-specific factors.8 See, e.g., Menk
v. MITRE Corp., 713 F. Supp. 3d 113, 133 (D. Md. 2024) (applying the balancing test). When
a case involves a valid forum-selection clause, however, Atlantic Marine mandates that district
courts alter the normal § 1404(a) analysis in three ways. 571 U.S. at 63. “First, the plaintiff’s
choice of forum merits no weight.” Instead, plaintiffs must show that transfer to the
bargained-for forum is “unwarranted.” Id. Second, a court “should not consider arguments
about the parties’ private interests.” Id. at 64. The parties may raise “public-interest factors
only.” Id. Third, a § 1404(a) transfer in these circumstances “will not carry with it the original
venue’s choice of law rules.” Id. Instead, the choice-of-law rules of the transferee forum—the
bargained-for forum—will apply. Id. (citing Van Dusen, 376 U.S. at 639). At bottom, in almost
all cases the district court should transfer the case. Id. at 62.
In their Response (ECF No. 18), Plaintiffs do not offer evidence of the exceptional
factors necessary to cause the cause the Court to avoid transferring this case. In fact, Plaintiffs
reference factors which Atlantic Marine explicitly prohibits the Court from considering. (Id. at
8 “District courts in [the Fourth Circuit] consider four factors when deciding to transfer
venue: (1) the weight accorded to plaintiff’s choice of venue; (2) witness convenience and
access; (3) convenience of the parties; and (4) the interest of justice.” Tr. of the Plumbers &
Pipefitters Nat’l Pension Fund v. Plumbing Servs., Inc., 791 F.3d 436, 444 (4th Cir. 2015) (collecting
cases).
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 18 of 19
19
4) Given that Plaintiffs have not overcome their high burden of showing why the forum-
selection clause should not be honored, this Court must TRANSFER the case to the forum
that the parties selected in the Common Unit and Warrant Purchase Agreement, the United
States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss for improper venue
(ECF No. 17) is DENIED. This case shall be TRANSFERRED to the United States District
Court for the Southern District of New York.9
A separate Order follows.
Date: December 1, 2025
Richard D. Bennett
United States Senior District Judge
9 Defendants’ additional request for costs and attorney’s fees (ECF No. 17) in
connection with this case is DENIED.
/s/
Case 1:25-cv-00336-RDB Document 23 Filed 12/01/25 Page 19 of 19

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.