IN RE: Cutter Laboratories, Inc., "Braunwald-Cutter" Aortic Heart Valve Products Liability Litigation

JPML, FORM 1A
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 367 -- IN RE CUTTER LABORATORTES INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER"AORTIC
HEART VALVE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION
bate
10/30/78] 1 MOTION, BRIEF, SCHEDULE OF CASES, CERT. OF SVC. --
Plaintiffs Donald and Claire Dodson. (ea)
SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE DISTRICT: Eastern District of New York
SUGGESTED TRANSFEREE JUDGE: (ea)
11/8/78 | 2 RESPONSE —- Plaintiff Lindsay w/cert. of svc.(ea)
11/8/78 | 3 RESPONSE, BRIEF -— Plaintiffs Dodson w/cert.of svc.(ea)
11/9/78 | 4 RESPONSE --— Plaintiffs Beznos w/cert. of svc. (ea)
11/9/78 5: RESPONSE -— Plaintiff Sally Tierno w/cert. of svc. (Case
filed in New Jersey State Court) (ea)
11/9/78 6 RESPONSE -- Plaintiff Carey w/cert. of svc. (Case not
yet filed) (ea)
11/9/78 APPEARANCES -- Duncan Barr, Esq. for Cutter Labs,Inc. and
Travelers Indemnity Co.; Ray E. Large, Esq. for Jo Ann
) Crabtree; John Bonina, Esq. for Calvin De Lorimiere,
et al. and Frank Beznos. (ea)
11/13/78 7 RESPONSE —-- Plaintiff DeLorimiere, et al.w/cert.of svc(ea)
11/13/78 APPEARANCES -- Donald M. Lubin, Esq. for Donald Dodson,
et al.; John F.Romano, Esq. for Dorothy Gibbs,etal.	(ea)
11/14/78 8 | RESPONSE —- Cutter Laboratories, Inc.w/cert. of svc.(ea)
11/14/78 APPEARANCES —- John A. Bonina, Esq.for Plaintiffs Menna,
. et al., Scura, et al., Lesch, Weintraub, McFadyen,
Lindsay and Young. (ea)
11/15/7 APPEARANCE -- John A. Bonina, Esq. for Eunice McFadyen(ea)
11/15/78 9 RESPONSE -- McFadyen w/cert. of svc. (ea)
11/16/78 10 RESPONSE —-- Plaintiffs Gibbs w/cert.of svc. (ea)
11/17/7 EXTENSION OF TIME —- Plaintiffs Glover, Wood and Jeter --
GRANTED to and including Nov. 30, 1978. (ea)
11/20/78 NOTICE OF CORRECTION OF PANEL ATTORNEY SVC. LIST —- DonaldM. Lubin, Esq. for Donald Dodson, et al. (correction due
| to lateness of original notice of appearance from	attorney) (ea)
11/27/7 11 REPLY BRIEF -- Donald Dodson, et al.w/cert. of svc. (ea)
12/1/78 | 12 | BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION —- Plaintiffs Glover, Wood
and Jeter w/cert. of svc. (ea)
12/8/78 HEARING ORDER -- setting A-1 thru A-16 for hearing to be
held in Wash., D.C. on Jan. 19, 1979. (ea)
1/3/78 13 REPLY —- Behalf of some plaintiffs (Counsel Bonia) --
w/Exhibit A & B and w/cert. of svc. (cds)
1/12/79 | 14 REPLY --— Plaintiffs Wood/Jeter/Glover - w/cert of serv (cs)
1/12/79] 15 REPLY -- Cutter Laboratories —-- w/Exhibits A - F and cert.
of serv. (cds)
1/19/79 HEARING APPEARANCES --
John Anthony Bonina for Dodson
Duncan Barr for Cutter Laboratories, Inc.
John D. Rowell for Plaintiffs Wood, Jeter & Glover
. (emh)

JPMIL, FORM 1A - Continuation DOCKET ENTRIES ~-- Dp. po
D
? n "
DOCKET NO. LU ~~ yor oro hie rs TABTLLTY LITIGATION ore
Date Pleading Description
2/28/79 CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE COURT assigning Honorable Jack B.
Weinstein to handle litigation for coordinated or consoli-
dated pretrial proceedings under 28 U.S.C. §1407. (ea)
2/28/79 OPINION AND ORDER -- transferring A-1, A-2, A-4, A-5, A-6,
A-7, A-8, A-9, A-10, A-11, A-12, A-13, A-14 to be consoli-
dated with A-15 and A-16 in the Eastern District of New
York for coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings
under 28 U.S.C. §1407 under Hon. Jack B. Weinstein. (ea)
3/15/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FILED TODAY --
B-17 Lindsay v. Cutter Labs, Inc., W.D.Wisc., #78C511
B-18 Crabtree v. Cutter Labs, Inc., N.D.Ala., #77-P2473S
B-19 McFadyen, etc. v. Cutter Labs, D.Kansas, #78-2119
NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL AND JUDGES (emh)
3/16/79 APPEARANCE -- E. Ray Large for Jo Ann Crabtree and Earl
Crabtree (emh)
L/2/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY -- i
B-17 Lindsay v. Cutter Lab., Inc., W.D. Wisc., #78C511
B-18 Crabtree v. Cutter Lab., Inc., N.D. Ala., #77-P2L73S
B-19 McFadyen, etc. v. Cutter Lab., D. Kans., #78-2119 —— .
Notified involved clerks and judges (cds)
4/3/79 B-21 Burchman v. Cutter Laboratories, Inc.,E.D.Pa., C.A.No.
CA-79-814
CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FILED TODAY. Notified involved
counsel and judges. (ea)
CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY —-
L/39/79 B-21 Burchman v. Cutter Lab., Inc., E.D. Pa., #CA-79-814
—— Notified involved counsel (cds)
05/09/ CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FILED TODAY ,B22,23,24,25,26,27
B-22 Zehenni v. Cutter, S.D. Ohio, 78-806
B-23 Gilloon v. Cutter, N.D. Iowa, 78-1010
B-25 B-24 Mancino v. Cutter, D. N.J., 79-0785
DeStefano v. Cutter, D. N.J., 779-786
B-26 Carey v. Cutter, N.D.N.Y., 79 CV 78
B-27 Holst v. Cutter, N.D. Ala, CA78-P0635S
Notified involved coungel and judges (rew)
5/25/79 CONDI TTONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY 18222 thru B-27)
captioned above. Notified involved clerks and judges. (ea)
5/31/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY --
B-28 Evelyn Welch, et al. v. Travelers Indemnity Co.,
et al., S.D. Fla., C.A. No. 79-8123-Civ-JE
NOTIFIED INVOLVED COUNSEL AND JUDGES. (emh)
6/18/79 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY —-
B-28 Evelyn Welch, et al. v. Travelers Indemnity Co.,
et al., S.D.Fla., C.A. No. 79-8123-Civ-JE :
[OTIFIED CLERKS AND JUDGES. (emh)

JPML FORM 1A
DOCKET ENTRIES p.3
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
SOCKET NO. 367 me
I	I ISIES moniTI NI III III TI ITIL
|
80/06/18: | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FILED TODAY -- B-30 Downey,
: | et al. v. Cutter Laboratories, Inc., S.D.N.Y., C.A. No.: | 79 CIV 5905, B-31 Davich, et al. v. Cutter Laboratories,Inc., S.D.N.Y., C.A. No. 79 CIV 2779 -- Notified involved
| counsel and judges. (ds)80/07/0 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY -- B-30 and B-31
i (listed above) -- NOTIFIED INVOLVED JUDGES AND CLERKS cs
|
|i
||
: |
|i
|j
!!
| i{
|
|
||
|
Co
|i
|
}
|

JPME Forit 1 : :
®
Revised: 8/78
DOCKET NO. 367 ~~ JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
CAPTION: IN RE CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER" AORTIC HEART VALVE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LIT.
SUMMARY OF LITIGATION
1/19/79 :
Dates Filed Type Citation District Name of Judge Assigned From
EB 28 1979 i} Joe 465 Supp. RIS] ELD.N.Y. Hon. Jack B. Weinstein
Special Transferee Information ipare crosep: (O/FF §O

JPMI, FORM 1 LISTING OF INVOLVED ACTIONS
DOCKET NO. 367 —- IN RE CUTTER EBABORATORIES, INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER" AORTIC HEART VALVE PRODUCTS
LIABILITY LITIGATION
Intra- District Civili rans feregbate of
Office and Action ransfer| Docket [Dismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Number fr Remand | Misc.
a-1 “| Jo Ann Crabtree v. Cutter Laboratories, N.D.A 77-P-147§f4B 28 19 g 20 yop peTEEA 192/58
Ince. — Pointer
- 0 99 745 af o/50A-2 Phillip D. Symons and Mildred Symons |W.D. Midh. M-76-79FEB 28 1979 7
ve. Cutter Laboratories, Inc. Miles :
A-3 Enoch Molgaard and Gina Molgaard v. |W.D.Wisd. 77-C-428 |[/T_ ou I a
Cutter Laboratories, Inc., et al. br Kel SE
. [0
Q 72258 afselsA-4 | Calvin DeLorimiere and Shirley N.D N.Y 78-cv-4F EB 28 197 17CS5 6
Delorimiere v. Cutter Laboratories, In¢.Foley
APY La {i » 9
A-5 | William Carl Glover v. Cutter C<D+€AL |78-0847- FLAK B28 1 9 FEST g/>0/50Laboratories, Inc. Waters |/7 YD Ts
) Si ad ‘
A-6 | Gary Lynn Wood v. Cutter Laboratoriesj€<D.CAL |CV-78-094FFBY8 1979 so sv§ gelsInc. Waters- | 7 £19 NF
on FEB 28 19 g 79 ¢s550 §/et/v0)	A-7 Hugh Ray Jeter v. Cutter Laboratories}C.D.CAL |CV-78-0943 "LF :
Inc. Waters | 77 «34d |a / 0! .
A-8 Donald Dodson and Claire Dodson Vv. N.D.ILL 76-C-354F HB 28 19 §79 05%) 9/2 ¥Cutter Laboratories, Inc. Flaum

| Ca Document 1 Filed 05/04/15 Page 6 of 11
. . JEML FORM 1 -= Lol einbiReith Listing of Involved Actions -- p. 2
DOCKET NO. 367 __ IN RE CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER" AORTIC HEART VALVE
PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No.pr Remand Misc.
© A-9 | Dorothy Gibbs and Windley Gibbs v. B.D.N.Chr 78-6 8:fIY 4 es 59 9/20 50	Travelers Indemnity Co., et al. Larkins 21 1979 Ld
¢/s2
A-10|Frank Beznos and Gladys Beznos V. E.D.MIC 77149¢ CD 8 1979 9 C53 9/2 J"| cutter Laboratories, Inc. Guy A
os. 2/18 gas lb /13 J80p
A-11 | Eunice McFayden v. Cutter Laboratories|D.Kan. |78=CI¥=2790 1979 7S
Inc. O'Connoxy Feo 28 . :lett /5e	gL
RAL ae
A-12| Nancy Sue Young v. Cutter Laboratories} S.D.MIS$ S-78-0042(N)
» h . 1)
Inc. Nixon FEB 28 1978
-— vs . . od - ef? gd b- A-13"| Gerald Weintraub and Anne Weintraub v.|S.D.N.Y| 78-CIV=27849 Hers A dl
Cutter Laboratories, Inc. ‘Sand FEB 28
A-14 | Max Lesch v. Cutter Laboratories,	Inc. |S.D.N.Y}| 78-CIV-2790 er? C < 3% rat
Sand FEB 28 197"
A-15 | Natale P. and Speranza Menna Vv. E.D.N.Y} 77=Civ.=-2361 .- 3 )ielog rCutter Laboratories, Inc. einstein PVE Tel ‘=
. A-16|Tess Scura and Cosmo Scura v. Cutter DN.Y, [77-Civ~-2359CCLaboratories, Inc. Weinstein : mem
B-17 | Robert H., Lindsay v. Cutter L W.D.Wisc|. 78C511 4279 79C 7 9/20 /s Note included
Laboratories, Inc. hs/79 Doyle on motion	/
B-18 | Earl Crabtree v., Cutter Laboratories, .Alabamp 77-P24738 4a)7 7 ¢ 70 xe / §
Inc., 8/s/79 Pointer ey A904 ¢ [13/80 |b
B-~19 | Eunice McFadyen, etc. v. Cutter D. Kan. | 78-2119 4/2/77 79C9 “ 4 3/i Laboratories, Inc. O'Connor
| | || i |

Case MDL No. 367 Document 1 Filed 05/04/15 Page 7 of 11 ,
JBML FORM 1 -- Continuation e Listing of Involved Actions -- p., 0
DOCKET NO. 367 -— IN RE CUTTER Laboratories, Inc. "Braunwald-Cutfer" Aortic Heart Valve Products
Liability Litigation
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action TransferlransfereePismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
XYZ-20 | Sam Weber, et ano v. Cutter Labs E.D.N.Y.| 79-655
. 2
B-21 Seymour Burchman v. Cutter Laboratorief,E.D.Pa} CA-79-814 4 179 290 10s 9/>¢/%
Inc. 9/3/79 Shapiro ! go
} 4-14 ° 7/28B-22 ,| A. Joseph Zehenni, et al.	v. Cutter S.D.Ohioj 78-806 SR, /9 7
Biomedica, etc. Cerf ogan @
19-115 |9 [26
B-23 | Margaret Gilloon, et al. ve. Cutter N.D.Iowaj 78-1010 s/f)
Laboratories, Inc. $/2i79 McManus /ar [3007
B-24 Louise Mancino, et al. v Cptter D., J. |79-0785 5 /AS, 792 9 u /
Laboratories, Inc. “i [7% oolahan JIT 9/- o/5°} _ q-
B-25 ‘Lawrence De Stefano, et al, v. Cutter P.N.J. [}9-0786 7135/71 /Laboratories, Inc. Seid oolahan
APN 4/652B-26 Kathleen Daniels Carey v. Cutter N.D.N.Y.| 79 CV 78 SIA 79 V7
Laboratories, Inc. “Ja [79 Not Assilgned
B-27 Edward T. Holst, et al. v. Cutter N.D.Ala |CA78 P0635S 575/297Laboratories, Inc. / 7/79 Pointer
KX ZHIBXKX AX SANK EHH K EHX EK XA XXX XEH	KRHA	K XXX ARERR EX KX ARRER id 7RHREXAKON KER XXINHK a V7 fo veB-28 Evelyn Welch, et al. v. Travelers S.D.Fla.| 79-8123-Ci 4/8 7979-11 79, ¥
Indemnity Co., et al. $/3//79 Eaton
X¥2-29 Morris Davich, et al. v. Cutter E.D.N.Y. 79 Civ 204 J 10/5 7/0
Laboratories, Inc. : | J FSS SE |CL TS TE JR tet Ea Sa 2 7, .. Va 7 Ly 7) ED A RY { ~~ pid .
"4 EETay SE SR EESSa a7 — )
p50 24 W0-Y	Wr 3 faa RS A
rely /7 Oo 2 Yyoi— 3 RS G
i i } i ! !

Cage MDL Nq..367 Docunrent 1 .Filed 05/04/15 Page 8 of 11
: ' JEML FORM 1 -- Continuation Listing of Involved Actions -- p._4
DOCKET NO. 367 -- IN RE CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC "BRAUNWALD~-CUTTER" AORTIC HEART VALVE PRODUCTS
LIABILITY LITIGATION
Intra- District Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferTransfereepPismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No.pr Remand Misc.
B-30 | Joseph Downey, et al. v. Cutter S.D.N.YJ 79 Civ 5905 7/7 O| Lo-/97 7/2¢/8¢ i
Laboratories, Inc. 4/850 Brieant i 3 he 2 (yA 0
B-31 | Morris Davich, et al. v, Cutter s.D.N.v| 79 civ 277d 7/7/80(8¢ 1775 etfs
Laboratories, Inc. Gi Brieant
- i)va/N =) LL
J oe 2p

JPML Form 4 R
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST *
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 367 -- IN RE CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER"
AORTIC HEART VALVE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION
DOROTHY GIBBS, ET AL. (A-9)
CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC. John F., Romano, Esq.
TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO. Con	ihnson’ & HoReowny BoA.’
Duncan Barr, Esq. P.O. Box 3466
O'Connor, Cohn, Dillon & Barr ) West Palm Beach, Fl. 3340270 Gold Street, P.O. Box 3142
San Francisco, Calif. 94119 CALVIN DELORIMIERE, ET AL. (A-4)
B FRANK BEZNOS, ET AL. (A-10)
JO ANNCRABTREE	(A-1) | EUNICE MCFAYDEN (A-11)
E. Ray Large, Esq. NANCY SUE YOUNG (A-12)
Skinner, Large & Donovan GERALD WEINTRAUB, ET AL. (A-13)
1407 City Federal Building MAX LESCH (A-14)
Birmingham, Alabama 35203 NANCY P. MENNA, ET AL. (A-15) .
TESS SCURA, ET AL. (A-16)
PHILLIP D. SYMONS, ET AL. (A-2) John A. Bonina, Esq. A
A, H. Wisti, Esq. 16 Court Street, Ste. 2606 | )101 Quincy Street Brooklyn, New York 11241 ° ’
| Hancock, Michigan 49930 3
| ROBERT H, LINDSAY (B-17) -
| ENQCH MOLGAJRD,/ ET .z(A-3 d, John A, Bonia, Esq. (Same as above) and
Dav Black, qd. nS . Cole, Esgud
13400 uth greeh, Ba ad 8 Ross
| acine, Wisconsin 340 1 ne eet
| Me®ison, Wisconsi 03
DONALD DODSON, ET AL. (A-8)
Donald M. Lubin, Esq.
Lubin & Meyer EARL CRABTREE (B-18)
141 Tremont Street E~—Pay-Large, Esq. —(Same—as A-1}— —
Boston, Mass. 02111 EUNICE MCFADYEN (B-19)
John A. Bonia, Esg. (Same as above) and
| WILL1AM CARL GLOVER (A-5) Lyn ohnson, E
GARY LYNN WOOD (A-6) schnider, J & May
| HUGH RAY JETER (A-7) 7th F 7 Huro ilding
| Mark Robinson, Esq. K s City, Kansas 1
| 888# West Sixth Street :
8 Los Angeles, California 90017

JPMI, FORM 4A -- Continuation
Panel Attorney Service List -- p.
. DOCKET NO. -- —
SEYMOUR BURCHMAN (B-21) E WELCH, ET AL. (B-28) :
Jerome H. Ellis, Esq. Edward M>~Ricci, Esquir@é
1210 Fox Building Cone, Owen, Wagners Nugent, Johnson,
1612 Market Street Hazouri & Roth" -
Philadelphia, Pa. 19103 507 North Olive Ave.
A. JOSEPH ZEHENNI, ET AL. (B-22) P.O. Box"3466Leo J. Breslin, Esquire west palm Beach, Florida 334Q2
1200 American Bldg. JOSEPH DOWNEY, ET AL. (B-30)
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 MORRIS DAVICH, ET AIL. (B=31)
John Anthony Bonia, Esquire
MARGARET GILLOON, ET AL. (B-23) (Same as A-4)
Edward J. Gallagher, Jr., Esq. i
405 East Fifth Street |
P.O. Box 2615 |
Waterloo, Iowa 50705 |LOUISE MANCINO, ET AL, (B-24)
. Myron W. Kronisch, Esq.
154 8x Lovingston Ave. ’
Livingston, N.J. 07039
’ LAWRENCE DE STEFANO, ET AL. (B-25)
Myron W. Kronish, Esd.
. (Same as above)
KATHLEEN DANIELS CAREY (B-26)
John Anthony Bonina, Esq.
(Same as abobe)
Frank N. Grasso, Esq.
Legal Arts Bldg.
124 clinton St.
Schenectady, N.Y. 12305
EDWARD T., HOLST, ET AL. (B-27)
H. Darden Williams, Esq.
Rutledge, Williams, Williams
& Norton
Box 519
Anniston, Alabama 36202

JPML FORM 3
p. 1 .
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 367 -- IN RE CUTTER LABORATORIES, INC. "BRAUNWALD-CUTTER" AORTIC
HEART VALVE PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION a
_ Name of Part 1 Named as Party in Following Actigns ]
BIL, BIC, DI [res bf] fe] fd 2, 2	Hee, 8-22 BA HIT 5
Cutter Laboratories, Inc.
IE EAN, =]