IN RE: Atlantic Department Stores, Inc., Litigation

ae] | . ~} =e
col
5a | |® -
d= i. _
Date Qa
8/2/72 [1	§ MOTION of Plaintiff Leggett	fo consolidation Of two actions	(A-1 and A-
{ pending in different districts pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407. Hemo,
; and certificate of service.
8/3/72 2 % Supplemental Motion	of plaintiff Leggett to add Nicholas action to
: I motion for consolidation, w/cert. of service. TT
HOWARD H. BLEICHER V. ATLANTIC DEPT. STORES, C.D.CAL. 72-1651
“Order	to Show Cause. Notified counsel, involved judge
8/16/72 | 3 J DEFENDANTS LOEB, RHOADS	& CO.,SHEARSON, HAMMILL	& INC., CBWL HAYDEN
1 STONE, INC ANDHERBERT	COHEN- Notice of CrossMotion,Averments
: and Brief w/exhibits	A & B and certificate o ervice
8/16/72 4 | DEFENDANTS ATLANTIC	DEPT. STORES, INC., ARLEN REALTY & DEVELOPMENT
CORP., CHARLESC. BASSINE, MARSHALL ROSE, ARTHUR N. Levien and
§ § ARTHUR COHEN Response to motion w/cert. of service.
8/18/72 t 5 J PLAINTIFFS NICHOLAS, ARNOLD	AND GERCHOW response to motion w/cert of
I. service ~~~ i
_8/22/7 _6 (PLAIN PTON AND STEINBERG response to motion w/cert. of service.
8/24/72 } 7 _§DEFENDANT MANAGING UNDERWRITERS response in support of motion, with _
Exhibit C and certificate	of service and Motion foradditional
IE _action (B-3)
9/1/72 {8 | DEFENDANTS ATLANTIC DEPT. STORES, INC., ARLEN REALTY &	DEVELOPMENT—
i CORP., BASSINE, ROSE AND LEVIEN AND COHEN Responsive Averments
HN : | w/statement and cert.	of service. ee
9/5/72 i HEARING ORDER - setting A-1 through B-3, Oct, 4, 1972, New Orleans, la
9/8 : BERNARD GABOR V. HAROLD FEIN, E.D.PA. C,A. 72-1609
ee Reque om _plainti 0 eX ®) ile esponse —
1 ORDER- extending plaintiff's time to AL 12 to file and serve response	9/8/72 i DEFENDANTS WERTHEIM & CO., INC., WHEAT, AND FIRST SECURITIES
Response and Certain other Defendants response	in opposition to
1 motion w/cert of service
9/18/72 | 10 { PLTF. GAROR, ET AL., memorandum for consolidation & transter.
9/22/92 4 } MANAGING--UNDERWRITERS supplementary averments-and-brief in- PRO
-— |of motion, Adding C-1 to litigation.	9/25/72 § |-DEE._ATTANTIC DEPT. STORES _& ARLEN REALTY & DEVELOPMENT CORP. Reply. Mmo	9/23/72 REBUTTAL OF DEFS. WERTHEIM & CO., INC. & WHEAT, FIRST SECURITIES, INC.,
— _____ HECKS, INC. AND CERTAIN OTHER DEFENDANTS IN PARTIAL OPPOSITIONyp TO THE MOTION FOR CONSOLIDATION
10/2/72 | 14 § SUPPLEMENTARY STATEMENT OF PLAINTIFF LEGGETT. oo
0 i 1s} ATEMENT OF PLAIN ANNENBERG (FILED IN OPEN COURT)
0/19 : i ORDER- Consolidating A-1 through C-1 in S.D. New York. Order
3 : states that a transferee judge should be named later. _
10/24/72 CORRECTION ORDER - adding N.S. Nicholas, inadvertently omitted.
i Notified all recipients of transfer order.
0/109 CONSENT of Judge Edelstein for a judge to handle litigation |
in the S.D.N.Y. pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1407 oo
12/12/72 § i OPINION AND ORDER - assigning Judge Charles R. Weiner to the S.D.N.Y.
1 : to handle litigation. Distribution made.
4/4/73 | | ZIMMER ABLON V. ATLANTIC DEPT. STOREES, S.D. OH, 4410
Td 4 CTO entered today. Notified counsel, involved judges. =
4/20/73 § | ZIMMER ABLON V.ATLANTIC	DEPT. STORES; S.D.OH;#410
g CTO final today. Notified transferee, transteror Clerks and—Jjudges.
9714773 § | KTLANTIC DEPT. STORES, INC: V. HECKRSS, 5.D. W.Va. CA-73-152-Ch
I CTO entered today. Notified counsel, involved judges. ~~~ ~~
— —
IR EE

8 £ 0 4
pate Jif i -
10/1/73 i FATLAR DEPT”“STORES; INC Vo HECK 3x05Do WestEvirginia TT
— TCR	A=73=I525CH == CTO final today: Notified xmmrs-transféree, transferc
_ 4} clerks amd judges.TTT
I ES
SERRE —TTTEE
RR ——— I,
EE eo
: 2 es eteee me eee eer	eer eee]
mt Mmme.re Ty +Tt Br 7.SMA rr1 RTARMAS 0AARstbmr mm 1+ rmeerm3 re	Te i3. Ae	0te,8 et	= ri8oe	et=r rrrtI 5i2enrm 25m+sone	mrmre
ES
—_— eb
— —+ee
_ —t- eT
EeSS— —
Ioe ————TTTT TTT TTT
— +——— er	tm eset oe ot tt er oe or een th 0eet	tte Pe Sore ter cent et eee = ett ete eee	eee
IR +=—
UE —

pocker no	SE APL NO. 115, Recent dye NOME LA Po F296 8" Brrr carTon Ll
Description of Litigation ~ [/[/
DOCKET NO. 113 -- IN RE ATLANTIC DEPARTMENT STORES, INC. LITIGATION {= [/ Id al	i fe é “i & Sr .
—_—re ee — ee - —
Summary of Panel Action =
Date(s) of Hearing(s) 7/5/72 _ i
Date(s) of Opinion{(s) or Order (s) 2% sala rar FS Pdr 271 5
= Consolidation Ordered V7 Name of Transferee Judge > CF E
Consolidation Denied : Transferee District Sed 2
Intra-| District| civil Date ofOffice and Action Transfer| Transferee |Dismissal
Number Caption Judge Number Date Docket No. |or Remand Misc.
R 7. i, FA) vy
A-1 Noel Bleecker Leggett, III, etc. S.D.N.Y.|72 Civ 2676 Saad As Motion 8/2/72
| v. Atlantic Department Stores, -% _ EE
Inc., et al. - SRE >S 7 7¥
4
A-2 Blake Upton and Merrill Steinberg, N.D.Cal {C-72-355-Sq /9//¢/7 74 bo 45% Motion 8/2/2
etc. v. Atlantic Department onti ee —— 1/- ) »
Stores, Inc., et al. | 7¢{ AJ
B-1 N. S. Nicholas, et. al. v. 5.D.N.Y | 72 Civ 3164 : | fotion 8/3/72
Arlen Realty & Development EE Re 1/7Corp., et-al. i ha
- ’ . 2 1 "
B-2 Howard H. Bleicher v. Atlantic C.D.Cal"7Z=T651-HP | /J//9/7 a 2 x/ co 8/15Department Stores, Inc., et al. Pregerso
. B-3 Bernard L. Gabor, et al. v. Harold|E.D;Ra. |72-1609 40 v abo 153 Motion 8/24
Fein, et al. Luongo mm S57) 7y
C-1 Norman Annenberg v. Sidney .D.N.Y. | / |Motion FazMittleman, et al. 7 —Civ+3856 - sT/7
C-2 | Zimmer Ablon v,. Atlantic Dept. S.D. Cl A 2
| Stores A 7 3 1° Oo 4410 20/7377 ’ 7¥

Case MDL Ngolkie BoGUMENST FIERY	ED) Page 4 of PAGE 2
—— 0 rT — —
Intra- District Civil Date of
Office and Action Transfer| Transferee| Dismissal
Number Caption Judge | Number Date	| Docket No.| or Remand Misc.
XYZ-1 Arthur Bohrer v. Arthur G. Cohen, 8.D N.Y. |73 Civ. 3371
et al. pS /i 7¢
c-3 Atlantic Department Stores, Inc. §$.D.W.Va.CA 73-152-CH 10h
v. Heck's Inc. 7-/ 9-73 Hall » 2 = 7¢
| |
| || i~
||
i
| | | | |
| | || | | | |

ATTORNEY LIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
C DESCRIPTION OF LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 113 -- IN RE ATLANTIC DEPARTMENT STORES, INC. LITIGATION
No. Plaintiff Defendant
A-1 Stanley J. Levey, Esquire Ly ATLANTIC DEPARTMENT STORES ~F
Kreindler & Kreindler oe ARLEN REALTY & DEVELOPMENT CORP. ."-
C 99 Park Avenue 7 Sei inn OT To PENew York, New York 10016 ’ Parker, Chapin & Flattau
530 Fifth Avenue
: New York, New Yorkl0036
A-2 David B. Flinn, Esquire —
Cerf, Robinson and Leland en LOEB RHOADES & CO.
570 Mills Building ’ Co SHEARSON, HAMMILIL & CO., INC. .
2201 Montgomery Street... oo CBWL-HADEN STONE, INC. ee
San Francisco, Calif. 94104 Clarteas dedlenty Sug	Dewey, Ballentine€, Bushby, Palmer
& Wood
140 Broadway
New York, New York 10005
Mr. Sidney Mittleman
111 8th Ave.
New York, New York
Mr. Tarold Fein | So taaneod
111 8th Aye Se noteleccere	dl.	NEw York, w York
o Mr. Ronald Defusco111 8th Ave. :
New York, New York
- Mr. Ch Bassine
60 E. st.
New York, Wew York
FRED HADDAD
HECK . :
HECK's, INC Stephen R. Steinberg	. JOHN V. RAY ;
Reavis & McGrath
ROY O. DARNALL
H. G. SHAFFER, JR. 1 Chase Manhattan Plag
: RUSSELL L. ISAACS New York, N.Y. 10005DOUGLAS R. COOK
C. H. HETZEL
NATHAN HADDAD :
DENVER	L., MORGAN
LESTER W. ELLIS

No. } Plaintiff “ Defendant
B-1 | Martin, Bloom, Lipton & Van de Walle Mr. Ixving Goldman eZee cel’ / >
17 Barstow Road 111 8th Ave ene lecioss @	Great Neck, New York 11021 New York, New York
Mr. Robert Epstein NeZarx ed
111 8th Ave. tenlede coerel)
New York, New York
Mr. Leonard Nieman netirred! .	111 8th Ave. cent
New York, New York
Mr. Payl Bonynge, Jr. o
oo &7 x- Jr
: Mr. Theodare Ellsworth flop edl	co SETA |
hN
NN |
Mr. Gordon E. Cadwgan NeZizrped) —
Ae, S’ $b CA av. yy. 2
Eisner & Lubin
Spurr,
Nasi eelepmbiahimiitisis
Douglas S. Liebhafsky, Tse. »
B-2 William P. Jacobson, Esquire hachrell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz © .~
Silverberg, Rosen & Leon New vor New, York /ci1880 Centruy Park East, Suite 1100 ew rork, New York jt.
Los Angeles, Calif 90067
B-3 (bavid Berger, EBs. =~ TS } C	Leonard Barrack ©. #2
A | 1622 Locust Street ~ ap Ae ne & Co	. . =< - ’
Rich D. Xréenfiie d, Esq. New York, New York
127 NX Van lt SPfeet :
: . Wertheim & Co., Inc.
Philad 1ph aA Porin Y 19103 Wheat, First Securities, Inc.
' J. Roderick Heller, III, Esquire
: XY Robert B. McCaw, Esquire
C-1 Annenberg & Lissner Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering
| 250 West 57th Street 900 17th Street, N.W. ®	New York, N. Y. 10019 Washington, D. C. 20006
C-2 Jeffrey B. Shulman, Esq.
Shaman, Winer, Shulman & Ziegler
60] Gas & Electrict Building
Dayton, Ohio 45402

ATTORNEY LIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
o DESCRIPTION OF LITIGATION
No. Plaintiff Defendant
C-3 Edward W. Eardley, Esq. HECK'S, INC.
C Box 1588 Harry G. Shaffer, Jr., Esq.	Charleston, West Virginia Shaffer and Shaffer
Josephine & State Streets
Madison, West Virginia
?

p. /
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 113 =--
C COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST
NAME OF PARTY NAMED AS PARTY IN FOLLOWING ACTIONS
Stores 7
Loeb, Rhoades & Co.
® —Arlen Realty & Develop
ment Corp ee
Shearson, Hammill & Co}, A-L, A-2 7-7 AB->~-2 |]
a. 7 re. ee
_	---"// «|
CBWL-HAYDEN STONE +142 Zz
INC. , 7
|
Bldney Mittleman rr
7
==Ronald Defusco 2-1 5-2 70 - z=
|
charles ¢. Bassine | A7
® a

P. _ 2
Arthur G. Cohen A-T —] C
aRE7 yr ISes ek (dein EE ®
ALA Epa ir” 7 B=	oo]
Viiie path Fer a oe
Aira. fleipe-te	ys ze
Go CE Cn ——————	—
CE : =z	OO]
7 hicerleiitr Mi dadisic ta
geal eno (a a A o
Sesbonst Cader” 57 7 OO
Js Theanam~— _ ee]
— , BC
] 1 @®