Dolan v. Nationstar Mortgage LLC et al

3:25-cv-02242Casd16 de dez. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

1
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
JAMES DOLAN, and TAMARA
DOLAN,
Plaintiffs,
v.
NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC d/b/a
MR. COOPER; U.S. BANK, NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION as trustee for the
HARBORVIEW MORTGAGE LOAN
TRUST 2006-4 MORTGAGE PASS-
THROUGH CERTIFICATES, SERIES
2006-4; MTC FINANCIAL INC., d/b/a
TRUSTEE CORPS; and DOES
1-100, inclusive,
Defendants.
Case No.: 25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS’
MOTION TO DISMISS
[ECF No. 6]
Before the Court is Defendants’—Nationstar Mortgage LLC, doing business as Mr.
Cooper, “Nationstar”; and U.S. Bank, National Association as trustee for the Harborview
Mortgage Loan Trust 2006-4 Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2006-4 (“U.S
Bank,” together with Nationstar, “Defendants”)—motion to dismiss Plaintiffs’ complaint
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 1/7
2
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (“Rules”)1 12(b)(2), 12(b)(4), and 12(b)(5).
ECF No. 6. Plaintiffs responded in opposition to Defendants’ motion on October 30, 2025,
ECF No. 8, to which Defendants replied on November 10, 2025, ECF No. 10. The Court
finds the matter suitable for disposition without a hearing under Local Rule 7.1(d)(1). For
the reasons below, the Court DENIES Defendants’ motion. The Court further VACATES
the hearing set for December 19, 2025.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On July 17, 2025, Plaintiffs James and Tamara Dolan filed a complaint against
Defendants in San Diego Superior Court. ECF No. 1-3. In their complaint, Plaintiffs allege
claims for quiet title, negligent and intentional infliction of emotional distress, fraud, and
violations of California and federal statute. Id. at 2.
Though the initial state court summons prepared by Plaintiffs was rejected on July
18, 2025, a second summons was signed and conformed by Deputy Clerk G. Lopez on
August 7, 2025. ECF No. 8, at 2-3; ECF No. 8-2; ECF No. 8-3, at 3-4. A copy of the
Register of Actions for the San Diego Superior Court produced by Plaintiffs indicates that
the Summons was considered filed as of July 18, 2025. ECF No. 8-3, at 5; see also ECF
No. 8-2, at 3. In their reply, Defendants do not dispute that the San Diego Superior Court
accepted and issued a conformed summons on August 7, 2025. See generally ECF No. 10.
At some point prior to August 28, 2025, Defendants received—though they were not
served—a copy of Plaintiffs’ complaint. ECF No. 6, at 3. On August 28, 2025, Defendants
removed the action to this Court based on federal question jurisdiction. See ECF No. 1.
On September 4, 2025, the Parties jointly moved to extend Defendants’ time to
respond to Plaintiffs’ complaint. ECF No. 3. Approximately one month later, Defendants
1 “Rule” or “Rules” refer to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure unless otherwise noted.
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 2/7
3
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
moved to dismiss Plaintiffs’ case for insufficient process, insufficient service of process,
and lack of personal jurisdiction. ECF No. 6.
On October 20, 2025, licensed process servers personally served each of the
removing Defendants—U.S. Bank and Nationstar—as well as non-removing Defendant
MTC Financial Inc., who has not yet appeared in this action, with the complaint, state court
summons, and notice of removal. See ECF Nos. 8-4, 8-5, 8-6.
LEGAL STANDARD
Sufficiency of service of process prior to removal is governed by state law, while
service after removal is governed by Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 4. Murray v. Gade,
No. CV 24-00005 HG-WRP, 2024 WL 1579976, at *1 (D. Haw. Apr. 11, 2024); Fed. R.
Civ. P. 4. “Rule 4 is a flexible one that should be liberally construed, but a federal court
does not have jurisdiction over a defendant unless the defendant has been served properly.”
Id.
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 12(b)(4) and 12(b)(5) authorize dismissal based on
insufficient process and insufficient service of process. More specifically, a motion to
dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(4) relates to the form of the process, while a motion under
Rule 12(b)(5) challenges the mode or lack of delivery of the summons and complaint.
Wasson v. Riverside Cnty., 237 F.R.D. 423, 424 (C.D. Cal. 2006) (citing United States v.
Hafner, 421 F. Supp. 2d 1220, 1223 n.3 (D.N.D. 2006)).
“Once a defendant challenges service, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing
valid service pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4.” Shoup v. JAG Welding, FAB
& Servs., Inc., No. 24-CV-1776 JLS (AHG), 2025 WL 1208916, at *2 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 25,
2025). “If the plaintiff is unable to satisfy his burden of demonstrating effective service, a
court may either dismiss the action or quash service and allow the plaintiff to serve the
defendant again.” Id. (citing Stevens v. Sec. Pac. Nat'l Bank, 538 F.2d 1387, 1389 (9th Cir.
1976)). “Where it appears that effective service can be made and there is no unfair prejudice
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 3/7
4
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
to the defendant, quashing service rather than dismissing the action, and leaving the
plaintiff free to effect proper service, is the appropriate course.” Wick Towing, Inc. v.
Northland, No. C15-1864JLR, 2016 WL 3461587, at *2 (W.D. Wash. June 21, 2016).
Lastly, because “service of process is the means by which a court asserts its
jurisdiction over the person.” SEC v. Ross, 504 F.3d 1130, 1138 (9th Cir. 2007), Defendants
have also moved to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(2). Rule 12(b)(2) provides that “[a]
defendant may move, prior to trial, to dismiss the complaint for lack of personal
jurisdiction.” Data Disc, Inc. v. Systems Technology Associates, Inc., 557 F.2d 1280, 1285
(9th Cir. 1977).
DISCUSSION
In this case, a state court summons was issued but not served prior to Defendants’
removal of the case on August 28, 2025.2 After removal, on October 20, 2025, Plaintiffs
served the complaint and state court summons on Defendants. ECF Nos. 8-4; 8-5. This
Court has not issued a new summons in this case. See generally Dkt.
Defendants rely on the Ninth Circuit decision in Beecher vs. Wallace to assert that a
“state court summons issued but not served prior to removal of the state court action to
federal courts” does not “retain any efficacy for further service of process after removal.”
381 F.2d 372, 373 (9th Cir. 1967).
2 While Defendants initially argued that no summons was ever issued by the state court
prior to removal, ECF No. 6, at 5, Plaintiffs counter that though the initial summons filed
on July 18, 2025, was rejected, a second summons was signed by the Deputy Clerk of Court
and issued on August 7, 2025, see ECF No. 8, at 2-3, ECF No. 8-2; ECF No. 8-3, at 3-4.
Defendants do not contest Plaintiffs’ contention that a state court summons was issued as
of August 7, 2025, in their reply, and thus concede that argument. See Palmer v. Cognizant
Tech. Sols. Corp., 2022 WL 18214014, at *31 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2022) (“Plaintiffs do not
respond to this contention in their Reply, which constitutes a concession of that
argument.”).
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 4/7
5
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Defendants are correct that generally, “[w]hen a case is removed to federal court,
‘[a]ll defendants properly served in the state-court action are deemed properly served in
the removed action, and unserved defendants must be served with a summons from the
federal court.’” Tehranian v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC, No. 8:24-CV-02037-FWS-JDE,
2025 WL 1543630, at *2 (C.D. Cal. Mar. 4, 2025) (quoting CMB Infrastructure Grp. IX,
LP v. Cobra Energy Inv. Fin., Inc., 572 F. Supp. 3d 950, 968 (D. Nev. 2021)). However,
the Beecher holding is more nuanced than Defendants acknowledge. Specifically, in an
unpublished decision, the Ninth Circuit has clarified that if “a defendant who is served with
a state summons after removal either initiated the removal or consented to it, and thus
indisputably had notice of the action prior to removal and notice that it was now a federal
action,” then the service limitations outlined in Beecher are “inapplicable.” Greenfield
Advisors LLC v. Salas, 733 F. App'x 364, 367 (9th Cir. 2018). See also Bella + Canvas,
LLC v. Ben Wachter Assocs., Inc., No. CV-19-8115-DMG-GJSX, 2020 WL 509170, at *1
n.1 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 31, 2020) (“Beecher may not apply when the defendant served with the
summons either initiated the removal or consented to it.”); Lazo v. E-Council Univ., No.
SA-CV-2202051-CJC-JDEX, 2023 WL 6785800, at *3 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 24, 2023) (quoting
Greenfield, 733 F. App’x at 367) (“In the Ninth Circuit, if a defendant ‘either initiated the
removal or consented to it, and thus indisputably had notice of the action prior to removal
and notice that it was now a federal action,’ that defendant may be properly served with a
state-court summons after removal.”); CMB Infrastructure, 572 F. Supp. 3d at 968-69
(same).
Here, the Defendants now challenging the efficacy of service are the same two
Defendants who initiated the removal of this action from state to federal court. See ECF
No. 1. Accordingly, the fact that Defendants were served with the state court summons that
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 5/7
6
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
was issued but not served prior to removal does not render service ineffective as to the
removing Defendants Nationstar and U.S. Bank.3 See Greenfield, 733 F. App’x at 367.
Aside from their objection to Plaintiffs’ service of a state rather than federal court
summons, Defendants do not otherwise challenge the sufficiency of the method or form of
process. See generally ECF No. 10. While Defendants emphasize that Plaintiffs served
Defendants with the state court summons nearly two months after Defendants removed the
case to federal court, ECF No. 10, at 2, they neglect to acknowledge that such a timeline is
within the ninety-day timeframe for service of process following removal. See Lazo, 2023
WL 6785800, at *3 (quoting Wickersham v. Washington, 2014 WL 3846094, at *2 (W.D.
Wash. Aug. 5, 2014)) (“In an action removed from state court, the [ninety]–day period to
serve process runs from the date of removal to federal court, rather than the date the action
was filed in state court.”); see also CMB Infrastructure, 572 F. Supp. 3d at 969 (explicitly
applying the 90-day post-removal timeline for service of process to the time for Plaintiff
3 The Court notes that, after removal to this Court by Defendants Nationstar and U.S. Bank,
Plaintiffs also served Defendant MTC Financial Inc., which has not yet appeared in this
action, with the state court summons, complaint, and notice of removal. See ECF No. 8-6.
Defendant MTC Financial Inc. was not served prior to removal, nor did it initiate or consent
to removal. Accordingly, Defendant MTC Financial Inc. may not be properly served with
the state court summons issued prior to removal. See Greenfield, 733 F. App’x at 367;
Beecher, 381 F.2d at 373.
Should Defendant MTC Financial Inc. appear and challenge the efficacy of Plaintiffs’
service, the Court will be required to find that Defendant MTC Financial Inc. received
insufficient service of process. See Ghusar v. Park 'N Shade of Tuscon, Inc., No. 2:22-CV-
00398-TLN-JDP, 2023 WL 3794294, at *3 (E.D. Cal. June 2, 2023) (“Here, Defendant
was not served prior to removal, nor did they consent to removal. Additionally, Plaintiffs
offer no evidence suggesting Defendant received notice of the federal action other than the
fact they included the notice of removal with their service of the state court summons . . .
This is insufficient. Service of a state court summons with a notice of removal does not
provide notice to a defendant of a pending federal action and thus does not satisfy the
requirements of Rule 4.”).
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 6/7
7
25-cv-2242-GPC-BJW
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
to serve Defendant with a state-court summons when Defendant consented to removal).
Indeed, Plaintiffs served Defendants and filed proof of service with the Court within the
ninety-day post-removal window allotted by Rule 4(m). See ECF No. 9.
In sum, process was both timely and sufficient. Accordingly, the Court DENIES
Defendants’ motion to dismiss Plaintiffs’ complaint for insufficient process and
insufficient service of process pursuant to Rules 12(b)(4) and 12(b)(5). Further, because
Defendants’ motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction was predicated solely on
the theory that Defendants had not been properly served, the Court also DENIES
Defendants’ motion pursuant to Rule 12(b)(2).
CONCLUSION
Defendants’ motion to dismiss, ECF No. 6, is DENIED. The hearing scheduled for
December 19, 2025, is VACATED.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated: December 16, 2025
Case 3:25-cv-02242-GPC-BJW Doc 15 Filed 12/16/25 PageID.<pageID> Pg 7/7

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.