In re M.G. CA2/8

CourtListener 9999881Calctapp11 de jul. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 7/11/24 In re M.G. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

In re M.G. et al., Persons Coming B332200
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP02312A-B
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.G.,
Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Philip L. Soto, Judge. Affirmed.
Akila A. Shenoy, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_____________________________
SUMMARY
The father in this dependency proceeding appeals from
orders terminating reunification services for his two young sons.
Father was incarcerated at the time and contends the juvenile
court abused its discretion in refusing his request for a
continuance of the review hearings. He points out the Los
Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(Department) filed its report four days, rather than 10 days,
before the hearing, changing its recommendation from continued
reunification services to termination of services, and his counsel
could not reach father in custody to discuss the report with him.
Father contends this defect in notice was not harmless; he was
entitled to an additional six months of reunification services; and
substantial evidence did not support the court’s finding that the
Department provided reasonable services to him.
We affirm the orders.
FACTS
M.G. was born in October 2021 and detained from both
parents in June 2022. In August 2022, the juvenile court
sustained allegations that the parents had a history of engaging
in domestic violence, including in the child’s presence; they
knowingly violated court orders by entering the caregiver’s
(paternal grandmother’s) home, engaging in a violent physical
altercation with her and abducting the child; father failed to
protect the child, knowing of mother’s mental and emotional
problems; and father had a history of mental and emotional
problems including erratic behaviors, aggression, and explosive
anger, making him incapable of providing regular care for M.G.
A.K.G. was born a month later, in September 2022, and
was detained from both parents in November 2022; similar

2
allegations to those just described were sustained in February
2023. Plaintiff was incarcerated for robbery in March 2023.
The two dependency cases proceeded on the same hearing
dates. Thus, the juvenile court sustained the allegations
concerning A.K.G. and removed him from his parents, ordering
reunification services, on February 7, 2023, and on the same day
held the six-month status review hearing (Welf. & Inst. Code,
§ 366.21, subd. (e)) for M.G. (Further undesignated statutory
references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.) Following
are some of the details from the hearings that occurred through
that date.
At many of the hearings that preceded his incarceration,
father was repeatedly admonished for his disruptive behavior. At
the June 16, 2022 detention hearing for M.G., father was
admonished for talking during the hearing and interrupting the
court. The court eventually told him to leave the hearing because
he would not stop talking, raising his voice and arguing with the
court.
At the August 8, 2022 adjudication hearing for M.G., father
was again admonished for interrupting the court, and he accused
Department counsel of “making up stuff,” stating, “This is like
some bullshit.” Father again began talking while minor’s counsel
was speaking, and the court remarked that “I don’t know what to
do to deal with the father’s impulse control issues in court and
his inability to remain silent for short periods of time.” At that
hearing, father was ordered, among other things, to attend a 52-
week batterer intervention program; parenting education and
individual counseling to address case issues; and submit to a
psychiatric evaluation. The court set February 7, 2023 for the
section 366.21, subdivision (e) six-month status review hearing,

3
and August 7, 2023 for the section 366.21, subdivision (f) 12-
month hearing.
At the November 17, 2022 detention hearing for A.K.G., the
bailiff admonished father to be quiet or he would be escorted out,
and the court later told father “to stop interrupting; is that
clear?” The court told father to “[s]top attacking the social
workers and start getting your programming done,” and “I’m not
going to tell you again. I’m not going to sit here and argue with
you.”
At the February 7, 2023 adjudication hearing for A.K.G.,
when the court sustained the allegation concerning father’s
“erratic behaviors, aggression, and explosive anger,” the court
observed that father “has explosive anger while not making
progress—or much progress towards eliminating that.” The court
again ordered the 52-week domestic violence group for
perpetrators, parenting education, individual counseling, and
psychological assessment (including to address father’s anger
management problems). The court set A.K.G.’s six-month status
review hearing on August 7, 2023. The court warned both
parents that “[y]ou must be in full compliance with your case
plan over the next six months to continue to receive services.”
Concerning M.G., the court observed that father had not
complied with the court’s previous orders about not going near
the mother or the home and continued: “Nor has he participated
in programs to realize how his behavior is—puts his child at risk
of physical and emotional harm.” Father did not comply with the
requirement not to visit when mother was there, and two visits in
November 2022 “had to be canceled because of his erratic
behavior.” On an October 2022 visit, father “became very erratic
when instructed to comply with court orders” and used profanity

4
with the social worker while walking out of the room. The court
found father was “in minimal compliance” with his case plan, and
warned both parents that “this is your last six-month period of
time for which to comply with the court’s orders in order to regain
custody.”
Six weeks later, on March 22, 2023, father was arrested for
robbery and remained incarcerated at the time of the August 7,
2023 hearing. During this time, he called the social worker
several times. In May 2023, he told the social worker he would
contact her after a scheduled June 1 hearing. He “stated that he
was unable to continue any counseling programs that were Court
ordered while in jail as he was considered ‘high level’ thus had no
access to attend programs.” He called again on June 20, 2023,
and said he was given a plea deal of 180 days jail time, with a
hearing set for July 27, 2023.
The Department’s status review report for both children
was due on July 25, 2023. On that day, the Department filed a
“last minute information,” requesting a continuance for receipt of
its reports to August 2, 2023, for the August 7 hearings. The
court granted the request. The notices that had been mailed to
father on July 24, 2023, stated the Department’s
recommendation was for continued family reunification.
On July 31, 2023, father called the social worker from jail
to say he had been convicted of receiving stolen property and
would be released on probation on September 14, 2023; he was
advised in criminal court that he needed to complete
16 parenting classes and 27 domestic violence classes; and he
would contact the social worker as soon as he was released.
The Department filed its status review report on August 3,
2023. The report acknowledged that notices to father were sent

5
with a recommendation of continued family reunification;
“however upon further review of the father’s compliance, change
in behavior and the timeframe he’s had to make the changes, the
recommendation has changed to terminate Reunification.”
Among other points, the Department’s report stated that,
as previously reported on February 7, 2023, father had only
attended two classes of the domestic violence program and then
was terminated. This was based on a January 4, 2023 progress
report from the provider, Single Parents of Power, which stated
that father had completed two sessions and “needs to enroll
again.” The provider also reported that father had participated
in 16 parenting classes and was “very consistent in attending”
those and “very concerned with reunifying with his children.”
The Department’s report concluded that father had not
made substantial progress and, although he was currently
incarcerated, “he had about 8 months before then . . . to make
progress” but had minimal attendance and did not finish any
program, and by his own admission could not attend any program
“given that he is in a section in jail where that is not an option.”
At the August 7, 2023 hearing, father’s counsel requested a
continuance. Counsel argued that the Department made no
effort to provide services to father while he was incarcerated, so
there were “no reasonable efforts on the part of the Department
and, therefore, my client is entitled to an additional six months of
services as the Department was ordered to provide services to an
incarcerated parent.” The court responded by stating its
understanding that father “was in some kind of high security
facility and no services were available. So how is it unreasonable
if they cannot provide services when they’re not available?”
Counsel replied that he (counsel) did not have “definitive proof

6
that is correct.” The Department argued that “you can’t just land
yourself in jail after [family reunification] services are already
ordered and then say, well, now I’m in jail and you’re not
providing me reasonable services because of, you know, what I’m
not able to get in jail.”
The court then asked father’s counsel if there was “any
other evidence of father trying to maintain contact with the
children since he’s been incarcerated,” and counsel replied that
“I have been unable to reach father since I learned of his
incarceration, and I cannot respond to that.” Counsel wanted “to
set the matter for a contested hearing in order to appropriately
prepare on that issue.” The court observed that “that’s what
I thought we were about here was the contest.” When asked if
there was anything else he wanted to say on father’s behalf,
counsel replied that “it is very difficult to set up a telephone—
confidential telephone interview with an individual in custody in
a short period of time, and I was unable to do so. And on that
basis, I’m requesting a continuance.”
The court stated: “I appreciate the difficulty, but under the
circumstances here, I’m not going to put this over any more time.
We need to move on. Father can certainly have visits arranged
upon his release. . . . But these are very young children, and we
need to move on to determine whether or not mother can reunify
or we need to go on to permanency with the current caretakers.”
The court continued by noting that “we have Title XX’s,”
and the court’s practice was “to order those for the contest which
was set for today.” (“Title XX’s” are “delivered service log[s]” of
all contacts, services and visits by the Department. The log for
February 7, 2023 to August 4, 2023, was electronically filed by
the Department on August 4, 2023.) The court stated the log

7
“would demonstrate from the entry on 2-14-23, father’s inability
or inaction in maintaining face-to-face contact with the children.
That was before his incarceration in March, which does have to
be considered by this court as the father’s conduct to put him in a
place where he can’t continue his services. Which, by the way,
were not—from my reading of the report, were not going very
well before he was incarcerated, claiming he couldn’t visit or
attend services because of his work schedule.”
The court stated father “could have maintained contact”
and “could have asked the social workers to allow him to have
telephone calls, cards, letters, things of that nature” after he was
incarcerated, but “none of that was done by him. And if they
couldn’t reasonably service him because of his security status,
they can’t be said to have not reasonably serviced the case. [¶]
It’s father’s conduct that got him into a situation where services
were not able to be provided. And he didn’t do anything while
incarcerated to try and maintain contact with the children.” The
court found “by clear and convincing evidence father is not in
substantial compliance,” there was “not a substantial probability
of return of the children,” and the Department was no longer
obligated to extend services for him.
Father filed a timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
Father argues the juvenile court abused its discretion in
denying his request for a continuance; the defect in notice of the
August 7, 2023 review hearings was not harmless; and father
was entitled to an additional six months of reunification services.
We reject each of these contentions.
The relevant principles are these. Under section 366.21,
the Department must file its status review report at least

8
10 calendar days before the hearing, including its
recommendation for disposition. (Id., subd. (c).) But “ ‘[i]f the
outcome of a proceeding has not been affected, denial of a right to
notice and a hearing may be deemed harmless and reversal is not
required.’ ” (In re A.D. (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 1319, 1327 (A.D.),
quoting In re James F. (2008) 42 Cal.4th 901, 918; A.D., at
p. 1325 [“a failure to give notice in dependency proceedings is
subject to a harmless error analysis”; the appealing party must
show “a more favorable result was likely absent the error”].)
Similarly, we review the juvenile court’s denial of a
continuance for abuse of discretion, and discretion is abused
“ ‘ “when a decision is arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd
and results in a manifest miscarriage of justice.” ’ ” (In re D.N.
(2020) 56 Cal.App.5th 741, 756 (D.N.).) The court may grant a
continuance of a review hearing beyond the time limit, but not if
the continuance is “contrary to the interest of the minor” and
“only upon a showing of good cause.” (§ 352, subd. (a)(1) & (2).)
Here, father claims prejudicial error due to the court
denying a continuance of the review hearings under
circumstances where the Department filed its report four rather
than 10 days before the hearing and, in the report, changed its
recommendation from continued reunification services to
termination of services, and where counsel could not reach father
in custody to discuss the report with him in advance of the
hearing. Father contends that as a result of the untimely notice,
counsel did not have a reasonable opportunity to interview him
“about the facts alleged in the reports, identify discrepancies . . .
based on statements provided by [father], identify and discuss
evidence omitted from the reports, obtain evidence excluded from
the reports, discuss [father’s] desire to testify, subpoena

9
witnesses, prepare direct and cross-examination, and gather any
other information to challenge the Department’s
recommendation.”
Father fails to explain how any of the items he lists
“impacted the outcome of the hearings.” He simply claims that
the children’s interest in the prompt resolution of their cases
“would not have been impacted by a brief continuance.” Whether
or not that is so is irrelevant because that is not the standard.
The question is whether father has shown he would have
obtained a more favorable result if the continuance had been
granted. He asserts “he would have had an opportunity to relay
helpful information to his counsel, and there is a reasonable
probability that the court would have granted Father an
additional six months of reunification services.” But he does not
identify any “helpful information” he would have provided if the
court had granted a continuance.
Father asserts his counsel did not have “definitive proof”
that father could not continue his court-ordered programs while
in jail because of his “high security” status, but that does not
demonstrate the juvenile court abused its discretion; there was
substantial evidence supporting that conclusion. Then he asserts
that if he were in a “high security” status because of his
cooperation with law enforcement, “this would have been a
favorable extenuating circumstance,” but that is just another “if”
and again does not demonstrate an abuse of discretion. Then
father complains the Department “failed to report on any contact
the Father had with the children while he was in custody,” and if
the report had been timely, he could have conferred with counsel
“and informed the court accordingly about Father’s efforts to
maintain contact with his children.”

10
Notably, father does not identify any such contact with the
children, or any efforts to contact them except one: the
Department’s “delivered service log” for April 19, 2023, reports
the social worker visited father in custody that day and father
told him he would like to see his children “if it is possible”; the
social worker told him “he would look into it with the jail facility,
as he [the social worker] does not know if they allow visits and
who would monitor.” Father complains there is “no indication in
the reports than any social worker followed up with Father’s
request.” Again, this does not establish the likelihood of a
different result if counsel had been able to discuss the point with
father; indeed, it is fair to infer that a facility that would not
allow participation in family reunification services would likewise
not arrange for monitored visitation with a then-one-and-a-half-
year-old toddler and an eight-month-old baby.
In short, father has not established that “a more favorable
result was likely” absent the Department’s failure to give timely
notice of its report and recommendation (A.D., supra,
196 Cal.App.4th at p. 1325), nor that the denial of a continuance
“ ‘ “result[ed] in a manifest miscarriage of justice” ’ ” (D.N., supra,
56 Cal.App.5th at p. 756).
Taking another tack, father contends substantial evidence
does not support a finding that reasonable services were provided
to him (In re K.C. (2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 323, 329), and therefore
he was entitled to an additional six months of services. (The
court found the Department “has complied with the case plan by
making reasonable efforts to return the child to a safe
home . . . .”) Father says he is entitled to more services because
the Department “consistently failed to facilitate a psychiatric
evaluation for Father”; “failed to facilitate visits or contact

11
between Father and his children while Father was in custody”;
and “failed to connect Father to any services prior to or during his
incarceration.”
The last two claims are patently erroneous. The record
supports the conclusion that services and visits did not occur
because of father’s felonious conduct, not due to any failure by
the Department. The claim that the Department did not connect
father to services before his incarceration is contradicted by the
evidence, for example, that he enrolled in a 52-week domestic
violence offenders’ program and then attended only twice.
We likewise reject father’s claim he should receive six more
months of services because he “never had the opportunity to
participate in and receive the benefits of a mental health
evaluation.” While the court ordered a “[p]sychological
assessment/730” for father on February 7, 2023 (as well similar
orders six months earlier at M.G.’s disposition hearing and two
and a half months earlier at A.K.G.’s detention hearing),1 father’s
own recounting points out that “there may have been challenges
to obtaining a psychiatric evaluation.” Indeed, the court observed
when addressing the mother on the same topic that “the
[Evidence Code, section] 730 evaluators are all very good, but
they have a huge backlog,” and the court “can’t guarantee you

1 These were orders that father “is to submit to a psychiatric
evaluation” (Aug. 8, 2022), and that the Department is “to give
[father] referrals and to assist the parents in getting into a
[Department]-approved assessment for mental health issues”
(Nov. 17, 2022). Notably, when the court ordered father’s mental
health assessment in November 2022, father interrupted the
court twice, said “I’m done,” and had to be admonished by the
bailiff.

12
that they’ll be done and ready with your evaluation,
730 evaluation” within the ensuing six months.
In short, we cannot find a lack of reasonable efforts by the
Department, particularly in light of father’s “minimal
compliance” during his first six months of services and his
incarceration without access to services during most of the second
six months.
Next, father contends the record does not support the
finding that he did not substantially comply with his case plan.
The record we have recited shows otherwise. Father glosses over
the fact that he essentially ignored the required 52-week
domestic violence perpetrator program, despite the sustained
allegations that brought on these dependency proceedings: his
history of engaging in domestic violence, including in the child’s
presence, and knowing violation of court orders by engaging in a
violent physical altercation and abducting M.G. This alone
constitutes substantial evidence he was not in substantial
compliance with his case plan.
Finally, father contends the juvenile court applied the
wrong legal standard for A.K.G.’s six-month review hearing and
that the error was not harmless. (M.V. v. Superior Court (2008)
167 Cal.App.4th 166, 180 (M.V.) [§ 366.21, “subdivision (e) asks
whether there is a substantial probability the child may be
reunited with the parent by the 12-month review;
subdivision (g)(1) asks whether there is a substantial probability
the child will be reunited with the parent by the 18-month
review”].) At the hearing, the court found “that there’s not a
substantial probability of return of the children.”
To support his contention, father cites the favorable
comments in Department reports (“[m]other and father are

13
currently participating in most court[-]ordered classes” and “are
able to apply the skills learned from parenting classes” during
visits), but omits pertinent items on the very same page of the
same report: “Father . . . continues to display very erratic
behavior and mood changes while interacting with [the
Department’s] staff. Father continues to display aggression.
Father has yet to identify/address any of the court orders. The
father is not yet enrolled in [a] domestic violence program. . . .
Father was recently arrested on 9/16/22 with battery on person.
This conduct is not safe for children.” But whether or not the
court applied the correct standard for a six-month review, father
was required to show a reasonable probability he “could have
obtained a more favorable result” had the court applied the
correct standard. (M.V., supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 183.) He
has not done so.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders terminating reunification
services are affirmed.

GRIMES, Acting P. J.

WE CONCUR:

WILEY, J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

14

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.