CourtListener 9986885•In re Aurora C. CA2/7
Texto completo
Filed 6/28/24 In re Aurora C. CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
In re AURORA C., a Person Coming B326310
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 19CCJP00167A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND
FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
HECTOR O.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Tara Newman, Judge. Conditionally
affirmed and remanded with directions.
Emery El Habiby, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Stephen Watson, Senior Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________
INTRODUCTION
Presumed father Hector O. appeals from the juvenile
court’s order denying his request at the Welfare and Institutions
Code section 366.3 permanency plan review hearing that minor
Aurora C. be returned to his custody.1 We conclude the juvenile
court did not abuse its discretion by denying Hector’s request
while continuing family reunification services and conjoint
counseling for him and Aurora. Hector also contends the Los
Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(Department) failed to comply with the inquiry requirements of
the Indian Child Welfare Act (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) (ICWA)
and related California law. The Department concedes the issue.
Therefore, we conditionally affirm the juvenile court’s order and
remand for full compliance with ICWA’s inquiry and notice
provisions.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Minor Aurora (born 2012) is the daughter of Jacqueline C.,
and has two presumed fathers: (1) her biological father Jonathan
S., and (2) appellant Hector O., the biological father of Aurora’s
1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare
and Institutions Code.
2
half-sisters I.O. (born 2013), L.C. (born 2018), and infant Mina
(not a subject of the underlying proceedings). Hector testified he
considered Aurora his daughter, and she and Jacqueline began
living with him in 2012.
A. The November 2018 Referral and January 2019 Dependency
Petition
In November 2018, the Department received a referral
alleging general neglect of L.C. and risk of harm to Aurora and
I.O. The referral stated Jacqueline had a positive toxicology
screen for marijuana and methamphetamine. L.C. was born at
home, and Jacqueline had no prenatal care. Jacqueline reported
Hector had become very controlling two years earlier and stated
she had ended her relationship with him. On January 2, 2019,
the juvenile court authorized a removal order for Aurora and her
half-sisters.2
On January 9, 2019, the Department filed a dependency
petition on behalf of Aurora, I.O. and L.C., alleging under
section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b)(1), that Jacqueline and
Hector had a history of violent altercations in the presence of the
children, and Jacqueline failed to protect the children from harm.
The petition also alleged under subdivision (b)(1), that L.C. was
born with a positive toxicology screen for amphetamines and
THC, Jacqueline had a history of drug use, Hector had a history
of substance abuse and was a current abuser of marijuana, and
2 Before having children with Jonathan and Hector,
Jacqueline was involved in another dependency proceeding that
resulted in her parental rights being terminated as to her son
Thomas C. (born 2006) in 2010.
3
Aurora’s biological father Jonathan had a criminal history that
rendered him incapable of caring for Aurora.
On January 10, 2019, the juvenile court detained the three
children from the parents. The court found Jonathan was
Aurora’s presumed father and Hector was I.O.’s and L.C.’s
presumed father. The court ordered monitored visits for Hector,
separate from Jacqueline. Jacqueline and Jonathan denied
Indian ancestry and the court found no reason to know Aurora
was an Indian child.
B. The Jurisdiction and Disposition Report and Hearings
In January 2019, Hector visited every Saturday for two
hours. Hector was on time, attentive, interacted well with the
foster mother and the children, and no concerns regarding the
visits were noted. The children appeared happy to see Hector,
who also contacted the children daily. In February 2019, Aurora
denied feeling afraid of Jacqueline or Hector. The same month
Hector enrolled in Project Fatherhood and completed six sessions.
On March 12, 2019, the juvenile court sustained the
petition as to Hector, Jonathan, and Jacqueline under counts
(b)-1, (b)-2, (b)-3, (b)-4, and (b)-5. The disposition was continued
for the family reunification services bypass recommendation and
paternity hearing. Hector thereafter consistently visited the
children every Saturday and was on time. Hector interacted well
with the children, and the children appeared happy during visits.
Hector dedicated the first hour to the older children, Aurora and
I.O., and the last hour to the baby, L.C. He did not appear to be
under the influence of drugs or alcohol. The foster mother
reported no concerns regarding the visits.
4
In April 2019, the court found Hector was Aurora’s second
presumed father and ordered all three children removed from the
parents, over Hector’s objection, with family reunification
services for Hector as to all three children and Jonathan as to
Aurora. Hector agreed to a case plan that included domestic
violence classes and random drug testing. Jacqueline was denied
reunification services. The court ordered monitored visits for
Hector a minimum of three times a week for three hours each
visit.
C. Review Hearings and Section 361.3 Placement Proceedings
As detailed below, Hector generally complied with his case
plan and maintained consistent visitation with his daughters, but
the juvenile court declined to place Aurora with him after she
expressed unwillingness to be reunited with Hector.
1. Six-month review hearing
At the section 366.21, subdivision (e), six-month review
hearing in November 2019, the juvenile court found Hector’s case
plan progress was substantial and continued reunification
services. Hector regularly visited the three children for one and a
half hours on Saturdays. He never appeared under the influence
of drugs or alcohol. I.O. and Aurora reported they enjoyed the
visits. Counsel for Jonathan asked the court to order that
Jonathan’s mother Patricia S. (Aurora’s biological paternal
grandmother) be evaluated for a potential relative placement as
to Aurora. Counsel further requested a section 361.3 hearing
because the Department had been resistant to removing Aurora
5
from Hector, even though Jonathan had reunification services.3
Aurora’s counsel requested a hearing before moving the children
because Aurora was closely bonded with her siblings and wanted
to stay with them. Hector requested a 361.3 hearing also be
conducted for his mother Vilma T. a/k/a/ Maria T. for all three
children, so the siblings could stay together. The court ordered
the Department to assess Patricia and Vilma for placement and
set the matter for a contested section 361.3 hearing.
2. The section 361.3 hearing and the section 366.21
12-month review hearing
In December 2019, the juvenile court initiated the
section 361.3 hearing. The court ordered Patricia to have
unmonitored visits and weekend overnight visits with Aurora
and further ordered the Department to facilitate Patricia
spending time with Aurora.4 In January 2020, the court
continued the section 361.3 hearing and ordered the Department
to continue to assess relatives for placement.
In March 2020, Hector remained in full compliance with his
visits and did not miss any visits. As before, he did not appear
3 Section 361.3, in relevant part, states as follows: “In any
case in which a child is removed from the physical custody of his
or her parents pursuant to Section 361, preferential consideration
shall be given to a request by a relative of the child for placement
of the child with the relative.”
4 The juvenile court also ordered the Department to assess
maternal grandmother Aida for placement. Aida filed a
section 388 petition seeking custody of Aurora. Aida
subsequently passed away, and the court denied her section 388
petition as moot.
6
under the influence of alcohol or drugs, and I.O. and Aurora
enjoyed the visits. But Hector was in minimal compliance with
his case plan and tested positive for marijuana once during this
reporting period.
On March 10, 2020, the court continued the section 366.21,
subdivision (f), 12-month review hearing as to Hector and
terminated reunification services for Jonathan. The court
continued the scheduled section 361.3 hearing. In May 2020, the
court again continued the 12-month review hearing and
section 361.3 hearing.
Hector had no monitored visits with the children between
April and September 2020 because the foster mother had
concerns regarding COVID-19. But Hector had monitored phone
and video calls with the children.
On September 24, 2020, the court held the section 361.3
hearing as to Patricia for Aurora and Vilma for all minors. The
children’s counsel and Hector’s counsel objected to the minors
being placed separately. The court continued the 12-month
review hearing and ordered unmonitored visits in a neutral
setting for Hector, with Department discretion to liberalize the
visits. The court ordered the Department to: follow up with a
visitation schedule for Hector and Jacqueline within two weeks
and ensure the court’s orders for in-person visits for the parents
were being followed; follow up with Hector to address issues
raised in Vilma’s assessment (as explained below); and assess the
appropriateness of a section 211 housing assistance referral for
Hector so that he could begin overnight visits.5
5 Section 211, subdivision (b), provides: “Notwithstanding
any other law, a person under the age of 16 years shall not be
7
A Department social worker subsequently instructed
Hector that Jacqueline was not to be present during his visits.
She warned Hector that if his contact with the children was
negative or if he allowed Jacqueline to have access to the children
during visits, his unmonitored visits would be revoked.
Hector had two unmonitored visits in October 2020, and
video calls with the children at least two to three times a week.
In November 2020, the Department reported Hector continued to
have stable housing and employment and complied with court-
ordered services.
On November 4, 2020, the court continued the section 361.3
hearing and the 12-month review hearing. The court ordered the
Department to make unannounced home visits and follow up on
the section 211 referral and process as to Hector. The court
ordered Hector to have overnight visits once he had appropriate
housing and ordered Aurora to continue having visits with her
grandparents (i.e., Patricia and her husband).
On November 5, 2020, the court found Hector was in
substantial compliance with his case plan, referred him to the
section 211 housing office, and ordered the Department had
discretion to send Aurora and her half-sisters on an extended
visit with Hector after he secured appropriate housing.
3. Eighteen-month review hearing and section 361.3
hearing placing Aurora with Patricia
As of February 2021, Hector had had no visits with the
children since the November 2020 hearing. Although the
housed in any facility under the jurisdiction of the Department of
Corrections and Rehabilitation.”
8
Department instructed him how important in-person visits were
to properly assess his readiness to reunify with the children, the
foster mother remained concerned about COVID-19 and Hector
tested positive for COVID-19 in December 2020 so she had not
allowed visits. He still had video sessions with the children at
least twice a week.
Because Hector had completed no additional in-person
visits, the Department was unable to assess his interactions with
the children or to conduct unannounced home visits. The
Department also expressed concern that Hector was residing in
Vilma’s home. The Department had recommended the court deny
placement of the children with Vilma because of her previous
involvement with the Department, where she denied knowledge
of sexual abuse by the paternal grandfather occurring in her
home over a period of years, including new allegations in 2017
involving Hector’s sister and her minor children. Hector was also
named in the sustained petition as a perpetrator of sexual abuse
against his sister.
In February 2021, the juvenile court held the section 361.3
hearing as to Patricia and ordered Aurora placed with her. The
court ordered the Department to ensure Aurora had frequent
sibling visits and to follow up with Patricia to work out a
schedule for Hector’s visits. It continued the 18-month review
hearing and ordered the Department to work with Hector to
resolve his housing status to facilitate overnight visits.
In April 2021, the Department reported Hector had no
visits since February due to Patricia’s COVID-19 concerns and
her surgery in March. But Hector maintained consistent phone
sessions with the children at least three times a week. Hector
then resumed in-person visits with Aurora and her sisters every
9
Saturday. Aurora called Hector “dad” and appeared to enjoy the
visits. Hector and Aurora appeared to have a strong bond.
Aurora stated she wanted to have overnight visits with Hector
and “sleepovers” with her sisters. But Patricia opposed such
visits due to Hector’s alleged history of sexual abuse. The
Department social worker told Patricia that Aurora must be
allowed to participate in overnight visits if Aurora so preferred.
The court continued the 18-month review hearing to follow up on
Hector’s housing needs. The court ordered the Department to
ensure in-person unmonitored visits between Aurora and Hector
were occurring. The Department was ordered to assist Hector
with section 211 housing, with discretion for the Department to
release the children to Hector if barriers to return were resolved.
In May 2021, Hector resumed unmonitored visits with I.O.
and L.C. Hector had consistent phone sessions with the children
at least once a week. Patricia reported she was unsure Aurora
wanted to attend in-person visits. Aurora told the social worker
she did not want to attend visits because Hector was not her
“‘dad.’” Aurora said she wanted to see her sisters but not Hector.
Aurora denied being coerced by Patricia to say so, and stated she
did not want to see Hector because he did not call her as often as
Jonathan did. She denied being afraid of Hector. The social
worker reminded Patricia that Hector’s visits were court-ordered,
but Patricia stated she could not force Aurora to attend. The
social worker reminded Patricia not to coerce Aurora into not
participating in family visits and not to speak negatively about
Hector to Aurora.
On June 17, 2021, the juvenile court held the 18-month
review hearing, found Hector’s case plan progress was
substantial, and continued reunification services for Hector. It
10
set a 24-month review hearing under section 366.25. The court
ordered the Department to: ensure its section 211 housing order
remained in effect; work with Hector to resolve any barriers for
releasing the children to him; facilitate Hector’s visits to include
overnight visits; and ensure in-person visits for Hector. The
court ordered the Department to arrange a child and family team
meeting regarding Hector’s housing, ordered no one to discourage
visits for Hector, and ordered Patricia not to interfere with court
orders. The court ordered the Department to address any issues
with visits, and meet with Patricia to address expectations for
facilitating visits between Hector and Aurora.
In July 2021, Hector began overnight weekend visits with
I.O. and L.C., which were positive.
4. At the 24-month review hearing, Hector regains
custody of Aurora’s two half-sisters but not Aurora
In September 2021, the juvenile court continued the
24-month subsequent review hearing at Hector’s request. The
court ordered the Department to initiate visits between Aurora
and her sisters and prepare a written visitation schedule. Hector
was to be included so his monitored visits with Aurora could take
place during the sibling visits. In November 2021, the juvenile
court found Hector was approved for housing through the PATH
program and twice continued the 24-month review hearing. The
court ordered the Department to assess Hector’s home, and
ordered Aurora and her half-sisters to be placed on an extended
visit with Hector pending the next hearing date. The court
ordered the Department to make best efforts to use the extended
visit to initiate the transition for Aurora from Patricia’s home to
Hector’s home.
11
Aurora agreed to visit but expressed that she did not wish
to participate in an extended visit with Hector and her sisters.
The Department strongly advised Patricia to follow through with
Aurora’s mental health assessment and not to speak ill about
Hector in Aurora’s presence. At an unannounced visit in
November 2021, Hector’s home was deemed to be appropriate for
the children and well-supplied, the children were properly
dressed for the weather, and they reported eating three meals a
day and brushing their teeth daily. Hector was late and had
alcohol on his breath on one occasion when picking up the
children; he stated he had one beer and agreed to an on-demand
drug test, which was negative. I.O. and L.C. disclosed Hector
spanked L.C. with an open hand more than once as discipline for
not following directions; Hector denied doing so.6
On December 3, 2021, the juvenile court held the 24-month
review hearing. Aurora testified that she called both Hector and
Jonathan “dad,” she could not remember the last time she saw
Jonathan, and she wanted to keep living with Patricia “because
she’s kind” and “doesn’t . . . make me feel nervous.” She further
testified she only wanted to visit with her sisters and Hector, but
not live with them, and was scared she might say the wrong
thing at the house and make her sisters mad. Aurora used to
have nightmares but they stopped when she came to her
grandmother’s house. Aurora claimed she never lived with
Hector.
6 On November 16, 2021, the juvenile court admitted
evidence for the 24-month review hearing but continued the
hearing so that Aurora could be present in person.
12
The court found return of Aurora to Hector would create a
substantial risk of detriment to Aurora, necessitating the current
placement with Patricia. The court terminated reunification
services for the parents, ordered permanent placement services
for Aurora, and set a hearing under section 366.26. The court
ordered that Hector would continue having unmonitored and
overnight visits with Aurora and that sibling visits were to
continue.
D. The Court Grants Section 388 Petitions, Reinstating
Hector’s Family Reunification Services
Subsequently, Hector’s and Aurora’s counsel each filed
section 388 petitions for modification of prior orders. Aurora’s
counsel requested the court take the section 366.26 hearing off
calendar and grant Hector reunification services in the form of
conjoint counseling with Aurora because Aurora enjoyed visits
with Hector and her sisters and did not want to foreclose the
possibility of reunifying with Hector. Hector requested an order
returning Aurora to his custody or alternatively to reinstate
reunification services because Aurora was bonded with Hector
and with her half-sisters.
In May 2022, Hector reported Aurora visited every other
weekend from Friday to Sunday. During these visits, she
expressed to Hector that she did not want to return to Patricia’s
home. Aurora reported to the social worker that she wanted to
continue overnight visits with Hector and her sisters but did not
want to reunify. Hector stated Patricia did not allow Aurora to
speak with him and reprimanded Aurora for calling him
“‘father.’” Hector did not believe it was true that Aurora did not
want to live with him. Hector expressed concern that he would
13
not be allowed in Aurora’s life if the Department was not
involved, and the Department acknowledged that Patricia made
it difficult for Aurora to visit Hector and her sisters. Patricia
reported that visits were going well between Hector and Aurora.
She stated it was Aurora’s decision if she wanted to live with
Hector, but did not think it would be safe due to Hector’s history
of alleged sexual abuse.
At the hearing on the section 388 motions on May 18, 2022,
Hector argued that Aurora’s sisters were thriving under his sole
physical and legal custody, he was fully case-plan compliant,
Hector and Aurora were visiting consistently, including overnight
visits, and it was in Aurora’s best interests to develop stronger
bonds with her two sisters and Hector, rather than staying in a
“toxic placement” where Patricia’s interference with her visits
and relationships was ongoing.
The court granted Hector’s section 388 petition in part by
reinstating Hector’s reunification services. The court reasoned
this was in Aurora’s best interest because circumstances had
changed, and Aurora was comfortable with Hector and wanted to
reunify. The court ordered the Department to: provide
reunification services to Aurora and Hector; provide individual
counseling and conjoint counseling for Hector and Aurora;
address any issues with Patricia; and create and implement a
transition plan for Aurora’s potential placement with Hector.
The Department had discretion to allow extended visits for
Hector with Aurora. The court also granted Aurora’s section 388
petition, granted reunification services to Hector, and took the
section 366.26 hearing off calendar.
14
E. The Court Denies Hector Custody but Orders Continued
Reunification Services at the Section 366.3 Hearing
In June and July 2022, Aurora had weekend visits with
Hector and her sisters, and she appeared to have a strong bond
with Hector. Her relationship with her grandparents in her
placement remained positive. Hector consistently stated his
interest in regaining custody of Aurora. He believed Aurora was
coached by Patricia to not want to visit with him and that Aurora
needed mental health services. Aurora indicated she wanted to
remain with Hector while visiting him, but she would change her
mind when at Patricia’s home. Hector stated again that Patricia
reprimanded Aurora for calling him “‘father.’”
In August 2022, Aurora reported she saw Jacqueline
during her last visit with Hector. Aurora stated she was nervous
to see or talk to Hector because Aurora had disclosed to the
Department that Hector and Jacqueline had a new baby, Mina.
Aurora then refused to resume overnight visits and only wanted
to talk with her sisters on the phone because Hector was “‘not
real family.’” Aurora further stated she would only visit at a park
with her sisters going forward. Aurora denied being coached by
Patricia to stop referring to Hector as her father. Patricia
resisted scheduling phone calls in lieu of visits; the social worker
reminded Patricia the calls were court ordered.
Aurora began receiving weekly individual therapy in
September 2022, and collateral therapy sessions with Patricia.
On several occasions, the therapist had to redirect Patricia not to
involve herself in Aurora’s private individual sessions. Aurora
was uncomfortable and would not participate as usual when
Patricia was present in her individual sessions.
15
In October 2022, Aurora had a visit with Hector and her
sisters at a park. Before the visit, she expressed feeling nervous
because she did not know how Hector was going to react because
Aurora had disclosed news of her new baby sister to the
Department. During the visit, Aurora appeared more at ease.
In November 2022, the Department reported Aurora
continued to do well in her placement, and had a strong bond
with both grandparents. Her grandparents ensured Aurora
attended all necessary medical, dental, and psychological
appointments, and Aurora felt safe and loved by them. Aurora
consistently stated she wanted to be adopted by her
grandparents, and worried when court hearings approached
because she did not know what the judge would decide. Patricia
was willing to transport Aurora to a park for visits to preserve
Aurora’s relationship with her sisters.
Hector remained open to visitation with Aurora and
emphasized the importance of her maintaining a relationship
with her younger sisters despite tensions between him and
Patricia. Aurora’s therapist reported Aurora expressed sadness
and anxiety when she was not able to visit her sisters. Aurora
reported she wanted to permanently reside with her
grandparents. Aurora said she would feel sad and angry if asked
to move because it was not her choice.
Hector believed Patricia reprimanded Aurora for wanting a
relationship with him and stated Patricia refused his efforts to
share custody. Aurora denied being reprimanded and stated she
did not feel comfortable talking with Hector. Patricia stated
Hector would engage Aurora in conversation after she said she
did not want to talk.
16
In November 2022, the juvenile court continued the
section 366.3 hearing so the Department could address its
reasons for recommending no reunification services for Hector.
The court observed Hector was more involved in Aurora’s life
than her biological father, Jonathan. It further noted that it did
not understand the basis for the Department’s recommendation
given that Hector had complied with the case plan and the
Department identified no specific safety risk to Aurora. The
court also expressed concern regarding Patricia’s interference
with efforts to reunify Hector and Aurora.
On December 16, 2022, the Department reported Aurora
continued to do well with her grandparents, had been attending
mental health and tutoring services, and was improving her
grades. Aurora continued to state she wished to reside
permanently with her grandparents and said she would feel sad,
angry, and worried if she had to leave them. Aurora refused to
visit or have any communication with Hector and expressed
feeling afraid of him. She said she wanted to remain in contact
and have in-person visits with her sisters.
On January 10, 2023, the juvenile court proceeded with the
permanency planning hearing, at which Aurora, Hector, and
Patricia testified. Aurora, then 10 years old, had been living with
her grandparents for two years and enjoyed living with them.
Aurora described Hector as her “stepfather” and Jonathan as her
“real dad.” She testified she had three sisters who lived with
Hector. Aurora indicated her choice was to live with Patricia
because (1) she felt happy when the grandparents were home,
and they paid for her private school; (2) Patricia cooked
homemade meals; and (3) Patricia would help Aurora with her
homework. She preferred to live with her grandmother instead of
17
Hector and her sisters. Aurora stated she would feel sad if she
had to live with Hector and her sisters because that was not the
choice she wanted to make. Aurora felt very strongly about her
decision.
Aurora denied speaking to Patricia about Hector, whom she
referred to by his first name. Aurora stated she would be sad if
she could not visit her sisters. However, she did not want to
spend the night with her sisters because she was the only person
to help with her grandmother’s food preparation business.
Hector testified he was currently not having visits with
Aurora, and he last saw her before Thanksgiving. Hector did not
have a written visitation schedule and the social worker had
trouble figuring out what days Patricia would allow a visit.
Patricia would say she would get back to the social worker but
never did. Hector was also to have phone calls with Aurora, and
during the last two phone calls, Patricia reprimanded Aurora for
speaking with Hector. He only spoke briefly to Aurora during
two phone calls over the past three or four months.
Patricia confirmed Aurora had been living with her since
February 2021, and denied she was preventing court-ordered
visits from occurring. She testified visits had not occurred
because Aurora was unwilling to go and Hector had limited
availability. The social worker would not force Aurora to go to
visits if she was not willing. Hector wanted Aurora to be taken to
his house, and Patricia was not available to drive the lengthy
distance. She conceded the social worker occasionally offered to
drive Aurora to visit with Hector. She denied reprimanding
Aurora for speaking to Hector on the phone or prevented her from
doing so. Patricia did not call Hector to set up visits because she
did not think it was Aurora’s obligation to ask for those visits.
18
Hector requested return of Aurora to his custody, and
alternatively requested a finding of no reasonable services or
visits and to set a review hearing in six months. Aurora’s counsel
requested the court continue the permanency planning review
hearing and order conjoint counseling so Aurora could confront
Hector about any concerns she had about their relationship. The
Department requested the court terminate reunification services
and set a 366.26 hearing. The Department requested the court
not order conjoint therapy, not return Aurora to Hector, and find
that reasonable services were provided.
The juvenile court found no reasonable services were
provided because there had been no conjoint counseling; no
visitation since the granting of Hector’s section 388 petition; and
Patricia interfered during Aurora’s therapy and possibly coached
Aurora against Hector. The court denied Hector’s request that
Aurora be returned to his custody without making findings
specific to the denial, but it granted Hector extended
reunification services for six months and ordered a new
permanent plan of continuation of family reunification services.
The court stated it appreciated Hector’s “support and love of
Aurora” and noted that guardianship rather than adoption might
be more appropriate for Aurora if reunification with Hector was
not going to occur. The court also observed that Patricia had
“provided Aurora with a very positive home environment,” was
“an excellent grandmother,” and that the court understood
Aurora wished to stay there.
The court ordered the Department to ensure conjoint
counseling between Hector and Aurora begin immediately, to
facilitate visits for Hector with Aurora, and to provide a written
visitation schedule to Hector and Jacqueline within five business
19
days, with continuing discretion to the Department to liberalize
Hector’s visits.
On January 11, 2023, Hector timely appealed the juvenile
court’s orders denying his request to have Aurora returned to his
care or custody.
DISCUSSION
A. Standard of Review and Governing Law
“Although section 361.5, subdivision (a), generally limits
family reunification services to a period not exceeding 18 months
after the date a child was originally removed from the physical
custody of the child’s parent, nearly 30 years ago in In re
Marilyn H. (1993) 5 Cal.4th 295, the Supreme Court held a
parent may utilize the section 388 petition procedure to
demonstrate circumstances have changed and additional
reunification services would be in the child’s best interest.” (In re
Malick T. (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1114-1115.) Additionally,
“section 366.3, subdivisions (e) and (f), expressly authorize the
juvenile court at postpermanent plan review hearings to order a
second period of reunification services if it would be in the child’s
best interest to do so.” (Ibid.; see § 366.3, subd. (f) [after a
permanent plan is ordered, “[i]t shall be presumed that continued
care is in the best interests of the child, unless the parent or
parents prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that further
efforts at reunification are the best alternative for the child.”)
If a parent succeeds in obtaining additional reunification
services after a successful 388 petition, review hearings are
conducted pursuant to section 366.3, which governs dependency
jurisdiction after an order for a permanent plan. (See In re
20
Jacob P. (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 819, 829; In re Malick T., supra,
73 Cal.App.5th 1109; see also § 366.3, subds. (d)-(e).) At a
section 366.3 review hearing, the best interest of the child
standard is applied to determine whether return to the parent is
appropriate, rather than the presumption during the initial
reunification period that a child should be returned to a parent
unless there is substantial risk of detriment. (See In re Jacob P.,
at pp. 828-829; § 366.3, subds. (f), (h)(1).) “
We review the denial of a request to return a child to
parental custody at a section 366.3 hearing for an abuse of
discretion. (See In re Jacob P., supra, 157 Cal.App.4th at p. 832.)
We will not disturb a trial court’s discretionary decision on
appeal “‘“‘unless the trial court has exceeded the limits of legal
discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination.’”’” (In re Raymundo B. (1988) 203 Cal.App.3d
1447, 1456.)
B. The Juvenile Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in Denying
Hector’s Request for Return of Aurora to His Custody
Hector argues the trial court erred in denying his request
for custody of Aurora at the section 366.3 hearing because
placement with him was in Aurora’s best interest.7 Hector
argues he is better able to care for Aurora than Patricia, his home
7 The Department argues we should deem Hector’s
arguments “waived” because his contention that the juvenile
court erred is “conclusory” and “lacks cogent legal argument,
relevant analysis, explanation of how the law applies to the case,
or reasoned argument.” We address Hector’s arguments on the
merits because they are not wholly lacking in reasoned
argument.
21
is comfortable, well-equipped, and appropriate for children, with
no risk factors present in his care, and Aurora would have the
chance to reunite with her sisters by living with him. He further
argues that, except for a short period in 2020 during the
COVID-19 pandemic, he had monitored phone and video calls, in
which he had positive in-person visits with Aurora, she enjoyed
the visits, had a strong bond with him, and called him “‘dad.’”
Although Aurora testified that she preferred to live with
Patricia, Hector argues her preference alone does not determine
her best interests. Hector contends Patricia influenced Aurora to
refuse visits with him and to say that he was not her real father.
In Hector’s view this was because Patricia resented that her son
Jonathan, Aurora’s biological father, did not get custody.
Hector also argues he had positive visits with I.O. and L.C.,
including weekend overnights beginning in July 2021. In
November 2021, when I.O. and L.C. were placed with Hector,
Aurora began positive unmonitored visits with Hector and her
sisters, which increased to every other weekend in May 2022.
Aurora enjoyed the visits, became more comfortable with Hector,
and told him she did not want to return to Patricia’s home.
Aurora also told the Department she wanted to continue
overnight visits with Hector and her sisters (although she did not
want to live with them). Hector testified that he did not believe
Aurora did not want to live with him.
Given the juvenile court’s finding that Patricia interfered
with Aurora’s therapy, possibly coached Aurora, and did not
facilitate visits with Hector, Hector argues the court should have
placed Aurora with him to facilitate conjoint counseling and other
family reunification services, without the risk that Aurora’s
22
relationship with him would continue to be negatively affected by
Patricia.
As previously noted, there is no presumption a juvenile
dependent will be returned to a parent at a section 366.3 hearing.
(See In re Jacob P., supra, 157 Cal.App.4th at pp. 828-829;
§ 366.3, subd. (h)(1).) At the time of the January 2023 hearing,
Aurora had been in dependency care for four years and living
with Patricia for two years. Aurora was closely bonded with
Patricia. “To return to a presumption of return this late in the
proceedings would be to ignore that relationship and the benefits
of that placement.” (In re Jacob P., at p. 831.) Further, although
it is generally the case, “a parent’s compliance with the case plan
is not a guarantee the child will be returned to the parent.” (Ibid.
[parental compliance with reunification services is a “separate
question” from whether it is in a child’s best interests to return to
that parent].)
Here, the juvenile court recognized Hector’s strengths as a
parent and made clear it had serious concerns about Patricia’s
interference with Hector’s relationship with Aurora. But the
court also determined Patricia “provided Aurora with a very
positive home environment” for two years, was “an excellent
grandmother,” and the court understood Aurora wished to stay
with her grandparents. Although Hector had no criminal history
and the Department identified no safety risk to Aurora, the
Department expressed concern in February 2021 that Hector
continued to reside with his mother Vilma, who was in denial
about sexual abuse by the paternal grandfather, and that there
was a sustained finding Hector was a perpetrator of sexual abuse
against his sibling.
23
Throughout 2022, the Department reported that while
Aurora enjoyed visits with Hector and her sisters, she
consistently stated she wanted to reside with her grandparents
and did not want to reunify with Hector. By January 2023,
Aurora was again refusing visits with Hector and only wanted
contact with her sisters. Her last visit with Hector was in
November 2022. She reported she felt afraid of him. Aurora
stated she wanted to live with Patricia, felt happy and grateful to
be in her home and would feel angry and sad if asked to move to
Hector’s home. She had a strong bond with her grandparents,
and repeatedly stated she wanted to be adopted by them. Her
grandparents ensured all of Aurora’s medical, dental,
educational, and mental health needs were met, supported her
education, and Patricia stated she could arrange for Aurora to
remain in contact with her sisters through visits.
Under these circumstances, we cannot conclude the
juvenile court abused its discretion when it denied Hector’s
request to return Aurora to his custody, while continuing
reunification services and mandating conjoint counseling. The
juvenile court’s determination was not arbitrary, capricious, or
patently absurd.
C. Conditional Affirmance and Remand for ICWA Compliance
is Necessary
1. ICWA and the duty of inquiry
ICWA and governing federal regulations (25 C.F.R.
§ 23.101 et seq.) set minimum federal standards a state court
must follow before removing Indian children from family and
placing them in foster care or adoptive homes. (See In re Y.W.
(2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 542, 551; accord, In re T.G. (2020)
24
58 Cal.App.5th 275, 287; 25 U.S.C. § 1902.) The statute
“authorizes states to provide ‘a higher standard of protection to
the rights of the parent or Indian custodian of an Indian child
than the rights provided under’ ICWA.” (In re T.G., at p. 288; see
25 U.S.C. § 1921.) ICWA permits tribes to intervene in or, where
appropriate, exercise jurisdiction over a child custody proceeding.
(See 25 U.S.C. § 1911(c); In re Isaiah W. (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1, 8.)
To ensure Indian tribes can exercise their rights in
dependency proceedings, an investigation of a family member’s
belief a child may have Indian ancestry must be undertaken and
notice provided to the relevant tribes. (See § 224.2, subd. (a)
[imposing on the court and child protective services agencies “an
affirmative and continuing duty to inquire whether a child . . . is
or may be an Indian child”].) “The continuing duty to inquire
whether a child is or may be an Indian child ‘can be divided into
three phases: the initial duty to inquire, the duty of further
inquiry, and the duty to provide formal ICWA notice.’” (In re
Y.W., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th at p. 552; accord, In re Antonio R.
(2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 421, 429.)
The duty to inquire “‘begins with initial contact (§ 224.2,
subd. (a)) and obligates the juvenile court and child protective
agencies to ask all relevant involved individuals whether the
child may be an Indian child.’” (In re Rylei S. (2022)
81 Cal.App.5th 309, 316; § 224.2, subds. (a)-(c).) The duty of
inquiry also extends to the juvenile court, which is required to
“ask each participant present in the hearing whether the
participant knows or has reason to know that the child is an
Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (c); see 25 C.F.R. § 23.107(a); In re
Benjamin M. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 735, 742.)
25
The Department’s initial duty of “[i]nquiry includes, but is
not limited to, asking the child, parents, legal guardian, Indian
custodian, extended family members, others who have an interest
in the child, and the party reporting child abuse or neglect,
whether the child is, or may be, an Indian child.” (§ 224.2,
subd. (b); see Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a)(1); In re Y.W.,
supra, 70 Cal.App.5th at pp. 551-552.) ICWA and state law
define “extended family member,” if not separately defined by the
law or custom of the Indian child’s tribe, as “a person who has
reached the age of eighteen and who is the Indian child’s
grandparent, aunt or uncle, brother or sister, brother-in-law or
sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or
stepparent.” (25 U.S.C. § 1903(2); see § 224.1, subd. (c).)
If the juvenile court or the Department “has reason to
believe that an Indian child is involved in a proceeding, but does
not have sufficient information to determine that there is reason
to know that the child is an Indian child” (§ 224.2, subd. (e); Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a)(4); In re Y.W., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th
at p. 552), further inquiry requires interviewing, “as soon as
practicable,” extended family members, contacting the Bureau of
Indian Affairs, and contacting “the tribe or tribes and any other
person that may reasonably be expected to have information
regarding the child’s membership, citizenship status, or
eligibility.” (§ 224.2, subd. (e), (e)(2)(C)); see also
rule 5.481(a)(4).)
If the further inquiry “results in a reason to know the child
is an Indian child, then the formal notice requirements of
section 224.3 apply.” (In re D.S. (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1041,
1052; see 25 U.S.C. § 1912(a); § 224.3, subd. (a) [notice under
ICWA “shall be provided” if the court, social worker, or probation
26
officer “knows or has reason to know . . . that an Indian child is
involved”].)
2. Remand for ICWA compliance is required
Hector argues, the Department concedes, and we agree that
remand is necessary because four paternal extended family
members likely to have meaningful information about Aurora’s
ancestry were not asked about Indian ancestry: paternal
grandmother Patricia; paternal grandfather T.S.; paternal aunt
Wendy S.; and paternal uncle S.S. “In most circumstances, the
information in the possession of extended relatives is likely to be
meaningful in determining whether the child is an Indian child—
regardless of whether the information ultimately shows the child
is or is not an Indian child.” (In re Antonio R., supra,
76 Cal.App.5th at p. 435.) Accordingly, the order is conditionally
affirmed and the matter remanded so that the Department can
comply with its duties under ICWA and interview the four
paternal extended family members regarding whether Aurora
has any Indian ancestry. (See In re Rylei S., supra, at pp. 324-
327; In re Antonio R., supra, at pp. 435-437; In re Y.W., supra,
70 Cal.App.5th at pp. 556-559.)
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s section 366.3 order is conditionally
affirmed. We remand to the juvenile court for full compliance
with the inquiry and notice provisions of ICWA and California
law, including but not limited to all reasonable efforts to
interview paternal grandmother Patricia, paternal grandfather
T.S., paternal aunt Wendy S., and paternal uncle S.S about the
27
possibility of Aurora’s possible Indian ancestry and to submit a
report of its interviews or efforts to conduct interviews to the
juvenile court. If the court finds Aurora is an Indian child, it
shall make all necessary orders to ensure compliance with ICWA
and related California law. If not, the court’s original
section 366.3 order will remain in effect.
MARTINEZ, P. J.
We concur:
SEGAL, J.
FEUER, J.
28
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.