In re S.M. CA2/5

CourtListener 9885714Calctapp26 de jun. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 6/26/24 In re S.M. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re S.M. et al., Persons Coming B332822
Under Juvenile Court Law.
_______________________________ (Los Angeles County Super.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Ct. No. 19CCJP05242AB)
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.M. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Lisa A. Brackelmanns, Commissioner. Affirmed.
Donna P. Chirco, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant C.M.
Suzanna Davidson, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant S.M.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Stephen Watson, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________

C.M. (mother) and S.M. (father) appeal from the juvenile
court’s orders terminating their parental rights over their son
and daughter. They argue the court erred in refusing to apply
the beneficial parent-child relationship exception (Welf. & Inst.
Code, § 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)).1 We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Facts
Mother and father married in 2008, and have two children
together, son (born 2013) and daughter (born 2018). At all
relevant times, son and daughter lived in the home of maternal
grandparents. Mother and father have a history of domestic
violence. For example, in 2008, father and mother got into a fight
in which mother’s leg was broken, requiring surgery. Father
“punches, slaps,” “chokes,” and bites mother, and then threatens
to report her and her family to immigration authorities if she
reports his abuse. Son has autism and receives counseling for
anxiety he has that stems from father’s violence against mother.
On July 29, 2019, father choked mother so badly that she
could not eat for a day because her throat was in so much pain.
On August 3, 2019, father got ahold of mother’s cell phone and
saw subject matter concerning mother and another man that
made father angry. Father choked mother, threw her on the bed,
and punched her back 10-20 times in front of their then 19-

1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.

2
month-old daughter and 6-year-old son. Father’s violence left
mother with bruises on her neck, chest, and back, and scratches
on her forehead and hand. Mother called 911, and father was
arrested. Father and mother were living with maternal
grandparents at the time, but father was in the process of moving
out.
On August 5, 2019, mother got a restraining order to
protect herself, the children, her parents, and her sister from
father (mother was residing with her parents). A three-year
restraining order was issued on September 5, 2019. Father
continuously denied touching mother during the incident on
August 3, 2019, and described himself as “nothing but caring and
loving.”
II. Procedural Background
A. Section 300 petition
On August 15, 2019, the Department of Children and
Family Services (Department) filed a petition asking the juvenile
court to exercise jurisdiction over son and daughter under section
300, subdivisions (a) and (b) based on mother and father’s history
of physical altercations in front of their children.
On August 16, 2019, the juvenile court ordered the children
detained from father and released them to mother’s custody.
Son enrolled in therapy in September 2019, and during
sessions he disclosed he had seen father push mother down the
stairs. Son was diagnosed with ADHD and was prescribed
Adderall.
Mother enrolled in a domestic violence support group in
October 2019.
On January 15, 2020, the juvenile court sustained the
petition based on domestic violence, ordered the children removed

3
from father and placed with mother, and granted father
monitored visitation. The court also ordered reunifications
services for both parents, including individual counseling,
parenting, and domestic violence groups.
In March 2020, father was convicted of misdemeanor
corporal injury to a spouse and was sentenced to 90 days in jail
and three years of probation with conditions.
Mother began attending parenting classes in May 2020.
As of June 2020, father had not enrolled in any of his court
ordered services, and had missed 11 of the 30 scheduled
monitored visits. At the visits father did attend, father was
“affectionate and loving towards his children,” and the children
were “happy and excited to visit with their father.”
As of June 2020, son was improving his skills of coping
with anger and expressing his emotions, and had become more
attentive since taking ADHD medication. Daughter’s vocabulary
was increasing, and she was participating in speech therapy.
Father was hospitalized on July 1, 2020, after his sister
found him unresponsive. The same month, father was arrested
for “corporal injury to a spouse.”2
In August 2020, father was released from jail, and he and
mother stayed together in a hotel in violation of the restraining
order. After this incident, son went from being “very open during
[therapy] sessions” to being “very closed off and guarded.” Son
reported that “mommy will hit me with a belt” if he talks about

2 This information is contained in the Department’s
Application and Declaration in Support of Removal, filed
October 13, 2020. Based on the father’s “rap sheet,” however, it
appears the “arrest” may have been for a violation of probation
involving violations of a restraining order and drug use.

4
father during therapy. He repeated this statement “5-8 times.”
Son stated he “couldn’t tell” the therapist if mother had hit him
recently.
In September 2020, son reported to the Department that
mother hits him and that, when she does, he protects his face and
head with his arms. He stated that mother hit both him and his
then two-year-old sister with a belt.
B. Subsequent petitions under section 342 and 387
On October 2020, the Department filed petitions under
sections 342 and 387, alleging mother physically abused the
children, father abuses methamphetamine and alcohol, and
mother fails to protect the children from father instead allowing
him unlimited access to them.
C. Adjudication of subsequent petitions
In March 2021, the juvenile court sustained the allegations
in the petitions filed under sections 342 and 387, ordered the
children removed from mother’s custody, and granted both
parents monitored visitation (with parents to visit separately) of
six hours per week, and continued reunification services for both
parents.
D. Six- to 12-month review period
Son and daughter continued to reside with maternal
grandparents, who shared their residence with maternal aunt
and uncle. Mother moved into a hotel with father, in spite of the
restraining order.
In September 2021, son and daughter were “thriving and
. . . happy” in the home of maternal grandparents, who expressed
their desire to adopt the children. Father continued to decline
participating in court-ordered services, and was a “no show” to
most of his drug tests. Mother’s visits were “going well” and

5
mother was “loving towards her children.” Father attended most
of his visits, and was “affectionate and loving towards his
children.” The children were “happy and excited” to visit with
father.
At the six-month review hearing on September 29, 2021,
the juvenile court found the parents’ progress towards alleviating
the causes necessitating removal of their children to be
insubstantial and continued reunification services.
In January 2022, maternal family reported that mother
had asked her sister to stay with mother for the weekend
“because [mother] feared being at home alon[e] after an
argument with [father].” Mother and father “were living
together” “in [m]otels and in the community.”
The restraining order “was modified to allow peaceful
contact” between mother and father in February 2022.
In March 2022, son and daughter continued to be “well
taken care of by their maternal grandparents,” who were “very
proactive and involved in addressing the needs of the children.”
The children had “a good bond” with maternal grandparents.
Son’s behavior had improved, and daughter’s speech “improved
significantly.” Mother and father continued to visit their children
consistently, and visits were going well. However, mother was
“on her phone often during the visits.” Father did not attend any
drug testing during this period, nor did he enroll in counseling.
The Department recommended the court terminate reunification
services for both parents.
At the 12-month review hearing in May 2022, the juvenile
court ordered further reunification services for parents and found
it would be detrimental to return the children to mother and
father.

6
E. 18-month review period
In October 2022, the Department reported the children had
a “strong bond” with maternal grandparents and aunt,
“continue[d] to thrive” in their home. Daughter had become potty
trained, started preschool, and begun to speak in full sentences.
Mother and father had only “sporadic” contact with the
Department. Father relied on mother to communicate with the
Department on his behalf, despite the Department explaining
that was not acceptable. Son “appeared to be happy” at home
with maternal grandmother and aunt, but “randomly
mention[ed],” unenthusiastically, that he would like to return
home, which “appears to be a coached statement.” Daughter was
too young to state her needs. Mother’s visitation with the
children was “inconsistent,” and mother did not cook for the
children, sometimes failed to engage with them, and declined to
help them with their homework. Instead, she watched television,
occupied herself with her phone, made demands of maternal
grandmother, and argued with maternal grandmother in the
children’s presence. Maternal grandmother requested the visits
be moved outside her home and with a visitation schedule,
because mother was taking time away from the children's studies
and leaving them “agitated or anxious” from her visits. Maternal
grandmother reported that “father is emotionally unstable[,] and
has [a] mental health history and anger issues that have not been
addressed.”
At the November 2022 18-month review hearing, the
juvenile court found that parents’ progress had been
“unsubstantial,” but nonetheless continued their reunification
services. The court also ordered that parents could attend two of

7
their six monitored visitation hours together. The permanency
planning hearing was scheduled for May 2023.
F. Permanency review period
In November and December 2022, parents had visits with
the children at their home “without . . . requesting authorization”
from the Department.
In December 2022, son expressed that he “does not trust
his father because of the [domestic violence] between the parents
and feels guilty of the removal from his parents.” Son felt
parents were “pressuring him to talk when they talk about
reunifying” during family therapy sessions. Maternal
grandmother reported that parents pick the children up right
when they get home from school before maternal grandmother
has time to prepare them a snack, and then parents fail to feed
the children, who return from the visits still hungry. Children
were “misbehaving at home after their visits” with mother and
father, and were having “mood swings” at school and at home.
Although son reported “lik[ing] his visits with his parents,” he
became anxious and irritable after such visits. Son returned
from visits with his parent “upset,” but refused to state why he
was upset.
Between January and May 2023, the children continued to
thrive in maternal grandparents’ care. Both children reported
being “comfortable living with their grandparents.” Son
“present[s] fears of loud noises, yelling and screaming, helicopters
patrolling at night and nightmares.” Son “continue[d] to struggle
with the trauma of seeing the domestic violence between the
parents,” and “changed his medication to help with [his] fears . . .
of observing [the violence].” “Children do not . . . ask about . . .
their parents when they do not visit.” At times, daughter “fights

8
to talk on the phone, taking up much of the time” on the phone
with mother, and at other times, both children decline to speak
on the phone. Parents showed no “understand[ing] . . . that they
have traumatized their son,” nor did they show that “father has
addressed his mental health or . . . mother’s codependency.” The
Department recommended terminating reunification services.
At the permanency review hearing on June 21, 2023, the
juvenile court found parents’ progress had been “unsubstantial,”
terminated reunification services, and scheduled a permanency
planning hearing for October 2023.
After the June 2023 hearing, “the children expressed relief”
“[o]nce the court terminated the reunification [services],” and felt
more “at ease without anxiety,” knowing “they would remain” in
maternal grandparents’ home. The children sometimes did “not
want to go” to visits with parents, and were “fine not visiting the
parents.” The children did not show a strong attachment to
parents, and saw the visits “as play time.” Daughter identified
maternal aunt “as the mother” and has “a very strong
attachment” with maternal aunt. The children “have limited
contact with the parents.” Mother calls the children, but they “do
not show much interest as they stay busy with their daily
activities.” Sometimes the children “look forward to their visits,”
but other times they “request to go home.”
G. Permanency planning hearing
At the permanency planning hearing on October 12, 2023,
the Department entered into evidence its reports, father’s
declaration, notes from father’s visitation supervised by a family
visitation center, and letters from his service providers describing
his participation. Mother’s counsel argued that the beneficial
parent-child relationship exception applied (§ 366.26, subd.

9
(c)(1)(B)(i)). Father’s counsel made a similar argument. Both the
children’s counsel and the Department asked the court to
terminate parental rights, arguing that neither parent satisfied
any exception to termination. The court found that the parents
had not maintained regular visitation3 and had not established a
bond with the children, and that “any benefit accruing to the
children from their relationship with the parents is outweighed
by the physical and emotional benefit the children will receive”
through permanency. Finding that no exception applied, the
juvenile court terminated parental rights.
Mother and father filed timely notices of appeal.
DISCUSSION
Mother and father each challenge the juvenile court’s
termination of their parental rights on the ground that the court
erred in finding inapplicable the beneficial parent-child
relationship exception.

3
Father argues that the reporter’s transcript reflects a
finding of regular visitation, and that it controls over the minute
order’s indication otherwise. The reporter’s transcript does not
reflect a finding of regular visitation, however. The juvenile court
merely stated that “although the parents have visited . . . , they
are still monitored visits, and . . . the court is considering the
amount of time they’ve been spending with the children, which is
. . . two hours per week, and the quality of the visits.” This
statement is not inconsistent with the court’s finding of no
regular visitation as reflected in the minute order, particularly
given that the parents had each been allotted six hours of
monitored visitation per week.

10
Once a juvenile court has terminated reunification services,
it “shall terminate parental rights” if it finds, “by clear and
convincing” evidence “that it is likely the child will be adopted”
within a reasonable time. (§ 366.26, subds. (a) & (c)(1).) Thus, a
juvenile court must terminate parental rights and order adoption
unless the parent opposing termination proves that one of six
statutory exceptions applies. (§ 366.26, subds. (c)(1) & (c)(1)(B).)
The exception at issue here is the beneficial parent-child
relationship exception, which “applies in situations where a child
cannot be in a parent’s custody but where severing the child’s
relationship with the parent, even when balanced against the
benefits of a new adoptive home, would be harmful for the child.”
(In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614, 630 (Caden C.).) A court
may only find the exception applicable if the parent establishes
“(1) regular visitation and contact, and (2) a relationship, the
continuation of which would benefit the child such that (3) the
termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child.”
(Id. at. pp. 631, 635.) We review the juvenile court’s findings on
the first two elements (visitation and relationship) for substantial
evidence, and its ruling regarding the balancing of detriment
versus benefit for abuse of discretion. (Id. at pp. 639-640.)
Although the parties dispute whether substantial evidence
supports the juvenile court’s finding of no regular visitation by
parents, we need not resolve that dispute. Nor do we need to
address the evidence showing children’s “substantial, positive,
[and] emotional attachment” to their parents, because—even if
we assume there was such an attachment—we conclude that the
juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in finding that
terminating parental rights would not be detrimental to the

11
children after weighing the degree of their attachment to parents
against the benefits of being adopted by maternal grandparents.
The children spent their whole lives living with maternal
grandparents. Although mother and father lived with maternal
grandparents and the children before the children were detained
(and ultimately removed) from their care, the quality of visits and
the impact of the visits on the children were not always positive.
Mother engaged in arguments with maternal grandmother, and
she left the children feeling “agitated or anxious” after visits.
The children returned from visits with both parents hungry. The
children misbehaved and had “mood swings” after visits with
parents. Son returned from visits, “upset,” but refusing to state
why. Further, children did not ask about parents, sometimes did
not want to visit them, and were “fine not visiting parents.” The
children thrived under the care of their maternal grandparents.
Son made progress in coping with his emotions through therapy,
and daughter improved her vocabulary and speech. Although son
had been coached to relate that he wanted to return to his
parents, he had been thoroughly traumatized by the domestic
violence he had witnessed between parents, and both children
expressed relief when reunification services were terminated
because it eased their anxiety over the prospect of leaving
maternal grandparents’ home. The children “stayed busy with
their daily lives,” and did “not show much interest” when mother
called them. At times, the children “request[ed] to go home” from
visits. We cannot say that the juvenile court here abused its
discretion in finding that the benefits to the children of being
adopted outweighed the loss of their relationships with parents.

12
Mother resists our conclusion citing In re Amber M. (2002)
103 Cal.App.4th 681 (Amber M.) and In re S.B. (2008)
164 Cal.App.4th 289 (S.B.). Neither of these cases impacts our
analysis. Unlike the children here, the children in Amber M. had
been in the care of mother—and not their maternal grandmother
caregiver—for significant portions of their lives. (Amber M., at
p. 689.) The record included a psychologist’s opinion after
conducting a bonding study that mother and her daughter shared
“a primary attachment.” (Ibid.) The son “had difficulty
separating from” mother. (Ibid.) As discussed above, the
children here did not view parents as their parents, but rather as
playmates. The children sometimes wanted to end visits, and
were fine with missing the visits altogether. In S.B., the juvenile
court exerted jurisdiction over a child due to her parents’
substance abuse, and ultimately terminated parental rights in
favor of adoption by the maternal grandmother. (S.B., supra,
164 Cal.App.4th at pp. 293, 296.) The court of appeal reversed,
observing that father, a veteran who suffered from severe health
problems and PTSD, “complied with every aspect of his case
plan,” and the child “display[ed] a strong attachment” to her
father during visits, including whispering “I love you” to him and
stating, “I’ll miss you” when visits ended; spontaneously stating
her desire to live with him; and showing physical affection, such
as sitting on his lap and asking him to pick her up. (S.B., at
p. 298.) Such strong displays of affection and attachment are not
present in this record.

13
DISPOSITION
The orders terminating mother’s and father’s parental
rights are affirmed.

LEE, J.*
WE CONCUR:

MOOR, Acting P. J.

KIM, J.


Judge of the San Bernardino County Superior Court,
assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of
the California Constitution.

14

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.