In re Mic.L. CA2/3

CourtListener 9567906Calctapp18 de jun. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 6/18/24 In re Mic.L. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re Mic.L. et al., Persons Coming B333195
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. Nos.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN 18CCJP07663A,
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 18CCJP07663B

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.A. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Juvenile Court Referee. Affirmed.

Gina Zaragoza, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant C.A.

Caitlin Christian, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant M.L.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Kelley G. Emling, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________

Mother C.A. and father M.L. appeal from the juvenile
court’s orders terminating parental rights to their twin
daughters, Mia.L. and Mic.L. Mother contends the juvenile
court erred by declining to apply the parental-benefit exception
to adoption. Father joins mother’s argument. We find no error
and affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1
1. The investigation and petition
Mother and father have twin girls together—Mia.L.
and Mic.L.—who were born in October 2018. Mother has
three children from other relationships: A.A. (born in 2012),
L.C. (born in 2015), and C.C. (born in 2016). L.C. and C.C. share
the same father and are Indian children. This appeal concerns
only the twins, Mia.L. and Mic.L.
In 2017, a dependency court sustained a Welfare and
Institutions Code section 3002 petition and removed A.A., L.C.,
and C.C. from mother’s custody. The court found mother abused
methamphetamine, which rendered her incapable of providing
regular care for the children. Mother had yet to reunite
with the children by the time she gave birth to the twins.

1 Although both mother and father appealed, their
arguments on appeal concern only mother’s relationship with
the children. Therefore, we focus on the facts related to mother
and do not summarize the facts related to father.
2 Undesigned statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

2
Mother told the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (the Department) she used
methamphetamine daily from the age of 13 until she became
pregnant with her first child, A.A. According to mother,
she stopped using the drug, but she relapsed in 2016. When
she found out she was pregnant with the twins, she entered
a treatment program and stopped using drugs.
On November 30, 2018, the Department filed a petition
asserting Mia.L. and Mic.L. are persons described by section 300.
The petition alleged mother has a history of illicit drug use,
including amphetamines and methamphetamine, which
renders her unable to provide regular care and supervision
for the children.
At a detention hearing on December 3, 2018, the court
found a prima facie case showing the children are persons
described by section 300. Nevertheless, the court ordered
the children released to mother.
2. The children are placed with relative caregivers
Mother’s treatment center terminated her from the
program sometime after the detention hearing. According to
mother’s counselor, this was the third time mother had been
terminated from the program, and she would not be allowed
to return.
The Department also learned mother had been involved
in two recent incidents involving the police. The first incident
occurred eight days after mother gave birth to the twins.
According to the police report, mother drove away when officers
tried to pull her over. When mother eventually stopped, two men
got out of her car and ran in opposite directions. Mother told
the officers she had just met the men at a liquor store and they

3
had invited her to a party. Mother was charged with felony
evading a police officer and misdemeanor driving without
a license.
During the second incident, mother was driving her friend
while the twins were in the car. The police surrounded the car
and arrested the friend. The Department learned the friend
was a gang member, has a history of domestic violence, and had
been charged with assault with a deadly weapon after beating
someone with a baseball bat.
In light of these developments, the court removed the
children from mother’s custody on February 22, 2019. The
Department placed the children with a maternal aunt and
her husband, whom we refer to as the relative caregivers.
3. The court takes jurisdiction over the children
and returns them to mother
The court held a combined jurisdiction and disposition
hearing on May 28, 2019. The court found true the allegations
related to mother’s substance abuse, declared the twins
dependents of the court, and removed them from their parents’
custody. The court ordered the parents to participate in
counseling, parenting classes, and alcohol and drug programs.
The court granted both parents monitored visitation.
The Department reported the children had bonded to
the relative caregivers and were thriving in their placement.
Mother visited the children regularly, and the Department
eventually liberalized her visits to unmonitored. According
to the Department, mother was affectionate, nurturing, and
attentive during visits. Mother engaged with the children,
fed them, talked to them, and changed their diapers.

4
The court ordered the twins be returned to mother’s
custody on September 24, 2020. As of March 2021, the
Department reported the children were doing well in mother’s
care. Mother was participating in services and consistently
tested negative for drugs and alcohol, although she was
occasionally a “no show.”
4. The Department places the children with foster
parents
On April 29, 2021, the Department removed the children
from mother’s custody after discovering six of her negative drug
tests had been diluted. Mother admitted occasionally drinking
alcohol, including while the children were at home. She also
admitted leaving the children in the care of her friend, whose
home the Department had not cleared. Mother had never
visited the home before allowing the children to stay there.
The Department explored placing the children with the
relative caregivers who had previously cared for them. However,
the caregivers had recently started caring for two of mother’s
other children—L.C. and C.C.—and their house was not large
enough to accommodate more children. Therefore, the
Department placed the children with foster parents.
The Department reported the foster parents were meeting
the children’s needs on a consistent basis. The children were
well-adjusted and “thriving” in their placement. However,
both children started to display aggressive behavior that
required intervention.
Mic.L. also experienced severe health issues while living
with the foster parents. The child underwent brain and heart
surgery, suffered frequent severe nosebleeds, and broke out
in hives for unknown reasons. A specialist prescribed Mic.L.

5
an EpiPen to prevent anaphylaxis, and an ophthalmologist
directed her to wear glasses at all times.
Mother consistently visited the children while they were
in foster care. The visits reportedly went well, and the children
were happy to see mother. Mother was nurturing, provided
appropriate snacks, and focused on the children. The
Department eventually liberalized mother’s visits to
unmonitored.
Although mother generally acted appropriately during
visits, the Department remained concerned about the children’s
safety while under her care. According to the caregiver, mother
did not always have an EpiPen on hand, and she did not make
Mic.L. wear her glasses at all times. During one visit, mother
gave Mia.L. over-the-counter cough medicine, despite the child’s
doctor warning that such medications could have adverse side
effects. At another visit, mother drove the children a significant
distance without securing them in car seats.
5. The court reverts mother’s visits
In November 2022, the Department discovered photographs
of mother drinking alcohol, handling nitrous oxide, and allowing
the children to visit father, in violation of a court order. The
Department also discovered text messages in which mother
coached father to lie to the Department about the visit. In other
messages, mother warned maternal uncle not to tell anyone she
had been drinking for fear it would get back to the Department.
Based on those photographs and messages, the Department
filed a petition to revert mother’s visits to monitored. The court
considered the petition at a review hearing on February 8, 2023.
Minors’ counsel urged the court to grant the petition and
terminate mother’s reunification services. Counsel argued

6
the new evidence undermined everything mother had been
telling the court about her progress.
The court granted the petition and reverted mother’s
visits to monitored. However, the court continued mother’s
reunification services, noting she had made some progress by
participating in services.
The Department reported the children were happy and
“thriving” in the foster parents’ home. The foster parents met
the children’s needs and attended all their medical appointments.
In contrast, mother did not show up to every appointment and
had not attended an EpiPen training class. A social worker
remarked that mother did not seem to realize the children’s
behavioral issues were the result of past trauma.
Mother continued to visit the children regularly. During
one visit, mother became angry when Mia.L. referred to the foster
parent as “ ‘[m]ommy.’ ” Mother insisted the foster parent was
not the child’s mommy. Mia.L. became upset and responded,
in a “firm voice, ‘No. I have two [m]ommy’s.’ ”
During another visit, Mic.L. became upset when mother
would not let the child’s older sister help her put on shoes.
Mother responded by firmly holding Mic.L. in her arms while the
child struggled to get free, called mother names, and hit mother.
It took 45 minutes for Mic.L. finally to calm down. The social
worker characterized the incident as a “ ‘power struggle’ ” over
the child recognizing mother as an authority figure.
The foster parents reported that, as of May 2023, Mic.L.
started to express not wanting to attend visits. Around the
same time, she started throwing tantrums during visits, although
she would eventually refocus and cooperate. According to a

7
social worker, Mia.L. would “become quiet” when asked about
visits with mother, which was out of the norm for the child.
6. The children return to the relative caregivers’ home
On July 12, 2023, the court found mother had made only
partial progress toward alleviating the causes necessitating
placement, and it terminated her reunification services.
About a month later, in August 2023, the Department
placed the children back in the relative caregivers’ home. The
relative caregivers continued to care for the children’s siblings
—C.C. and L.C.—as well. Although the caregivers originally
had not been able to care for all four children at the same time,
they had recently purchased a larger home specifically for
that purpose.
According to the relative caregivers, the children continued
to exhibit aggressive behavior and struggled to control their
anger while in their home. Among other things, they would hit
one another, shout, and use obscene gestures. Both children
were referred to behavioral therapists to address their issues.
Mother continued to visit the children, typically for six
hours per week. The visits reportedly went well, and the children
were happy to see mother. The caregiver said the children were
ready to leave at the end of visits and did not struggle to say
goodbye. The children rarely mentioned mother during the week.
Occasionally, they would throw tantrums and say they missed
her.
The children said visits with mother were both good and
bad. They enjoyed spending time with mother, eating with her,
and hugging her. However, the visits could be bad because
they would play rough and mother would get mad at them
for misbehaving.

8
Mother said she was “100% bonded” with the children.
However, a social worker observed the children were not very
bonded with mother, noting they seemed to view her as a
“ ‘weekend mother.’ ”
The Department reported that mother did not consistently
and timely respond when the children became aggressive with
each other. Instead, mother waited to intervene until the
situation escalated. The caregiver remarked that mother did
not set rules during visits. As a result, after visits, the children
would struggle to adjust to their routine at home and had
difficulty keeping their hands to themselves.
7. The court terminates parental rights
The court held a section 366.26 permanency planning
hearing on November 8, 2023. The Department recommended
terminating parental rights and pursing adoption with the
relative caregivers.
Mother urged the court instead to apply the parental-
benefit exception to adoption. According to mother, the exception
applied because she had maintained regular visitation and
contact with the children, the children would benefit from
continuing their relationship with her, and termination of
that relationship would be detrimental to them.
Minors’ counsel joined mother in arguing for the parental-
benefit exception to adoption. Counsel said she was torn on
the issue, because adoption would seem to be the best plan for
the children. However, the twins’ siblings—L.C. and C.C.—are
Indian children, and their tribe objected to adoption. Counsel
said she was concerned that, at some point in the future, mother
might file a section 388 petition seeking to reunite with L.C.
and C.C. If so, Mia.L. and Mic.L. might be confused as to why

9
they do not have a similar opportunity to reunite with mother.
Under these unique circumstances, counsel argued, the benefits
of adoption are marginally outweighed by the harm of losing
a connection to mother.
The court terminated parental rights, finding mother
had not shown the parental-benefit exception to adoption. The
court noted the children had spent most of their lives outside
mother’s custody, and they had never articulated a strong
desire for mother to remain in their lives. The court rejected as
speculative minors’ counsel’s argument concerning the possibility
that mother would seek to regain custody of the children’s
siblings.
Mother and father timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Mother’s sole contention on appeal is the juvenile court
erred by failing to apply the parental-benefit exception to
adoption at the section 366.26 hearing. Father joins mother’s
argument. He does not raise any independent grounds for relief.
“The sole purpose of the section 366.26 hearing is to select
and implement a permanent plan for the child after reunification
efforts have failed.” (In re J.D. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 833,
851–852 (J.D.); In re Marilyn H. (1993) 5 Cal.4th 295, 304;
see also § 366.26, subd. (b).) At that stage, the “focus shifts
from monitoring the parents’ progress toward reunification
to determining the appropriate placement plan for the child.”
(Marilyn H., at p. 305.) “The dependency statutes embody
a presumptive rule that, after reunification efforts have failed,
parental rights must be terminated in order to free a child
for adoption.” (J.D., at p. 852, citing In re Caden C. (2021)
11 Cal.5th 614, 630–631 (Caden C.).) The juvenile court must

10
select adoption as the permanent plan and terminate parental
rights unless it finds doing so would be detrimental to the child
under one of several statutory exceptions. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1);
Caden C., at pp. 630–631.)
Section 366.26, subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i) codifies one of
those exceptions to adoption, which is commonly referred to as
the parental-benefit exception. (See Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th
at p. 625, fn. 2.) The exception applies where “[t]he parents have
maintained regular visitation and contact with the child and the
child would benefit from continuing the relationship.” (§ 366.26,
subd. (c)(1)(B)(i); J.D., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th at p. 852.) The
exception has three elements, each of which the parent must
prove by a preponderance of the evidence: (1) regular visitation
and contact with the child, taking into account the extent of
visitation permitted; (2) the child has a substantial, positive,
emotional attachment to the parent; and (3) terminating
that attachment would be detrimental to the child even when
balanced against the countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive
home. (Caden C., at p. 636.)
In assessing whether termination of parental rights would
be detrimental to the child, the juvenile court must perform
a “case-specific inquiry,” asking, “does the benefit of placement
in a new, adoptive home outweigh ‘the harm [the child] would
experience from the loss of [a] significant, positive, emotional
relationship with [the parent?]’ [Citation.] When the
relationship with a parent is so important to the child that the
security and stability of a new home wouldn’t outweigh its loss,
termination would be ‘detrimental to the child due to’ the child’s
beneficial relationship with a parent.” (Caden C., supra, 11
Cal.5th at pp. 633–634.) To decide the issue, courts may consider

11
“[t]he age of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the
parent’s custody, the ‘positive’ or ‘negative’ effect of interaction
between parent and child, and the child’s particular needs.”
(In re Autumn H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 575–576
(Autumn H.).)
Here, the juvenile court found mother satisfied the first
element of the parental-benefit exception by maintaining regular
visitation with the children. As to the second element, the
court found a substantial positive emotional attachment from
mother to the children, but not from the children to mother.
Nevertheless, the court explained that “for purposes of my ruling,
I will find that prong 2 may exist in this case as well, though
I do think the evidence is somewhat lacking in this regard.”
Based on this comment, it appears the court declined to
apply the parental-benefit exception based solely on mother’s
failure to satisfy the third element. That element required
mother to show termination would be detrimental to the children
even when balanced against the benefit of a new, adoptive home.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) The court’s decision
on the issue is discretionary, and we review it for abuse of
discretion. (Id. at p. 640.) An abuse of discretion occurs when
the juvenile court exceeds the bounds of reason by making a
determination that is arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd.
(See In re N.M. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090, 1094.)
Considering the relevant factors here, the juvenile court
did not abuse its discretion by concluding any detriment to
the children from losing their relationship with mother did not
outweigh the benefits of adoption. The children were five years
old when the court terminated parental rights. Over the course
of those five years, the children spent less than a year in mother’s

12
care. In contrast, the children spent four years—the vast
majority of their young lives—out of mother’s home.
Although mother maintained consistent and regular
visitation during that time, it is not apparent the children
received any significant benefit from those visits. Mother’s visits
typically lasted only a few hours per week, and many of them
were monitored. The caregivers reported the children generally
enjoyed their time with mother, but they had no trouble saying
goodbye at the end of visits. Nor did the children frequently
talk about mother when she was not around. In fact, at one
point, Mic.L. expressed not wanting to attend visits at all.
This strongly suggests any benefit the children received from
the visits was minimal.
Mother also failed to show her relationship with the
children provided significant benefits outside of visits. The
children experienced severe medical and behavioral issues,
for which they likely would have benefited from additional
parental support and care. However, mother’s involvement in
those aspects of the children’s lives was minimal. According to
the foster parent, mother often did not show up to the children’s
medical appointments. Nor did mother seem to appreciate fully
the seriousness of the children’s medical needs, as evidenced by
her delay in attending an EpiPen training and failure to ensure
Mic.L. wore her glasses at all times. On this record, the court
reasonably could have determined mother is unlikely to provide
the children meaningful support and care in the future.
In addition to the lack of significant benefits from the
relationship with mother, the court reasonably could have found
there was a risk that continuing the relationship would actually
be detrimental to the children. The Department reported that

13
mother did not consistently and timely respond to the children’s
aggressive behavior. According to a caregiver, mother’s lack
of rules resulted in the children struggling to readjust to
their routines after returning home from visits. The caregiver
specifically noted the children had more difficulty keeping
their hands to themselves. This suggests visits were worsening
the children’s aggressive behavior, which already was an area
of significant concern.
There also is evidence the visits were causing the children
to suffer emotional harm. During one visit, the Department
observed a “ ‘power struggle’ ” between mother and Mic.L. over
whether the child recognized mother as an authority figure.
During another visit, Mia.L. became upset when mother insisted
the child not refer to the caregiver as “ ‘[m]ommy.’ ” The court
reasonably could have found mother’s insistence that the children
recognize her as their parent—despite not always fulfilling
that role in their lives—would be confusing and ultimately
detrimental to their emotional well being.
Mother contends the children would have benefited from
continuing the relationship because they were bonded to her,
showed her affection, considered her to be their parent, enjoyed
spending time with her, and claimed they missed her. While
all that may be true, a “showing the child derives some benefit
from the relationship is not a sufficient ground to depart from
the statutory preference for adoption.” (In re Breanna S. (2017)
8 Cal.App.5th 636, 646, disapproved on another ground in
Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 637–638, fns. 6–7.) Rather,
a parent has the burden to show the relationship “promotes
the well-being of the child to such a degree as to outweigh the
well-being the child would gain in a permanent home with new,

14
adoptive parents.” (Autumn H., supra, 27 Cal.App.4th at p. 575.)
Although the evidence mother points to would tend to support
that finding, it does not compel it.
Mother also points to evidence that the children displayed
aggressive behavior and difficulty transitioning between
placements. She argues, because she was the only stable
presence in the children’s lives, they will suffer greatly from
losing their relationship with her. While we agree with mother
that the children struggled with the lack of stability in their
lives, we do not agree that forgoing adoption is the answer. To
the contrary, it would seem adoption is the option most likely to
provide the children the security and stability they so desperately
need. At the very least, we cannot say the juvenile court abused
its discretion in finding the benefits of adoption outweigh any
detriment from terminating the children’s relationship with
mother.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the orders.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

EGERTON, J.

We concur:

LAVIN, Acting P. J. ADAMS, J.

15

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.