CourtListener 9505383•Lerma v. Cottrell CA4/1
Texto completo
Filed 5/20/24 Lerma v. Cottrell CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
NICHOLAS LERMA et al., D082595
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
v. (Super. Ct. No. 37-2018-
00008499-CU-PL-CTL)
COTTRELL, INC.,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Kenneth J. Medel, Judge. Affirmed.
Carpenter & Zuckerman, John P. Kristensen, and Frank M.
Mihalic, Jr., for Plaintiffs and Appellants.
SBE and Jeffrey Y. Choi for Defendant and Respondent.
Nicholas and Gina Lerma appeal from an order dismissing their second
of two product liability cases against Cottrell, Inc. for failure to serve the
summons and complaint within the statutory three-year deadline after filing.
(Code Civ. Proc.,1 §§ 583.210, 583.250.) We reject their sole contention that
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.
service of the summons and complaint was unnecessary because Cottrell
made a “general appearance in the action.” (§ 583.220.) Accordingly, we
affirm the order of dismissal.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Lerma I, Lerma II, and Wehn Actions
In February 2018, the Lermas filed a lawsuit in San Diego Superior
Court against Cottrell and other defendants arising from an accident
Nicholas suffered when he fell from the upper deck of a Cottrell truck rig in
February 2016. (Lerma v. Cottrell, Inc., San Diego Superior Court No. 37-
2018-00008499-CU-PL-CTL (Lerma I).)
In October 2019, the Lermas filed a second lawsuit (represented by the
same counsel) in San Diego Superior Court against Cottrell and other
defendants arising from another accident Nicholas suffered when he fell from
a Cottrell truck rig in November 2018. (Lerma v. Cottrell, Inc., San Diego
Superior Court No. 37-2019-00057325-CU-PL-CTL (Lerma II).)
In May 2019, Michael and Sharan Wehn (represented by the same
counsel as the Lermas) filed a lawsuit in San Diego Superior Court against
Cottrell and other defendants arising from an accident Michael suffered when
he fell from a Cottrell truck rig in May 2017. (Wehn v. Cottrell, Inc., San
Diego Superior Court No. 37-2019-00024330-CU-PL-CTL.)
B. Consolidation for Pretrial Purposes Only
In November 2019, counsel stipulated to consolidate all three cases
under the Lerma I case number “for pretrial purposes only.” The parties
further stipulated “[t]hat each matter be ultimately adjudicated by separate
trials after pretrial proceedings are completed.” Accordingly, the Lerma I
court entered an order consolidating all three cases “into the [Lerma I] case
number . . . for pretrial purposes only” and directing that the files in the
2
other cases “shall be transferred to this department forthwith.” The order
further stated that “[e]ach matter shall be ultimately adjudicated by separate
trials after pretrial proceedings are completed.”
C. Summary Judgment in Lerma I
In April 2022, Cottrell filed a motion for summary judgment and
summary adjudication solely as to the Lerma I claims arising from the
February 2016 accident. The caption listed Lerma I as the lead case number
and noted that it was consolidated with the other two cases. The Lermas
opposed the motion solely on the ground that it failed to address their claims
relating to November 2018 accident at issue in Lerma II. Their opposition
papers further stated that they were dismissing without prejudice their
Lerma I claims relating to the February 2016 accident.
In September 2022, the trial court granted Cottrell’s motion for
summary judgment in Lerma I only and rejected the Lermas’ attempt to
dismiss those claims without prejudice “to avoid a pending summary
judgment motion.”
D. Dismissal of Lerma II
Two days after filing the Lerma I summary judgment motion in April
2022, counsel for Cottrell sent an email to the Lermas’ counsel following up
on a conversation they had regarding the three consolidated cases. The email
included the following language: “Additionally, one of the Lerma cases
[Lerma II] has not been served per our discussion. Please let us know your
proposal for handling that. We will have additional discovery to do once that
gets handled.” This email was sent over six months before the three-year
deadline for service of the summons and complaint expired in Lerma II.
(§ 583.210, subd. (a).) For reasons not explained in the record, the Lermas
never served the Lerma II summons and complaint on Cottrell.
3
In November 2022, Cottrell filed a motion to dismiss Lerma II for
failure to serve the summons and complaint within the three-year deadline.
The Lermas opposed the motion solely on the ground that Cottrell had filed a
general appearance in the consolidated actions by failing to object to the
consolidation and thereafter filing a motion for summary judgment in
Lerma I.
The trial court granted Cottrell’s motion to dismiss Lerma II. The court
rejected the Lermas’ argument that Cottrell had made a general appearance
in Lerma II for the following reasons: (1) the cases were consolidated only for
pretrial purposes and remained separate for trial purposes; (2) such a limited
consolidation did not constitute a complete merger of the actions, under the
holding of Sanchez v. Superior Court (1988) 203 Cal.App.3d 1391 (Sanchez);
(3) the only subject of Cottrell’s summary judgment motion was Lerma I, not
Lerma II; and (4) Cottrell had not propounded, been served with, or
responded to any discovery requests in Lerma II.
DISCUSSION
Relying heavily on Hamilton v. Asbestos Corporation (2000) 22 Cal.4th
1127 (Hamilton), the Lermas contend that the trial court erred in dismissing
Lerma II because Cottrell made a general appearance by stipulating to
consolidate Lerma I and Lerma II for pretrial purposes and then filing a
summary judgment motion under the consolidated case number. We
disagree.2
Section 583.210, subdivision (a) provides that the summons and
complaint in a civil action shall be served within three years of the filing of
2 The parties agree that the applicable standard of review is abuse of
discretion. We find it unnecessary to decide this question because we would
affirm the order under any standard of review.
4
the complaint. Subject to certain statutory exceptions, section 583.250 states
that if service is not made within the time prescribed, the action is subject to
mandatory dismissal. The only exception at issue here is section 583.220,
which provides that the three-year deadline “does not apply if the defendant
enters into a stipulation in writing or does another act that constitutes a
general appearance in the action.” (Italics added.)
A general appearance need not be a formal or technical act. (Sanchez,
supra, 203 Cal.App.3d at p. 1397.) Rather, “the term may apply to various
acts which, under all of the circumstances, are deemed to confer jurisdiction
of the person.” (Ibid.) “What is determinative is whether defendant takes a
part in the particular action which in some manner recognizes the authority
of the court to proceed.” (Ibid.)
In Sanchez, two sets of plaintiffs filed separate actions arising out of
the same vehicle accident. The complaint in the first action was served on all
defendants, but the complaint in the second action was not. The two actions
were consolidated for trial only. After the three-year deadline to serve the
second complaint passed, defendants filed motions to dismiss the second
action. The trial court denied the motions, but the appellate court granted
writ relief and directed the trial court to grant the petitioning defendant’s
motion to dismiss. (Sanchez, supra, 203 Cal.App.3d at pp. 1394–1395, 1401.)
The Court of Appeal rejected the plaintiffs’ contention that the
defendant’s appearance in the first action constituted an appearance in the
second because the cases were consolidated. The court concluded that the
two actions remained separate and distinct and were not completely merged
because they were consolidated for purposes of trial only. (Sanchez, supra,
203 Cal.App.3d at pp. 1396, 1399.) The court reasoned that “there were two
different sets of plaintiffs who pleaded their cases separately and would
5
presumably expect separate judgments,” there was “no indication in the
record that the two complaints in these actions became merged,” and “the
actions retained their separate numbers.” (Id. at p. 1396.) Accordingly, the
court concluded that by appearing at depositions noticed by the plaintiffs and
otherwise defending his interests in the first action, the petitioning defendant
had not made a general appearance in the second action. (Id. at p. 1399.)
In Hamilton, our Supreme Court reached a different result. There, the
plaintiff brought two different actions against the same defendant (Asbestos
Corporation) for different diseases arising from the same asbestos exposure.
(Hamilton, supra, 22 Cal.4th at pp. 1132–1133.) The first complaint was
never served on Asbestos Corporation, but the second one was. (Id. at
p. 1133.) The court consolidated the two cases for all purposes, and the case
went to trial against Asbestos Corporation, resulting in a single verdict and
judgment for the plaintiff under the consolidated case number. (Id. at
pp. 1133–1134, 1136–1137, 1148.) Asbestos Corporation fully participated in
the consolidated action and trial from beginning to end without objecting to
the trial court’s jurisdiction on the basis that the complaint in the first action
had never been served on it. (Id. at p. 1149.) Asbestos Corporation did not
even raise the issue in its appeal from the judgment—instead, the Court of
Appeal raised and decided it on its own motion. (Id. at p. 1149, fn. 13.)
After granting review, the Supreme Court concluded that because the
two cases had been consolidated “for all purposes,” and Asbestos Corporation
had fully participated in the consolidated action all the way through trial and
judgment without objection, it had made a general appearance in the first
action. (Hamilton, supra, 22 Cal.4th at pp. 1147, 1149.) In reaching this
result, the court distinguished between two different kinds of consolidation:
(1) “a consolidation for purposes of trial only, where the two actions remain
6
otherwise separate” (as in Sanchez); and (2) “a complete consolidation or
consolidation for all purposes, where the two actions are merged into a single
proceeding under one case number and result in only one verdict or set of
findings and one judgment.” (Id. at p. 1147.) The Hamilton court repeatedly
emphasized that the consolidation at issue there was “for all purposes.”
(Id. at pp. 1147–1149.)
This case involves a third type of consolidation: “for pretrial purposes
only.” The consolidation order explicitly stated that “[e]ach matter shall be
ultimately adjudicated by separate trials after pretrial proceedings are
completed.” Even the Lermas concede in their reply brief that the “cases
were to unmerge” when they went to trial. Thus, the stipulation and order to
consolidate the actions for “pretrial purposes only” contemplated separate
trials, separate verdicts, and separate judgments for each of the three cases,
presumably entered in the original case numbers after the cases were
“unmerged.”
We conclude that Sanchez rather than Hamilton is controlling in these
circumstances. Because the cases were not consolidated for all purposes, and
the consolidation did not contemplate a single proceeding resulting in only a
single verdict and judgment, the holding of Hamilton does not apply. A
consolidation for all purposes results in a complete merger of the actions,
such that an appearance in one constitutes an appearance in the others.
(Hamilton, supra, 22 Cal.4th at pp. 1147–1149.) But here, the actions
retained their separate identities because they were consolidated only for the
limited purpose of pretrial proceedings. As the Ninth Circuit has observed,
“individual cases that are consolidated or coordinated for pretrial purposes
remain fundamentally separate actions, intended to resume their
independent status once the pretrial stage of litigation is over.” (Bahn v.
7
Korean Airlines Co. (In re Korean Air Lines Co.) (9th Cir. 2011) 642 F.3d 685,
700.)
Because the Lerma I and Lerma II actions were not consolidated for all
purposes, they were not merged into one, and Cottrell’s summary judgment
motion filed only as to Lerma I did not constitute a general appearance in
Lerma II. Cottrell never filed any motions in Lerma II or took part in any
other proceeding that recognized the authority of the court to proceed in that
matter. We therefore conclude that the trial court correctly dismissed the
Lerma II complaint for failure to serve the summons and complaint within
the three-year deadline.
Although the argument headings of the Lermas’ opening brief only
refer to Cottrell’s summary judgment motion as a basis for their claim that
Cottrell made a general appearance in Lerma II, they observe in passing that
Cottrell noticed and took the deposition of Nicholas Lerma in two sessions
occurring in July and November 2021, after the cases were consolidated for
pretrial purposes. But the Lermas did not mention this deposition in their
opposition papers below; they did not argue that Cottrell’s participation in
this or any other discovery constituted a general appearance in Lerma II; and
they have provided no reasoned argument or authority to support such an
argument in their appellate briefs. We therefore deem the argument to have
been forfeited. (See Sea & Sage Audubon Society, Inc. v. Planning Com.
(1983) 34 Cal.3d 412, 417 [issues not raised in trial court cannot be raised for
first time on appeal]; Tellez v. Rich Voss Trucking, Inc. (2015) 240
Cal.App.4th 1052, 1066 [point asserted without reasoned argument or
citation to authority is forfeited].)3
3 Though not argued below, there is California authority not cited by the
Lermas holding that making discovery demands or initiating discovery
8
DISPOSITION
The order of dismissal is affirmed. Respondent is entitled to recover its
costs on appeal.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
IRION, Acting P. J.
DATO, J.
proceedings unrelated to jurisdiction can constitute a general appearance.
(See, e.g., Factor Health Management v. Superior Court (2005) 132
Cal.App.4th 246, 250; Roy v. Superior Court (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 337, 341;
Creed v. Schultz (1983) 148 Cal.App.3d 733, 740.) Even if the issue were not
forfeited, however, the record is unclear whether Cottrell deposed Nicholas in
both Lerma actions or just Lerma I. The document requests accompanying
the notice of deposition and amended notices only mention the February 2016
accident date at issue in Lerma I as well as a singular “rig at issue”—even
though the accidents in Lerma I and Lerma II involved two different rigs.
Moreover, at one point during the deposition, counsel for Cottrell asked, “And
did you understand that this lawsuit that we’re here on today is different
from the other lawsuit, that they are two separate ones?” Counsel for the
Lermas did not object or disagree with this statement. Although counsel for
Cottrell ultimately did ask Nicholas questions about both the 2016 accident
and the 2018 accident, that may have been just to differentiate which injuries
he was attributing to which accident. Because the issue was not raised
below, Cottrell had no opportunity to explain or develop the record on this
point. A new theory involving a legal question may be presented for the first
time on appeal only if it is determinable from facts that are
(1) uncontroverted in the record, and (2) could not have been altered by the
presentation of additional evidence. (Meridian Financial Services, Inc. v.
Phan (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 657, 699.)
9
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.