CourtListener 9502591•In re S.C. CA3
Texto completo
Filed 5/13/24 In re S.C. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(San Joaquin)
----
In re S.C., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C098625
Law.
SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES (Super. Ct. No. STK-JD-DP-
AGENCY, 2021-0000107)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
S.W.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appellant S.W. (mother), mother of the minor S.C. (the minor), appeals from the
juvenile court’s dispositional orders. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 361, 395.)1 Mother
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
1
contends there was insufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s order removing
the minor from her custody. We will affirm.
BACKGROUND
In February 2021, mother was a party to a pending dependency proceeding
involving one of the minor’s half siblings, R.S., in which mother was arrested and
charged with physical abuse of R.S. while under the influence of alcohol. The San
Joaquin County Human Services Agency (the Agency) initially did not include the minor
or the minor’s other half sibling, A.W., in those proceedings because their respective
fathers agreed to keep the minors away from mother and to file for legal custody of their
respective children.2 However, when it was discovered that the minor’s father, L.C.
(father), had been allowing mother to care for the minor unsupervised despite having
been previously admonished for doing so, the minor was removed from father and placed
in protective custody.
The Agency filed a dependency petition on behalf of the minor pursuant to section
300, subdivisions (b) and (j), alleging failure to protect the minor due to mother’s
unresolved history of alcohol abuse, father’s failure to protect the minor from mother, and
mother’s physical abuse of R.S. The detention report noted that, in December 2020,
mother had been arrested and charged with felony child abuse for punching and causing
injuries to R.S., then 14 years old. In that pending companion case, R.S. was removed
from mother’s custody and placed in out-of-home care, and mother was prohibited from
having any of her other children, including the minor, in her care until she completed her
case plan and reunified with R.S. The detention report also detailed mother’s extensive
history of alcohol abuse.
2 The minor’s half siblings, R.S. and A.W., are not parties to this appeal and will be
mentioned only when relevant to the issues raised by mother.
2
At the March 18, 2021, detention hearing, the juvenile court ordered the minor
detained, with supervised visits for mother. The court also ordered mother to drug court.
The minor was placed with the maternal aunt.
The juvenile court sustained the amended petition as to father on April 13, 2021,
and as to mother on May 11, 2021.
At the July 27, 2021, disposition hearing, mother’s counsel reported that mother
was participating in outpatient substance abuse treatment, individual counseling, and
parenting classes. The juvenile court expressed concern regarding mother’s “lifelong
pattern” of physical and mental abuse of R.S. and the fact that the minor was not
protected from such abuse. The court also expressed its reservations about ordering
reunification services, noting mother had substantial issues with alcohol and violence
which she directed toward “people who cannot protect themselves.” Notwithstanding
those reservations, and the existence of an applicable bypass provision, the court ordered
that mother be provided with reunification services. The court ordered services for father
as well. Mother’s case plan included substance abuse treatment (including random
drug/alcohol testing), compliance with court orders, parenting education, and personal
counseling.
On October 7, 2021, the Agency filed a supplemental petition (§ 387), and the
juvenile court ordered the minor detained after the maternal aunt allowed mother to have
unsupervised visits with the minor.
In January 2022, the Agency recommended continued reunification services to
mother, who was reportedly participating in services. Mother participated in outpatient
substance abuse treatment but was terminated twice for testing positive for alcohol or
failing to test at all. She was allowed to return to the program each time. Mother tested
positive for alcohol on December 21, 2021, and was at risk of being terminated again.
The Agency stated that, despite her recent positive test, mother still demonstrated the
ability to complete her case plan and possibly reunify with the minor.
3
In February 2022, the Agency reported that mother had received a charge of
driving under the influence (DUI) in June 2021 but did not disclose the DUI prior to re-
entering her substance abuse treatment program. Mother was placed on a Secure
Continuous Remote Alcohol Monitoring (SCRAM) device in October 2021. The
SCRAM device was removed on December 17, 2021, and mother tested positive for
alcohol several days later. Mother denied having consumed alcohol and claimed to have
no knowledge of how she could have tested positive. However, the tests were sent to the
lab and the positive results were confirmed. The Agency recommended the juvenile court
terminate mother’s reunification services and set the matter for a section 366.26 hearing.
By May 2022, mother had been reinstated to drug court and her outpatient
substance abuse treatment program, had completed a 52-week parenting program, and
was testing negative for substances. Mother was having consistent unsupervised visits
with the minor weekly without incident. The Agency changed its recommendation to
continued reunification services for mother.
On May 19, 2022, the juvenile court inquired about the Agency’s change in
recommendation. The Agency explained that the original recommendation to terminate
mother’s services was because she “still denies the alcohol.” However, mother had been
clean since that recommendation and was receiving positive reports from her service
providers, thus warranting the new recommendation to continue her services. The court
ordered continued services for mother, noting her completion of many of the case plan
components but admonishing her to “be on top of” the substance abuse problem and be
fully committed to her recovery.
In July 2022, the Agency reported that mother completed individual counseling
and reportedly gained insight into her behavior patterns. She remained engaged in drug
court and random testing, attended Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, was compliant with
her DUI court program, was completing her case plan, and was able to reunify with R.S.
Mother’s visits with the minor increased and included overnight visits. On July 21, 2022,
4
at the recommendation of the Agency, the juvenile court ordered the minor returned to the
parents (who were living separately) with family maintenance services.
On September 15, 2022, the Agency informed the juvenile court that father had
reported to the social worker that mother was intoxicated during a custody exchange in
August 2022. Mother denied the claim. It was also reported that mother and R.S.
engaged in a physical altercation during which mother was reportedly under the influence
of alcohol. Mother denied the allegation and R.S. later denied mother was under the
influence. Nonetheless, the Agency requested the court order random testing. When
mother’s counsel objected and argued mother had already completed drug court, the court
stated, “The completion of a program does not ensure a hundred percent that someone is
going to be clean and sober,” and ordered that both parents test immediately. Both
parents tested positive for tetrahydrocannabinol (THC).
Father argued he only used marijuana in small amounts when he was working, as
prescribed by his doctor, and that the social worker had stopped by his home and “found
no issues” with his marijuana use. The Agency informed the juvenile court that father
had been terminated from drug court, but the Agency had no safety concerns with father.
Mother acknowledged she made a mistake and was willing to do whatever the court
ordered, including additional counseling, random testing, and outpatient treatment.
The juvenile court noted that father had not sufficiently demonstrated his ability to
stop using marijuana as promised. The court also noted that while mother’s willingness
to address the marijuana issue was positive, there were also allegations of alcohol abuse,
and the case would not get resolved until mother fully addressed that issue as well. The
court expressed serious concern about the parents’ ability to care for the minor and his
siblings and stated it could not leave the minor in the care of the parents, who were not
following the court’s directions, adding, “I believe there’s a safety issue if these children
are remaining in the home.” Finding that the continued placement of the children in the
parents’ respective homes was contrary to the children’s welfare, the court ordered the
5
minor removed from both parents and directed the Agency to file a section 387
supplemental petition and initiate more counseling for mother to address the issue of
substance abuse.
On September 16, 2022, the Agency filed a second supplemental petition (§ 387)
on behalf of the minor. The petition alleged mother was intoxicated when she picked up
the minor from father’s home on August 19, 2022, she showed up “very drunk” to a visit
on September 2, 2022, and urinated on herself, she became physically and verbally
abusive toward R.S. on September 2, 2022, and she tested positive for THC on
September 15, 2022. It was further alleged that father was terminated from drug court on
August 5, 2022, after missing his appointments, he tested positive for marijuana on May
16, 2022, and he tested positive for THC on September 15, 2022.
At the detention hearing, over the parents’ objections, the juvenile court reaffirmed
its previous detention orders noting its continuing concerns about mother’s use of both
marijuana and alcohol, and further noting there were issues going on in mother’s home
that “rise to the risk level that . . . requires the Court to step in and remove these
children.” The court stated it would not consider returning the minor to father either until
he re-engaged in drug court and demonstrated “a much stronger commitment” to the
program. Thereafter, the court sustained the amended supplemental petition as to both
parents.
By January 2023, mother was reportedly engaged in drug court, testing negative
for any substances, and staying in communication with her drug court case manager and
her counselor. Father had not been reinstated into drug court and had not addressed the
court’s concerns. The Agency stated it believed the minor could be safely returned to
mother and recommended that the juvenile court order family maintenance services to her
and no further services to father.
However, at the March 14, 2023, dispositional hearing, the Agency changed its
recommendation as to mother due to two recent positive tests for alcohol while mother
6
was caring for the minor. The juvenile court continued the matter and, at the Agency’s
request, terminated mother’s overnight and in-home visits with the minor, ordering visits
at a supervised facility instead. In-home visits for father were also terminated.
The May 2023 supplemental disposition report stated that, while mother attempted
to explain her two positive tests by stating she had “used a lot of body spray,” the tests
were confirmed positive for consumption of alcohol. The drug court case manager
recommended mother enter inpatient treatment, but mother stated she was unable to do so
because she had R.S. (then 16 years old) in her care. Mother’s recent consumption of
alcohol led the Agency to recommend no further services to mother.
The contested dispositional hearing was held on May 1 and May 8, 2023. The
social worker testified that the minor was initially removed from mother in March 2021
due to mother’s substance abuse, namely alcohol, and sustained allegations of her
physical abuse of R.S. while under the influence of alcohol. The minor was thereafter
removed from father due to his failure to protect the minor by leaving him in mother’s
care notwithstanding a safety plan prohibiting him from doing so.
The social worker testified that mother’s drug of choice was alcohol, but she also
had a history of marijuana use. Mother was referred to outpatient substance abuse
treatment and drug and alcohol testing. Her initial case plan required her to complete a
parenting program and individual counseling and participate in drug court and her
probation program (which was the result of her June 2021 DUI conviction). The social
worker testified that mother completed her outpatient treatment program, the Agency
recommended and the juvenile court ordered, the return of the minor to mother with
family maintenance services.
The social worker testified the minor was removed again in September 2022
pursuant to a section 387 supplemental petition alleging mother showed up at father’s
house intoxicated, drove off without a driver’s license with the minor in the car, and
tested positive for marijuana. Mother claimed the allegation was “a lie.” The social
7
worker testified that mother tested positive for marijuana over the next several months,
but denied using marijuana the latter two months and claimed those positive tests were
the result of R.S. smoking marijuana in the house. The social worker testified that the
Agency nonetheless recommended the return of the minor to mother with family
maintenance services because marijuana was not mother’s first drug of choice, mother
was engaged in drug court even though she was testing positive, she was communicating
with the drug court and the social worker, and the social worker believed mother was
being honest about not using marijuana.
The social worker further testified that, in February 2023, R.S. reported that
mother was “drunk or drinking again.” Mother again denied any alcohol use but began
missing testing appointments and was eventually fitted with a SCRAM device. The
social worker testified that her initial recommendation that mother be given family
maintenance services changed when mother’s SCRAM monitor returned positive tests for
alcohol on March 3 and 4, 2023, when mother was caring for the minor. When
confronted, mother claimed the positive tests were the result of a body spray she used that
contained alcohol. The social worker testified, however, that the body spray was taken
into consideration when the test results were being read and confirmed for alcohol
consumption.
The social worker testified that mother completed all the components of her case
plan, but mother’s consumption of alcohol was concerning to the Agency because her
alcohol use was one of the main reasons for the minor’s removal. Mother’s continuing
struggle with alcohol raised concerns that she could not properly care for the minor and
that her behavior changed when she was under the influence, as evidenced by her
physical abuse of R.S. The social worker testified that, there was not “a substantial
probability” that the Agency could safely return the minor to mother’s care by May 15,
2023, the 18-month statutory limit for services. The social worker further testified that it
was not safe to return the minor to father because of father’s lack of engagement in
8
services and his continued denial that his use of marijuana played a role in the minor’s
removal.
Father testified he did not know the circumstances involving mother that resulted
in the removal of the minor but admitted that he left the minor in mother’s care despite
being instructed not to, resulting in the removal of the minor from his custody. Father
further testified that, on August 19, 2022, mother came to his home to pick up the minor
and began screaming and swearing at him before driving away with the minor. Father
called the social worker to report the incident. He testified he was “pretty sure” mother
was intoxicated because he knew how mother acted when she was intoxicated.
Mother testified she had a long history of substance abuse, that alcohol was her
drug of choice, and that she also had a history of marijuana use. Mother admitted she
relapsed several times during the R.S. matter in 2021, and that she had four prior DUI
convictions, the most recent of which was in June 2021. She testified she graduated from
drug court in July 2022 and the minor was returned to her care. She completed her case
plan components and remained clean and sober through August 2022, denying she was
under the influence of alcohol during the custody exchange on August 19, 2022. She
testified the minor was removed again in September 2022 and the juvenile court ordered
her to participate in drug court and random testing after she tested positive for marijuana.
Mother testified she tested positive for marijuana throughout the months of
September, October, and November 2022, but she denied using marijuana during the
latter two months claiming that the positive results were due to R.S. smoking marijuana
in her home. When her driving privilege was suspended and she missed several random
tests, she was fitted with the SCRAM device to monitor for substance use. Mother
claimed the SCRAM monitor detected alcohol on March 3 and 4, 2023, because she had
used a spray perfume that contained alcohol. She denied consuming alcohol on those
days and stated she had worn a SCRAM monitor one or two years prior during the R.S.
9
dependency case and, in her experience, the SCRAM system would on occasion provide
false positives from other products containing alcohol.
With respect to mother, the Agency argued, and the minor’s counsel agreed, that
there was a substantial danger to the minor if returned home and there was no reasonable
means by which to protect the minor without removal. The Agency requested
termination of reunification services arguing mother had exceeded the maximum time
allowed by law for reunification services (more than 24 months), she was provided with
reasonable services, and the reasons why the minor was first removed from mother—her
physical assault of R.S. while under the influence of alcohol—still existed despite mother
having completed nearly all her case plan. Notwithstanding mother’s persistent struggle
with alcohol and marijuana, and her DUI conviction in June 2021, she continued to deny
any alcohol consumption and attempted to explain away the positive tests despite
laboratory confirmation of those positive results. Finally, the Agency argued mother
exhibited a willingness to make false statements to the Agency regarding her substance
use and noncompliance with court orders, demonstrating there were no conditions of
supervision that would guarantee the minor’s safety in her care.
The juvenile court ordered the minor returned to father with family maintenance
services. As to mother, the court acknowledged her periods of success in obtaining
sobriety but noted her numerous relapses and the four DUI convictions. The court stated
it did not find mother’s testimony credible regarding her explanations for missed and
positive tests. The court stated it agreed with the arguments put forth by the Agency and
minors’ counsel, found mother had a “serious substance abuse problem” and was “out of
time” and was not able to reunify with the minor, terminated mother’s reunification
services, and adopted the Agency’s recommended findings and orders. The court also
confirmed there would not be a section 366.26 hearing as to the minor, who was being
returned to the care and custody of father.
10
DISCUSSION
Mother contends there was insufficient evidence to support the juvenile court’s
dispositional order removing the minor from her custody. She claims there was no
evidence to support a finding that the minor would be at substantial risk of harm, based
on mother’s substance abuse, if returned to mother’s care or that there were no reasonable
means to protect the minor short of removal. We disagree.
Section 361 provides, in pertinent part, that a dependent child “shall not be taken
from the physical custody of his or her parents . . . with whom the child resides at the
time the petition was initiated, unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing
evidence. . . . [¶] There is or would be a substantial danger to the physical health, safety,
protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned
home, and there are no reasonable means by which the minor’s physical health can be
protected without removing the minor from the minor’s parent’s . . . . ” (§ 361, subd.
(c)(1); In re Heather A. (1996) 52 Cal.App.4th 183, 193.)
“In determining whether a child may be safely maintained in the parent’s physical
custody, the juvenile court may consider the parent’s past conduct and current
circumstances, and the parent’s response to the conditions that gave rise to juvenile court
intervention.” (In re D.B. (2018) 26 Cal.App.5th 320, 332; accord, In re I.R. (2021)
61 Cal.App.5th 510, 520.) “A removal order is proper if it is based on proof of
(1) parental inability to provide proper care for the minor and (2) potential detriment to
the minor if he or she remains with the parent. [Citation.] The parent need not be
dangerous and the minor need not have been harmed before removal is appropriate. The
focus of the statute is on averting harm to the child.” (In re T.W. (2013) 214 Cal.App.4th
1154, 1163.)
“The juvenile court has broad discretion to determine what would best serve and
protect the child’s interest and to fashion a dispositional order.” (In re Javier G. (2006)
137 Cal.App.4th 453, 462 [applying § 361, subd. (c) within the context of a § 387
11
removal].) When reviewing removal findings, “ ‘[w]e review the record in the light most
favorable to the trial court’s order to determine whether there is substantial evidence from
which a reasonable trier of fact could make the necessary findings based on the clear and
convincing evidence standard.’ ” (T.J. v. Superior Court (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 1229,
1239-1240, italics omitted; see Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1004-
1005.)
Here, there was significant evidence that, despite having nearly completed her
case plan components, mother still presented a substantial danger to the minor’s safety.
The minor was initially removed due to mother’s physical abuse of R.S. while under the
influence of alcohol. The minor’s physical safety was at risk if mother were to become
intoxicated and perpetrate physical abuse on the minor, and if father continued to allow
mother to care for the minor contrary to the juvenile court’s order in the R.S. dependency
case.
In late 2021, mother was participating in outpatient substance abuse treatment but
was terminated twice for testing positive or not testing. She admitted she relapsed
several times. She was allowed to return to the program each time but failed to disclose
that she had been convicted of DUI in June 2021. She wore a SCRAM device from
October 2021 to mid-December 2021, but tested positive for alcohol just days after the
device was removed. She denied having consumed alcohol or having any knowledge of
how she could have tested positive. A lab confirmed the positive results.
The minor was returned to mother in July 2022, but removed just two months later
after mother reportedly arrived intoxicated at the custody exchange at father’s home.
Father testified mother appeared and acted in a manner that caused him to believe she
was intoxicated and then drove off with the minor inside the car. Mother also engaged in
a physical altercation with R.S. while under the influence of alcohol. Again, mother
claimed she had not consumed alcohol. Mother also tested positive for marijuana, but
denied using the drug and claimed the positive tests were the result of R.S. smoking
12
marijuana in the house. The juvenile court did not find her claims or explanations
credible.
Mother was engaged in drug court in January 2023; however, R.S. reported she
was “drunk or drinking again” in February 2023, and by March 2023, she had tested
positive twice for alcohol while she was caring for the minor. Laboratory tests confirmed
the positive results. Mother again denied consuming alcohol and attempted to explain the
positive tests by claiming she used body spray that contained alcohol and the SCRAM
devices occasionally produced false positives. Again, the juvenile court did not find
mother’s explanations credible.
As the Agency aptly argued, and the juvenile court agreed, the reasons why the
minor was first removed from mother—her physical assault of R.S. and her abuse of
alcohol—still existed despite mother having virtually completed her case plan
components. She was reportedly intoxicated when she drove off with the minor in her
car, and she tested positive when she had the minor in her care. And, in the face of every
one of the confirmed positive tests for either alcohol or marijuana, mother continued to
deny use and attempted to explain away the positive results. The court did not find her
denials or explanations credible, particularly in light of her long history of alcohol abuse,
her various DUI convictions, and her refusals to acknowledge her use of alcohol and
marijuana. Considering mother’s past conduct and current circumstances, and her
response to the conditions that gave rise to juvenile court intervention (In re D.B., supra,
26 Cal.App.5th at p. 332), there was sufficient evidence that there existed a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, protection, and physical or emotional well-being of
the minor if the minor were returned to mother. (§ 361, subd. (c)(1); In re Heather A.,
supra, 52 Cal.App.4th at p. 193.)
There also was sufficient evidence that there were no reasonable means by which
the minor’s physical health could be protected without removing the minor from mother.
As previously discussed, the minor was removed due to mother’s physical abuse of R.S.
13
while under the influence of alcohol. Over the course of the two-year dependency,
mother completed virtually all her case plan components, including outpatient substance
abuse treatment. However, over that same period, mother tested positive for alcohol
numerous times, was convicted of DUI, engaged in a physical altercation with R.S., and
tested positive for marijuana. Mother ignored the juvenile court’s order in the R.S.
companion case and had the minor and his half sibling in her care. She did not disclose
her 2021 DUI conviction even though she had been terminated from drug court and was
being considered for re-entry into that program. She was not truthful with the Agency,
the social worker, or the court when she denied using alcohol and marijuana, making
excuses for her positive tests that did not comport with the facts and circumstances or
with the laboratory confirmation of those tests. The juvenile court agreed with the
Agency’s argument that mother’s “willingness to make false statements . . . concerning
her substance use and her non-compliance with Court orders” created an environment in
which there were no conditions of supervision that would reasonably guarantee the
minor’s safety in mother’s care. (§ 361, subd. (c)(1).)
The juvenile court’s dispositional orders removing the minor from mother’s
custody is supported by substantial evidence.
14
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s judgment is affirmed.
\s\ ,
Krause, Acting P. J.
We concur:
\s\ ,
Boulware Eurie, J.
\s\ ,
Ashworth, J.*
* Judge of the El Dorado County Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
15
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.