CourtListener 9502477•People v. Lovejoy
Texto completo
Filed 5/2/24
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D080941
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCN363925)
DIANA LOVEJOY,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Sim von Kalinowski, Judge. Affirmed.
Carl Fabian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
A. Natasha Cortina, Lynne G. McGinnis, James M. Toohey, Christine
Levingston Bergman and Kelley Johnson, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
Defendant Diana Lovejoy was convicted of conspiring with her
codefendant, Weldon McDavid, to murder her ex-husband, Greg Mulvihill.
She was also found guilty of attempted murder after McDavid shot and
wounded Mulvihill. Several years after her convictions were final, she sought
to be resentenced pursuant to current Penal Code1 section 1172.6, claiming
that both convictions may have been based on a theory of imputed malice.
The trial court disagreed and denied her petition for relief without an
evidentiary hearing. Based on the trial record, including in particular the
verdicts and jury instructions, we conclude that Lovejoy’s conviction for
conspiracy to commit murder was necessarily based on a jury finding that she
personally harbored an intent to kill, making her ineligible for relief under
the statute. Accordingly, we affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2017, Lovejoy and her lover, codefendant Weldon McDavid, were
convicted of conspiracy to commit murder (count 1) and premeditated
attempted murder (count 2). As to both counts, the alleged victim was
Lovejoy’s ex-husband, Greg Mulvihill. Consistent with their plan, Lovejoy
drove McDavid, a former Marine Corps firearms instructor, to a secluded
location. After she left, McDavid lured Mulvihill to his location using an
untraceable cell phone. Hidden in some bushes, McDavid fired a single shot
from a sniper rifle that wounded but did not kill Mulvihill. (See People v.
Lovejoy (July 28, 2020, No. D073477) [nonpub. opn.] (Lovejoy).)2
1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 These skeletal facts, provided for context, are taken from our prior
opinion and are not disputed by the parties.
2
Both Lovejoy and McDavid filed appeals, and while their appellate
cases were pending the Legislature enacted Senate Bill No. 1437 (2017–2018
Reg. Sess.) (Senate Bill 1437), which amended sections 188 and 189 to
substantially narrow murder liability in California based on the felony
murder rule and the natural and probable consequences doctrine. (See
People v. Curiel (2023) 15 Cal.5th 433, 448–449 (Curiel); People v. Lewis
(2021) 11 Cal.5th 952, 959 (Lewis).) Lovejoy argued the changes to section
188 applied retroactively to her premeditated attempted murder offense.
(Lovejoy, supra, D073477.) In her view, the statutory changes that
eliminated natural and probable consequences as a viable theory of
attempted murder meant the trial court committed reversible error when it
“instruct[ed] [the jury] on criminal liability for acts done (e.g., attempted
murder) that are natural and probable consequences of the conspiracy to
commit murder.” (Ibid.) Our opinion assumed “for the purpose of addressing
Lovejoy’s argument, that [Senate Bill 1437’s] provisions apply to attempted
murder and that the court erred by instructing on the natural and probable
consequences theory.” (Lovejoy, supra, D073477.) We nonetheless concluded
that any assumed error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt because
“the jury in fact, necessarily found that Lovejoy had the requisite malice for
attempted murder (i.e., that she had the intent to kill Mulvihill).” (Ibid.)
Our conclusion was based on the jury’s independent determination that
Lovejoy was guilty of conspiracy to commit murder, which necessarily
required a finding that she possessed an intent to kill. (Ibid. [“By finding
Lovejoy guilty of conspiracy to commit murder (count 1), the jury necessarily
found that she had the intent to unlawfully kill Mulvihill.”].)3 Both of
Lovejoy’s convictions were affirmed on appeal.4
3 We view it as an intriguing question whether our prior opinion
3
The Legislature subsequently extended relief to defendants convicted of
attempted murder based on the natural and probable consequences doctrine.
(Sen. Bill No. 775, ch. 551 (2021–2022 Reg. Sess.) § 1 (Senate Bill 775).)
Lovejoy then filed a petition for resentencing under former section 1170.95
(now section 1172.6). In her form petition, she alleged that she had been
“convicted of . . . attempted murder . . . following a trial” and “could not
presently be convicted of [conspiracy to murder] . . . or attempted murder
because of changes made to Penal Code §§ 188 and 189, effective January 1,
2019.”5 Following the appointment of counsel and briefing, the superior
court denied the petition in a detailed statement of decision, concluding that
Lovejoy “failed to make a prima facie showing for relief under section
[1172.6].”
constitutes law of the case on the question Lovejoy seeks to raise in her
resentencing petition. (See People v. Medrano (2024) 98 Cal.App.5th 1254,
1264, distinguishing People v. Harden (2022) 81 Cal.App.5th 45, 50.) But
because the Attorney General does not attempt to defend the trial court’s
ruling on that basis, we offer no opinion on the viability of that theory.
4 McDavid’s sentence was vacated and the matter was remanded for
resentencing. The resentencing order that followed was the subject of a
subsequent appeal. (See People v. McDavid (Apr. 29, 2024, S275940)
___ Cal.5th ___ [2024 Cal.Lexis 2292].)
5 The bracketed language was a handwritten interlineation on the form,
which as printed merely speaks of a conviction for “murder or attempted
murder” with no mention of conspiracy.
4
DISCUSSION
When a trial court reviews a petition for resentencing under section
1172.6, it must first decide if the petitioner has established a prima facie case
for relief under the statute. (Lewis, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 971.) The court
accepts the allegations as true and determines whether the petitioner would
be entitled to relief if he or she proves the allegations. (Ibid.) In making its
evaluation, the court may review the record of conviction—including the
charging documents, jury instructions, verdicts, and to a limited extent any
prior appellate opinion—to determine if the petitioner’s allegations are
conclusively rebutted by the record. (Id. p. 972; People v. Strong (2022)
13 Cal.5th 698, 708.) But the court may not engage in factfinding and
weighing credibility at the prima facie stage of petition review. (Lewis, at
p. 971.) A court’s decision to deny a resentencing petition at the prima facie
stage “ ‘is a purely legal conclusion, which we review de novo.’ ” (People v.
Ervin (2021) 72 Cal.App.5th 90, 101; see also People v. Flores (2022) 76
Cal.App.5th 974, 991.)
Because the legal analysis differs, we separately consider Lovejoy’s
contentions that she could no longer be convicted of either attempted murder
or conspiracy to commit murder because of the statutory changes effected by
Senate Bill 1437 and Senate Bill 775.
A. Conviction for Attempted Murder
Following the passage of Senate Bill 775 in 2022, it is now clear that
defendants like Lovejoy convicted of attempted murder are potentially
eligible for relief under section 1172.6 if the conviction could have been based
on the natural and probable consequences doctrine. Indeed, subdivision
(a)(1) of section 1172.6 “applies by its terms only to attempted murders based
on the natural and probable consequences doctrine.” (People v. Coley (2022)
5
77 Cal.App.5th 539, 548.) Accordingly, Lovejoy’s petition was properly denied
as to her attempted murder conviction only if the record affirmatively
demonstrates the jury did not rely on the natural and probable consequences
doctrine.
In finding that Lovejoy had failed to establish a prima facie case for
relief, the trial court focused on the fact that the jury convicted Lovejoy of
conspiracy to commit murder, which necessarily required a finding that she
intended to kill Mulvihill. In the court’s view, because the object of the
conspiracy to murder and the intended victim of the attempted murder were
the same person, the conspiracy verdict eliminated the possibility that jurors
relied on the natural and probable consequences doctrine to convict Lovejoy
of attempted murder.
Lovejoy contests this reasoning. She contends the jury could have
reasonably concluded from the evidence that she understood “McDavid would
only frighten Mulvihill when the two men met that night.” She points to
instructions provided to the jury regarding the crime of conspiracy,
emphasizing that the jurors were instructed not only with regard to the
conspiracy to commit murder as charged in count 1, but also as to the lesser
included offense of conspiracy to commit an assault with a firearm. She then
highlights an additional instruction on the liability of a conspirator for a
coconspirator’s acts. (CALCRIM No. 417.) This instruction told the jury that
a member of a conspiracy is liable not only for crimes she conspires to
commit, but also “for any act of any member of the conspiracy if that act is
done to further the conspiracy and that act is a natural and probable
consequence of the common plan or design of the conspiracy.” (Ibid., italics
added.) Relying on this combination of instructions, Lovejoy suggests we
cannot conclusively rule out the possibility that the jury may have utilized
6
an impermissible natural and probable consequences theory. As she phrases
it, she is entitled to an evidentiary hearing because “the jury instructions on
co-conspiracy liability permitted the jury to find her guilty of attempted
murder based upon the natural and probable consequences doctrine.”
In Lovejoy’s posited scenario, she and McDavid agreed that McDavid
would shoot in Mulvihill’s direction, intending to frighten him. But
thereafter, McDavid deviated from the plan and intended to kill Mulvihill
when he shot him. The jury nonetheless convicted Lovejoy of attempted
murder, reasoning that McDavid’s conduct—shooting Mulvihill with an
intent to kill—while not intended by Lovejoy was nonetheless a natural and
probable consequence of the conspiracy to assault him with a firearm. In
that way, McDavid’s malice/intent to kill was improperly imputed to Lovejoy.
Lovejoy is correct that at this stage of the proceedings, it is neither our
function nor that of the trial court to evaluate the likelihood the jury would
have accepted a factual scenario that would entitle the defendant to relief
under section 1172.6. At the prima facie stage, we can only consider whether
relief is possible given the record of conviction, including the jury’s verdicts
and instructions.
Here, the problem is that Lovejoy’s factual theory cannot be squared
with the instructions and the jury’s verdict. If the jury believed Lovejoy only
agreed to frighten Mulvihill, but relied on the natural and probable
consequence doctrine to convict her of attempted murder, it would have found
her guilty of the lesser included offense of conspiracy to commit assault with
a firearm. But that is not what happened. She, along with McDavid, were
convicted of conspiracy to commit murder, which necessarily required an
intent to kill. (CALCRIM No. 563 [requiring agreement “to intentionally and
unlawfully kill”].) And a finding that the defendant intended to kill
7
eliminates any need or reason to rely on the natural and probable
consequence doctrine.
The Supreme Court employed analogous reasoning in People v. Beck
and Cruz (2019) 8 Cal.5th 548 (Beck and Cruz), where the two defendants
were convicted of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder as
to the same victims. As Lovejoy argues here, defendants in Beck and Cruz
maintained “that the trial court’s conspiracy instructions improperly allowed
[them] to be convicted of first degree premeditated murder as an aider and
abettor under the natural and probable consequences doctrine.” (Id. at
p. 644.) Although the Attorney General conceded error in the giving of the
natural and probable consequences instruction, the Supreme Court found the
error harmless. In the court’s view, there was “no possibility” that
defendants “were found guilty of murder on a natural and probable
consequences theory” because they “were charged with [and convicted of]
conspiracy to murder, not conspiracy to commit a lesser crime that resulted
in murder.” (Id. at p. 645.)
In People v. Medrano (2021) 68 Cal.App.5th 177 (Medrano I), the
Court of Appeal relied on Beck and Cruz to affirm the denial of a
resentencing petition under former section 1170.95, holding that a defendant
concurrently convicted of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit
murder was ineligible for relief as a matter of law. (Medrano I, at p. 179.)
Just as Lovejoy relies on the natural and probable consequences language in
CALCRIM No. 417, the defendant in Medrano I cited similar language in the
instructions provided to his jury. (Medrano I, at p. 184 [quoting functionally
identical language from CALJIC No. 6.11].) The appellate court nonetheless
concluded that he “was not convicted of first degree murder under this
doctrine,” which focuses on the defendant’s intent to commit a lesser (target)
8
crime that has foreseeably greater consequences. (Medrano I, at p. 182.)
“Here,” the court emphasized, “the target offense was first degree murder”
and “[w]e know this because appellant was convicted of conspiracy to commit
first degree murder.” (Id. at pp. 182–183, italics omitted.)
The thrust of Lovejoy’s argument is that due to the statutory changes
effected by Senate Bill 1437, the jury should not have been given instructions
that allowed it to convict her of attempted murder based on a natural and
probable consequences theory. But in ruling on the adequacy of a prima facie
showing under section 1172.6, the issue is not whether there was a
theoretical error in the jury instructions. The relevant question is whether it
is possible Lovejoy was convicted of attempted murder based on a now-
impermissible theory, i.e., the natural and probable consequences doctrine.
As both Beck and Cruz and Medrano I make clear, the natural and probable
consequences instruction as applied to a conspiracy (CALCRIM No. 417) is
problematic in this context only where a defendant is convicted of murder or
attempted murder based on a conspiracy to commit “a lesser crime that
resulted in murder.” (Beck and Cruz, supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 645; see also
Medrano I, supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at p. 184 [“First degree murder was the
object of the conspiracy, not the natural and probable consequence of an act
committed to further the object of the conspiracy.”].) Here, where Lovejoy
was found guilty of conspiring with McDavid to murder Mulvihill, there is
no possibility she “could not presently be convicted of . . . attempted murder
because of changes to Section 188 or 189 made effective January 1, 2019
[by Senate Bill 1437].” (§ 1172.6, subd. (a)(3).)
Citing People v. Croy (1985) 41 Cal.3d 1 (Croy), Lovejoy argues that
“the existence of a conspiracy does not mandate that the jury accept every act
by a conspirator is in furtherance of the conspiracy.” In Croy, the defendant
9
was partying with a large group late one evening. He got into an argument
with a police officer who came to quiet the party. After the officer left, the
alleged conspiracy began when one member of the group declared, “ ‘I’m going
to shoot him,’ ” or “ ‘I’m going to shoot the sheriff.’ ” (Croy, supra, 41 Cal.3d
at p. 7.) The group then drove to defendant’s girlfriend’s house, where he
picked up his rifle, then continued on to a liquor store. Some of defendant’s
cohorts caused a disturbance inside the liquor store, harassing the store clerk
and apparently taking multiple boxes of ammunition. The clerk called the
police. Multiple police vehicles chased defendant’s fleeing car into the
mountains, with shots fired from defendant’s car towards the police along the
way. Defendant’s group took refuge in and around a cabin. A gun battle
ended with defendant fatally shooting an officer early the following morning.
(Id., at pp. 6–11, 17.)
The defendant was convicted of first degree murder in the death of the
officer. One theory was that the killing amounted to a felony murder that
occurred in the aftermath of the liquor store robbery. Relying on its earlier
decision in People v. Beeman (1984) 35 Cal.3d 547, the Supreme Court found
prejudicial error in the jury instructions on robbery, requiring reversal of that
conviction. (Croy, supra, 41 Cal.3d at pp. 6, 15–16.) It also reversed the first
degree murder conviction, concluding it might have been based on the invalid
robbery coupled with the felony murder rule. (Id. at p. 16.) In doing so, the
court rejected the Attorney General’s argument that defendant’s conviction
for conspiracy to commit murder necessarily established that he harbored
malice when he killed the officer, reasoning that “[t]he conspiracy conviction,
without more, cannot provide the predicate for appellant’s first degree
murder conviction.” (Id. at p. 17.)
10
Lovejoy views Croy as establishing a timing principle requiring a
separate finding that defendant harbored an intent to kill at the time of the
actual shooting. In her view, the fact that the jury found she and McDavid
intended to kill Mulvihill at some earlier point in time, when their conspiracy
was formed, does not necessarily mean she had the same intent on the night
of the shooting when she drove McDavid to the scene of the attack. As a
result, she contends, some jurors could have resorted to the natural and
probable consequences theory to convict even if they concluded she did not
intend to kill when the crucial shot was fired. Lovejoy is mistaken in her
reading of the law.
It is important to recognize that the natural and probable consequences
doctrine was not an issue in Croy. More importantly, the defendant there
was prosecuted as the actual shooter, not an aider and abettor. For an aider
and abettor of murder or attempted murder, the timing of the necessary
mental state is analyzed differently where there is a preexisting conspiracy to
commit murder. A conspiracy is presumed to continue until its object is
achieved or frustrated. (People v. Saling (1972) 7 Cal.3d 844, 852, 859.)
A defendant’s responsibility for a coconspirator’s pursuit of that object
continues until she affirmatively rejects or repudiates it and communicates
that repudiation to her former cohorts. (People v. Crosby (1962) 58 Cal.2d
713, 730; People v. Ochoa (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 15, 33–34.) “A defendant’s
mere failure to continue previously active participation in a conspiracy . . .
is not enough to constitute withdrawal.” (Crosby, at p. 730.)
Here, Lovejoy has maintained she never agreed with McDavid that
Mulvihill should be killed. But she has not asserted she withdrew from a
conspiracy to commit murder that the jury found she joined. The jury was
never instructed pursuant to CALCRIM No. 420 regarding withdrawal from a
11
conspiracy, which would have been required had there been substantial
evidence to support such a theory. (See Bench Notes to CALCRIM No. 420.)
Nor did Lovejoy argue on direct appeal that the trial court erred in failing to
do so. Under these circumstances, the jury’s finding that Lovejoy intended to
kill Mulvihill when the conspiracy was formed continued to make her
criminally responsible for McDavid’s efforts to achieve that result without
any additional finding regarding Lovejoy’s specific mental state at the time of
the shooting.6
6 In a variation on the same theme, Lovejoy also cites the Supreme
Court’s recent decision in Curiel, supra, 15 Cal.5th 433 for the proposition
that a finding of intent to kill “does not, itself, conclusively establish that
[she] is ineligible for relief.” (Id. at p. 441.) But the circumstances of Curiel
are readily distinguishable. There, the defendant was charged with murder
based on alternative theories of direct aiding and abetting and aiding and
abetting based on the natural and probable consequences doctrine. (Id. at
p. 446.) The jury verdict did not specify which theory the jury adopted.
A separate sentencing enhancement, found true by the jury, determined that
the defendant intended to kill the victim and that the murder was carried out
to further a criminal street gang’s activities. Even so, the Supreme Court
determined that where the jury was permitted to find aiding and abetting
liability for murder based on the now-prohibited natural and probable
consequences doctrine, the abstract presence of an intent to kill was not
enough to show that the defendant remained guilty of murder after the
recent amendments to section 188. It still must be established that the
defendant knew the perpetrator intended to kill and acted to aid the
commission of that killing. (Curiel, at p. 463.)
Unlike in Curiel, Lovejoy’s jury was never instructed on aiding and
abetting liability for attempted murder based on a natural and probable
consequences theory. As we have explained, the only instruction on natural
and probable consequences pertained to the liability of a conspirator for the
acts of her coconspirators. And the only conspiracy of which Lovejoy was
convicted was a conspiracy to commit murder. Moreover, Lovejoy’s jury was
specifically instructed that to convict her of a conspiracy to commit murder,
jurors had to find not merely that she intended to kill Mulvihill, but also that
the members of the conspiracy agreed to kill him and that one or both
coconspirators committed an overt act to accomplish the killing.
12
B. Conviction for Conspiracy to Commit Murder
Lovejoy relies on a similarly misdirected reading of the law and
instructions in arguing that she made a prima facie case for resentencing
relief on her conspiracy conviction. She again focuses on the natural and
probable consequences language in CALCRIM No. 417 to suggest that the
jury could have found her guilty of conspiracy to commit murder based on
McDavid’s malice being imputed to her. She is mistaken.
To begin with, the express terms of section 1172.6 provide the potential
for resentencing relief only for persons convicted of murder, attempted
murder, or manslaughter. Conspiracy to murder is not mentioned in the
statute. As the court explained in People v. Whitson (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 22
(Whitson), one key purpose of Senate Bill 775 was to “include convictions for
attempted murder and manslaughter in the list of crimes subject to petition.”
(Whitson, at p. 34.) Whitson found it “particularly significant” that “the
Legislature had the opportunity to extend [resentencing] relief to conspiracy
to murder convictions alongside attempted murder and manslaughter
convictions, but did not.” (Id. at pp. 34–35.) As a result, the appellate court
concluded, section 1172.6 “does not permit a challenge to a conviction for
conspiracy to murder.” (Whitson, at p. 35.)
As Whitson goes on to explain, the failure to include conspiracy to
commit murder in the list of offenses eligible for resentencing relief is
entirely consistent with the legislative purposes in enacting both Senate Bills
1437 and 775—“to ensure, with certain exceptions related to felony murder
that ‘a conviction for murder requires that a person act with malice
aforethought,’ and that ‘culpability for murder [is] premised upon that
person’s own actions and subjective mens rea.’ (Stats. 2018, ch. 1015, § 1,
subd. (g).)” (Whitson, supra, 79 Cal.App.5th at p. 35.) Contrary to Lovejoy’s
13
assertion, a conviction of conspiracy to commit murder “is based on the
conspirator defendant’s own subjective mens rea [and] requires that a
defendant either act with malice or intend to kill.” (Id. at pp. 35–36, italics
added, citing Medrano I, supra, 68 Cal.App.5th at pp. 182–183; see People v.
Swain (1996) 12 Cal.4th 593, 607 [“conviction of conspiracy to commit murder
requires a finding of intent to kill”].)
Lovejoy inexplicably argues that the natural and probable consequence
language in CALCRIM No. 417, coupled with the prosecutor’s argument
linking the conspiracy with the attempted murder, “funneled the jury into
convicting appellant of conspiracy to commit murder without ever having to
find that appellant had the intent to murder.” To the contrary, the
instruction on conspiracy to commit murder (CALCRIM No. 563) required the
jury to find both that: (1) Lovejoy “intended to agree and did agree with
[McDavid] to intentionally and unlawfully kill”; and (2) “At the time of the
agreement, [Lovejoy] and [McDavid] intended that one or more of them would
intentionally and unlawfully kill[.]” (Ibid., italics added.) The jury was also
told that the prosecution “must prove that the members of the alleged
conspiracy had an agreement and intent to commit murder.” (Ibid., italics
added.) Thus, in convicting Lovejoy of conspiracy to commit murder, the jury
necessarily found she joined a conspiracy that had as its object killing
Mulvihill and that she personally intended to kill him. She could not have
been convicted of conspiracy to murder based on McDavid’s imputed malice.
Lovejoy further suggests that the instructions “allowed the prosecution
to bootstrap the weaker charge (conspiracy to commit murder) with the
charge with the vastly stronger evidence, attempted murder.” But the
linkage she identifies is not due to any erroneous instruction; it is a function
of the facts of the case and the jury’s finding that Lovejoy agreed with
14
McDavid to kill Mulvihill and then attempted to carry out that plan.
Her arguments ignore the fact that CALCRIM No. 417, which addresses
a coconspirator’s liability for acts committed by other members of the
conspiracy, did not become relevant until the jury found the existence of a
conspiracy to commit murder in which each of the coconspirators possessed
an intent to kill the victim.
In short, because the jury necessarily found that Lovejoy personally
possessed an intent to kill as part of a conspiracy to commit murder, she is
ineligible for relief under section 1172.6. (People v. Allen (2023) 97
Cal.App.5th 389, 393, 398.)
DISPOSITION
The order denying Lovejoy’s petition for resentencing is affirmed.
DATO, J.
WE CONCUR:
O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.
BUCHANAN, J.
15
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.