CourtListener 10870823•In re H.D. CA4/1
Texto completo
Filed 6/5/26 In re H.D. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
In re H.D., a Person Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
S.D. COUNTY HEALTH AND HUMAN D087487
SERVICES AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. J521542)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Alexander M. Calero, Judge. Affirmed.
Jacob I. Olson, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Damian M. Brown, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, Katie Abajian, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
I. INTRODUCTION
A.P. (Mother) appeals the juvenile court’s visitation order, arguing the
court abused its discretion in not ordering unsupervised visitation with
then one-and-a-half-year-old H.D. (Child) at the six-month review stage of
this dependency case. We conclude the court reasonably considered the
totality of circumstances, including the nature of Child’s harm, Mother’s
delayed engagement in services, and a new domestic violence incident, in
finding that supervised visitation was in Child’s best interest. We affirm the
order.
II. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Events Leading to the Petition
Child came to the attention of the San Diego County Health and
Human Services Agency (Agency) in September 2024 after Mother called the
police to report that Child’s father (Father)1 had hit her on her head while
she was holding Child, an infant at the time. According to the police report,
Mother disclosed several prior unreported domestic violence incidents
between her and Father.
In January 2025,2 the Agency received a referral alleging that
then six-month-old Child had bruising on his right cheek. Mother was unable
to explain how the injuries occurred. In an interview with a social worker,
Mother reported that Father hit her a few days earlier, causing a dark bruise
and blood in the corner of her left eye. A medical examination of Child
revealed he had previously sustained two bilateral skull fractures, a right
1 Because Father is not a party to this appeal, we discuss him only when
relevant.
2 All dates herein are for the year 2025, unless otherwise specified.
2
femur fracture, and a left tibia fracture. Initially, the parents denied
knowing how Child’s bruising or fractures occurred but later disclosed that
Child had fallen off the bed three to six times. Parents also described a
recent incident where, during an argument, Father pulled Child out of
Mother’s arms and Mother pulled Child back. Doctors reported that bruising
on children Child’s age was “incredibly rare” and concluded that Child’s
injuries were indicative of multiple instances of physical abuse. Father was
arrested for charges related to child abuse, and a criminal protective order
(CPO) protecting Mother and Child from Father was issued.
B. Petition and Detention Hearing
On January 9, the Agency filed a petition under Welfare and
Institutions Code3 section 300, subdivision (a), based on physical abuse. At
the detention hearing, the juvenile court ordered Child detained. It further
ordered voluntary services and separate, liberal, and supervised visitation for
the parents. The court afforded the Agency discretion to allow unsupervised
visitation and overnight visits. On January 14, Child was detained with a
relative caregiver.
C. Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
At the April 28 jurisdiction and disposition hearing, the Agency
reported that Mother was arrested on March 14 for spousal/cohabitant abuse
in connection with an altercation involving another individual. The victim
alleged that Mother got angry and swung at him because he would not give
Mother money to buy alcohol. Law enforcement observed several scratches
on the victim’s neck and arms.
3 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
3
The juvenile court found the Agency met its burden of establishing by a
preponderance of the evidence the allegations in the petition were true. In
reaching its decision, the court considered Mother’s admission to domestic
violence between her and Father, Mother’s recent arrest for domestic
violence, and the medical professionals’ opinions that the injuries were
consistent with multiple instances of physical abuse. The court also noted
that mother violated the CPO by communicating with Father while he was
incarcerated. The court concluded that Child was at substantial risk of
serious physical harm in the future. The court also found by clear and
convincing evidence that removal was appropriate, ordered continued
supervised visits subject to the CPO, and rejected Mother’s request to expand
visitation.
D. Agency Reports and the Six-month Review
In its October 27 status review report and supporting documents, the
Agency reported that Mother visited Child two to three times per week in a
supervised setting and the interaction with Child was positive. Mother’s case
plan required her to take steps to avoid domestic violence, monitor and pay
attention to Child, develop a positive support system, and refrain from
physically abusing Child. As a component of her case plan, Mother was
required to participate in a nonprotective parenting/child abuse group. At
the time of the status review report, however, Mother had been discharged
from this group due to excessive no-shows. The Agency submitted a second
referral for the nonprotective parenting/child abuse class. The Agency
advised that Mother needs to consistently engage in services to address the
protective issues, and it recommended that Child remain with the relative
caregiver with supervised visitation for Mother.
4
In its December 15 addendum, the Agency reported that Mother
continued to have consistent and positive supervised visits with Child, but it
still had concerns about Mother’s level of understanding about the need for
services and the severity of Child’s injuries. Mother had declined parenting
services. The nonprotective parenting/child abuse class rejected the Agency’s
second referral due to concerns relating to Mother bringing alcohol to the
group and wearing inappropriate attire. The Agency’s recommendations
remained unchanged.
At the six-month review hearing on January 14, 2026, the juvenile
court received into evidence the Agency’s October 27 and December 15
reports and a letter from Community Services for Families, which showed
that Mother had participated in three in-home parenting education sessions.
Mother was also scheduled to begin nonprotective parenting/child abuse
group services in January 2026. Mother requested the court return Child to
her care or, alternatively, expand her visitation to structured, unsupervised
visits.
The juvenile court acknowledged the barriers Mother faced in making
progress on her case plan, commended her renewed engagement in services,
but determined that additional progress was necessary to address the
protective concerns before visitation could be expanded. The court also
considered the serious physical harm Child suffered, the parents’ lack of
explanation for the injuries, and Mother’s continued involvement in domestic
violence with someone other than Father. Adopting the Agency’s
recommendations, the court ordered continued placement for Child and
supervised visits with Agency discretion to expand the visits.
5
III. DISCUSSION
Mother contends the juvenile court abused its discretion in not ordering
unsupervised visitation with then one-and-a-half-year-old Child at the
six-month review hearing. “One of the dependency court’s responsibilities is
to define the rights of the parties to visitation by balancing the rights of the
parent with the best interests of the child.” (In re R.R. (2010) 187
Cal.App.4th 1264, 1284.) “Visitation shall be as frequent as possible,
consistent with the well-being of the child.” (§ 362.1, subd. (a)(1)(A).) In
balancing these interests, the court in the exercise of its discretion may
impose “conditions or requirements” on visitation consistent with the child’s
best interest. (In re Jennifer G. (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 752, 757.) We review
an order setting visitation for abuse of discretion. (In re R.R., at p. 1284.)
Here, the juvenile court’s decision at the 6-month review hearing was
reasonable in view of the evidence presented. The court had already made it
clear to Mother that, in addition to consistent and regular visitation with
Child, Mother would need to make significant progress in resolving the
problems that led to removal and demonstrate a capacity and ability to
complete the objectives of the treatment plan. Although the court granted
the Agency discretion to lift supervision upon proof that Mother had made
progress with her services, the record shows Mother minimally complied with
her case plan and did not adequately address the underlying domestic
violence that led to removal. In these circumstances, it was reasonable for
the court to once again conclude that allowing Mother to care for Child
unsupervised was not in his best interest at this early stage of the
proceeding—particularly given that Child was only one and a half years old
at the time of the hearing. (See In re T.M. (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 1214, 1220
[explaining “ ‘[w]hile visitation is a key element of reunification, the court
6
must focus on the best interests of the child[] “and on the elimination of
conditions which led to the juvenile court’s finding that the child has suffered,
or is at risk of suffering, harm specified in section 300” ’ ”].)
The juvenile court’s decision was also supported by the fact that Mother
engaged in a violent confrontation with another individual after Child was
removed. This offered further grounds for the court to be concerned about
Mother providing unsupervised care for Child, notwithstanding their positive
supervised visits. The court therefore acted within its discretion to protect
the safety of Child. (§ 362.1, subd. (a)(1)(B).)
Finally, the juvenile court granted the Agency discretion to allow
Mother unsupervised and/or overnight visits with 72 hours’ notice to Child’s
counsel. The court may delegate discretion to the Agency regarding “the
time, place and manner of the visits” (In re Christopher H. (1996)
50 Cal.App.4th 1001, 1009), and we assume the Agency will exercise this
discretion with the goal of normalizing contact between Mother and Child
when it is safe to do so in the exercise of its “statutory mandate to supervise
each case in a manner consistent with the child’s best interests.” (Moriah T.
(1994) 23 Cal.App.4th 1367, 1376.)
7
IV. DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s visitation order is affirmed.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.
CASTILLO, J.
8
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.