People v. Zaragosa CA4/1

CourtListener 10865728Calctapp28 de mai. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 5/28/26 P. v. Zaragosa CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D084814

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v. (Super. Ct. No. 24AD-000285)

JESUS ZARAGOSA JR.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Bernardino
County, David S. Cohn, Judge. Remanded with directions.
Sheila O’Connor, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Thomas S. Patterson, Assistant Attorney
General, R. Matthew Wise and Kevin L. Quade, Deputy Attorneys General,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Jesus Zaragosa Jr. appeals the denial of his application for a concealed
carry weapon license. Statutory changes since Zaragosa first applied mean
that, even if Zaragosa might have once been entitled to obtain a concealed
carry license, he may not possess one if he is a “disqualified person” under
Penal Code section 26202. (Pen. Code, § 26195(b).) Although the trial court
found Zaragosa disqualified, the underlying record is years old and may not
comply with current statutorily required investigation standards. (See
§ 26202(b).) We therefore remand to the trial court with directions to remand
the matter to the licensing authority to investigate whether Zaragosa is a
disqualified person ineligible to hold a concealed carry license under
sections 26195(b) and 26202.
I.
A.
In 2023, the law provided that the licensing authority “may issue” a
concealed carry license upon proof that the applicant “is of good moral
character,” among other requirements. (Former § 26150, subd. (a)(1),
amended by Stats. 2023, ch. 249, § 10.)
Zaragosa applied for a license to carry a concealed weapon in 2023.
In his application, Zaragosa answered various background questions.
He indicated he drinks alcoholic beverages “[r]arely and [in] small
amount[s],” citing “low tolerance.” Zaragosa disclosed that he “was given”
antidepressants to treat his depression. As a minor, Zaragosa was arrested
on a drug-related charge that was later dismissed. According to Zaragosa,
the only time he has used physical force against anyone was to defend
himself during a school fight when he was 17 years old.
On matters of domestic violence, restraining orders, and losing his
temper, Zaragosa explained that he was the subject of a six-month
restraining order in 2011 because of “claims” he threatened the protected
person’s life. Zaragosa’s daughter later accused that same person of rape,
which prompted the person to seek another restraining order against
Zaragosa in 2022 because “he feels that [Zaragosa] might hurt him.” In 2022,

2
Zaragosa obtained a three-year civil harassment restraining order protecting
him and his children from this same person.
Zaragosa underwent a psychological evaluation as part of his
application. Under “Interview Impressions,” the evaluator indicated “No
Concerns,” yet he identified “Mental health concerns” elsewhere. According
to the evaluation summary, Zaragosa responded to an assessment “in a
guarded, defensive manner, possibly invalid[at]ing the protocol results.” As a
result, “the test results were inconclusive for the presence or absence of
mental illness.” Zaragosa reported being treated for depression and anxiety
in 2021. He told the evaluator that he took medication to treat those
symptoms for one month before discontinuing use.
An investigator determined Zaragosa lacked good moral character and
should not be issued a license based on his “psychological evaluation, where
he presented as guarded and defensive along with him consuming alcoholic
beverages potentially mixed with psych meds.”
The licensing agency denied Zaragosa’s application after finding he
lacked good moral character. The sheriff denied Zaragosa’s appeal.
B.
Effective in 2024, the law on concealed carry licenses changed
significantly. Under the amended law, a licensing authority “shall” issue a
concealed carry license upon proof that, among other things, the applicant “is
not a disqualified person” under the standards set in section 26202.
(§ 26150(a)(1), added by Stats. 2023, ch. 249, § 10.) Relevant here, a
“disqualified person” is someone who (1) “[i]s reasonably likely to be a danger
to self, others, or the community at large, as demonstrated by anything in the
application for a license or through the investigation described in
subdivision (b), or as shown by the results of any psychological assessment”;

3
or (2) has been subject to a restraining order within five years of the
application’s completion, with some caveats. (§ 26202(a)(1)-(3).) Those
disqualifying prohibitions “shall apply whether or not the relevant conduct,
order, conviction, charge, commitment, or other relevant action took place or
was issued or entered before” the subdivisions effective date. (§ 26202(e).)
When an applicant challenges a disqualified person determination in
court, the People bear the burden to show the applicant is disqualified by a
preponderance of the evidence. (§ 26206(e).)
Zaragosa challenged his license denial in the trial court in 2024. At a
closed hearing, the trial court expressed concern about the restraining order
and the psychological evaluation. Zaragosa explained that, after he obtained
the restraining order against the person who allegedly sexually assaulted his
daughter, that individual obtained a temporary restraining order and sought
a restraining order against Zaragosa “out of retaliation.” The TRO, however,
did not result in a permanent restraining order because the court dismissed it
without prejudice after the individual failed to appear at the hearing. When
Zaragosa, then age 43, mentioned his drug-related arrest was at age 17, the
court said it was “going to disregard that all together” because Zaragosa was
a “juvenile at the time” and it “sounds like it didn’t result in a conviction.”
The trial court denied Zaragosa’s challenge after finding the People had
shown by a preponderance of the evidence that he is disqualified from
obtaining a license. Specifically, based on “[t]he existence of the [temporary]
restraining order within the prescribed period, history of drug use, the use of
psychiatric medications, [and] violence in the past,” the court found “there’s a
risk of danger to others and the community.”

4
II.
A.
We initially denied Zaragosa’s application to unseal the record. We
later notified the parties we were considering unsealing the appellate record
on our own motion and gave them an opportunity to oppose. (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.46(f).) Neither party opposed.
“[W]ithout a clear enumeration of specific facts alleged to be worthy of
the extraordinary measure of maintaining our records under seal, there is
simply no basis to conclude that unsealing the records will actually infringe
any interest of plaintiff’s or inflict any harm on” the plaintiff. (H.B. Fuller
Co. v. Doe (2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 879, 898.)
After further review, we unseal the record in this matter. The trial
court conducted the hearing in camera based on the People’s belief the
information to be discussed “would qualify as confidential,” and it placed the
exhibits submitted during the hearing under seal based on Zaragosa’s right
to privacy related to his medical information and section 26206(d)(1). But a
court should not conduct this hearing in camera unless it is established that
“confidential information is likely to be discussed during the hearing that
would cause harm to the person, . . . unless the court finds that the public
interest would be better served by conducting the hearing in public.”
(§ 26206(d)(1).) We have no evidence of how any of the sealed information
would harm Zaragosa, particularly given his earlier request to unseal it. And
section 26206(d)(1) requires only that an applicant’s criminal history report
be filed under seal. Here, however, the checks on Zaragosa’s criminal history
yielded no results. Because the record lacks specific grounds justifying
maintaining the record under seal, we unseal it. We retain as confidential,

5
however, the psychological evaluation and list of medication on pages 85
through 90 of the augmented clerk’s transcript.
B.
We agree with the parties that the court’s order is appealable. (Knoll v.
Davidson (1974) 12 Cal.3d 335, 343 [appeals from special proceeding
permitted unless statutorily prohibited].)
C.
Zaragosa argues the court erred and he should be issued a concealed
carry license. He seeks review under the 2023 version of the law, which he
contends is unconstitutional based on the former “good moral character”
requirement. But as the People note, regardless of whether Zaragosa might
have originally been entitled to a license, any such license “shall be revoked”
if, as the trial court found here, Zaragosa has become a “disqualified person”
under section 26202. (§ 26195(b).) Under the circumstances here, we
conclude the best course of action is to remand with directions for the trial
court to remand the matter to the licensing authority to investigate whether
Zaragosa is a “disqualified person” ineligible to hold a concealed carry license
under sections 26195(b) and 26202.
Zaragosa does not challenge the constitutionality of section 26195(b).
Zaragosa claims more broadly that applying the 2024 version of the law
would violate his due process rights because it (1) purportedly contained
contradictory provisions and (2) automatically disqualified persons from
obtaining a license if, as in his case, a TRO had been issued against them
within a certain timeframe. Yet subsequent amendments to the law on
concealed carry licenses have eliminated those purported issues. Effective in
2026, section 26205 deletes the former language directing the licensing
authority to “apply the statutory requirements in effect as of the date the

6
licensing authority received the completed application” that Zaragosa claimed
contradicted another provision. (Former § 26205(b), as amended by
Stats. 2025, ch. 570, § 9.) And now, an expired, vacated, or canceled
temporary restraining order issued without notice and a hearing does not
automatically disqualify a person from obtaining a license. (§ 26202(a)(3).)
Thus, the relevant question is whether Zaragosa is a disqualified
person under section 26202 such that, regardless of whether he might have
previously been entitled to one, he may not possess a concealed carry license.
(§ 26195(b).) The trial court found Zaragosa disqualified on two grounds.
First, because of the TRO, which under the 2024 version of the law was
automatically disqualifying but under the current 2026 version is not.
(§ 26202(a)(3).) Second, the court found Zaragosa presented “a risk of danger
to others and the community” based on “the existence of the [temporary]
restraining order within the prescribed period, history of drug use, the use of
psychiatric medications, [and] violence in the past.”
Although the court made a danger finding under section 26202(a)(1),
Zaragosa rightly points out that the licensing authority’s investigation “never
analyzed the circumstances and facts of Zaragosa’s application under that
standard.” In addition, it seems unlikely the original investigation satisfied
current standards. When assessing if an applicant is a disqualified person,
the licensing authority “shall conduct an investigation” that meets certain
minimum requirements, including an in-person interview of the applicant
and interviews with “at least three character references.” (§ 26202(b).)
Because the record from which the trial court made its finding was compiled
well over two years ago based on the 2023 version of the law and without
necessarily satisfying the current statutorily required investigatory
standards, we remand to the trial court with directions to remand to the

7
licensing authority to conduct a new investigation to determine if Zaragosa is
a disqualified person under sections 26195(b) and 26202.
III.
We remand to the trial court with directions to remand the matter to
the licensing authority to investigate whether Zaragosa is a “disqualified
person” ineligible to hold a concealed carry license under sections 26195(b)
and 26202.

CASTILLO, J.

WE CONCUR:

MCCONNELL, P. J.

RUBIN, J.

8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.