CourtListener 10864349•In re M.M. CA4/3
Texto completo
Filed 5/26/26 In re M.M. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re M.M., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G066239
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. 19DP0654A)
v.
OPINION
I.M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
June Jee An, Judge. Conditionally reversed and remanded.
Jesse McGowan, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant I.M.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Chloe R.
Maksoudian, Deputies County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance for the Minor.
* * *
I.M. (Father) appeals from a juvenile court order terminating
parental rights to his minor child following a hearing held under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.26.1 He contends the Orange County Social
Services Agency (SSA) failed to comply with its inquiry obligations under the
Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.; ICWA) and the
related state legislation (§ 224 et seq.). SSA concedes the error and
acknowledges the challenged orders must be conditionally reversed. We
conclude conditional reversal for the sole purpose of ICWA compliance is
required because SSA failed to conduct an adequate initial inquiry of Father
prior to the court terminating parental rights, and we remand the matter for
compliance with ICWA.
FACTS2
In September 2023, SSA successfully sought a protective custody
warrant removing M.M., the then four-year-old minor (minor), from Mother’s
care. At the time, Father was in prison and Mother reported he had a parole
eligibility date in February 2024. The warrant application indicated SSA
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2 Because the sole issue on appeal concerns ICWA compliance,
the facts we recite are likewise limited to ICWA related matters.
2
asked Mother and the maternal grandmother about Indian heritage and they
both denied any such ancestry.3
A subsequently filed juvenile dependency petition alleged, inter
alia, Mother had an unresolved substance abuse problem and had exposed
the minor to domestic violence between her and the maternal grandmother,
with whom they lived. It further alleged Father had an unresolved substance
abuse problem, had a history of violence against others, and had not
provided, and could not provide, safety, support, and protection for the minor.
Both the petition and the detention report stated SSA once again asked
Mother and the maternal grandmother about any Indian heritage and they
denied any such ancestry. The maternal grandfather was asked about the
same and also denied any Indian ancestry. Although the reports included the
name of the prison where Father was incarcerated and his California
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation number, the detention report
conveyed SSA had been unable to interview him.
At the initial detention hearing, Mother’s counsel provided a form
to the juvenile court which indicated Mother had no reason to believe the
minor is or may be an Indian child. Mother’s counsel represented the same.
Father, who was incarcerated at the time, was appointed counsel. The court
deferred making any ICWA findings. It also ordered: (1) Father’s counsel to
file a completed ICWA form before the next hearing; (2) Mother and Father to
provide SSA with the names of any relatives to assist SSA with its duty of
inquiry under ICWA; and (3) SSA to continue its due diligence under ICWA
and make any relevant information known to the court in the future.
3 We use the term “Indian” throughout to be consistent with the
language used in both federal and state law. No disrespect is intended.
3
Subsequent reports detailed further ICWA related inquiry by
SSA. A maternal uncle denied Indian heritage. While SSA also attempted to
contact the paternal grandfather, they instead reached his adoptive mother
who confirmed he lived with her but said she was not home at the time. She
was asked for, but did not have, contact information for the paternal
grandmother. SSA asked her to have the paternal grandfather contact SSA.
When SSA later spoke with the paternal grandfather, he said he “did not
know as he never looked up his family history.” A paternal cousin “reported
having researched her family’s DNA history and stated according to the
results, their family has some Native American and Indigenous background.
However, she was not able to provide further information as she did not know
the tribal name.”
After continuing the jurisdictional hearing multiple times so
Father’s counsel could contact him and Father could appear remotely, the
juvenile court held the hearing in February 2024. Father was physically
present, in custody. The court did not inquire about, or make any mention of,
ICWA during the hearing or as part of its ruling on the jurisdictional issues.
A subsequent SSA report provided an updated prison location
and address for Father. While SSA mailed various documents to him, there
was no indication any of them concerned ICWA.
Father was once again present, in custody, at the disposition
hearing. The juvenile court did not inquire about, or make any mention of,
ICWA during the hearing or as part of its dispositional order.4
4 Father appealed from the disposition order and raised the sole
issue of noncompliance with ICWA. This court dismissed the appeal because
the lack of an ICWA finding at or before the dispositional hearing made the
ICWA issue not ripe for review.
4
Prior to the six-month review hearing, SSA sent at least two
certified letters to Father inquiring about Indian ancestry. Although SSA was
unsuccessful in making contact with the paternal grandfather and cousin
with whom it had previously spoken, SSA spoke with Father’s paternal
grandmother, who was also his legal mother by adoption. She conveyed her
deceased father-in-law “used to claim that he had Native American heritage”
and they used to travel to New Mexico to visit family which may have been
part of a tribe, but she did not believe he was ever registered. Based on this
information, SSA noted in a report that there was reason to believe ICWA
may apply and documented its outreach to the Bureau of Indian Affairs, to
which it had not yet received a response.
After continuing the 12-month review hearing multiple times so
Father could appear, the juvenile court held the hearing in March 2025 and
Father appeared virtually. No ICWA related inquiry was made at the
hearing. Before terminating reunification services, the court found ICWA did
not apply.
No additional ICWA related inquiry occurred in the seven-month
period between the termination of reunification services and the section
366.26 hearing. Ultimately, at the section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile court
terminated Mother’s and Father’s parental rights to the minor and ordered
the minor placed for adoption. It did not make any ICWA related inquiries at
the hearing or any additional ICWA related findings. Father was present in
person and testified.
Father timely appealed from the order terminating parental
rights. Mother did not appeal.
5
DISCUSSION
The sole issue raised by Father on appeal is whether SSA
complied with its inquiry obligations under ICWA. He contends SSA’s inquiry
was deficient because it never asked him about Indian ancestry after he was
released from prison even though it was in contact with him on multiple
occasions and he appeared in court. SSA concedes the ICWA error and
acknowledges conditional reversal of the parental rights termination order is
required to allow for ICWA compliance. We agree.
“‘ICWA is a federal law giving Indian tribes concurrent
jurisdiction over state court child custody proceedings that involve Indian
children living off of a reservation. [Citations.] Congress enacted ICWA to
further the federal policy “‘that, where possible, an Indian child should
remain in the Indian community . . . .’”’” (In re A.R. (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th
197, 203.) To that end, the federal regulatory scheme implementing ICWA
requires the provision of certain notice to “ensure[] that an Indian tribe is
aware of its right to intervene in or, where appropriate, exercise jurisdiction
over a child custody proceeding involving an Indian child.” (In re Isaiah W.
(2016) 1 Cal.5th 1, 8 (Isaiah W.); see In re J.C. (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 70, 77
5th (J.C.).)
In California, section 224.2 “codifies and elaborates on ICWA’s
requirements of notice to a child’s parents or legal guardian, Indian
custodian, and Indian tribe, and to the [Bureau of Indian Affairs].” (Isaiah
W., supra, 1 Cal.5th at p. 9.) More specifically, the statute “creates three
distinct duties regarding ICWA in dependency proceedings. First, from
[SSA]’s initial contact with a minor and [their] family, the statute imposes a
duty of inquiry to ask all involved persons whether the child may be an
Indian child. [Citation.] Second, if that initial inquiry creates a ‘reason to
6
believe’ the child is an Indian child, then [SSA] ‘shall make further inquiry
regarding the possible Indian status of the child, and shall make that inquiry
as soon as practicable.’ [Citation.] Third, if that further inquiry results in a
reason to know the child is an Indian child, then the formal notice
requirements of section 224.3 apply.” (In re D.S. (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1041,
1052; see also In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1132–1133 (Dezi C.).)
“‘“‘The juvenile court must determine whether proper notice was
given under ICWA and whether ICWA applies to the proceedings.’”
[Citation.] “If the court makes a finding that proper and adequate further
inquiry and due diligence as required in [section 224.2] have been conducted
and there is no reason to know . . . the child is an Indian child, the court may
make a finding that [ICWA] does not apply to the proceedings, subject to
reversal based on sufficiency of the evidence.”’” (J.C., supra, 77 Cal.App.5th
at p. 78.)
Here, SSA had difficulty contacting Father at times because he
was incarcerated. However, Father appeared in person or remotely for
multiple court hearings. Neither SSA nor the juvenile court asked him any
questions concerning Indian ancestry during those times. In addition, SSA
facilitated one in person visit between Father and the minor, but no ICWA
related inquiry took place. On such a record, particularly given the potential
tribal affiliation mentioned by the paternal cousin and Father’s paternal
grandmother, we must conditionally reverse the challenged orders and
remand the matter to allow for ICWA compliance. (See § 224.2, subds. (b) &
(c) [duty to inquire includes asking, inter alia, parents]; 25 U.S.C. § 1912(a)
[duty to inquire of each participant]; 25 C.F.R. § 23.107(a) (2026)
[participants include parents]; Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1136
[inadequate initial inquiry “requires conditional reversal with directions for
7
the child welfare agency to comply with” ICWA inquiry, documentation, and
notice requirements].)
Because the minor has been without certainty and permanency
for more than two and a half years since being removed from Mother’s care,
we strongly urge SSA, the juvenile court, and counsel to diligently work to
ensure ICWA’s requirements are satisfied without unnecessarily delaying
resolution of this dependency matter.
DISPOSITION
The order terminating Mother’s and Father’s parental rights is
conditionally reversed and the matter is remanded to the juvenile court. On
remand, the court shall conduct further proceedings, as necessary, for the
limited purpose of ensuring full compliance with ICWA and related California
law. If the court finds, after proper inquiry and notice, the minor is not an
Indian child as defined by ICWA, the order terminating parental rights shall
be reinstated. Alternatively, if the court determines ICWA applies, the court
shall vacate the order terminating parental rights and conduct further
proceedings consistent with ICWA.
DELANEY, J.
WE CONCUR:
MOORE, ACTING P. J.
SANCHEZ, J.
8
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.