CourtListener 10863034•Urias v. Dept. of Motor Vehicles CA5
Texto completo
Filed 5/21/26 Urias v. Dept. of Motor Vehicles CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
CAYETANO SALDANA URIAS,
F089406
Plaintiff and Appellant,
(Super. Ct. No. BCV-24-100410-TSC)
v.
DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR VEHICLES, OPINION
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Kern County. Thomas S.
Clark, Judge.
Middlebrook & Associates, Richard O. Middlebrook and Gabrielle Burnett for
Plaintiff and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Chris A. Knudsen, Assistant Attorney General,
Gabrielle H. Brumbach, Thomas F. Cochrane and Linda G. Ronan, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Defendant and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
This appeal involves the suspension of appellant Cayetano Saldana Urias’s
driver’s license following an administrative per se (APS) hearing. An administrative
hearing officer (AHO) for respondent Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) concluded
that Urias had driven his vehicle with a blood-alcohol content (BAC) of 0.08 or greater
and upheld the suspension of his driver’s license. The AHO’s decision was subsequently
upheld by the Kern County Superior Court. In this appeal, Urias contends that: (1) his
due process rights were violated because the AHO acted as the advocate for the DMV and
the adjudicator; (2) his arrest was unlawful because reasonable suspicion did not support
his initial seizure; and (3) alternatively, even if reasonable suspicion existed for the initial
seizure, his continued seizure was not supported by reasonable suspicion. We affirm.
APS SYSTEM
In California, the DMV must immediately suspend the driver’s license of a person
who is driving with a BAC of 0.08 or more. (Veh. Code, § 13353.2, subd. (a)(1).)1
However, drivers have a right to an administrative hearing, that is an APS hearing, before
the suspension of a license takes effect. (Cisneros v. Department of Motor Vehicles
(2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 381, 408.) At the APS hearing, an AHO determines: whether an
arresting officer had reasonable cause to believe the driver was driving under the
influence, whether the driver was lawfully arrested, and whether the driver was driving
with a BAC of 0.08 or greater. (Evans v. Gordon (2019) 41 Cal.App.5th 1094, 1101.)
The Legislature crafted the APS laws to address the time lag that often occurs between an
arrest and a conviction for driving while intoxicated or with a prohibited BAC level.
(MacDonald v. Gutierrez (2004) 32 Cal.4th 150, 155.) As a result, APS hearings are
intended to be expedited (Lake v. Reed (1997) 16 Cal.4th 448, 455, fn. 2 (Lake)), and the
rules governing the admissibility of evidence are relaxed. (McDonald, at p. 159.) The
DMV bears the burden at the APS hearing of demonstrating that the driver drove with a
1 All further statutory references are to the Vehicle Code.
2.
BAC of 0.08 or more. (Gerwig v. Gordon (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 59, 65 (Gerwig);
Petricka v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1341, 1348.)
Additionally, since April 2022, the DMV has been enjoined from requiring that AHO’s at
APS hearings act as both the adjudicator and the DMV’s advocate. (California DUI
Lawyers Association v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 517, 530–
533, 538 (CDLA)). The injunction was necessary because DMV policy mandated that
AHO’s act as both the adjudicator and the DMV’s advocate, which created a
constitutionally intolerable probability of bias and thus, deprived drivers of their due
process right to a constitutionally impartial adjudicator. (Id. at pp. 526, 532–533 & fn. 5.)
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On September 30, 2023, Urias was arrested for violation of section 23152,
subdivisions (a) and (b) (driving under the influence of alcohol with a BAC of 0.08 or
more).
On January 18, 2024, an APS hearing was conducted pursuant to section 13557.
On January 19, 2024, the AHO found that Urias had been lawfully arrested and
had driven with a BAC of 0.08 or more. As a result, Urias’s license was suspended
pursuant to sections 13353.2 and 13353.3.
On February 6, 2024, Urias filed an administrative petition for writ of mandate
with the Kern County Superior Court to challenge the suspension determination.
On October 11, 2024, the trial court denied the writ.
On February 27, 2025, Urias filed a notice of appeal.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
On September 30, 2023, at 3:45 a.m., Shafter Patrol Officer E. Davalos was
patrolling in the City of Shafter.2 As Davalos approached the intersection of Mannel
2 Pursuant to rule 8.90, we refer to some persons by their initials. No disrespect is
intended.
3.
Avenue and Handel Avenue, he saw a gray SUV at the further intersection of Mannel and
Fresno Avenue. The gray SUV did not come to a complete stop at the four-way signed
intersection of Mannel and Fresno but sped through the intersection at a high rate of
speed, which was a violation of section 22450, subdivision (a).
Davalos drove towards the intersection of Mannel and Fresno and then turned
down Fresno, where he saw the gray SUV’s taillight about a quarter of a mile ahead of
him. As Davalos was approaching the gray SUV, it turned down Eckman Street. When
Davalos turned down Eckman, he lost sight of the gray SUV. Davalos turned on Handel
to search for the gray SUV.
At the intersection of Handel and Tamera Avenue, Davalos “spotted a pair of
headlights and presumed it to be the same SUV [he] saw moments ago.” The vehicle
drove to Bree Drive, which ended in a cul-de-sac. Davalos followed and turned down
Bree.
As Davalos drove down Bree, he saw an SUV in the process of making a
three-point turn. After making the turn, the SUV drove towards Davalos. Because it was
dark in the early morning hours and there was low visibility, in order to get a better view,
Davalos activated his patrol vehicle’s “ ‘scene’ white lights.”3 The SUV then came to a
stop next to Davalos’s patrol vehicle. The SUV was a gray Acura MDX.
Davalos spoke to the driver of the gray SUV, who was later identified as Urias, at
approximately 3:47 a.m. Davalos asked if Urias was the person he saw speed through the
intersection of Mannel and Fresno, to which Urias answered, “ ‘No.’ ” Davalos then
asked what Urias was doing, and Urias responded that he came from Wasco to visit his
girlfriend, who lived on Kern Street in Shafter. Because Kern was about a quarter of a
3 “Scene white lights” appear to be additional lights on a patrol vehicle that are used
to help illuminate an area; they are not the traditional red and blue lights used to
effectuate a stop. (E.g., State v. Decanini-Hernandez (Iowa Ct.App. 2021) 957 N.W.2d
724.)
4.
mile away from where Urias and Davalos were stopped, Davalos believed that Urias was
lost. However, while he spoke with Urias, Davalos noticed that Urias had red watery
eyes, slow, slurred speech, and a flushed and sweaty face, even though it was only around
65 degrees outside. Based on these observations, Davalos suspected that Urias might be
driving under the influence of alcohol.
Davalos then ordered Urias to turn off the SUV, and Urias complied. Davalos
pulled his patrol vehicle behind the gray SUV, exited, and approached Urias. When he
was close to Urias, Davalos smelled the strong odor of alcohol coming from the gray
SUV. Davalos began to conduct a DUI investigation, including administering field
sobriety tests. Davalos ultimately arrested Urias for DUI at approximately 4:03 a.m.
Davalos administered a preliminary alcohol screening test at 4:16 a.m., which yielded a
BAC of 0.094. Davalos then administered two breath tests at 4:36 a.m. and 4:38 a.m.
The two tests yielded BAC levels of 0.084 and 0.083, respectively.
APS Hearing & Decision
On January 18, 2024, an APS hearing was held. Prior to the hearing, Urias
received a notice from the DMV that informed him of his right to provide evidence at the
APS hearing and that the AHO “will develop the facts and render a final decision on your
matter but does not advocate on behalf of the [DMV]. The [AHO] will ensure that all
relevant evidence is considered. The [AHO] will examine and admit the DMV’s official
records, [as] well as the official records of the agency that arrested you.” Consistent with
this pre-hearing advisement, the AHO informed Urias at the hearing that he (the AHO)
would be: “acting as a neutral factfinder,” was “prohibited from and will not act as an
advocate for the DMV or law enforcement,” and was to “review the evidence as
provided, ask clarifying questions of witnesses, if necessary, make legal rulings and
determinations under the relevant statutes as necessary.” The AHO then explained that
there were three issues for the hearing: (1) did Davalos have reasonable cause to believe
5.
Urias was driving under the influence; (2) was Urias lawfully arrested; and (3) was Urias
driving with a BAC of 0.08 or more?
After explaining the issues to be adjudicated, Urias’s counsel objected that the
structure of the APS hearing violated due process as explained by CDLA. The AHO
stated that he did not have the statutory authority to rule on the objection. The AHO then
introduced as exhibits Davalos’s unsworn police report, a sworn DMV investigative
report (the DS-367 form), and Urias’s DMV driving record. Urias objected to the
DS-367 form and Davalos’s police report in part as hearsay. The AHO overruled Urias’s
objection and admitted all three documents as exhibits. The AHO admitted no other
evidence and invited Urias to present his case. Urias’s counsel did not call any witnesses
but did argue that Urias was unlawfully detained because Davalos was unable to confirm
that Urias ran the stop sign. Counsel particularly noted that Urias was driving a gray
sedan and not a gray SUV.4 After Urias’s counsel finished her argument, the AHO
concluded the hearing.
On January 19, 2024, the AHO issued a written decision confirming the
suspension of Urias’s license. The AHO determined Urias was lawfully stopped,
reasonable cause existed for Urias’s arrest, and Urias drove with a BAC of 0.08 or more.
In part, the AHO more specifically determined that Davalos observed Urias running a
stop sign and that Davalos had reasonable suspicion to contact Urias because the vehicle
he was driving matched the description of the vehicle that Davalos had observed.
Trial Court Proceedings
On February 6, 2024, Urias filed a petition for peremptory writ of mandamus with
the Kern County Superior Court to set aside the suspension of his license. A hearing on
the writ was held on September 20, 2024, and a decision was issued on October 11, 2024.
4 In this appeal, Urias does not contend that he was driving a sedan.
6.
In relevant part, the trial court addressed the legality of Urias’s seizure and whether the
APS hearing violated Urias’s right to due process.
With respect to due process, the trial court found no constitutional violation.
Following Knudsen v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2024) 101 Cal.App.5th 186
(Knudsen) and appellate cases applying Knudsen, the court concluded the AHO
constitutionally collected and developed evidence and then adjudicated the matter
without impermissibly acting as an advocate on behalf of the DMV.
With respect to the initial seizure and continued seizure of Urias, the trial court
found Davalos had reasonable suspicion that Urias had run the stop sign because Urias’s
vehicle was the same type and color as the gray SUV, Urias’s vehicle was found within a
few minutes of, and in the same general area as, the traffic violation, and there were few
other vehicles on the road at 4:00 a.m. in that residential part of Shafter. The court noted
Urias was not seized merely because Davalos engaged his scene light, rather Urias
voluntarily stopped his vehicle next to Davalos. The court also found Davalos’s
observations of Urias were consistent with intoxication, and Davalos had reasonable
suspicion to order Urias to turn off the SUV and initiate a DUI investigation. The court
concluded that, after Urias’s breath tests revealed BAC’s of 0.084 and 0.083, Davalos had
probable cause and properly arrested Urias for DUI.
I. Due Process
A. Parties’ Arguments
Urias argues his due process rights were violated because the APS system requires
an AHO to act as both an adjudicator and an advocate who represents the DMV at the
APS hearing. Urias argues that Knudsen, and all of the cases that have followed
Knudsen, were wrongly decided and inconsistent with California Supreme Court
precedent and CDLA. In particular, Urias argues Knudsen took a dicta footnote from
CDLA out of context and improperly looked at the actions of an AHO instead of the role
of the AHO. Further, Urias argues the AHO’s actions of choosing what documents to
7.
introduce, admitting the documents into evidence, and then making a decision based on
those documents improperly combines advocacy with adjudication. Because it is the role
of the AHO to act on the DMV’s behalf, and thus act as its advocate, and because the
AHO engaged in advocacy by choosing which documents to admit into evidence, Urias
argues there was an unconstitutional probability of bias in his APS hearing. Urias
contends that this due process error is structural and that reversal is required.
The DMV argues that Urias’s due process rights were not violated. The DMV
argues the record demonstrates that the AHO merely gathered and developed evidence, in
addition to acting as the adjudicator. CDLA, California Supreme Court cases, Knudsen,
and cases following Knudsen all recognize that such a combination of roles in one person
is constitutionally permissible. The DMV also argues that there is no basis to disregard
Knudsen or cases that follow Knudsen, and that Urias is improperly reading and
expanding the holding of CDLA.
B. Legal Standard
Challenges to the procedural fairness of an administrative hearing present a
question of law that is reviewed de novo on appeal. (Romane v. Department of Motor
Vehicles (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1002, 1016, review granted Aug. 13, 2025, S291093
(Romane);5 Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at p. 210.) An irreducible minimum of the
federal and California constitutional rights to due process is that an impartial adjudicator
5 Urias asserts that our Supreme Court has determined that Romane conflicts with
CDLA based on the grant of review in Romane. As part of the grant of review, the
Supreme Court stated: “Pending review, the opinion of the Court of Appeal … may be
cited, not only for its persuasive value, but also for the limited purpose of establishing the
existence of a conflict in authority that would in turn allow trial courts to exercise
discretion … to choose between sides of any such conflict.” (Romane v. Department of
Motor Vehicles (2025) 335 Cal.Rptr.3d 275, 275–276.) Notably, the plain language of
this grant of review does not mention CDLA, does not state that a conflict actually exists,
and permits citation to Romane for its persuasive value only, irrespective of any actual or
potential conflict with published authority. Without more, we cannot agree that the
Supreme Court has determined Romane conflicts with CDLA.
8.
must preside over a hearing. (Today’s Fresh Start, Inc. v. Los Angeles County Office of
Education (2013) 57 Cal.4th 197, 212 (Today’s Fresh Start); Knudsen, at pp. 197–198.)
The requirement of an impartial adjudicator is violated if the adjudicator is actually
biased or operates under a constitutionally intolerable probability of bias. (Morongo
Band of Mission Indians v. State Water Resources Control Bd. (2009) 45 Cal.4th 731,
737; Knudsen, at p. 198.) A violation of the due process right to an impartial adjudicator
is a structural error that is not subject to a harm analysis. (Clarke v. Gordon (2024) 104
Cal.App.5th 1267, 1277 (Clarke); Knudsen, at p. 206.) The complaining party has the
burden of demonstrating a due process violation based on the absence of a
constitutionally impartial adjudicator by “com[ing] forward with ‘specific evidence
demonstrating actual bias or a particular combination of circumstances creating an
unacceptable risk of bias.’ ” (Today’s Fresh Start, at p. 221.)
Combining the roles of adjudicator and advocate into a single person is a violation
of the due process right to an impartial adjudicator because it creates a constitutionally
intolerable probability of bias. (Kazelka v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2025) 109
Cal.App.5th 1239, 1255 (Kazelka); Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at p. 199; CDLA,
supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at p. 532.) Whether an AHO at an APS hearing unconstitutionally
acted as the DMV’s advocate is determined by examining the record, hearing transcripts,
and the AHO’s decision to see if the AHO engaged in advocacy.6 (Romane, supra, 110
6 Recently, the First Distrct Court of Appeal disagreed with Romane’s and Clarke’s
use of Knudsen to resolve due process challenges to APS hearings that occurred after
CDLA. (Chi v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 119 Cal.App.5th 473, 484–487
(Chi).) Although Chi recognized that the actions of an AHO could be relevant to
demonstrating constitutional bias (Chi, pp. 486–487), it specifically faulted Clarke for
focusing on the appearance of bias, rather than on the presence of disqualifying interests
on the part of the adjudicator. (Chi, p. 486.) Nevertheless, Chi held that the post-CDLA
format for APS hearings, which permitted AHO’s to adjudicate and to collect and develop
evidence, did not violate the due process right to an impartial adjudicator because AHOs
act in an inquisitorial capacity under post-CDLA DMV policy. (Chi, pp. 482–484.)
Because the result will not change whether we follow Chi or Romane, and because the
9.
Cal.App.5th at p. 1020; Kazelka, at p. 1255; Clarke, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1275;
Knudsen, at pp. 206–207.) If the record shows the AHO engaged in advocacy, and thus
acted as the DMV’s advocate, then due process is violated, and the driver is entitled to a
new APS hearing before an impartial AHO. (Clarke, at p. 1275; Knudsen, at pp. 193,
212–213; cf. CDLA, at p. 533, fn. 5 [“[An AHO] must refrain … from advocating on
behalf of the DMV.”].)
C. Analysis
At Urias’s APS hearing, the AHO explained what issues would be decided and,
consistent with both the CDLA injunction and the DMV’s pre-hearing advisement,
explained that he would be “acting as a neutral factfinder.” The AHO advised that he was
“prohibited from and will not act as an advocate for the DMV or law enforcement,” and
was to “review the evidence as provided, ask clarifying questions of witnesses, if
necessary, make legal rulings and determinations under the relevant statutes as
necessary.” No witnesses were called or examined, and Urias’s counsel was permitted to
make her arguments without objection or interruption. The AHO offered and admitted
three records into evidence as exhibits: Urias’s driving record, Davalos’s arrest report,
and the DS-367 form. Urias objected to the DS-367 form and Davalos’s unsworn arrest
report on hearsay grounds, and the objections were overruled.7 After Urias’s counsel
issue is currently before the Supreme Court, we will follow the majority position as
reflected in Romane.
7 Urias does not argue the objections were improperly overruled, and we also detect
no error, let alone a clear and obvious error. (Cf. Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 212–213 [finding an unconstitutional probability of bias in part because the AHO
made a clear error of law that benefitted the DMV].) It is well established that the rules
governing the admission of evidence are relaxed at APS hearings (MacDonald v.
Gutierrez, supra, 32 Cal.4th at p. 159), and that DS-367 forms and unsworn police
reports are admissible and routinely admitted and considered at APS hearings. (Lake,
supra, 16 Cal.4th at pp. 451–452; Romane, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1016–1018;
Gerwig, supra, 61 Cal.App.5th at pp. 65–66.)
10.
concluded her arguments, the hearing ended. Further, there are no clear
mischaracterizations of evidence in the AHO’s decision that would indicate advocacy.
Therefore, there are no acts of advocacy discernable from the record.
Given the conduct of the AHO, as well as the operative CDLA injunction and the
pre-hearing and in-hearing advisements regarding the AHO’s functions and roles
(particularly as a “neutral fact-finder” and “not an advocate for the DMV”), there is no
indication that the AHO acted as an advocate for the DMV or that Urias’s due process
right to a constitutionally impartial adjudicator was violated. (Romane, supra, 110
Cal.App.5th at pp. 1016–1021 [finding no due process violation where the AHO merely
admitted evidence]; cf. Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at pp. 210–213 [finding a due
process violation where the AHO mischaracterized evidence, made legal errors that
benefitted the DMV, and asked questions that were not consistent with developing
testimony].)
Urias argues the act of choosing what records to introduce, admitting those
records, and then deciding the matter based on those chosen records shows the AHO
functioned as an advocate. However, a government agency may constitutionally permit a
single person within that agency to act as both an adjudicator and as a collector and
developer of evidence in the same proceeding. (Today’s Fresh Start, supra, 57 Cal.4th at
p. 220; Romane, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1014–1015; Kazelka, supra, 109
Cal.App.5th at p. 1255; Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at p. 199; CDLA, supra, 77
Cal.App.5th at p. 533, fn. 5.) Further, when a driver is arrested for driving under the
influence of alcohol, law enforcement officers are statutorily required to forward a sworn
report to the DMV that includes the facts and circumstances of the arrest and the results
of any BAC tests. (§ 13380; Romane, at pp. 1016–1017.) It is well established that a
prima facie case sufficient to uphold the suspension of a driver’s license may be
established through admission of such documents because these documents generally
establish the lawfulness of an arrest and the driver’s BAC level. (See Lake, supra, 16
11.
Cal.4th at p. 451; Romane, at pp. 1016–1018; Gerwig, supra, 61 Cal.App.5th at pp. 65–
66; Delgado v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th 572, 577.) As a
result, most APS hearings are resolved through the sworn and unsworn police records that
have been forwarded to the DMV. (Lake, at p. 451; Romane, at pp. 1016–1018; Gerwig,
at pp. 65–66.)
Given the routine and accepted practice of an AHO admitting police records at
APS hearings, and law enforcement’s statutory obligation to forward a sworn record to
the DMV, the introduction and admission of these records do not involve independent
investigatory work by the AHO or some form of pre-hearing assessment by the AHO in
which multiple documents are examined in order to find and admit only the most
damning evidence in favor of the DMV. Rather, the introduction and admission of
forwarded police records that are routinely admitted in APS hearings (e.g., Lake, supra,
16 Cal.4th at p. 451; Gerwig, supra, 61 Cal.App.5th at pp. 65–66) are minimal acts of
evidence collection and development that amount to no more than the AHO moving law
enforcement’s forwarded records from the DMV’s file into the record of the APS hearing.
Therefore, when an AHO in an APS hearing introduces and admits “the documents that
law enforcement duly forward[] to the DMV, which are routinely admitted into evidence
at APS hearings, the [AHO] is merely collecting and developing evidence, not advocating
for the DMV.”8 (Romane, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 1018.) Because that is what the
8 Urias argues that CDLA rejected this argument and points to the following
passage: “Due process protections are not dispensed with simply because the ‘DMV
hearing officer typically introduces two or three official documents into evidence and
decides a limited number of issues.’ Rather, ‘whenever “due process requires a hearing,
the adjudicator must be impartial.” ’ ” (CDLA, supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at p. 532.) This
statement was made in response to the DMV’s attempts to distinguish the types of
“overlap” functions regarding the hearing officers in Howitt v. Superior Court (1992) 3
Cal.App.4th 1575 and Nightlife Partners, Ltd. v. City of Beverly Hills (2003) 108
Cal.App.4th 81, with the functions of an AHO in an APS hearing. (CDLA, at p. 532.)
The argument was clearly made in an attempt to save the DMV’s policy of combining the
roles of advocate and adjudicator. Because CDLA involved a taxpayer challenge to the
12.
AHO did in this case, he did not act as an advocate. (Ibid.; cf. Knudsen, supra, 101
Cal.App.5th at pp. 206–207 [explaining that because an AHO may collect and develop
evidence, and because a prima facie case for license revocation is often established
through the submission of documents, “scenarios can easily be envisioned in which the
[AHO] adjudicates without actually acting as an advocate”].)
To the extent Urias complains the DMV mandates that an AHO at an APS hearing
acts as an adjudicator and a collector and developer of evidence, instead of providing
one DMV official to act as an AHO and a second to act as an investigator, advocate,
and/or developer of evidence, his complaint is misplaced. Administrative agencies are
not required to import the full trial model in all administrative contexts. (Today’s Fresh
Start, supra, 57 Cal.4th at p. 220; Chi, supra, 119 Cal.App.5th at p. 482.) As a result, an
agency may charge the same individual both with developing the facts and rendering a
final decision. (Today’s Fresh Start, at p. 220.) In relation to APS proceedings, it is
universally agreed that the DMV may charge the same AHO with both adjudicating the
matter and collecting and developing evidence at the APS hearing. (Chi, at p. 484;
Romane, supra, 110 Cal.App.5th at p. 1021; Kazelka, supra, 109 Cal.App.5th at p. 1255;
Clarke, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1275–1276; Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at
p. 207; CDLA, supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at p. 533, fn. 5 [“CDLA concedes the DMV may
task the same person with both collecting and developing the evidence and rendering a
final decision. [Citation.] He or she must refrain, however, from advocating on behalf of
APS system (California DUI Lawyers Assn. v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2018) 20
Cal.App.5th 1247, 1251, 1253, 1259), it was the DMV’s policy that was at issue, not an
actual APS hearing. What may happen in a “typical” APS hearing does not address the
actual DMV policy being challenged. As such, we do not read the above quotation from
CDLA to mean that the actual function and conduct of an AHO in an actual APS hearing
can never be examined to determine whether the AHO was actually acting as both
advocate and adjudicator, particularly when the DMV policy at issue in CDLA has been
judicially enjoined and subsequently abandoned.
13.
the DMV as the [DMV policy] currently mandates ….”].)9 Particularly considering the
evidence involved in this case, that is the standard forwarded documents that are
routinely admitted in APS hearings, we see no reason to reach a contrary conclusion.
Finally, to the extent Urias contends we should presume that the AHO acted as an
advocate, or that we should presume there exists a constitutionally intolerable probability
of bias because the AHO does more than simply adjudicate the matter, we cannot agree.
“Absent a financial interest, adjudicators are presumed impartial.” (Today’s Fresh Start,
supra, 57 Cal.4th at p. 219.) It is true in Knudsen that the burden of demonstrating that
an AHO did not act as an advocate was placed on the DMV. (Knudsen, supra, 101
Cal.App.5th at p. 207.) This burden was placed on the DMV because, before CDLA,
DMV policy required an AHO in part to act as an advocate on behalf of the DMV.
(Knudsen, at pp. 206–207; CDLA, supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at pp. 526, 532–533 & fn. 5.)
Because courts presume that a governmental agency regularly follows its policies,
Knudsen presumed that an AHO would have followed DMV policy and functioned as an
advocate. (Knudsen, at pp. 206–207.) It was therefore appropriate to place the burden on
9 Urias argues that CDLA’s footnote five is dicta that should be ignored. We
disagree. “Dicta” involves “ ‘observations and statements unnecessary to the appellate
court’s resolution of the case.’ ” (Sonic-Calabasas A, Inc. v. Moreno (2013) 57 Cal.4th
1109, 1158.) Footnote five addressed an express argument made by the DMV in support
of the DMV policy at issue. (CDLA, supra, 77 Cal.App.5th at p. 533, fn. 5.)
Footnote five was also appended to a sentence that held “[S]ection 14112, subdivision (b)
is unconstitutional to the extent it permits the DMV to combine the advocacy and
adjudicatory roles in a single APS hearing officer.” (CDLA, at p. 533.) Footnote five
appears to clarify and emphasize that section 14112, subdivision (b) was unconstitutional
only to the extent that it permitted a single individual to act as both adjudicator and
advocate; other roles or functions could be combined in the same individual, such as
adjudicator and collector and developer of evidence. This clarification not only explains
the nature of CDLA’s holding, but also would have aided the trial court and the parties
during the proceedings on remand. Because footnote five was “ ‘responsive to the issues
raised on appeal and … intended to guide the parties and the trial court [on remand],’ ”
footnote five of CDLA is not dicta. (Sonic-Calabasas A, at p. 1158; see Leider v. Lewis
(2017) 2 Cal.5th 1121, 1134.)
14.
the DMV to rebut the presumption of regularity and show that an AHO did not in fact
function as an advocate, that is the AHO did not engage in advocacy on behalf of the
DMV. (See ibid.)
However, CDLA enjoined the DMV’s policy and held that acting as both advocate
and adjudicator created a constitutionally intolerable probability of bias. (CDLA, supra,
77 Cal.App.5th at pp. 526, 532, 538; see also Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 198–199.) Since CDLA, the DMV has not functioned under a policy that required
AHO’s to act as advocates. (Chi, supra, 119 Cal.App.5th at pp. 478–479, 483.) As a
result, there is no basis to presume that an AHO acts as an advocate for the DMV.
Because the policy at issue in CDLA is gone (ibid.), the starting point in examining any
post-CDLA APS hearing is no longer that the AHO was acting as an advocate on behalf
of the DMV per DMV policy. Rather, the starting point is that the AHO did not act as an
advocate because no DMV policy was in place that mandated the AHO was to act as an
advocate.
In fact, CDLA and current DMV policy prohibit AHOs from doing so.
Accordingly, it is the driver’s burden to show through specific evidence and argument,
and without a presumption that an AHO followed a policy that required him or her to be
the DMV’s advocate, that an AHO was not constitutionally impartial. (See Today’s Fresh
Start, supra, 57 Cal.4th at p. 221; cf. Knudsen, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at pp. 206–207.)
“Otherwise, the presumption that agency adjudicators are people of ‘ “conscience and
intellectual discipline, capable of judging a particular controversy fairly on the basis of its
own circumstances” ’ will stand unrebutted.” (Today’s Fresh Start, at pp. 221–222.) As
discussed above, the AHO’s conduct and the pre-hearing and in-hearing advisements
regarding the AHO’s role in the APS hearing all demonstrate that the AHO did not
function as an advocate as prohibited by CDLA.
In sum, Urias has failed to meet his burden of demonstrating the DMV violated his
due process right to an impartial adjudicator.
15.
II. Lawfulness of Urias’s Detention
A. Parties’ Arguments
Urias argues his arrest for DUI was unlawful due to violations of the
Fourth Amendment. Contending that he was seized when Davalos turned on the scene
lights and illuminated the SUV, Urias argues this seizure was unconstitutional because
Davalos had lost sight of the gray SUV and had only a hunch that Urias was the driver of
that vehicle. Alternatively, he maintains that even if reasonable suspicion existed to stop
him, Davalos unconstitutionally prolonged the encounter without reasonable suspicion.
Specifically, Urias asserts that after he denied speeding through the intersection,
Davalos’s investigation of the matter was required to end and Davalos was obligated to
either let him go without asking further questions or to issue him a citation.
The DMV maintains that Urias was lawfully arrested. They assert Urias was not
seized but instead voluntarily stopped when Davalos engaged the scene lights. The DMV
also argues that Davalos had reasonable suspicion to believe Urias was the driver of the
gray SUV that had sped through the intersection. Finally, the DMV contends Davalos’s
inquiry was within the permissible scope of a traffic stop and did not unconstitutionally
prolong the detention.
B. Legal Standards
1. Review of Petition for Writ of Mandate
In ruling on a petition for a writ of mandate following an order of license
suspension, trial courts are to exercise their independent judgment and determine
“ ‘ “whether the weight of the evidence supported the administrative decision.” ’ ” (Lake,
supra, 16 Cal.4th at pp. 456–457; Kazelka, supra, 109 Cal.App.5th at p. 1247.) On
appeal, appellate courts review the record in order to determine whether the trial court’s
findings are supported by substantial evidence. (Lake, at p. 457; Kazelka, at p. 1247.) As
part of the substantial evidence review, courts resolve all evidentiary conflicts and draw
all reasonable inferences in favor of the trial court’s decision. (Lake, at p. 457; Freitas v.
16.
Shiomoto (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 294, 300.) However, issues raised in the appeal that
involve pure questions of law are reviewed de novo. (Freitas, at p. 300; Manriquez v.
Gourley (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1227, 1233.)
2. Fourth Amendment–Seizure of the Person Generally
The Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution protects individuals
against unreasonable searches and seizures by government actors. (See Florida v. White
(1999) 526 U.S. 559, 563; People v. Helzer (2024) 15 Cal.5th 622, 645.) A seizure
occurs if, under the totality of the circumstances, “ ‘a reasonable person would have
believed that he was not free to leave.’ ” (Brendlin v. California (2007) 551 U.S. 249,
255; see People v. Tacardon (2022) 14 Cal.5th 235, 241 (Tacardon).) Whether a seizure
has occurred is an objective inquiry that considers the relevant surrounding
circumstances, including: the presence of multiple officers, an officer’s display of a
weapon, the use of a siren or overhead emergency lights, physically touching the person,
the use of a patrol vehicle to block movement, or the use of language or of a tone of voice
indicating that compliance with the officer’s request is compelled. (See Michigan v.
Chesternut (1988) 486 U.S. 567, 574–575; Tacardon, at pp. 241–242.) However,
consensual encounters, in which law enforcement approach and engage an individual in
consensual conversations or questions (so long as a reasonable person would understand
he could refuse to cooperate), do not constitute a seizure and thus, do not implicate the
Fourth Amendment. (Florida v. Bostick (1991) 501 U.S. 429, 434; Tacardon, at p. 241.)
Further, an individual is not seized merely because he may feel himself the object of
official police scrutiny. (Tacardon, at p. 250.)
3. Fourth Amendment–Traffic Stops
A traffic stop for a suspected violation of law is considered a seizure and must be
performed in accordance with the Fourth Amendment. (Heien v. North Carolina (2014)
574 U.S. 54, 60; People v. Letner and Tobin (2010) 50 Cal.4th 99, 145–146.)
Accordingly, a traffic stop is constitutional if it is supported by at least reasonable
17.
suspicion. (Navarette v. California (2014) 572 U.S. 393, 396–397; Letner and Tobin, at
pp. 145–146.) Reasonable suspicion exists if an officer “can point to specific articulable
facts that, considered in light of the totality of the circumstances, provide some objective
manifestation that the person detained may be involved in criminal activity.” (People v.
Souza (1994) 9 Cal.4th 224, 231; see United States v. Sokolow (1989) 490 U.S. 1, 7.)
Stated differently, reasonable suspicion exists if, under the totality of the circumstances,
an officer has “ ‘a particularized and objective basis for suspecting the particular person
stopped of criminal activity.’ ” (Navarette, at pp. 396–397; People v. Brown (2015) 61
Cal.4th 968, 981.) Reasonable suspicion is a “ ‘less demanding standard’ ” than either
probable cause or a preponderance of the evidence. (Kansas v. Glover (2020) 589 U.S.
376, 380 (Glover); People v. Flores (2024) 15 Cal.5th 1032, 1041 (Flores).) While a
mere “hunch” is not sufficient, reasonable suspicion permits an officer to make
“ ‘commonsense judgments and inferences about human behavior,’ ” and “ ‘depends on
the factual and practical considerations of everyday life on which reasonable and prudent
men, not legal technicians, act.’ ” (Glover, at pp. 380–381; Flores, at p. 1041.)
Reasonable suspicion “ ‘need not rule out the possibility of innocent conduct.’ ”
(Navarette, at p. 403; see Letner and Tobin, at pp. 146–147.)
C. Analysis
As both parties agree, we review Urias’s Fourth Amendment arguments regarding
the legality of his seizure using our independent judgment, but accept the express and
implied findings of the trial court if they are supported by substantial evidence. (People
v. Tully (2012) 54 Cal.4th 952, 979 (Tully); People v. Sims (2021) 59 Cal.App.5th 943,
950.) Exercising our independent judgment, we conclude that Urias’s detention did not
violate the Fourth Amendment.
1. Activation of Scene Lights
Urias argues that he was seized when Davalos activated the patrol vehicle’s white
scene lights. We disagree.
18.
In addressing the use of spotlights by law enforcement,10 our Supreme Court has
held the “use of a spotlight, standing alone, does not necessarily effect a detention,” but
otherwise has refused to establish any “bright-line” rules. (Tacardon, supra, 14 Cal.5th at
p. 247.) Instead, courts “must consider the use of a spotlight together with all of the other
circumstances.” (Ibid.)
In this case, the totality of the circumstances demonstrate that Davalos was driving
down a residential cul-de-sac around 3:47 a.m. Urias was in the process of making a
three-point turn to get out of the cul-de-sac when Davalos began driving towards him.
After Urias completed the three-point turn and was slowly approaching Davalos, Davalos
turned on his scene lights to get a better view. Neither before turning on the scene lights
nor immediately thereafter, was there any indication that Davalos had turned on his red
and blue emergency lights, made any kind of motion for Urias to pull over, issued any
commands to Urias, or displayed any weapons. (Cf. Tacardon, supra, 14 Cal.5th at
pp. 241–242.) Nevertheless, after Davalos turned on the scene lights, Urias stopped next
to Davalos’s patrol vehicle (which apparently at some point had also stopped). In other
words, Davalos was simply scrutinizing Urias and turned on his nonemergency scene
lights because of low visibility, and Urias voluntarily stopped his SUV without
prompting. (Id. at pp. 247, 250 [noting that police scrutiny alone and use of a spotlight
alone do not constitute a seizure].) We detect nothing about the circumstance
surrounding Davalos’s use of his scene lights that would make a reasonable person in
Urias’s position believe that he was not free to keep driving away. (Id. at p. 241.)
Therefore, under the totality of the circumstances, Urias was not seized for purposes of
the Fourth Amendment when Davalos engaged his scene lights and Urias voluntarily
10 We are unaware of any California cases that analyze law enforcement’s use of
“scene lights.” Since scene lights seem to be used to light a general area, and spotlights
are generally used to illuminate a smaller, specific area, we detect no reason why
Tacardon’s analysis of spotlights would not also apply to Davalos’s use of scene lights.
19.
stopped his SUV. (Id. at p. 247 [holding that no detention occurred when an officer drove
by a parked BMW, made eye contact with the defendant in the BMW, made a U-turn,
parked 15 to 20 feet behind the BMW, turned the spotlight on the BMW, waited
20 seconds, and then began walking towards the BMW].)
2. Reasonable Suspicion
Urias contends that Davalos merely had a hunch that Urias was driving the gray
SUV that he had observed speeding through the controlled intersection. Urias explains
that Davalos was initially following taillights, lost sight of the gray SUV, and then
“presumed” the headlights he saw belonged to the gray SUV. Urias argues this is
“ironclad” evidence that Davalos only had a “hunch.” However, Urias’s argument is
based on the legal conclusion that Davalos’s use of scene lights effectuated a seizure. As
explained above, this is not true. Urias was not seized for purposes of the
Fourth Amendment when Davalos engaged his scene lights, rather, Urias voluntarily
stopped his vehicle. Therefore, Davalos’s use of the scene lights was not required to be
supported by reasonable suspicion. (Tacardon, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 247.)
Moreover, we agree with the trial court that Davalos had more than just a “hunch”
that Urias had committed a traffic violation. Davalos initially followed the gray SUV that
he had observed speed through the controlled intersection. When Davalos lost sight of
the gray SUV, he drove around the general area where he had last seen the gray SUV in
an attempt to find it. There is no indication that other vehicles were in the area, nor is it
likely that there would be, considering that Davalos was searching for the gray SUV at
3:45 a.m., a time in which it is widely known and understood that there is very little
traffic on city roads (particularly in an area the trial court indicated was residential in
nature). Further, because Davalos had engaged his scene lights and Urias had stopped
right beside him after the scene lights were turned on, Davalos would have been aware
20.
that Urias was driving a gray SUV.11 Finally, the DS-367 form and Davalos’s arrest
report indicate that approximately two minutes had elapsed from the time Davalos saw
the gray SUV speed through the intersection at 3:45 a.m. to the time he made contact
with Urias at 3:47 a.m. Reasonable suspicion is based on common sense experiences and
inferences and is a lower standard than both probable cause and a preponderance of the
evidence. (Glover, supra, 589 U.S. at pp. 380–381; Flores, supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 1041.)
Given the area where Urias was found, the time of day Urias was found, the short period
of time (about two minutes) between Davalos’s initial observation of the gray SUV and
his making contact with Urias, and the type and color of vehicle that Urias was driving,
these specific articulable facts constitute reasonable suspicion that Urias was the driver of
the gray SUV that Davalos had seen illegally speed through the intersection. 12 (Glover,
11 We note the arrest report states that after he believed that Urias was driving under
the influence, Davalos activated his red and blue emergency lights and pulled behind
Urias’s SUV, “which was revealed to be a gray Acura MDX displaying California license
plate [number] .…” However, we do not read the arrest report as meaning Davalos only
discovered it was a gray SUV after he engaged his emergency red and blue lights and
pulled behind the SUV. Because the SUV had been illuminated by the scene lights and
had stopped beside the patrol vehicle, it is unreasonable to believe that Davalos did not
know the SUV was gray until after he pulled behind the SUV. Instead, we view this
passage of the arrest report as providing additional information about the SUV that
became apparent from being behind the SUV, specifically the make, model and license
plate number, none of which would have been apparent to Davalos from his view of the
side of the SUV.
12 Our conclusion does not change simply because Davalos’s police report uses the
term “presumed.” Again, reasonable suspicion includes the commonsense inferences and
judgments that flow from the specific articulable facts known to the officer. Given the
specific articulable facts described above, we think that Davalos’s “presumption” is
synonymous with “deduction” or “inference.” (Glover, supra, 589 U.S. at pp. 380–381
[reasonable suspicion is based on commonsense inferences and judgments]; Flores,
supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 1041 [same].) Further, that an inference or a particular suspicion
of illegal activity may ultimately prove to be incorrect does not negate the fact that the
officer had a reasonable suspicion, and thus acted constitutionally, in the first instance.
(Flores, at p. 1050.)
21.
at pp. 380–381; Navarette v. California, supra, 572 U.S. at p. 397; Flores, at p. 1041;
People v. Brown, supra, 61 Cal.4th at p. 981.)
3. Exceeding the Scope of the Initial Detention
Urias argues that even if reasonable suspicion existed that he had sped through the
controlled intersection, the detention was unconstitutionally prolonged when he was
asked what he was doing after he stated that he had not sped through the intersection.
Like his argument regarding reasonable suspicion, Urias’s argument appears to be
premised on the legal conclusion that he was seized when Davalos engaged the scene
lights. Again, Urias was not seized for purposes of the Fourth Amendment when Davalos
engaged his scene lights, rather, Urias voluntarily stopped his vehicle next Davalos. As a
consensual encounter, Davalos was free to ask what Urias was doing in the area
irrespective of reasonable suspicion.
Alternatively, Urias is correct that the scope of a detention for a traffic stop is
generally limited to discussions regarding the traffic violation at issue and to the
performance of ordinary tasks that are incident to a traffic stop. (Rodriguez v. United
States (2015) 575 U.S. 348, 354–356; People v. Felix (2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 439, 448
(Felix); People v. Gyorgy (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 659, 669–670 (Gyorgy).) Inquiries
beyond the scope of the traffic stop that are not themselves supported by reasonable
suspicion unconstitutionally prolong the traffic detention. (Rodriguez, at p. 355; Gyorgy,
at pp. 670–671.) However, assuming that Urias was seized and that reasonable suspicion
existed to believe that Urias had sped through the controlled intersection, we cannot agree
that Davalos had to either let Urias go or write a citation after Urias said that he had not
sped through the controlled intersection.
Law enforcement may discuss with and make relevant inquiries to a driver
regarding the traffic violation at issue. (See Tully, supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 981; Felix,
supra, 100 Cal.App.5th at p. 448; Gyorgy, supra, 93 Cal.App.5th at p. 670.) By asking
what Urias was doing in the area, it is possible that Davalos could learn additional
22.
information that would have placed Urias near the relevant intersection within the last
few minutes. Such information would make it more likely that Urias had in fact sped
through the controlled intersection. While different or more direct questions could have
been asked along those lines, officers are not required to ask only a specific set of
investigatory or follow-up questions. The fact remains that relevant information
regarding the traffic violation could have been obtained from Urias’s answer to Davalos’s
question, and we cannot accept that Davalos’s investigation into the traffic violation was
required to end simply because Urias answered “no” to a pointed a question.
We are aware of no authority that requires law enforcement to accept a driver’s
simple and blanket denial of wrongdoing and that forbids any related follow-up
questions. Therefore, because Davalos’s follow-up question as to what Urias was doing
could have yielded relevant information and was not too unrelated to the traffic violation
at issue, Davalos’s single follow-up question did not unconstitutionally prolong Urias’s
seizure.13 (Rodriguez v. United States, supra, 575 U.S. at pp. 354–356; Tully, supra, 54
Cal.4th at p. 981; Felix, supra, 100 Cal.App.5th at p. 448 [finding that a question about
where the driver was “headed” was a proper and a typical traffic stop inquiry]; Gyorgy,
supra, 93 Cal.App.5th at pp. 670–671.)
13 Further, after Urias explained what he was doing in the area, Davalos had
reasonable suspicion to formally detain Urias and transform the traffic stop into a DUI
investigation. Specifically, Davalos had just observed Urias driving on Tamera Avenue
and Bree Drive and, as Urias was answering Davalos, Davalos noticed that Urias’s words
were slurred, Urias had red watery eyes, and Urias was sweating despite mild
temperatures. Further, when Davalos approached the gray SUV, he could smell the odor
of alcohol. (Cf. Salazar v. Burresch (C.D. Cal. 1999) 47 F.Supp.2d 1105, 1108 [noting
that red watery eyes, slurred speech, and an odor of alcohol are all objective signs of
being under the influence of alcohol]; Ramirez v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2023) 88
Cal.App.5th 1313, 1317–1318 [officer described same signs as symptoms of being under
the influence of alcohol].)
23.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. DMV is entitled to its costs on appeal.
HARRELL, J.
WE CONCUR:
DETJEN, Acting P. J.
PEÑA, J.
24.
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.