CourtListener 10860844•In re Ernesto M. CA2/8
Texto completo
Filed 5/18/26 In re Ernesto M. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re Ernesto M. et al., Persons B343495
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP02994A–B)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
D.P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Stephen Marpet, Commissioner. Affirmed.
Caitlin Christian, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Aileen Wong, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________________
INTRODUCTION
D.P. (Mother) appeals from the juvenile court’s orders at a
combined six-month and 12-month review hearing held for her
minor children under Welfare and Institutions Code
section 366.21, subdivisions (e) and (f).1 On appeal, Mother
contends the juvenile court erred in finding that the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS)
provided her with reasonable services because the agency failed
to make and implement a reunification plan tailored toward
Mother’s specific needs as a developmentally disabled person.
We conclude there was substantial evidence to support the
juvenile court’s reasonable services finding, and accordingly,
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
1. Section 300 petition
Mother and Francisco M. (Father) are the parents of two
children, Ernesto M. (a boy born in January 2012) and Ana M.
(a girl born in May 2015). Mother was previously diagnosed with
an intellectual disability and receives Regional Center services.
The children were first declared dependents of the juvenile court
in 2015, and were removed from the parents based on Father’s
domestic violence against Mother and Mother’s failure to protect
the children from Father. The court returned the children to the
parents’ custody in 2017 and then terminated jurisdiction.
The current matter came to DCFS’s attention in August
2023 after Mother was hospitalized due to methamphetamine
use. As of 2023, Mother had been residing with the paternal
1 Unless otherwise stated, all further undesignated statutory
references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
grandparents for 11 years. The children also resided with
Mother in the paternal grandparents’ home. In July 2023, the
paternal grandmother forced Mother to leave the home because of
her drug use. In an August 2023 interview with DCFS, Mother
initially denied any drug history, but later admitted she used
cocaine while the children were present in the home. A maternal
aunt told DCFS that Father supplied Mother with the drugs.
The maternal aunt also noted that Mother was not capable of
caring for the children on her own and was “barely able to care
for herself” due to her developmental delays.
After Mother was released from the hospital, she began
staying in a group home for developmentally disabled adults.
The children continued residing with Father in the paternal
grandparents’ home. In an August 2023 interview with DCFS,
Mother’s parent trainer, Maria Marquez, reported that she had
been working with Mother through the Regional Center for about
12 years. Marquez assisted Mother three days a week, and she
observed that Mother was appropriate with the children and able
to meet their basic needs. However, due to her disability, Mother
could be easily distracted, and the paternal grandmother had
always been there to assist Mother in caring for the children.
On September 5, 2023, DCFS filed a section 300 petition for
the children, alleging that they were at substantial risk of harm
based on Mother’s substance abuse and Father’s failure to protect
the children from Mother. At a September 20, 2023 detention
hearing, the juvenile court detained the children from both
parents and placed them with the paternal grandmother. The
court initially ordered Father to reside outside the paternal
grandparents’ home, but later allowed Father to return to the
home on the condition that he test negative for drugs and alcohol.
3
The court granted Mother monitored visits with the children.
At a subsequent hearing held on October 23, 2023, the court
ordered DCFS to provide Mother with appropriate referrals for
services, including weekly random drug testing, and to assist
Mother with a visitation schedule.
2. Jurisdictional and dispositional hearing
For its October 2023 jurisdiction/disposition report, DCFS
interviewed the family regarding the allegations in the petition.
In her interview, Mother admitted she used drugs in the past,
but continued to deny any recent usage. She also declined to
submit to a drug test at that time. The social worker observed
that Mother was able to engage in conversation, but had
difficulty explaining her thinking and elaborating on her
answers. Even though Mother requested that the interview be
conducted in English, she was better able to respond when the
social worker re-asked certain questions in Spanish. Mother
related that she wished to see the children, but she could not care
for them on her own and wanted them to remain with Father and
the paternal grandmother. In his interview, Father denied that
he was aware of any drug use by Mother prior to her August 2023
hospitalization.
In addition to interviewing the family, DCFS spoke with
Mother’s group home supervisor, Melissa Gordon. She stated
that the home was working with Mother on her daily living skills
such as obtaining a job and transitioning to her own apartment.
Gordon indicated that if Mother had to participate in court-
ordered services, the home could not link her with those services,
but could assist with transportation. For its report, DCFS also
obtained a letter from Mother’s Regional Center service
coordinator, Deisy Villanueva, verifying that Mother began
4
receiving services in 1994 and would continue to do so throughout
her lifetime due to her intellectual disability. Villanueva
provided a copy of Mother’s psychological evaluation, which was
conducted in 1994 when Mother was 12 years old to determine
her eligibility for services. According to the evaluation, Mother
had the cognitive and adaptive skills of an eight-year-old, and she
was diagnosed with mild mental retardation.
In its report, DCFS stated that, due to Mother’s intellectual
disability, she did not appear to understand the impact that her
drug use had on the children and their safety. DCFS
recommended the juvenile court sustain the petition and provide
Mother with enhancement services, including weekly drug
testing, developmentally appropriate parenting classes, and
individual counseling to address case issues.
Prior to the adjudication hearing, DCFS submitted several
addendum reports providing updated information on the family.
As of November 2023, Father had left the paternal grandparents’
home and was not assisting with the care of the children. He
later informed the social worker that he was not interested in
participating in services, and instead wanted the paternal
grandmother to become the children’s legal guardian. During
this period, the social worker set up weekly drug testing for
Mother, mailed the drug testing referral to her, and made various
attempts to call her to discuss the case. However, Mother was
not responsive to these efforts to reach her.
In December 2023, the social worker spoke with the
Regional Center’s START program coordinator, who reported
that she was assisting Mother in obtaining services, and that
Mother only recently became aware that she had to submit to
drug testing. A few days later, the social worker met in person
5
with Mother and reviewed the drug testing referral with her.
The social worker also met with Mother’s caregiver at her group
home, who indicated that he was helping Mother call the testing
line, but Mother was refusing to attend the tests. During the
meeting with Mother, the social worker asked about her goals for
the children and if she would be able to care for them. Mother
replied that she was busy because she had to do laundry, and she
wanted the children to remain with the paternal grandmother.
In January 2024, Mother began weekly drug testing with
the help of her case manager at the group home, and had four
consecutive negative tests. However, in February 2024, Mother
tested positive for both methamphetamine and marijuana despite
denying that she used any drugs. As of March 2024, Mother was
consistently visiting the children, but she tended to focus her
attention on Ernesto rather than engaging with both children
during the visits.
On March 18, 2024, the juvenile court held a combined
jurisdictional and dispositional hearing. The court sustained the
petition as pled and declared the children dependents of the court
under section 300, subdivision (b). The court removed the
children from the parents and ordered that they remain placed
with the paternal grandparents under the supervision of DCFS.
The court granted both parents reunification services, including
monitored visitation with the children. Mother’s case plan
consisted of a six-month drug and alcohol program with weekly
on-demand testing, a 12-step program with a sponsor, a
developmentally appropriate parenting class, and individual
counseling to address case issues.
6
3. Status review reports
On April 9, 2024, the social worker contacted Villanueva,
Mother’s Regional Center service coordinator, to inquire what
support the Regional Center could provide to assist Mother in
completing her court-ordered case plan. The following day,
Villanueva advised the social worker that she contacted Shields
for Families and confirmed that Mother was on their waiting list
for therapy. Villanueva noted that she also offered Mother
referrals for substance abuse programs and parenting classes,
but Mother declined to participate at that time. Villanueva
planned to contact the START program for assistance in offering
resources to Mother and ensuring that she understood the case
plan.
On April 15, 2024, the social worker met in person with
Mother and members of her support system, which included
Villaneuva, Ricardo Ruiz (the START program clinical team
leader), and Tair Funches (Mother’s group home caregiver).
The social worker provided Mother with a copy of the court’s
orders and reviewed the case plan with her. Mother indicated
that she understood the court’s orders, but did not understand
why she had to complete a substance abuse program or attend a
12-step program because she did not use drugs. Although the
social worker reminded Mother of her recent positive test for
methamphetamine, Mother did not appear to understand.
During the meeting, the social worker also provided Mother with
several referrals for substance abuse programs, counseling
services, and parenting classes. Ruiz and Funches indicated that
they could assist Mother in enrolling in services if she agreed.
On April 29, 2024, Villanueva informed the social worker
that she would be reaching out to Mother to again offer her
7
services. Villaneuva also reported Mother had been assigned a
therapist at Shields for Families, but despite multiple reminders,
Mother had not responded to the agency’s attempts to schedule
an intake assessment with her.
Between April and May 2024, Mother tested negative for
drugs on four occasions, but missed a number of other tests.
On May 17, 2024, the social worker met with Mother about her
compliance with her case plan. Mother indicated that she had
not enrolled in any services because she had been busy cleaning
the house, washing clothes, and visiting the maternal
grandmother. She also stated that she was “done” with drug
testing because she was tired. The social worker again reviewed
the case plan with Mother and provided her with an additional
referral for individual counseling and a parenting class.
On June 10, 2024, the social worker met with Mother and
asked her about her progress with services. Mother replied that
she had not had an opportunity to call any service providers
because she was busy. With Mother’s consent, the social worker
assisted her in calling a substance abuse program to begin the
intake process. During the call, Mother was advised that she
would be contacted within the next week for an initial
assessment and then connected to a program in her area.
On June 16, 2024, Mother showed up outside the paternal
grandparents’ home where she began hitting the windows and
screaming for the children. When the police arrived, Mother
assaulted the responding officer and resisted arrest. Mother
later admitted to the social worker that she was under the
influence of drugs during the incident.
Throughout June 2024, Mother failed to appear for her
on-demand drug tests. During a July 10, 2024 meeting with the
8
social worker, Mother indicated that she still had not enrolled in
any services, but she could not explain why. When asked about
her missed drug tests, Mother responded that she was busy
visiting the maternal grandmother and cleaning the restroom.
During the meeting, the social worker provided Mother with
several additional referrals for a parenting class.
On July 29, 2024, Mother told the social worker that she
had enrolled in a parenting class and substance abuse program,
but could not recall the names of the providers. That same day,
the social worker spoke with Angela Johnson from the VL Open
Hearts program, which was assisting Mother with her services.
According to Johnson, Mother recently began attending an online
parenting class. Johnson sat with Mother during the class and
explained the material to her because Mother would not be able
to comprehend it on her own. Mother had not enrolled in a
substance abuse program, but she had started attending
Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) meetings twice a week accompanied
by Johnson. Mother had not enrolled in any other services.
On August 20, 2024, the social worker met with Mother
about her failure to drug test. Mother replied that she was busy
washing her clothes. She also indicated that she called the
testing line, but did not need to test that day. At the social
worker’s request, Mother demonstrated how she checked whether
she was required to test, and appeared to be able to
independently call the line for drug testing.
On August 21, 2024, the juvenile court heard a section 388
petition filed by DCFS to modify Mother’s visitation. At the
hearing, Mother’s counsel advised the court that she recently
learned that Villanueva was no longer serving as Mother’s
Regional Center service coordinator, and that it took considerable
9
effort to get a new coordinator assigned. Mother’s counsel also
argued that although the Regional Center and its community
partners had been assisting Mother in enrolling in services, it
was DCFS’s responsibility to do so. After hearing from counsel,
the court granted the petition and ordered that Mother’s visits
with the children be limited to phone contact until she enrolled in
a substance abuse program and tested negative for drugs and
alcohol. The court also ordered DCFS to provide Mother with
referrals for a drug program and to assist in setting up drug
testing.
In a September 2024 status review report, DCFS informed
the court that Mother was assigned to a new Regional Center
service coordinator, Natalie Yousef, on August 20, 2024. In an
August 2024 e-mail exchange with the DCFS social worker,
Yousef explained that due to Mother’s intellectual disability,
Mother had difficulty retaining information and seemed “a bit
overwhelmed with all that is being asked of her.” However,
Yousef also stated that “[a]s long as [Mother] wants to put in the
work to follow through with the conditions of her DCFS case and
ultimately regain custody of her children, we are all supplying
her with the necessary tools and resources to make that happen.”
On August 26, 2024, the social worker assisted Mother with
submitting a referral to a substance abuse program, and Mother
was scheduled for an intake appointment two days later.
Although the social worker provided the appointment
information to Mother as well as to her Regional Center service
coordinator and providers, Mother did not follow through with
enrolling in the program. Additionally, while Mother had been
attending AA meetings since July 2024, she reported that she
had not participated in the meetings because she was not ready
10
to share. She also continued to miss the majority of her
on-demand drug tests. Mother was attending a parenting class
with the assistance of VL Open Hearts, which provided her with
additional services such as child development resources and
parenting skills workshops. Yet when asked what she learned in
the class and how she would implement those lessons with her
children, Mother was only able to articulate “ ‘not hitting kids, be
good, love each other.’ ” With respect to individual counseling,
Yousef indicated that Mother was linked to mental health
services through the Regional Center, but due to inconsistent
participation, Mother would not be assigned a therapist until she
agreed to regular ongoing services.
In a last minute information report filed in September
2024, DCFS informed the court that Mother recently tested
positive for cocaine in two on-demand tests. DCFS also reported
that, although Mother attended a screening for a substance abuse
program on September 6, 2024, she failed to appear for her
treatment assessment appointment a few days later. When the
social worker followed up with Mother about the program, she
stated that she was not sure if she wanted to participate because
it would require a lot of time and she was busy going out,
washing clothes, and staying home to watch movies. On
September 16, 2024, the juvenile court set a contested six-month
review hearing at Mother’s request.
In its November 2024 status review report, DCFS provided
an update on Mother’s progress with her case plan. In late
September 2024, Mother enrolled in a substance abuse program
consisting of two hours of early intervention services each week.
Mother’s substance abuse counselor did not recommend an
outpatient program for Mother due to her intellectual disability,
11
and instead determined that the one-on-one support provided by
her current program best suited her abilities. In September
2024, Mother also agreed to participate in individual counseling.
Yousef advised DCFS that the START program would provide a
referral and assist Mother in enrolling in counseling using her
managed care plan. Due to an issue with Mother’s insurance
coverage, she did not begin individual counseling until mid-
November 2024. During this period, Mother continued to attend
AA meetings and an online parenting class with the assistance of
her caregiver from VL Open Hearts. In October 2024, the
facilitator for the parenting class informed DCFS that Mother
might benefit from retaking the class in person because she did
not appear to understand the lessons. However, following a one-
on-one meeting, the facilitator determined that Mother had a fair
understanding of the class material, and provided a letter of
completion for Mother in November 2024.
4. Contested review hearing
On November 19, 2024, the juvenile court held a combined
six-month and 12-month review hearing. In addition to
admitting documentary evidence offered by the parties, the court
heard testimony from Araceli Arriaga, the DCFS social worker,
and Paul Martinez, a Regional Center forensic specialist.
In her testimony, Arriaga stated that she worked for DCFS
for three years, but had not worked with a parent who received
Regional Center services prior to Mother. During her initial
review of the case, Arriaga made contact with Mother’s Regional
Center service coordinator, Villanueva, who provided background
on what services Mother was receiving at that time. Arriaga
offered Mother the same type of program referrals that she
offered to parents who did not have an intellectual disability.
12
Arriaga explained that once the program providers conducted an
intake with Mother, they would decide what services she needed
based on her cognitive abilities. Arriaga did not expect the
Regional Center to find appropriate programs for Mother to
attend as part of her case plan. Rather, Arriaga’s goal was to
work together with the Regional Center to ensure Mother was
enrolled in her court-ordered programs if she was willing to
participate in those services. Arriaga could not recall if she had
contact with the Regional Center between May and July 2024.
Arriaga did, however, meet with Mother on a monthly basis
about her progress with her case plan, and when Mother
consented, Arriaga would also meet with her caregivers at the
group home. In addition, Arriaga kept in contact with Mother’s
caregiver at the START program, which was assisting Mother
with her case plan. Arriaga stated that Mother currently had
two parent support persons to help her with her visits and
services, along with the 24-hour support provided by the group
home. Arriaga believed Mother could benefit from additional
support from the Regional Center because Mother often
expressed that she felt overwhelmed.
In his testimony, Martinez stated that he was a forensic
specialist at the Regional Center where Mother received services.
Based on his review of Mother’s case file, Martinez did not
believe that Mother could independently enroll in her court-
ordered programs, and that she would need someone to walk her
through the process each time. Mother also would need
assistance complying with weekly on-demand drug testing.
Generally, DCSF and the Regional Center should be able to work
together to locate appropriate services for a parent. However, the
Regional Center did not have a legal obligation to provide parents
13
with reunification services. Due to Mother’s intellectual
disability, she likely would need to attend specialized programs
in substance abuse and parenting. Martinz had seen parents
with Mother’s level of disability reunify with their children when
they had the support of the Regional Center and DCFS.
After hearing the witness testimony and the argument of
counsel, the juvenile court found that continued jurisdiction over
the children was necessary, and that it would be detrimental to
return the children to the parents’ custody at that time. The
court further found that DCFS provided reasonable services to
the parents. The court terminated reunification services for
Father based on his lack of compliance with his case plan, and
ordered continued reunification services for Mother. The court
also ordered DCFS to continue assisting Mother with her
reunification services by providing “ ‘hands on’ ” help with her
programs and visits. The court set a nonappearance progress
hearing for January 2025 to address Mother’s progress with her
case plan.
Mother filed a timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
On appeal, Mother challenges the juvenile court’s finding at
the combined six-month and 12-month review hearing that DCFS
provided her with reasonable services. Mother contends that the
evidence was insufficient to support a reasonable services finding
because DCFS failed to make a good faith effort to develop and
timely implement a reunification plan tailored to Mother’s needs.
Based on the totality of the record in this case, we conclude the
juvenile court’s reasonable services finding was supported by
substantial evidence.
14
1. Governing law
At the six-month and 12-month review hearings, the
juvenile court must “determine by clear and convincing evidence
whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent
… in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and
the continued custody of the child have been provided or offered
to the parent.” (§ 366.21, subds. (e)(8), (f)(1)(a).) “To support a
finding that reasonable services were offered or provided … ‘the
record should show that the supervising agency identified the
problems leading to the loss of custody, offered services designed
to remedy those problems, maintained reasonable contact with
the parents during the course of the service plan, and made
reasonable efforts to assist the parents in areas where compliance
proved difficult.’ ” (In re A.G. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 994, 1001.)
The agency “must make a ‘ “ ‘good faith effort’ ” ’ … to
provide reasonable reunification services in spite of difficulties in
doing so or the prospects of success.” (In re Taylor J. (2014)
223 Cal.App.4th 1446, 1451.) Moreover, “[r]eunification services
should be tailored to the particular needs of the family,” which
includes “accommodat[ing] the special needs of disabled …
parents.” (Tracy J. v. Superior Court (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th
1415, 1425–1426.) “The ‘adequacy of reunification plans and the
reasonableness of the [Agency’s] efforts are judged according to
the circumstances of each case.’ ” (Id. at p. 1426.) The standard
is not whether the services “ ‘were the best that might be
provided in an ideal world, but whether the services were
reasonable under the circumstances.’ ” (In re J.E. (2016)
3 Cal.App.5th 557, 566.) We review the juvenile court’s
reasonable services finding for substantial evidence. (In re J.P.
(2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 616, 624.)
15
2. Substantial evidence supported the finding that
reasonable services were provided to Mother
In this case, the juvenile court initially detained the
children from the parents in September 2023. Early in the case,
DCFS made contact with several members of Mother’s support
team, including her Regional Center service coordinator, her
START program coordinator, and her group home supervisor, to
discuss what services were available to Mother at that time. The
social worker also provided Mother with a resource packet, set up
weekly on-demand drug testing for her, and began meeting with
Mother on a regular basis about the case. At the March 2024
adjudication hearing, the court ordered reunification services for
both parents. A few weeks later, in April 2024, the social worker
met in person with Mother and her support team, reviewed the
reunification plan with them, and provided Mother with referrals
for services in accordance with that plan. Then, over the next
several months, DCFS worked with Mother’s support team to
assist Mother with enrolling in services and complying with her
reunification plan, even where compliance proved difficult.
Mother’s case plan required her to participate in drug and
alcohol services, including a six-month substance abuse program,
a 12-step program, and weekly on-demand drug testing. In April
2024, both the social worker and Mother’s Regional Center
service coordinator offered her referrals for substance abuse
programs, but Mother declined to participate at that time
because she did not believe she had a drug problem. Between
June and September 2024, the social worker made repeated
efforts to assist Mother with contacting a substance abuse
program to begin the enrollment process, but Mother did not
follow through with her scheduled intake and assessment
appointments. In late September 2024, Mother did enroll in an
16
early intervention drug treatment program which, according to
the program counselor, was best tailored to meet Mother’s
cognitive abilities because it provided one-on-one support. With
the assistance of VL Open Hearts, a program funded by the
Regional Center, Mother also began attending AA meetings on a
regular basis in July 2024. During this period, Mother did not
consistently submit to drug testing, even though her support
team at VL Open Hearts and the group home were available to
assist with calling the referral line and transporting Mother to
the testing site. As Mother’s Regional Center service coordinator
explained, these caregivers could “ensure [Mother] has the tools
she needs” for drug testing “as long as [Mother] is willing to
comply.”
In addition to drug and alcohol services, Mother was
required to attend a parenting class as part of her case plan.
The social worker provided Mother with referrals for this service
in April, May, and July 2024. Mother enrolled in an online
parenting class in July 2024, and she consistently attended the
class with the aid of Johnson, her caregiver at VL Open Hearts.
Johnson advised DCFS that she sat with Mother during the class
and explained the material to her. VL Open Hearts also provided
Mother with additional parenting services, such as child
development resources and parenting skills workshops. The
facilitator for the parenting class later informed DCFS that
Johnson did not always appear to assist Mother during the
lessons, and that Mother might need to retake the class in
person. However, after meeting with Mother on an individual
basis, the facilitator found that she had a fair understanding of
the material and provided a certificate of completion for the class
in November 2024.
17
Another component of Mother’s case plan required her to
attend individual counseling to address case issues. On appeal,
Mother claims that DCFS did not provide her with timely access
to this service because it “failed to intervene for eleven months,
while Mother languished on the waiting list for a therapist.” This
claim is not supported by the record. In April 2024, one month
after the adjudication hearing, Mother’s Regional Center service
coordinator, Villanueva, informed DCFS that Mother was on a
waitlist for therapy at Shields for Families. Villanueva also
stated that she was trying to get Mother “moved up in line” given
that Mother now had a court order for therapy. A few weeks
later, Villanueva reported that, although Mother had been
assigned a therapist through Shields for Families, she had not
responded to their attempts to schedule her for an intake
assessment. Over the next few months, the social worker
continued to meet with Mother and offer her referrals for
services, including for individual counseling, but Mother often
stated she was too busy to participate in services. In August
2024, Mother’s new service coordinator, Yousef, reported that
Mother was linked to mental health services through the
Regional Center, but Mother needed to agree to participate in
regular ongoing services. Once Mother agreed to participate in
therapy in September 2024, Yousef advised the social worker that
the START program would be able to assist Mother with the
enrollment process using her managed care plan. Due to
insurance coverage issues, there was some additional delay in
finding a therapist for Mother, but she began individual
counseling in November 2024.
Mother argues that DCFS overlooked certain services that
were essential to reunification such as a psychological evaluation,
18
housing assistance, and Spanish-language programs. However,
throughout the proceedings, Mother’s counsel never asked the
juvenile court to order these services for Mother as part of her
reunification plan. While the parties disputed whether the
services provided to Mother were reasonable at the November
2024 review hearing, none of them argued that an updated
psychological evaluation was necessary to determine the scope of
Mother’s intellectual disability. Nor did any of the parties argue
that Mother could not comply with her case plan because of a
language or housing barrier. In any event, the record showed
that Mother was able to communicate in English even though her
primary language was Spanish, and that the Regional Center
was providing Mother with housing assistance.
Moreover, contrary to Mother’s characterization on appeal,
this was not a case where DCFS simply provided Mother with a
list of referrals and then left it to the Regional Center to decide
what services, if any, could meet Mother’s needs. Rather, the
record reflects that DCFS made a good faith effort to work with
the various members of Mother’s support team at the Regional
Center, the START program, the VL Open Hearts program, and
Mother’s group home to provide her with services that were
consistent with the court-ordered case plan. The social worker
also met with Mother on a regular basis to review the case plan
and reiterate the importance of participating in reunification
services. When Mother agreed to engage in those services, the
social worker along with Mother’s support team were able to
enroll her in programs that accommodated her intellectual
disability, such as a substance abuse program that provided one-
on-one support and a parenting education class that allowed for
an aide to be present to explain the material. Although there
19
were some delays and DCFS arguably could have done more, the
standard is not whether the services “ ‘were the best that might
be provided in an ideal world, but whether the services were
reasonable under the circumstances.’ ” (In re J.E., supra,
3 Cal.App.5th at p. 566.) On this record, the juvenile court’s
finding that DCFS provided Mother with reasonable services was
supported by substantial evidence.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s findings and orders at the November
19, 2024 review hearing are affirmed.
VIRAMONTES, J.
WE CONCUR:
STRATTON, P. J.
SCHERB, J.
20
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.