People v. Sobhani CA2/8

CourtListener 10850495Calctapp29 de abr. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 4/29/26 P. v. Sobhani CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

THE PEOPLE, B340650

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. SA107329)
v.

NICOLE SOBHANI,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Christopher W. Dybwad, Judge. Affirmed.

Heather E. Shallenberger, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and Deepti Vaadyala, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
A jury convicted Nicole Sobhani of three counts of corporal
injury to a child. Sobhani appeals, arguing the trial court abused
its discretion in admitting the prosecution’s rebuttal evidence.
We find harmless error and affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. The Underlying Offenses
An information charged Sobhani with three counts of
corporal injury to a child, Aubrianna S., in violation of Penal
Code1 section 273d, subdivision (a) (counts 1, 2, and 3) and one
count of corporal injury to a spouse, in violation of section 273.5,
subdivision (a) (count 4). A jury convicted Sobhani of all three
section 273d, subdivision (a) counts. It deadlocked on count 4,
which the court later dismissed. We do not discuss count 4.
II. Facts Adduced at Trial
A. Prosecution Case-in-Chief
Sobhani and her husband Casey married in 2004, and had
two children—Aubrianna, born in 2009, and Brady, born in 2011.
1. Count 1
In August 2022, Aubrianna was 13 years old and lived with
Sobhani, Casey, and her brother Brady. One day Sobhani
entered Aubrianna’s room in the morning before school and
accused her of stealing a phone charger. Aubrianna denied her
mother’s accusation. Sobhani then grabbed a phone charger that
was in the room and the two engaged in a tug of war over the
charging cord, pulling it between them. Sobhani wrapped the

1
Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal
Code.

2
cord around her daughter’s neck and pulled. Aubrianna could not
speak or breathe. Eventually Aubrianna was able to remove the
cord from around her neck and Sobhani left the room without the
charging cord. Aubrianna’s neck was visibly bruised and red
from the incident. Aubrianna texted a photo of the bruise on her
neck to her father Casey, who was out of town at the time.
2. Count 2
One month later, in September 2022, Aubrianna was asleep
in her room when she woke up to a liquid being poured on her
chest. The liquid smelled like bleach. She saw Sobhani in the
room holding a bottle with a blue cap. Sobhani muttered
something under her breath and left. Aubrianna sat up and the
liquid dripped down her body and her skin began to burn. She
tried to wipe off the liquid and she took a shower, but the burning
did not stop. Aubrianna’s skin turned purple and red; multiple
showers did not stop the burning. Aubrianna returned to her
bedroom and was unable to sleep, so she sat in her bed awake.
At some point Sobhani reentered Aubrianna’s room, threw a tube
of burn cream at her, and left. Aubrianna had burn scars on her
neck, chest, shoulder, arms, and knees; some are permanent.
Aubrianna took photos of the burns and scabs on her body.
3. Count 3
A few days later, Casey noticed burn scars on Aubrianna,
who later told him what Sobhani had done. Casey confronted
Sobhani about the abuse. Sobhani then confronted Aubrianna for
“making stuff up” and punched her in the face, causing a black
eye. When Casey asked Aubrianna what had happened to her
face, she told him what Sobhani had done.

3
4. Sobhani’s Arrest
In late September 2022, Casey called the police after
Sobhani became belligerent over the family dog. When police
arrived, Casey told them about Sobhani’s acts against Aubrianna.
When police questioned Aubriana, she confirmed what Sobhani
had done to her and showed them the burn scars. Sobhani was
arrested.
B. Evidentiary Discussion Between Court and Counsel
Before the defense began its case, the following exchange
occurred between court and counsel about issues that could arise
if Sobhani testified: “[Prosecutor:] There was also information
counsel has had for quite some time in the very beginning of the
case that the child Brady was also strangled. And so I would
potentially introduce that. [¶] To be quite frank with everyone in
this room, . . . I am weighing very carefully and heavily having to
bring him in to testify, but if I see that we need to for the case,
then I am going to, and they are ready to do so beginning this
afternoon.”
The court responded: “I think it’s likely cross-examination
on all those topics becomes admissible. The analysis is a little bit
different depending on what incident we are talking about.
There’s an [Evidence Code section] 1101(b) analysis for prior bad
acts. But there’s also [an Evidence Code section] 1109 analysis
for incidents that do rise to the level of child abuse as defined in
[section] 273(d). So I’ll parse that out on the record should Ms.
Sobhani testify.”
Seeking clarification, defense counsel then asked, “[W]ould
the court’s tentative be at least if [Sobhani] does not testify about
other acts of abuse by Casey that that would not be opening the

4
door to either prior allegations of abuse by her against Casey or
either of the children?” The court responded: “Should Ms.
Sobhani take the witness stand and say she has always been a
devoted, loving mother, she would never hurt her kids, that’s a
type of representation that may open the door.”
C. Defense Case
Sobhani testified in her own defense. Sobhani denied
strangling Aubrianna with the phone charging cord and pouring
liquid on Aubrianna. Sobhani testified that in September 2022,
she noticed burn scars on Aubrianna and thought Aubrianna had
spilled something on herself. Sobhani then received photos of the
burn scars via text message to her phone from an unknown
number and immediately called her own mother to come over.
Her mother spoke to Aubrianna, but Sobhani herself never
discussed the injuries or the photographs of the injuries with
Aubrianna or Casey.
Sobhani also testified that Aubrianna made a report to the
school about having food withheld from her. Sobhani testified
that child protective services got involved. She denied
withholding food from Aubrianna and, upon inquiry from the
prosecutor, she denied physically abusing Brady. The following
exchange occurred on cross-examination.
“[Prosecutor:] Your son Brady, how old is he now?
“[Sobhani:] 12.
“[Prosecutor:] And how much younger is he than
Aubrianna?
“[Sobhani:] They are about two and a half years apart
almost to the month.

5
“[Prosecutor:] Isn’t it true that you have also physically
abused Brady?
“[Sobhani:] No, and I haven’t had an allegation of that.
“[Prosecutor:] You haven’t had an allegation of that?
“[Sobhani:] No.
“[Prosecutor:] Isn’t it true that you also in the middle of the
night went to his room and strangled him as well?
“[Sobhani:] No.”
D. Prosecution’s Rebuttal
In rebuttal, the prosecutor called Brady to the stand.
Brady testified his mother Sobhani once woke him up in the
middle of the night looking for a lost bracelet. Brady denied
knowing where the bracelet was and suggested Aubrianna had
taken it, but Sobhani accused him of lying, screamed at him, and
demanded he look for it. Brady testified Sobhani spanked him
and squeezed his neck with her hands, which made him
“nervous” and “scared.” He “panicked” after it happened and
continued to look for the bracelet.
Aubrianna also testified on rebuttal. She told her school
counselor in seventh grade that Sobhani withheld food from her
as a means of punishment. As a result, the counselor called child
protective services which initiated a formal investigation. When
Sobhani learned of Aubrianna’s allegations, she demanded that
Aubrianna “reverse” her statement, telling her that otherwise she
would become a “foster kid” and go to an “orphanage” and that
“would be really bad.” Aubrianna attested she felt “[n]ot good”
after hearing from her mother that she would become an orphan;
Aubrianna eventually retracted her statements.

6
E. Defense Surrebuttal
On surrebuttal, Sobhani denied the allegations made by
her children, attesting that she never told Aubrianna she would
become an orphan and denying she ever put her hands around
Brady’s neck. She did admit to spanking Brady in the past.
F. Defense Objection to Rebuttal
After the court charged the jury and dismissed it to
deliberate, defense counsel made an objection to Brady’s rebuttal
testimony. The court responded that the testimony was
admissible, responding that “it was [Evidence Code section] 1109
evidence, period. Full stop.” Defense counsel countered that he
did not believe there was “anything that Ms. Sobhani said during
her testimony that opened the door for that to be rebuttal.” The
prosecutor responded “the door was opened by essentially
[Sobhani] painting herself to be the victim in the family,” and she
“made a blanket statement during her direct examination
regarding the fact that she wouldn’t hurt her children.” The
court ruled the testimony “was proper impeachment and that it’s
admissible under the relevant rules.”
III. Verdict and Sentencing
On June 12, 2024, the jury found Sobhani guilty of counts
1, 2, and 3 involving allegations of corporal injury to Aubrianna.
The jury deadlocked on count 4 alleging corporal injury to spouse
Casey. On that count the trial court declared a mistrial.
On August 20, 2024, the trial court sentenced Sobhani to
an aggregate term of four years and eight months in county jail
pursuant to section 1170, subdivision (h), consisting of the low
term of two years on count 1, and one-third the midterm of four
years for 16 months on counts 2 and 3, each to be served

7
consecutively to the principal term. The court granted the
People’s request to dismiss count 4.
Sobhani filed a timely notice of appeal.
DISCUSSION
Sobhani contends Brady’s testimony on rebuttal, where he
was asked about the incident involving her and the missing
bracelet, was improper rebuttal evidence. We agree but find the
error harmless.
I. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
“Section 1093, subdivision 4, of the Penal Code provides
that after the defendant has offered his evidence, the prosecution
may then offer ‘rebutting testimony only, unless the court, for
good reason, in furtherance of justice . . .’ permits it to offer
evidence upon its original case. In a sense all evidence that tends
to establish the defendant’s guilt over his protestations of
innocence rebuts the defendant’s case, but it is not all rebuttal
evidence within the purpose of section 1093, subdivision 4. The
purpose of the restriction in that section is to assure an orderly
presentation of evidence so that the trier of fact will not be
confused; to prevent a party from unduly magnifying certain
evidence by dramatically introducing it late in the trial; and to
avoid any unfair surprise that may result when a party who
thinks he has met his opponent’s case is suddenly confronted at
the end of trial with an additional piece of crucial evidence.”
(People v. Carter (1957) 48 Cal.2d 737, 753 (Carter).) Proper
rebuttal evidence does not include a material part of the case in
the prosecution’s possession that tends to establish the
defendant’s commission of the crime. (Id. at p. 753.) It is
restricted to evidence made necessary by the defendant’s case in

8
the sense that he has introduced new evidence or made
assertions that were not implicit in his denial of guilt. (Id. at
pp. 753–754.) A defendant’s reiterated denial of guilt and the
principal facts that purportedly establish it does not justify the
prosecution’s introduction of new evidence to establish that which
defendant would clearly have denied from the start. (Id. at
p. 754.) Changes in the order of proof called for by section 1093
can be made within the sound discretion of the trial court. (Ibid.)
Rebuttal evidence is relevant and admissible if it tends to
disprove a fact of consequence on which the defendant has
introduced evidence. (People v. Valdez (2012) 55 Cal.4th 82, 169.)
“[E]vidence presented or argued as rebuttal must relate directly
to a particular incident or character trait defendant offers in his
own behalf.” (People v. Rodriguez (1986) 42 Cal.3d 730, 792,
fn. 24.)
The trial court has broad discretion to determine the
admissibility of rebuttal evidence and, absent palpable abuse, an
appellate court may not disturb the trial court’s exercise of that
discretion. (People v. Gurule (2002) 28 Cal.4th 557, 656.) A court
abuses its discretion when it makes an arbitrary or capricious
decision by applying the wrong legal standard or bases its
decision on express or implied factual findings not supported by
substantial evidence. (People v. Qualkinbush (2022)
79 Cal.App.5th 879, 887.)
II. Analysis
Here, on direct examination Sobhani never once raised new
facts or evidence as to Brady. Indeed, she never even mentioned
his name or referred to him. She restricted her testimony to
denying the factual abuse allegations in counts 1, 2, and 3 as to
Aubrianna and the corporal injury allegations in count 4 as to her

9
spouse Casey S. She gave her version of events for some of those
counts without giving any testimony whatsoever about Brady.
She made no general statements about how she would never
abuse her children, how she was being victimized, or how great
she was at being a mother. She offered no character evidence
other than her generic denial of the allegations against her.
The one mention of Brady occurred on cross-examination
when, out of the blue, the prosecutor twice asked her point blank
whether she had ever abused Brady. She said no twice. The
People contend that by denying any abuse of Brady, Sobhani
“opened the door” to the rebuttal evidence they presented
through Brady’s testimony. They contend Sobhani’s answer is
new evidence that they could properly contradict in rebuttal.
Not so.
First, the People should have presented Brady’s testimony
in their case-in-chief as it was evidence to prove guilt. (§ 1093,
subd. (c).) Indeed, when the trial court overruled Sobhani’s
objection to the rebuttal evidence, the reason it gave was that the
evidence was “1109 evidence, period. Full stop” and also
impeachment evidence. That would be Evidence Code section
1109 which permits evidence of prior acts of uncharged child
abuse to prove propensity to commit child abuse. That evidence
would only have been admissible in rebuttal if Sobhani had put
her character in issue when she testified, which she did not.
Nonetheless, section 1094 expressly gives the trial court
discretion to depart from the order of proceedings outlined in
section 1093 “for good reasons” or “[w]hen the state of the
pleadings requires it.” (§ 1094.) Here, there was no evidence
that the state of the pleadings required Brady’s testimony. Nor
was any good reason given for departing from the order of proof,

10
that is, for not presenting this potential Evidence Code section
1109 evidence in the case-in-chief so that it could have been
properly met in the defense case. Here, Brady was available that
day to testify in the People’s case-in-chief. The People stated
they did not want to call Brady to the stand before they rested
their case only because he was a “sweet young little boy.” Yet
they also announced he was available to testify and they were
prepared to call him that afternoon. They had no problem doing
so after the prosecutor raised his name randomly in
cross-examination. It is not hard to fathom that asking the
question about abusing Brady on cross-examination and having
the boy available to testify immediately after his mother testified
was a tactical move rather than an effort to protect a young
witness. Unfair advantage is the precise purpose of the
constraints imposed by section 1093 on the order of proof. (See
Carter, supra, 48 Cal.2d at pp. 753–754 [“The purpose of the
restriction . . . is to assure an orderly presentation of evidence so
that the trier of fact will not be confused; to prevent a party from
unduly magnifying certain evidence by dramatically introducing
it late in the trial; and to avoid any unfair surprise that may
result when a party who thinks he has met his opponent’s case is
suddenly confronted at the end of trial with an additional piece of
crucial evidence.”]; see also People v. Rodriguez (1984)
152 Cal.App.3d 289, 295 [“ ‘Factors to be considered in reviewing
the exercise of [the trial court’s] discretion include the stage the
proceedings had reached . . . , the diligence shown by the moving
party in discovering the new evidence, the prospect that the jury
would accord it undue emphasis, and the significance of the
evidence.’ ”].)

11
Further, introduction of rebuttal evidence must be
triggered by new evidence introduced by the defendant. (People
v. Valdez, supra, 55 Cal.4th 82 at p. 169 [evidence presented or
argued as rebuttal must relate directly to a particular incident or
character trait the defendant offered in his own behalf].) Sobhani
did not introduce any evidence about Brady or her relationship
with him nor did she offer evidence about her own character. It
was the People who introduced the subject and elicited Sobhani’s
response. We decline to allow the People to sandbag the
defendant by introducing a new subject in cross-examination not
implicated by defendant’s testimony and then claiming the
defendant’s answer warranted their rebuttal. Indeed, as the
court in Carter pointed out, where defendant had entered a not
guilty plea to the charges, his denial of other possible evidence of
guilt did not furnish new matter for rebuttal. (Carter, supra,
48 Cal.2d at p. 754 [defendant’s reiterated denial of guilt and the
principal facts that purportedly establish it does not justify the
prosecution’s introduction of new evidence to establish that which
defendant would clearly have denied from the start].)
People v. Rodriguez (1943) 58 Cal.App.2d 415 is instructive
and its analysis bears repeating. There the People prosecuted
Rodriguez for robbery. (Id. at p. 416.) Rodriguez was asked on
cross-examination whether he had earlier given a complete
account of the events of the robbery to a particular police officer.
(Id. at p. 418.) Defendant denied making any such statement.
(Ibid.) After the defense rested and in rebuttal, the police officer
was called and testified to a complete and detailed confession
made by defendant shortly after he had been booked postarrest.
(Ibid.) The People contended they properly presented the officer’s
testimony to impeach the defendant. (Id. at pp. 418–419.)

12
The Court of Appeal concluded that the alleged confession
“was held back, to be offered in rebuttal and in the guise of
impeachment of defendant after his denials upon
cross-examination. . . . The procedure was entirely wrong. If the
defendant had confessed, proof of the confession was a part of the
case of the People and it was the duty of the district attorney to
offer it before resting his case, when the testimony was then
available and there was no reason for not offering it in chief.
When the case of the People is closed and the defense is in, the
remainder of the People’s case is limited to evidence in rebuttal of
that produced by the defense and should be so limited by the
court, except where a proper showing is made for reopening the
case in chief for the receipt of further evidence. The People have
no right to withhold a material part of their evidence which could
as well be used in their case in chief, for the sole purpose of using
it in rebuttal. . . . The alleged confession was offered to establish
facts constituting guilt; the impeachment feature was incidental
and comparatively unimportant. It was no more proper for the
district attorney to offer the evidence as rebuttal after
defendant’s denial of the alleged statement, under the pretense
that it was offered to impeach the defendant, than it would have
been to offer it in rebuttal if the defendant had not been
questioned about it at all. It makes no difference here that the
testimony as to the confession, aside from being evidence of the
fact of guilt, also tended to impeach the defendant. [Citation.]
The practice of allowing the district attorney to withhold a part of
his case in chief and to offer it after the defendant has closed
cannot be approved.” (People v. Rodriguez, supra, 58 Cal.App.2d
at pp. 418–419.)

13
Here, as in People v. Rodriguez, supra, 58 Cal.App.2d 415,
the use of Brady’s testimony to impeach Sobhani was peripheral
compared to its use as evidence of propensity to commit child
abuse under Evidence Code section 1109. This type of evidence of
prior abuse is classically used as evidence supporting guilt, so it
was properly part of the People’s case-in-chief, whether initially
or upon a motion to reopen and showing of good cause under the
statute. It was error for the trial court to permit it as it did.
III. Prejudice
Evidentiary error under state law is evaluated for prejudice
under the harmless error rule of People v. Watson (1956)
46 Cal.2d 818, 836. Under Watson, a reviewing court must
reverse if “it is reasonably probable that a result more favorable
to the appealing party would have been reached in the absence of
the error.” (Ibid.) There is a reasonable probability of a more
favorable result within the meaning of Watson when there exists
at least such an equal balance of reasonable probabilities as to
leave the court in serious doubt as to whether the error affected
the verdict. (People v. Mower (2002) 28 Cal.4th 457, 484.)
We find no prejudice in the admission of the rebuttal
testimony. The evidence of Brady’s “abuse” paled in comparison
to that inflicted upon Aubrianna. The evidence of Aubrianna’s
abuse consisted of photos, observation of the injuries, and more
detailed testimony by the complaining witness. Further, Brady’s
testimony was short and somewhat vague as to whether any
injury was inflicted when Sobhani allegedly shouted at him and
squeezed him.
Importantly, the trial court also offered Sobhani an
opportunity to meet the rebuttal evidence with a surrebuttal.
Sobhani did so by testifying as to the allegations about her

14
treatment of Brady, effectively having the last word on the
subject.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

STRATTON, P. J.

We concur:

VIRAMONTES, J.

SCHERB, J.

15

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.