In re B.A. CA2/3

CourtListener 10847927Calctapp24 de abr. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 4/24/26 In re B.A. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re B.A. et al., Persons Coming B346601
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. Nos.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN 24CCJP00479A,
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 24CCJP00479B,
24CCJP00479C
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

S.A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Mark A. Davis, Judge. Affirmed in part, dismissed
in part.
Emery El Habiby, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Brian Mahler, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
Mother appeals from the juvenile court’s orders made
at the 12-month review hearing as to her three children. She
argues the court erred when it (1) found the children would be
at substantial risk of detriment if returned to mother and ordered
they remain in their placement; and (2) found the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) had
provided mother with reasonable services under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.21.1 As the children have since
been returned to mother’s custody, we conclude mother’s appeal
as to the court’s suitable placement order is moot. We conclude
substantial evidence supported the court’s reasonable services
finding and affirm the court’s orders.
BACKGROUND
1. The family
The family consists of mother, father (who is not a party
to this appeal), and their three children B.A. (born in 2011),
M.A. (born in 2013), and J.A. (born in 2015). Parents are not
married and live in separate homes in Apple Valley, a town
in San Bernardino County. Mother was diagnosed with
schizoaffective disorder when she was 18 and has a history
of mental health hospitalizations.
The family has a prior child welfare history. In May 2013,
the juvenile court in San Bernardino County sustained a
dependency petition finding B.A. was at substantial risk of
neglect and harm due to mother having a mental health condition
that interfered with her ability to care for the child. That court
terminated its jurisdiction in September 2014 and issued a family

1 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code unless otherwise noted.

2
law order granting mother sole physical custody of B.A. and M.A.
and both parents legal custody. Over the years, several reports
of general neglect were made about the family that were deemed
unfounded or inconclusive.
2. Section 300 petition
On February 13, 2024, DCFS filed a section 300 petition
on behalf of the three children, who were staying with their adult
half-sibling April and her husband Aaron in Los Angeles county.
The petition alleged parents had medically neglected and failed
to provide the children with regular education instruction, and
mother was incapable of providing regular care and supervision
of the children due to: her history of mental and emotional
problems, including a diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder; her
symptoms of depression, paranoia, suicidal ideation, and auditory
hallucinations; and her failure to take psychotropic medications
as prescribed and to participate in mental health treatment.
In October 2023, parents had asked April (father’s
daughter) to care for the children because mother was suffering
from depression and hearing voices. Father was unable to care
for the children due to his own health issues. Mother didn’t
communicate with April “for weeks due to ongoing psychiatric
hospitalizations.”
When the children arrived at April’s home, the children
were “disheveled,” had no schedule, could not “complete daily
living tasks” independently—such as getting dressed, and had
extreme delays in their speech, motor and cognitive skills, and
“health.” April also had learned from the children that they had
not been to school for more than three years.2 In December 2023,

2 Mother had home schooled the children since Covid. In her
words, it “didn’t work.” J.A. never had been to school.

3
mother had asked April to return the children—she was worried
she’d lose her home if she lost the funding she received for the
children. April and Aaron convinced parents to let the children
stay. Parents gave April and Aaron authorization to make
medical and educational decisions for the children.
On January 4, 2024, April took the children to the
pediatrician.3 Mother went to the pediatrician’s office to sign
the paperwork but did not stay for the children’s appointment.
The pediatrician was concerned about neglect as the children
had “speech delays, gait challenges, sensory challenges, audiology
concerns, tinnitus, high cholesterol, and high blood pressure.”
The children were referred to behavioral and mental health
services, neurology, audiology, occupational therapy, speech
therapy, physical therapy, and for ADHD/autism evaluations.
April enrolled the children in school the second week
of January 2024. The children were improving in April and
Aaron’s care. Mother had calls with the children most evenings.
Parents had monitored visits with the children on Saturdays
and Sundays.
In its jurisdiction/disposition report filed March 26, 2024,
DCFS described the children as “hav[ing] demonstrated failure to
meet necessary milestones in areas such as speech, motor, social,
emotional, and cognitive development or independent skills.”
There also were “gaps in [the] children’s learning.” DCFS noted
the children had “present[ed] with extreme delays” in several
areas. DCFS described parents as having “a chronic pattern of

3 Mother had not taken the children to the doctor since
August 2022, and she had last taken the children to the dentist
more than a year earlier.

4
neglecting their children’s needs.” DCFS concluded mother
“lack[ed] regular and consistent medication compliance to
manage her symptoms, which has been the case for many years,
as evident by DCFS referral history.” The report continued,
“Though [mother] regularly makes her own protective plans
for her children to go with family when she is experiencing . . .
symptoms, [mother]’s mental health has impeded her from
meeting the needs of her children, including access to regular
medical and dental visits, developmental and behavioral services,
and education.” DCFS was concerned that “both parents
appear[ed] to lack insight and minimize[d] their children’s
developmental delays and mental health issues” and believed
it was unsafe for children to return to either parent.
In May 2024, the juvenile court sustained the petition
and assumed jurisdiction over the children, removed the children
from parents’ care and ordered them suitably placed, and granted
reunification services to parents. Mother’s case plan included
participation in parenting classes, individual counseling
to address mental health issues, mental health counseling
and taking all prescribed psychotropic medications, conjoint
counseling with the children if recommended by their individual
therapists, and three-hour monitored visits three times each
week.4

4 Mother filed an appeal from the court’s jurisdictional
findings and disposition orders. This court dismissed that appeal
after mother’s counsel filed a brief under In re Phoenix H. (2009)
47 Cal.4th 835, 844, and mother did not notify the court of any
contentions that she believed the court should consider. (Id.
at p. 838.)

5
3. Six-month review period
According to DCFS’s status review report filed October 17,
2024, the children had made “tremendous progress” in April’s
and Aaron’s care. They were attending in-person school,
extracurricular activities, and church.
The children had been receiving medical services at
Olive View Medical Center, but their medical care was being
transferred to Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) where
they could receive more services at one facility. At Olive View,
B.A. received weekly physical therapy, she and M.A. both had
EEG tests showing abnormalities, and J.A. had been diagnosed
with an eustachian tube dysfunction that affected his ability
to eat. All three children were being evaluated for IEPs due to
signs of autism. B.A. had received mental health services since
June 2024 to address her anxiety from suffering neglect and
recently had begun weekly, individual counseling; M.A.—due
to facility scheduling delays—hadn’t begun his weekly therapy
sessions until July 25, 2024; and J.A. was on the waitlist.
In September 2024, the social worker conducted a home
assessment of mother’s home in Apple Valley. There were many
animals in the home, it had a “foul odor,” and the floors were
“very dirty.” Mother agreed to change the cat litter and clean
the floors.
DCFS reported that mother had been complying with
her case plan. She had received a certificate of completion for
her parenting class but continued to attend class. Mother said,
“ ‘The parenting classes have taught me the tools to get closer
to my children and understand them.’ ” Mother stated she
understood “the mistakes she made,” and she was glad the
children were receiving the services they needed and would

6
“assure that they continue to receive those services when and
if the children return to her care.” Mother began individual
counseling in May 2024. On October 2, 2024, mother’s therapist
told the social worker that mother had been “mentally stable,
ever since she started services with her.” The therapist was
working with mother on “how to stay motivated to get tasks
completed.” The therapist planned to do a full assessment
of mother’s home and give her feedback on how to make it
suitable for her children. She also had been teaching mother
about nutrition and suitable meals for the children, instead of
fast food. The therapist stated mother “has shown commitment
to her case plan and is trying to do what is needed to reunify with
her children.” Mother also was under the care of a psychiatrist.
She was taking all her prescribed medications and receiving a
monthly injection.
Visitation had been challenging due to the children’s
school schedule, the fact parents lived about 100 miles away
from April’s home, and that mother was unable to drive long
distances on the freeway. The family agreed to weekend visits,
with a monitor transporting the children. Mother and father
also had FaceTime calls with the children three times a week
from 7 p.m. to 8 p.m. Mother was on time and prepared for visits.
The social worker had observed mother was appropriate with
the children and stayed engaged with them as she watched
them play. The social worker also observed mother “redirect
the children when they were misbehaving.” DCFS liberalized
visitation in September, giving mother two hours of unmonitored
and two hours of monitored visitation. The children said they
enjoyed their time with parents. They wanted to reunify with
mother.

7
In a “Reunification Assessment,” however, the same
social worker reported mother had been observed to “lack[ ]
focus” and “lack[ ] empathy for the children” during visits.
Mother had “not show[n] that she is attuned to the [c]hildren’s
physical or emotional needs.” She did not “demonstrate acts
of protection and supportive behaviors during visitation” and
“struggle[d] to show the ability to reinforce appropriate roles
and boundaries for the children.” Mother “often required
prompting from the visitation monitor.”
At the November 1, 2024 six-month review hearing, DCFS
recommended the court continue family reunification services
for parents. Counsel noted mother was “in full compliance” and
“doing very well with her case plan” but stated DCFS still had
concerns about the children’s safety in her care. Mother’s home
“still had multiple animals and had a foul odor,” and she still had
not shown she was “in tune to the physical and emotional needs”
of the children during visits. Minors’ counsel asserted the
children had “serious medical conditions that need[ed] to be
attended to before they [would be] ready to return” to mother’s
home. The court questioned counsel about DCFS’s safety
concerns given mother’s progress. Counsel explained DCFS
did not have “substantive evidence” that mother would be able
to meet the children’s special medical needs “at this point.”
Counsel further explained that, although mother could not drive
to the children’s appointments in Los Angeles, rescheduling
their appointments closer to her home would delay the children’s
diagnoses and medical care. Counsel clarified it “certainly is
not [DCFS]’s position the children can never return home.”
The court continued parents’ reunification services but
declined to return the children to mother “in light of health

8
conditions and the appointments set up.” The court ordered
DCFS to provide mother with overnight visits on one weekend
night, once a week for a month. If there were no issues, DCFS
had discretion to increase mother’s overnight visits. Overnight
visits were to begin “once the odor and pet issues ha[d] been
resolved.”
4. 12-month review period
On April 14, 2025, DCFS filed its status review report for
the upcoming 12-month review hearing. Mother’s home now was
clean and odor-free. According to mother, overnight visits were
going well, and she was “actively implement[ing] the parenting
skills” she had learned. Mother prepared “homemade meals”
for the children and occasionally took them out to eat when they
asked. B.A. wanted to return to mother’s home after she finished
middle school. Her brothers wanted to visit parents only on the
weekends. They loved their parents but wanted to continue to
live with their caregivers where they felt safe and happy.
On April 7, 2025, during a call from the social worker,
B.A.’s therapist said B.A. had “started opening up more” than
she had in her earlier sessions. They were beginning to build
a “strong [rapport] and therapeutic bond.” B.A. was “making
a lot of progress,” and the therapist expected her “to continue
improving.” In January, B.A.’s pediatrician also had referred
her to “trauma focused cognitive behavioral therapy.”
M.A. continued to suffer from “focal seizures,” as well as
asthma and allergies. He was to have another EEG and MRI.
His next neurology appointment was scheduled for June. On
April 8, the social worker spoke to M.A.’s therapist who said
M.A. also had “been opening up more during therapy.” He was

9
“doing very well and continue[d] to make positive strides in the
therapeutic process.”
J.A. was to have a tonsillectomy. J.A. had had a neurology
appointment on February 10, 2025, and an EEG on March 14.
The social worker attempted to speak with J.A.’s therapist,
but the therapist did not return her call. The caregiver said
J.A. was participating in therapy and “progressing well.”
A child and family team (CFT) meeting was held on
February 19, 2025, consisting of DCFS staff, the caregivers,
parents, and mother’s therapist. The group discussed several
“[w]orries.” The caregivers discussed the children’s medical and
behavioral issues. They said the children’s medical providers
“refer[red] to the children[’s] extreme neglect and trauma” as
the reason their “current needs [were] so high risk,” including
“self-harming, choking, and escalating behaviors.” The
caregivers also were “extremely worried” about B.A.’s behavior
—she intentionally hurt her brothers and showed no remorse.
The caregivers also discussed the boys’ history of self-harming.
J.A. had hit his head up until two months after his detention,
and M.A. had confided to April that he had cut his arms while
mother slept. The team also discussed concerns about mother’s
ability to recognize when one of the children was in “grave need
of attention, when having seizures, choking, and demonstrating
escalating behaviors.”
Because the children’s medical care had been transferred
to CHLA, their medical appointments now were delayed. Mother
wanted to be part of the doctors’ visits, but they were too far
away for her to attend. She had tried to call during medical
appointments, but the calls were not “clear.” The caregivers said
they had offered to pay for mother to take an Uber to CHLA to

10
attend the children’s appointments, but mother wouldn’t “accept
the help she is offered.” Mother also was worried about missing
her overnight visits if DCFS couldn’t transport the children.
Due to her anxiety, mother couldn’t drive to pick the children up.
Mother’s therapist also was concerned that, if the children had
to be driven to CHLA, mother wouldn’t be able to do that.
The team also discussed various “[f]amily [n]eeds,”
including, among others, “[t]he children need to have [the]
opportunity to address case issues in a therapeutic setting”;
and “parents need to be child specific medically trained for
the care of the specific needs of the children,” “attend medical
appointments[,] and participate in child [s]pecific medical
training.” The team developed and agreed on a case plan for
one “need” identified as: “Parents going to children’s specialists
and getting child specific training for each of the children.”
Parents were to “focus on specialists first.” The social worker
was to “provide the Child Specific Training confirmation form
to parents so that they [could] have [the forms] signed off by
specialists when they attend.” The caregivers were to “provide
information as to the upcoming appointments in time for the
Team to support and explore transportation options for the
parents.” The social worker gave CHLA the documentation
it required to show parents still had rights.
DCFS reported that, since the February CFT meeting,
the children had not had any in-person, specialist appointments.
There was an upcoming appointment for the boys on June 2,
2025 at CHLA. Mother had been prepared to participate in
a telephonic follow-up appointment with B.A.’s pediatrician
on March 6, but the provider could not “accommodate” a call
from a separate line.

11
On April 7, 2025, the social worker spoke with mother’s
therapist. The therapist confirmed mother remained mentally
stable and was taking her prescribed medications. Mother
had been “learning and applying new skills, such as preparing
homemade meals, in preparation for reunification with her
children.” Mother also had been keeping her home clean and
was “very mindful to maintain it, ensuring it [did] not return
to its previously unkempt state.” The therapist noted mother
had reported that “she does not hear voices anymore.” Earlier,
in January 2025, the social worker spoke with mother’s
psychiatrist. He stated mother was “expected to remain stable
as long as she continues to follow her prescribed medication
regimen and attend her monthly appointments” to receive a
prescribed, monthly injection.
Mother (and father) had had consistent virtual visits
with the children during the week and in-person visits on the
weekend. On February 1, 2025, mother began weekly, overnight
visits with the children. The social worker drove the children
from the caregivers’ home to mother’s home on Saturdays and
drove them back the next day. The social worker observed the
children were excited when they went to eat with parents at a
restaurant. The report stated the social worker had “observed
and assessed that mother is still in process of getting accustomed
on how to attend to all the children[’s] medical needs.” The social
worker stated mother “always appears scared when she needs
to attend to the children[’s] needs.” B.A. told a different social
worker she enjoyed spending time with parents and “loves being
at her mother’s home because her mother is ‘less strict’ compared
to the caregivers.” M.A. and J.A. enjoyed their visits with
mother, but during “one-on-one conversations” with the same

12
social worker “both boys became emotional and cried, repeating
that they only want to continue visiting their parents and do not
wish to be forced to live with them.”
DCFS determined the risk to the children was “high”
if returned to parents’ care at that time. DCFS found it was
“not yet appropriate to transition the children to mother’s care
due to concerns” that M.A. and J.A. could self-harm “if they
were sent to live with the mother again.” DCFS explained
the children’s “medical, developmental, and mental health
needs require ongoing caregiver attentiveness, advocacy,
and coordination with medical and educational providers to
ensure appropriate support and safety for each child.” DCFS
summarized those needs: B.A. had language delays, processing
challenges, and memory deficits, had an IEP for dyscalculia,
and was performing at a kindergarten level in math; M.A.
had hypoglycemia and seizures, required careful management
of his diet and close monitoring for mental health changes,
and used an inhaler; and J.A. had fine and oral motor delays,
sleep apnea, developmental delays, and possible apraxia, had
an IEP for stuttering, and was to have a tonsillectomy and
adenoidectomy with follow-up studies.
Although mother had complied with her case plan, DCFS
had concerns about “the safety of the children and the effects of
returning them to their mother’s care due to [J.A.’s] and [M.A.’s]
continued reiteration that they do not want to return to live with
[m]other.” DCFS also noted mother had “yet to receive child
specific medical training that was recommended to her during
the CFT[ ] [meeting] for [J.A.] and [M.A.] to be well aware of their
medical needs and treatment that she would have to follow-up

13
with to maintain their health and safety.” DCFS thus
recommended that the court continue reunification services.
In a last minute information filed May 19, 2025, DCFS
reported on parents’ virtual visits. The caregiver said parents
demonstrated “emotional warmth and affection toward the
children during visits,” such as saying, “ ‘I love you.’ ” Parents’
interactions, however, were “superficial,” and “lack[ed] consistent
structure or engagement.” The caregiver was concerned that,
“while the parents care for the children, they do not appear to
fully understand or respond to the children’s physical, medical,
or psychological needs, particularly during moments requiring
immediate or informed action.” During both in-person and
virtual visits, M.A. had “exhibited signs consistent with seizure
activity,” but parents had “failed to take appropriate steps, such
as engaging [M.A.] to assess his awareness or following medical
protocols” that had been shared with parents. According to the
caregiver, parents also had overlooked symptoms indicating
M.A. or J.A. might need their inhalers. The caregiver believed
parents “appear[ed] unprepared or inconsistent in responding
to the children’s more complex physical and emotional needs,
particularly in situations requiring medical judgment or
emotional regulation.”
5. 12-month review hearing
Mother submitted a declaration to the court in anticipation
of the May 1, 2025 12-month review hearing. On February 20
and 24, 2025, April had shared with mother a “ ‘Google Doc’ ”
listing the children’s upcoming appointments. Mother declared
she called CHLA on February 24 to speak to one of the doctors
about the children but was told CHLA “will only contact one
person, the caregiver, during these calls [and] . . . does not

14
facilitate three-way calls.” Mother declared that, between
February 24 and April 1, she called “multiple medical providers”
to obtain the children’s medical records, but many of them
told her the caregiver would have to provide authorization
to release the records. Mother declared she followed up with
the social worker on April 3 and 7 about having April authorize
the release of the records to her.
The May 1 hearing was continued for a contested hearing
on May 22. The court admitted DCFS’s exhibits and mother’s
declaration and exhibits into evidence. Mother also testified.
She generally described each child’s medical issues. She testified
she had learned to use M.A.’s glucose monitor by watching videos
and through April’s demonstration. April also had had mother
practice with it on M.A. once. Mother had not yet participated
in the children’s medical appointments. She had asked to
participate in telephonic appointments, but the providers would
call only one person, and April was afraid she’d accidentally be
disconnected if she tried to make a three-way call with mother.
Mother confirmed she’d been offered transportation to the
children’s initial in-person visit at CHLA, but she didn’t go
because she wasn’t “prepared” to stay overnight. The reporter’s
transcript reflects mother then said, “You won’t be going on
June 2.”5
Mother testified she was participating in individual
counseling once a week, was seeing a psychiatrist and taking all
prescribed medication, had attended approximately 35 parenting

5 This appears to be a mistranscription. Later, mother
testified she did not go to the first appointment at CHLA because
she didn’t have anyone to watch her dog, but she no longer had
that dog.

15
classes, and had maintained a clean and odor-free home for
“[a]t least six months.” Mother answered “no” when her counsel
asked if the social worker had “helped you to start counseling
with the children.” Counsel asked about mother’s plans if the
children were returned. Mother planned to enroll them in their
pre-Covid school. As for the children’s medical appointments,
the children’s insurance included transportation that mother
could use to take them to appointments in her area. Mother also
had investigated extracurriculars in her area for the children
to attend.
DCFS’s counsel asked mother to describe some of M.A.’s
symptoms when he “starts to experience a seizure.” She did
but testified she hadn’t seen M.A. exhibit any symptoms during
her visits. When asked about a video visit during which M.A.
had a seizure, mother stated it was “very hard to see exactly
what’s going on,” as she and father shared her phone for video
calls. She didn’t see M.A. having a seizure at the time. Counsel
also asked if M.A. ever had signs of low blood sugar and how
mother had responded. Mother stated that once—during a
monitored visit at a trampoline park—M.A. said he felt his blood
sugar might be low. He tested it and it was in the normal range,
so “he put his head down on the table and waited it out until
part of the visit was over.” As for J.A., mother testified she
gave him his inhaler as instructed when it was sent with him.
She observed J.A. to have difficulty breathing only once.
In terms of what she had done to improve her
understanding of the children’s medical care, mother testified
she had discussed their medical needs with April and looked
over their health care “passport[s].” She also had tried—
unsuccessfully—to get the children’s medical records from CHLA.

16
Counsel also asked mother to describe the types of doctors
the children needed to see. Mother responded, “[n]eurologist,”
an “ear, nose and throat doctor” for J.A., the pediatrician, and
the children had counseling and physical therapy. She wasn’t
sure about other specialists.
Mother was aware the boys had stated they were not ready
to return home. Their counsel asked mother if she were “willing
to respect their wishes and perhaps start with conjoint counseling
before having them” return. Mother was “willing to do that.”
B.A.’s counsel called the caregiver April as a witness.
April testified that for the initial CHLA appointment, she
and her husband had offered to pick parents up, drive them
to Los Angeles and pay for their hotel stay, take them to the
children’s medical appointments and to see the children’s
teachers, and to drive them back home. Parents declined.
April stated mother said she had to take care of her dogs.
All three children had upcoming neurology appointments on
June 2 at CHLA: to go over B.A.’s results of her EEG and MRI,6
to determine if M.A.’s seizures were related to his hypoglycemia
or PTSD, and to rule out seizures or anything else that could be
“impacting [J.A.’s] cognition.” J.A. also had trouble breathing at
night and was choking on his food due to difficulties swallowing.
April still was waiting to hear from the surgeon about scheduling
J.A.’s tonsil removal. April testified she was concerned that
mother wouldn’t be able to recognize M.A.’s seizure or low blood
sugar symptoms. She had the same concern with respect to J.A.’s
difficulty breathing at night. She and Aaron had to prop up J.A.

6 B.A. also had several referrals in other areas for which she
had upcoming assessments.

17
and give him medication when they heard him trying to catch
his breath in the middle of the night. April wanted the children
to finish their pending medical appointments to determine
their diagnoses before they returned to mother.
B.A.’s counsel joined in DCFS’s recommendation to
continue reunification services. Counsel acknowledged mother
had completed her case plan and “made great accomplishments.”
Counsel “would have liked to have seen . . . parents participating
meaningfully in [B.A.’s] care and in their medical and therapeutic
appointments.” Counsel noted mother had neglected B.A.’s
“medical, behavioral, and developmental issues and still hasn’t
participated in these appointments.” Counsel acknowledged
mother’s failure to participate wasn’t always her fault, but as
she had not, the children remained at risk. Counsel noted the
social worker had given mother a “form that needed to be signed”
by B.A.’s doctors but that hadn’t been done.
The boys’ counsel joined in B.A.’s counsel’s argument.
Counsel further argued that, as mother had not been to the boys’
medical appointments—and had not “observed any of these
very concerning medical issues with respect” to M.A. and J.A.—
counsel didn’t believe she was “educated with respect to how
serious and significant their medical concerns are.” Counsel
also commended mother’s progress and compliance with her
case plan but argued the emotional well-being of the children
must be considered. Counsel noted the boys had made “detailed
statements . . . about how strongly they feel about not going home
to mother at this time.” Counsel asked that the court continue
reunification services and “that we get conjoint counseling.”
Mother’s counsel asked the court to make a “no reasonable
services finding” and to release the children to mother. Counsel

18
argued the social worker had “not made any efforts to follow up
with any of mother’s providers.” She argued DCFS “failed to
give any services to [mother] in the last six months” other than
visiting mother’s home once a month. Counsel noted the court
had ordered conjoint counseling as part of mother’s case plan,
but there were “no recorded attempts to inquire with the
minors’ therapist about their readiness to participate in conjoint
counseling.” Counsel asserted mother’s “testimony clearly
demonstrated her increasing insight as to (A) what brought
this case here in the first place and (B) what she needs to do
going forward to ensure that the children’s education and
medical needs are met.” Counsel queried, “If we do not send
them home for mother to have time to observe these medical
behaviors, how will she ever learn?” Counsel reiterated there
had “been no efforts made to get these people into conjoint
counseling to ameliorate these issues.”
DCFS’s counsel argued DCFS had provided reasonable
services. Counsel noted the social worker “made regular,
consistent contact with the parents,” and went to mother’s home
and assessed it. Counsel argued that any failure on DCFS’s part
to “not follow up with [mother’s] service providers” “would really
only be a problem if [DCFS] was arguing that mother’s service[s]
had not been completed.” DCFS, however, conceded “mother has
done very well in her case plan.” Counsel argued the concern was
not about whether mother had “done programs” but “whether or
not these children can be safely returned to her care.”
Counsel noted “[m]other has not done the child’s specific
medical training that’s needed to safely meet these complex
needs.” Counsel also noted mother had not attended the
children’s in-person medical visits. Counsel acknowledged

19
mother had said she’d reached out and was prevented from
participating, but to counsel’s “mind,” that wasn’t “enough.”
Counsel argued the court should “continue reunification services
for mother, allow her an opportunity to participate actively in
all the children’s medical appointments. If she can demonstrate
she can do that, then the court would be in a better position
to order return, but at this time it is [DCFS]’s position that
she’s not capable of doing that.”
The court stated, “The only negative thing I see is that
there’s medical training for the children’s needs that was not
necessarily in [the] order that require a bit more time because
the needs are so significant for these kids.” The court noted it
“would be very comfortable if mother had opportunity [sic] to go
to more appointments, see what’s going on.” The court continued,
“I would like mother to participate meaningfully in the
appointments. That’s been an issue because very frequently
[April] did not really say she was necessary to go to some of these
appointments, but the ability to recognize the symptomology
for the kids that are choking at night. They cannot breathe.
They are behind in school. [They] have gross motor skill issues.
Those things are important.” The court noted the boys had
associated suicidal ideations with the idea of return that the
court “absolutely needs to consider.” The court commended
mother for all she had “done” and “encourage[d] her to go
further.”
The court found return to mother would create substantial
risk of detriment to the children’s physical or emotional well-
being. The court ordered further family reunification services
“as appropriate” and that continued jurisdiction was justified.
The court asked DCFS to assist mother “to get to these doctor

20
appointments and allow her to be prepared when we return for
a 22 hearing.” The court explained,
“This was a close call; but in light of the
potential detriment and physical well-being of the
children and their health conditions, I think a little
more time. [¶] It is important that mom have an
opportunity to be at these appointments to see more
of the kids, to see what people are saying so all
parties [sic]. It could be easy as [mother’s counsel]
said. She really does not see and cannot recognize
what’s going on well. The kids are not with her, so
it’s tough for her to make that determination. [¶] I
ask all parties allow mom to visit the kids frequently.
I encourage mom to go to appointments. I know she’s
gotten rid of the dog, so there’s no excuse why mom
would not be at every appointment she can be at just
to make sure she’s in the loop. All these conditions
sound very scary to me, and I want mom to be on top
of everything going on. [¶] I think she has an idea
but not as firm as I would like her to have before
the kids can return.”
The court ordered DCFS to work with mother and the
caregiver to put together an overnight schedule for the children
to visit mother during the summer. The court also ordered DCFS
to contact the children’s therapist about “the appropriateness
of conjoint counseling.” If the therapist recommended it,
the children were to begin conjoint counseling with mother
“forthwith.” DCFS was to assist the children and mother with
transportation to therapy, medical appointments, and visits.

21
The court found DCFS had “complied with the case plan
by making reasonable efforts to return the child to a safe home
and to complete any steps necessary to finalize the permanent
placement of the child.” The court found by clear and convincing
evidence that returning the children to mother’s physical custody
would create a substantial risk of detriment to the children,
“creating a continued necessity for and appropriateness of
the current placement.” The court set a review hearing for
November 18, 2025. Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
1. Mother’s challenge of the juvenile court’s suitable
placement order is moot
“A case becomes moot when events ‘ “render[ ] it impossible
for [a] court, if it should decide the case in favor of plaintiff,
to grant [the plaintiff] any effect[ive] relief.” ’ [Citation.] For
relief to be ‘effective,’ two requirements must be met. First, the
plaintiff must complain of an ongoing harm. Second, the harm
must be redressable or capable of being rectified by the outcome
the plaintiff seeks.” (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 276 (D.P.)
[“ ‘the critical factor in considering whether a dependency appeal
is moot is whether the appellate court can provide any effective
relief if it finds reversible error’ ”].) “A reviewing court must
‘ “decide on a case-by-case basis whether subsequent events in a
juvenile dependency matter make a case moot and whether [its]
decision would affect the outcome in a subsequent proceeding.” ’ ”
(Ibid.)
Part of mother’s appeal challenges the juvenile court’s
orders made at the 12-month review hearing finding return of
the children to her custody would be detrimental and ordering
the children remain suitably placed. While mother’s appeal

22
was pending—at the 18-month review hearing held on December
15 and 30, 2025—the court terminated its suitable placement
orders and ordered the children be returned to parents’ custody
on the condition that they live with mother.7 DCFS contends
mother’s challenge to the suitable placement orders is thus moot.
As the children have been returned to mother’s care,
a reversal of the suitable placement orders and remand of the
matter would have no practical effect. Accordingly, we can
grant mother no effective relief as to this portion of her appeal.
Nor will the now-superseded suitable placement orders have any
legal or practical effect on a future proceeding; mother does not
claim they will. The issue thus is moot. Mother has not asked
us to exercise our inherent discretion to reach the merits of this
moot part of her appeal. (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 282.) We
decline to do so and dismiss mother’s appeal as to the suitable
placement orders as moot.
2. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
reasonable services finding
a. Governing Law and Standard of Review
“When a child has been removed from a parent’s custody,
the court ordinarily must order child welfare services designed to
facilitate the reunification of the family.” (Michael G. v. Superior
Court (2023) 14 Cal.5th 609, 624 (Michael G.); § 361.5, subd. (a).)
Reunification services “ ‘enable [parents] to demonstrate parental
fitness and so regain custody of their dependent children.’ ”
(Michael G., at p. 624.) At each review hearing, if the child is
not returned to the parent, the juvenile court must determine

7 We took judicial notice of these orders on DCFS’s request.
(Code Civ. Proc., § 909; Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (d)(1), 459.)

23
“by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services
that were designed to aid the parent . . . in overcoming the
problems that led to the initial removal and the continued
custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent.”
(§ 366.21, subd. (e)(8).) Generally, “to support a finding that
services were reasonable, ‘the record should show that the
supervising agency identified the problems leading to the loss
of custody, offered services designed to remedy those problems,
maintained reasonable contact with the parents during the
course of the service plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist
the parents in areas where compliance proved difficult . . . .’ ”
(Michael G., at p. 625, fn. 6.)
“Reunification services should be tailored to the particular
needs of the family.” (In re A.G. (2017) 12 Cal.App.5th 994, 1001
(A.G.).) “The standard is not whether the services provided were
the best that might be provided in an ideal world, but whether
the services were reasonable under the circumstances.” (In re
Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 547; see also In re A.O.
(2025) 111 Cal.App.5th 1048, 1062 (A.O.) [“ ‘The adequacy of the
reunification plan and of the [D]epartment’s efforts to provide
suitable services is judged according to the circumstances of
the particular case.’ ”].)
We review the juvenile court’s reasonable services findings
for substantial evidence. (A.O., supra, 111 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 1061–1062.) “ ‘In general, when presented with a challenge to
the sufficiency of the evidence associated with a finding requiring
clear and convincing evidence, the court must determine whether
the record, viewed as a whole, contains substantial evidence
from which a reasonable trier of fact could have made the finding
of high probability demanded by this standard of proof.’ ” (Id. at

24
p. 1062, quoting Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989,
1005.) In making this assessment, “we review the record in the
light most favorable to the court’s determinations and draw all
reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the findings
and orders. [Citation.] ‘We do not reweigh the evidence or
exercise independent judgment, but merely determine if there
are sufficient facts to support the findings of the trial court.’ ”
(Kevin R. v. Superior Court (2010) 191 Cal.App.4th 676, 688–
689.)
b. Application
Mother contends DCFS did not provide her with reasonable
services during the review period between the six-month and
12-month review hearings. She argues DCFS failed (1) to
follow up with the children’s therapists to determine if conjoint
counseling could begin; (2) to follow up with mother’s medical
providers about her progress in treatment; and (3) to ensure
mother received child specific medical training.
As mother acknowledged, the problems that led to the
removal of the children stemmed from her inability to care for
them properly due to her mental health diagnosis, resulting
in her neglect of their medical care, education, and behavioral
and developmental issues. Mother’s case plan included her
participation in a parenting program, individual counseling, and
mental health counseling; an order that she take all prescribed
medications; and monitored visitation. The children were to have
individual counseling, and DCFS was “to provide [them] with
conjoint counseling if recommended by an individual therapist.”
It is undisputed mother was in full compliance with her
case plan and was having regular virtual visits with the children
during the week and in-person day and overnight visits on the

25
weekends. The social worker visited mother’s home each month
and had assessed it. Mother nevertheless argues DCFS hadn’t
contacted her medical providers about her progress in treatment
since October 2024, the end of the six-month review period. She
contends that, as a result, DCFS could not “adequately assess[ ]”
her “ability to regain custody of the children.” As DCFS noted
in its report filed for the 12-month review hearing, however,
a social worker contacted mother’s therapist on April 7, 2025.
DCFS reported the therapist’s statements that mother actively
was participating in weekly therapy sessions and was mentally
stable, was learning and applying new skills in preparing to
unify with the children, was compliant with her medication,
and was maintaining a clean home.8 As DCFS’s counsel noted
at the hearing, DCFS agreed mother had “done very well in
her case plan.”
Mother also argues there was no evidence in the record
indicating DCFS made any effort to follow up with the children’s
therapists to see if conjoint counseling with mother could begin.
She contends conjoint counseling was critical, as her sons had
said they did not want to live with her. Although DCFS was
in contact with the children’s therapists, mother is correct that
nothing in the record shows DCFS asked them about the children
beginning conjoint therapy with mother.9 We do not conclude

8 DCFS spoke to mother’s psychiatrist earlier, on
January 14, 2025, who stated mother was mentally stable and
in compliance with her oral medications and monthly injection.
9 There also is no indication, as DCFS notes, that any of
the children’s therapists had recommended conjoint counseling.
In April 2025, B.A.’s and M.A.’s therapists told the social worker
each child was beginning to open up more during therapy.

26
that lapse constituted a failure to provide mother with reasonable
services, however.
Mother testified—when asked by her counsel—that the
social worker had not helped her to start counseling with the
children. But nothing in the record indicates mother asked the
social worker about beginning conjoint therapy. As DCFS notes,
mother raised the issue for the first time at the 12-month review
hearing.10 (See In re Christina L. (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th 404, 416
(Christina L.) [“If Mother felt during the reunification period that
the services offered her were inadequate, she had the assistance
of counsel to seek guidance from the juvenile court in formulating
a better plan.”].) Starting conjoint therapy also was not one of
the “worries” the team—which included mother and her therapist
—discussed at the February 2025 CFT meeting. The team’s
discussion of “Family Needs” included the children’s “need to
have opportunity to address case issues in a therapeutic setting.”
Again, there is no indication that mother or her therapist (or
DCFS) discussed asking the children’s therapists about conjoint
therapy. Indeed, during the meeting, the team agreed on a case
plan to address only one of the discussed “needs”—parents going
to the children’s specialists and getting child specific training.
In any event, the children were undergoing individual
counseling—as ordered—and being treated for several serious
medical conditions that required numerous appointments and
diagnostic tests. (April testified each child had about six to 10
appointments each month.) The evidence supports a finding that

10 Even the declaration mother submitted for the hearing
—which the court admitted into evidence—did not mention
anything about conjoint therapy. Minors’ counsel also did not
raise the issue until the review hearing.

27
—based on the circumstances—DCFS’s prioritization of the
children’s participation in individual counseling and resolution
of their medical diagnoses, and mother’s participation in their
medical appointments and care, was reasonable. Moreover,
mother’s visitation had not been curtailed because conjoint
therapy had not begun.
The circumstances here thus are not at all like those in
the cases on which mother relies.11 (See T.J. v. Superior Court
(2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 1229, 1243–1245 [reasonable services
not provided where agency delayed in providing intellectually-
disabled mother with individual therapy until 11 months after
children had been removed and failed to provide her with, among
other services, a referral for anger management, despite anger
issues having been a reason for the dependency], disapproved
of on another ground in Michael G., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 631,
fn. 8; In re T.W.-1 (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 339, 346 [agency did not
provide reasonable services to out-of-state father where its initial
case plan “failed to identify any service providers and instead
placed the burden on [f]ather to locate services”; its updated
case plan, filed more than three months after disposition,
did not address all issues that had led to the minors’ removal
or determine whether the identified services would address
case issues; and agency set up only one telephone visit for father
during the six-month review period].)

11 We do not intend to suggest conjoint counseling between
mother and the children is not important—at the hearing the
court ordered DCFS to inquire about it and that it should begin
if the children’s therapists recommended it. We hold only that
substantial evidence supported the court’s reasonable services
finding.

28
Finally, mother contends the court’s reasonable services
finding was in error because DCFS did not ensure she received
the child specific medical training it had recommended at the
CFT meeting. The main impediment to returning the children
to mother at the 12-month review hearing was the fact—in the
court’s words—“there’s medical training for the children’s needs
that was not necessarily in [the] order that require a bit more
time because the needs are so significant for these kids.” Mother
had not been to the children’s medical appointments. The court
found it was “important” that mother be at the appointments
to hear what the doctors were saying, so she could recognize
when the children required medical attention. As mother notes,
nothing in the record indicates DCFS arranged medical training
for her. We conclude substantial evidence supports the court’s
finding that the services DCFS provided mother to address
this issue were reasonable under the circumstances.
First, the children’s medical conditions still were being
diagnosed and assessed during the review period. Their medical
care only recently had been transferred to CHLA. And their
next in-person appointment with their CHLA specialists—
in part, to go over their EEG and MRI results with a neurologist
—was not until June 2, 2025.
Second, the record shows mother had received information
on caring for M.A.’s and J.A.’s medical conditions. April had
shown mother how to use M.A.’s glucose monitor and had mother
practice with M.A.—mother also had watched videos; mother had
been instructed to give J.A. his inhaler every four to six hours,
which she did; M.A.’s 504c plan outlined “medical protocols”
to follow when he showed seizure activity symptoms; and the
pediatrician’s and school nurse’s “medical directives” had been

29
shared with mother. April also affirmed she had “made efforts
to familiarize mother with [the children’s] needs.” Nevertheless,
mother had not responded to M.A.’s symptoms “in a manner
consistent” with that guidance, and at a weekend visit,
apparently had not asked about M.A.’s “well-being” after he
had symptoms associated with low blood sugar. Mother also
apparently overlooked M.A.’s and J.A.’s symptoms indicating
they might need their inhalers.
The necessity for mother to attend the children’s
appointments with their specialists and to be trained on each
child’s specific medical conditions, as mother notes, was raised
at the CFT meeting in February. The team discussed concerns
about mother being able “to recognize when [a] child is in
grave need of attention, when having seizures, choking, and
demonstrating escalating behaviors.” Mother also had not
attended the children’s in-person medical appointments because
her anxiety prevented her from driving long distances. Although
the caregivers offered to transport her to CHLA, and pay for her
hotel, mother chose not to go because she had no one to watch
her dog.12
To address these issues, the team agreed on a case plan
for parents to “go[ ] to [the] children’s specialists and get[ ]
child specific training for each of the children.” The team agreed
parents would “focus on specialists first.” The record shows
DCFS provided reasonable services designed to help mother
implement that plan. DCFS asked the caregivers to provide
information on the children’s appointments in advance so

12 The children had had other in-person tests and emergency
room or urgent care visits that mother also did not attend.

30
the team could “support and explore transportation options”
for parents to get to those appointments. April promptly sent
mother a list of the children’s upcoming appointments. The
social worker also gave CHLA paperwork to demonstrate parents’
parental rights were intact. Mother still could not get access
to the children’s medical records because the caregiver had yet
to authorize their release, but mother had informed the social
worker about the issue only in early April.13 As part of the
CFT-agreed case plan, the social worker was to provide parents
with “the Child Specific Training confirmation form,” so they
could “have them signed off by specialists when they attend.”
It is unclear from the record whether the social worker gave
mother the form, but—as we said—the next appointment—
where mother would need the form—wasn’t until June 2.14
Although mother reached out to the social worker about
her inability to get the children’s records after the CFT meeting,
there is no indication that she asked for assistance in obtaining
medical training. Mother’s declaration, signed April 29, 2025,
did not mention medical training. Nor did mother’s counsel
argue DCFS’s services were unreasonable because they had
not provided her with child specific medical training. (See
Christina L., supra, 3 Cal.App.4th at p. 416.)

13 The providers also continued to be unable to facilitate
three-way calls. That mother could not participate in
telephonic appointments unfortunately delayed her ability to
get information on the children’s conditions directly from their
providers. That delay was not due to DCFS, however.
14 At the hearing, B.A.’s counsel asserted the social worker
had given mother “a child specific training confirmation form
that needed to be signed by [the children’s] doctors.”

31
It makes sense that DCFS would not yet have facilitated
medical training for mother, as the team had agreed she would
focus on seeing the children’s specialists first. Reasonably,
mother would have to meet with the specialists to learn what
they had to say about the children’s conditions before she could
understand how to care for those specific conditions. In short,
the true barrier to mother being able to understand the children’s
conditions and recognize their symptoms was the fact that—
through no fault of DCFS—she had not yet been to the children’s
appointments.
In any event—based on the fact mother was to have the
specialists “sign[ ] off” on the child specific training confirmation
form—it appears that either (1) mother’s attendance at the
children’s appointments—where presumably the specialists
would go over the children’s specific medical conditions with her
—was the “training”; or (2) the specialists had to sign the form
to confirm what specific training mother was to receive for each
child. Either way, as no in-person medical appointments had
been scheduled between the February CFT meeting and the
May 2025 hearing, the court reasonably could find DCFS
could not assist mother with child specific medical training
until she met with the specialists.
Mother argues the record doesn’t show DCFS “provided
her with resources and referrals to comply with the case plan
requirements.” She suggests her out-of-county location was the
reason. There is nothing in the record to suggest DCFS failed
to provide services to mother or it did not provide services due
to difficulties caused by the distance between the children’s
placement and mother’s home or mother’s inability to drive long
distances. Indeed, DCFS staff drove the children to mother’s

32
home and back to their placement for her weekend visits, and
DCFS said it would explore transportation options for mother
to attend the children’s upcoming appointments with their
medical specialists. (Cf. A.G., supra, 12 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1002–
1003, relied on by mother [reversing reasonable services finding
where father had been deported and there was no evidence
agency assisted father in contacting Mexican social services
agency for service referrals or identified any available services
that would comply with his case plan requirements; father’s
statement that he did not need reunification services did not
support finding of reasonable services].)
In sum, we conclude substantial evidence supported the
juvenile court’s finding by clear and convincing evidence that
DCFS provided mother with reasonable services given the
family’s circumstances.

33
DISPOSITION
We affirm the juvenile court’s May 22, 2025 orders and
dismiss as moot the appeal from the suitable placement orders.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

EGERTON, Acting P. J.

We concur:

ADAMS, J.

HANASONO, J.

34

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.