CourtListener 10846320•In re T.D. CA4/2
Texto completo
Filed 4/21/26 In re T.D. CA4/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re T.D., a Person Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
THE PEOPLE,
E087188
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super.Ct.No. DLRI2200026)
v.
OPINION
T.D.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from the Superior Court of Riverside County. Mark E. Petersen, Judge.
Affirmed.
Debbie Yen, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief Assistant Attorney
General, Arlene A. Sevidal, Assistant Attorney General, Eric A. Swenson and Tyler L.
Krentz, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
1
Defendant and appellant T.D. (Minor), who was 16 years old at the time, obtained
a firearm from a friend and shot an adult male several times resulting in his death. After
shooting the victim, he then attacked his uncle with a hammer rendering him
unconscious. Prior to this murder and assault, Minor had committed numerous offenses
as a juvenile and spent time in juvenile hall and other facilities. The People filed a
motion pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 seeking to transfer Minor’s
case to a court of criminal jurisdiction. The juvenile court transferred Minor’s case to
adult court after finding all factors true under Welfare and Institutions Code section 707
and that he was not amenable to rehabilitation under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court.
On appeal, Minor contends that the juvenile court abused its discretion by finding
that Minor should be transferred to a court of criminal jurisdiction as there was not
substantial evidence to support two of the five factors under Welfare and Institutions
Code section 707. He also insists that the juvenile court abused its discretion by finding
he was not amenable to rehabilitation under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court. We
find that substantial evidence supports the transfer order.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
A. PRIOR DETENTIONS
Minor committed several offenses and had several detentions leading up to the
current offense which brought about the motion by the People to transfer Minor to a court
of criminal jurisdiction. On August 10, 2022, he was booked into the Youth Treatment
and Education Center (YTEC) on suspicion of robbery (Pen. Code, § 211). Minor, who
was 14 years old at the time, beat up a man waiting for a bus and Minor’s cohort stole the
2
man’s cellular telephone. Minor was found nearby with blood on his shirt and the man’s
cellular telephone in his pocket. A petition pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code
section 602 was filed on August 11, 2022 charging Minor with robbery. Minor admitted
the allegations in the petition and was placed in his home on wardship probation for three
years.
On December 20, 2022, Minor was taken into custody and placed into the YTEC.
A petition was filed on December 21, 2022, for taking a vehicle without consent (Veh.
Code, § 10851) and driving without a license (Veh. Code, § 12500). Minor had taken his
mother’s car without her consent, and she had reported to the police that it had been
stolen. Minor returned to his mother’s residence in the vehicle while the police were
taking the report. A notice of hearing (NOH) for violation of the conditions of the
wardship probation was filed by the People. Minor admitted to the NOH. The petition
was dismissed. Minor was continued on probation along with being ordered to serve five
days in juvenile hall.
A review memorandum was submitted by the probation department on February
22, 2023. Minor’s school behavior was reported as poor. Minor had to be transferred to
another school. On his first day at the new school, he was suspended for five days for
using marijuana. On January 27, 2023, he was suspended for three days for intimidating
another student and breaking the student’s chain. On that same day, he took property by
use of force and intimidation from another student and was suspended for five days. A
recommendation was made by school officials that he be expelled. Minor had failed to
attend the recommended anger management and victim awareness classes which were
3
part of his probation. On January 31, 2023, Minor tested positive for marijuana. Minor
had completed some community service. It was recommended that Minor continue to be
on probation and submit to weekly drug tests. The matter was continued for three months
for Minor to comply with the terms of his probation.
On April 6, 2023, while Minor was still on probation, he was taken into custody
and placed into YTEC. He was charged in a petition filed on April 7, 2023, with
carjacking (Pen. Code, § 215) and attempting to evade a police officer (Veh. Code, §
2800.2). Minor, along with two other suspects, approached the victim at a gas station.
Minor placed the victim in a chokehold and demanded his car keys. The victim gave up
his keys and Minor proceeded to punch the victim in the face four or five times. Minor
and the other two suspects got into the victim’s vehicle and drove away. Minor, who was
driving, led the police on a high-speed chase until he crashed the vehicle. He fled and led
the police on a foot pursuit until he was finally apprehended. It was recommended that
Minor remain detained and not returned home.
At a hearing held on April 10, 2023, the juvenile court ordered that Minor be
detained at juvenile hall as continuance in the mother’s home was not appropriate.
Probation submitted a pre-plea report. Minor had advised the probation department that
he was jumped into the Happy Town Pomona gang when he turned 14 years old. His
gang moniker was “Active.” Minor was expelled from school in February 2023. Minor’s
mother claimed he was enrolled in home school. Minor admitted to using marijuana two
times each week. Minor was reported to suffer from night terrors and was prescribed
medication. Minor had never completed counseling as ordered as part of his probation.
4
Minor had not been submitting to drug testing. He finally was tested on March 28, 2023,
and tested positive for marijuana. The probation department was concerned about the
current charges as they were very serious in nature and showed disregard for the safety of
others. The probation department recommended out-of-home placement.
On June 16, 2023, Minor admitted to the carjacking charge and the evading a
police officer charge was dismissed. Minor was again placed on wardship probation.
Minor was to remain in juvenile hall until an appropriate placement could be found for
him. Upon successful completion of placement, he could be returned to his mother’s
home. The maximum confinement was six years. Minor was seen by a physician who
reported that Minor suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and
“Unspecified Disruptive, Impulse Control and Conduct Disorder.” He was prescribed
medication. Minor had been placed at Boys Republic on July 5, 2023.
On October 23, 2023, a NOH was filed by the probation department. Minor had
run away from the court-ordered placement facility of Boys Republic on October 20,
2023. His whereabouts were unknown. A warrant for Minor’s arrest was executed by
the juvenile court on October 24, 2023.
On November 22, 2023, the probation department submitted a review
memorandum. Prior to being AWOL from Boys Republic, Minor had participated in
counseling and had been attending high school. However, he had several behavior
reports. He also continued to test positive for marijuana. Minor’s whereabouts were still
unknown. At the six-month review hearing held on December 4, 2023, Minor had still
not been found. The matter was set for a 12-month review hearing.
5
On January 4, 2024, Minor surrendered himself to the Riverside Police
Department on the outstanding warrant. A hearing on the NOH filed on October 23,
2023, was conducted on January 5, 2024. Minor was placed in juvenile hall. The matter
was continued to January 8, 2024 At the NOH hearing, Minor admitted to leaving Boys
Republic without authorization. Minor was ordered to remain at juvenile hall until a
decision was made on disposition.
The probation department prepared a report on the proper disposition. It
concluded that placement in a secure youth treatment facility was required based on
several factors. The probation department noted that despite multiple efforts to support
Minor in his treatment, he had failed to maintain sobriety and continued to engage in
negative behavior. The probation department recommended placement away from the
area in a facility similar to Boys Republic would be appropriate so he could focus on his
treatment. At the hearing on the NOH, the People objected to placement and sought to
have him in a secure facility like YTEC. The matter was continued for a contested
dispositional hearing.
A NOH was filed on January 31, 2024. It alleged that Minor had violated his
wardship probation by committing battery (Pen. Code, § 242) and vandalism (Pen. Code,
§ 594, subd. (a)(2)) on December 30, 2023. He was alleged to have repeatedly punched a
female in the face and smashed her cellular telephone. A hearing was held on February
6, 2024. The probation department was ordered to prepare a new memorandum with
disposition recommendations based on all the new information. Minor remained detained
at juvenile hall.
6
The probation department filed a memorandum on February 26, 2024,
recommending placement at a secure facility, YTEC, for Minor’s own safety and the
safety of the public. The maximum confinement time would be six years. On February
29, 2024, Minor admitted to the October 23, 2023, NOH and the People agreed to dismiss
the new NOH filed on January 31, 2024. Minor was to be placed at YTEC. On February
23, 2024, Minor was approved for continued psychotropic medication. It was reported
that Minor had been getting into fights with other inmates at juvenile hall. One of his
victims had to be taken to the hospital as he had received a concussion. Minor was
placed at YTEC on April 3, 2024. Minor graduated from YTEC on October 9, 2024, and
was released from custody.
On October 19, 2024, Minor was detained on charges of two counts of assault with
a firearm (Pen. Code, § 245, subd. (a)(2)) on behalf of the Happy Town Pomona gang
(Pen. Code, § 186.22). A NOH was filed on January 10, 2025. On October 19, 2024,
Minor and three other youths approached their two victims in the park. One of the
suspects pistol whipped one of the victims while another told him not to move or he
would kill him. The other victim reported that Minor had pointed a pistol at his face.
The other two suspects were apprehended and admitted Minor was present during the
time of the assaults. In November and December 2024, Minor tested positive for
marijuana and alcohol. Minor had not been enrolled in school.
Minor was ordered detained at juvenile hall on January 13, 2025. According to
the report submitted by the probation department on January 27, 2025, the probation
department was recommending Minor’s placement in the Pathways to Success program
7
(Pathways). It was recommended that he be committed for four years in order to
complete all of the treatment programs. The probation department also requested that
Minor be restrained at all times while he was in the courtroom. He had been involved in
two fights while in court holding. The request was granted.
A memorandum on the January 10, 2025, NOH and subsequent petition was filed
on February 21, 2025. The probation department stated that the nature of the current
offense was “exceptionally severe and violent.” Minor coordinated with the other
suspects and showed a “disturbing level of indifference and brutality.” He was a
significant danger to society. Minor was a documented Happy Town gang member. He
had “H” and “T” tattoos. The probation department also reviewed Minor’s juvenile
justice history.
The probation department noted that child protective services had been involved
with Minor’s family from 2011 through 2024 based on allegations of general neglect by
Minor’s mother. Minor denied being a victim of physical or sexual abuse as a child; he
was unsure if he was subjected to emotional abuse. Minor reported using drugs because
he was “feeling bored.” Minor noted some childhood trauma but did not identify the
trauma. The evaluator from the probation department was concerned the trauma was
based on the death of Minor’s father and the neglect by his mother. However, his
childhood trauma was the not the only contributing factor to his criminal activity. He
showed no remorse for his criminal activity. The probation department noted it was
particularly disturbing that he committed this crime only 10 days after his release from
YTEC.
8
As for the time of confinement necessary for Minors rehabilitation, Minor had
been involved in an altercation in the court holding where he punched another youth in
the face. On February 9, 2025, he was involved in a “physical altercation” in the shower
with another inmate at juvenile hall. He had also been heard talking about his gang.
Minor was found suitable for commitment to Pathways. Minor was meeting all of his
developmental milestones and had successfully held a job while at YTEC. Minor’s
mother felt that Minor struggled with anger management and grief due to the passing of
his father. The probation department also noted that despite prior interventions including
therapy and less restrictive secure treatment programs, he repeatedly disregarded his
terms and conditions of probation. His confinement should be for four years.
At the hearing on February 27, 2025, Minor admitted to the violation of Penal
Code section 245, subdivision (a)(2), along with the gang enhancement pursuant to Penal
Code section 186.22, subdivision (b)(1)(B). He agreed to maximum confinement of eight
years at Pathways. The NOH was dismissed by the People. Minor was on the waitlist to
be admitted into Pathways for a baseline term of four years.
B. CURRENT CHARGES
A new petition was filed on April 9, 2025, which charged Minor with murder
(Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a)), assault with a deadly weapon (Pen. Code, § 245, subd.
(a)(1)) and possession of a firearm by a minor (Pen. Code, § 29820, subd. (a)). It was
additionally alleged for the murder charge that Minor personally used a firearm causing
great bodily injury and death (Pen. Code, § 12022.53, subd. (d)). It was also alleged as to
the assault that Minor caused great bodily injury within the meaning of Penal Code
9
section 12022.7, subdivision (a). According to a detention hearing report filed by the
probation department on April 10, 2025, on November 6, 2024, Minor went to a house
belonging to his uncle, David Rhodes. Minor was accompanied by his cousin A.D. and
her boyfriend, P.V. Minor asked Rhodes if the victim S.S. was at the house. They found
the victim in his room next to the garage. Rhodes heard gunshots. He yelled at Minor
and the two others who were standing just outside the victim’s room that they could not
shoot at his house. Rhodes looked inside the victim’s room and saw that the victim
appeared to be dead. Minor told Rhodes, “ ‘I fucked up uncle, I shot your friend.’ ”
Minor also told him, “ ‘I have the devil in me.’ ” Rhodes believed that Minor was under
the influence of methamphetamine. Minor then struck Rhodes in the head several times
with a hammer. Rhodes fell unconscious after being struck with the hammer.
Cellular telephone records showed that Minor was at Rhodes’s home the night of
the suspected murder. Recovered casings matched casings from a shooting that occurred
on the Gila River Indian Reservation in Arizona in May 2024. The victim died from
multiple gunshot wounds to his torso, back and arms.
P.V. admitted transporting his firearm from Arizona to California. He witnessed
Minor use the firearm to shoot the victim. He also witnessed Minor hit Rhodes with the
hammer. P.V. believed that Minor and his grandmother hid the hammer and other
evidence before the police arrived. A.D. heard Minor shoot the victim. She also
overheard Minor apologize to his grandmother for shooting the victim.
10
C. MOTION AND RULING ON TRANSFER TO COURT OF CRIMINAL
JURISDICTION
On April 10, 2025, the People filed a notice of motion and motion to transfer to a
court of criminal court jurisdiction pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 707,
subdivision (a)(1) (Transfer Motion). The Transfer Motion was based on the grounds
that Minor was 16 years old or older at the time of the commission of the crime and that
he was not amenable to the care, treatment and training available through facilities of the
Juvenile Court. At a hearing held on April 11, 2025, counsel for Minor asked for a
Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 transfer report (Transfer Report). Minor was
to remain detained at juvenile hall.
The probation department filed the Transfer Report on May 5, 2025. At the time
of the report, Minor was 17 years old. The report detailed that Minor had shot and killed
the victim on November 6, 2024, on the Soboba Indian Reservation. He also attacked
Robles with a hammer. Minor was interviewed on November 6, 2024, by the police. He
admitted that he was at Rhodes’s house and that Rhodes told Minor that he was under the
influence of a controlled substance. Rhodes told Minor that he had been in a fight with
the victim. Rhodes was bleeding from his head and face. Minor went to the victim’s
room and found him deceased. Rhodes told Minor that the victim had attacked him with
a hammer and that the victim was stealing from him. Minor then left the residence and
went home. Minor admitted picking up the hammer he saw in the living room at
Rhodes’s house but then dropped it. After an investigation, the police determined that
Minor had shot the victim and he was arrested on April 9, 2025. Statements regarding
11
the impact of the death of the victim were received from the victim’s family members
and friends. The loss of the victim had hit the family and friends hard, and they desired
to have Minor tried as an adult.
Minor had “H” and “T” tattoos on his arms. He was of American Indian ethnicity.
Minor was now denying any gang involvement, and claimed his tattoos stood for “Hot
Topic.” Minor also stated he left the gang in October 2024. Minor was in the 10th grade
and attending school while at juvenile hall. He wanted to graduate so he could enter the
Army. He denied he needed any special assistance at school. He was not taking any
medication. He admitted to drinking alcohol and using marijuana; he denied any use of
methamphetamine. Minor decided not to continue psychiatric treatment at juvenile hall
but he was participating in some individual and group therapy. Minor was previously
diagnosed with PTSD and “Unspecified Disruptive, Impulse Control and Conduct
Disorder.” Minor denied he was experiencing any mental health issues; he was not
taking medication. He also denied any abuse as a child.
It was reported by the supervising probation officer at juvenile hall that Minor,
since his admission in January 2025, had demonstrated inconsistent behavior and was
unpredictable. He had angry outbursts, which required his separation from other inmates.
In March 2025, Minor sustained a rule violation for inappropriate sexual misconduct. It
was reported from another inmate that Minor had made harassing statements to him that
were sexual in nature and had committed unwanted touching. An investigation was
ongoing. Another inmate recently complained about inappropriate statements made by
Minor ,which required that Minor be separated from other inmates. Minor had no
12
explanation for why he ran away from Boys Republic. The Transfer Report also
provided a detail of his previous charges.
Minor was interviewed on April 15, 2025, at juvenile hall. He was not asked
about the current offense based on the court’s order not to inquire about the offense. He
was willing to comply with any terms of probation. He wanted to be homeschooled. He
wanted to be placed at Pathways. He wanted to graduate and become a barber.
Minor’s mother was interviewed and she was an “emotional wreck.” She opined
the reasons for Minor’s behavior may be due to his father being incarcerated since Minor
was three years old. Minor and his father had a “bad falling out” right before his father
passed away in 2023. Minor’s mother hoped the allegations were not true and was not
sure of the appropriate disposition should they be found true.
The Transfer Report then detailed the five factors in Welfare and Institutions Code
section 707. As for the degree of criminal sophistication exhibited, Minor showed
sophistication by illegally obtaining a firearm especially at his young age. The reporter
also noted that he was unable to discuss the crime with Minor due to the court order.
Further, since no psychiatric evaluation was completed, it was unknown how to evaluate
any childhood trauma. Although Minor had previously been treated with medication, he
was currently refusing medication. Despite any previous treatment and time at YTEC,
Minor continued to engage in violent and very dangerous behaviors. Due to his
continued pattern of criminality and the escalation of his level of crime, Minor was
deemed appropriate for transfer to a court of criminal jurisdiction.
13
The second factor, whether he could be rehabilitated prior to the expiration of the
juvenile court’s jurisdiction, also favored that he should be transferred to adult court. If
Minor were to remain in juvenile court jurisdiction, the maximum time he would receive
would be seven years. The probation department was concerned that despite all of the
prior incarcerations and treatment he continued to commit crimes and procure weapons.
They noted, “The [Minor]’s actions, which included a weapon in each of the instant
offenses, and further planning to dispose of a murder weapon by providing it to a family
member, demonstrate sophistication and a calculated individual who has little regard for
the value of life or safety of others.” The probation department noted that Minor had
“received the entirety of services the juvenile justice system has to offer” but had not
benefitted from the services. The probation department addressed the third factor, his
previous delinquent history, which dated back to 2022. The probation department
detailed his prior offenses which have been set forth, ante. Minor’s dangerous behavior
showed a pattern of engaging in violent offenses and the crimes were escalating. The
fourth factor, previous attempts to rehabilitate Minor, detailed his previous commitments
to Boys Republic and YTEC, and that he had not benefitted from the programs.
Finally, the probation department addressed the fifth factor, the circumstances and
gravity of the offense alleged to have been committed by Minor. It noted the
circumstances of the new offense were intentional, violent, reckless and deliberate. They
involved sophistication and cruelty toward the victims. He also tried to cover up the
crime. There was no indication that Minor’s mental and emotional development impeded
his ability to know the illegal nature of his actions. His actions showed a high degree of
14
sophistication by illegally acquiring the firearm and disposing of evidence. The
probation department concluded that Minor was deemed appropriate for a transfer to a
court of criminal jurisdiction.
The first hearing on the Transfer Motion was held on May 8, 2025. The matter
was continued based on Minor’s counsel wanting a psychological evaluation of Minor.
Subsequent reports submitted by the probation department reported that Minor was
involved in physical altercations at juvenile hall on May 30 and May 31, 2025. They
were gang related. The probation department reported on June 16, 2025, that Minor was
upset he had not been transferred to the Pathways. He was refusing to attend school.
Minor appeared to have given up.
On July 10, 2025, Minor was transferred to Pathways. Minor reported being
happy he was starting the program. On August 20, 2025, it was reported Minor was
participating in weekly individual therapy sessions at Pathways. He was attending
school. He was respectful to other participants in the program and to staff. Minor was
not prescribed medication and did not have any special needs. A contested hearing on the
Transfer Motion was set for September 15, 2025.
On September 8, 2025, Minor’s counsel filed opposition to the Transfer Motion
relying on an evaluation by Dr. Tonneka Caddell, a clinical psychologist, to support that
Minor should remain in juvenile court. Dr. Caddell concluded that Minor lacked
antisocial or delinquent tendencies, and based on his personality testing and background,
he was amenable to rehabilitation and should remain in juvenile court.
15
Dr. Caddell interviewed Minor and advised him the responses may be shared with the
juvenile court and opposing counsel. Dr. Caddell issued a scale of intelligence test, a
PTSD checklist, a depression test and assessment of violence risk test. Dr. Caddell
reviewed all of Minor’s records after November 2024.
As for Minor’s background, he indicated that both of his parents were Native
American. He lived on the Soboba Reservation during his childhood. He spent time in
foster care, which he described as bringing stability to his life. Minor reported that he
moved many times while he was young as his mother had no income. She relied on
money from the tribe. He expressed frustration with their financial situation. He felt as
though he had to raise himself. He indicated that his mother remarried and his stepfather
was emotionally abusive toward him.
As for his father, Minor reported feeling abandoned by his father. He had early
exposure to guns and drugs. His father went to prison for murder and was killed in prison
when Minor was 14 years old. He felt that he was left without a role model when his
father went to prison. He also stated that his cousins physically abused him starting when
he was seven years old. His only support system was his girlfriend and one friend,
Danny, who was a gang member. Danny was involved in illegal activity including theft.
Minor moved in with Danny until he was 15 years old. He joined the Happy Town gang
at age 14 in order to have a sense of identity and belonging. He had a hard time being
consistent at school based on constantly moving. When he was at school, he
acknowledged significant behavioral issues.
16
Minor admitted to marijuana use and taking Xanax. He blamed the substance
abuse on early exposure to drugs by his family. He insisted that he was under the
influence of drugs when he committed most of his crimes. He also blamed impulsiveness
and boredom for the reasons he committed his crimes. Minor left his placement at Boys
Republic because he thought he was going to be transferred back to juvenile hall because
he was fighting a lot. As for his mental health, he reported a history of depression and
anxiety. He also reported a history of anger issues and PTSD. He did not take
medication because he did not like how it made him feel. He coped with the anxiety and
depression by praying to Santa Muerte which Dr. Caddel explained was common for
those engaged in illegal activities. Minor appeared to be somewhat guarded but was
oriented to person, place, time and situation. He had no thought disturbances such as
hallucinations or paranoia.
As for the tests administered to Minor, on the scale of intelligence, he scored in
the borderline range of intellectual functioning. Dr. Caddell did note that Minor was
discouraged during the test and appeared to give up. It was possible that the test may
have underestimated his intellectual ability. The test on depression showed that he was
suffering from “severe depression.” He also scored on the PTSD test to likely be
suffering from PTSD. Dr. Caddell administered the “Structured Assessment of Violence
Risk in Youth” (SAVRY) test. It focused on the future risk of violent or harmful
offending by youths ages 12 through 18. There were 24 factors that were considered that
were divided into three categories: historical risk factors; social/contextual risk factors;
and individual/clinical risk factors. Minor had four factors that were high in the historical
17
risk factors, which addressed past experiences and behaviors. He was moderate in three
of the factors. The factors that were critical to his risk were the lack of personal support,
poor parental management, and stress/poor coping. The lack of supportive relationships
was critical to a future risk for violence. Minor significantly lacked parental
involvement. He had three factors in the individual/clinical risk factors that were high
including negative attitudes, risk-taking behavior and anger management problems. Dr.
Caddell stated, “Risk-taking behaviors, negative attitudes, and anger management
difficulties were the most salient of his individual risk factors and should be addressed
with relevant interventions.”
Dr. Caddell reviewed the five factors in Welfare and Institutions Code section 707.
She referred to research on developmental maturity and that they showed the process of
childhood to adulthood was not complete until the age of 25. Minor’s drug use and
desire for connection made him more susceptible to negative peer influence and
engagement in reckless behaviors. He never learned adequate coping skills. He also had
borderline intellectual ability. These all moderated the idea that Minor’s behaviors
involved a high degree of criminal sophistication. Dr. Caddell also believed that Minor
could be rehabilitated with proper interventions, supervision, guidance and programs in
place within the juvenile court’s jurisdiction. She referred to his current behavior at
juvenile hall showing he was capable of complying with supervision requirements. Dr.
Caddell insisted that Minor had experienced a number of traumatic and distressing
experiences that had not been adequately addressed. Those issues could be addressed
under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court and not in criminal court. He should be
18
treated for PTSD and persistent depressive disorder. His substance abuse all should be
addressed. He required extensive treatment. He was capable of making positive changes
if he was in a safe environment that was highly structured and supervised. She opined
that treatment could address his criminal background. She also believed that Minor had
not performed adequately during prior programs because he did not understand the
importance of participating in treatment. She believed he could complete his treatment if
provided with social support, guidance and disengagement from negative associations. It
was her belief that Minor would not receive the rehabilitative care he needed if
transferred to criminal court.
In summary, she noted that Minor had not received appropriate support. Although
he was provided with some support once he was involved with the juvenile court system,
he was not “mentally or emotionally” able to benefit from the support. She also noted
that in the Native American community, there was a strong correlation between
delinquency and drug use. Minor needed extensive support to develop resiliency, coping
skills and necessary protective factors to become a productive member of society. He
was amenable to such rehabilitation. He was suitable for juvenile court proceedings.
Minor’s counsel argued that, based on these findings, Minor’s current crime
lacked criminal sophistication based on his age and negative peer influence. Minor could
rehabilitate for the six years in juvenile custody. Further, based on his age, he did not
grasp the consequences of committing the current offense.
19
The People filed a response. They agreed with the overall recommendation of the
probation department to transfer Minor to a court of criminal jurisdiction. The People
referred to the assessment by the probation department under the five factors of Welfare
and Institutions Code section 707. The People argued the weight that the court gives to
each factor was within the trial court’s discretion. The court had to find by clear and
convincing evidence that Minor was not amenable to rehabilitation while under the
jurisdiction of the juvenile court. The People also argued the trial court should consider
the safety and protection of the public.
The hearing was conducted on September 15, 2025. The juvenile court stated that
it had reviewed the report filed on May 5, 2025, the opposition filed by Minor, along with
the evaluation by Dr. Caddell, and the brief filed by the People on September 9, 2025.
The People reiterated their argument that all five factors in Welfare and Institutions Code
section 707 supported transfer. There was clear and convincing evidence supporting the
transfer. Minor’s counsel argued that Minor had been abandoned by his father, mother
and had no role models. He should be given the opportunity to rehabilitate. No evidence
was presented and the matter was taken under submission.
The juvenile court filed its “Ruling on Submitted Matter on September 15, 2025”
on October 2, 2025. The juvenile court reviewed the factual background of the case. The
juvenile court confirmed it had read Dr. Caddell’s report and provided a summary of that
report. The juvenile court noted, “Interestingly, Dr. Caddell’s report does not provide
any insight as to the minor’s participation in a multitude of crimes, his planning and
execution of those crimes, and his ability to obtain weapons, such as firearms in an illegal
20
manner.” The juvenile court also noted that Minor had been afforded treatment at Boys
Republic and YTEC. Despite receiving services in these controlled environments, Minor
continued to commit crimes upon his release. The juvenile court noted, “Little analysis is
given to the minor’s actual behavior during his long and complex criminal activity and
behavior, as well as multiple attempts at prior rehabilitation.” Further, there was no
explanation as to why prior services did not help but future services would help.
In evaluating the five factors, the juvenile court found that Minor exhibited a high
degree of sophistication. Minor graduated from the YTEC program on October 9, 2024,
and illegally obtained a firearm on October 19, 2024. Prior to the current crimes, he
participated in the Boys Republic program and YTEC. Minor had violently victimized
five separate individuals since the age of 14. The juvenile court concluded that by
obtaining an illegal firearm, planning to go to the victim’s residence, and attacking two
victims, he showed he had the ability to plan and engage in violent criminal conduct.
Further, by discarding or hiding the firearm, he showed the mindset of trying to avoid
responsibility. The burden of proof was met with this criteria.
As for whether Minor could be rehabilitated prior to the expiration of juvenile
court jurisdiction, Minor was currently 17 years old and jurisdiction would expire when
he was 23 or 25 years old. Despite the YTEC program and other services, Minor’s
criminal behavior continued. He continued to “procure weapons.” His procurement and
disposal of the weapons showed sophistication and disregard for the safety of others. His
pattern of criminal behavior while on probation showed he was not willing to comply
with terms of probation. After being released from YTEC, he committed new offenses
21
within 30 days. Minor had been afforded all levels of services by the probation
department. His criminal mentality had continued, and he was currently refusing
medication. The juvenile court concluded Minor did not show “amenability to
rehabilitation at all.” Minor showed no respect for the law or court orders. Sufficient
time did not exist to provide Minor with successful rehabilitative services.
The juvenile court also found the third factor was supported by substantial
evidence as Minor had an extensive, documented, delinquent history. Previous attempts
to rehabilitate Minor had not been successful despite the previous services being adequate
and extensive. Minor had completed the YTEC program. The juvenile court stated that
any progress seen in the programs was merely a “facade and did not represent a true
intent to change behavior or comply with lawful orders.” Finally, the gravity of the
offenses supported transfer to a court of criminal jurisdiction. Minor attacked his victims
in a violent and vicious manner. Minor confessed to killing the victim. He hid evidence
including his bloody shoes and the handgun.
The juvenile court concluded, after considering all the evidence, that “the People
have met their burden by clear and convincing evidence to have this court order a transfer
to a court of criminal jurisdiction.”
At a hearing on October 2, 2025, the parties appeared in court on the written
ruling. The juvenile court put on the record that it had reviewed all of the documents
submitted by the parties and reviewed the criteria in Welfare and Institutions Code
section 707. It found Minor was 16 years old when he committed the current crimes. It
found by clear and convincing evidence that Minor should be transferred to a court of
22
criminal jurisdiction. The juvenile court stated on the record the evidence in support of
the five factors as found in the written ruling. The order of transfer was filed on October
2, 2025.
DISCUSSION
Minor contends that two of the factors found true by the juvenile court—the
degree of criminal sophistication and whether he could be rehabilitated prior to the
expiration of juvenile court jurisdiction—do not support his transfer to juvenile court
under Welfare and Institutions Code section 707.
“In order to find that the minor should be transferred to a court of criminal
jurisdiction, the court shall find by clear and convincing evidence that the minor is not
amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court.” (Welf. &
Inst. Code, § 707, subd. (a)(3).) “[T]he express terms of [Welfare and Institutions Code]
section 707[, subdivision](a)(3) require the court to evaluate five criteria in determining
whether ‘the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the
juvenile court’ and that the statute does not require that any of those criteria be afforded
any greater weight than any other.” (In re Miguel R. (2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 152, 167
(Miguel R.).)
These five factors include: “(1) ‘[t]he degree of criminal sophistication exhibited
by the minor’ (§ 707, subd. (a)(3)(A)(i)); (2) ‘[w]hether the minor can be rehabilitated
prior to the expiration of the juvenile court’s jurisdiction’ (id., subd. (a)(3)(B)(i)); (3)
‘[t]he minor’s previous delinquent history’ (id., subd. (a)(3)(C)(i)); (4) ‘[s]uccess of
previous attempts by the juvenile court to rehabilitate the minor’ (id., subd. (a)(3)(D)(i));
23
and (5) ‘[t]he circumstances and gravity of the offense alleged in the petition to have
been committed by the minor’ (id., subd. (a)(3)(E)(i)).” (In re J.S. (2024) 105
Cal.App.5th 205, 212 (J.S.).)
“The juvenile court’s findings with respect to each of section 707’s five criteria
are findings of fact reviewed for substantial evidence. [Citation.] In conducting
substantial evidence review, we draw all reasonable inferences in support of the court’s
findings.” (Miguel R., supra, 100 Cal.App.5th at p. 165.) “We review the juvenile
court’s determination to transfer a minor to criminal court for abuse of discretion.” (J.S.,
supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at p. 211.)
Minor disputes two of the relevant factors: the degree of Minor’s criminal
sophistication, and whether he could be rehabilitated prior to the expiration of the
juvenile court’s jurisdiction.
A. CRIMINAL SOPHISTICATION
Minor first disputes that the evidence supported that he exhibited criminal
sophistication. “When evaluating the degree of criminal sophistication exhibited by the
minor, [Welfare and Institutions Code] section 707 requires the juvenile court to ‘give
weight to any relevant factor, including, but not limited to, the minor’s age, maturity,
intellectual capacity, and physical, mental, and emotional health at the time of the alleged
offense; the minor’s impetuosity or failure to appreciate risks and consequences of
criminal behavior; the effect of familial, adult, or peer pressure on the minor’s actions;
the effect of the minor’s family and community environment; the existence of childhood
trauma; the minor’s involvement in the child welfare or foster care system; and the status
24
of the minor as a victim of human trafficking, sexual abuse, or sexual battery on the
minor’s criminal sophistication.’ ” (J.S., supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at pp. 213-214.)
The juvenile court concluded that the factor of criminal sophistication was
supported by the evidence. It relied on the fact that 10 days after Minor was released
from YTEC, he obtained a firearm. This showed his criminal sophistication and ability to
engage in negative behavior. The juvenile court also referred to Minor having been
involved in three prior arrests that involved firearms. He also had been involved in
various programs including counseling and anger management programs in his prior
commitments. It noted that Minor had committed violent crimes against five different
victims since the age of 14. It concluded that by obtaining an illegal firearm, planning to
go to the victim’s residence, killing the victim, and then hitting Rhodes with a hammer,
showed Minor was capable of planning and engaging in violent conduct. Further, hiding
the evidence showed a criminal mindset. The juvenile court properly concluded based on
Minor committing several prior violent crimes, and the planned murder here wherein he
illegally obtained a firearm, that his criminal sophistication supported transfer to a court
of criminal jurisdiction.
Minor complains that the juvenile court did not meaningfully consider Dr.
Caddell’s findings. The juvenile court first noted in its ruling that it had reviewed Dr.
Caddell’s report. This included the information about Minor’s borderline intellectual
ability, his depression over his father dying in prison, his upbringing that included
involvement of child protective services, and that Minor’s drug use contributed to the
crimes he committed. Dr. Caddell found that there was not a high degree of
25
sophistication based on the fact Minor’s brain was not fully developed. Further, his drug
use and need for connection with someone made him susceptible to peer influences and
risky behavior. The juvenile court did consider the report by Dr. Caddell. It provided a
detailed summary of the evidence in Dr. Caddell’s report in its written ruling. The
juvenile court in its ruling stated, “The court has taken into consideration the
psychological evaluation when evaluating each of the criteria listed below.” It also noted
in its ruling that Minor had been involved with child protective services due to abuse and
neglect. It further noted Dr. Caddell’s conclusion that Minor was amenable to treatment
in the juvenile court. Minor’s claim on appeal that the juvenile court did not consider the
findings as to his childhood trauma is belied by the record. Further, the juvenile court
remarked that Dr. Caddell’s report failed to consider that Minor’s prior participation in
services at Boys Republic, YTEC, and services did nothing to stop his continued criminal
activity. It was clear that the juvenile court reviewed the entirety of Dr. Caddell’s report
but found, as was within its discretion, that it was not persuasive based on Minor’s crimes
and his failure to benefit from services already provided.
Minor also contends the juvenile court erred by concluding that the killing of the
victim was calculated and planned. He relies on evidence that P.V. disclosed that Minor
may have been sexually abused by the victim. The killing could have been in the heat of
passion. Further, Minor could have been armed with a firearm for any reason, including
that he was going to fix it up or because he was a gang member. Minor also points to his
youth, which undermines a finding of criminal sophistication.
26
The evidence supports the juvenile court’s conclusion that Minor planned the
killing of the victim. Minor obtained a firearm 10 days after leaving YTEC. While there
was no evidence that he specifically obtained the firearm to kill the victim, it is
undisputed that he took a loaded firearm to his uncle’s home. He went to his uncle’s
house armed with said firearm and asked immediately for the victim. He then shot the
victim multiple times. The evidence supports a calculated killing. P.V. told the
probation officer that he believed that Minor wanted to “get” the victim. When they
arrived at Rhodes’s house, Minor said that he was going to “handle this.” Immediately
following the murder, Minor told his uncle he had “fucked up” and killed the victim, and
that he had the “devil in me.” Further, he actively sought to hide the firearm after the
killing and he tried to blame his uncle. While Minor claims that the murder could have
been the result of Minor being sexually assaulted by the victim, Minor denied to the
probation officer that he had ever been physically or sexually abused. The juvenile court
could reasonably rely on Minor’s statement. All of these factors support that Minor
calculated the killing of the victim by immediately asking for the victim when he arrived
at Rhodes’s home, readily admitting to killing the victim, and disposing of the firearm to
avoid detection.
Finally, the juvenile court did consider Minor’s age in considering his criminal
sophistication. The court relied on the evidence pointed out by the People that Minor had
committed violent crimes against five different victims while he was between the ages of
14 and 17. Further, Minor had the “mindset” of destroying or getting rid of the evidence,
which showed maturity. The juvenile court also noted that Minor was 16 years and 8
27
months when he committed the instant crime and had received numerous services prior to
the commission of the crime. Finally, as noted, the juvenile court had extensively
reviewed Dr. Caddell’s report. The juvenile court’s finding as to the first criteria of
criminal sophistication is supported by substantial evidence.
B. REHABILITATION WITHIN JUVENILE COURT JURISDICTION
Minor also contends there was no substantial evidence supporting that he could
not be rehabilitated prior to the expiration of juvenile court jurisdiction.
“[T]he focus of the second criterion [in Welfare and Institution Code section 707]
is whether there is enough time to rehabilitate the minor while the minor is still eligible to
remain under juvenile court jurisdiction.” (Miguel R., supra, 100 Cal.App.5th at pp. 166-
167.) When evaluating this criterion, “the juvenile court shall give weight to . . . the
minor’s potential to grow and mature.” (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 707, subd. (a)(3)(B)(ii).)
The juvenile court noted that Minor would have approximately five or seven years
to benefit from rehabilitative services. The juvenile court agreed with the probation
report that Minor’s pattern of criminal behavior while on probation showed he was not
willing to comply with the terms of probation. Minor had left Boys Republic, and he
completed the YTEC program, only to immediately obtain a gun and commit murder. He
had received therapy, anger management classes and participated in substance abuse
programs. He refused his medication. The juvenile court concluded that he did not
“show amenability to rehabilitation at all. In fact, the minor has gone out of his way to
continue with delinquent behavior” and escalated the severity by shooting and killing
28
another human being. The juvenile court noted that Minor had no respect “for the law or
court orders.”
These conclusions were supported by substantial evidence. Minor was placed on
probation in 2022 after committing a robbery during which he beat the victim. While on
probation, he drove his mother’s car without her permission and had to serve five days in
juvenile hall. Not more than four months later, he was involved in a carjacking, wherein
even though the victim immediately gave up his keys, he punched the victim in the face.
He was sent to Boys Republic in July 2023, where he went to school and engaged in
services, but ran away in October 2023. He ran away because he thought he was going to
be transferred to juvenile hall for fighting. In January 2024, he surrendered but was
found to have committed battery and vandalism while AWOL from Boys Republic.
While in juvenile hall, he was involved in fights.
Minor was committed to YTEC in April 2024, and graduated October 9, 2024.
Once released, he committed assault with a deadly weapon against two victims. He was
placed in juvenile hall awaiting transfer to Pathways. In March 2025, he had to be
restrained at all times because he punched other inmates in the holding cell at court. Also
in March 2025, he was being investigated for inappropriate sexual behavior with another
inmate at juvenile hall. He had to be separated from the other inmates. Further, in May
2025, he had two physical altercations in juvenile hall.
29
Despite commitment to juvenile hall, and other commitments, Minor was
incapable of following orders. He continued his criminal activities, and as stated by the
juvenile court, he showed no respect to the law or court orders. The juvenile court
properly found that there was not sufficient time to provide Minor with successful
rehabilitative services. Although there is evidence of Minor’s childhood trauma and that
he suffered from PTSD and depressive disorder, he was given multiple opportunities to
address these issues. The structured program at YTEC did not benefit Minor. He
continued to get into fights. The juvenile court was well within its discretion to find that
Minor would not benefit from services during the time he was subject to the juvenile
court’s jurisdiction.
Finally, Minor argues that although the trial court found that all five criteria in
Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 weighed in favor of transfer, substantial
evidence fails to support that he was not amenable to rehabilitation. We disagree. The
juvenile court reviewed all of the evidence, including the information related to Minor’s
childhood, and found all five factors in Welfare and Institutions Code section 707 favored
transfer to a court of criminal jurisdiction. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion
in making a finding that Minor was not amenable to rehabilitation. We affirm the
juvenile court’s order.
30
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order transferring Minor to a court of criminal jurisdiction is
affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
MILLER
Acting P. J.
We concur:
CODRINGTON
J.
RAPHAEL
J.
31
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.