Lee v. Access Services CA2/5

CourtListener 10840448Calctapp9 de abr. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 4/9/26 Lee v. Access Services CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

BRENDA LEE, B345522

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21STCV38404)

ACCESS SERVICES, et al.,

Defendants and
Respondents.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of the
County of Los Angeles, Lee S. Arian, Judge. Dismissed.
Law Office of Gil L. Arbel, Gil L. Arbel, for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
McCune & Harber, Joseph W. Cheung, for Defendants and
Respondents.
I. INTRODUCTION

Plaintiff Brenda Lee appeals from an amended judgment
adding costs to the original judgment. She contends the trial
court erred when it entered the underlying order granting
summary judgment in favor of defendants Access Services and
MV Transportation, Inc. Because her notice of appeal purporting
to challenge the summary judgment order was untimely, we
dismiss the appeal.

II. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Original Judgment and First Appeal

On October 19, 2021, plaintiff filed a complaint against
defendants and three governmental entities asserting one cause
of action for negligence based on injuries she allegedly sustained
while boarding an Access Services van for disabled persons.
On November 20, 2024, the trial court granted defendants’
summary judgment motion.
On December 2, 2024, the trial court entered a judgment of
dismissal based on the summary judgment order. That judgment
dismissed the action in favor of defendants and provided that
they were prevailing parties entitled to an award of recoverable
costs. The clerk served a notice of entry of judgment on
December 3, 2024. The notice of appeal from the original
judgment was therefore due within 60 days, or on or before
February 1, 2025. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a)(1)(A).)1

1 All further rules references are to the California Rules of
Court.

2
On January 15, 2025, defendants filed their memorandum
of costs requesting an award in the amount of $43,298.74.
On January 21, 2025, within 60 days of the notice of entry
of judgment, plaintiff filed a notice of appeal from the judgment
(first appeal). That first appeal was assigned case number
B344026.2

B. Amended Judgment

On February 13, 2025, the trial court filed an amended
judgment which referenced and attached the November 20, 2024,
order granting summary judgment and provided that “the
December 2, 2024[,] judgment entered in [defendants’] favor
against [plaintiff] is amended to grant [defendants] $43,298.74 in
costs against [plaintiff].” Defendants served a notice of entry of
the amended judgment that same day.

C. Dismissal of First Appeal

On March 13, 2025, this court entered and served a
dismissal of the first appeal pursuant to rule 8.100(c). The
dismissal notified plaintiff that “[t]his order becomes final in 30
days and thereafter is not subject to rehearing or modification.
This time cannot be extended ([R]ule 8.264(b)(1)). Any party
desiring reinstatement must file a motion within 15 days of the
date of this order.” Plaintiff did not file a motion to reinstate the
appeal and on June 6, 2025, the clerk issued a remittitur in the
first appeal.

2 Plaintiff’s January 21, 2025, notice of appeal was received
and lodged by this court on February 14, 2025.

3
D. Second Appeal

On April 4, 2025, plaintiff filed a notice of appeal (the
second appeal) “from the [a]mended [j]udgment entered on
February 13, 2025, in favor of [d]efendants . . . and against
[p]laintiff, which dismissed [p]laintiff’s action on summary
judgment and awarded costs to [d]efendants. [¶] Plaintiff also
appeals from the original judgment entered on December 3, [sic]
2024, and all intermediate rulings, orders, and decisions that led
to the dismissal of this action.” That second appeal was assigned
case number B345522 and is the current pending appeal.

E. Dismissal Motion

After defendants filed their respondents’ brief, they filed a
motion to dismiss the second appeal, arguing that the April 4,
2025, notice of appeal purporting to challenge the trial court’s
December 2, 2024, judgment of dismissal was untimely as it was
filed more than 60 days after the clerk mailed notice of entry of
that judgment.
Plaintiff opposed the motion contending that she filed a
notice of appeal from the original judgment on January 21, 2025,
timely invoking this court’s jurisdiction and that, after the trial
court entered the amended judgment on February 13, 2025, she
filed a second notice of appeal on April 4, 2025, “as a protective
measure to ensure inclusion of the amended judgment and cost
award.” (Emphasis omitted.) According to plaintiff, “that second
notice did not nullify, supersede, or retroactively invalidate the
earlier timely notice.”

4
III. DISCUSSION

“Jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal is limited in scope to
the notice of appeal and the judgment appealed from.” (Dakota
Payphone, LLC v. Alcaraz (2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 493, 504
(Dakota).) “‘If a judgment or order is appealable, an aggrieved
party must file a timely appeal or forever lose the opportunity to
obtain appellate review.’ [Citations.]” (Norman I. Krug Real
Estate Investments, Inc. v. Praszker (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 35,
46.) “If the appeal is untimely, this court has no jurisdiction to
consider it, and it must be dismissed. ([R]ule 8.104(b);
[Citations].)” (Dakota, supra, 192 Cal.App.4th at p. 504.)
Here, after plaintiff’s first appeal was dismissed on
March 13, 2025, she filed a second notice of appeal from the
amended judgment. It is that second notice and judgment which
define and limit the scope of this appeal. Contrary to plaintiff’s
contention, “‘[w]here the judgment is modified merely to add
costs, attorney fees and interest, the original judgment is not
substantially changed and the time to appeal it is therefore not
affected.’ [Citations.] ‘When a party wishes to challenge both a
final judgment and a postjudgment costs/attorney fee order, the
normal procedure is to file two separate appeals: one from the
final judgment, and a second from the postjudgment order.’
[Citation.]” (Torres v. City of San Diego (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th
214, 222 (Torres).)
We conclude that the second appeal, to the extent it seeks
to raise a challenge to the merits of the trial court’s ruling on the
summary judgment motion,3 is untimely. The judgment

3 Plaintiff’s briefs in the second appeal raise only challenges
to the merits of the summary judgment order; she does not

5
dismissing the action based on that ruling was entered on
December 2, 2024, and the trial court served a notice of entry of
that judgment the next day. That notice triggered the 60-day
period in which plaintiff was required to file her notice of appeal
under rule 8.104(a)(1)(A). Although plaintiff initially filed a
notice of appeal within that time period, that first appeal was
subsequently dismissed for failure to timely prosecute and this
court was, at that point, divested of jurisdiction to consider the
merits of the summary judgment order. Therefore, the second
notice of appeal, which was filed well beyond the 60-day limit,
was ineffective to reinvest this court with the necessary
jurisdiction to act on the summary judgment order.
Although plaintiff acknowledges her first appeal was
dismissed after the 60-day limit had lapsed, she does not address
the effect of that dismissal on the timeliness issue, asserting only
that her first appeal was timely when filed. To the extent she is
suggesting that the initial filing of that appeal somehow tolled or
extended the running of the 60-day period, she provides no
authority in support of that proposition. And, based on the
reasoning in Torres, supra, 154 Cal.App.4th 214, we would reject
any such argument.

challenge the merits of the post-judgment order granting fees and
costs.

6
IV. DISPOSITION

The appeal is dismissed. Defendants are awarded costs on
appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

KIM (D.), J.

We concur:

BAKER, Acting P. J.

MOOR, J.

7

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.