CourtListener 10814364•In re R.P. CA2/2
Texto completo
Filed 3/24/26 In re R.P. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re R.P. et al., Persons Coming B345382
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct.
No. 19CCJP04473B-D)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
R.W.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Lucia J. Murillo, Juvenile Court Referee.
Affirmed.
Shaylah Padgett-Weibel, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Aileen Wong, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
******
Mother R.W. (mother) appeals from a dispositional order of
the juvenile court removing her children R.P. (born June 2019),
R.E. (born September 2021), and S.H. (born January 2024) from
her custody. We find the removal order was supported by
substantial evidence, minding the heightened burden of proof,
and find the juvenile court properly assessed whether DCFS
made reasonable efforts to prevent removal. We therefore affirm
the order.
COMBINED FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The family
Robin P. is the alleged father of R.P. Johnnie E., Robin P.’s
brother, is the presumed father of R.E. and paternal uncle to R.P.
Dontae H. is the presumed father of S.H.1
When the case was initiated, R.P. and S.H. were in
mother’s custody. R.E. lived with Johnnie E. However, mother
admitted leaving R.P. with Johnnie E. for two or three days.
Johnnie E. said mother would leave both R.P. and S.H. with him
several times a week.
Two years earlier, the Los Angeles Unified School District
(LAUSD) had evaluated R.P. and diagnosed him with autism.
1 The fathers are not parties to this appeal.
2
Mother disagreed with the diagnosis and did not believe R.P. was
autistic.
Prior child welfare history
On June 25, 2019, the Los Angeles Department of Children
and Family Services (DCFS) received a referral alleging mother
neglected R.P. Mother had a history of substance abuse and had
tested positive for methamphetamine on April 7, 2019. Mother
was living in transitional housing and had enrolled in an
inpatient substance abuse program but left the program shortly
thereafter, saying she did not need substance abuse treatment.
While the investigation was pending, on July 9, 2019, the social
worker was informed that Robin P. had forced mother to orally
copulate him. R.P. was not present during the incident. On
July 10, 2019, mother and R.P. were evicted from transitional
housing because mother allowed Robin P. in her room and a
domestic dispute occurred. Robin P. had a history of
methamphetamine use and was found passed out on the floor of
mother’s room with empty bottles on the floor, which may have
contained liquor.
Mother admitted to using methamphetamine since she was
12 years old because of the abuse she endured as a child. She
also admitted to using methamphetamine while pregnant. The
referral was substantiated.
On December 12, 2019, the juvenile court sustained a
petition pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 300
alleging mother had a seven-year history of substance abuse and
was a current user of methamphetamine, and that Robin P. had a
3
history of engaging in violent altercations with his female
companion.2
On February 18, 2021, the juvenile court terminated
jurisdiction with R.P. remaining in mother’s custody. Robin P.’s
whereabouts were unknown.
Current referral and initial investigation
On September 20, 2024, DCFS received a referral alleging
possible child abandonment of R.P. Johnnie E. arrived at the
police station with then-five-year-old R.P., stating mother was
homeless and periodically asked relatives to care for R.P. Mother
had asked Johnnie E. to care for R.P. the previous evening and
said she would pick up R.P. at 5:00 a.m. on September 20, 2024.
Mother failed to collect R.P. as she said she would. Johnnie E.
made numerous unsuccessful attempts to contact mother, with no
response. Johnnie E. asked other relatives if anyone could care
for the child, as he had to go to work. As no relatives were able to
care for R.P., and R.P. was in police protective custody, law
enforcement requested DCFS to respond.
Upon arrival the social worker spoke with Officer Burfield,
who reported mother could not be reached. Johnnie E. said
mother, who was reportedly homeless, had left R.P. with him at
least 10 times within the last six months. Due to work,
Johnnie E. was unable to provide further care for R.P., explaining
his job was in jeopardy because of mother’s constant failure to
pick up R.P. at the agreed times, making Johnnie E. late to work.
Johnnie E. informed the officer that mother had a history of
methamphetamine use. R.P. was placed in temporary protective
2 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
4
custody because no adult came forward to care for the child.
Police were considering charging mother with willful failure to
provide for her minor child, R.P., who was not enrolled in school,
daycare, or any other childcare program.
R.P. was unable to provide a meaningful statement. The
social worker observed several scars on his right cheek.
Johnnie E. informed the social worker he lived alone with
his son, R.E., and believed mother relapsed with
methamphetamine. Mother had struggled with addiction since
she was a teenager. Johnnie E. believed mother had relapsed
because she looked thinner than usual. Johnnie E. did not know
whether mother was under the influence when she dropped off
R.P. He was also unaware of whether mother used any other
substances.
Johnnie E. and mother had been in a relationship in the
past. During that time, mother would smoke methamphetamine
while at home with the children. Johnnie E. would have mother
smoke in the restroom and outside the home while the children
were inside. Johnnie E. described mother as a great mother, but
when she did not use methamphetamine, she became irritable.
Mother had participated in an inpatient rehabilitation program
as a condition of her prior DCFS involvement. Johnnie E. said
when she is feeling stressed, mother uses methamphetamine to
alleviate the stress. Mother also enjoyed using it and did so “just
for the heck of it.”
Johnnie E. admitted to having been arrested in the past for
selling “crack” and ecstasy. He denied using crack but admitted
he had used ecstasy in the past. Johnnie E. denied current use or
involvement in the sale of drugs. Since he was able to secure
other employment, Johnnie E. stopped using and selling drugs.
5
Johnnie E. identified his brother, Robin P., as the father of
R.P. Johnnie E. reported Robin P. was incarcerated.
Johnnie E. claimed there was no formal custodial
arrangement allowing him full custody of R.E., but mother
allowed Johnnie E. to care for R.E. fulltime. Johnnie E. described
himself as single but reported a desire to rekindle his
relationship with mother. However, mother prioritized her
methamphetamine use over their relationship. Johnnie E. stated
mother chooses to be homeless and “hooked on”
methamphetamine rather than to be with him.
Johnnie E. denied domestic violence between him and
mother. Regarding his arrest history for domestic violence,
Johnnie E. said mother called the police on him several times
because she was jealous of his sexual partners. Recently, mother
was upset because Johnnie E. refused to allow mother and the
children to spend the night because he had company. Mother
was angry and called the police falsely accusing him of assault.
Regarding the incident leading to the referral, Johnnie E.
said mother arrived at his home around 10:00 p.m. on
September 19, 2024, asking if she could leave R.P. with him
because she needed to sleep and get something to eat. Johnnie E.
agreed, and before mother left, she agreed she would pick up R.P.
at 5:00 a.m. because Johnnie E. had to work the next day.
Mother left with S.H. Mother never returned to pick up R.P., and
Johnnie E. called her 12 to 20 times before deciding to take R.P.
to the police station. Mother had previously left R.P. in his care
for “days on end.”
Johnnie E. reported mother had been homeless since April
2023 and had no routine or plan for the children’s care. Mother
6
previously lived with S.H.’s father, but their relationship soured,
and mother was evicted from the home.
The social worker called mother, but mother did not
answer. While the social worker was at Johnnie’s home, however,
mother called Johnnie E. crying, asking for R.P.’s location. The
social worker asked mother to meet so they could talk about R.P.
and S.H. Mother continued to cry and yell, but agreed to meet at
the police station.
At the police station meeting, mother was in distress and
crying intermittently throughout the interview. Mother said she
was not currently employed and initially refused to provide
information as to the whereabouts of S.H. She then stated the
child was with his paternal grandmother, Judy M. Mother
refused to provide information regarding the children’s fathers,
though confirmed she was previously in a relationship with
Johnnie E. but no longer wished to be with him. She continued to
rely on Johnnie E. to watch R.P. because Johnnie E. and R.P.
were blood relatives. Mother initially denied domestic violence
between Johnnie E. and her, but then said she and Johnnie E.
engaged in violence when mother was pregnant with S.H.
Mother refused to provide details about the incident.
Mother admitted previous involvement with DCFS and
confirmed participation in a drug rehabilitation program as part
of the case. Mother felt her previous enrollment was “a complete
waste of time” because she denied using drugs. Mother said she
completed the course in order to get her child back. Mother
reported when she was a minor, she was a dependent of the
court, but she eventually aged out of the dependency system.
Mother denied use of any illicit substances. She admitted
to having used drugs as a foster child but denied recent use. She
7
said the last time she used “hard drugs” was when she was 15 or
16 years old. Mother denied methamphetamine use, saying
Johnnie E. was trying to get her in trouble. She agreed to drug
test.
Mother denied R.P. had any behavioral or emotional
problems. She admitted LAUSD diagnosed him with autism, but
she disagreed with the diagnosis. R.P. did not participate in any
services regarding his diagnosis of autism. Mother stated she
knew R.P. best and did not feel he needed any services. R.P. was
not enrolled in school and did not receive dental care.
Mother also denied any behavioral or emotional problems
regarding R.E., who she allowed to stay with Johnnie E. fulltime
because R.E. was “a bad kid” and she felt he needed an
authoritative parent to handle him. Mother let Johnnie E.
handle R.E.’s medical and dental needs.
Mother said S.H. was meeting his developmental
milestones and had all immunizations.
Mother said she dropped off R.P. at Johnnie’s home the
night before. She usually allowed Johnnie E. to keep R.P. for a
day or two so the two boys could spend time together and bond.
Mother had agreed to pick up R.P. early the next morning, but
she accidentally overslept and did not return at the agreed-upon
time. Mother said she tried to reach Johnnie, but he ignored her
calls. Mother showed the social worker her call log, which
showed outgoing calls to Johnnie’s number and her Instagram,
revealing her attempts to contact Johnnie. Mother also showed
the social worker several messages from Johnnie E. asking
mother where she was, threatening mother for lying and accusing
mother of being “on dope” and neglecting R.P. Mother denied
being homeless, but said she was transitioning from place to
8
place. She had issues with “Section 8” housing assistance and
frequently stayed at hotels with the children while she searched
for an apartment that would accept her Section 8 housing
voucher. She refused to provide the location of the hotel where
she was currently staying.
Mother refuted Johnnie’s statements she would smoke in
the bathroom while the children were present or that she smoked
methamphetamine. Mother believed Johnnie’s allegations were
an attempt to get back at her for not reciprocating his sexual
advances.
The social worker unsuccessfully attempted to contact
Judy M. The social worker asked mother if Judy M. would allow
mother, R.P. and S.H. to stay in Judy M.’s home. Mother replied
Judy M. would not agree, but the maternal great-grandmother
(MGGM), Blanche H., would agree. The social worker proposed a
safety plan where the children could stay with mother at the
home of MGGM for seven days while mother drug tested.
MGGM reported Johnnie E. had called her and threatened
to call DCFS to report mother several weeks prior but had not
done so. MGGM thought Johnnie E. and mother got into an
argument and Johnnie E. intended to call DCFS as retaliation.
MGGM agreed to the safety plan to allow mother and the
children to stay with her for the next seven days.
The social worker went to Judy M.’s home where Judy M.
denied S.H. was present, and she did not know S.H.’s location.
Judy M. said mother was lying and did not want to be involved
with mother’s lies and drama. Judy M. denied taking care of S.H.
that day.
When the social worker confronted mother about the
discrepency, mother said Judy M. dropped off S.H. at the child’s
9
father’s home without her knowledge. Mother said she needed to
locate S.H. and ended the call.
The social worker went to MGGM’s home and was there
when mother arrived. The social worker was able to assess S.H.
and observed no bruises, markings or abnormalities. Mother and
MGGM agreed to the safety plan where mother would stay with
R.P. and S.H. at MGGM’s home for seven days. Mother would
submit to drug testing, and MGGM would primarily care for the
children and monitor mother’s contact with the children.
On September 24, 2024, the social worker attempted
unsuccessfully to contact mother. The social worker asked
MGGM about mother’s whereabouts and was told mother and the
children stayed at MGGM’s home for the weekend, but mother
left on Monday evening with the children. MGGM did not know
where mother spent the night.
When the social worker reached her, mother apologized for
missing the social worker’s call and said she had been sleeping.
Mother agreed to drug test. Mother said she violated the
agreement to stay at MGGM’s home because she felt like she was
imposing. She also said she was out late and did not feel like
driving to MGGM’s home. The social worker reminded mother of
the safety plan and mother agreed to comply. The social worker
informed mother of the nearest facility to drug test. The social
worker texted mother the testing site’s address and hours of
operation.
Mother informed the social worker all three children were
seen at St. John’s Community Health Center. However, S.H. was
not a patient at St. John’s Community Health Center and had
never been seen there. S.H. had an appointment on August 19,
2024, but the appointment was missed.
10
The social worker received a police report from an incident
that took place on July 17, 2024. Officer Segura reported mother
and Gary H. were arrested for possessing personal identifying
information with intent to defraud. The police stopped Gary H.
for failing to stop at a crosswalk for pedestrians. The officers
smelled marijuana coming from inside the car and asked mother
and Gary H. to exit the car. The police found mother in
possession of several identifying documents that did not belong to
her, and a bag of marijuana. Mother and Gary H. were arrested.
When mother was transferred to jail and was informed it was a
felony to enter the facility with drug paraphernalia, mother
disclosed she had a methamphetamine pipe in her bra. Mother
admitted the pipe belonged to her but denied she used it to smoke
methamphetamine.
On October 3, 2024, the social worker requested to assess
mother’s home. Mother said she was moving between different
motels so she could not give the social worker a location.
Mother’s drug test had been negative for drugs and alcohol.
On October 4, 2024, the social worker informed mother the
children needed to be seen at Los Angeles General Medical
Facility. Mother said the children received care from St. John’s
Community Health. The social worker stated S.H. had never
been to St. John’s and R.P. had not been seen for two years.
Mother said the health center’s records must be wrong. Mother
and the children were staying at Hollywood Inn Suites, but she
was scheduled to check out that day. Mother said she would
inform the social worker where she and the children went from
there.
The social worker texted mother later that day, as well as
the following day, but mother did not respond.
11
On October 8, 2024, mother stated she would take the
children to the scheduled medical appointment but requested
money for gas. When asked about the July 17, 2024 police report,
mother denied it was her in the police report. Upon further
questioning, mother admitted she was with a male under the
influence of marijuana who was driving recklessly. Mother
denied being under the influence of methamphetamine at that
time and denied use of methamphetamine.
Later the same day, the social worker received a call from
Los Angeles General Medical facility asking for mother’s address.
S.H. had been diagnosed with pink eye and needed a
prescription, but mother left the facility before the prescription
was ready.
The social worker interviewed Robin P. at Men’s Central
Jail. He had known mother for 10 years and had been in a
romantic relationship with mother for two years. Robin P. had
some concerns about mother’s drug use. Mother had a history of
crystal methamphetamine use and had been struggling with her
substance use for over five years. Mother previously participated
in a drug rehabilitation program and completed the course.
Robin P. admitted having a chronic drug problem. However, he
never used drugs with mother as he isolated himself and
disappeared for weeks while under the influence of
methamphetamine. Robin P. had no concerns regarding
Johnnie E. using substances. Robin P. confirmed he was the
biological father of R.P. and said the referral was mother’s fault
for violating her agreement with Johnnie.
The paternal grandmother (PGM) for R.P. and R.E.
reported mother had a troubled past and a penchant for drugs.
Mother would either use drugs, sell them, or both. Mother had
12
used substances since she was 16 years old. PGM had housed
R.P. and R.E. many times due to the mother’s and fathers’
instability. R.P. stayed with PGM for about a month, during
which time PGM tried to enroll him in school. Mother refused to
allow PGM to enroll R.P., saying PGM was overstepping.
Sometime in 2024, Johnnie E. asked PGM to help him kick
mother out of his home. PGM drove from Victorville to Los
Angeles to assist Johnnie. The police and Dontae H. were
present. Mother brought drugs into Johnnie’s home, which
resulted in an argument. Dontae H. and another male had gone
to Johnnie’s home, stating mother had in her possession drugs
that did not belong to her. PGM, concerned for the safety of R.P.
and R.E., got R.E. away from the situation, but mother refused to
give R.P. to PGM. PGM recalled mother looked anxious and
slapped R.P. for no reason.
PGM believed the children were in danger in mother’s care.
PGM noted that R.P. was not in school, had been diagnosed with
autism, and was not receiving any services. PGM believed R.P.
needed immediate services to address his speech delay and
autism, and mother needed substance abuse and domestic
violence services.
On October 10, 2024, the social worker learned that
Dontae H. was incarcerated.
The social worker spoke with Johnnie’s upstairs neighbor,
Jessica, who recalled seeing mother walking out of the apartment
complex with two children, apparently under the influence of
alcohol. Jessica was concerned because mother had placed the
children on top of one another in a stroller. When Jessica spoke
to mother, mother denied she had been drinking even though she
smelled strongly of alcohol. Mother then went to a nearby liquor
13
store with the children. Jessica also observed mother smoking
marijuana with other tenants in the lobby of the apartment
complex.
R.P. was examined on October 8, 2024. Mother refused to
have the child’s hearing, vision, and mental health screened. She
also refused to fill out the developmental milestone
questionnaire. It was noted R.P. had marks on his face and
arms.
S.H. was examined the same day. Mother declined
vaccinations and refused to have him screened or fill out the
developmental milestone questionnaire. S.H. had no vaccination
records. He was diagnosed with pink eye, but medication could
not be prescribed because mother refused to provide her address.
Removal and section 300 petition
On October 16, 2024, the juvenile court granted a removal
warrant. DCFS took S.H. and R.P. into protective custody. R.E.
remained released to Johnnie. R.P. was detained with PGM, and
S.H. was detained with a foster parent. Mother agreed to drug
test and was scheduled to test on October 18, 2024.
Regarding reasonable efforts to prevent removal, DCFS
reported the social worker had instituted a safety plan, but
mother broke the terms of the safety plan within three days. To
prevent further detention, DCFS recommended mother
participate in a substance abuse program with weekly testing,
parenting education, and individual counseling, and for the
children to participate in services and be referred to the Regional
Center.
On October 21, 2024, DCFS filed a section 300 petition on
behalf of R.P., R.E., and S.H. alleging mother had failed to make
an appropriate plan for R.P.’s care and supervision, had an
14
unresolved history of substance abuse, Robin P. was a current
user of methamphetamine, and Dontae H. had a history of violent
behavior.
Detention hearing
At the October 22, 2024 detention hearing, the children’s
counsel joined with DCFS in asking that the children be detained
from mother.
Mother’s counsel requested the court release the children to
mother with a safety plan that mother reside with MGGM and
drug test.
The juvenile court ordered S.H. and R.P. detained from
parental custody and ordered R.E. detained from mother and
released to Johnnie. The juvenile court ordered monitored visits
for mother three times a week for three hours each. Johnnie E.
was not to monitor mother’s visits with R.E. DCFS was ordered
to provide a clothing allowance for the children, a Regional
Center and speech therapy referral for R.P., and to make best
efforts to provide mother help with her phone bill, referrals for
drug testing, housing, transportation, and a written visitation
schedule.
On October 30, 2024, the juvenile court designated PGM co-
educational rights holder for R.P.
Further investigation
On September 11, 2024, mother requested a domestic
violence restraining order against her partner, Christine P.,
protecting her and S.H. Mother alleged Christine P. punched
mother in the head multiple times, pushed her down the stairs,
and destroyed her property. Mother attached photographs of the
injuries Christine P. caused. On October 4, 2024, the family law
15
court dismissed the restraining order request because no parties
appeared and mother failed to serve Christine P.
Mother informed the dependency investigator that
Johnnie E. was a criminal, made up allegations against her, and
wrongfully left R.P. at the police station because they had not
discussed what time she would pick him up. Mother admitted
she sometimes left R.P. with Johnnie E. for up to 36 hours.
Mother denied receiving phone calls from Johnnie E. the day of
the referral, saying she was the one who messaged Johnnie E. to
see how R.P. was doing. Mother stated she planned on pressing
charges against Johnnie E. for leaving R.P. at the police station.
Mother denied that she had an unresolved substance abuse
problem. She completed an inpatient substance abuse program
in 2019, and she had not tested positive for drugs.
Regarding her arrest, mother denied the drugs belonged to
her and said she was with a gang member.
Mother denied domestic violence with Robin P. or
Dontae H. She admitted she and Johnnie E. engaged in domestic
violence but refused to provide details. Mother planned to obtain
a restraining order against Johnnie E.
Mother explained Christine P. was her ex-girlfriend.
Mother acknowledged her attempt to obtain a restraining order
against Christine P., but she was unable to serve her. She said
she and Christine P. “got into it.”
Mother was enrolled in random drug testing and would
begin weekly testing on November 12, 2024. Mother tested
negative for drugs on October 30, 2024. However, she failed to
test on November 1, 2024. Mother said she missed the test
because she was confused whether she was enrolled in weekly or
random drug testing. Mother said she was enrolled in parenting,
16
substance use, anger management, and a life skills program at
Shields for Families. Mother was residing at Connections for
Women in Homeless Outreach Program Integrated Care System.
Mother was allowed to stay for up to 90 days and could have
extensions for 90 days thereafter if needed.
Robin P. was released from jail on October 30, 2024, and
his whereabouts were unknown.
Johnnie E. said mother had used methamphetamine in the
past for approximately five years, but he did not know how often.
He believed mother stopped using methamphetamine about four
months earlier, because he tested her once five months prior and
she tested clean.
Johnnie E. stated Dontae H. was a gang member who once
came to his home to get S.H. and retrieve his belongings.
Johnnie E. denied Dontae H. was violent or brought a gun.
Mother had told Johnnie E. Dontae H. was hostile, robbed, stole,
and killed. Johnnie E. had no information about domestic
violence between mother and Dontae H.
Dontae H. informed the dependency investigator he did not
know about mother’s substance abuse.
On November 2, 2024, mother arrived with R.E. at S.H.’s
doctor appointment in violation of the monitored visitation order.
On November 12, 2024, Johnnie E. reported he monitored a two-
hour visit for mother, stating he did not receive the court minute
order and did not know he was not supposed to monitor mother’s
visits. Mother denied she visited R.E.
Mother tested negative for drugs on November 27, 2024,
December 4, 2024, December 19, 2024, December 26, 2024,
January 3, 2025, and January 14, 2025. Mother failed to drug
test on November 18, 2024, December 12, 2024, and January 8,
17
2025. Mother failed to drug test for her on-demand tests on
November 22, 2024, and January 6, 2025. Mother claimed she
missed the drug tests because she worked double shifts and was
unable to test when called. The dependency investigator
explained a missed test is considered a positive test result.
Mother requested DCFS reform drug testing because she had
bills to pay and had to support herself so she could not take time
off to drug test.
Mother said she had been attending parenting education,
domestic violence, and substance abuse programs since
November 2024. Mother provided an enrollment letter from
Shields for Families, reporting she had been enrolled since
October 29, 2024, and listing her programs.
On January 21, 2025, mother’s case manager,
Mr. Williams, said he could not provide any information as there
was no release of information signed by mother. When the
dependency investigator asked mother to complete a release of
information, mother said, “[I]f I’m not getting my kids back
January 28th then we can postpone me signing that. But I will
email u [sic] my progress report.”
DCFS monitored mother’s visits with R.P. and S.H. S.H.’s
caregiver, Andrea,3 reported concerns that mother had R.E. in
her custody at a doctor appointment and at Halloween. During
virtual visits with S.H., mother made inappropriate comments,
discussed inappropriate topics with S.H., and dressed
inappropriately. Mother had also been drunk on virtual calls.
On New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day, mother informed S.H.
that she was drunk and still drunk from the night before.
3 Andrea was S.H.’s paternal great-aunt.
18
On November 22, 2024, a relative showed Andrea a video of
mother being pulled over by the police. Andrea had reason to
believe mother had been drinking. Earlier that morning, Andrea
received a call from mother’s ex-girlfriend, Christine P., stating
mother “got into it with her and was breaking down
[Christine P.’s] door.”
Andrea also shared text messages mother had sent her.
Mother had called Andrea’s work supervisor and DCFS making
allegations against Andrea. For example, mother sent the
following text: “Fuck you Andrea now I’m back acting like this
because the shit u keep doing ima report u till my son gets the
proper care he deserves and your supervisor say they can’t do
nothing but ima keep reporting you till they do.” Andrea was
unable to monitor mother’s visits or continue to care for S.H. due
to mother’s behavior.
On January 4, 2025, Andrea submitted a 14-day notice for
removal of S.H., though she was open to caring for him until a
new placement was secured.
On December 30, 2024, DCFS received a referral for R.E.
Although mother was permitted only monitored visits with R.E.,
mother had taken the child, who had been in her care since
December 27, 2024. Mother had gone unannounced to
Johnnie E.’s house with her friend, Destiny, to drop off a present
for R.E. Johnnie E. informed mother that R.E. was at daycare.
Mother pushed Johnnie E., ran inside, and mother attempted to
fight with a visiting female friend of Johnnie E.’s. The female
ran to the bathroom. Mother went through Johnnie E.’s and the
female friend’s belongings, banged on the bathroom door, saying,
“come out bitch.” While Johnnie E. held mother’s arms, the
female called law enforcement. Mother then opened R.E.’s gift of
19
silly string and sprayed Johnnie E. and his home, leaving
thereafter. When Johnnie E. went to collect R.E. from daycare,
he was informed mother had already picked him up. Johnnie E.
called mother to bring back R.E. She agreed but did not return
the child. There had been other occasions when mother took R.E.
from Johnnie E.’s custody. Mother agreed to return the child to
the DCFS office.
In a February 19, 2025 last minute information for the
court, the children’s social worker reported mother did not
consistently visit the children. Mother had not visited R.P. since
December 2024. The social worker had obtained a monitor for
mother’s visits on a weekly basis, but mother declined. Mother
also declined visits with S.H. because her car broke down and she
was under stress.
Mother moved in to a new apartment on February 5, 2025.
Mother failed to drug test on February 10, 2025, because she was
“tired, sleepy and had to move.”
Mother was not enrolled in any programs at that time,
though she had been provided with referrals. Mother stated they
were too far away. Mother continued to harass and threaten
S.H.’s caregiver, Andrea. Despite the social worker discussing
the matter with mother several times, her behavior continued to
escalate. Her texts were laden with obscenity and threats.
Andrea notified law enforcement and was in the process of
obtaining a restraining order. Mother was also harassing S.H.’s
PGM and sending her threatening text messages. Mother
informed the social worker she possessed a gun, and S.H.’s
relative confirmed mother had a gun.
20
On February 19, 2025, the court ordered mother to have
peaceful contact with all of her children’s caregivers and their
families.
On March 12, 2025, DCFS informed the court mother had
reported Dontae H. abused substances and had mental health
problems. Mother disclosed Dontae H. regularly hit her,
resulting in bruising. Mother called the police on Dontae H.
multiple times. In September 2024, Dontae H. hopped on
mother’s car windshield while holding S.H., causing the
windshield to break. The dependency investigator noted mother
previously denied Dontae H. abused substances or that they
engaged in domestic violence.
Mother’s aunt was present during the windshield incident
and witnessed Dontae H. slap and bang mother’s head.
Dontae H. grabbed S.H. and jumped on mother’s windshield
twice, causing it to break. The aunt grabbed S.H. from Dontae H.
and called police.
Mother failed to drug test on February 21 and 27, 2025.
DCFS received call logs from the police for the address of
mother and Dontae H. On August 29, 2024, mother was under
the influence of methamphetamine, assaulted Dontae H., and
threatened to shoot him. An anonymous person also reported
mother and Dontae H. engaged in ongoing domestic violence
throughout their relationship.
Regarding her missed visits, mother said her car was not
working so she could not visit R.P. A visit between mother and
S.H. was canceled February 17, 2025, because Andrea and S.H.
were sick. Mother had canceled previously scheduled visits with
R.P. and S.H. because mother was in Las Vegas.
21
Jurisdiction and disposition hearing
The jurisdiction and disposition hearing was held on
April 2, 2025. Mother filed exhibits for the hearing, including a
March 31, 2025 letter from Epiphany Counseling, stating mother
completed her first appointment with a therapist on March 27,
2025, and was scheduled for biweekly sessions; documentation
showing mother was scheduled for an intake appointment on
April 8, 2025, at an alcoholism center for women; and an April 1,
2025 letter of enrollment at Breakthrough Parenting at Claris
Health. The juvenile court admitted mother’s exhibits and
DCFS’s reports into evidence.
Mother’s counsel argued the counts against mother should
be dismissed. Children’s counsel asked the juvenile court to
sustain the petition as pled, arguing mother was not credible and
the evidence showed she had ongoing substance abuse issues.
Children’s counsel further noted it was not reasonable for mother
to drop off her children with someone who said he had to work
the next day and then not respond to the point where the child
was taken to the police station. Counsel for DCFS joined the
children’s arguments and added mother’s counsel minimized
mother’s lack of accountability in assuming responsibility for her
children and her overall behavior.
Following the arguments, the juvenile court addressed
mother: “[R]egarding the reasons the children or that [R.P.] was
with his uncle, I agree with you. It looks like it was a dirty trick
on [Johnnie’s] part to get DCFS attention, but I can’t negate that
it did happen. If it was a one time incident, then I can say yeah I
don’t think it’s jurisdictional; [¶] [h]owever, [counsel] pointed
out . . . it happened more than once—in fact, he said at least ten
times—that once you dropped off [R.P.], you were not reachable.
22
As a parent, that cannot happen.” The court further noted there
was ample evidence of mother’s being under the influence of
substances from neutral witnesses, pointing to mother having an
unresolved history of substance abuse. The court then struck the
language regarding mother’s use of methamphetamine and
marijuana, and added alcohol, because “it appears [mother] has
an alcohol problem which seems to be the catalyst every time law
enforcement was called.”
The juvenile court sustained the allegations against mother
indicating she failed to make an appropriate plan for R.P.’s care
and supervision; has an unresolved history of substance abuse,
including alcohol abuse, and is a current user of alcohol; and that
mother and Dontae H. had a history of engaging in violent
altercations, including an incident in which Dontae H. jumped on
mother’s windshield while carrying S.H.
The matter proceeded to disposition. Mother asked for a
home-of-parent order, or if the court was not willing to grant a
home-of-parent order, that the court consider a family member,
Verna H., for placement. Mother objected to being required to
complete a full drug and alcohol program as she did not believe
sufficient evidence was presented to require these programs.
Mother also objected to both a parenting and a domestic violence
class, as they were unnecessary and overly burdensome.
The children’s counsel and Johnnie E.’s counsel agreed that
R.E.’s case could be closed with a home-of-parent father order.
Mother objected, asking that R.E.’s case remain open so mother
could have an opportunity to reunify with R.E.
The court found the children to be dependents under
section 300. As to R.P. and S.H., the court found a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, and well-being of the
23
children if returned to the care of their parents, and there were
no reasonable means to protect them without removing them
from the physical custody of their parents. R.E. was released to
Johnnie E.’s custody. The court granted mother’s request to keep
R.E.’s case open for three months, and granted mother’s request
to have DCFS assess Verna H. for placement of S.H.
In addressing the reasons for its orders, the court informed
mother: “The goal of this court is to reunify you with your
children. I don’t want to take your children away from you, but I
need you to show insight into the issues that cause you to misuse
alcohol, to get into relationships with violent men.”
DISCUSSION
I. Applicable law and standard of review
After declaring a child a dependent of the juvenile court,
the court must determine whether the child may remain with or
be removed from the custodial parent. (§ 361, subd. (c).) “A
dependent child shall not be taken from the physical custody of
their parents . . . with whom the child resides at the time the
petition was initiated, unless the juvenile court finds clear and
convincing evidence . . . [¶] [t]here is or would be a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned
home, and there are no reasonable means by which the minor’s
physical health can be protected without removing the minor
from the minor’s parent’s . . . physical custody.” (§ 361, subd.
(c)(1).) The court must first “make a determination as to whether
reasonable efforts were made to prevent or to eliminate the need
for removal of the minor from their home . . . .” (§ 361, subd. (e).)
24
Clear and convincing evidence requires a high probability,
leaving no substantial doubt. (In re C.M. (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th
1394, 1401.) Requiring proof by clear and convincing evidence is
an essential aspect of parents’ presumptive rights to care for
their children. (In re Kieshia E. (1993) 6 Cal.4th 68, 76.) “Still,
the appellant bears the burden of showing ‘“there is no evidence
of a sufficiently substantial nature”’ to support the dispositional
removal order.” (In re L.O. (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 227, 245.)
“[W]hen presented with a challenge to the sufficiency of the
evidence associated with a finding requiring clear and convincing
evidence, the court must determine whether the record, viewed as
a whole, contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable
trier of fact could have made the finding of high probability
demanded by this standard of proof.” (Conservatorship of O.B.
(2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1005.)
II. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
determinations of a substantial risk of harm to the
minors if returned to mother and no reasonable
means to protect the minors without removal
Section 361, subdivision (c)(1) contains two elements that
must be satisfied before a dependent child may be removed from
the physical custody of his or her parent. First, the juvenile court
must find clear and convincing evidence there is or would be a
substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or
physical or emotional well-being of the child if the child were
returned home. Second, the juvenile court must find by clear and
convincing evidence there are no reasonable means by which the
minor’s health, safety, or well-being can be protected without
removing the minor from the physical custody of the parent.
25
(§ 361, subd. (c)(1).) Mother argues the juvenile court erred in
finding these elements were met in this case.
A. Substantial danger
The record supports the juvenile court’s decision that clear
and convincing evidence existed of a substantial danger to the
children’s physical health, safety, and physical and emotional
well-being if the children remained in mother’s custody. Mother
had a long history of substance abuse. In 2019, mother admitted
she had been using methamphetamine since she was 12 years
old. R.P. had previously been a dependent of the juvenile court
due to mother’s substance abuse and domestic violence with
Robin P.
In July 2024, mother was in possession of a bag of
marijuana and a methamphetamine pipe. Mother admitted the
pipe was hers. On August 29, 2024, mother was under the
influence of methamphetamine when she was involved in an
altercation with Dontae H. Johnnie E. informed DCFS of
mother’s long history of methamphetamine use and his belief she
had relapsed because she looked thinner than usual. Johnnie E.
also said mother would smoke marijuana in the bathroom in the
presence of the children. Although mother had previously
participated in a drug rehabilitation program, she continued to
use methamphetamine. Robin P. also disclosed mother had a
history of crystal methamphetamine use and had been struggling
with substance abuse for over five years. PGM reported mother
had a substance abuse problem and had been using drugs since
she was 16 years old.
Johnnie E.’s neighbor, Jessica, witnessed mother under the
influence of alcohol, placing two of her children on top of the
other in a stroller, and taking them to the liquor store. Jessica
26
also observed mother smoking marijuana. Mother had left R.P.
in Johnnie E.’s care at least 10 times in the preceding six months,
sometimes leaving him for days while out of contact.
S.H.’s caregiver reported mother visited the children while
under the influence, appearing drunk on virtual calls and by
informing S.H. she was drunk.
Despite this evidence mother denied substance use. She
claimed she last used “hard drugs” when she was 15 or 16 years
old. Although mother admitted participation in a drug
rehabilitation program in 2019 due to her dependency case with
R.P. at the time, mother said it was “a complete waste of time”
because she denied use of drugs. Mother claimed to have
completed the course just to get R.P. back. In spite of her denial
of drug use, mother missed many drug tests, which counted as
positive tests. (L.C. v. Superior Court (2024) 98 Cal.App.5th
1021, 1036 [court properly treats missed tests as positive tests].)
In addition to the evidence mother was using drugs, mother
neglected the children’s medical and educational needs. Mother
refused services for R.P.’s autism and had not enrolled him in
school. Mother had not provided S.H. any medical care since his
birth, and R.E. had received no medical care for two years. Such
neglectful conduct was a substantial danger to the children’s
health and well-being.
There was also evidence mother engaged in domestic
violence with her romantic partners, including Johnnie E.,
Robin P., Dontae H., and Christine P. Although mother initially
denied engaging in domestic violence with Robin P. and
Dontae H., she later admitted to violence with Dontae H.,
admitting Dontae H. regularly hit her, resulting in bruising.
Mother reported Dontae H. to law enforcement multiple times.
27
In September 2024, Dontae H. jumped on mother’s car
windshield while holding S.H., causing the windshield to break.
Evidence was presented that in August 2024, when mother was
under the influence of methamphetamine, she assaulted and
threatened Dontae H. Mother’s engagement in violence with her
partners was a substantial danger to the children’s health and
well-being. (In re I.R. (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 510, 521 [domestic
violence is a serious threat to a child’s physical and emotional
well-being].) Mother’s initial denial of domestic violence and
failure to recognize the risks to which she was exposing her
children, suggest such behavior will continue. (In re V.L. (2020)
54 Cal.App.5th 147, 156; In re A.F. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 283,
293.)
Given the evidence of mother’s unresolved substance abuse
issues, her neglect of her children’s medical and educational
needs, and the evidence she engaged in domestic violence with
her romantic partners, the juvenile court did not err in
determining there was a substantial risk to the physical health,
safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the
children unless removed from mother’s custody.
B. No reasonable means to protect the minors
without removal
Mother claims the social study failed to discuss any efforts
to prevent removal, and substantial evidence did not support the
juvenile court’s determination that there existed no reasonable
alternatives to removal. As set forth below, we disagree.
In the detention report, DCFS reported the social worker
instituted a safety plan with mother for the benefit of the
children. Mother and MGGM agreed to the safety plan where
mother would stay with R.P. and S.H. at MGGM’s home for seven
28
days. Mother would submit to drug testing, and MGGM would
primarily care for the children and monitor mother’s contact with
the children. Mother broke the terms of the safety plan within
three days by leaving MGGM’s home with the children without
informing MGGM where she had gone.
In addition, mother was uncooperative with DCFS.
Initially she refused to provide the social worker with
information about S.H.’s whereabouts, then lied, telling her S.H.
was with his paternal grandmother, Judy M. When the social
worker went to Judy M.’s home, Judy M. denied S.H. was there
and denied taking care of S.H. that day. Mother failed to drug
test and violated the court’s orders. Mother took R.E. from
Johnnie E.’s custody in violation of the juvenile court’s orders and
failed to return the child to Johnnie E. until DCFS became
involved. Mother threatened S.H.’s caregiver and continued to do
so even after the juvenile court ordered her to have peaceful
conduct with the children’s caregivers. This uncooperative,
defiant behavior and failure to engage in services supports
removal from parental custody at disposition. (In re E.E. (2020)
49 Cal.App.5th 195, 212.)
In re Ashly F. (2014) 225 Cal.App.4th 803, cited by mother,
is distinguishable. In Ashly F., the court noted the detention
report “did not mention any reasonable alternatives to removal
from the home that had been tried and failed or that had been
considered and rejected.” (Id. at p. 807.) Here, in contrast, DCFS
attempted to institute a safety plan to avoid detention of the
children. However, mother broke the terms of the safety plan
within days, without letting either MGGM or the social worker
know her or the children’s whereabouts. Given mother’s failure
to adhere to the terms of the safety plan, and her failure to
29
cooperate with DCFS in general, the juvenile court did not err in
determining there were no reasonable means to prevent removal
of the children from mother’s custody.
III. The court sufficiently stated facts supporting its
decision
Section 361, subdivision (e) provides, “The court shall state
the facts on which the decision to remove the minor is based.”
Mother argues the juvenile court failed to make these findings
here. However, the record reveals the court made sufficiently
detailed findings regarding the facts of the case.
The juvenile court made its findings as to the allegations
involving mother during the jurisdictional portion of the hearing.
The court addressed mother directly, stating there was evidence
she left R.P. at the home of Johnnie E. at least 10 times and
Johnnie E. was unable to reach her. The court also noted
strangers had reported mother being under the influence with
the children, and there was evidence she had a
methamphetamine pipe when she was arrested in July 2024.
The court noted all this evidence “point[s] to [mother] having an
unresolved history of substance abuse.” The court stated, “This is
a pattern of behavior that exposes these children to so much
chaos and detriment: screaming, hitting, [mother] being the
victim of several violent assaults by [Dontae H.].”
At the dispositional hearing, the juvenile court was direct
with mother, informing her she needed to “show insight into the
issues that cause [her] to misuse alcohol, to get into relationships
with violent men.” The court sufficiently stated the facts on
which its decision to remove the minors from mother’s custody
was based.
30
In re D.P. (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 1058, cited by mother, is
distinguishable. In D.P., the juvenile court removed one of two
children “‘pursuant to Dependency Court Order 415, [upon] the
terms of which are contained in the minute order.’” (Id. at
p. 1065.) Under those circumstances, the D.P. court agreed with
the mother’s argument that the juvenile court had violated the
mandate of section 361, subdivision (e), that the juvenile court
must state the facts on which the decision to remove the minor is
based. (D.P., at p. 1066.) The referenced dependency order
merely recited the findings the juvenile court must draw from the
supporting facts to order removal under section 361. By failing to
state such facts, the juvenile court erred. (D.P., at p. 1067.)
Here, in contrast, the juvenile court met its obligation to state the
facts supporting removal.
DISPOSITION
The removal order is affirmed.
CHAVEZ, J.
We concur:
LUI, P. J. GILBERT, J.*
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, Second
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
31
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.