In re R.B. CA2/5

CourtListener 10812464Calctapp20 de mar. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/20/26 In re R.B. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re R.B., a Person Coming Under B347734
the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN 18CCJP01602E)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

R.B. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Sally Espinoza, Judge. Affirmed.
Anne E. Fragasso, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant R.B.
John L. Dodd, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant L.C.
Office of the County Counsel, Dawyn R. Harrison, County
Counsel, Kim Nemoy, Assistant County Counsel, and Navid
Nakhjavani, Principal Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.

2
The juvenile court took jurisdiction over then four-month-
old R.B. (Minor) after sustaining allegations that Ro.B. (Father)
perpetrated domestic violence against L.C. (Mother) and Mother
was abusing alcohol. The court later terminated reunification
services and, ultimately, parental rights. Father, joined by
Mother, asks us to decide whether the juvenile court erred in
finding he did not establish any of the elements of the parental
benefit exception: regular visitation, a substantial positive
attachment to Minor, and detriment from terminating parental
rights even when balanced against the countervailing benefit of
adoption.

I. BACKGROUND
A. Dependency Jurisdiction
In December 2022, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (the Department) received a
referral alleging Father engaged in a violent altercation with
Mother while she was holding the child. Father and Mother were
not residing together at the time. The Department began
investigating and removed Minor from parental custody
(pursuant to a court order) in January 2023, when Minor was
four months old.
That same month, the Department filed a four-count
dependency petition alleging Minor was at risk of harm from his
parents’ domestic violence, from Mother’s history of substance
abuse including methamphetamine and alcohol (and Father’s
failure to protect Minor from the same), and because Minor’s
siblings had previously been declared dependents of the juvenile
court due to Mother’s substance abuse.

3
The juvenile court later sustained the petition in its
entirety at a jurisdiction hearing. The court’s disposition order
required Father to participate in a full drug and alcohol program;
to submit to random and on demand drug and alcohol testing
weekly; and to participate in a 52-week domestic violence
program, a parenting course, and individual counseling. Father
was also granted three, two-hour monitored visits with Minor per
week.

B. The Ensuing Dependency Proceedings Prior to
Termination of Parental Rights
In late May 2023, when Minor was approximately 8 months
old, he was placed with different foster parents and Father’s
visitation schedule was revised. From June 2023 to February
2024, Father attended roughly half the number of possible visits
(not including visits that were canceled or not scheduled due to
illness, Father’s incarceration, or other extenuating
circumstances).
Father was generally attentive to Minor during these
visits—playing with him, feeding him, and changing his diaper.
There were, however, some instances of inappropriate behavior.
For example, during one visit monitored by Minor’s foster
mother, Father appeared upset every time Minor looked for her.
During another visit, Father covered Minor’s head and part of his
face to prevent Minor from looking at anyone else. Father told
Minor that once he came back home, they would move back in
with Mother. At one point, Father’s tone of voice turned
aggressive and his hands were shaking.
In February 2024, the court found there was no substantial
probability of Minor reunifying with Mother because she had not

4
consistently contacted or visited Minor, had not made significant
progress in resolving problems that led to the proceedings, and
had not demonstrated the capacity or ability to complete the
objectives of the treatment plan. The court informed Father his
services would be extended until late July of the same year, and
that if Father wanted to reunify with Minor, he needed to attend
his visits and continue to participate in services.
From February to April 2024, Father visited with Minor as
allowed by the inpatient drug-treatment program in which he
was enrolled. The visits generally went well, but there were
some exceptions (similar to the instances of inappropriate
behavior that occurred previously). Father was dropped from the
inpatient drug program after he tested positive for alcohol in late
April.
Father remained fairly consistent with his visits over the
following two months, but his visitation dropped off in July and
August 2024. During the visits that did occur in this timeframe,
Minor was usually happy to see Father when he arrived. Father
was attentive to Minor during visits, played with him, and fed
him. Minor did not exhibit distress at the end of visits.
Father participated in some of his court-ordered programs.
As of July 2024, he completed 24 of 52 domestic violence
counseling sessions and completed a 12-week parenting class. He
was not participating in individual counseling.
At a review hearing in August 2024, the juvenile court
observed that Father had failed out of three outpatient and one
inpatient programs and had recently entered a new outpatient
program. Though the court recognized Father asserted he was
testing negative, he had also missed several tests. The court
concluded Father was not establishing a positive bond with

5
Minor and was not acknowledging or taking care of Minor’s
special needs. The court stated they were past the 18-month date
and there were no grounds to justify extending services. The
court accordingly terminated reunification services.
Father’s visits became more sporadic thereafter. During
the period from September through mid-November, Father had
approximately five visits with Minor and missed at least twice
that number either because he did not confirm a visit in time or
because he canceled a visit. While Father was generally still
attentive to Minor during the visits that did occur, he
occasionally fell asleep and became unfocused for short periods
during visits. Father also had difficulty redirecting Minor’s
behaviors. During one visit in late October, Minor did not listen
to Father and at one point told Father he hated him.
Additionally, Father was not attentive to Minor’s medical needs.
During the proceedings it became clear Minor suffers from
epileptic seizures, and Father received guidance on how to react
when Minor has a seizure. However, a visit monitor reported
that Father did not appear to be aware when Minor was having a
seizure.
In November 2024, foster mother told the Department that
Minor regresses because of the visits with Father. After visits,
Minor usually wanted to be fed even though he was eating more
independently, he appeared more needy, and he had a difficult
time sleeping at night. It usually took Minor a day to return to
his regular self after a visit.

6
From January through March 2025, Father completed 15
visits and missed around half that number.1 Minor was
aggressive with Father during the visits they had and would hit
Father if he was told “no.” Minor was happy to see Father when
visits began, but, with one exception,2 he had no problem leaving
the visits when they finished.
During the dependency proceedings, Minor was evaluated
for muscle tightness, fetal alcohol syndrome, and plagiocephaly.
Minor was determined to be developmentally delayed and
received feeding therapy, speech therapy, occupational therapy,
physical therapy, and early intervention. He showed significant
progress in services.
Minor’s foster parents were consistent in bringing him to
his therapy sessions. He was placed with the foster parents
in May 2023, and by September 2023, foster mother said Minor
was thriving in the home and she expressed interest in adopting
Minor. By early 2025, Minor’s foster parents reported they had a
great bond and love for Minor and reaffirmed they wanted to
provide a permanent home via adoption. They stated that since
his placement in their home, they considered him a part of the

1
A Department last minute information report included a
statement from the visitation monitor that Father’s “‘visitation
since January of 2025 has been inconsistent, infrequent. He
would cancel or not show up. On March 27th, he was scheduled
for a visit but he was arrested a few hours later. There was no
visitation in April because of that.’”
2
Minor did become very upset one day when he arrived at
the location for the planned visit (the record does not specify
where) and Father did not show up.

7
family. A Department social worker reported Minor looks to
foster parents for comfort and to have his needs met, and Minor
appears to be happy, active, and healthy in their care.

C. Father’s Request to Change Court Orders
In March 2025, Father filed a Welfare and Institutions
Code section 388 petition asking the court to return Minor to his
care or change its order terminating his reunification services.3
The Department opposed the petition and argued Father was not
ready to care for Minor and had difficulty bonding with Minor.
Elaborating, the Department explained Minor had medical and
physical challenges that Father did not appear to understand,
Father made an effort during visits with Minor but did not know
what to do with him, and Minor did not appear to respond well
and listen to Father.
The court held a hearing on Father’s section 388 petition in
April 2025 and Father testified. He described his visits with
Minor in positive terms and asserted he has a strong bond with
Minor. Father testified he is the only one there for Minor, Minor
always runs to him at the beginning of visits, and Minor waits
until Father is packed up and ready to leave at the end of visits
so they can leave together.
The court denied Father’s section 388 petition, finding both
that Father’s circumstances were changing but not yet changed
and that granting the petition would not be in Minor’s best
interests.

3
Undesignated statutory references that follow are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.

8
D. Termination of Parental Rights
At the ensuing June 2025 permanency planning hearing,
the court admitted a letter from Father into evidence and took
judicial notice of Father’s testimony from the section 388 petition
hearing, including his testimony concerning his bond with Minor.
The Department asked the court to terminate parental
rights, maintaining there was no evidence Minor would suffer
any harm from ordering termination. An attorney for Minor
agreed with the Department because Mother had been totally
absent and Father’s visits were inconsistent, because Father
lacked protective capacity, and because Father was not familiar
with Minor’s multiple medical diagnoses. Father argued he had a
bond with Minor and asked the court to forgo terminating
parental rights because the parental benefit exception applied.
After reviewing the three elements a parent must establish
to successfully invoke the parental benefit exception (consistent
visitation, a positive attachment, and detriment from termination
(see generally In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614)), the juvenile
court found Father had not established any. The court found
Father’s visits had been “inconsistent,” pointing to Father’s
attendance at only 7 out of 25 possible visits from August 2024 to
the end of the year and several cancelled or unconfirmed visits in
2025. The court further found that even if Father could establish
consistent visitation, the other two elements of the parental
benefit exception had not been proven. The court acknowledged
Father loves Minor and there was “a bond to some degree”
between the two, but the court found there was no substantial,
positive emotional attachment because Father’s inconsistency in
visiting created an unpredictable environment for Minor and

9
disrupted his sense of stability and emotional security. The court
also reasoned terminating the parent-child relationship would
not be detrimental to Minor when balanced against the benefits
of a new adoptive home in light of Father’s occasionally
inappropriate behavior during visitation, the observed ill-effects
of visits on Minor after visits, and the “great bond” Minor had
with foster parents—who had provided a home where he was
happy, active, and healthy. The court accordingly ordered
parental rights terminated.

II. DISCUSSION
The juvenile court did not err in deciding the parental
benefit exception does not apply. Substantial evidence supports
the juvenile court’s findings that consistent visitation was lacking
and that Minor did not have a substantial positive emotional
attachment to Father. There was also no abuse of discretion in
the court’s determination that severing Father’s relationship
with Minor, which was premised primarily on sporadic (albeit
numerous) visits over a span of over two years, would not be
detrimental when considering the many benefits of adoption.

A. Legal Framework
If a juvenile court finds by clear and convincing evidence at
the section 366.26 hearing that a child is likely to be adopted,
“the court shall terminate parental rights and order the child
placed for adoption” unless, as relevant here, it “finds a
compelling reason for determining that termination would be
detrimental to the child due to one or more” enumerated
exceptions. (§ 366.26, subds. (c)(1) & (c)(1)(B); see also Caden C.,
supra, 11 Cal.5th at 630-631.) “The statutory exceptions merely

10
permit the court, in exceptional circumstances [citation], to choose
an option other than the norm, which remains adoption.” (In re
Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53.)
The exception at issue here, the parental benefit exception,
applies if “termination would be detrimental to the child” because
the parent has “maintained regular visitation and contact with
the child and the child would benefit from continuing the
relationship.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i).) A parent invoking the
exception in an effort to forestall termination of parental rights
bears the burden to demonstrate three things by a preponderance
of the evidence. First, the parent must show he or she had
“regular visitation and contact with the child, taking into account
the extent of visitation permitted.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th
at 636.) Second, the parent must show “the child has a
substantial, positive, emotional attachment to the parent—the
kind of attachment implying that the child would benefit from
continuing the relationship.” (Ibid.) This element is affected by
“‘[t]he age of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the
parent’s custody, the “positive” or “negative” effect of interaction
between parent and child, and the child’s particular needs.’” (Id.
at 632 [in conducting this assessment, “courts often consider how
children feel about, interact with, look to, or talk about their
parents”].) Third, the parent must show that “terminating that
[parental] attachment would be detrimental to the child even
when balanced against the countervailing benefit of a new,
adoptive home.” (Id. at 636.) Our review of the juvenile court's
ruling on the parental benefit exception is for substantial
evidence on the first two of these elements and for abuse of
discretion on the third. (Id. at 639-640.)

11
B. Analysis
Father disputes the juvenile court’s findings on all three
elements of the parental benefit exception. He maintains (1) his
visitation, while not perfect, was regular and beneficial; (2) his
bond with Minor, which the juvenile court concluded was not
substantial, was strong; and (3) termination of parental rights
would be detrimental to Minor because Minor should be provided
with as many caring adults supporting him as possible and
eliminating Father from that number would be harmful. His
arguments are all unpersuasive.
There is no dispute that Father visited with Minor many
times over the two-plus years that dependency proceedings were
ongoing. But the governing statute and controlling case law do
not require a certain number of visits, they require “regular” or
“consistent” visitation. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i) [exception
applies when a parent has, among other things, “maintained
regular visitation”]; Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at 632 [“The first
element—regular visitation and contact—is straightforward. The
question is just whether ‘parents visit consistently,’ taking into
account ‘the extent permitted by court orders’”].) Under the
deferential standard of review that applies, there is no basis to
disturb the juvenile court’s finding that Father’s visits were
neither regular nor consistent. The record shows there were
months when Father only had a handful of visits with Minor
though no extenuating circumstances prevented visitation.
Substantial evidence also supports the juvenile court’s
conclusion Father had not established “a substantial, positive,
emotional attachment to [Father]—the kind of attachment
implying that the child would benefit from continuing the
relationship.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at 636.) At the time

12
Minor was removed from Father’s custody, he was four months
old; by the time the court terminated Father’s parental rights,
Minor was almost three. Although there were periods when
Father visited Minor frequently, and Minor was generally happy
to see Father when visits commenced, Minor and Father’s
interactions demonstrated increasing levels of strife over the
course of the proceedings. Minor did not listen to Father when
Father told him to refrain from certain behaviors and would hit
Father to show his displeasure. Additionally, Minor had no
difficulty separating from Father at the end of visits, and there is
no indication Minor asked for Father when he was not present or
when he missed a visit—with the exception of the one time when
Minor was very upset because Father failed to appear for a visit.
All this supported the juvenile court’s conclusion that Father’s
bond was not substantial enough to satisfy this requirement.
Additionally, the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion
when it determined terminating the parental relationship would
not be detrimental when balanced against the benefit of a new
adoptive home. Minor had been in foster care since he was four
months old and had been with his current foster parents (the
prospective adoptive parents) since he was approximately eight
months old—meaning he had lived with them slightly more than
two years at the time of the permanency planning hearing.
Minor’s prospective adoptive parents treated him like a member
of their family and were attentive to his varied medical needs.
He was healthy and happy in their care. Additionally, though
there was evidence Minor was happy to see Father during visits,
there was also evidence he struggled with the more recent (and
more sporadic) visits—regressing in feeding patterns and having
trouble sleeping. With scant evidence that severing Minor’s bond

13
with Father would be detrimental, and strong evidence Minor’s
foster parents were providing him with safety and security, the
juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in deciding that
terminating Father’s parental rights would not be detrimental.

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

KIM (D.), J.

14

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.