Zeng v. Wang CA1/5

CourtListener 10806213Calctapp9 de mar. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/9/26 Zeng v. Wang CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

YING MAGGIE ZENG,
A171959
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.
(Sonoma County
ALBERT WANG, Super. Ct. No. SFL-089930)

Defendant and Appellant.

Defendant Albert Wang appeals from an order denying his motion for
sanctions under Code of Civil Procedure section 128.7.1 Wang sought
sanctions based on the allegation that counsel for plaintiff Ying Maggie Zeng,
respondent and real party in interest Johanna Beth Kleppe, forged a court
order. We conclude that Wang has not established an abuse of discretion and
affirm.
I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Earlier Proceedings2
Wang and Zeng’s marriage was dissolved in 2013 in Orange County
Superior Court. In 2021, Zeng sought a change of venue to Sonoma County,

1 All further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.
2 We summarize the prelude to this appeal based on our summary of

the facts in one of Wang’s earlier appeals. (Zeng v. Wang (Mar. 28, 2024
1
where she was living with the parties’ daughter. The Orange County
Superior Court transferred the case and ordered Kleppe to cause the
following documents to be sealed in the Sonoma County court: “ ‘State of
California Health and Welfare Agency Department of Social Services
Investigation Information, and accompanying documents attached as Exhibit
L to Petitioner's July 2, 2021 Request for Order . . . [and] . . . Kaiser
Permanente Medical Records attached as Exhibit B to Petitioner's July 2,
2021 Request for Order.’ ” The Orange County court directed Kleppe to
“ ‘take care of sealing the documents that were stated on the record as soon
as the case gets transferred to Sonoma County.’ ”
Pending completion of the transfer, Zeng filed another proceeding in
Sonoma County Superior Court to obtain a domestic violence restraining
order (DVRO) against Wang. (Fam. Code, § 6200 et seq.) In March 2022, the
trial court issued a two-year DVRO with custody and visitation orders.
On October 21, 2022, roughly 10 months after the transfer to Sonoma
County was complete, the Sonoma County trial court entered an order
sealing records identified in and pursuant to the Orange County order.
Ten days later, Wang sought monetary sanctions against Kleppe under
section 177.5, claiming that Kleppe had not made good faith efforts to comply
with the Orange County order. Among other things, he complained that
Kleppe sought the sealing order late, only asked the trial court to seal two
exhibits, and filed additional confidential records without sealing them.
Kleppe filed a responsive declaration on November 29, 2022, explaining
her delay in complying with the Orange County order. She further asserted

A168238) [nonpub. opn.].) Zeng moved for judicial notice of our opinion in
case No. A168238 and we deferred our ruling until our consideration of the
merits. We now grant the unopposed motion.
2
that on October 10, 2022, she sought and obtained the October 21, 2022
sealing order and tried to resolve Wang’s concerns.
After a hearing in December 2022, the trial court denied Wang’s
request for sanctions, noting that the “ ‘Court does not find Counsel Kleppe’s
behavior to be willful or malicious.’ ” Wang appealed.
We affirmed the order denying sanctions under section 177.5. We also
addressed Wang’s belated accusation that Kleppe forged the Sonoma County
trial court’s sealing order of October 21, 2022 and submitted that forged order
to the Orange County and Sonoma County courts in November 2022 to obtain
the sealing of more documents than the true October 21 order authorized.
Specifically, he contended that the real October 21 order, which both
identified the documents to be sealed and stated that the “ ‘records to be
sealed are attached as ATTACHMENT 1,’ ” lists only two exhibits to be
sealed. An allegedly “fake” order, accompanying Kleppe’s Declaration in
Support of Order to Seal Documents dated November 28, 2022 in the Orange
County Superior Court, lists three exhibits to be sealed in Attachment 1,
including an Exhibit Q (medical records). Another allegedly fake order,
which accompanied Kleppe’s Declaration in Support of Order to Seal
Documents dated November 28, 2022 in Sonoma County Superior Court, lists
10 exhibits in Attachment 1.
We concluded that Wang’s argument about Kleppe’s purported forgery
of a court order, which was not raised until his reply brief, did not compel
reversal of the order from which he appealed. We were nonetheless
concerned that each Kleppe declaration purporting to attach the same
October 21, 2022 order contained a different Attachment 1 to that order.
Kleppe provided no explanation for the discrepancy in her respondent’s brief.
We therefore stated: “Because of the potential seriousness of this matter,

3
because it arose after Father filed his October 31, 2022 Request for Order,
and because the trial court may not have had a meaningful opportunity to
examine it, our affirmance of the December 2022 order does not preclude the
court from considering, on its own motion after the remittitur (1) whether
Kleppe accurately represented the October 21, 2022 order in her declarations
and (2) whether all the documents that should be sealed in the trial court
have, in fact, been ordered sealed. And we strongly suggest that the court do
so.” In a footnote, we added: “In any event, our decision today does not
preclude [Wang] from raising these two issues with the trial court again.”
B. Proceedings After Remittitur
In April 2024, Wang requested an order sanctioning Kleppe under
section 128.7 and referring her to the California State Bar based on the
declarations she filed in late November 2022. Specifically, he asked the trial
court to (1) consider whether Kleppe accurately represented the October 21,
2022 order in her declarations, (2) determine whether all the documents that
should be sealed have actually been sealed, (3) impose monetary sanctions,
(4) order Kleppe to review court filings and file a motion to seal all of the
daughter’s confidential information, and (5) refer Kleppe to the State Bar for
misconduct.
Kleppe filed a responsive declaration on May 2, 2024. The declaration
does not appear in the clerk’s transcript in this appeal. Wang does not cite to
the declaration, and the page Zeng cites from the clerk’s transcript merely
notes the filing of the declaration as a line item in the trial court’s case
summary. There is also no active link to the declaration itself.
The trial court heard Wang’s request on May 15, 2024. No transcript of
the hearing appears in the appellate record. In its minute order dated May
17, 2024, the court stated that it did “not find any willful intention from

4
Counsel Kleppe regarding her filing of the documents placed under seal” and
denied Wang’s request for monetary sanctions and referral of Kleppe to the
State Bar. Kleppe was directed to prepare the formal order but no such order
appears in the record. Wang filed a timely appeal from the minute order.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Appealability
Zeng contends that Wang’s opening brief should be stricken because it
does not address the appealability of the May 17, 2024 minute order. (See
Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(2)(B) [requiring appealability statement in
opening brief].) We decline to strike Wang’s brief. (Id., rule 8.204(e)(2)(C).)
Zeng next contends that the minute order is not appealable. She points
out that, while section 904.1, subdivision (a)(11), allows an appeal from an
order imposing monetary sanctions over $5,000, it does not authorize an
appeal from an order denying a motion for monetary sanctions. Further,
Zeng argues that the order is not appealable as a postjudgment order
(§ 904.1, subds. (a)(2) & (b)) because it does not affect the judgment or relate
to the judgment’s enforcement. For this proposition, she relies on Lakin v.
Watkins Associated Industries (1993) 6 Cal.4th 644, 651 (Lakin).)
We are not persuaded. Wang appealed from a minute order,
apparently because Zeng failed to present a formal order as the trial court
had directed. The minute order constitutes a postjudgment order that
disposes finally of Wang’s motion and is therefore appealable. (In re
Marriage of Dupre (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1525 [minute order denying
sanctions is appealable under section 904.1, subdivision (a)(2)].) As Lakin
explains, the rule that a postjudgment order must affect the judgment or
relate to its enforcement is only intended to exclude review of orders that lack
finality because they are preliminary to a later judgment. (Lakin, supra, 6

5
Cal.4th at p. 653.) Zeng does not show how this rule applies here. Nor does
Zeng explain how Wang would obtain appellate review of the order if not by
this appeal. She also provides no authority holding that the postjudgment
denial of sanctions in an ongoing family law proceeding is not appealable.
We therefore turn to the merits.
B. Section 128.7
Section 128.7 provides that an attorney, by filing certain documents in
the trial court, represents that those documents are not presented primarily
for an improper purpose, that the claims therein are warranted by existing
law or nonfrivolous argument in support of a change in the law, that the
claims have evidentiary support, and that the factual contentions are
warranted from the evidence or reasonably based on a lack of information or
belief. (§ 128.7, subd. (b).) If the court determines otherwise, it may sanction
the attorney. (Id., subd. (c).)
We assume for purposes of argument that section 128.7 applies to a
declaration of the sort Kleppe filed on November 28, 2022. We thus review
the trial court’s denial of Wang’s motion for abuse of discretion. (Kojababian
v. Genuine Home Loans, Inc. (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 408, 420–421.) In so
doing, we presume that the order is correct and indulge all intendments and
presumptions to support it on matters as to which the record is silent. (Sayta
v. Chu (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 960, 963, fn. 3.) Wang must affirmatively
demonstrate error. (Ibid.)
Wang fails to establish an abuse of discretion. He contends that the
trial court failed to consider “ ‘whether Kleppe accurately represented the
October 21, 2022 order in her declarations.’ ” But the record is silent as to
whether the court decided if Kleppe’s declarations were misrepresentations.

6
We therefore must presume that the court considered what it was supposed
to consider.
More broadly, Wang insists that the trial court erred by not granting
the relief he requested. He urges that the record clearly shows that Kleppe’s
two declarations each purport to attach the same October 21, 2022 order but
with a different Attachment 1 – one of which lists documents beyond what
the court had ordered to be sealed – and that this constitutes criminal forgery
and a violation of an attorney’s ethical rules.
But Wang fails to address, or even include in the record, Kleppe’s
declaration that explains her version of what occurred. Nor has he provided
a transcript or other record of the hearing. It is therefore unclear what the
trial court considered and why it ruled as it did. In the absence of a record of
an oral proceeding, we presume that the trial court acted properly and the
record supports the order. (Elena S. v. Kroutik (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 570,
576.) In short, based on the briefs and record that Wang has provided, Wang
has not affirmatively established that the court erred. On that basis, we
affirm the order. (Ibid.)
Moreover, on our own motion, we have augmented the appellate record
to include a copy of Kleppe’s declaration that we obtained from the trial
court. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.155(a)(1)(A).) In her declaration, Kleppe
recounts the history of events, explains what happened from her perspective,
and takes responsibility but denies any intent to deceive. In light of this
evidence, we again conclude that Wang has not demonstrated an abuse of
discretion in denying relief under section 128.7.

7
III. DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

CHOU, J.

WE CONCUR.

JACKSON, P. J.
BURNS, J.

8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.