In re C.D. CA1/1

CourtListener 10796324Calctapp19 de fev. de 2026

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 2/19/26 In re C.D. CA1/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re C.D., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

CONTRA COSTA COUNTY A173748
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES BUREAU, (Contra Costa County
Super. Ct. No. J24-00204)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
C.D.,
Defendant and Appellant.

C.D. (mother) challenges the visitation order entered by the juvenile
court when it terminated jurisdiction over her son, C.D. (minor). Mother
contends the juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering that her visits be
supervised by a professional monitor at her expense. We affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
A. Juvenile Dependency Petition
In April 2024, the Contra Costa County Children and Family Services
Bureau (Bureau) filed a dependency petition pursuant to Welfare and

1
Institutions Code1 section 300, subdivision (b)(1), on behalf of minor, then
nearly two years old. The petition alleged mother had a chronic mental
health condition which placed minor at risk of serious physical harm or
injury. Specifically, the petition alleged mother: expressed paranoid
ideations that she and minor were being followed and that minor’s father2
and minor’s uncle had kidnapped minor; expressed threatening comments
and aggressively tried to yank minor out of the uncle’s arms; expressed
suicidal ideation; exhibited poor judgment in visiting a person she met online,
during which the person’s mother slapped minor in the face; and had been
placed on psychiatric holds at least twice due to psychotic episodes and was
inconsistent with her psychiatric medications. Additionally, the petition
alleged mother and father had physical altercations in minor’s presence and
that father had failed to protect minor from mother’s conduct.3
The Bureau’s detention/jurisdiction report recommended that minor
remain detained in an out of home placement. In late-March 2024, mother
was in the inpatient psychiatry unit and accused father of abusing her.
Mother was admitted for bipolar disorder and placed on a section 5150 hold.
The social worker interviewed the family on April 8, 2024. Minor was happy
and appeared well cared for. He smiled, laughed, and appeared bonded with
both parents.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions

Code.
2 Father is not a party to this appeal.

3 The petition also alleged father had a chronic substance abuse

problem which impacted his ability to provide regular and safe care for
minor, but this allegation was subsequently dismissed.

2
Father admitted that he and mother had had at least two physical
altercations. The last one occurred in 2023 while he was driving and mother
had a psychotic episode. Father reported that mother had been diagnosed
with schizophrenia, but he believed she was misdiagnosed. He thought she
had postpartum depression and sleep deprivation. Father stated mother was
a good mother. He explained she was overly protective but he was not
worried about minor in mother’s care and did not think she would hurt
minor.
Mother reported that father and her brother had kidnapped minor.
She also claimed that both father and her brother had physically and
sexually abused her, but she refused to provide additional information. She
reported she did not have any mental health diagnoses. Maternal
grandmother reported she did not know mother’s diagnoses but knew she was
“ ‘off and on with her medication.’ ” The social worker reported that maternal
grandmother appeared to have little control or authority over mother.
At the April 2024 detention hearing, the juvenile court ordered minor
detained and placed him in the Bureau’s care. It awarded visitation to both
parents.
B. Subsequent Review
In May 2024, the Bureau submitted a memorandum to update the
court before the jurisdiction hearing. Minor was placed in a resource family
approved home and the parents visited separately. During one visit, mother
appeared frustrated and had aggressive tones. She became agitated, causing
a shift in minor’s behavior, who began to hit mother and yank her hair.
Mother did not redirect minor and blamed it on him imitating father, who she
said “ ‘beat [her] ass.’ ” At another visit, mother talked about “ ‘abusive
‘n*ggas’ ” and having blood and urine running down her leg.

3
Mother reported to the social worker that father had abused her as
recently as early-May 2024 and she feared for her life, but she would not
provide details. She also accused father of raping her while on her sleeping
medication. The Bureau identified concerns regarding mother’s untreated
mental health issues and her reported domestic violence. At the May 13,
2024 jurisdiction hearing, the juvenile court sustained certain counts of the
petition.
The Bureau’s disposition report recommended the juvenile court
continue out of home placement and offer family reunification services to both
parents. During a meeting with the social worker in early-May 2024, mother
reported father had stalked her since she was around 17 years old and he
would currently “kidnap[] her” by forcing her in the car and taking her
places. She repeated her claims of physical violence and sexual abuse by
father. She believed she was misdiagnosed with schizophrenia. The social
worker advised that mother was a strong advocate for herself and for minor
and was determined to ensure minor’s needs were met. Father had a
demonstrated bond with minor and expressed a desire to enroll in services
related to the safety concerns raised by this case. Minor appeared to be
thriving and played well. He was bonded with his parents and experienced
emotional distress during separation.
Regarding mother’s referrals or progress, a psychiatric evaluation was
still pending. Mother participated in weekly individual therapy. She had
been provided several domestic violence resources and services to enroll in.
Father indicated he would enroll in a 52-week domestic violence education
program and planned to participate in an alcohol or drug abuse intake
assessment.

4
Regarding visitation, the Bureau’s report summarized visits by both
parents from April to June 2024. Mother’s agitation and inappropriate
behavior had already been documented in a prior report. Mother had
challenges regulating her emotions and at the end of visits she became
dysregulated, causing minor to become dysregulated. Father appeared
emotional and was good at redirecting minor’s behavior, and he had
established a goodbye routine which allowed minor to be relaxed. Mother
and father both engaged with minor. Minor often ran to mother and hugged
her. Minor seemed happy. The report stated that both parents’ care,
concern, and love for minor was evident since the case began.
At the June 17, 2024 disposition hearing, the juvenile court found that
minor’s placement with mother and father would be detrimental and
continued out of home placement. The court ordered reunification services
for both parents.
In the following months, both parents engaged in services and their
interactions improved. They completed parenting education classes and
participated in family therapy with minor. Mother participated in individual
therapy sessions and was reported to be actively addressing her concerns.
Mother also completed a domestic violence program. She began taking her
medication in September 2024 and participated in monthly meetings with
her psychiatrist for medication management. By November 2024, mother
had “stabilized her mental health and [was] actively taking her medication as
prescribed.” Father participated in individual therapy and in a 52-week
domestic violence education program. The improvements led to weekly
unsupervised visitation and, in November 2024, the juvenile court granted
the parents a 29-day overnight with minor. At the December 2024 family
reunification review hearing, the juvenile court returned minor to his

5
parents’ custody with family maintenance services. There were no safety
concerns observed or expressed by either parent when the social worker made
unannounced visits to the home in December 2024 and January 2025.
Circumstances changed drastically after January 2025, as documented
by the Bureau’s May 2025 report prepared for the family maintenance
review. At the time, father lived in the family’s apartment and mother lived
with maternal grandmother and minor spent equal time in each parent’s
separate residence. For the first time, the Bureau summarized events from
July 2024 which had not previously been reported. This included mother
claiming that both father and members of her family had sex trafficked her.
Father denied the allegations.
On February 25, 2025, mother went to a domestic violence shelter with
minor. The social worker met with mother and minor at the shelter the next
day. Mother alleged: father screamed at minor; father hung minor upside
down, although mother did not say if it was during play or discipline; father
did not answer the phone when she called; he drove recklessly; father kicked
her out of the apartment and forced her to go to grandmother’s home; father
was “ ‘drugging’ ” minor with melatonin gummies; father left minor
unsupervised while playing video games, but mother stated she was there;
and at the park father was on his phone and mother watched as minor ran
towards a stream and crawled under a fence and father did not get to him
before minor got wet. One time mother heard minor crying and asked him
what was wrong, “ ‘Did daddy hit you?’ ” Minor stated, “ ‘Daddy don’t hit
me.’ ” Mother did not remember when this happened or whether minor had
bruises. Mother claimed she reported these incidents to her therapist, the
family therapist, and her parent partner. The social worker informed mother
that none of these three mandated reporters had called in a referral.

6
When the social worker spoke with father about mother’s claims, he
replied: He did raise his voice when minor misbehaved; he denied holding
minor upside down; sometimes he needed a break and played video games;
one day while driving, mother and he argued and he drove faster than
mother wanted, but minor was in his car seat and there was no collision;
since returning home, minor’s sleep schedule had been off so father bought
melatonin gummies but he did not give them to minor because mother told
him they were for the wrong age; and sometimes he smacked minor on the
hand or took away toys when he misbehaved. Father felt blindsided by
mother’s decision to leave the home due to feeling unsafe because they got
along and spent time together on family outings. He was tired of mother’s
false accusations.
The family therapist reported the last session was intense because the
parents had different parenting styles. Mother tried to leave the session and
had mistrust with father. The therapist was unable to confirm mother’s
claims. Mother had reported that she informed Edna White, the domestic
violence program advocate, about issues in the relationship. White reported
that mother participated sporadically in the support group and that mother
admitted she was not taking her medication, explaining it made her sleepy
and father did things to her when she was asleep. White was not clear
whether this account was true. The parent partner advised that mother had
reported the same allegations she made at the shelter and the parent partner
believed her. The social worker was unclear why the parent partner did not
alert her to the claims.
After the Bureau informed mother that it did not find minor to be at
risk and he would be allowed to visit with father, mother sent the social
worker recordings without context and a picture of father when he was

7
younger holding a gun. Father explained he was gang involved when he was
younger but not currently and reported he did not have any guns.
Subsequently, mother called father and asked him to pick her up from the
shelter.
After an emergency meeting of the family’s team in March 2025, a
safety plan was implemented: the parents were not to reside in the same
home; they would exchange minor at maternal grandmother’s home; they
could communicate by phone and video chat so the other parent could speak
to minor; and they were to confer with the therapist to decide how best to
proceed with sessions. At the time of the May 2025 report, father was
enrolled in domestic violence education classes and was an active contributor.
He had attended 33 sessions of the 52-session program and reported that the
frequency of his arguments with mother had decreased. Mother reported she
was taking her medication.
Mother provided a letter of support from the domestic violence
program. White, the advocate, reported mother had contacted the agency
four times since 2024. Her habit was that she would make an elaborate
allegation and when they questioned her for clarity, her allegations were not
logical. In April 2025, White contacted the social worker expressing concern
after a conversation with mother where mother advised she planned to flee
with minor prior to the next court date. Mother had stated she was going to
Alabama. The social worker discovered that maternal grandfather lived in
Alabama and should be considered a safety concern because mother had
previously identified him as someone who trafficked her as a minor.
Minor was healthy and his speech had improved. He performed
physical activities in line with his developmental age. He had a loving
relationship with both of his parents. He continued to participate in family

8
therapy. The parents had different parenting styles which caused confusion
in minor understanding his boundaries.
Regarding visitation, prior to the incident of February 25, 2025—when
mother went to the domestic violence shelter—there had been no visitation
plan in place. After the incident and now that the parents lived separately,
minor was with each parent a few days a week. At the time, the visitation
plan worked. Father confirmed he planned to move back to New Jersey after
this case closed.
In its May 2025 report, the Bureau assessed the circumstances as
follows: Mother had been inconsistent with medication management and not
transparent. The social worker questioned whether mother was medication
compliant even though members of her support network stated she was
taking her medication. Mother’s behavior was concerning. For example, she
stated she felt unsafe with father and left the home, then called father to pick
her up. She was unwilling to share what made her feel unsafe, told service
providers father was trying to get a gun and shared an old picture of him
with a gun, and identified maternal grandfather as someone who trafficked
her as a child yet she wanted to flee with minor to him. Father was
appropriate with minor and met his needs. Father needed to maintain clear
boundaries with mother and understand that unless mother’s mental health
was being treated, she was a safety concern to herself, him, and minor.
The Bureau recommended that minor remain in the care of both
parents, separately. At the May 19, 2025 family maintenance review
hearing, the juvenile court ordered the Bureau to file a supplemental
petition. The court ordered father to care for minor until detention was
addressed and father was not to allow mother access to minor. Minor was
not to leave the courthouse with mother.

9
C. Supplemental Petition
On May 20, 2025, the Bureau filed a supplemental petition pursuant to
section 387. The petition alleged mother’s mental health continued to
jeopardize minor’s safety and well-being. The next day, the Bureau filed a
memorandum recommending that minor be detained from mother and placed
with father. On May 16, 2025—three days before the recent hearing—
mother and minor were at a domestic violence shelter and mother planned to
seek a restraining order. After the May 19, 2025 court hearing, the social
worker and father spent 15 minutes looking for minor, mother, and maternal
grandmother. Father remained in the parking lot while the social worker
went to update the court. When the social worker returned outside, father,
minor, mother, and maternal grandmother were there. Mother was yelling at
father then she yelled at the social worker. Mother screamed that she had
bruises all over her body.
The social worker spoke with father on May 19, 2025. He did not know
mother had been to a shelter even though they had been together a couple
days later. He was blindsided by mother’s domestic violence allegations.
Father denied being physical with mother since the incident when the case
first opened. He wanted to keep minor safe. On the evening of May 19,
mother showed up at father’s home and beat on his front door asking to see
minor. Father contacted the police department twice but apparently mother
had left before the police arrived.
At the May 21, 2025 detention hearing on the supplemental petition,
the juvenile court appointed a guardian ad litem for mother and mother
denied the allegations. The court found a substantial danger to minor’s
physical and emotional health and detained minor from mother based on her
ongoing mental health struggles. The court ordered supervised visitation to

10
mother for a minimum of two hours, two times per week to be supervised by
the Bureau or its professional designee. The court also barred mother from
going on father’s premises and attempting to contact minor. The jurisdiction
and disposition hearing was set for July 7, 2025.
D. Hearing on Mother’s Visitation
On June 30, 2025, at the Bureau’s request, the juvenile court held a
hearing to address mother’s visitation. The Bureau explained that mother
refused to work with it. The Bureau discovered that mother used services for
trafficked victims to obtain a flight and she had ended up in Maryland.
While there, she was put on a section 5150 hold. At some point she was
released from the hospital and returned to California and was now
demanding visitation with minor. Mother called the Bureau while a police
officer was with her, thinking the police could enforce visitation. The Bureau
wanted to speak with mother and assess her for safety before it would
proceed with visitation. Mother had rescinded her releases of information so
the Bureau was unable to speak with her psychiatrist or therapist.
Accordingly, the Bureau did not know how mother was doing. The Bureau
asked the court to suspend visitation, to which minor’s counsel agreed.
Counsel acknowledged that minor was “very close to his mom and visitations
are important,” so counsel hoped mother could obtain help and take her
medication to safely resume visits.
The juvenile court issued a temporary order in place until the hearing
the following week: Mother needed to cooperate with the Bureau and submit
proof that she was actively engaged in mental health treatment and was
taking her medication as prescribed. She had to provide the Bureau access to
that information. If the Bureau deemed her stable, then the court would
continue supervised visits. If mother did not provide the required proof and

11
did not meet with the Bureau, then the court would suspend visitation. The
court found that visitation during a time when mother had not demonstrated
her compliance with mental health treatment would be detrimental to minor.
E. Termination of Jurisdiction and Exit Orders
The Bureau submitted a memorandum to update the court before the
July 7, 2025 disposition hearing. The social worker had received the
following contacts from mother: On June 9, mother confirmed she was in
Maryland. She explained she had been transported there “ ‘by several
people’ ” to a home owned by father’s family. She also reported she had been
given a flight by a domestic violence program. Mother stated she was at
Adventist Hospital. On June 11, the social worker received an assessed out
referral stating mother reported she had escaped father. She disclosed sex
trafficking and said she was sold to father for an arranged marriage when
she was 17 years old. There were concerns her information was vague and
unclear and it was believed she may have been mentally unstable. On June
12, the social worker received a call from an employee at University of
Maryland Capital Regent Health who explained mother had been placed on a
psychiatric hold the day before. She arrived at the hospital stating she was
the victim of human trafficking and she was believed to be having an acute
episode of schizophrenia. The employee expressed concerns regarding
minor’s whereabouts. With her, mother had a brown paper bag containing at
least two cups of minor’s hair and a suitcase with his clothes, crayons, toys,
and diapers.
On June 14, mother left a voicemail for the social worker stating she
had been poisoned by carbon monoxide and had been raped. On June 16,
mother left another voicemail stating she was being released from the
hospital soon and would make her way back to California to see minor. That

12
same day, mother spoke with the social worker inquiring whether she could
still have visits with minor. Mother repeated that she had been hospitalized
due to carbon monoxide poisoning. When the social worker inquired whether
she was on a psychiatric hold, mother did not answer. On a call the following
day, mother stated she was going to another facility and would return to
California once released. When the social worker asked multiple times if she
was on a psychiatric hold, mother would not answer.
On June 23, mother inquired about visitation and the social worker
explained that mother had left the state for two weeks and needed to submit
a new visitation form because she was requesting visits be moved to
Richmond. On June 25, mother informed the social worker she was with the
police to help enforce the visitation order. The social worker explained that
law enforcement could not enforce the order because the Bureau designated
the visits and who supervised them. In an email to the social worker the next
day, mother explained she had made consistent trips to the emergency room
for physical injuries and sexual assault.
On July 1, the social worker met with mother to assess her for safety
after the juvenile court paused visits. The social worker attempted to have
mother sign a release so she could contact mother’s psychiatrist, but mother
did not sign the form. The following day, mother sent a picture of the signed
release form. While the form the social worker had provided checked boxes
for the exchange of information for psychiatric/psychological evaluations and
therapist/counseling reports, mother had crossed out those items and wrote
in that she authorized the exchange of information regarding coordination of
care/medication. Mother requested to be present for those conversations.
The social worker advised the court that she was not able to assess mother
for safety.

13
As to father, the Bureau advised that father had no concerns regarding
minor. Father confirmed that outside of a supervised video call on June 27,
mother had not had contact with minor. He confirmed his plan was to return
to the East Coast where he would have his family’s support.
The report explained that in the prior four weeks, mother had provided
the social worker with vague details regarding the causes of her
hospitalizations. She continued to make allegations of sex trafficking and
sexual assaults but could not provide any evidence or answer follow up
questions. Overall, the Bureau recommended that the juvenile court sustain
the supplemental petition, terminate family reunification services to mother,
have minor remain in father’s care, and discharge the matter.
At the July 7, 2025 disposition hearing, the Bureau requested the
juvenile court give physical and legal custody to father. Minor’s counsel and
father agreed and mother objected. The court awarded sole physical and
legal custody to father.
As to visitation, the Bureau requested supervised visitation to mother
when she was local in the area where father and minor resided, with a
professional supervisor to be paid for by mother. Mother’s counsel objected,
explaining mother “won’t be able to afford a professional supervisor” so it was
“tantamount to denying her any kind of visitation with her son.” While the
Bureau was open to a supervisor from father’s family, other than father
himself, if someone could handle visitation, father opposed the option. While
he was planning to move back to the East Coast and had family to do it there,
he explained he had no family here. Minor’s counsel agreed to the current
visitation order and was open to visitation with a member of father’s family
when they moved to the East Coast. The juvenile court ordered visitation to
mother with a minimum of two hours of visits each month to be supervised by

14
a professional supervisor, the cost to be paid for by mother. The visits were
to occur in whatever community minor resided in. The court allowed mother
to have phone visitation monitored by father.
As to visitation supervised by a family member, the juvenile court
explained mother “is extraordinarily unstable at the time and poses a very
significant and real risk to the safety and well-being of [minor], and
historically father has had a hard time protecting [minor] from that, and, in
fact, that’s what led to the dependency in the first instance.” The court also
explained mother had “shown herself capable of absconding with the child
and has at times led what appears to the [c]ourt to be a rather nomadic
lifestyle with the child in tow, which is extraordinarily risky to the safety and
well-being of a child, especially [minor] who is soon to be school age and
cannot be tracing around communities from shelter to shelter, across state
lines, living in that fashion with a mother who seems disconnected from
reality.” Therefore, the court stated, it was not “appropriate to allow a family
member to supervise the visits as [the court did] not believe a family member
could keep [minor] safe under the current circumstances.”
The juvenile court dismissed the dependency petition and terminated
its jurisdiction over minor. The court’s written exit order stated, “Supervised
visitation for the mother with the child when the mother is local to the father.
Visits must be supervised by a professional supervisor to be paid for by
[m]other. Father is not to supervise visits. Mother has long standing and
untreated mental health issues that pose a substantial risk to the child.”

15
II. DISCUSSION
Mother challenges the condition of the juvenile court’s exit order
requiring visits to be supervised by a professional monitor at her expense.4
A. Legal Principles and Standard of Review
“When a juvenile court terminates its jurisdiction over a dependent
child, it is empowered to make ‘exit orders’ regarding custody and visitation.
(§§ 364, subd. (c), 362.4; . . . .) Such orders become part of any family court
proceeding concerning the same child and will remain in effect until they are
terminated or modified by the family court.” (In re T.H. (2010) 190
Cal.App.4th 1119, 1122–1123.) A juvenile court “has broad discretion” in
fashioning exit orders. (In re Nicholas H. (2003) 112 Cal.App.4th 251, 265,
fn. 4.) In doing so, “ ‘the court’s focus and primary consideration must always
be the best interests of the child.’ ” (In re T.S. (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 503,
513; see also In re John W. (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 961, 974 [court must use
“strict best interest standard”].) In ascertaining those interests, the court
“ ‘must look to the totality of a child’s circumstances when making decisions
regarding the child.’ ” (In re J.T. (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 953, 963.) Our
Supreme Court has explained that there are situations where a court may
determine dependency jurisdiction is no longer necessary “and at the same
time conclude that conditions on visitation are necessary to minimize, if not
eliminate, the danger that visits might subject the minor to the same risk of
physical abuse or emotional harm that previously led to the dependency
adjudication.” (In re Chantal S. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 196, 204 (Chantal S.).)

4 While mother includes statements regarding the portion of the order

requiring that visits be a minimum of two hours per month, a review of her
opening brief demonstrates that she only challenges the paid professional
supervisor requirement.

16
We review a juvenile court’s exit orders for abuse of discretion. (In re
N.M. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090, 1094.) Thus, we will not disturb the order
unless it constitutes “ ‘ “ ‘ “an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination.” ’ ” ’ ” (Ibid.) “ ‘The appropriate test for abuse of discretion is
whether the trial court exceeded the bounds of reason. When two or more
inferences can reasonably be deduced from the facts, the reviewing court has
no authority to substitute its decision for that of the trial court.’ ” (In re
Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318–319.)
B. Analysis
Mother does not challenge the requirement that her visits must be
supervised. She challenges only the portion of the juvenile court’s exit order
requiring that such supervision must be by a professional monitor at her
expense. We conclude that the court did not abuse its discretion in imposing
this condition on mother’s visitation.
We acknowledge that the record demonstrates that mother loves and
cares for minor and that minor is bonded with her. The juvenile court
sustained allegations in the initial dependency petition that mother’s mental
health condition placed minor at risk. From September 2024 to January
2025, mother had made progress in treating her mental health issues, taking
her medication, and engaging in services. But the record highlights major
concerns raised by mother’s actions which posed a substantial risk of harm to
minor beginning in February 2025 through the July 2025 disposition. In
February 2025, mother took minor to a domestic violence shelter and made
accusations against father which were not confirmed. Despite these
accusations, mother then called father to pick her up from the shelter. In
June 2025, she obtained a flight from a domestic violence program and ended
up in Maryland. There, she reported she was at a hospital and, a couple days

17
later at a different hospital, she was placed on a psychiatric hold for an acute
schizophrenic episode and had minor’s hair and belongings with her. She
subsequently provided the social worker only vague details of the cause of her
hospitalizations and claimed she had carbon monoxide poisoning and had
been raped. Mother expressed an intent to abscond with minor to Alabama
where her father lived despite having alleged her father trafficked her when
she was younger. Immediately preceding the disposition hearing, mother
continued to make allegations of sex trafficking and sexual assaults but could
not provide any evidence or answer follow up questions. She did not provide
proof mandated by the juvenile court that she was actively engaged in mental
health treatment and taking her medications as prescribed. Mother herself
concedes that “the reports immediately preceding and following the section
387 [supplemental] petition provide support for a finding that the previous
disposition was no longer effective in protecting [minor].”
The juvenile court considered whether mother’s visits could be
supervised by a non-professional and rejected that option. Mother’s failure to
treat her mental health issues and take her medications were the court’s
primary concerns. The court explained that mother was unstable and posed
a risk to minor’s safety and well-being, and it determined that a family
member could not keep minor safe under the circumstances. Mother’s failure
to engage in mental health treatment and actions described above support
the court’s determination that visits must be supervised by a professional, as
there is no demonstration that a non-professional could adequately monitor
mother’s circumstances and behavior to preclude any risk of harm to minor.
Moreover, mother never identified a potential non-professional monitor.
At the time the juvenile court made its decision, both parents and minor
resided in the Bay Area. No party suggested that a member of mother’s

18
family, or anyone else in the area, could serve as a monitor. And father’s
family is on the East Coast. The record contains no evidence that mother
was able or willing to find someone to serve as a monitor.
Mother asserts she cannot afford to pay a professional monitor, which
would result in losing contact and a relationship with minor. Preliminarily,
mother cites nothing in the record regarding her ability to bear the expense of
a monitor. In mother’s opening brief, appellate counsel merely states that
“mother is an indigent party of limited means – hence, the representation by
appointed counsel on appeal.” In any event, mother objected on this ground
at the disposition hearing. The juvenile court was entitled to weigh that
consideration against the concurrent concerns raised by mother’s recent
behavior and the inability to assess whether mother was engaging in mental
health treatment and taking her medications. (See In re T.M. (2016) 4
Cal.App.5th 1214, 1220 [“ ‘the parents’ interest in the care, custody and
companionship of their children is not to be maintained at the child’s
expense’ ”].) The court determined that a professional monitor, rather than
an unpaid non-professional, was in minor’s best interest. Its decision is
supported by the behavior and concerns set forth above. (See Chantal S.,
supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 204 [court may impose conditions on visitation
necessary to minimize or eliminate the danger that visits might subject the
minor to the same risk of harm which led to the dependency adjudication].)
The question on appeal is not whether evidence could support a different
order—it is whether the court abused its discretion in issuing the order it did.
(See In re N.M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at p. 1094.)
Finally, mother contends that the visitation order contradicts a policy
enunciated under the Family Code—that children should have frequent and
continuing contact with both parents after a marriage or relationship ends.

19
(Fam. Code, § 3020, subd. (b).)5 Mother’s reliance on family law principles is
misplaced. Juvenile courts and family courts have separate purposes.
(Chantal S., supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 201.) While “both courts focus on the best
interests of the child, ‘[t]he presumption of parental fitness that underlies
custody law in the family court . . . does not apply to dependency cases’
decided in the juvenile court.” (Ibid.) The juvenile court here properly
focused on minor’s best interests.
In sum, the juvenile court’s determination that visits must be
supervised by a professional monitor at mother’s expense was not arbitrary,
capricious, or patently absurd. Accordingly, the exit order imposing
conditions on mother’s visitation was not an abuse of the juvenile court’s
discretion. Mother remains free to seek modification of the order in the
family court. (See §§ 302, subd. (d), 362.4.)
III. DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s July 7, 2025 order is affirmed.

5 We observe that Family Code section 3020, subdivision (a), states in

pertinent part, “The Legislature finds and declares that it is the public policy
of this state to ensure that the health, safety, and welfare of children shall be
the court’s primary concern in determining the best interests of children
when making any orders regarding . . . visitation.”

20
_________________________
LANGHORNE WILSON, J.

WE CONCUR:

_________________________
HUMES, P. J.

_________________________
BANKE, J.

In re C.D. / A173748

21

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.