CourtListener 10795812•People v. Escandon CA2/3
Texto completo
Filed 2/18/26 P. v. Escandon CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE, B330244
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA432701
v.
JOSEPH ESCANDON,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Stephen A. Marcus, Judge. Affirmed in part,
reversed in part, and remanded with directions.
Laura Schaefer, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Idan Ivri and Nikhil Cooper, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
In 2003, appellant Joseph Escandon shot fellow gang
members Frank Barajas, Jr. and Alfred Salinas, Jr. after a verbal
argument at a gathering outside his apartment. Barajas Jr. died
and Salinas Jr. suffered great bodily injury. In 2005, Escandon
also murdered another fellow gang member named Esteban Real
pursuant to a greenlight order from the Mexican Mafia. In 2019,
a jury convicted Escandon of two counts of first degree murder
and one count of attempted premeditated murder and found true
the multiple murder and gang murder special circumstances, and
gang and firearm enhancements.
On appeal, Escandon challenges the admission of recorded
calls and a gang expert’s interpretation of them, and the
admission of other out of court statements implicating him in the
Real murder. He also contends the trial court incorrectly
declined to instruct on alibi and coerced the jury into making its
true finding on the special circumstances. We reject these
arguments.
But we agree with Escandon’s insufficiency of evidence
claims as to the gang murder special circumstance and gang
enhancement for the Barajas Jr. murder and the gang
enhancement for the Salinas Jr. attempted murder. We further
agree that the instructions for the gang murder special
circumstances and gang enhancements did not include the
changes made by Assembly Bill No. 333 (2021–2022 Reg. Sess.).
We reverse and vacate the true findings for the gang murder
special circumstances and gang enhancements for the Barajas Jr.
and Real murders and the gang enhancement for the Salinas Jr.
attempted murder. We remand the gang murder special
circumstance and gang enhancement as to the Real murder only.
We affirm the judgment in all other respects.
2
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. The Facts
A. The prosecution case
1. The Avenues gang and the Mexican Mafia
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the Avenues gang
controlled the area patrolled by LAPD’s Northeast Division. The
cliques of the Avenues gang included Drew Street, Five Seven,
Division, 43rd, and Assassins.
In the early 2000s, the Avenues gang was under the
umbrella of the Mexican Mafia, a prison gang that consisted of
100 to 150 validated members. The Mexican Mafia ordered
predominantly Hispanic streets gangs like the Avenues to collect
taxes or extort drug dealers and local businesses. The money
collected was funneled back to the Mexican Mafia. In the early
2000s, the Avenues gang collected more than $30,000 per week
for the Mexican Mafia. The Drew Street area was considered
lucrative for tax collection because its proximity to a freeway
facilitated drug sales.
Escandon was a member of the Drew Street clique of the
Avenues gang with the moniker of “Lokito.” Between 2005 to
2007, he worked as a top-level tax collector for the Mexican
Mafia.
2. Murder of Frank Barajas, Jr. and
attempted murder of Alfred Salinas, Jr.
On January 14, 2003, at 1:30 a.m., LAPD Officer Cesar
Rodriguez responded to an assault with a deadly weapon call at
367 Leslie Way, near 5745 Arroyo Drive, in Los Angeles. He
found Alfred Salinas, Jr., who was in his 20s with a shaved head
3
and tattoos on his upper body. He was an Avenues gang member
known as Lil Tigre. Salinas Jr. had gunshot wounds on his back
and stomach. He told Officer Rodriguez his name and that he
had been shot. But he did not answer any questions because he
was in a lot of pain. Officer Rodriguez did not see any firearm on
Salinas Jr. An ambulance arrived and transported Salinas Jr. to
a local hospital.
Officer Steven Aguilar and his partner responded to a
“shots fired” radio call at 367 Leslie Way. After learning that
other officers had already arrived, Officer Aguilar heard another
radio call generated from 5745 Arroyo Drive. They parked at the
intersection of Arroyo Drive and Leslie Way. Officer Aguilar saw
blood on the sidewalk and beer cans on the ground near an
apartment building. He followed the blood trail northbound on
Arroyo Drive where he was flagged down by people who directed
him to a person who was two houses north of the apartment.
Officer Aguilar saw a man lying face down with blood coming out
of his mouth. The man was identified as Frank Barajas, Jr., who
was an Avenues gang member known as Lil Stretch. He died
from multiple gunshot wounds.
a. Olivier Cuevas
On January 13, 2003, leading into January 14, 2003,
Olivier Cuevas was in her apartment at 5745 Arroyo Drive when
the shooting occurred. She was Escandon’s neighbor. She lived
with Sandra Ramirez.1 Sandra’s daughter Cassandra Schroeder
1 Because Sandra Ramirez and William Ramirez share the
same last name, we refer to Sandra Ramirez as Sandra and
William Ramirez as William or Ramirez.
4
lived in the unit above them. Cuevas knew Sandra’s sons,
William and Andy, to be associated with the Avenues gang.
On the night of the shooting, seven to 10 people gathered
outside Escandon’s apartment. Cuevas heard them arguing but
could not hear what was being said. She went outside to throw
out the trash and saw multiple people from the group chasing
each other around and fighting. Cuevas saw William being
chased and told him that his mother was calling him. William
went inside. Cuevas saw Escandon walking from the driveway
toward his apartment unit. After Cuevas threw out the trash,
she saw Escandon come out of his unit, look around, and put his
arm up with a revolver in his hand. Cuevas saw Escandon shoot
one person. After the man was shot, he ran on Arroyo Drive. He
fell after passing two driveways. Another man ran by the area
where Cuevas was. Escandon followed this man and shot him.
Cuevas hid behind a car. She saw the others from the gathering
run away.
Sandra came outside and walked to the sidewalk where
Cuevas was. Escandon tried to grab Sandra. Cuevas pushed her
to the side and told Escandon, “ ‘Hey, what are you doing? Just
leave us alone.’ ” Escandon pushed Cuevas against a wall.
Escandon pointed the gun at her head and pulled the trigger.
The gun clicked. Escandon’s father and mother approached and
got in between him and Cuevas. Escandon’s father pulled him
back. Cuevas grabbed Sandra, and they ran into their
apartment.
About 10 or 15 minutes after the shooting, Cuevas jumped
out of one of the side windows with William because she did not
feel safe inside her apartment. Sandra remained in the
apartment because she was worried about her daughter. When
5
Cuevas went outside, she heard someone banging on a door,
saying, “ ‘Help me, help me.’ ”
According to Cuevas, Escandon moved out of the apartment
two to three weeks after the shooting. Three or four weeks after
the shooting, Escandon’s father blocked Cuevas from leaving her
car and said, “ ‘You fucking bitches better keep your mouths
[shut], you fucking dykes.’ ” He also stated, “ ‘You guys better get
out of here or what happened to [those] guys down here’ . . .
‘that’s nothing compared to what is going to happen to you.’ ”
Cuevas interpreted the statement by Escandon’s father to mean
that she and Ramirez would be harmed like the victims of the
shooting.
Cuevas called the police. When officers arrived, they first
spoke to Escandon’s father. The officers told Cuevas that
“ ‘nothing happened’ ” and “ ‘it’s . . . neighbors being neighbors,’ ”
cautioning them “ ‘to stay out of each other’s way’ ” and “ ‘just
leave it alone.’ ” Cuevas was too scared to inform the officers that
she witnessed the shooting that occurred on January 14.
Ten minutes after the officers left, Cuevas called the
landlord of the apartment complex and told him that she was
having issues with Escandon’s father. She told the landlord
about the threat.
On March 15, 2003, Escandon’s father again approached
Cuevas and threatened her. He stated, “So I know you called the
landlord. You guys better keep your mouth shut, and you fucking
dykes better get out of here.” He further threatened to break her
neck and warned, “You better open your eyes and look around
before you go outside again.” Escandon’s father added that they
had “better not be snitching” to the landlord. Cuevas went to her
unit and called the police. While waiting for officers to arrive,
6
she looked out her window and saw Escandon’s father walking
back and forth in front of her unit with a gun in his hand. The
officers arrived and took a report from Cuevas.
b. Cassandra Schroeder
Cassandra Schroeder also lived in an apartment at 5745
Arroyo Drive. She lived with her brother William. Schroeder’s
other brother Andy, her mother Sandra and Cuevas, and other
family members lived in a separate unit in the same complex.
Escandon and his girlfriend and their children lived in a unit
below Schroeder. Escandon’s parents also lived in a separate
unit.
On the late night of January 13, 2003, going into the early
morning of January 14, Schroeder heard gunshots. At trial, she
testified that she looked out her windows but did not see
anything.
At trial, after being shown photos of William—one of a
tattoo on his chest and the other of him making hand gestures—
Schroeder denied knowing that he was an Avenues gang member,
knowing that he had gang tattoos, or recognizing his hand
gestures as gang signs. She confirmed that Escandon and
another man were depicted in one of the photos making the letter
A with their hands.
Schroeder denied being afraid of retaliation against herself
or her family for testifying at the trial. She acknowledged that in
2016, she was brought in handcuffs to testify at the preliminary
hearing for the case. Schroeder recalled speaking to a deputy
district attorney who told her that she would need to come to
court.
In 2009, Schroeder spoke with Detective Lisa Padilla
Sanchez about the incident. She told Detective Padilla Sanchez
7
that when she arrived at her apartment, she saw Escandon and
others in the parking lot. Schroeder heard her mother’s voice and
went outside. She saw her mother, Escandon, and Escandon’s
parents. Schroeder’s mother was trying to calm everyone down
and told her to go back inside. When Schroeder returned to her
apartment, she heard two shots, a pause, and additional shots.
She looked out the window and saw people leaving in cars. After
the shooting, Schroeder never had contact with Escandon again.
3. Murder of Esteban Real
a. Tomas Membrila
On January 22, 2005, at 2:00 or 3:00 p.m., Tomas Membrila
arrived at his mother’s home next to 4327 Toland Way. He saw
three men standing outside. At trial, he testified that later on
the way back to his car, he heard shots and ran.
On February 22, 2005, Membrila spoke with Detectives
Larry Burcher and Rick Ortiz about the shooting. At trial,
Membrila acknowledged that he told the detectives that he saw
two of the men firing guns at the third person, who was lying on
the ground. Membrila denied telling the detectives that he saw
these individuals earlier when he parked his car.
b. Griselda Alvarez
On January 22, 2005, Griselda Alvarez was at her
apartment at 4337 Toland Way when she heard a shooting at
around 7:30 p.m. She saw one young man shoot another young
man. The man who got shot fell to the ground. He was shot
again while he was on the ground. The man with the gun and
another man ran past Alvarez’s window. The man with the gun
looked at Alvarez. On past occasions, Alvarez would greet the
man who got shot. Alvarez called 911.
8
On February 9, 2005, Alvarez met with Detective Burcher.
She selected Escandon out of a photographic lineup as the person
who had the gun. She wrote, “I think that the hair is like the
person that I saw. His skin color is like light tan, slightly tan,
tanned. His height and his weight are similar.” Alvarez told
Detective Burcher that she did not notice anything in the hands
of the person who ran by her window, but she also told him that
she did not look at the person’s hands.
At trial, she testified that she saw Escandon at the
preliminary hearing on October 16, 2016. Alvarez testified that
he had a gun when she saw him on the date of the shooting in
2005.2
c. Melissa Chavez
On January 22, 2005, Melissa Chavez was at her home in
unit 13 of an apartment building at 4319 Toland Way in Los
Angeles. She was with Esteban Real.3 They were in a dating
relationship. Chavez knew Real to be an Avenues gang member
with the moniker Demon.4
2 At trial, Alvarez incorrectly identified Efrain Ramirez as
the other shooter. She also testified that Efrain Ramirez looked
like the person depicted in one of the photographic lineups.
However, Ramirez was not charged with the murder of Real.
3 Esteban Real shares the same last name with his brothers
Nicolas Real, Albert Real, and Francisco Real. To avoid
confusion, we refer to Esteban Real as Real.
4 Throughout the record, Real is referred to as Demon and
Lil Demon.
9
Chavez received a call for Real on her cellphone. Chavez
left the room while Real spoke with the caller. Real got dressed
and went outside. Chavez heard what sounded like fireworks
five or six times. One of Chavez’s family members told her that
Real had been shot.
d. Interviews with Chavez
On January 22, 2005, at 7:15 p.m., Officer Rene Morales
received a radio call originating from 4327 Toland Way. He saw
Real near the sidewalk and curb area. He saw that Real had
sustained multiple gunshot wounds. At the time, Officer Morales
was assigned to the Northeast Division gang enforcement detail
where he would monitor the Avenues and Highland Park gangs.
Officer Morales was familiar with Real and knew his moniker to
be “Demon.”
Officer Morales met with Chavez who identified herself as
Real’s girlfriend. Chavez told him that Real received a call on
her phone at 6:49 p.m. and went outside after talking on the
phone. Chavez further told him that after a few minutes, she
heard multiple gunshots. Chavez could not remember the caller’s
name but recalled that it started with an L.
After midnight on January 23, Detective Burcher spoke
with Chavez in her apartment. She told him that Real’s behavior
had recently been “a little strange.” She said that Real was
wearing a bulletproof vest and carrying a gun on a regular basis.5
Chavez told Detective Burcher about the call for Real on her
cellphone and that she could only remember the caller’s name
5 At trial, Chavez testified that she never saw Real with a
gun and never knew him to wear a bulletproof vest.
10
starting with an L. She also said that after taking the call, Real
got dressed and went outside. Minutes later, the shooting
occurred.
Chavez showed the phone number of the caller to Detective
Burcher. That phone number was 323-220-2125. Detective
Burcher obtained records for that number pursuant to a search
warrant.
On February 8, 2005, Detective Burcher and Detective
Ortiz met with Chavez at the police station. She remembered the
name “Lokito” as the caller.
On July 9, 2014, Detective Sanchez Padilla interviewed
Chavez. Chavez told her that Real appeared very stressed out
before he left the apartment after taking the phone call. Chavez
asked Real how much money he would need and gave him a
hundred dollars.
e. Nicolas Real
Nicolas Real was Real’s brother. He grew up on Drew
Street and had brothers who were Avenues gang members.
Everyone called him “Niko.”6 Niko knew Real’s moniker was “Lil
Demon.” His other brother Albert was known as “Baby Demon.”7
At trial, Niko denied being a member of the Avenues. But in
2008 or 2009, Niko served 11 years in prison for a federal
racketeering charge related to the Avenues gang.
6 To avoid confusion with Real, we refer to Nicolas Real as
Niko.
7 To avoid confusion with Real, we refer to Albert Real as
Albert or Baby Demon.
11
On the night of the murder, Niko heard that Real was
killed and went looking for him at a 7-Eleven. He eventually
found Real on the ground on Toland Way.
f. Additional investigation
Detective Michael Arteaga became familiar with the
Avenues gang when assigned to the gang detail of LAPD’s
Northeast Division. He knew Real’s brothers Niko, Albert,
Francisco “Poncho” Real, and Daniel “Clever” Leon.8 Arteaga
opined that each was a member of the Avenues gang.
On March 31, 2005, at 1:40 p.m., when Arteaga was a
uniformed officer assigned to the gang unit, he participated in
searching a home at 3304 Drew Street, which was a location
known for gang and narcotics activity. When he arrived, Arteaga
detained Albert for violating a gang injunction. Niko intervened,
stating, “ ‘Come on Arteaga, let him go. You know what’s going
on.’ ” Niko continued, “ ‘You know about Demon. I was talking to
Demon when he got killed.’ ” Niko directed Arteaga to look under
a mirror in the living room because he wrote down the phone
number of the phone his brother was using when he was shot.
Arteaga looked under the mirror and saw “1/22/05,” “7:14,” and
“220-2125.” Niko told him that this was the time and date that
he wrote down the phone number and added that the phone
number was from a “323” area code.
On April 4, 2005, Officer Arteaga wrote a report that
included the information provided by Niko. He submitted the
report to Detective Burcher. Based on the information in the
8 To be consistent with the witnesses’ references to Daniel
“Clever” Leon, we refer to him as Clever.
12
report, Detectives Burcher and Ortiz contacted Niko at his home
on April 13, 2005. Niko informed them that he received a call on
the night Real was killed. When he answered the call, Real said
his name Niko twice and multiple gunshots were fired. Niko
showed the detectives the wall where he had written down the
information about the call. Detective Burcher confirmed the
information observed by Arteaga: “7:14,” “1/22,” and “220-2125.”
Detective Burcher’s investigation of the phone number of
323-220-2125 revealed that the service provider was Nextel and
the name of David Martinez was listed as the subscriber.
Detective Burcher inquired whether the phone was a “burner
phone” or a cell phone that was purchased for a pre-specified
number of minutes without the need to subscribe to a service and
submit to a credit check. The subscriber named for the phone
often did not match the actual user of the phone. Through
investigation of phone numbers called from the 2125 cellphone,
Detective Burcher confirmed the phone numbers called from the
cellphone included those for Niko, Melissa Chavez, Jasmine
Villalobos, and Lupe Cullar.9 Detective Burcher’s investigation
revealed that Cullar was Escandon’s mother. The records
indicated that two calls were made to Chavez’s cellphone at 6:48
p.m. and 6:49 p.m. on January 22, 2005. At 6:51 p.m., Chavez’s
home phone number called the 2125 number. The records also
showed that at 7:14 p.m., the 2125 number called Niko’s
cellphone.
An autopsy revealed that Real died from four gunshot
wounds to his neck, jaw, chest, and back. Three other shots
struck Real’s ribcage, lower back, left thigh, and right finger.
9 The name was also spelled Cueller.
13
Real also sustained nonfatal, superficial injuries from fragments
of medium-caliber, copper-jacketed bullets that riddled his body
in a manner consistent with bullets striking the concrete ground
and deflecting into him as he lay on the sidewalk. Three .45
caliber casings and four 9-millimeter casings were recovered from
around Real’s body.
g. James Campbell
James Campbell was an Avenues member who became an
associate of the Mexican Mafia, but he was never a fully
validated member. Campbell was convicted of manslaughter in
1994 and imprisoned in Pelican Bay State Prison. While serving
his sentence, Campbell requested to be housed next to Richard
“Cyco” Aguirre10 who was a Mexican Mafia member. Cyco
Aguirre was also an Avenues gang member.
Cyco Aguirre taught Campbell about Mexican Mafia
politics and its tax collecting operation with the Avenues. During
this time of 2001 or 2002, the Avenues’ tax collecting operation
was chaotic and divided with Alex “Pee Wee” Aguirre, Albert
10 The record refers to multiple persons with the last name
Aguirre. For example, Richard “Cyco” Aguirre is the uncle of
Richard “Lil Peewee” Aguirre. To avoid confusion and to be
consistent with the witness’ references to Richard “Cyco” Aguirre,
we refer to him as Cyco Aguirre.
14
“Boxer” Tolento,11 and Alfred “Tigre” Salinas12 running their own
operations. Boxer specifically collected from the Drew Street
area. Campbell testified that Cyco Aguirre became the director of
the entire tax collecting operation. He also learned that Tigre
was no longer a Mexican Mafia member and was an outcast in
the eyes of Cyco Aguirre, Pee Wee Aguirre, and Boxer.
Cyco Aguirre assigned Campbell to implement this new
structure on the streets. Campbell was instructed that anyone
opposing Cyco Aguirre’s tax collecting operation would be given
an opportunity to align with him or be eliminated. When
Campbell was about to be released from prison in 2004, Cyco
Aguirre gave him a “greenlight” list of people to be killed if they
opposed the reorganization. This list included Real, Carlos “Lil
Wolfie” Cortez, Salinas Jr., and Frank “Kiko” Cordova.
When released, Campbell contacted Carlos “Chopper”
Gonzalez13 who was dating Cyco Aguirre’s daughter. Chopper
was also operating the tax collecting operation for Cyco Aguirre.
A portion of the money collected was being funneled to the
Mexican Mafia. Cyco Aguirre further told Campbell to contact
his nephew Rudy Aguirre, also known as “Lil Rudy” or “Lil
11 To be consistent with the witnesses’ references, we refer to
Albert “Boxer” Tolento as Boxer.
12 Alfred “Tigre” Salinas and his son Alfred “Lil Tigre” Salinas
Jr. share the same first and last names. To avoid confusion, we
refer to the father as Tigre and to the son as Salinas Jr.
13 To be consistent with the witnesses’ references to Carlos
“Chopper” Gonzalez, we refer to him as Chopper.
15
Cyco.”14 Lil Rudy introduced Campbell to Escandon and Sam
“Fox” Vega. Escandon and Vega were to assist Campbell with the
tax collecting in the area for the Avenues gang and dealing with
those on the greenlight list, including Salinas Jr., Cordova, and
Real.
In 2004, Campbell tried to find Real. He received
information from Chopper and a woman named Ysela “Evil”
Castro, who was associated with Boxer. Specifically, they told
Campbell that Real was at his girlfriend’s house in Echo Park on
a street referred to as Teardrop. The name of the street is
Everett Street and circles a park known as Teardrop Park
because it is shaped like a teardrop. Campbell went to the
Teardrop location twice to try to find Real and kill him.
In 2004, Campbell was imprisoned for illegally possessing
body armor. While in custody, Escandon would write letters to
Campbell about the tax collecting operation. Cyco Aguirre
terminated Chopper from the operation in the Drew Street area
because a large sum of money was not being sent to him. Cyco
Aguirre assigned Campbell to find out what happened to his
missing money.
When released from prison in 2006, Campbell met with Lil
Rudy, Vega, and Escandon about the tax collecting operation.
Campbell was introduced to Neo “Nito” Perez at the meeting.
14 Cyco Aguirre was the uncle of Rudy Aguirre, who was also
known as Lil Cyco or Lil Rudy. At trial, the prosecutor’s exhibit
incorrectly referred to Lil Cyco as Richard Aguirre, not Rudy
Aguirre. To avoid confusion and to be consistent with the
witness’ references to Rudy Aguirre, we refer to him as Rudy
Aguirre or Lil Rudy.
16
On June 6, 2006, Campbell arranged to meet with Drew
Street members Niko, Clever, and “Nene” about organizing its
tax collecting operation. According to Campbell, the Drew Street
members were not paying money to the Mexican Mafia from their
tax collection. Along with Niko and Clever, Nene was also Real’s
brother.
According to Campbell, Niko and either Nene or Clever
arrived first in one car.15 They refused to get out of their car, so
Campbell removed the keys from the ignition. When they got out
of the car, Escandon frisked or put his arm around one of them.
Shots were fired from a high-powered rifle from a second car
down the street. One shot struck Campbell. Two days later,
Campbell met with other Drew Street members and ordered that
the Real family pay him $10,000 for the shooting.
Later in June, Campbell, Escandon, and their respective
girlfriends were at Dusty’s Bar to meet with Rigoberto Perez,.16
who was an Avenues member. Campbell knew Rigoberto because
he grew up on Drew Street. Rigoberto made certain that the Real
family would pay the $10,000 and brought the initial payment to
Campbell at Dusty’s Bar. Campbell and Escandon had also
assigned Rigoberto to collect money from the Drew Street area.
At Dusty’s Bar, Escandon admitted that he and Neo killed
Real. Campbell told Escandon that Cyco Aguirre wanted him
15 Campbell initially testified that Niko and Nene arrived
first and Clever shot him. He later testified that Niko and Clever
arrived and shots were fired from the car occupied by Nene.
16 Because Rigoberto Perez shares the same last name as Neo
Perez, we refer to each by his first name.
17
greenlighted because he killed Real in front of his sister’s house.
Campbell added that he convinced Cyco Aguirre to give Escandon
a “pass” because he was simply following the order to kill Real.
During the meeting, Escandon also talked about killing
Barajas Jr. Escandon revealed that during a party at his house,
he got into an argument with Barajas Jr. Escandon said he shot
Barajas Jr. and Salinas Jr. Rigoberto expressed concern about
the repercussions of killing Barajas Jr. Escandon moved out of
the area because others wanted to kill him in retaliation.
Campbell brought up how he and Chopper later shot and
killed Salinas Jr. Campbell revealed that he, Chopper, and
Herman Huitron went to speak with Salinas Jr. at his mother’s
home. They started shooting when they drove up to Salinas Jr.’s
car and saw him reach into the backseat. According to Campbell,
Escandon was present for the shooting.
Campbell testified that during a Fourth of July party,
Escandon again talked about killing Real and Barajas Jr.
Escandon held the party at his house in Pico Rivera. He told
Campbell that the Real killing did not occur in front of Cyco
Aguirre’s sister’s home. Escandon explained that he
intentionally fired away from the home. Escandon further
described how he lured Real outside. Chopper called Escandon to
inform him that Real was at the apartment building. Escandon
said that he originally called Fox to help him kill Real. But Fox
refused. Escandon enlisted Neo to help. According to Campbell,
Escandon said they were armed with a .45 caliber handgun and a
9-millimeter handgun. Apparently, Real was collecting tax
money for Javier “Gangster” Marquez, not Cyco Aguirre.
Escandon and Neo called Niko to instruct Real to provide them
18
with the money collected for Gangster. Escandon said that Niko
was the last person to whom Real spoke before he was killed.
In 2008, Campbell was indicted and arrested on federal
racketeering charges, along with other Avenues gang members
including Escandon and Neo. Campbell met with federal
prosecutors and revealed information he had about his
involvement with the gang’s criminal activity, including the tax
collecting operation.
During this time in custody, Escandon sent kites, or
handwritten messages, to Campbell. In two kites, written
months apart, Escandon again admitted to killing Real, which he
referred to as the “ ‘Teardrop thing.’ ”17 Campbell later provided
the kites to the federal authorities.
Campbell was ultimately sentenced to seven years on the
federal case. The federal government relocated Campbell when
he was released in 2014.
h. Rigoberto Perez
In the late 1980s, Rigoberto was jumped into the Avenues
gang when he was 13 or 14 years old. He began selling drugs and
gave a percentage of the money from his sales to Cyco Aguirre
17 In one kite, Escandon wrote, “The Teardrop thing, Carlos
said to do it, and if not[,] Peewee was going to greenlight us.”
The kite also stated, “me, Nito and Fox” and “he called [¶]
. . . ‘you know what you need to do, so do it.’ And we did it.”
Campbell testified that the kite originally named Neo as the
person who “did it” with Escandon, but Neo replaced his name
with Fox’s name. Neo also changed the kite to read that “Rudy,”
not Fox, was supposed to join Escandon.
In the second kite, Escandon stated, “me and Nito put that
to sleep,” referring to the Real killing.
19
who was the Mexican Mafia member in charge of the Avenues
gang.
Rigoberto testified that the Avenues gang territory was
divided into smaller areas, including the areas of Drew Street
and Highland Park. He became a shot caller for the Drew Street
area. He also ended up collecting taxes in the Drew Street area.
He further testified that he would turn over the money to
Escandon, Neo, and Campbell,18 who would pay him a portion for
his service. Rigoberto had frequent meetings with Escandon,
Neo, and Campbell to turn over money and discuss what was
going on and who owed money. 19
Rigoberto testified that Escandon personally told him about
his involvement in killing Real on at least two occasions: at
Dusty’s Bar and at a restaurant called La Fuente. The meeting
at Dusty’s bar occurred a few months after he began providing
tax money to Escandon, Neo, and Campbell. During this
conversation at Dusty’s Bar, Escandon told Rigoberto that he
shot Salinas Jr. and Barajas Jr. at his apartment on Arroyo
18 Rigoberto referred to Campbell by his moniker of Drifter.
19 Rigoberto testified that he, Gangster Marquez, and Real,
among others, were affiliated with the Drew Street area. He
further testified that Escandon, Neo, Campbell, Rudy Aguirre,
and a person named Stalker were affiliated with the Highland
Park area. According to Detective Castro, Stalker is Sam
Salinas. Because Sam Vega and Sam Salinas have the same first
name and Sam Salinas, Alfred “Tigre” Salinas, and Alfred
Salinas Jr. have the same last name, we refer to Sam Salinas as
Stalker.
20
Drive. Escandon also told Rigoberto that he and Neo killed Real
outside his girlfriend’s apartment. Rigoberto testified that Real
was in trouble with the Mexican Mafia because he was collecting
tax money for Gangster Marquez who lost his status as a
Mexican Mafia member. During the conversation, Escandon
provided additional details about how he made Real believe they
were going to collect money from him rather than Gangster
Marquez. When Escandon and Neo met Real, they shot him in
the head. Escandon also told Rigoberto that Vega was supposed
to help him kill Real. But Vega “chickened out,” making an
excuse that he had to babysit his daughter. Instead, Neo went
with Escandon. As a result of Neo’s participation in the Real
murder, he “went up the ranks” and earned tax collecting
privileges even though he was not an Avenues member.
During the meeting at La Fuente, Escandon and Neo told
Rigoberto again about their involvement in the Real murder.
This time, Escandon also revealed that he knew about Rigoberto
committing a murder.
In addition to telling Rigoberto about the Real murder,
Escandon also told him about how he was prohibited from
collecting in the Drew Street area. Rigoberto testified about
another meeting he had with Escandon, Neo, Rudy Aguirre, and
Stalker at his mother’s home. According to Rigoberto, because of
the Real murder, members from the Highland Park area
controlled by the Avenues could not go into the Drew Street area
and collect taxes. Escandon, Rudy Aguirre, and Campbell told
Rigoberto that he would be the shot caller because he was an
intermediary between both sides. Rigoberto testified that he was
to collect taxes and forward the money to them.
21
Rigoberto collected taxes for Drew Street until 2007 when
he was arrested for a firearm offense. At that point, he wanted
out of the gang because he no longer knew whom to trust.
B. Defense evidence
1. William Ramirez
William Ramirez was Escandon’s neighbor when he lived at
5745 Arroyo Drive. Ramirez knew Escandon for “maybe a couple
years” prior to January 14, 2003. At trial, he testified that he did
not know if Escandon was a gang member. Ramirez also denied
being an Avenues gang member, even though he admitted to
posing in photographs throwing gang signs and had an “L.A.”
tattoo.
Ramirez testified that he was present at the apartment
when the shooting occurred outside. He initially testified that he
was “in the parking lot, in front of [his] house” and “everywhere.”
At about 12:00 p.m. or 1:00 p.m., he was drinking beer with about
ten others. Ramirez testified that Escandon “was there probably
the entire day before he left.” He saw Escandon leave with a man
who drove an SUV. Ramirez did not “know where they went, to
get more beer, food.”
Ramirez was inside arguing with his mother, Sandra
Ramirez, when the shooting occurred. He had been arguing
inside for four or five minutes when he heard gunfire outside.
Ramirez did not see the shooting. He could not see outside
because the blinds were closed. He did not see anyone fighting or
anyone with a bat chasing people prior to the shooting.
Ramirez went outside after he heard the shooting. When
Ramirez walked outside after the shooting, he did not see
Escandon. Ramirez’s mother and Cuevas came outside after
22
Ramirez had been outside for two to three minutes. Ramirez did
not see Escandon point a gun at Cuevas or grab his mother and
push her against a wall. He did not see anyone with a gun. He
saw Barajas Jr. on the ground. Ramirez knew him as Baby
Stretch. After Ramirez went outside, he ran by himself to Arroyo
Seco Park which is nearby.
Since January 14, 2003, Escandon called Ramirez collect
one time a few years ago, and continued to call him once in “a
blue moon.”
2. Jasmine Villalobos
Jasmine Villalobos was Escandon’s girlfriend. She had
known him for 24 years. She testified that they have two
children. She believed Escandon to be an Avenues gang member.
On January 14, 2003, they had been living at 5745 Arroyo
Drive for about six or seven years. Villalobos knew her neighbors
Sandra Ramirez and “Ollie.”20 Escandon’s parents were
neighbors on the other side of Villalobos’s apartment with
Escandon. Villalobos’s sister lived in the unit above. Cassandra
Schroeder lived next to Villalobos’s sister.
Villalobos was not present during the shooting on January
14, 2003. When she was leaving for work, Escandon was also
about to leave to meet a friend named Adan Tejeda.
Villalobos denied ever going to Dusty’s Bar with either
James Campbell or Rigoberto Perez. When shown the kites to
Campbell, which were introduced as prosecution evidence,
Villalobos denied that the handwriting was Escandon’s.
20 Olivier Cuevas was previously referred to as Ollie. Her
name is also spelled Olly in the record.
23
Villalobos testified that she went to Pelican Bay with
Escandon, Neo, and Neo’s girlfriend Raquel to meet Cyco Aguirre.
According to Villalobos, she met with Cyco Aguirre because
Campbell had taxed her $30,000 because Escandon owed him.
She wanted to see if Cyco Aguirre could do anything about the
taxing. Ultimately, Villalobos gave her car to Campbell.
In October 2016, Villalobos testified at the preliminary
hearing that she went to meet with Cyco Aguirre on January 27,
2007. Villalobos testified at the preliminary hearing that she felt
that she did not have a choice. Escandon had instructed her to
go. He wanted Villalobos to tell Cyco Aguirre that “everything
was fine” and “he sends his love.”
II. Procedure
On November 21, 2019, a jury convicted Escandon of first
degree murder of Barajas Jr. (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a)21; count
1), attempted premeditated murder of Salinas Jr. (§§ 187, subd.
(a), 664, subd. (a); count 2), and first degree murder of Real (§
187, subd. (a); count 4). As to count 1 and count 4, the jury found
special circumstances true for multiple murder (§ 190.2, subd.
(a)(3)) and gang murder (§ 190.2, subd. (a)(22)). As to counts 1, 2,
and 4, the jury found the firearm allegations true for personal
use, discharge, and discharge causing great bodily injury or death
(§ 12022.53, subds. (b), (c), (d)). The jury also found the gang
allegation (§ 186.22, subd. (b)(1)) true for counts 1, 2, and 4. The
jury acquitted Escandon of attempted murder of Cuevas (§§ 187,
subd. (a), 664, subd. (a); count 3).
21 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Penal Code.
24
On May 26, 2023, the trial court sentenced Escandon to
consecutive terms of life without the possibility of parole for each
first degree murder with the special circumstances in count 1 and
count 4. The court imposed a consecutive term of seven years to
life on the attempted premeditated murder in count 2. On each
count, the court imposed an additional term of 25 years to life for
the firearm enhancement under section 12022.53, subdivision (d).
DISCUSSION
I. Detective Castro’s expert interpretation of the
recorded calls
Escandon argues that the trial court abused its discretion
by admitting recordings of three of his calls with Neo and
Detective Arthur Castro’s interpretation of the statements they
made. We disagree.
A. Detective Castro’s expert qualifications
At trial, LAPD Detective Arthur Castro testified as a gang
expert for the prosecution. At the time of the trial, he had been
working with LAPD for almost 23 years. He was assigned to
LAPD’s Northeast Division gang enforcement detail from 2000 to
2007. As a gang officer, Detective Castro would assist detectives
with solving crimes, prevent crime during patrol, make arrests,
and gather intelligence by speaking with gang members and their
family members and members of the community, including
homeowners and business owners. He specifically collected
intelligence on the Avenues gang.
In November of 2007, Detective Castro participated in a
task force which investigated Avenues gang members. He was
assigned to an investigation called Operation Black Hand. His
role was to assemble the case, gather necessary documents, and
25
review video recordings. At the same time, Detective Castro also
prepared a case for indictment against a Mexican Mafia member
named George Bustamante, with whom some Avenues members
associated.
In the beginning of 2008, six months to a year after joining
the task force, Detective Castro listened to a few thousand
recorded calls between Avenues gang members and others.
Detective Castro’s knowledge of most of the players in the
Avenues gang assisted him in reviewing the calls. During this
time, active wiretaps recorded calls between Escandon and Neo.
Detective Castro became more familiar with them from these
calls. He also conducted surveillance of Escandon and Neo.
For six or seven months in 2016, Detective Castro was
temporarily assigned to LAPD’s Robbery Homicide Division to
review nearly 20,000 recorded calls. These calls were connected
to Escandon and Neo.
Detective Castro had contacts with other Avenues members
who were referenced in the calls, including Stalker, Vega,
Rigoberto, Real, Salinas Jr., Barajas Jr.22, Niko, and William
Ramirez. Senior gang officers at the Northeast Division also
informed Detective Castro about other Avenues members
including Gangster Marquez, Tigre, and Cordova. Detective
Castro testified that several of these Avenues members were
22 The prosecutor referred to this person as Barajas with the
moniker of Stretch. Because Detective Castro confirmed that this
person was killed in 2003, they must have been referring to
Frank Barajas, Jr., whose moniker was Lil Stretch, rather than
his father Frank Barajas whose moniker was Stretch. Barajas
Jr. is the decedent in count 1.
26
ultimately killed, including Real, Barajas Jr., Cordova, and
Salinas Jr.
Detective Castro testified that he interviewed Rigoberto in
October 2007.23 Rigoberto informed him about the political
structure of the Avenues gang and its affiliation with the
Mexican Mafia.
During Detective Castro’s review of the calls, he learned
about the tax collecting operation of the Avenues. He testified
that Escandon was part of the tax collecting operation specifically
associated with Cyco Aguirre, who was a member of the Avenues
and the Mexican Mafia. Detective Castro learned that Rigoberto,
Stalker, Vega, and a person named Herman Huitron were also
involved in tax collection for the Avenues gang.
Detective Castro also reviewed video and audio recorded
visits at Pelican Bay state prison, where most of the “shot callers”
for the Mexican Mafia were imprisoned. These included visits to
Cyco Aguirre.
B. The calls
The prosecutor played three calls between Escandon and
Neo for the jury and elicited testimony from Detective Castro
about them. The calls were placed by Escandon on October 4,
2007, January 18, 2007, and February 26, 2007.
1. The call from October 4, 2007
During the jail call from October 4, 2007, Escandon and
Neo referred to a man as “Fireball.” Detective Castro testified
23 Detective Castro originally testified that the interview with
Rigoberto was in October 2000 but then stated it was October
2007.
27
that he had heard the name Fireball in other calls between
Escandon and Neo and others. Based on the references in these
other calls, he identified Fireball as Vega. Prior to testifying
about the jail call, Detective Castro mentioned that he previously
had contact with Vega and knew him to be an Avenues member
with the moniker of Fox.
In the October 4, 2007 call, Neo stated that according to
“Bad Boy,” Stalker was with Fireball at the Glendale Galleria,
even though he was instructed not to associate with him.
Detective Castro knew Stalker to be an Avenues member named
Sam Salinas. Detective Castro identified Bad Boy as Gonzalo
Pineda, a shot caller for the Assassins clique of the Avenues
gang. According to Detective Castro, Bad Boy had a girlfriend
who worked at the Glendale Galleria. Bad Boy’s girlfriend called
him from the Glendale Galleria, and he spoke to Stalker and
Fireball, confirming they were together. At multiple points
during the call, Neo recounted the conversation that Bad Boy had
with Fireball. When asked about Escandon and Neo, Fireball
said he no longer talked to either. Neo told Escandon that he
later talked to Stalker and confronted him about being with
Fireball.24
During the call, Neo described a tattoo of “Melissa” on the
head of the man who went to the Glendale Galleria. Detective
Castro testified that he knew Vega’s girlfriend to be named
Melissa, corroborating Fireball was Vega.
24 When Neo discussed Bad Boy’s conversation with Fireball,
he referred to “Locs” and “Nito.” Detective Castro testified that
“Locs” is short for “Lokito,” which is Escandon’s moniker. “Nito”
is Neo.
28
Neo also told Escandon that Fireball said, “fuck the
construction.” Detective Castro explained that the Mexican
Mafia members and their associates used code words. The term
“construction” referred to the Avenues gang’s tax collecting
operation. Neo described how Fireball was not aligned with the
Avenues tax collecting operation led by Cyco Aguirre. According
to Detective Castro, Neo also criticized Fireball for spending time
with his girlfriend instead of participating in their tax collecting
operation.
Detective Castro testified that Escandon and Vega were
arrested on March 23, 2005 for the Real murder. According to
Detective Castro, later in the call, Neo mocked Fireball for
complaining about time he spent in custody for the Real murder.
During this portion of the call, Escandon also told Neo, “Fireball’s
going to be back here.” Detective Castro testified that Escandon
was telling Neo that Fireball would eventually return to working
in their tax collecting operation under Cyco Aguirre’s faction of
the Mexican Mafia.
During the call, Escandon and Neo also referred to a person
known as “White Boy.” Detective Castro testified that “White
Boy” was Campbell. He knew Campbell to be an Avenues
member who was Caucasian.
2. The call from January 18, 200725
During a call intercepted by a wiretap on January 18, 2007,
Escandon and Neo discussed a person they referred to as “Cock
Nose” or “Cock Breath,” who was involved in the tax collecting
25 Both counsel stipulated that the call was from January 18,
2007.
29
operation under Cyco Aguirre. Detective Castro testified that
this person was Herman Huitron.26 During the call, Escandon
stated that Huitron suffered a “pay deduction” by Chopper, who
Detective Castro identified as Carlos Gonzalez. Chopper also
participated in the tax collecting operation. According to
Detective Castro, Escandon and Neo talked about how Huitron
did not collect all the tax collection money owed to the Avenues
gang as ordered.
Detective Castro testified that Chopper lived on Toland
Way and dated a member of the Aguirre family who lived at the
address next to where Real was killed. 27 Detective Castro
testified that Escandon and Neo used the term “Teardrop” to
refer to Real’s murder.28 Detective Castro testified that Real
26 According to Detective Castro, in other calls, Escandon and
Neo had referred to him as “Mouth” and “Yuckmouth,” and
described him as having bad breath.
27 According to Campbell, Chopper was dating the daughter of
Cyco Aguirre’s sister, and he was working for Cyco Aguirre.
28 In the call on January 18, 2007, Escandon recounted, “I
don’t know, but he was sad, dog. I’m sad, dog. Teardrop. I’m
sad.” The record is unclear whether Escandon’s use of the term
“teardrop” during this part of the conversation referred to
Huitron’s grief over his brother’s death or the Real murder, as
suggested by Detective Castro. Earlier in the conversation,
Escandon and Neo were talking about Huitron lamenting over
the death of his brother. Neo first mentioned Huitron’s brother’s
death when he stated, “He—that fool—hey, remember that one
time, ‘That was my brother, ah.’ And they were clocking that
fool? It was like the same day his fucken brother died, fool.”
Escandon later added, “Remember, fucken, Chops, fool, he fucken
was gonna give him a pay deduction because he didn’t go,
30
lived on Everett Street, north of Sunset. He also testified that
Neo and Escandon referred to the Real murder as Teardrop in
other calls.
3. The call from February 26, 2007
Detective Castro testified that during the call from
February 26, 2007, Escandon told Neo about a conversation he
had with Vega. According to Detective Castro, Escandon
discussed with Neo how he had told Vega about an Avenues
member named “Creeper” who did not get along with Rigoberto.
Both Creeper and Rigoberto participated in the tax collecting
operation. Escandon appeared to have described how Vega
complained about Creeper and contrasted him to Neo, who was
not even an Avenues member,29 but still supported Cyco Aguirre.
Detective Castro explained that members from gangs outside of
the area would frequently join a Mexican Mafia tax collecting
operation.
Detective Castro testified that in the call, Neo and
Escandon paid homage to Cyco Aguirre, while complaining about
Vega. Specifically, they complained about Vega’s commitment to
his girlfriend over the tax collecting operation.
Detective Castro testified that Neo also discussed the Real
murder. Specifically, Neo stated, “Teardrop, dog,” and recounted
because it was his brother’s funeral or something?” Neo also
noted, “It’s almost the fucken anniversary, huh?” Detective
Castro agreed that they were talking about Huitron and his
brother. Detective Castro did not know who Huitron’s brother
was. The record is unclear whether Huitron was referring to a
biological brother or a close friend.
29 Neo was a member of the Compton Tortilla Flats gang.
31
how he was with his family when Escandon called him “to come
do that” and he left his family “to go do it.” Neo further stated
that everybody was busy so he “handled it.” According to
Detective Castro, Neo was “representing Cyco Aguirre on the
street and showing his loyalty by answering the call, so to speak,
and going and handling business,” even though he was not a
member of the Avenues gang. Detective Castro further testified
that Neo complained that he and Escandon did not get anything
from killing Real. Detective Castro testified that Neo was upset
that he did not get credit from members of Cyco Aguirre’s faction
for helping Escandon in murdering Real, and Escandon got
arrested.
C. Trial court’s gatekeeping of Detective Castro’s
opinions
In Escandon’s challenge to the admission of the three calls,
he highlights three of Detective Castro’s opinions of statements
made by Escandon and Neo. First, Detective Castro identified
Fireball as Vega. Second, he determined that the term
“Teardrop” referred to the Real murder. Third, he understood
Neo’s story about answering Escandon’s call as joining Escandon
in killing Real. Escandon asserts that the trial court should have
excluded Detective Castro’s interpretations of these statements
as a part of its “ ‘gatekeeping’ responsibility” under Sargon
Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55
Cal.4th 747, 769 (Sargon).
“The trial court has broad discretion in deciding whether to
admit or exclude expert testimony.” (People v. McDowell (2012)
54 Cal.4th 395, 426; People v. Corbi (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 25,
35.) We review the trial court’s admission of evidence, including
expert opinion evidence, for abuse of discretion. (People v.
32
Alvarez (1996) 14 Cal.4th 155, 201; People v. Caitlin (2001) 26
Cal.4th 81, 131.) The trial court’s admission of evidence is an
abuse of discretion if it is “ ‘so irrational or arbitrary that no
reasonable person could agree with it.’ ” (Sargon, supra, 55
Cal.4th at p. 773.)
In Sargon, the Supreme Court charged trial courts with a
gatekeeping duty to exclude expert opinion testimony “that is (1)
based on matter of a type on which an expert may not reasonably
rely, (2) based on reasons unsupported by the material on which
the expert relies, or (3) speculative.” 30 (Sargon, supra, 55 Cal.4th
at pp. 771–772.)
At the outset, we cannot summarily discount Detective
Castro’s experience and the matter on which he relied. He was a
30 In fashioning these factors, the Supreme Court drew from
Evidence Code section 801 which limits expert opinion to an
opinion that “is: [¶] (a) Related to a subject that is sufficiently
beyond common experience that the opinion of an expert would
assist the trier of fact; and [¶] (b) Based on matter (including his
special knowledge, skill, experience, training, and education)
. . . that is of a type that reasonably may be relied upon by an
expert in forming an opinion upon the subject to which his
testimony relates, unless an expert is precluded by law from
using such matter as a basis for his opinion.” The Court
determined that “under Evidence Code section 801, the trial court
acts as a gatekeeper to exclude speculative or irrelevant expert
opinion.” (Sargon, supra, 55 Cal.4th at p. 770.) Sargon also
considered “Evidence Code section 802, [which] provides: ‘A
witness testifying in the form of an opinion may state . . . the
reasons for his opinion and the matter . . . upon which it is
based.” (Id., at p. 771.) “Evidence Code section 801 governs
judicial review of the type of matter; Evidence Code section 802
governs judicial review of the reasons for the opinion.” (Ibid.)
33
23-year veteran police officer, specifically monitoring the Avenues
gang while assigned to the gang enforcement detail.
Significantly, he reviewed nearly 20,000 calls generated by its
members, including Escandon. Detective Castro also had
personal contacts with many of them, again, including Escandon.
Additionally, he reviewed recordings of prison visits to Cyco
Aguirre and other Mexican Mafia members. Detective Castro’s
“special knowledge and experience” about the Avenues gang and
its members’ conversations with one another provided a sufficient
basis under Evidence Code section 801, subdivision (b) to
interpret the calls, including the three challenged portions. Any
gang expert would reasonably rely on such recorded calls between
gang members to form opinions about references they made and
terms they used as code for gang activity.
The trial court fulfilled its gatekeeping duty under Sargon.
It did not admit every opinion formed by Detective Castro that he
generically based on his review of the recorded calls alone. For
example, the trial court struck Detective Castro’s testimony that
in the first call, Neo was referring to the Real murder when he
stated, “[I]t’s already been a known fact from before, homie. And
you know what I’m talking about.” The court reasoned, “I know
he’s an expert. He’s allowed to tell us what gang slang means.
He’s allowed to offer an opinion. But he’s not allowed to make
straw into gold, meaning he’s not allowed to take three lines that
are completely incomprehensible and say they mean
this . . . because I listened to 20,000 other conversations. That he
can’t do.” The court demonstrated its understanding of Sargon’s
reference to an unacceptable “ ‘analytical gap between the data
and the opinion proffered.’ [Citation.]” (Sargon, supra, 55
Cal.4th at p. 771.)
34
This example of speculative opinion testimony starkly
contrasts with Detective Castro’s opinion that Escandon and Neo
interchangeably used the nicknames of Fireball and Fox for Vega.
Other portions of the admitted calls supported this opinion, as
Detective Castro testified.
First, in the October 4, 2007 call, Escandon and Neo
referred to the story about Fireball spending time with his
girlfriend instead of fulfilling his gang duties. In the February
26, 2007 call, they described how Fox did the same.
Second, in the October 4, 2007 call, Neo recounted how
Fireball complained about spending time in custody. According
to Detective Castro, Fireball’s time in custody aligned with the
time that Vega and Escandon spent in custody for the Real
murder.31
Third, in the October 4, 2007 call, Neo told a story about
Stalker’s critical association with Fireball at the Glendale
Galleria. In the February 26, 2007 call, Escandon described how
he questioned Fox about Stalker, and Fox denounced any
association with him. Fox’s distancing himself from Stalker was
consistent with the story mentioned in the first call.
Fourth, during the October 4, 2007 call, Neo described a
tattoo of “Melissa” on Fireball’s head when he discussed the story
of Fireball and Stalker going to the Glendale Galleria. Detective
Castro testified that he knew Vega’s girlfriend to be named
31 The parties stipulated that on March 25, 2005, the Los
Angeles County District Attorney filed one count of murder
against Escandon and Vega for killing Real and announced the
prosecution would not proceed on August 9, 2005.
35
Melissa. The totality of these references supported Detective
Castro’s opinion that Fireball and Fox both referred to Vega.
Portions of the February 26, 2007 call also reasonably
allowed Detective Castro to opine that Neo referred to killing
Real with Escandon in his story about Escandon calling him. As
we stated earlier, during the call, Neo complained about how he
did not receive credit for participating in the killing when Fox
declined to participate. Additionally, Neo used the term
“Teardrop” during this call, after he and Escandon used the term
in the January 18, 2007 call. From the context of Neo’s reference
to Teardrop, Detective Castro opined that it referred to the Real
murder. Because other portions of the admitted calls supported
Detective Castro’s opinions about the name Fireball, the term
Teardrop, and Neo’s story of answering Escandon’s call, we
conclude that the trial court acted within its discretion in
determining they were not unsupported nor based on improper
speculation.
D. Relevance of the calls
Escandon further appears to argue that had the trial court
excluded Detective Castro’s interpretations, the calls would have
been irrelevant because they “could not be understood to have
anything to do with the charged offenses.” We reject Escandon’s
contention. Because we conclude that adequate foundation
supported Detective Castro’s expert testimony, we further
conclude the calls were relevant in that they implicated Escandon
in the Real murder.
The October 4, 2007 call revealed Escandon’s and Neo’s
loyalty to Cyco Aguirre, who ordered the killing of Real for
improperly funneling his tax collection money to Gangster
Marquez. This call also included Escandon’s and Neo’s
36
involvement in Cyco Aguirre’s tax collecting operation and
knowledge of Campbell, who ultimately communicated the order
to kill Real. In the January 18, 2007 call, Escandon and Neo
used the term Teardrop, which was code for the Real murder.
The February 26, 2007 call included Neo’s and Escandon’s
complaints about Vega declining to participate in the Real
murder. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting
these calls as relevant to establish Escandon’s identity as one of
the participants in the Real murder, and his motive and intent to
kill Real by following Cyco Aguirre’s order. (People v. Heard
(2003) 31 Cal.4th 946, 973.)
E. Any assumed error was harmless
Even if we assume that the trial court erroneously
admitted the calls and Detective Castro’s interpretations, we
conclude any error was harmless under the standard articulated
in People v. Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, 836 (Watson) and
People v. Prieto (2003) 30 Cal.4th 226, 247. Under the Watson
standard, we must reverse when it is reasonably probable that
the jury would have reached a result more favorable to Escandon
absent the error. (Watson, at p. 836.) Even if the trial court
excluded the entirety of the three calls and Detective Castro had
not opined on the three challenged portions or any other portion
that was admitted, we cannot conclude that it is reasonably
probable that Escandon would have achieved a more favorable
outcome in this case.
First, the jury did not blindly adopt Detective Castro’s
opinions. The trial court instructed the jury that it was “not
bound by” any expert opinion, must give each opinion the weight
it deserves, and was free to disregard any unreasonable opinion.
(CALJIC No. 2.80.) We presume the jury understood and
37
followed this instruction. (People v. McKinnon (2011) 52 Cal.4th
610, 670 (McKinnon).) Nothing rebuts this presumption. Second,
other evidence confirmed Detective Castro’s interpretations of the
portions of the calls. Rigoberto and Campbell testified that while
at Dusty’s Bar, Escandon told them that Neo helped him kill Real
and further confirmed that Vega declined when asked to
participate in the killing. Campbell testified that Real lived on a
street known as Teardrop because it circled around a park in the
shape of a teardrop. The Real murder reasonably adopted the
Teardrop name from the street’s nickname. Campbell also
testified about kites from Escandon that included his admission
to killing Real and references to the murder as Teardrop.
Third, overwhelming evidence established Escandon’s guilt
for the Real murder.32 In addition to Escandon’s admission to
Rigoberto and Campbell at Dusty’s Bar and his kites to Campbell
while in custody, he also admitted to Campbell at a Fourth of
July party. Escandon included details of how he tried to avoid
shooting at the Aguirre family’s home when he shot Real, and
after Vega declined to help, he and Neo obtained .45 caliber and
9-millimeter handguns. The police found casings in the same
calibers near Real’s body.
32 We further reject Escandon’s assertion that the jury “felt
this was a close case” based on the eight days of the jury’s
deliberations. The jury deliberated eight days for the entire case,
which included consideration of the Real murder, the Barajas Jr.
murder, the attempted murder of Salinas Jr., the attempted
murder of Cuevas, and the multiple enhancements, allegations,
and special circumstances. The jury never indicated that it was
deadlocked on Escandon’s guilt for the Real murder.
38
Escandon argues that Campbell and Rigoberto lacked
credibility because they had an incentive to testify favorably for
the District Attorney to obtain leniency with other prosecutions.33
But each was also “marked for death” by their gang for
cooperating with law enforcement. The jury could have found
them more credible because of this harsher consequence for
testifying. Their credibility was bolstered by corroborating
evidence, such as Real identifying the caller with Escandon’s
moniker Lokito, the eyewitness identification of Escandon as the
shooter by Griselda Alvarez, and the two different calibers of
casings found at the scene as matching the calibers of firearms
about which Escandon told Campbell.
F. No due process violation
Escandon further asserts that the admission of the calls
and Detective Castro’s interpretation of them violated his federal
constitutional right to due process. The admission of evidence in
violation of California law will only be found to violate due
process if the error rendered a defendant’s trial fundamentally
unfair. (People v. Merriman (2014) 60 Cal.4th 1, 70.) We cannot
conclude that admitting the calls and Detective Castro’s
interpretation of them rendered Escandon’s trial fundamentally
unfair because the same information was admitted through other
sources, as we discussed.34
33 Campbell was indicted on federal racketeering charges and
ultimately cooperated with the federal prosecutors. Rigoberto
testified under a grant of immunity and acknowledged that he
had not been prosecuted for a murder he committed.
34 We also reject Escandon’s conclusory argument that
Detective Castro implied there was “incriminating extrajudicial
39
II. Statements introduced through Rigoberto Perez
and James Campbell
Escandon argues that the trial court abused its discretion
by admitting statements from the testimony of Rigoberto and
Campbell that implicated him in the Real murder. Specifically,
he challenges the admission of Rigoberto’s testimony that
Escandon and Neo did not directly control the Drew Street
territory “[b]ecause they had killed [Real].” He also challenges
Campbell’s testimony about statements made by Cyco Aguirre.
Escandon reasons that no foundation was laid for either
statement, and both statements were irrelevant to any issue in
the case. He additionally asserts that one layer of statements in
Campbell’s testimony was inadmissible hearsay. We reject
Escandon’s arguments.
A. Admissibility of the statements to Rigoberto
Escandon challenges the admission of Rigoberto’s
testimony that he turned over money to Escandon and Neo
because they were not in control of Drew Street as a result of
killing Real. He asserts Rigoberto did not have the requisite
personal knowledge to testify to this statement. Escandon
suggests that Rigoberto must have learned the information from
an unidentified third-party source. Escandon is wrong.
Rigoberto’s testimony directly refutes Escandon’s
suggestion on appeal that an unidentified third party provided
the information for the challenged statement. Escandon, not an
evidence” in the calls that violated his Sixth Amendment rights
to confrontation and to a jury trial because portions of the
admitted calls supported his interpretations.
40
unidentified third party, provided Rigoberto with the requisite
personal knowledge that the reason for funneling tax-collected
money to Escandon and the others was because they were not in
control of Drew Street as a result of killing Real. (Evid. Code, §
702, subd. (a); People v. Cortez (2016) 63 Cal.4th 101, 123
(Cortez).) A rational trier of fact could find that Rigoberto
accurately perceived and recollected his conversation with
Escandon who told him about the requisite information. (Cortez,
at p. 124; People v. Flinner (2020) 10 Cal.5th 686, 741 (Flinner).)
It was up to “ ‘ “the jury to decide whether [Rigoberto’s]
perceptions and recollections [were] credible.” ’ [Citation.]”
(People v. Johnson (2018) 6 Cal.5th 541, 583.) We conclude that
the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting this
portion of Rigoberto’s testimony because he had the requisite
personal knowledge from Escandon’s admissions. (People v.
Lucas (1995) 12 Cal.4th 415, 466 [“[t]he decision whether the
foundational evidence is sufficiently substantial is a matter
within the court’s discretion”].)
The trial court admitted the statement from Rigoberto’s
testimony as non-hearsay to explain “why [Rigoberto] does
certain things and his relationship with [Escandon] and [Neo].”35
Without sufficient elaboration, Escandon also argues that the
statement was “not relevant to explain why Rigoberto gave the
35 After overruling an objection by defense counsel, the trial
court told the jury, “I am going to, over the objection, allow it in,
but it’s not for the truth of the matter. And obviously that’s, you
know, one of the things you’re going to decide in this case. So
clearly it’s not for the truth of the matter, but it’s to explain why
he does certain things and his relationship with [Escandon] and
[Neo.]”
41
taxes he collected to [him],” nor was it relevant to “shed any light
on” their relationship. We reject Escandon’s arguments.
At the outset, since Escandon made the statement, it
qualifies as a party admission, which is an exception to the
hearsay rule that would allow its admissibility for the truth of
the matter asserted. (Evid. Code, § 1220.)
The non-hearsay purpose of the statement was to explain
why Rigoberto “funneled ‘thousands of dollars’ in Drew Street
taxes to [Escandon] on behalf of the Mexican Mafia.” Because
Escandon and Neo killed Real, who was a Drew Street member,
they were prohibited from collecting taxes from the Drew Street
area. Because of this prohibition against Escandon and Neo, they
had to use Rigoberto to collect the tax money for them.
In Escandon’s reply brief, he elaborates that Rigoberto’s
testimony was offered to prove the truth of the assertion that
Escandon “could not collect taxes [from] Drew Street because he
killed Real.” Escandon appears to further argue that if this is the
relevance of the statement, then the statement is inadmissible
hearsay. Escandon states that the Attorney General asserts that
the relevance of the statement was to “prove why Escandon could
no longer collect taxes.” But he oversimplifies the Attorney
General’s assertion.
In his brief, the Attorney General states, “Rigoberto’s
statement explained why, despite this status, appellant could not
collect directly from Drew Street and why Rigoberto became the
Drew Street shot caller who funneled ‘thousands of dollars’ in
Drew Street taxes to [Escandon] on behalf of the Mexican Mafia.”
The statement contained information about the prohibition of
Escandon collecting taxes from Drew Street and the reason for
the prohibition. This statement prompted Rigoberto to accept the
42
role of shot caller for Drew Street and funnel the tax money to
Escandon. The statement was relevant to show why Rigoberto
gave the tax money to Escandon and Neo, as opposed to
Escandon personally collecting it. Escandon focuses only on the
latter portion. We conclude the statement supported the non-
hearsay purpose of the effect on Rigoberto as the listener and to
explain his subsequent conduct. (Evid. Code, § 1250; People v.
Clark (2016) 63 Cal.4th 522, 562.)
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the
challenged portion of Rigoberto’s testimony. (Flinner, supra, 10
Cal.5th at p. 740; People v. Cowan (2010) 50 Cal.4th 401, 483;
People v. Waidla (2000) 22 Cal.4th 690, 725.)
B. Admissibility of Campbell’s testimony about
Cyco Aguirre wanting to kill Escandon
Escandon challenges the admission of Campbell’s
testimony that Cyco Aguirre told him that he wanted to kill
Escandon for shooting Real in front of his sister’s home.36
Escandon argues that the statements were inadmissible because
Cyco Aguirre had no personal knowledge of Real’s murder and
his statements to Campbell were hearsay.
36 Campbell testified, “Lokito at the time was bringing up the
fact that he killed Lil Demon. Him and Nito killed Lil Demon.
They were—at the that time there was concern that Cyco wanted
him greenlighted because he killed him in front of his sister’s
house, and I had this conversation personally with Cyco about
him ordering Lokito killed for doing that, and I mean I just—how
are you going to kill someone for doing what you want them to do
in the first place. So at that time he let Lokito have a pass.”
43
The trial court admonished the jury that Cyco Aguirre’s
statements were not offered for their truth “because obviously
that person making [those statements] was not present when
anything happened along those lines, but [they] came in for the
impact the words had on this person who is being told that
information, and the subsequent conversations that occurred as a
result of that.”
Escandon argues that Campbell’s testimony “lacked
foundation because it was not established how Campbell knew
that Aguirre obtained [the] news [of Escandon committing the
Real murder].” Escandon is unclear about whether he is
challenging how Campbell knew Cyco Aguirre obtained the news
or how Cyco Aguirre obtained the news. Campbell testified that
he knew that Cyco Aguirre obtained the news about Escandon
committing the murder because Cyco Aguirre told him. But the
record does not indicate how Cyco Aguirre obtained the news.
The personal knowledge requirement extends to statements
of hearsay declarants. (Cortez, supra, 63 Cal.4th at pp. 123–124.)
Escandon relies on the rule that the proponent of a hearsay
statement must show that the hearsay declarant has personal
knowledge of his statement when it is admitted for its truth.
(People v. Valencia (2006) 146 Cal.App.4th 92, 103–104
[inadmissible testimony about a statement by a declarant offered
for its truth that defendant molested her for more than three
months to prove element of continuous sexual abuse]; Cortez, at
pp. 123–124 [ample evidence from which a rational trier of fact
could conclude hearsay declarant had personal knowledge of the
admissible hearsay statements suggesting defendant knew of and
went along with a plan to commit a shooting].)
44
We can dismiss Escandon’s challenge because the
statement was not admitted for its truth. Cyco Aguirre’s
statement was admitted as non-hearsay to explain its effect on
Campbell and on Escandon. Campbell first testified about
hearing the statement from Cyco Aguirre to explain why
Escandon told him about the Real murder. Campbell then
testified that he later told Escandon about Cyco Aguirre’s
statement to mitigate his concern about being executed.
Campbell had personal knowledge that Cyco Aguirre made the
statement because it was made during a conversation between
the two. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in
determining the statement was relevant, non-hearsay, and
supported by sufficient foundation.
C. Any assumed error was harmless
Even assuming the trial court erred in admitting the
statements through Rigoberto’s or Campbell’s testimony, any
error was harmless under any standard.37 (Chapman v.
California (1967) 386 U.S. 18, 24 [reversal required under federal
standard if the prosecution cannot show beyond a reasonable
doubt that the error did not contribute to the verdict]; Watson,
supra, 46 Cal.2d at p. 836 [requiring reversal only if the
defendant can show it is reasonably probable the jury would have
reached a different result but for the error].)
37 “[G]enerally, violations of state evidentiary rules do not rise
to the level of federal constitutional error.” (People v. Benavides
(2005) 35 Cal.4th 69, 91.) Any error did not violate the Due
Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment or otherwise result
in an unfair trial.
45
As stated, overwhelming evidence implicated Escandon in
the Real murder, including his admissions to both Rigoberto and
Campbell. Additionally, after each witness testified to the
respective challenged statement, the trial court admonished the
jury to not consider it for its truth, but for non-hearsay purposes.
The trial court also instructed the jury to consider the testimony
only for its admitted purposes (CALJIC No. 2.09) and to assess
the credibility of the witnesses based on their ability to perceive
the subject matter of their testimony (CALJIC No. 2.81). No
evidence rebuts the presumption that the jury followed the
court’s instructions. (McKinnon, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 670.)
III. Instruction on alibi
Escandon argues that the trial court should have read the
instruction on alibi (CALJIC No. 4.50) because there was
substantial evidence that he was not present during the
shootings of Barajas Jr. and Salinas Jr.
A. Additional facts
The defense called William Ramirez as a witness. He
testified that he was Escandon’s neighbor at the Arroyo Drive
apartment when Barajas Jr. and Salinas Jr. were shot. He was
inside his unit when he heard shots fired. When Ramirez went
outside, he did not see Escandon.
After Ramirez testified, the trial court said it would
consider reading an alibi instruction to the jury. Escandon’s
counsel confirmed that he was requesting the instruction. The
court ultimately concluded that substantial evidence did not
support an alibi. The court highlighted that the evidence did not
establish when Ramirez was present to observe the shooting or
who fired the shots. Specifically, the court stated, “He’s at least
46
not there at least five or more minutes before the murder, he’s
not there at least five minutes after the murder, he’s not there
during the murder itself.” The court added that Ramirez was
unclear about when Escandon left the scene. Ramirez testified
that he was with Escandon all afternoon. But Ramirez did not
provide any time frame as to when he left. Ramirez did not say
where he went nor what he did when he left.
B. No substantial evidence to instruct on alibi
Escandon argues that the trial court erred in refusing to
instruct the jury on alibi based on William Ramirez’s testimony
that he did not see Escandon outside after the shots were fired.
Escandon elaborates that the instruction would have informed
the jurors that the defense introduced evidence to show he was
not present at the time and place of the commission of the
offenses, and they should acquit if they had a reasonable doubt
that he was present when the offenses were committed. (CALJIC
No. 4.50.) We reject Escandon’s argument.
An alibi is not an affirmative defense. (People v. Bradley
(1945) 71 Cal.App.2d 114, 119 (Bradley).) It merely disputes
“ ‘that the defendant was personally present at the place when
the offense was committed.’ ” (Ibid.) It “cannot be considered by
itself, but must be considered in connection with all other
evidence in the case.” (People v. Branch (1962) 205 Cal.App.2d
688, 691.) When “ ‘instructions relate particular facts to a legal
issue in the case or “pinpoint” the crux of a defendant’s case, such
as mistaken identification or alibi[,] . . . [t]hey are required to be
given upon request when there is evidence supportive of the
theory, but they are not required to be given sua sponte.’ ”
(People v. Gutierrez (2009) 45 Cal.4th 789, 824.) The trial court
should give a pinpoint instruction on a defense theory if it is
47
supported by substantial evidence. (People v. Jo (2017) 15
Cal.App.5th 1128, 1174.) Substantial evidence means evidence
that is sufficient to “deserve jury consideration.” (People v.
Marshall (1997) 15 Cal.4th 1, 39.) It is “ ‘ “not ‘whenever any
evidence is presented, no matter how weak.’ ” ’ [Citations.]”
(People v. Wilson (2005) 36 Cal.4th 309, 331.)
Although Ramirez did not see Escandon after the shots
were fired, no evidence supported him being somewhere other
than the location of the shooting at the time the shots were fired.
(Bradley, supra, 71 Cal.App.2d at p. 119.) Ramirez did not
witness the shooting. He was inside and could not see outside
because the blinds were down. He only went outside after the
shots were fired.
Even if the trial court denied a request to read the alibi
instruction and substantial evidence supported it, Escandon did
not suffer prejudice because the jury was generally instructed to
consider all the evidence and to acquit if the prosecution failed to
prove guilt beyond a burden of proof. (People v. Freeman (1978)
22 Cal.3d 434, 438; People v. Alcala (1992) 4 Cal.4th 742, 804.)
The jury presumably considered these instructions—provided in
CALJIC Nos. 2.90 and 2.91—to ultimately reject any theory of
alibi and convict Escandon.
IV. No cumulative error
Escandon argues that the cumulative effect of the
purported errors deprived him of a fair trial and due process.
The aggregate prejudice from multiple errors could require
reversal even if no single error was itself prejudicial. (People v.
Hill (1998) 17 Cal.4th 800, 844.) Under the cumulative error
doctrine, we must review each challenge and evaluate the
cumulative effect of any errors to determine if it is reasonably
48
probable the jury would have reached a more favorable result in
their absence. (People v. Williams (2009) 170 Cal.App.4th 587,
646.) But here, we have rejected every claim of error raised by
Escandon. We have merely concluded that any assumed error
was not prejudicial. We reach the same conclusion after
considering the assumed errors’ cumulative effect. (Ibid.; People
v. Booker (2011) 51 Cal.4th 141, 195.) There was no miscarriage
of justice and Escandon was not denied a fair trial or deprived of
due process. (Hill, at pp. 844–845.)
V. Gang murder special circumstance and gang
enhancement
A. Sufficiency of the evidence for the gang murder
special circumstance and gang enhancement as
to the Barajas Jr. murder
Escandon argues that insufficient evidence supported the
gang murder special circumstance under section 190.2,
subdivision (a)(22) and the gang enhancement under section
186.22, subdivision (b), both as applied to the murder of Barajas
Jr. in count 1.38 The Attorney General concedes that they must
both be reversed and double jeopardy bars retrial. We agree with
Escandon and accept the Attorney General’s concession.
Section 186.22, subdivision (b) provides a sentencing
enhancement or an alternate penalty for the commission of a
felony “for the benefit of, at the direction of, or in association with
any criminal street gang, with the specific intent to promote,
further, or assist in any criminal conduct by gang members.” In
38 Escandon incorrectly refers to count 4 as involving the
murder of Barajas Jr., which was the offense in count 1.
49
simple terms, the enhancement requires “gang-related” conduct
that was “committed to promote the criminal activity of gang
members.” (People v. Renteria (2022) 13 Cal.5th 951, 963
(Renteria).)
The gang murder special circumstance requires that the
defendant intentionally killed a victim, while an active
participant in a gang, to “further the activities” of the gang. 39
(§ 190.2, subd. (a)(22).) Furthering the activities of the gang
“substantially parallels” the requirements of the gang
enhancement under section 186.22, subdivision (b). (People v.
Carr (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 475, 488.)
The Attorney General observes that the record lacked
specific evidence about why Escandon killed Barajas Jr.
Although the record established that both Escandon and Barajas
Jr. were Avenues gang members, it did not reveal anything about
the circumstances surrounding the killing other than occurring
after a verbal argument.
The prosecutor’s closing argument shed minimal light on
the circumstances surrounding the Barajas Jr. murder. The
prosecutor vaguely asserted that Escandon murdered Barajas Jr.
“because there was an argument . . . .” In rebuttal argument, the
prosecutor admitted, “And when we think about Frank
Barajas[, Jr.], who we know nothing about really, other than
being an Avenues gang member and hanging out with Escandon,
the defendant, in 2003, there’s a fight that breaks
39 The activities to be furthered are those that constitute the
gang’s pattern of criminal activity described in section 186.22,
subdivision (e), which includes the commission of two or more of
the 33 enumerated felonies. (People v. Arce (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th
700, 712–714.)
50
out . . . [Escandon] walks into his house, pulls out a gun, makes
sure it’s loaded, comes out and shoots Frank Barajas[, Jr.] in the
back and kills him . . . .”
When discussing the gang enhancements in closing
argument, the prosecutor described how Escandon was elevating
his status as a gang member by killing for the Avenues and
Mexican Mafia, as well as publicizing the violent reputation of
both gangs by showing that they “clean . . . house by killing
[their] own members.” When arguing about the gang special
circumstance, the prosecutor repeated, “Was the murder carried
out to benefit the activities of the criminal street gang?
Absolutely. It’s to clean house, so that they are now a more
effective operation.” But the prosecutor did not refer to any
evidence that would tie this “cleaning house” motive or any other
gang-related motive to killing Barajas Jr.
Even “ ‘in the light most favorable to the judgment below,’ ”
the record does not disclose substantial evidence for a reasonable
trier of fact to find the special circumstance allegation or
sentencing provision true beyond a reasonable doubt. (People v.
Boyce (2014) 59 Cal.4th 672, 691; People v. Albillar (2010) 51
Cal.4th 47, 60 (Albillar).) We conclude that insufficient evidence
supported the element of the special circumstance that Escandon
murdered Barajas Jr. “to further the activities” of the gang, as
required under section 190.2, subdivision (a)(22). Similarly,
nothing supported Escandon killing Barajas Jr. for the “benefit
of, at the direction of, or in association with” a gang, as required
under section 186.22, subdivision (b).40 Our conclusion regarding
40 The Attorney General asserts that there was no evidence
that Escandon murdered Barajas Jr. with the requisite specific
intent for the gang enhancement. However, neither the Attorney
51
the insufficiency of the evidence requires us to reverse both the
special circumstance and the enhancement for count 1. (People v.
Hin (2025) 17 Cal.5th 401, 468 (Hin).)
The double jeopardy clause of the federal constitution’s fifth
amendment provides that no person may “be subject for the same
offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb.” The state
constitution provides the same protection. (Cal. Const., art. I, §
15.) A defendant may not be tried a second time for the same
offense if the conviction is set aside for insufficiency of the
evidence. (Hin, supra, 17 Cal.5th at pp. 454–455, 468.) Our
conclusion that the gang special circumstance and the gang
allegation were unsupported by sufficient evidence bars retrial.
(Id. at p. 468.)
General, nor Escandon, discusses the specific intent element,
which, for a lone actor such as Escandon, requires “knowledge of
at least some of the criminal activities of the gang and its
members and intent to further those activities.” (Renteria, supra,
13 Cal.5th at p. 967.) Instead, the Attorney General addresses
only the absence of a reason for killing Barajas Jr. which is
relevant for whether the murder was committed for the benefit
of, in association with, or at the direction of the gang. Escandon
does the same. Because we conclude the evidence is insufficient
to support this first element of the gang enhancement, we need
not discuss the sufficiency of the evidence to support the specific
intent element.
52
B. Sufficiency of evidence for the gang
enhancement as to the attempted murder of
Salinas Jr.
In the conclusion of his opening brief, Escandon asserts
that retrial of the gang allegation is barred for the attempted
murder of Salinas Jr. in count 2. But Escandon’s opening brief
never substantively discusses the sufficiency of evidence of the
gang enhancement as to count 2. The Attorney General asserts
that any sufficiency of evidence claim for the gang allegation for
count 2 is forfeited. (People v. Silveria and Travis (2020) 10
Cal.5th 195, 255 [“ ‘ “[I]t is axiomatic that arguments made for
the first time in a reply brief will not be entertained because of
the unfairness to the other party.” ’ [Citation.]”].)
In his reply brief, Escandon asserts that the sufficiency of
evidence for the gang allegation in count 2 was “properly
addressed in [his] opening brief.” He reasons that the
circumstances leading to the shooting of Salinas Jr. were
identical to those of the shooting of Barajas Jr. which were
discussed in his brief.
Anticipating that Escandon inadvertently excluded the
Salinas Jr. attempted murder from his discussion about the
Barajas Jr. murder, the Attorney General points out additional
facts that might support a gang-related motive to kill Salinas
Jr.41 These facts center around Salinas Jr.’s and his father’s
41 We commend the Attorney General’s thoroughness, and we
conclude that it is necessary to reach the issue in the interests of
justice. (People v. Selivanov (2016) 5 Cal.App.5th 726, 794;
People v. Masotti (2008) 163 Cal.App.4th 504, 508; see also People
v. Norwood (1972) 26 Cal.App.3d 148, 152.)
53
opposition to Cyco Aguirre. Specifically, the Attorney General
provides reasons for Escandon to target Salinas Jr, including
Cyco Aguirre’s exclusion of his father Tigre from his restructured
tax collecting operation, Salinas Jr.’s opposition to that
restructuring, and Cyco Aguirre’s greenlight order to kill Salinas
Jr.
The Attorney General appears to claim that the trial
prosecutor also highlighted Salinas Jr.’s opposition to Cyco
Aguirre as Escandon’s gang motive to kill him. But the
prosecutor did not go so far as to say that Escandon’s loyalty to
Cyco Aguirre or his effort to fulfill the greenlight order motivated
his attempt to kill Salinas Jr. At most, the prosecutor mentioned
the conflict between Tigre and Cyco Aguirre and merely implied
that Escandon had the gang motive to kill Salinas Jr. because he
would naturally take Tigre’s side as his son.42
42 The prosecutor first discussed Escandon’s 2003 attempted
murder of Salinas Jr. by stating, “We know from evidence that
was presented that there was a fight that broke out, an argument
that broke out . . . between several members there, and that
included this defendant here, ‘Lokito,’ and it included Alfred
Salinas[, Jr.] and Frank Barajas[, Jr.]”
The prosecutor changed topics, stating, “Now, again, it’s
interesting, it’s important to note that at this time period, there
is that slow rift developing up in Pelican Bay, between the
Aguirre crowd, those coming from Five-Seven section, which Joe
Escandon is part of, and the Lil Tigre crowd, the one that is
separated out by Big Tigre. Big Tigre is out there; he’s having
issues with the Aguirre crowd, and Lil Tigre his son.”
The prosecutor returned to discussing the 2003 incident
between Escandon, Barajas Jr., and Salinas Jr., stating, “An
argument breaks out, including the son of Big Tigre, and Joe
Escandon at that point ends up killing them [sic].”
54
Not surprisingly, the prosecutor did not explicitly argue
that Escandon attempted to kill Salinas Jr. because of loyalty to
Cyco Aguirre or because of the greenlight order. No evidence
supported Escandon’s loyalty to Cyco Aguirre at the time of the
Salinas Jr. attempted murder in 2003, nor Escandon’s knowledge
of the conflict between Cyco Aguirre and Tigre at that time.
According to Campbell, while he was in Pelican Bay state prison
from 1998, he discussed the Mexican Mafia tax collecting
operation with Cyco Aguirre, who would become its “main
director.” Campbell also testified that during this time, Tigre
became an outcast from the Mexican Mafia. But Campbell was
not released from Pelican Bay until 2004.43 Prior to his release
from Pelican Bay in 2004, Campbell spoke to Cyco Aguirre about
a list of people who would need to change their alliances
regarding the tax collecting operations or face elimination. The
list included Salinas Jr. After Campbell was released in 2004, he
met Escandon for the first time. Not until that time did
Campbell discuss the persons on the greenlight list with
Escandon.
No reasonable trier of fact could have found that at the
time of the Salinas Jr. shooting in 2003, Escandon aligned with
43 The record is not clear as to the date Campbell was
released from Pelican Bay. Initially, he testified that he was
released in April 2004. But then he stated that he was in custody
for an arrest for, and conviction of, unlawfully possessing body
armor in April 2004. He further testified that he was released
from Pelican Bay for two and a half months to three months
before that arrest. If Campbell’s estimates were correct, he was
either arrested for the body armor in June or July or he was
released from Pelican Bay in January or February 2004.
55
Cyco Aguirre, knew about the conflict between Cyco Aguirre and
Salinas Jr.’s father, or attempted to follow the later greenlight
order against Salinas Jr. We conclude that substantial evidence
does not support Escandon committing the attempted murder of
Salinas Jr. in count 2 for “ ‘the benefit of, at the direction of, or in
association with any criminal street gang.’ ” (Albillar, supra, 51
Cal.4th at p. 59.) We reverse the jury’s true finding of the gang
enhancement as to count 2. The double jeopardy clauses of the
state and federal constitutions bar retrial of this enhancement as
to count 2. (Hin, supra, 17 Cal.5th at pp. 454–455, 464)
C. Instructions did not include changes by
Assembly Bill No. 333
Escandon asserts that the instructions for the gang murder
special circumstances for the murders of Barajas Jr. and Real in
counts 1 and 4, respectively, and the gang enhancements as to
counts 1, 2, and 4 did not include the changes to the law made by
Assembly Bill No. 333.44 He further argues that the deficient
instructions were prejudicial. The Attorney General concedes.
We agree and accept the Attorney General’s concession.45
Effective January 1, 2022, Assembly Bill No. 333 (2021–
2022 Reg. Sess.) amended section 186.22. (Stats. 2021, ch. 699,
44 The trial court read CALJIC No. 8.81.22 for the gang
murder special circumstance and CALJIC No. 17.24.2 for the
gang enhancement.
45 Because we accept the Attorney General’s concession that
the special circumstance and enhancement for count 1 must be
reversed for insufficient evidence, we need not address the
instructions for the gang murder special circumstance and gang
enhancement as to that count.
56
§§ 1–5; People v. Cooper (2023) 14 Cal.5th 735, 738 (Cooper); Hin,
supra, 17 Cal.5th at pp. 460.) The amendment narrowed the
definition of a “criminal street gang” as used for the gang
enhancement in section 186.22, subdivision (b) and the gang
murder special circumstance in section 190.2, subdivision (a)(22).
Assembly Bill No. 333 changed the definition to an “ongoing,
organized association or group of three or more persons . . . whose
members collectively engage in, or have engaged in, a pattern of
criminal gang activity” (§ 186.22, subd. (f), italics added), rather
than “individually or collectively engage in . . . a pattern of
criminal gang activity” (Former § 186.22, subd. (f), italics added).
A “pattern of criminal activity” under former section
186.22, subdivision (e) required two or more predicate offenses
committed “on separate occasions” or by evidence of such offenses
committed “by two or more persons” on the same occasion. The
amendment changed the requirements of a “pattern of criminal
activity” in four ways. First, a pattern of criminal activity now
requires the predicate offenses to be separate from the currently
charged offense or offenses. (§ 186.22, subd. (e)(2).) Second, the
last predicate offense must have occurred within three years of
the commission of the currently charged offense. (Id., subd.
(e)(1).) Third, it requires that the predicate offenses were
committed by two or more gang “members,” as opposed to
“persons.” (Ibid.) Fourth, the predicate offenses must have
“commonly benefited a criminal street gang.” (Ibid.)
Assembly Bill No. 333 narrowed the “common benefit” for
the gang by the commission of an offense to be “more than
reputational.” (§ 186.22, subd. (g); Hin, supra, 17 Cal.5th at p.
461; People v. Tran (2022) 13 Cal.5th 1169, 1206.) The
prosecution must show how the predicate offenses provided an
57
actual common benefit to the gang, and that they did not merely
enhance the reputation of its individual members. (People v.
Lamb (2024) 16 Cal.5th 400, 450 (Lamb).)
Assembly Bill No. 333 applies retroactively to nonfinal
judgments as we have here. (People v. Lopez (2025) 17 Cal.5th
388, 396.) The instructions read to Escandon’s jury preceded the
effective date of Assembly Bill No. 333 and his appeal was
pending on that effective date. The parties agree that the new
requirements in section 186.22 apply retroactively to Escandon’s
case on appeal under In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740, 745.
(Cooper, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 738–739.)
We must reverse the gang enhancements and the gang
murder special circumstance if “ ‘any rational fact finder could
have come to the opposite conclusion’ ” regarding the new
requirements of Assembly Bill No. 333. (Hin, supra, 17 Cal.5th
at p. 462; Cooper, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 739; Lamb, supra, 16
Cal.5th at p. 453.)
Officer Elias Villasenor testified as a prosecution expert on
the Avenues gang. He testified about three predicate acts to
support the Avenues gang’s pattern of gang activity, including
three robberies committed by Jose Luis Argumedo on June 3,
2000, two murders, an attempted robbery, and a burglary
committed by Porfirio Avila on November 3, 2000, and a robbery
and a carjacking committed by Leo Cienfuegos on November 13,
2003. The prosecution introduced certified minute orders for
each predicate act, containing the superior court’s case number,
date of conviction, and other information about procedural
history. Officer Villasenor opined that each person was an
Avenues gang member.
58
Officer Villasenor also testified that Cienfuegos, Argumedo,
and Avila committed their respective offenses for the benefit of
the Avenues gang. In unclear language, Officer Villasenor
testified that the offenses committed by Cienfuegos benefited the
gang “based upon his status within the gang, being the fact [sic]
the magnitude of the carjacking and the several robberies he
committed. And also to benefit the Avenues Street gang.” Officer
Villasenor merely answered, “yes,” when asked if Argumedo
committed the robberies for the benefit of the Avenues gang.
Also without elaboration, he testified that Avila committed the
murders and other crimes to benefit the Avenues gang and his
status in the gang. For each case, Officer Villasenor did not
provide additional details about the crimes or the nature of the
benefit provided to the gang.
As stated, because of the amendment by Assembly Bill No.
333, section 186.22, subdivision (g) now requires the predicate
offenses to provide a benefit beyond enhancing reputation and
status of individual members. It suggests non-reputational
benefit to include “financial gain or motivation, retaliation,
targeting a perceived or actual gang rival, or intimidation or
silencing of a potential current or previous witness or informant.”
(§ 186.22, subd. (g).) Officer Villasenor’s testimony did not
establish that the predicate offenses provided any benefit to the
Avenues gang. (Cooper, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 743.) Nor did
they preclude a jury from reasonably concluding that any benefit
was merely reputational. (Lamb, supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 451.) A
rational juror could have found the requirements omitted from
the instructions to be unsupported. We cannot conclude that the
instructions read to the jury were harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt. (Cooper, at p. 739.)
59
The error requires reversal of the gang murder special
circumstance in count 4 and the gang enhancements in counts 2
and 4.46 (Hin, supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 463.) Because we conclude
that the evidence was insufficient only under the law as amended
after the trial by Assembly Bill No. 333, not the law in effect at
the time of the trial, the District Attorney may retry this special
circumstance and these gang enhancements. (Hin, at pp. 464,
509; Lamb, supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 456; Cooper, supra, 14 Cal.5th
at pp. 746–747.)
VI. Inquiry into the direction of the jury’s numerical
division
Escandon argues that the trial court coerced the jury into
reaching a verdict on the special circumstances by ordering it to
resume deliberations after inquiring about the numerical division
of its voting and the possibility of reaching a unanimous verdict.
We disagree.
A. Additional facts
On November 7, 2019, at 4:05 p.m., the jury began
deliberations. On November 19, 2019, the eighth day of
deliberations, the jurors sent a note to the court, requesting help
on how to proceed if they could not agree on a special
circumstance. At 11:35 a.m., the trial court excused the jury for
46 Because we accept the Attorney General’s concession, we
need not address Escandon’s alternative argument that reversal
of the gang murder special circumstances and gang
enhancements is required based on the possibility that the jury
could have relied on the charged offenses rather than the
predicate offenses in finding a pattern of criminal activity.
60
the rest of the day. The court told the prosecutor and defense
counsel that it would answer the jury’s questions, order
additional argument by the attorneys, or direct the jury to
continue with deliberations, after inquiring “how they’ve voted,
how many votes, what the division is.” Neither counsel objected.
On November 20, 2019, at 9:25 a.m., the foreperson
confirmed that the jury was deadlocked. The court offered to
answer legal questions or read back testimony. But the
foreperson stated that he did not believe “anything along those
lines” would assist with breaking the deadlock and reaching a
unanimous verdict.
The court began polling the jurors with Juror No. 1 and
Juror No. 2 stating the jury was “deadlocked.” The foreperson
stated that three votes had been held. The court asked, “[W]as it,
you know, 8 to 4? 10 to 2? 11 to 1? 6 to 6?” The foreperson
clarified that two votes had been held. The exchange proceeded
as follows:
“Court: What was the first vote?
“[Foreperson]: The numbers were 2, 3, and 7.
“Court: Okay. That is an unusual configuration,
and we’ll get into that. What was the second
vote?
“[Foreperson]: Two and 10.
“Court: Okay. Pardon me if on the first one I
don’t understand what 2, 3 and 7 means,
because normally it’s—
“[Foreperson]: Well, your honor on the form
itself it says ‘true’ or ‘not true,’ however, we
added ‘not sure’ in this case, so that is why we
have three numbers rather than two numbers.
61
“Court: Okay. What does the two represent?
The people—the two people, what did they vote
for? [¶] . . . [¶]
“[Foreperson]: Two true; three not true; seven
not sure.
“Court: And then the vote, the second vote,
which is 2–10, what does that represent?
“[Foreperson]: Two true and 10 not true.
“Court: Okay.
“[Foreperson]: I do recall at the very end before
leaving there was a third, and I believe it was
three not true and nine true.
“Court: Now you’ve changed the whole thing
around.
“[Foreperson]: I’m sorry. I misspoke on the last
one. [¶] . . . [¶]
“Court: I don’t understand anything about that
third one.
“[Foreperson]: That’s fine. We’ll just dismiss
that, because we are not on the same page.
“Court: Was there a third vote or not?
“[Foreperson]: I’m going to say no, because we
don’t have it noted.”
Juror No. 2 informed the court that it could “break the logjam” if
it would clarify the last two paragraphs of CALJIC No. 8.80.1,
beginning with “ ‘you must decide separately each special
circumstance alleged in this case.’ ” The court explained that the
two special circumstances were not dependent on each other and
the jury had to decide each one separately. The court further
explained, “You don’t literally have to unanimously agree. We do
62
have deadlocked or hung juries. But in order for there to be a
verdict, you must unanimously agree.” The court stated, “All I’ve
done is converted what it says into more simple English . . . there
are two special circumstances, they have to be individually and
separately looked at. You have to resolve each one separately.
And then when you resolve it, you have to do it unanimously.”
Juror No. 2 replied, “That helps. That helps us tremendously.
Because we weren’t sure.”
The court also asked Juror No. 2 if a third vote was taken.
Juror No. 2 responded that there was a third vote “right before
[they] left” with nine “true” and three “not true.”
The court continued polling the remaining jurors. Juror
No. 3 and Juror No. 10 stated the jury was deadlocked. Juror
No. 4, Juror No. 5, Juror No. 6, Juror No. 8, and Juror No. 9 told
the court that further deliberations would result in a verdict.
Juror No. 7, Juror No. 11, and Juror No. 12 stated a verdict was
possible with further deliberations.
The court conferred with both counsel and without
objection from either, ordered further deliberations.47 Before the
47 The court told the jury:
“At this time, based on the interviews and
discussions that we’ve had, I am going to require
you to continue deliberating. I am going to
suggest, or at least welcome, if you have any
questions or clarifications that you need on the
jury instructions, if that is something that you
need, I’m not saying you have to do that, but if
that is something you need, write it on the form
that we provide, and we will try to answer any
questions you have about the actual
instructions.”
63
jurors returned to deliberating, the court asked about the
direction of the second vote. Juror No. 5 replied that it was two
“true” and 10 “not true.”
The jury resumed deliberations. The court later answered
the jury’s question about the specific intent requirement for the
gang enhancement. On November 21, 2019, at 10:00 a.m., the
jury returned its verdicts, which included true findings on the
multiple murder and gang murder special circumstances as to
counts 1 and 4.
B. Applicable law
Section 1140 requires the court to not discharge the jurors,
once the trial is submitted to them, until they have reached a
verdict and read it in open court. Two exceptions allow discharge
without reaching a verdict. First, both parties can agree to
discharge the jurors. (§ 1140.) Second, the court can discharge
the jurors when “it satisfactorily appears that there is no
reasonable probability the jury can agree” after a time “deem[ed]
proper” by the court. (Ibid.) The court determines in its sound
discretion whether there is a reasonable probability the jury can
agree. (People v. Rodriguez (1986) 42 Cal.3d 730, 775
(Rodriguez).)
But the court may not coerce the jury and must “avoid
displacing [its] independent judgment ‘ “in favor of considerations
of compromise and expediency.” ’ [Citations.]” (People v. Thomas
(2023) 14 Cal.5th 327, 403 (Thomas).) Determining whether a
trial court has improperly coerced a jury is a separate issue from
whether it violated section 1140. (Thomas, at p. 403.)
As Escandon acknowledges, a “neutral inquiry” into a
deadlocked jury’s numerical division allows the trial court to
64
assure that a verdict is rendered under section 1140.48 (People v.
Carter (1968) 68 Cal.2d 810, 815 (Carter), abrogated on another
point in People v. Gainer (1977) 19 Cal.3d 835, 851–852 (Gainer),
disapproved on other grounds by Valdez, supra, 55 Cal.4th at p.
163; People v. Proctor (1992) 4 Cal.4th 499, 538–539.) Such an
inquiry assists with evaluating the probability of agreement.
(Rodriguez, supra, 42 Cal.3d at p. 776, fn. 14.)
The Supreme Court observed that if the trial court learns
the direction of the numerical division, any “urging of
agreement . . . creates in the jury the impression that the court,
which has also heard the testimony in the case, agrees with the
majority of jurors.” (Carter, supra, 68 Cal.2d at p. 816, abrogated
on another point in Gainer, supra, 19 Cal.3d at pp. 851–852,
disapproved on other grounds by Valdez, supra, 55 Cal.4th at p.
163.) But simply asking a jury to resume deliberating after
48 Escandon mentions the federal rule that an inquiry into the
jury’s numerical division—even when the direction of the vote is
neither requested nor revealed—is prejudicial per se. (Brasfield
v. United States (1926) 272 U.S. 448, 450.) But this federal rule
is not binding on state courts. (People v. Howard (2008) 42
Cal.4th 1000, 1030–1031; Rodriguez, supra, 42 Cal.3d at p. 776,
fn. 14.) The California Supreme Court has specifically rejected
this rule of procedure for federal courts and upheld the process of
inquiring into the numerical division without determining the
direction of the vote. (People v. Breaux (1991) 1 Cal.4th 281, 319
(Breaux); People v. Valdez (2012) 55 Cal.4th 82, 160 (Valdez);
People v. Bryant, Smith and Wheeler (2014) 60 Cal.4th 335, 462
(Bryant, Smith and Wheeler).) The Court has also denied past
requests to overrule decisions permitting a trial court to inquire
about the numerical division of a jury. (People v. Price (1991) 1
Cal.4th 324, 467.)
65
discovering the direction of the numerical division is not
inherently coercive.49 (People v. Sheldon (1989) 48 Cal.3d 935,
959–960 (Sheldon).)
C. Forfeiture
The Attorney General concedes that the trial court erred by
inquiring into the direction of the jurors’ numerical division. But
the Attorney General argues that Escandon forfeited his claim.
We agree that Escandon forfeited his claim.
Despite multiple opportunities, defense counsel failed to
object to the inquiry of the jurors’ numerical division and the
direction of their vote. (Thomas, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 405–
406; People v. Lewis and Oliver (2006) 39 Cal.4th 970, 1038;
People v. Neufer (1994) 30 Cal.App.4th 244, 254.) First, prior to
the jury entering the courtroom, the court announced to the
attorneys its plan to answer the jury’s questions, order additional
argument by the attorneys, or direct the jury to continue with
deliberations, after inquiring “how they’ve voted, how many
votes, [and] what the division is.” Neither counsel objected.
49 Our case differs from Jiminez v. Myers (1993) 40 F.3d 976,
980–981, which Escandon also mentions. At the outset, we are
not bound by federal court opinions, even though we may
consider them for their persuasive weight. (People v. Brooks
(2017) 3 Cal.5th 1, 90 (Brooks); People v. Linton (2013) 56 Cal.4th
1146, 1182, fn. 8; Thomas, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 404.) Jiminez
involved an inquiry into the jury’s numerical division and
included the court telling the jury that it approved of progression
toward a unanimous verdict and encouraged the holdout jurors to
follow the majority. (Jiminez, at pp. 980–981.) In our case, the
court expressly indicated that a verdict was not necessary, and it
is not uncommon for juries to be “deadlocked or hung.”
66
Second, after receiving information about the number of votes,
numerical division, and direction of the votes, the court
addressed counsel again to indicate its intention to confirm the
direction of the second vote and to order further deliberations.
Again, neither counsel objected.50 By consenting to each of the
trial court’s courses of action, counsel waived his claim of error.
(People v. Debose (2014) 59 Cal.4th 177, 207.)
D. Any assumed error was harmless
Anticipating forfeiture, Escandon argues that the trial
court violated his constitutional right to a fair and impartial jury.
Even assuming the trial court erred and Escandon’s claim was
preserved, we conclude that any error was harmless.
The court’s discovery of the direction of voting arose only
because of the unusual breakdown of three voting categories—
true, not true, and not sure—as reported by the foreperson. After
discovering this information, the court did not communicate to
the jurors in the voting minority that it wanted them to change
their minds or “reconsider their views in light of the numerical
breakdown of the votes.” (Brooks, supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 90.) The
court did not exert pressure on the jurors voting in the minority
or single them out in any way. (Valdez, supra, 55 Cal.4th at p.
162; Gainer, supra, 19 Cal.3d at p. 848, disapproved on other
grounds by Valdez, at p. 163; Sheldon, supra, 48 Cal.3d at pp.
959–960.)
Instead, the court simply ordered all jurors to resume
deliberations. A court’s order to further deliberate is not coercive
50 After the jury returned to the jury room, defense counsel
only commented, “This makes no sense. It’s very simple.”
67
even if all jurors “were negative on the prospects of a verdict.”
(Breaux, supra, 1 Cal.4th at pp. 319–320; People v. Sandoval
(1992) 4 Cal.4th 155, 196.) The court never expressed or implied
to the jurors that they must reach a specific outcome.51 (Brooks,
supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 89.)
The court’s only statement regarding deliberations was its
response to Juror No. 2’s question about whether a unanimous
finding was required for the special circumstances. Specifically,
the court explained that it was permissible for the jury to
deadlock. The court “explicitly left open the possibility that
agreement might not be reached.” (Bryant, Smith and Wheeler,
51 Escandon claims that People v. Talkington (1935) 8
Cal.App.2d 75, disapproved on another ground in People v. Friend
(1958) 50 Cal.2d 570, 578, held that inquiry into the direction of
the jury’s vote requires reversal. Talkington mentioned Brasfield
and the federal rule that requires reversal when a trial court
asks about the direction of a numerical split. (Id. at p. 84.) But
the coercive statement by the trial court was not limited to the
mere inquiry into the direction of the split. When informed by
the foreperson about the deadlock and numerical division of the
jury, the court commented, “ ‘Well, if [a verdict] can be reached
within the next two hours, well, as far as that is concerned, you
are not going to get away from here for some time, and you
needn’t worry about that at all; you needn’t talk about that if you
don’t agree. As far as talking to me about getting away, forget it;
just retire.’ ” (Ibid.) Talkington held that the trial court’s
language coerced the jurors, threatening that it would not
discharge them unless they agreed on a guilty verdict. (Id. at p.
88.)
Similarly, People v. Crowley (1950) 101 Cal.App.2d 71, 75,
also cited by Escandon, recognized the potential coercive effect of
such “insistence upon an agreement” after learning that the
jurors voting to acquit constituted the minority.
68
supra, 60 Cal.4th at p. 462.) The court ordered the jury to
resume deliberations because its explanation appeared to clarify
the reason for the deadlock. The court did not punish the jury for
being deadlocked or to otherwise compel a verdict.
Based on the circumstances presented by the court’s
discussion with the jury, we conclude there was no reasonable
probability that a different result would have occurred absent the
discovery of the direction of the numerical division, (Valdez,
supra, 55 Cal.4th at p. 164), as well as no violation of Escandon’s
constitutional rights to trial by an impartial jury and to due
process.
69
DISPOSITION
We reverse and vacate the true findings on the gang
murder special circumstances for counts 1 and 4. We also reverse
and vacate the true findings on the gang enhancements for
counts 1, 2, and 4. We remand the matter to the trial court to
allow the District Attorney to retry the gang murder special
circumstance and the gang enhancement for count 4 under the
current version of the laws as amended by Assembly Bill No. 333.
Principles of double jeopardy preclude retrial as to the gang
murder special circumstance for count 1 and the gang
enhancement for counts 1 and 2.
In all other respects, we affirm the judgment.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
HANASONO, J.
We concur:
EDMON, P. J.
EGERTON, J.
70
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.