CourtListener 10786714•Zenith Insurance Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Bd.
Zenith Insurance Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Bd.
CourtListener 10786714Calctapp10 de fev. de 2026
Texto completo
Filed 1/14/26; certified for publication 2/10/26 (order attached)
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
ZENITH INSURANCE COMPANY H052785
et al., (WCAB No. ADJ13725280)
Petitioners,
v.
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION
APPEALS BOARD and KIN CHAN,
Respondents.
In Mayor v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 713
(Mayor), review granted December 11, 2024, S287261, the First District
Court of Appeal held that the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB,
appeals board, or the Board) acted in excess of its jurisdiction when it
granted a petition for reconsideration after expiration of the 60-day statutory
deadline set out in former section 5909 of the Labor Code 1 (Stats. 1992, ch.
1226, § 5, p. 5766) (former section 5909). Citing a similar decision in Zurich
American Ins. Co. v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2023) 97 Cal.App.5th 1213
1 All further unspecified statutory references are to the Labor Code.
(Zurich), the Court of Appeal in Mayor assumed without deciding that while
equitable tolling might be available to avoid the running of the statutory
deadline in limited cases, the facts of that case did not support the
application of such an exception. (Mayor, at p. 1311.)
In City of Salinas v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2025) 113
Cal.App.5th 801 (City of Salinas), review granted November 19, 2025,
S293212, a panel of this court largely agreed with the analysis in Mayor and
Zurich. This court further decided that the statutory timeframe for the grant
or denial of a petition for reconsideration does not implicate the Board’s
fundamental jurisdiction, allowing for the possibility of equitable tolling in a
narrow class of cases. (Id. at pp. 826–827.) This court found such
circumstances present in City of Salinas and affirmed the Board’s decision
granting reconsideration. The California Supreme Court has granted review
of this court’s decision in City of Salinas, holding the decision for its review of
Mayor.
The petition for writ of review in this case presents issues similar to
those in City of Salinas, Mayor, and Zurich. Petitioners Zenith Insurance
Company (Zenith) and New Sam Kee Restaurant, LLC (the restaurant) seek
review of the appeals board’s order and decision after reconsideration. In
that decision, the appeals board rescinded the order of the workers’
compensation administrative law judge (WCJ) denying compensation to
respondent Kin Chan and substituted a new finding that Chan’s injury is not
barred from compensation.
Petitioners contend that the Board lacked jurisdiction to grant Chan’s
petition for reconsideration, which was “deemed denied” by operation of
former section 5909. Petitioners maintain, contrary to this court’s decision in
City of Salinas, that equitable tolling is not available under former section
2
5909 as a matter of law. Petitioners assert in the alternative that, even if
equitable tolling were available, the circumstances of this case do not
warrant its application here.
We decline to revisit the statutory analysis in City of Salinas and agree
with petitioners that the Board exceeded its jurisdiction in granting Chan’s
petition for reconsideration. We also agree with petitioners’ alternative
argument that the narrow grounds for the Board to exercise equitable tolling
have not been met in this case. We therefore reverse the order and decision
of the appeals board.
I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Workers’ Compensation Claim
At the time of his injury, Chan was an employee of the restaurant
working as a prep cook. Chan’s coworkers included chef Ha Xu Huynh
(Huynh) 2, cashier and waiter Johnny Trieu (Trieu), and kitchen worker Kieu
Luu (Luu). Chan and Huynh had worked together since approximately 2008.
Trieu is the restaurant owner’s son.
On September 15, 2020, Chan and Huynh were preparing dishes in the
restaurant when they began to argue. The argument escalated. Huynh
struck Chan in the right eye, causing a broken eye socket, among other
injuries.
Chan filed an application for workers’ compensation claim in October
2020. He alleged specific injuries to the eye and other body parts stemming
from the workplace incident with Huynh. The restaurant and its insurance
carrier, Zenith, filed an answer denying the allegations and asserting
2 Huynh is also referred to in the record as Ah Chuan.
3
affirmative defenses, including the “initial physical aggressor defense under”
section 3600, subdivision (a)(7). 3 (Capitalization omitted.)
The matter proceeded to trial before the WCJ. The WCJ received
evidence, including medical records documenting Chan’s injuries and
treatment, and heard testimony from Chan, Huynh, Trieu, and Luu. 4 The
parties agreed that because Zenith and the restaurant had the burden of
proof as to the initial physical aggressor defense, they presented testimony
first.
According to Chan, the incident occurred when Huynh began tossing
vegetable and meat scrapings on to the restaurant kitchen’s worktable and
yelling obscenities at him. Chan testified that he walked toward Huynh but
did not yell or throw anything, nor did he have anything in his hands. As
Chan tried to explain Huynh’s conduct to Trieu, Huynh stepped forward and
struck Chan in the right eye.
Huynh denied arguing with Chan. Huynh testified that he had
complained about Chan’s ingredient preparation, and in response Chan
insulted Huynh’s mother, threw a container at Huynh, and picked up a knife
and came toward him. Although Trieu and the owner’s other son entered the
kitchen and restrained Chan and Huynh, Chan hit Huynh on the head and
3 Section 3600, subdivision (a) provides, in relevant part, for workers’
compensation liability against an employer “for any injury sustained by his or
her employees arising out of and in the course of the employment . . ., in
those cases where the following conditions of compensation concur: [¶] . . .
[¶] (7) Where the injury does not arise out of an altercation in which the
injured employee is the initial physical aggressor.”
4 The testimony recounted herein is drawn from the WCJ’s detailed
minutes of the hearing and summary of evidence. No transcript of the
hearing appears in the record on appeal.
4
Huynh hit him back, believing he was in danger and needed to defend
himself.
The other witnesses (Trieu and Luu) testified that there was an
argument, though they did not know how it started, and that Chan
approached Hunyh with a knife. Trieu testified that Chan came walking fast
around the table towards Huynh with a knife in his hand, while Luu reported
that Chan threw a dish across the worktable at Huynh, then pounded on the
table with a knife and approached Huynh.
Luu and Huynh each testified that they did not believe the presence of
their employer (the restaurant owner) in the courtroom affected their
testimony in any way.
After trial, the WCJ issued written findings and order (findings and
order), finding that Chan “sustained a specific injury” which “occurred during
an affray with a co-worker in which [Chan] was the initial physical
aggressor.” The WCJ ordered that Chan “shall take nothing by reason of this
claim.”
The WCJ discredited Chan’s and Huynh’s inconsistent narrations and
self-described innocent conduct, finding that “the sworn testimony of neither
[Chan] nor [Huynh] is credible enough to inspire confidence.” The WCJ found
Luu and Trieu “generally credible,” noting their observations varied in only
minor respects. The WCJ thus determined that Luu and Trieu both saw
Chan take up a knife from his workstation and walk toward Huynh, who
stepped around Trieu and struck Chan on his face, causing significant injury.
The WCJ reasoned that case law does not limit application of the “ ‘initial
physical aggressor’ ” defense to the party who initiated actual physical
contact. The WCJ held that “[a]ssault without battery has been held to meet
the definition of ‘initial physical aggressor’ on many occasions, and that was
5
clearly the case here” in that Chan advanced toward Huynh “in an angry
fashion with a knife in hand.” The WCJ deemed Chan the initial physical
aggressor, barring compensation for his injury.
B. Petition for Reconsideration
On November 18, 2022, Chan timely submitted a petition for
reconsideration of the findings and order. The petition for reconsideration
challenged the WCJ’s finding that Zenith and the restaurant had established
the initial aggressor defense. Chan argued that Zenith and the restaurant
failed to meet their burden of proof as to the affirmative defense and that the
WCJ’s factual findings establish “by law” that Huynh, not Chan, was the
aggressor.
Zenith opposed the petition for reconsideration, arguing that the trial
judge’s credibility determination should be afforded great weight and
persuasive evidence supported the WCJ’s finding that Chan was the initial
physical aggressor.
On November 28, 2022, the WCJ served on the parties a report and
recommendation (report and recommendation), recommending that
reconsideration be denied.
On November 30, 2022, the case file for the petition for reconsideration
was transmitted via the electronic adjudication system (EAMS) 5 to the
5 When a petition for reconsideration is filed, it is scanned into EAMS
pursuant to the division rules (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 8, §§ 10206 [electronic
document filing], 10205.11 [manner of filing]). Next, a “task” is sent to the
WCJ through EAMS, and the WCJ receives notice that a report is required.
(See id., tit. 8, §§ 10206, 10962.) Notice is provided to the Board when the
district office electronically transmits the case to the Board through EAMS.
The EAMS system is maintained by the administrative director of the
Division of Workers’ Compensation, who administers all 24 district offices
and the employment of more than 190 WCJs. (See Mayor, supra, 104
6
Board. However, the Board did not receive notice of and review the petition
for reconsideration until January 17, 2023. 6 Upon receiving notice, the Board
acted on the petition for reconsideration within 60 days and, on March 3,
2023, issued an order granting the petition for reconsideration for purposes of
“further study” (grant-for-study order). The grant-for-study order stated that
“reconsideration must be granted to allow sufficient opportunity to further
study the factual and legal issues in this case. We believe that this action is
necessary to give us a complete understanding of the record and to enable us
to issue a just and reasoned decision. Reconsideration is therefore granted
for this purpose and for such further proceedings as we may hereafter
determine to be appropriate.”
Approximately one year and eight months after the grant-for-study
order, on November 1, 2024, the Board issued an opinion and decision after
reconsideration (November 2024 order). The November 2024 order rescinded
the WCJ’s findings and order denying compensation and substituted a new
finding that Chan’s injury is not barred from compensation because the
restaurant and Zenith “failed to prove that [Chan] was the initial physical
aggressor.”
As for the timing of its November 2024 order, the Board acknowledged
that former section 5909 provided for the denial of a petition for
reconsideration “by operation of law” if the appeals board failed to act on the
petition within 60 days of the petition’s filing. The Board explained that the
filing of a petition for reconsideration at a district office commences the
review process by the WCJ, who reviews the petition and transmits the
Cal.App.5th at p. 1303, fn. 3, review granted; City of Salinas, supra, 113
Cal.App.5th at p. 811, fn. 4, review granted.)
6 The Board states it cannot explain why it did not receive notice of the
petition for reconsideration until approximately 48 days after it was filed.
7
report and recommendation and case file to the Board to act on the petition.
However, according to the Board, on “rare occasions, the case file may be
transmitted, but may not be received and processed by the [a]ppeals [b]oard
within the 60-day period, due to an administrative error or other similar
occurrence.” When this occurs due to no fault of the applicant seeking
reconsideration, the Board argued that it may consider “whether
circumstances exist to allow an equitable remedy, such as equitable tolling.”
In support of applying equitable tolling to the instant occasion, the
Board invoked Shipley v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (1992) 7 Cal.App.4th
1104, 1108 (Shipley) for the proposition that “ ‘the burden of the system’s
inadequacies should [not] fall on [a party].’ ” The Board explained that a
timely filed petition that is never considered by the appeals board because it
is “ ‘deemed denied’ ” due to an administrative irregularity outside the
petitioning party’s control deprives the parties of their due process right to a
decision on the merits and is incompatible with the constitutional mandate
for the workers’ compensation system “to ‘accomplish substantial justice in
all cases expeditiously, inexpensively, and without [i]ncumbrance of any
character.’ ” (Quoting Cal. Const., art. XIV, § 4.) The Board also considered a
party’s apparent reliance on the grant of a petition for reconsideration for
purposes of further study (insofar as the party has not attempted to seek
judicial review of the “ ‘deemed denial’ ” or the grant-for-study order) as
additional support for the application of equitable tolling. Applying these
considerations to Chan’s petition for reconsideration, the Board concluded
that “the requirements for equitable tolling have been satisfied in this case.”
C. Petition for Writ of Review
Zenith and the restaurant filed a petition for writ of review in this
court (petition) to challenge the lawfulness of the Board’s November 2024
8
order acting on the petition for reconsideration long after the expiration of
the 60-day statutory deadline under former section 5909. Petitioners
asserted that the Board’s action granting Chan’s petition for reconsideration
met none of the statutory requisites governing the time to act or the
permissible grounds for reconsideration. Petitioners disagreed that appellate
decisions supported the use of “grant-for-study” orders and the application of
equitable tolling to extend the Board’s jurisdictional window for ruling on a
reconsideration petition. They argued that Shipley was “questionable when
decided” and that more recent cases, including Earley v. Workers’ Comp.
Appeals Bd. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 1 (Earley), Zurich, supra, 97 Cal.App.5th
1213, and Mayor, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th 1297, review granted, have rejected
similar actions of the Board as in excess of its statutory authority.
Petitioners also asserted, as an independent basis for review, that the
November 2024 order paid no deference to the trial judge’s express and
implied factual findings and erroneously substituted the Board’s own
evidentiary findings and conclusions for those of the WCJ.
Chan and the Board (together, respondents) each filed an answer in
opposition to the petition. The Board noted the California Supreme Court’s
consideration of the equitable tolling question in Mayor and argued that as a
matter of judicial economy, proceedings in this matter be stayed until our
high court’s decision in Mayor. Alternatively, the Board asserted the 60-day
timeline under former section 5909 is not jurisdictional in a fundamental
sense and may be subject to equitable tolling by the appeals board when,
through no fault of the parties, it is unable to review a petition for
reconsideration until after the 60-day period has elapsed. The Board argued
that the circumstances of this case warrant equitable tolling because the
facts are “squarely in line with those in Shipley.”
9
In his answer, Chan further argued that the Board acted timely in
granting the petition for reconsideration under circumstances “directly
analogous” to Shipley. Chan emphasized that after being injured by a
coworker in the workplace, his petition for reconsideration was “lost within
the inefficiency of the” workers’ compensation system through no fault of his
own, leaving him without benefits due to the trial judge’s misinterpretation of
the law on the initial physical aggressor defense.
On July 30, 2025, this court issued an order granting the writ of
review. The writ of review directed the Board to certify and return its official
record in the case to this court and invited briefing. The Board submitted
opposition to the requested relief and petitioners filed a reply to the
opposition. Chan did not file an opposition brief following the order granting
writ of review.
II. DISCUSSION
Petitioners contend the Board’s order and decision after reconsideration
exceeded the fundamental jurisdiction of the Board and usurped the
factfinding authority of the trial court. Petitioners further contend that City
of Salinas should not control the outcome of this case, arguing that the
decision misinterpreted the law on fundamental jurisdiction as applicable to
government agency deadlines and, in any event, does not support the
application of equitable tolling under the facts of this case.
In response, the Board requests that this court stay proceedings
pending the California Supreme Court’s disposition in Mayor. The Board
asserts that should this court proceed on the merits, the decision of the Board
should be affirmed under City of Salinas.
For the reasons stated in City of Salinas, we decline the Board’s
invitation to stay our consideration of this matter until the California
10
Supreme Court completes its review in Mayor. (See City of Salinas, supra,
113 Cal.App.5th at p. 823, review granted.) We therefore turn to the merits
of the petition, beginning with jurisdiction and the standard of review.
A. Writ Review and Standard of Review
Section 5950 authorizes an application for writ of review of Board
decisions on petitions for reconsideration “for the purpose of inquiring into
and determining the lawfulness of the original order, decision, or award or of
the order, decision, or award following reconsideration.” If reconsideration is
granted, “[t]he application for writ of review must be made . . ., within 45
days after the filing of the order, decision, or award following
reconsideration.” (Ibid.)
“Judicial review ‘is limited to determining whether the Board acted
“without or in excess of its powers” and whether its decision was
unreasonable, not supported by substantial evidence, or procured by fraud.’ ”
(Mayor, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1305, review granted, quoting
Department of Corrections & Rehabilitation v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd.
(2018) 27 Cal.App.5th 607, 617 (Department of Corrections); § 5952.) “A court
is not permitted ‘to hold a trial de novo, to take evidence, or to exercise its
independent judgment on the evidence.’ (§ 5952.) ‘The findings and
conclusions of the appeals board on questions of fact are conclusive and final
and are not subject to review.’ (§ 5953.)” (Mayor, at p. 1305.)
We review issues of statutory interpretation and questions of law de
novo. (Department of Corrections, supra, 27 Cal.App.5th at p. 617.)
Nonetheless, “unless clearly erroneous, the [Board]’s interpretation of the
workers’ compensation laws is entitled to great weight.” (Genlyte Group, LLC
v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 705, 714; accord
Boehm & Associates v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (1999) 76 Cal.App.4th
11
513, 516.) “When the statutory language is clear and unambiguous, there is
no room for the Board’s interpretation.” (Department of Corrections, at
p. 617.)
We review de novo the jurisdictional effect of the statute and the
availability of equitable tolling. (Zurich, supra, 97 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1226,
1230; City of Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 814, review granted.)
B. Analysis
Petitioners contend that the Board acted in excess of its jurisdiction
when, approximately two years after Chan sought reconsideration of the
WCJ’s findings and order denying compensation on his claim, the Board
rescinded the WCJ’s order and substituted a new finding that Chan was not
barred from recovering on his claim.
Petitioners assert that the language of former section 5909 provides a
60-day period within which the Board must act on a petition for
reconsideration and allows for no equitable exceptions or extensions.
Petitioners maintain that recent appellate court opinions and the 2024
legislative amendments to former section 5909, 7 which took effect while the
petition for reconsideration remained pending before the Board in this
matter, support their interpretation of the statute and the Board’s
jurisdiction to act. Petitioners moreover question the jurisdictional analysis
articulated in City of Salinas and this court’s determination that neither the
language nor legislative history of former section 5909 deprives the Board of
fundamental jurisdiction to act on a petition after the 60-day deadline,
allowing in some circumstances the Board to exercise its equitable powers,
7 In 2024, the Legislature amended former section 5909 by enacting
Assembly Bill No. 171 (2023–2024 Reg. Sess.) (Assembly Bill 171) (Stats.
2024, ch. 52, § 27).
12
including tolling of the deadline. (City of Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 824–825, review granted.)
We recognize petitioners’ disagreement with the conclusion in City of
Salinas that former section 5909 does not preclude as a matter of law
equitable tolling of the 60-day deadline for the Board to act on a petition for
reconsideration. Nevertheless, we decline to revisit that discussion here,
because even assuming the availability of equitable tolling under City of
Salinas, the facts do not support its application in this case.
1. Former Section 5909, Case Law, and Amendments
At the time that Chan filed his petition for reconsideration in
November 2022, former section 5909 provided that “[a] petition for
reconsideration is deemed to have been denied by the appeals board unless it
is acted upon within 60 days from the date of filing.” (Stats. 1992, ch. 1226,
§ 5, p. 5766.) Effective July 2, 2024, the Legislature amended former section
5909 by enacting Assembly Bill 171, implementing a two-year period in
which the 60-day period is measured from the date the WCJ transmits the
case to the appeals board rather than from the filing date of the petition for
reconsideration. (Mayor, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1303, review granted;
see Stats. 2024, ch. 52, § 27.)
The Board’s November 2024 order after reconsideration, as well as the
March 2023 grant-for-study order (granting the petition for reconsideration
for purposes of further study), were issued well after 60 days from the filing
of the petition for reconsideration. 8 The Board contends that equitable
8 Even under the amended statute, which temporarily shifted the
trigger for the running of the 60-day period to the WCJ’s transmission of the
case file to the Board (Stats. 2024, ch. 52, § 27), the Board’s grant of
reconsideration as of the March 2023 grant-for-study order would not have
13
tolling applied to extend the statutory timeline, given the Board’s belated
receipt of notice—due to no fault of the parties—of the petition for
reconsideration.
Several appellate court decisions have considered the dilemma posed by
inaction of the appeals board on a petition for reconsideration within the 60-
day review period. As described by this court in its decision in City of
Salinas, we “agree[d] that the ‘deemed denied’ language of former section
5909 is mandatory, rendering—absent an exception—a decision outside the
60-day statutory deadline in excess of the Board’s jurisdiction to act.” (City of
Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 823, review granted; see Zurich, supra,
97 Cal.App.5th at p. 1231; Mayor, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1302, review
granted.)
This court further considered the nature of the jurisdictional deadline
established by former section 5909—an issue left unresolved by the decisions
in Zurich and Mayor—and held that the consequence that a petition be
deemed denied after 60 days does not deprive the Board of fundamental
jurisdiction to act on a petition after that point. (City of Salinas, supra, 113
Cal.App.5th at p. 824, review granted; see Kabran, supra, 2 Cal.5th at p. 341;
Law Finance Group, LLC v. Key (2023) 14 Cal.5th 932, 950–951.) This court
concluded that in the absence of a clear legislative intent to preclude the
Board from exercising equitable powers, the statutory deadline under former
fallen within the 60-day window. Under section 5909 (in its current
configuration, as of July 1, 2024, and until July 1, 2026), Chan’s petition
would have been deemed denied unless acted upon within 60 days from the
date the WCJ “transmits a case to the appeals board.” (§ 5909, subd. (a).)
According to the WCAB, transmission of the case file (presumably including
the WCJ’s report and recommendation) occurred on November 30, 2023,
rendering the March 2023 grant-for-study order and November 2024 order
after reconsideration substantially outside the statutory cutoff.
14
section 5909 may allow for equitable tolling in limited circumstances. (City of
Salinas, at p. 824.) This court also reasoned that the recent legislative
change in Assembly Bill 171, shifting the running of the 60-day period from
filing of the petition for reconsideration to transmission of the case file by the
WCJ to the appeals board, does not undermine this interpretation. (City of
Salinas, at p. 826.)
2. The Grounds for Equitable Tolling Have Not Been Met
“[E]quitable tolling is a narrow remedy that applies to toll statutes of
limitations only ‘occasionally and in special situations.’ ” (Saint Francis
Memorial Hospital v. State Dept. of Public Health (2020) 9 Cal.5th 710, 724
(Saint Francis).) Courts typically look to three “ ‘elements’ ” in deciding
whether equitable tolling applies. (Ibid.) These elements are timely notice,
lack of prejudice to the defendant, and reasonable and good faith conduct by
the plaintiff. (Ibid.; see also Addison v. State of California (1978) 21 Cal.3d
313, 319.)
This court in City of Salinas evaluated these criteria with regard to the
Board’s tolling of the statutory deadline between the claimant’s filing of the
petition for reconsideration and the Board’s receipt of the file transmission
from the district office approximately 29 days after of the running of the 60-
day period. (City of Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 827, review
granted.) Relevant to our consideration in City of Salinas was the timing and
nature of the Board’s and claimant’s actions, including that the Board’s
receipt of the file transmission was apparently prompted by a telephone
inquiry to the Board by the claimant’s counsel, who understood from his
inquiry that the Board would adjust the timeframe for a decision on the
petition once it received the file. (Id. at p. 829, fn. 10.) Further, in City of
Salinas, the Board issued its decision after reconsideration within 60 days of
15
receipt of the transmission of the case file. (Ibid.) Under these
circumstances, this court concluded that the claimant’s conduct was
objectively reasonable and in good faith, and all three factors for application
of equitable tolling had been met. (Id. at p. 830.)
We recognize that the elements of equitable tolling identified in Saint
Francis do not translate perfectly to the context here, where the delay being
scrutinized is not a plaintiff’s late filing but an administrative agency’s tardy
adjudication of a timely filing outside the statutory window. Nevertheless, as
a “judicially created, nonstatutory doctrine” (McDonald v. Antelope Valley
Community College Dist. (2008) 45 Cal.4th 88, 99) designed, in limited
circumstances, “to ‘soften the harsh impact of technical rules which might
otherwise prevent a good faith litigant from having a day in court’ ” (Saint
Francis, supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 719), we consider its applicability here.
We disagree with the WCAB’s contention that all elements of tolling
are established in this matter. In City of Salinas, although the claimant’s
case file was scanned into EAMS, the case was not electronically transmitted
to the Board until almost three months later, after the claimant’s counsel
contacted the Board to inquire about the status of the petition. (City of
Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 811, review granted.) By contrast, the
WCAB acknowledges that Chan’s case file for the petition for reconsideration
was electronically transmitted via EAMS to the Board on November 30, 2022,
two days after the WCJ served his report and recommendation on the parties
and 12 days after Chan filed the petition for reconsideration.
Despite transmission of the case file to the Board well within the 60-
day window from Chan’s filing, the Board asserts that for reasons “not
entirely clear from the record,” it did not receive notice of and review the
16
petition for reconsideration until January 17, 2023—the last day of the 60-
day period under former section 5909. 9
As a preliminary matter, we note that, unlike in City of Salinas, there
is no evidence that the party seeking reconsideration—here, Chan—inquired
into the status of his petition when the 60-day period elapsed, nor of any
express or implied communication by the Board to counsel that would suggest
the timeline for action on the petition was being reset to accommodate the
Board’s unexplained delay in receiving the transmitted case file.
Even more important, the Board has failed to show that, once it
received notice of the petition for reconsideration, it acted diligently and in
keeping with the spirit of the deadline that former section 5909 placed on
Board reconsideration. Reasonable and good faith conduct in this context
requires some showing of reasonable diligence by the party or parties seeking
relief from the statutory cutoff. (See Saint Francis, supra, 9 Cal.5th at p. 729
[explaining that the third element encompasses the “two distinct
requirements” of objective reasonableness and subjective good faith, where
reasonableness focuses not on a party’s intentions or motives “but instead on
whether that party’s actions were fair, proper, and sensible in light of the
circumstances”]; Hull v. Central Pathology Service Medical Clinic (1994) 28
Cal.App.4th 1328, 1336 [examining diligence in the context of equitable
tolling].)
9 In its briefing in response to the petition, the Board refers to
November 19, 2022, as the date Chan filed his petition for reconsideration
and January 18, 2023, as the date the petition would be deemed denied
pursuant to former section 5909. However, according to the certified record
on appeal, the petition for reconsideration was filed and served on the parties
on November 18, 2022.
17
The Board contends that it “sent a clear signal to the parties” of its
intention to exercise jurisdiction and issue a final decision on the merits after
reconsideration by issuing the grant-for-study order on March 3, 2023, within
60 days of its receipt of the case file. More specifically, the Board argues that
insofar as the grant-for-study order was within the deadline for Chan to seek
writ review of the denial by operation of law of his petition for
reconsideration, 10 the failure to seek review at that point signals the parties’
reliance on the March 3, 2023 grant of reconsideration. 11 The Board
maintains it was objectively reasonable for Chan to rely upon the March 2023
grant-for-study order, since the only decisional authority at the time the
10 The Board asserts that strictly applying former section 5909 would
result in the petition for reconsideration being deemed denied on January 18,
2023, giving the parties until March 4, 2023, to file a petition for writ of
review pursuant to section 5950. Adjusting for the one-day discrepancy
between alleged filing dates, described ante (fn. 9), we assume the petition for
reconsideration was deemed denied on January 17, 2023, giving the parties
until March 3, 2023, or 45 days, to file a petition for writ of review pursuant
to section 5950.
11 The Board also asserted that petitioners should have sought writ
review from the March 3, 2023 grant-for-study order. Citing Mayor, supra,
104 Cal.App.5th at pages 1309–1310, review granted, for the proposition that
orders granting reconsideration for further study are final orders subject to
review, the Board suggested that because petitioners failed to seek writ relief
from the March 3, 2023 grant-for-study order, they are “now precluded from
collaterally attacking the order as the Court of Appeal would lack
jurisdiction.” We reject this argument, which appears to conflate the
mechanism of a writ of mandate pursuant to section 5955, as in Mayor, with
that of a writ of review, pursuant to section 5950. Section 5950 authorizes
application for writ of review “if a petition [for reconsideration] is granted . . .,
within 45 days after the filing of the order, decision, or award following
reconsideration.” (Italics added.) Petitioners’ writ of review was properly
taken from the November 2024 decision on the merits following
reconsideration.
18
appeals board granted reconsideration was Shipley. (The decisions in Zurich
and Mayor, issued in December 2023 and August 2024, respectively.)
We are not persuaded. The March 2023 grant-for-study order provided
generic language stating that “reconsideration must be granted to allow
sufficient opportunity to further study the factual and legal issues in this
case.” No action was taken thereafter by the Board until approximately 20
months later when the Board issued its November 2024 order after hearing
on the merits of the case. This is not analogous to City of Salinas, which
applied equitable tolling only to the limited period in which the Board was
delayed in receiving transmission of the case file and where the Board
provided a decision on the merits after reconsideration within 60 days of the
delayed receipt of the case file. (City of Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 810–811, review granted.)
Moreover, the decision in City of Salinas expressly declined to address
the circumstance that exists here, in which the Board’s issuance of a grant-
for-study order purportedly operated to further extend the time for a ruling
on the merits of the reconsideration beyond the 60-day deadline. (See City of
Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 823, fn. 8, review granted.) Subsequent
appellate authority (issued while the Board was considering the merits of
Chan’s petition for reconsideration following its March 2023 grant-for-study
order and before the November 2024 order) squarely addressed the WCAB’s
practice of utilizing grant-for-study orders in this manner and directed the
Board “to cease its grant-for-study procedure and to comply with the statute
when granting reconsideration.” (Earley, supra, 94 Cal.App.5th at p. 8.) 12
12 Earley held that orders granting reconsideration must comply with
the relevant statutory provisions, namely section 5908.5, requiring the Board
to explain its reasons for granting reconsideration and to identify the
19
Although Earley postdated the grant-for-study order in this case, the decision
highlights the Board’s practice of issuing orders granting reconsideration for
purposes of further study that fail to state “the evidence relied upon and
specify in detail the reasons for the decision” (§ 5908.5) and may lead to a
delay of months or years before the Board issues a decision on the merits.
(Earley, at p. 7; Zurich, supra, 97 Cal.App.5th at p. 1231.)
We agree with other decisions by the Court of Appeal that the Board’s
grant-for-study procedure does not comply with the statutory scheme. As
explained in Zurich, “section 5906 envisions that the Board may grant a
petition for reconsideration and rule based on the evidence previously
submitted in the case or elect to grant reconsideration and then ‘direct the
taking of additional evidence.’ [Citation.] And section 5908.5 requires the
Board to state what evidence it relies on and the reasons for its decision—
both in granting or denying a petition for reconsideration, and in its final
decision affirming, rescinding, altering, or amending the initial findings or
order. [Citation.] But the plain language of section 5909 and its legislative
history make clear what the Board cannot do—ignore the 60-day deadline
and then rule on the petition for reconsideration—because after 60 days, the
evidence supporting its decision. (Earley, supra, 94 Cal.App.5th at pp. 10–
11.) The Earley court rejected as noncompliant with the statute the Board’s
grant-for-study orders that “gave no reason for granting reconsideration
other than a boilerplate statement that further study is necessary” (id. at
p. 11) and reasoned that “a long-standing and incorrect procedure remains
incorrect” (ibid.). The court further held that while the Board is not required
to issue a final ruling on the merits within 60 days and a separate ruling on
the merits may follow an order granting reconsideration (id. at pp. 13–15),
the authority to rule subsequently on the merits does not alter the time of the
Board under section 5909 to “ ‘act[] upon’ a petition for reconsideration within
60 days by granting or denying the petition, not by finally deciding the
merits.” (Earley, at p. 16.)
20
Board no longer has jurisdiction to consider the petition.” (Zurich, supra, 97
Cal.App.5th at p. 1231, fns. omitted; see also Earley, supra, 94 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 10–11.)
The Board in this case has not attempted to explain the significant
delay of 22 months between its receipt of the transmitted case file in January
2023 and the November 2024 order after reconsideration. The timing and
nature of the orders issued by the Board in this case stand in contrast with
City of Salinas and do not present circumstances suitable to the narrow,
equitable remedy intended for “ ‘special situations’ ” (Saint Francis, supra, 9
Cal.5th at p. 724) as opposed to “ ‘a cure-all for an entirely common state of
affairs.’ ” (Ibid.) In the absence of a record suggesting diligence in
attempting to comply with the statutory procedures and the timeline for
reconsideration notwithstanding expiration of the 60-day period under former
section 5909, we decline to infer the third element of reasonable and good
faith conduct to support the application of equitable tolling. (See Saint
Francis, at p. 724.) Even assuming that, like in City of Salinas, the first two
elements of timely notice and lack of prejudice to the defendant (here,
petitioners) have been satisfied, we conclude this case does not present a
special situation justifying tolling.
Absent application of an equitable exception extending the timetable
for the appeals board to act on the petition for reconsideration, the Board’s
action may not be upheld under former section 5909. We conclude that the
Board’s November 2024 order was in excess of its jurisdiction to act on the
petition for reconsideration and consequently must be reversed. (See Zurich,
supra, 97 Cal.App.5th at p. 1236; Mayor, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 1301,
review granted; City of Salinas, supra, 113 Cal.App.5th at p. 823, review
granted.) In light of this conclusion, we need not reach the merits of
21
petitioners’ argument challenging the Board’s substitution, in deciding the
petition for reconsideration, of its own findings and conclusions for those of
the WCJ concerning the trial judge’s interpretation and application of the
“initial physical aggressor” affirmative defense.
III. DISPOSITION
The November 1, 2024 opinion and decision after reconsideration of the
Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board is reversed. In the interests of
justice, the parties are to bear their own costs in this original proceeding.
(Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.493(a)(1)(B).)
22
______________________________________
Danner, J.
WE CONCUR:
____________________________________
Greenwood, P. J.
____________________________________
Bromberg, J.
H052785
Zenith Insurance Company et al. v. WCAB
Filed 2/10/26
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
ZENITH INSURANCE COMPANY H052785
et al., (WCAB No. ADJ13725280)
Petitioners,
v.
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION
APPEALS BOARD and KIN CHAN,
Respondents.
BY THE COURT:
The opinion in this case filed January 14, 2026, was not certified for
publication. The court has received requests for publication made under
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1120(a). After reviewing the requests, it
appears the opinion meets the standards for publication under California
Rules of Court, rule 8.1105(c). The court therefore orders that the opinion be
published in the Official Reports.
1
______________________________________
Danner, J.
_____________________________________
Greenwood, P. J.
_____________________________________
Bromberg, J.
H052785
Zenith Insurance Company et al. v. WCAB
2
Chernow, Pine & Williams, Barbara Mendenhall and Jeffrey J.
Williams; Horvitz & Levy, Lisa Perrochet and Benjamin P. Covington for
Petitioners Zenith Insurance Company and New Sam Kee Restaurant.
Allison J. Fairchild and Eric D. Ledger for Respondent Workers’
Compensation Appeals Board.
Hanna Leung, Dan Herman Pelin for Respondent Kin Chan.
H052785
Zenith Insurance Company et al. v. WCAB
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.