People v. Craig CA2/8

CourtListener 10767617Calctapp31 de dez. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 12/31/25 P. v. Craig CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

THE PEOPLE, B337679

Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. MA082001
v.

RODNEY LAMAR CRAIG,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Lisa M. Strassner, Judge. Affirmed.
William J. Capriola, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and Deepti Vaadyala, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
Four years ago, Rodney Lamar Craig brutalized his former
girlfriend over multiple days. Now he seeks to undo his
conviction and two sentencing enhancements. We affirm.
Neither prosecutorial misconduct nor sentencing error taint the
judgment. Unspecified code citations are to the Penal Code.
I
Craig’s ex-girlfriend, Sandra Johnson, testified about her
tumultuous relationship with Craig. Craig had abused Johnson
before. He often suspected she was cheating on him. He would
search her phone and smashed a few of them.
In June 2021, Craig “lost it” after seeing a text message
from a man to Johnson. He held her captive for two days and
beat her. Johnson testified about Craig’s violence. Almost all of
her ribs were fractured. Both lungs had collapsed. Doctors put
rods and screws in her neck to stabilize it.
Video evidence, police and medical testimony, and
photographs corroborated Johnson’s battered state when she
escaped Craig.
An expert testified it is common for domestic violence
victims to stay in abusive relationships and not report the abuse.
The jury heard about Craig’s violence against two previous
partners. Craig often suspected cheating and was controlling in
these relationships, too.
One of the women testified Craig hit her in the face so hard
he split open her eyebrow; then he refused to let her leave.
Another time, Craig held her captive for a day and threatened to
break her jaw and light her on fire. She sought a clean break
from Craig and went to Arizona. Craig harassed her by phone
and threatened to torture and kill her dogs and family. He also
set her property on fire.

2
The other ex similarly feared Craig. When he thought she
was “talking to someone” else, he hit her in the face, swung her
around by the hair, and slashed her tires. She ended the
relationship, but he kept threatening her. When she saw him out
driving, he tried to run his car into hers, jumped up and down on
her car, and said he would kill her.
One of Craig’s neighbors witnessed Craig verbally abuse
Johnson. He testified the last time he saw her at Craig’s home,
she had a black eye, looked “raggedy,” and “was in a panic-type
frantic mode.”
Craig did not testify.
The jury convicted him of the four charged counts: injuring
a dating partner (§ 273.5, subd. (a); count 1), criminal threats
(§ 422, subd. (a); count 2), false imprisonment by violence (§ 236;
count 3), and driving or taking a vehicle without consent (Veh.
Code, § 10851, subd. (a); count 4).
For counts 1 through 3, the jury determined Craig
personally inflicted great bodily injury (§ 12022.7, subd. (e)).
Craig waived a jury trial of his prior convictions and
aggravating factors. The court found he had suffered convictions
for criminal threats (§ 422) and arson (§ 451), and further found
these convictions amounted to strikes under the Three Strikes
law (§§ 667, subds. (b)-(j), 1170.12, subds. (a)-(d)). The court
found several other aggravating factors true as well.
Accounting for Craig’s strikes and enhancements, the court
imposed a total prison sentence of 14 years, plus 50 years to life.
II
On appeal, Craig first claims prosecutorial misconduct
requires the reversal of count 1, the count for willfully inflicting

3
corporal injury on a dating partner and causing a traumatic
condition.
We assume error and find, under any standard of prejudice,
the challenged comment by the prosecutor was harmless.
We explain.
Craig complains of one sentence in the prosecution’s closing
argument. When addressing count 1, the prosecutor highlighted
some of Craig’s violence against Johnson, the objects he used to
beat her, and the severe injuries she sustained. Then the
prosecutor encouraged the jury to reject a lesser included offense.
The prosecutor said, with our emphasis: “Now by law the Court
does have to give a lesser crime instruction. And it’s simple
battery. Simple battery doesn’t -- in my opinion it does not even
come close to describing what happened to this woman. Simple
battery can be anything --”
Defense counsel objected, and the court struck the words
“in my opinion.” The prosecutor went on to describe simple
battery.
Craig argues the prosecutor, through the italicized remark,
improperly proffered her opinion of his guilt in violation of
California law and his constitutional rights, and no curative
instruction could rectify this wrong.
The prosecutor’s remark was harmless under any standard.
(See People v. Peoples (2016) 62 Cal.4th 718, 798–799 (Peoples)
[applying the typical standard of People v. Watson (1956) 46
Cal.2d 818 to prosecutorial error]; People v. Powell (2018) 5
Cal.5th 921, 952, fn. 8 [applying Chapman v. California (1967)
386 U.S. 18 to defendant’s due process challenge to an
evidentiary ruling].)

4
The prosecutor’s remark was fleeting. “In general, we will
not find brief, passing comments by the prosecutor to be
prejudicial.” (People v. Ghobrial (2018) 5 Cal.5th 250, 289.)
Defense counsel objected to the remark, and the court
immediately struck the objectionable part and cured any
inappropriate vouching. The court also instructed the jurors that
counsel’s remarks are not evidence and that their verdict must be
based only on the trial evidence and the law. We presume the
jurors followed these instructions. (Peoples, supra, 62 Cal.4th at
p. 799.)
Finally, the evidence of Craig’s guilt on count 1 was
overwhelming.
Johnson testified Craig erupted after seeing the text
message on her phone. They were in her truck at the time, and
she tried to run away. Craig “came at” her and punched her
three or four times in the face. He grabbed a wrench from the
truck bed and repeatedly hit her ribs. He kept hitting and
kicking her in the ribs, chest, and face while she lay on the
ground. Then he got back in the truck and aimed for her.
Craig eventually forced Johnson into the truck and
continued the abuse at his home. He punched “every part” of her,
hit her with a broomstick, bit her, and spit on her more times
than she could count. He smashed glass around the home. He
ignored her pleas to stop and let her go.
At one point, Craig made Johnson eat dog food, telling her
she was “lower than a piece of shit.” Later, he threatened to kill
her. He pulled out a handgun and gave her the choice between a
bullet to the head or a fentanyl overdose. She chose the latter,
and Craig approached her with a syringe. He ended up shooting

5
the drugs into her mouth—a mix of methamphetamine and
fentanyl—which put her to sleep.
Craig continued the abuse over two days. He strangled
her. He threw her to the ground by the hair. He kicked her on
the side of the head. He struck her in the chest many times,
making it hard for her to breathe. He would wake her by
throwing full soda cans at her.
At one point, Craig made Johnson go to his friends’ house,
even though she could not lift her arms to put on a shirt and had
trouble breathing. There, he tried to convince his friends to help
him kill and bury her.
Eventually, Johnson persuaded Craig to get cigarettes and
food. When they were out, she was able to flag down help and
call 911 at a Dollar General store. The man who helped Johnson
testified she was barefoot and bruised and asked for help.
Meanwhile, Craig drove off in Johnson’s truck.
Sheriff’s deputies later found Craig in this truck. It
contained, among other things, a bag of methamphetamine, a
syringe, Johnson’s cell phone, firearm parts, and a metal wrench.
One deputy who came to the store testified Johnson was
“very distraught” and upset there. Her eyes were swollen and
purple, and she had red marks on her face. She was hunched
over and unable to stand on her own. Johnson reported some of
what happened and described the extreme pain in her
midsection. She said she feared Craig would come after her for
the rest of her life for “doing this.”
Johnson spent 10 days in the hospital. Nearly all of her
ribs were broken. She had ligament injury to her cervical spine.
Both of her lungs had collapsed. She had to have spinal fusion
surgery and tubes placed in her chest to reinflate her lungs. She

6
had bruising from head to toe. A forensic nurse testified about
the subconjunctival hemorrhage and ruptured blood vessels on
Johnson’s eyes, head, and upper back—signaling blunt force
trauma injury and/or strangulation.
Craig’s text messages dispelled any skepticism of Johnson’s
story. Shortly before his most recent string of violence, Craig had
texted Johnson the following:
“Okay, you want it you’ve got it. I’ve done two prison terms
over you stupid fucking bitches. One thing I’ve learned is how to
avoid it in the future. You enjoy the very expensive roller coaster
ride you are getting into. Have fun. LOL.”
“Let’s see how bad and a man your new boyfriend is when I
fuck you up right in front of him. I’ll have the pleasure in
trashing him as well[.]”
“I already know you will be calling the cops, the last two
did so I’m ready for that as well. This time, I will hold court in
the middle of the streets, but not before I deal with this. You’re
part of the five percent of women who shouldn’t be allowed to
consume oxygen and put solid motherfuckers away. . . . You
pushed me into a mode you will regret for the rest of your life. If
it’s costing me my life, you can bet you are paying dearly, bitch.
At the least I have nothing to lose and don’t give a fuck, so bring
or call anyone you want. I’ll do this single handed and see how
far I get.”
The evidence against Craig on count 1 was overwhelming.
The passing remark by the prosecutor of which Craig complains
did not affect the verdict or render the trial unfair. (See Peoples,
supra, 62 Cal.4th at p. 799; People v. Seumanu (2015) 61 Cal.4th
1293, 1344–1345 [prosecutor’s remarks encouraging the jury to
identify with the victim were harmless and did not violate

7
defendant’s constitutional rights, given the trial court’s
instructions and the strong evidence of guilt].)
Craig’s citations underscore this conclusion. (E.g., Berger v.
United States (1935) 295 U.S. 78, 88–89 [assuming prejudice to
the defendant where the case against him was weak and the
prosecutor’s misconduct was “pronounced and persistent,” not
“slight or confined to a single instance”]; People v. Allen (1978) 77
Cal.App.3d 924, 934–935, citation omitted [“It is only in the
exceptional case that ‘the improper subject matter is of such a
character that its effect … cannot be removed by the court’s
admonitions’ ”].)
III
Craig’s second appellate contention lacks merit.
He argues the trial court did not actually find that his prior
convictions amounted to serious felonies under section 667,
subdivision (a)(1) (section 667(a)(1)). Thus, he claims, imposing
two five-year enhancements under this provision generated an
unauthorized sentence.
People v. Clair (1992) 2 Cal.4th 629 (Clair) leaves no room
for this argument. Our high court dismissed a claim mirroring
Craig’s, finding there was no reason to vacate the defendant’s
serious felony enhancement after a bench trial on the prior
conviction. Clair reasoned the trial court “impliedly—but
sufficiently—rendered a finding of true as to the [section
667(a)(1)] allegation when it imposed an enhancement expressly
for the underlying prior conviction.” (Id. at pp. 645 & 691, fn. 17.)
Craig’s amended information alleged the same prior
convictions amounted to strikes and serious felonies under
section 667(a)(1). Before trial, the court acknowledged the

8
prosecution sought to use the same convictions to enhance Craig’s
sentence under both laws.
In the bench trial of Craig’s prior convictions, the court
considered the prosecution’s evidence and found beyond a
reasonable doubt that he had sustained two convictions for
criminal threats and one for arson, all of which amounted to
“strike priors.”
The court sentenced Craig at the same hearing. It imposed
consecutive five-year enhancements under section 667(a)(1),
saying “the court is sentencing [Craig] to five years as to both,
consecutive to one another as to both 667(a)(1) allegations.” In
response to a question by defense counsel, the court repeated
Craig was getting “ten years on the 667(a)’s.” Both the minute
order and the abstract of judgment show the court imposed these
enhancements.
Craig relies on a single, distinguishable case that does not
help him, People v. Farias (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 619. Farias
involved uncertainty about strike allegations. No reporter’s
transcript documented the trial court’s findings on the
defendants’ priors; the findings were not made in the presence of
the parties or counsel; the related minute order was silent as to
the strike allegations; the court referenced only “serious” priors
(not “strike” or “violent” priors) at sentencing; and the abstracts
of judgment were contradictory. (See id. at pp. 626, 630–635.)
There was no uncertainty here.
The trial court was not silent on Craig’s prior convictions.
It found these convictions beyond a reasonable doubt and
explicitly imposed five-year serious felony enhancements under
the relevant provision. These enhancements are documented in

9
the reporter’s transcript, the related minute order, and the
abstract of judgment.
This suffices. (See Clair, supra, 2 Cal.4th at p. 691, fn. 17;
see also People v. Williams (2002) 99 Cal.App.4th 696, 699–701
[trial court impliedly found a defendant’s prior conviction was for
a serious felony when it imposed a five-year prison term under
section 667(a)(1)]; People v. Chambers (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th
1047, 1048–1051 [trial court impliedly found true a firearm
allegation “because it imposed a 10-year prison term for the
enhancement. We reject appellant’s contention that the absence
of an express finding requires that the 10-year enhancement be
stricken . . . . Here the record is not ‘silent’ as the oral
pronouncement of judgment ‘speaks’ to impliedly affirm the truth
of the use of a firearm allegation”].)
DISPOSITION
We affirm the judgment.

WILEY, J.

We concur:

STRATTON, P. J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

10

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.