CourtListener 10759396•People v. Murray CA2/4
Texto completo
Filed 12/16/25 P. v. Murray CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
THE PEOPLE, B336638
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA518083)
v.
PARRIS RAMON MURRAY,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Renee Korn, Judge. Affirmed.
James M. Crawford, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Wyatt E. Bloomfield, Supervising
Deputy Attorney General, Charles Chung, Deputy Attorney
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Defendant Parris Ramon Murray appeals his conviction for
stalking. (Pen. Code, § 646.9.)1 He argues (1) the evidence is
insufficient to support his conviction, (2) the trial court erred in
failing to instruct sua sponte on the lesser included offense of
attempted stalking, and (3) the court erred by failing to instruct
the jury it had to unanimously agree which acts constituted
harassment for purposes of stalking. We disagree with each
contention and affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Evidence at Trial
For more than three years, Gabrielle P. lived in her van in
an alley behind an auto repair shop run by her friend Juan
Carlos Mercado. Mercado allowed Gabrielle to live in the alley
because she felt safe there. Gabrielle shared the van with her
cat, Georgie, whom she had raised and owned for about five
years.
Gabrielle first met Murray in February 2023 when he
began painting a mural of two giant black wings on a wall in the
alley. He asked her if she would go to a store and buy him
something to drink and “some blunt wrappers,” which she did.
Gabrielle testified that Murray was initially quiet and polite.
However, after she brought him a soda in the first week or so of
meeting, Murray grabbed her from behind with a sudden bear
hug and clutched her breast. Gabrielle was shocked and said she
felt the “fear response,” which caused her to “stop still and
endure until it was over.”
1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
Murray went to the alley every day, and Gabrielle felt
dread when he was there. He started intimidating and chasing
away people who tried to walk through the alley, especially
Gabrielle’s friends. He would ask how they knew Gabrielle and
tell them they could not walk through the alley. After a few
weeks, Murray finished the mural but continued going to the
alley.
Murray began threatening Gabrielle. He went to the alley
on an evening in early April 2023. Two friends were visiting
Gabrielle, and she asked them to stay with her for protection
when Murray arrived. Hours later, Murray, unprovoked,
threatened to steal Gabrielle’s van and to “beat [her] ass.”
Gabrielle believed Murray’s threats. At about three in the
morning, Gabrielle fled to the home of her friend Marisha
Madrigal and rang the doorbell. The alley was behind Madrigal’s
house.
Madrigal woke up when the doorbell rang. She saw
Gabrielle standing on the front porch looking panicked. Gabrielle
said there was someone stalking her and she was afraid.
Madrigal invited her inside and tried to calm her down.
Gabrielle was trembling and terrified. Madrigal had never seen
her in that state.
Gabrielle asked Madrigal to call 911. Gabrielle reported in
the 911 call that Murray threatened to steal her van and beat her
to death. The police showed up, but she felt they did not take her
seriously. They suggested she move her van, and she did so for
the night.
Later that same day, Murray went back to the alley and
threatened to kill Gabrielle and shoot her cat in the face.
Gabrielle ran to Mercado’s shop. Mercado saw her shaking,
3
crying, and trying to hide. Mercado went to the alley and saw
Murray leaving. Mercado called 911 and reported Murray
threatened Gabrielle.
The following morning, Murray sped into the alley and
parked directly in front of Gabrielle’s van. Gabrielle was sitting
in her van with her phone beside her. Murray went up to her and
took her phone. He said, “You called the cops, b*tch.” Gabrielle
denied doing so, and Murray told her, “[Y]ou better hope that
you’re not lying . . . .” He drove away with her phone. He
returned 10 minutes later, threw Gabrielle’s phone back into her
van, and said, “‘You’re lucky you’re not lying.’”
On another occasion, Murray went to Gabrielle’s van and
tried to enter uninvited. Gabrielle stopped him from doing so by
putting her finger to his chest and saying, “No man enters my
car.” Murray said, “If you want to keep this car, you better let me
in.” Gabrielle again declined. Murray backed off and told
Gabrielle he hoped she was ready to deal with the consequences.
She felt certain he was going to follow through on his threat.
Gabrielle testified that, over the months, Murray returned
to the alley close to a hundred times. He would spend anywhere
from one to 10 hours there. He would park his car directly
behind Gabrielle’s van and keep the engine running, which made
loud whirring noises, at all hours of the day. Gabrielle could hear
the loud whirring when he was there and could not sleep because
of the noise.
Gabrielle was generally too afraid to ask Murray to move
his car. When Gabrielle did ask him to move his car a few times,
he did not do so. In one instance, he moved his car when she
asked but returned shortly after. To try to stop him from parking
directly by her, Gabrielle placed broken glass by her van that she
4
kept with a broom. While the broken glass stopped Murray from
parking directly by her van, he continued to return and park in
areas that blocked the alley. Gabrielle stated she felt a
“relentless sense of legitimate dread” whenever Murray was in
the alley.
The day before Labor Day in September 2023, Murray
parked his car in the alley with the engine running. Gabrielle’s
cat got away from her and ran into some bushes behind Murray’s
car. Gabrielle was afraid her cat was going to run away because
Murray’s engine scared it. Gabrielle asked Murray if he could
move his car so her cat could get out of the bushes, but Murray
laughed and rolled up his windows. Gabrielle was unable to get
her cat, and it went deeper into the neighborhood. She was
exhausted from not sleeping the last few nights because Murray
had parked by her van with the engine running. Frustrated
looking for her cat, she yelled, “‘Why are you being such a
n*gger.’” She then went to search for her cat.
The next day, Gabrielle was sleeping in her van in the early
afternoon. She left the door slightly open so her cat could get in if
it returned. Murray suddenly yanked open the door to the van
and climbed on top of her. Murray put one hand over Gabrielle’s
mouth and inserted his other hand into her vagina. Murray said,
“‘Why aren’t you wet yet, b*tch,’” and “‘Do you have any idea
what my people have been through for that word, b*tch.’”
Murray took his hand out of her vagina and tried to unzip his
pants. Gabrielle broke free and grabbed a knife she kept in her
van. She backed up holding the knife, saying, “‘Get off. Get off.’”
She urinated on herself when this happened.
Gabrielle ran to a nearby gas station. She was in a panic
screaming, and the gas station cashier saw Gabrielle’s clothes
5
were ripped and that she was really scared. The cashier also
noticed Gabrielle had red marks on her neck. The cashier called
911. Gabrielle spoke with the police and told them what
happened. Additionally, Gabrielle called Madrigal after the
incident. Madrigal described Gabrielle as sounding “extremely
upset. . . . Kind of screaming, crying, every indication of being
upset.”
Murray drove up as Gabrielle was speaking to a friend
outside the same gas station the following morning. He told
Gabrielle he was going to have his sister beat her up and that her
“days were numbered.” He approached Gabrielle, and she raised
her hand to show him a taser she was holding. Murray said,
“[O]h, really. I got something better than that,” walked back to
his car, and started reaching as if he was going to pull something
out. He then smiled, got back into his car, and left.
Murray continued driving to and sitting in the alley after
the sexual assault. On one occasion after seeing him drive
through, Gabrielle packed up her belongings and drove elsewhere
for the night because she was afraid something bad was going to
happen. She returned the next morning. That day, Murray
again pulled up next to Gabrielle’s van. He rolled his window
down and told her that he was going to burn her van with her
and her cat in it. Gabrielle felt that he meant it.
Los Angeles Police Department Detective Myra Correa,
who conducted special assault investigations, was assigned to the
case. Gabrielle texted Detective Correa about Murray’s threat to
burn her van the same morning he made the threat. Gabrielle
had also texted Detective Correa a few days prior, telling her
Murray was in the alley behind her. Detective Correa obtained
surveillance video of Murray’s car in the alley from a security
6
camera on Mercado’s property. She obtained surveillance video
of the alley and Gabrielle’s van at the time of the sexual assault
from a security camera on Madrigal’s property. Additionally,
Detective Correa obtained six 911 calls relating to Gabrielle.
B. Verdict and Sentencing
Murray was charged by information with stalking (§ 646.9,
subd. (a); count 1) and sexual penetration by use of force (§ 289,
subd. (a)(1)(A); count 2).
In March 2024, the jury found Murray guilty on count 1,
not guilty on count 2, and guilty of the lesser included offenses of
assault with intent to commit forcible sexual penetration (§ 220)
and sexual battery (§ 243.4). In a bifurcated proceeding, the trial
court found an aggravating factor under California Rules of
Court, rule 4.421(b)(2) to be true. The court sentenced Murray to
a total term of four years and eight months.
Murray timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
A. Substantial Evidence Supports the Stalking
Conviction
Murray argues there was insufficient evidence to support
his stalking conviction. We disagree.
The elements of stalking are: (1) willfully, maliciously, and
repeatedly following or willfully and maliciously harassing
another person; (2) making a credible threat; and (3) intending to
place the person in reasonable fear for his or her safety. (§ 646.9,
subd. (a).)
Under section 646.9, “‘harasses’ means engages in a
knowing and willful course of conduct directed at a specific
7
person that seriously alarms, annoys, torments, or terrorizes the
person, and that serves no legitimate purpose.” (§ 646.9,
subd. (e).) “‘[C]ourse of conduct’ means two or more acts
occurring over a period of time, however short, evidencing a
continuity of purpose.” (§ 646.9, subd. (f).) “‘[C]redible threat’
means a verbal or written threat, . . . or a threat implied by a
pattern of conduct or a combination of verbal, written, or
electronically communicated statements and conduct, made with
the intent to place the person that is the target of the threat in
reasonable fear for their safety, or the safety of their family, and
made with the apparent ability to carry out the threat so as to
cause the person who is the target of the threat to reasonably
fear for their safety or the safety of their family. It is not
necessary to prove that the defendant had the intent to actually
carry out the threat.” (§ 646.9, subd. (g).)
We review challenges to the sufficiency of the evidence for
substantial evidence. (People v. Tafoya (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th
868, 892; People v. San Nicolas (2004) 34 Cal.4th 614, 658.)
“[W]e review the entire record in the light most favorable to the
prosecution to determine whether it contains evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value, from which a rational
trier of fact could find [the elements of the crime] beyond a
reasonable doubt.” (Tafoya, at p. 892.) “‘We presume in support
of the judgment the existence of every fact the trier of fact
reasonably could infer from the evidence. [Citation.] If the
circumstances reasonably justify the trier of fact’s findings,
reversal of the judgment is not warranted simply because the
circumstances might also reasonably be reconciled with a
contrary finding.’” (People v. D’Arcy (2010) 48 Cal.4th 257, 293
8
(D’Arcy).) We do not reweigh evidence or reevaluate a witness’s
credibility. (Ibid.)
The record discloses ample evidence to support Murray’s
stalking conviction. Gabrielle testified that Murray came to the
alley where she lived nearly 100 times over the course of several
months, and the record shows many acts of willful and malicious
harassment during this time. Early on, Murray grabbed
Gabrielle from behind and clutched her breast. Murray chased
Gabrielle’s friends out of the alley to keep them away from her.
He would park directly by or near her van and keep his engine
running, which made loud noises that kept Gabrielle awake at
night. Murray sexually assaulted her on Labor Day 2023 and
continued to seek her out in the following days and weeks.
Murray argues that there is no evidence he entered the alley with
the “intent or design” to harass or intimidate Gabrielle. Even if
we accepted this as true, Murray nonetheless repeatedly
harassed Gabrielle once he was in the alley. Accordingly, there is
substantial evidence that Murray harassed Gabrielle.
Substantial evidence also supports the jury’s finding that
Murray made a credible threat to Gabrielle. In early April 2023,
Murray threatened to steal Gabrielle’s van and to “beat [her]
ass.” He also threatened to beat Gabrielle and shoot her cat.
When Gabrielle denied reporting his threats to the police, he told
her, “[Y]ou better hope that you’re not lying . . . .” When Murray
tried to enter Gabrielle’s van uninvited and she refused him, he
told her that she had better be ready to deal with the
consequences. Murray later sexually assaulted Gabrielle, and
the next morning, he said his sister was going to beat her up. He
also told Gabrielle her “days were numbered.” Shortly after,
Murray returned to the alley and threatened to burn Gabrielle’s
9
van with her in it. A reasonable jury could conclude that
Murray’s acts and statements constituted a credible threat under
section 646.9. (See People v. Uecker (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 583,
594–596 (Uecker) [defendant’s conduct of following victim over
seven months, placing hostile notes on her car, and positioning
himself so he could see her come and go at work, constituted
credible threat].)
Furthermore, substantial evidence supports the jury’s
finding that Murray intended to place Gabrielle in reasonable
fear for her safety. “‘“‘[I]ntent is rarely susceptible of direct proof
and must usually be inferred from all the facts and circumstances
disclosed by the evidence.’”’” (People v. Frias (2024) 98
Cal.App.5th 999, 1019 (Frias).) The many threats Murray made,
along with the encroachment on her living space and the sexual
assault, indicate that he intended to put her in reasonable fear.
The evidence showing that Murray persistently parked near her
with his engine running also supported an inference that he
wanted her to know he was watching her to put her in fear. (See
Uecker, supra, 172 Cal.App.4th at p. 595 [“a reasonable jury could
conclude defendant wanted [the victim] to know he had been
watching her while she was parked at work and keeping track of
her schedule to place her in fear of her safety”].)
Additionally, Gabrielle consistently testified that she
believed Murray’s threats and feared for her safety. Other
witnesses corroborated her statements and described seeing her
terrified of Murray. On one occasion, Mercardo saw her panicked
and shaking when she was trying to hide in his shop after
Murray threatened her. On another occasion, Madrigal saw
Gabrielle trembling after Murray threatened her. The cashier at
the gas station saw Gabrielle screaming and scared after Murray
10
assaulted her. Gabrielle and her friends called the police
multiple times because of the threats. “A reasonable jury could
infer from [Murray’s] course of conduct ‘that he intended the
result he caused.’” (Frias, supra, 98 Cal.App.5th at p. 1019.)
Murray admits he was “in the alley almost on a daily basis”
but asserts it was to work on his mural, not to harass Gabrielle.
In essence, he argues the evidence might have supported a
contrary finding, but this is immaterial under the applicable
standard of review. (D’Arcy, supra, 48 Cal.4th at p. 293.) On the
record before us, a reasonable jury could find beyond a reasonable
doubt that Murray’s conduct posed a credible threat to Gabrielle
and that he intended to put her in fear for her safety.
Substantial evidence thus supports Murray’s stalking conviction.
B. The Trial Court Did Not Err by Not Giving Lesser
Included Offense Instructions for Attempted
Stalking
Murray contends the trial court prejudicially erred in
failing to instruct the jury on the lesser included offense of
attempted stalking. He acknowledges he did not request the
instruction but contends the court was required to give the
instruction sua sponte because there was substantial evidence
that he took several direct but ineffectual steps towards stalking
Gabrielle. We are not persuaded.
“Trial courts must instruct on general legal principles
closely related to the case, including necessarily included offenses
when the evidence raises a question as to whether all the
elements of the charged offense are present. But the existence of
any evidence, no matter how weak, will not justify instructions on
a lesser included offense, for such instructions are required only
11
where there is substantial evidence from which a rational jury
could conclude that the defendant committed the lesser offense
but not the greater offense.” (People v. Obermueller (2024) 104
Cal.App.5th 207, 217 (Obermueller).) “‘Substantial evidence,’ in
this context, ‘is evidence sufficient to “deserve consideration by
the jury,” that is, evidence that a reasonable jury could find
persuasive.’” (People v. Williams (2015) 61 Cal.4th 1244, 1263.)
We review the trial court’s failure to instruct on a lesser included
offense de novo. (People v. Nelson (2016) 1 Cal.5th 513, 538.)
“In a noncapital case, the error in failing to instruct on a
lesser included offense is reviewed for prejudice under People v.
Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818 . . . which requires reversal of the
conviction for the greater offense ‘if, “after an examination of the
entire cause, including the evidence” [citation], it appears
“reasonably probable” the defendant would have obtained a more
favorable outcome had the error not occurred.’” (People v. Racy
(2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1327, 1335.)
Murray must identify evidence that would have permitted
conviction on the lesser offense but would not have allowed
conviction on the greater charge. (Obermueller, supra, 104
Cal.App.5th at p. 216.) He asserts that the occasion where
Gabrielle called him a racial epithet undermined any claim his
conduct placed her in actual and reasonable fear. However, the
statutory offense of stalking requires a course of conduct. (People
v. Zavala (2005) 130 Cal.App.4th 758, 769 (Zavala).) Murray
cites no authority suggesting that each of a perpetrator’s acts
throughout a course of conduct must individually satisfy the
elements of stalking. To the contrary, the jury was required to
consider his entire course of conduct. The trial court had no duty
to instruct on attempted stalking, for there was no substantial
12
evidence from which a rational jury could conclude that Murray
committed the lesser offense but not the greater one.
(Obermueller, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 216.)
Furthermore, any error in failing to give an instruction on
attempted stalking is harmless. As we have discussed, the
evidence that Murray’s conduct placed Gabrielle in reasonable
fear for her safety was overwhelming. Murray, over a period of
months, continually bothered, threatened, and harassed
Gabrielle. Gabrielle testified that she was scared and believed he
would carry out the threats. Madrigal, Mercado, and the gas
station cashier corroborated her fear. Based on the evidence
presented at trial, it is not reasonably probable that the jury
would have found Murray only attempted and did not complete
the crime of stalking.
C. The Trial Court Was Not Required to Instruct on
Unanimity
The trial court declined to give the jury an instruction on
unanimity (CALCRIM No. 3501) because stalking requires a
continuous course of conduct. Murray argues the court erred. He
argues the jury should have been instructed on the need to
unanimously agree on what acts constituted harassment under
the stalking statute. We reject his contention.
“The requirement of unanimity as to the criminal act is
intended to eliminate the danger the defendant will be convicted
even though there is no single offense all the jurors agree the
defendant committed.” (Zavala, supra, 130 Cal.App.4th at
p. 768.) However, “[t]here is a well established exception to the
unanimity instruction requirement in cases in which the
defendant is charged with violating a statute by a continuous
13
course of conduct.” (Ibid.) “[T]here is no need for a unanimity
instruction as to individual acts within the course of conduct,
because the jury need only agree on whether the defendant
committed acts the net effect of which constitutes the statutory
offense.” (Id. at p. 769.) Stalking is “self-defined to require a
course of conduct.” (Ibid.)
The evidence shows that Murray’s stalking consisted of one
continuous course of conduct. The prosecutor did not make any
meaningful distinction between Murray’s conduct for purposes of
the stalking conviction. “Because [Murray] was charged with a
‘course of conduct’ offense occurring over a period of time, we
conclude that the continuing course of conduct doctrine applies
and, therefore, no unanimity instruction was required.” (Zavala,
supra, 130 Cal.App.4th at p. 769.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL
REPORTS
MORI, J.
We concur:
COLLINS, acting P. J.
TAMZARIAN, J.
14
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.