CourtListener 10709882•Olaniyi v. Baksh CA2/4
Texto completo
Filed 10/23/25 Olaniyi v. Baksh CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
CHARLES K. OLANIYI, B333197
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 20CMCV00027)
v.
AJIM BAKSH,
Defendant and
Respondent.
APPEAL from judgment of the Superior Court of the
County of Los Angeles, Michael J. Shultz, Judge. Affirmed.
Charles K. Olaniyi, in pro. per., for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Law Office of Jillisa L. O’Brien, Jillisa O’Brien, Conor H.
McElroy, and Jack David Mantych for Defendant and
Respondent.
Appellant and plaintiff in pro. per. Charles K. Olaniyi
purchased a duplex. After allegedly discovering various
construction defects, he sued the builder, defendant and
respondent Ajim Baksh dba Baksh Construction (Baksh), for
breach of warranty and fraud. Olaniyi presented his case at a
bench trial, and after he rested, the trial court granted Baksh’s
motion for judgment pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure,
section 631.8.1 Judgment was entered for Baksh, and Olaniyi
appealed. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Operative Complaint
We summarize the relevant allegations of Olaniyi’s
operative verified fourth amended complaint.
Baksh constructed the subject duplex, and in early
November 2017, executed a written warranty. The warranty
covered defects in the workmanship and materials but was
limited to “such instances of substantial nonconformity” as to
which Olaniyi “shall have given written notice to [Baksh]” during
a one-year period.
After purchasing the duplex, Olaniyi allegedly discovered
problems with the flooring, drainage, sewer lines, water sprinkler
systems, landscaping, joists, foundation, roofing, and concrete.
He alleged that the installation of an air conditioning system was
not completed. Olaniyi also alleged that he notified Baksh of
defects in April and June 2018, and Baksh failed to fix the
problems, thereby breaching the warranty.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure, and undesignated references to rules are to the California
Rules of Court.
2
A cause of action for fraud was based on a Certificate of
Occupancy that Olaniyi allegedly received from Baksh. Olaniyi
characterized this document as a representation that the duplex
was “suitable for occupancy,” a statement that was false because
Baksh knew of the defects in the construction of the property.
Baksh allegedly intended to induce Olaniyi’s “reliance on
completeness and occupancy of the new construction,” and
Olaniyi completed the purchase in reliance on the
misrepresentation. Olaniyi’s alleged damages included loss of
use of the property, lost rental income, and repair costs.
B. Trial and Baksh’s Motion Under Section 631.8
Olaniyi represented himself at a bench trial. The only
witnesses he called were his wife and himself. He expressed his
desire to call three others (nonparties Jason Sparks, Ory
Rodriguez, and Mike Brown), but the court found that they were
not served with subpoenas requiring their attendance.
After Olaniyi rested his case, Baksh’s counsel orally moved
for judgment under section 631.8, arguing that essential
elements of the claims had not been established. Before Olaniyi
responded, the court explained the nature of the motion and told
him, “[Y]ou really want to address the elements of the cause of
action here.” Olaniyi argued in opposition to the motion. The
court offered Olaniyi the opportunity to reopen his case, and
though he initially indicated he wished to do so, he conceded he
had no further evidence to present.
The trial court began its ruling with a finding that
Olaniyi’s testimony “was just simply not credible on many, many,
many issues.” Addressing the breach of warranty claim, the
court found that the warranty required Olaniyi to notify Baksh of
3
defects in writing, and there was no proof he had done so.
Further, the warranty covered only instances of “substantial
nonconformity,” but the defects described at trial did not rise to
that level. Thus, it found that Olaniyi “cannot and did not prove
[his] case” for breach of warranty.
As for fraud, the trial court found the evidence insufficient
to establish Baksh’s knowledge of falsity in the Certificate of
Occupancy and warranty or his intent to induce Olaniyi’s
reliance. The court also found that Olaniyi failed to show any
reliance was justifiable. The court pointed to Olaniyi’s testimony
that he had independently obtained an inspection report that
disclosed problems with the property, which showed Olaniyi
“kn[e]w what the defects [were] prior to signing that sales
contract, and . . . signed it anyway.” As for damages, the court
acknowledged that the repair estimates Olaniyi offered had been
excluded as hearsay, resulting in a “disconnect at every level”
that left the court in a position where it “d[id]n’t really even know
what the full scope of the repairs should be.”
The court granted the motion and entered judgment for
Baksh. Olaniyi appealed.
DISCUSSION
A. Governing Law
Code of Civil Procedure, section 631.8 authorizes a party to
move for judgment after the opposing party “has completed his
presentation of evidence in a trial by the court.” The motion
enables the trial court, when it finds at the completion of
plaintiff’s case that the evidence does not justify requiring the
defense to produce evidence, to weigh evidence and make findings
of fact. (Kinney v. Overton (2007) 153 Cal.App.4th 482, 487.) The
4
court may enter judgment in favor of the defendant if it concludes
that the plaintiff failed to sustain its burden of proof. (Ibid.)
Ordinarily, we would review a judgment entered under
section 631.8 under the same standards as we review judgments
entered after a completed bench trial: factual findings are
reviewed for substantial evidence and questions of law are
reviewed independently. (Pettus v. Cole (1996) 49 Cal.App.4th
402, 424–425.)
B. Claims of Error, Inadequate Record, and Forfeiture
A trial court’s judgment is presumed correct, and it is the
appellant’s burden to demonstrate reversible error. (Jameson v.
Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 609.) Olaniyi asserts 10 claims of
error in this appeal.2 He argues that: (1) Baksh violated a
pretrial order by failing to exchange exhibits; (2) Baksh’s counsel
engaged in witness tampering by discouraging two nonparties,
Sparks and Rodriguez, from appearing at trial; (3) the trial court
improperly excluded some of his exhibits as hearsay; (4) the trial
court mishandled video evidence by playing one video with the
narrator’s voice muted and watching others outside of the
courtroom; (5) the court refused to allow him to read Baksh’s
discovery responses into the record; (6) Baksh’s counsel used
falsified deposition transcripts to impeach him; (7) the trial court
erroneously refused to compel the attendance of Brown, one of
Baksh’s experts; (8) Baksh falsified the warranty; (9) the trial
2 To the extent that Olaniyi attempts to assert more than the 10
contentions of error we can discern from the subheadings in his
opening brief, we deem such contentions forfeited. (Petrovich
Development Co., LLC v. City of Sacramento (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th
963, 976, fn. 9, citing Rule 8.204(a)(1)(B).)
5
court erroneously expelled his wife from the courtroom; and
(10) the section 631.8 motion was granted in error because of the
aforementioned errors and because it was not made in writing
pursuant to section 1005.
These purported errors are not cognizable, however,
because Olaniyi has failed to comply with basic tenets of
appellate practice that apply to attorneys and self-represented
litigants alike. (See Elena S. v. Kroutik (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th
570, 574.) He has failed to support many of his points with
cogent argument, citations to relevant legal authority, and
specific citations to the appellate record that would permit us to
analyze them properly. Because his arguments and the citations
to supporting evidence are insufficient, they are forfeited. (See
United Grand Corp. v. Malibu Hillbillies, LLC (2019) 36
Cal.App.5th 142, 153 [an appellant must supply the reviewing
court with cogent argument supported by legal analysis and
citation to the record]; Duarte v. Chino Community Hospital
(1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 849, 856 [arguments may be waived where
the appellant fails to provide appropriate references to the record,
including page citations].)
For example, Olaniyi argues that eight of his trial exhibits
should not have been excluded as hearsay because they qualified
as business records under Evidence Code, section 1271.
However, he fails to explain how each exhibit qualifies as a
business record. He also provides no citations to the record to
show he presented evidence to satisfy section 1271’s foundational
requirements, such as testimony from “custodian[s]” or other
“qualified witness[es]” describing each exhibit’s “identity and the
mode of its preparation,” and no such testimony is readily
6
apparent from the record. (Evid. Code, § 1271, subd. (c).) This
argument and other similarly defective arguments are forfeited.
Some of Olaniyi’s arguments are forfeited due to his failure
to make timely and specific objections to the trial court. (People
v. Jackson (2016) 1 Cal.5th 269, 328.) For example, Olaniyi did
not object when his wife was excluded from the courtroom after
she testified as a witness. Similarly, though he now argues that
an oral motion under section 631.8 was improper, he did not
object on this basis below. These and other points raised for the
first time on appeal are forfeited.
Finally, the record Olaniyi procured is insufficient to
permit us to review or confirm his claims of error. Appellants
cannot meet their burden on appeal with arguments unsupported
by the record. “Failure to provide an adequate record on an issue
requires that the issue be resolved against” the appellant.
(Hernandez v. California Hospital Medical Center (2000) 78
Cal.App.4th 498, 502.)
The record before us does not contain any pretrial order
addressing the exchange of trial exhibits. The trial court found
that Olaniyi failed to subpoena the witnesses who failed to
appear at trial, and the record contains no documents to indicate
otherwise. No deposition transcripts have been furnished despite
Olaniyi’s serious accusation that opposing counsel used falsified
transcripts at trial. Many of Olaniyi’s arguments pertain to the
admissibility or handling of trial exhibits, but none of these have
been provided. Testimony about an exhibit is not a substitute for
the exhibit itself. (See Sanders v. Walsh (2013) 219 Cal.App.4th
855, 874.) Because the first eight claims of error are
unreviewable due to an inadequate record, we resolve those
claims against Olaniyi.
7
Acknowledging the deficient record, Olaniyi has filed two
motions in this appeal. The first motion, seeking to attach a trial
exhibit to the opening brief, is denied. The exhibit (a building
plan) is not cited in his opening brief in support of any of the
10 claims of error, and he does not otherwise explain its
relevance.
The second motion cites rule 8.130(h)(1), which permits a
party to provide a settled statement describing proceedings for
which there is no reporter’s transcript. The rule is inapplicable to
Olaniyi’s motion because he does not seek to provide a settled
statement. Instead, he seeks leave to file an amended
designation that would add numerous new items to the record.
Thus, Olaniyi has provided no authority to support the granting
of his request.
Olaniyi’s motion does not request augmentation of the
record pursuant to rule 8.155, but had he done so, leave to
augment also would be inappropriate. His motion is unsupported
by good cause and noncompliant with the rule. (See Courtell v.
McEachen (1956) 147 Cal.App.2d 219, 221 [augmentation denied
due to appellants’ unexcused delay and failure to show good
cause].) Olaniyi fails to explain how each item he seeks to add to
the record relates to the specific claims of error on appeal. (Steele
v. International Air Race Association of America (1941) 47
Cal.App.2d 61, 63 [reviewing courts will not order documents to
be added to the record “except on a showing that they are
material to and will assist in a determination of the appeal on its
merits”].) There is also no showing that each item was filed or
lodged in the Superior Court. (Rule 8.155(a)(1)(A); Lewis v.
YouTube, LLC (2015) 244 Cal.App.4th 118, 123 [record on appeal
is generally limited to items that were part of the record at the
8
time judgment was entered].) Indeed, some of the proposed items
could not have been part of the Superior Court’s records because
they are argumentative statements, not records or transcripts.
For example, one of the “administrative proceeding[s]” Olaniyi
proposes to include in the appellate record is the “Court’s
preferential treatment of defendant over plaintiff” during trial.
Finally, Olaniyi has failed to attach copies of any documents he
seeks to have added to the record. Thus, we deny this motion.
In sum, all of Olaniyi’s claims of error are either forfeited,
are unsupported by an adequate record, or both.
C. Failure to Demonstrate Prejudicial Error
Even if we were to find merit in Olaniyi’s claims of error, he
has not shown that the errors warrant reversal of the judgment
after trial. “Only prejudicial error results in reversal of a
judgment. Error is prejudicial when it is probable that the party
against whom it was made would have achieved a better result
but for the error.” (Sargent Fletcher, Inc. v. Able Corp. (2003) 110
Cal.App.4th 1658, 1674, citing Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13; Code
Civ. Proc., § 475.) Here, Olaniyi has not shown that the
purported errors prevented him from establishing the essential
elements of his claims.
The trial court granted the section 631.8 motion based on
its finding that Olaniyi failed to establish multiple elements of
breach of warranty and fraud. Two of these failures are sufficient
to illustrate the absence of prejudicial error. First, a breach of
warranty was not proved because the warranty covered only
those defects described in a timely written notice to the
warrantor, and the trial court found no evidence that such a
notice was delivered to Baksh. Second, fraud was not proved
9
because Olaniyi did not justifiably rely on any misrepresentation;
instead, he purchased the duplex with knowledge of defects that
had been reported by the property inspector he independently
retained.
Olaniyi does not explain how the alleged errors prevented
him from proving these elements. He does not contend that he
was prevented from presenting evidence that proved delivery of a
written notice of defects to Baksh. He also does not explain how
any of the errors could have changed the finding of no justifiable
reliance, which was predicated on an inspection report that
Olaniyi himself offered at trial. Accordingly, Olaniyi has failed to
demonstrate prejudicial error.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Baksh is awarded his costs on
appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
MORI, J.
We concur:
ZUKIN, P. J.
TAMZARIAN, J.
10
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.