CourtListener 10701302•In re J.H. CA2/4
Texto completo
Filed 10/13/25 In re J.H. CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
In re J.H. et al., Persons B336802
Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. Nos.
23CCJP02377,
23CCJP02377A,
23CCJP02377B)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent.
v.
M. H.,
Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed.
Serobian Law and Liana Serobian, under appointment by
the Court of Appeal, for Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Avedis Koutoujian Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
Father Michael H. appeals from a juvenile court exit order
under Welfare and Institutions Code section 362.41 assigning
physical and legal custody of his two children, J. H. and G. H., to
their mother, with monitored visitation for father. Father argues
that the juvenile court failed to consider the children’s best
interests, and the order was not supported by the evidence.
We affirm. Father asserts the court’s findings regarding
his drug abuse were unsupported, but the record includes ample
evidence that father had unaddressed drug abuse issues and
lacked insight into his mental health condition – a combination
that contributed to a cycle of domestic violence in the children’s
home. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in finding
that the children’s best interests would be served by awarding
mother sole physical and legal custody and ordering that father’s
visits must be monitored.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The following is an abbreviated background summary,
focused on issues relevant to father’s arguments on appeal.
A. Detention
J. H., born in February 2017, and G. H., born in February
2019, came to the attention of the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) in May
2023. A court had recently issued a temporary restraining order
1 All undesignated section references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
protecting mother and the children from father based on
allegations of domestic violence. The report stated that father
had “showed up unannounced” at mother’s home, “threatening to
kill the mother and the family.”
A children’s social worker visited mother in May 2023.
Mother reported that father had a long history of drug use and
domestic abuse. Mother said that father previously had been in a
substance abuse treatment program, but he was dismissed from
the program for taking drugs not prescribed to him. In 2021
father began showing signs of mental illness; in 2022 he was
diagnosed with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia and was
prescribed medication. The children witnessed parts of the
abuse. In 2020 or 2021, for example, the children saw father
“storming upstairs and charging at” mother. Mother closed the
door to the room in which the children were watching television.
Father then picked mother up, dragged her, and slammed her to
the floor. After the incident, the children asked mother if she
was okay, and mother told them she fell. When the social worker
spoke with J. H. and G. H. in 2023, they both denied seeing or
hearing any abuse.
Mother said she and father separated in April 2022 after
another violent incident. In May 2022, father was involuntarily
hospitalized after an “episode” in which he heard voices, became
irate, and became violent with family members who attempted to
restrain him. Mother sought a restraining order in 2023 after
father “forced his way into maternal grandmother’s house,”
threatening to kill mother.
A social worker’s attempts to contact father in person and
by phone were unsuccessful. A one-year domestic violence
restraining order was entered in June 2023, protecting mother
3
and the children from father, and granting sole physical and legal
custody to mother with supervised visitation for father.
In July 2023, DCFS filed a petition seeking jurisdiction
under section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b). Allegation a-1
asserted that mother and father had a long history of engaging in
violent confrontations, including that father hit, dragged, and
choked mother, which placed the children at risk of serious
physical harm. Allegation b-1 included similar allegations, and
asserted that mother failed to protect the children. Allegation b-
2 stated that father had a history of substance abuse that
rendered him incapable of providing adequate care for the
children, and mother failed to protect the children. Allegation b-
3 stated that father had a history of mental and emotional
problems that endangered the children, he failed to take his
prescribed medications, and mother failed to protect the children.
At the detention hearing on July 31, 2023, the court found
a prima facie basis for jurisdiction. The court ordered the
children released to mother with monitored visitation for father.
B. Jurisdiction and disposition
In the jurisdiction/disposition report filed on August 31,
2023, mother confirmed her previous statements about father’s
physical abuse, drug use, and psychological issues. She said the
children did not directly witness the incident in which father
slammed mother to the floor, but they were crying because they
heard father screaming. Mother said father’s previous drug
treatment program in 2020 or 2021 was meant to address his
addiction to Xanax and opioids. He did not complete the
program. Mother did not think the children should be with
father unmonitored because “[d]rug use impacts the way he can
care for two children. You have to learn how to multi-task. They
4
need 100% of your full attention. I don’t think that’s something
he can be capable of.”
The children’s paternal grandmother confirmed father’s
drug use and psychological issues, but said she thought mother
was making allegations against father because she didn’t want
him to see the kids. Paternal grandmother said that “things
started going wrong” with father around 2020 when he became
addicted to opiates after an accident. Father’s family “wanted to
get him on the Suboxone again. Suboxone is for when you are
addicted to Opiates.” Father was hearing voices. Paternal
grandmother said this was “[b]asically an auditory psychosis but
[he] never . . . wanted to hurt anybody,” it was just “paranoia.”
Paternal grandmother said that father was now “taking an
injection to help him not go into a psychosis,” and since he
started going to church “he believed that God helped him not to
hear the voices anymore.” Paternal grandmother said that when
father was in psychosis, the family did not allow him to be near
the children. She said he would be safe around the children now
because he was mentally stable. Father, who had three
monitored visits per week with the children, did not make
himself available to DCFS.
At the disposition hearing on September 15, 2023, mother
pled no contest to the petition. Father’s counsel argued that the
petition allegations were “all lies made up by the mother,” and
that father posed no current risk to the children.
The court noted that father was in denial and lacked
insight into the allegations. The court also observed that father
did not make himself available to DCFS or participate in testing
so there was a lack of contradictory evidence. The court
sustained the petition but ordered it amended as to mother,
5
finding she had been “unable” to protect the children. The court
ordered that the children remain in mother’s care with monitored
visitation for father. The court also ordered father to enroll in
and complete a drug treatment program, mental health
counseling, parenting classes, and a domestic violence program.
C. Termination of jurisdiction
The interim review report filed on December 26, 2023
stated that the children were doing well living with mother and
their maternal grandparents. At the time a children’s social
worker met with father on December 13, father reported that he
had not yet enrolled in domestic violence or parenting classes.
Father said he could not afford the programs and asked for
financial assistance. Father said he suffered from anxiety and
was meeting with a psychiatrist once per month online. Father
stated that “he has met with many psychiatrists in the past and
none has been able to meet his needs,” because none would
prescribe him the medication that “works for him,” alprazolam
(Xanax). Thus, father was taking alprazolam that he got from an
uncle. Father also said he was taking prescribed suboxone “for
pain and anxiety.” Father said he was attending online drug and
alcohol classes and Narcotics Anonymous. He did not have a
sponsor. Between October 20 and December 6, 2023, father
tested positive for alprazolam multiple times. He tested negative
on November 17 and missed a test on December 6.
Father was visiting the children two to three times per
week. G. H. enjoyed the visits, but sometimes J. H. did not want
to take part. The restraining order remained in place.
The status review report filed February 28, 2024 stated
that the children’s visits with father continued to go well. Father
had enrolled in domestic violence classes, parenting classes, and
6
individual counseling; his drug tests were negative for opioids
and cocaine, and he had missed two tests. Father said he had not
enrolled in a 12-step program and Narcotics Anonymous would
not assign him a sponsor. Father said he did not know why the
court ordered him to participate in drug treatment because he
does not use drugs.
DCFS noted that father did not take responsibility for his
actions that led to DCFS involvement, and remained in denial
about his domestic violence, substance abuse, and mental health
issues. Father admitted he suffers from panic attacks for which
he takes medication, but DCFS noted it was “unclear if father has
fully grasped how mental health issues could affect his well-
being.” In addition, father was “conflicting and defensive when
[the social worker] reaches out to him.” Father did “not seem
remorseful and continuously blames [mother] for his conduct and
actions.”
The children were thriving in mother’s care, and mother
had completed parts of her court-ordered services. Mother was
remorseful for not removing the children from father’s care
earlier. Mother said she would not be comfortable leaving the
children alone with father, because he was in denial about what
he did in the presence of the children. DCFS recommended that
jurisdiction be terminated with a family law order granting
custody to mother with monitored visits for father.
t the section 364 review hearing on March 21, 2024,
father’s counsel asked that the case remain open, and that father
be granted unmonitored visitation. In the alternative, he asked
that the case close with an order for joint custody and
unmonitored visitation. Father’s counsel argued that father was
in compliance with his psychotropic medications and individual
7
counseling requirements, and he had completed five parenting
class sessions. He also argued that the majority of father’s drug
tests were “negative.”
Father submitted several exhibits, including a letter
stating that father was attending domestic violence classes and
parenting classes. He also submitted a letter from the Los
Angeles Centers for Alcohol and Drug Abuse, which stated that
father could not enroll in a substance abuse treatment facility
because, based on the program’s triage assessment, “we were
unable to make an appropriate substance abuse diagnosis at this
time.” The attached triage papers stated that father was there
because DCFS referred him, and father had “No history of alcohol
or any other drugs used.” A letter from MELA Counseling
Services Center also stated that father did not meet the criteria
for substance abuse treatment because father reported that he
had “No history of alcohol or any drugs used.”
The children’s counsel joined DCFS in requesting that
mother be granted full custody and father’s visits be monitored.
The children’s counsel asserted that “liberalization is not
appropriate at this time” because mother had addressed case
issues, but “Father is absolutely in denial about the domestic
violence, about his mental health issues and substance abuse
issues. [¶] He continues to blame the mom for everything that
happened to him and the family.”
Mother’s counsel “join[ed] wholeheartedly in minors’
counsel[’s] argument.” She asserted that mother posed no risk to
the children, the restraining order was still in place, and father,
“despite his[ ] recent progress, does not appear to have
demonstrated any insight.” DCFS joined the minors’ and
mother’s arguments.
8
The court found that the conditions justifying jurisdiction
no longer existed as to mother. Conditions were not resolved as
to father, because despite the evidence and the sustained petition
regarding father’s drug abuse, father had told the service
providers he had no history of drug use. In addition, father had
waited months to enroll in the court-ordered programs, and he
had only completed five domestic violence classes. As a result,
the court said, “it is too early to liberalize his visitation and too
late to keep this case open.” The court stated that it would
terminate jurisdiction with an order giving mother sole physical
and legal custody. The court ordered the parties to mediate the
details of visitation, including holidays.
The final custody order, entered April 11, 2024, gave
mother sole physical and legal custody. Father’s visitation was to
be monitored by paternal grandmother or a monitor at father’s
expense. On the form stating the reasons for supervised
visitation, boxes were checked stating that father had not
completed parenting classes, individual counseling, or a drug and
alcohol abuse treatment program.
Father timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Father asserts that the juvenile court’s award of custody to
mother failed to take the children’s best interests into account,
and that the order requiring father’s visits to be monitored was
not supported by substantial evidence. Father also contends the
court made errors in law by requiring father to participate in a
drug treatment program because father did not have a substance
abuse problem. We find no error.
Section 362.4 authorizes a juvenile court to make “exit
orders” regarding custody and visitation upon terminating
9
dependency jurisdiction over a child. (See § 362.4, subd. (a); In re
J.M. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 95, 112.) “‘[I]n making exit orders,
the juvenile court must look at the best interests of the child.’
[Citations.] The court must be guided by the totality of the
circumstances and issue orders that are in the child’s best
interests.” (In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p. 112.) We
review the juvenile court’s exit order for abuse of discretion; thus,
we will not disturb the ruling unless the court has exceeded the
limits of legal discretion by making a determination that is
arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd. (Id. at p. 113.)
In asserting that the juvenile court’s order was erroneous,
father relies on the reasoning of (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090,
which also involved a father’s challenge to a juvenile court exit
order. In that case, the Court of Appeal stated, “Here, the
juvenile court made no express finding that granting sole
physical custody to mother would be in the children’s best
interests. Instead, the court stated, ‘It’s not appropriate to
reward a parent who does nothing in this court, so I’m not going
to make it joint legal.’ (Italics added.) The court thus granted
mother sole custody to avoid rewarding father, who had refused
to participate meaningfully in the case plan. This was an abuse
of discretion because an exit order must serve the best interests
of the children, not reward or punish one parent or another for
failing to comply with the case plan.” (Id. at pp. 1094-1095.)
After quoting In re N.M., father dedicates several pages of
his appellate brief minimizing the events that led to jurisdiction
before explaining that he is “not revisiting the jurisdictional
findings, but only is attempting to clear the factual record.” He
argues that he “substantially complied with the court’s
dispositional case plan,” and he did not qualify for drug
10
treatment “given his negative drug tests for almost one year.”
Father argues that DCFS therefore “failed to meet its burden of
proof that continuing out of home placement from father . . . was
warranted to protect [the children’s] safety or well-being, or that
it was in their best interests.” He also asserts that the order
“limiting father to only monitored visits was not in [the
children’s] bests interests and must be reversed.”
We are not persuaded. Unlike In re N.M., the court below
did not state or suggest that its order was intended to punish
father for his lack of compliance. To the contrary, the court
considered the best interests of the children by considering their
safety while in the care of each parent. The court noted that the
children were no longer at risk of danger in mother’s care.
Father, on the other hand, had admitted that he was taking
alprazolam without a prescription, which he was getting from an
uncle because he could not convince a doctor to prescribe it to
him.2 Most of father’s drug tests were positive for alprazolam.
Mother and paternal grandmother noted that father had a
history of opiate addiction, and that he had been discharged from
a drug treatment program for taking drugs. Father denied that
history to at least two different drug treatment programs who
then, on that basis, denied him admission. Father’s continued
disavowal and minimization demonstrated that he lacked insight
into the behaviors that placed the children at risk. That blind
2 We note that possession of alprazolam without a
prescription is illegal. See Health & Saf. Code, §§ 11350, subd.
(a); 11057, subd. (d)(1).)
11
spot could continue to place the children at risk during
unsupervised visits. (See, e.g., In re William B. (2008) 163
Cal.App.4th 1220, 1228 [it “generally is not in the minor[’s] best
interests” to place a child with a parent who has been “shown to
be a chronic abuser of drugs who has resisted prior treatment for
drug abuse”].) Based on the totality of the circumstances, we find
no abuse of discretion in the juvenile court’s custody award or
visitation order.
Father also argues that the court made a “mistake of law”
by requiring him to participate in a drug treatment program
“when it was deemed by two separate substance abuse treatment
programs that [he] did not meet the medical necessity for such
treatment and was ineligible to enroll, because he tested negative
for all substances for about a year and the Department failed to
produce a reason for such treatment.” He asserts it was error for
the juvenile court to continue to “force” him to enroll in a
program, despite these “circumstances beyond [father’s] control.”.
We typically review issues of law de novo. (See, e.g., In re
Isabella G. (2016) 246 Cal.App.4th 708, 718.) However, father
has not alleged a legal error. Instead, his argument is that the
evidence did not support the juvenile court’s order.3 As discussed
above, ample evidence supports the court’s findings. And the exit
3 To the extent father is challenging the juvenile court’s
initial requirement that he complete a drug and alcohol program,
that contention has been forfeited. (See Vascos Excavation
Group, LLC v. Gold (2022) 87 Cal.App.5th 842, 856, 857.) That
requirement was in the disposition order, which father did not
appeal. “An unappealed disposition order is final and binding
and may not be attacked on an appeal from a later appealable
order.” (B. D. v. Superior Court (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1132,
1152.)
12
order did nothing to “force” father to enroll in a drug treatment
program; it simply noted that one reason for requiring supervised
visitation was that father failed to comply with this aspect of the
court’s previous orders. Father therefore has failed to
demonstrate any error of law.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
VAN ROOYEN, J.*
We concur:
ZUKIN, P. J.
TAMZARIAN, J.
* Judge of the San Luis Obispo Superior Court, assigned by
the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.
13
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.