Dumpit v. Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions CA4/1

CourtListener 10674440Calctapp19 de set. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 9/19/25 Dumpit v. Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions CA4/1

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or
ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

MICHELLE DUMPIT et al., D083828

Plaintiffs and Respondents,

v. (Super. Ct. No. 37-2020-
00023700-CU-MC-CTL)
GREEN LEAF PAYROLL &
BUSINESS SOLUTIONS, INC. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Katherine A. Bacal, Judge. Affirmed.
Higgs Fletcher & Mack, John Morris and Steven M. Brunolli for
Defendants and Appellants.
Haight Brown & Bonesteel, Arezoo Jamshidi; Tencer Sherman and
Sam Sherman for Plaintiffs and Respondents.

Michelle Dumpit and Jonathan Daniel brought suit against their
former employer, Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc. (Green Leaf)
and its two majority shareholders, Kira Amundsen and Marc Rodriguez.
Dumpit and Daniel alleged Amundsen and Rodriguez fraudulently induced
them to leave high-paying jobs at their shared former employer, failed to pay
them while simultaneously misusing corporate funds, and then wrongfully
terminated them. After trial, the jury found in favor of Dumpit and Daniel
on their claims for failure to pay wages, retaliation, breach of contract, and
false promise. The jury also found that Green Leaf engaged in this conduct
with malice, oppression, or fraud. The jury awarded Dumpit $60,000 in lost
wages and $50,000 in emotional distress and awarded Daniel $84,000 in lost
wages and $75,000 in emotional distress. The jury also awarded Dumpit and
Daniel $250,000 each in punitive damages.
On appeal from the ensuing judgment, Green Leaf challenges only the
award of punitive damages. It argues insufficient evidence supported the
jury’s punitive damages award because (1) there was no evidence of its
financial condition at the time of trial and (2) the evidence concerning the
company’s value showed it was too low to support an award of $500,000. For
the reasons set forth below, we reject Green Leaf’s arguments and affirm the
judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Rodriguez, Amundsen, Dumpit, and Daniel worked together at
Paychex, a human resource services and payroll processing company.
Rodriguez was Dumpit’s and Daniel’s supervisor. Dumpit, Daniel, and
Amundsen all held sales roles at Paychex.
In 2018, Rodriguez and Amundsen decided to start a competing payroll
company, Green Leaf, that would focus on providing services to employers in
the cannabis industry. In the ensuing year, Rodriguez and Amundsen began
building Green Leaf and approached Dumpit and Daniel, who were also close
friends, about joining their venture.

2
In April 2019, Rodriguez and Amundsen left Paychex and began
working for Green Leaf full time. Daniel and Dumpit followed suit later that
year based on Green Leaf’s promise of certain compensation. Daniel testified
he was promised compensation of $7,000 per month and Dumpit testified she
was promised compensation of $10,000 per month. Daniel and Dumpit also
became minority owners of Green Leaf. Dumpit invested $50,000 into the
company in exchange for a 20% ownership stake, and Daniel was given a 10%
ownership stake for his work for the company before he left Paychex.
Once Daniel and Dumpit joined Green Leaf and were no longer working
at Paychex, they became concerned about Rodriguez’s and Amundsen’s
handling of the company’s finances. Neither Daniel nor Dumpit received any
compensation in 2019 and they became aware that Rodriguez was using
corporate funds for personal expenses. They also learned that cash received
from the company’s clients was missing. In early 2020, Daniel, Dumpit, and
another minority owner, Tyler Priest, investigated the company’s finances.
They discovered Rodriguez had used corporate funds for his personal
expenses, and confronted him and Amundsen.
At a meeting in February 2020, Daniel, Dumpit, and Priest explained
to Rodriguez and Amundsen that their business practices needed to improve.
Rodriguez and Amundsen responded no changes would be made and that
Daniel and Dumpit were not a good fit for their business. Shortly after,
Rodriguez, Amundsen, and Priest voted to remove Daniel and Dumpit as
shareholders of Green Leaf.
In July 2020, Daniel and Dumpit filed suit against Green Leaf,
Amundsen, and Rodriguez. The complaint alleged Amundsen and Rodriguez
misused corporate funds and fraudulently induced Daniel and Dumpit to
leave their lucrative jobs at Paychex to work for Green Leaf. Daniel and

3
Dumpit asserted claims for breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, violation of the
Unfair Competition Law, failure to pay wages in violation of the Labor Code,
wrongful termination, breach of contract, and retaliation. They also asserted
a claim for punitive damages. The case proceeded to trial in February 2023,
and, as relevant here, both parties introduced the expert testimony of
forensic accountants concerning damages and the value of Green Leaf.
Daniel and Dumpit’s expert, Steven Schenk, testified he was retained
to value Green Leaf as of December 31, 2021, and to evaluate Daniel’s and
Dumpit’s claims for unpaid wages. With respect to his valuation of the
company, Schenk first testified generally about different business valuation
approaches: (1) an asset-based approach, which he explained simply
subtracts a company’s liabilities from its assets; (2) an income approach,
which typically measures a company’s projected income on an annual basis,
then discounts back to a present value; and (3) a market approach, which
compares a company to other similar companies to estimate an appropriate
valuation. Schenk explained that he used both market and income based
approaches to value Green Leaf. He stated that because the company is
service-based, it holds few assets, and thus, the asset-based approach would
not yield an accurate valuation.
Schenk also explained there were two types of market valuation
approaches, the revenue multiplier method and the Earnings Before Interest,
Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) method. The revenue
multiplier approach looks at the revenue of similarly situated companies
compared to the stock price or the sale price of the company to determine its
value, while the EBITDA method compares a company’s cash flow to its stock
or sale price. Schenk used the revenue method to evaluate Green Leaf
because the financial information that the company provided to the plaintiffs

4
in the discovery showed “they didn’t make any money.” Schenk, however,
clarified that this did not establish the business had no value because of the
importance of revenue to valuation and Green Leaf produced significant
revenue.
Schenk testified he determined 1.1 to 1.2 times revenue was an
appropriate valuation for Green Leaf based on available data from the
marketplace. Schenk calculated the company’s value as of December 31,
2021, as $2,691,914. Schenk also testified that he had reviewed the report of
Green Leaf’s expert, Paul Zimmer, and that his calculations using the same
revenue multiplier approach were similar to Schenk’s calculation. Zimmer
used a multiplier of 1, rather than the 1.1 to 1.2 multiplier used by Schenk,
resulting in just a slightly lower valuation of Green Leaf of approximately
$2.5 million. Schenk also testified that the EBITDA approach used by
Zimmer was problematic because it used a lower multiplier than what would
be appropriate based on the data Zimmer examined. Finally, Schenk opined
that the discounts that Zimmer applied to the value for lack of control and
marketability were too steep.
During his testimony, Zimmer testified he was retained to value a 10%
and 20% minority interest in Green Leaf as of May 31, 2022. Zimmer
calculated value using each of the methods discussed by Schenk. He testified
the book value of the company, i.e. the asset-based approach, was negative
$255,631; under the income based approach, Zimmer found the value was
$563,074; and under the market valuation approach, he concluded the value
was $644,992. Zimmer also opined that after considering the totality of the
circumstances and his calculations, as well as applying discounts for lack of
control and marketability, the company’s value on May 31, 2022 was
$370,000. In Zimmer’s opinion, the market valuation approach was the least

5
reliable approach because there was limited data about companies
comparable to Green Leaf. Zimmer criticized Schenk’s market valuation
analysis as using companies that were not sufficiently equivalent to Green
Leaf.
On cross-examination, Zimmer testified that in calculating the
company’s value, he assumed revenue of approximately $340,000 per month
based on Green Leaf’s financials from February, March, April, and May

2022.1 From these figures, he projected revenue of $3.6 million, then applied
a cash flow multiplier of 3.4% to arrive at a value of $563,074 under the
income based valuation approach.
Before it began its deliberations, the jury was specifically instructed
with respect to punitive damages. In addition to explaining that such an
award was appropriate only if the jury determined the defendants engaged in
conduct “with malice, oppression, or fraud,” and defining those terms, the
instruction explained: “There is no fixed formula for determining the amount
of punitive damages, and you are not required to award any punitive
damages. If you decide to award punitive damages, you should consider all of
the following factors in determining the amount: [¶] (a) How reprehensible
was Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc.’s conduct? In deciding
how reprehensible Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc.’s conduct
was, you may consider, among other factors: [¶] 1. Whether the conduct
caused physical harm; [¶] 2. Whether Green Leaf Payroll & Business
Solutions, Inc. disregarded the health or safety of others; [¶] 3. Whether
Michelle Dumpit and Jonathan Daniel were financially weak or vulnerable
and Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc. knew Michelle Dumpit

1 Consistent with Zimmer’s analysis, Rodriguez testified that Green
Leaf’s revenue for calendar year 2022 was “around four million.”
6
and Jonathan Daniel were financially weak or vulnerable and took advantage
of them; [¶] 4. Whether Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc.’s
conduct involved a pattern or practice; and [¶] 5. Whether Green Leaf Payroll
& Business Solutions, Inc. acted with trickery or deceit. [¶] (b) Is there a
reasonable relationship between the amount of punitive damages and
Michelle Dumpit and Jonathan Daniel’s harm? [¶] (c) In view of Green Leaf
Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc.’s financial condition, what amount is
necessary to punish them and discourage future wrongful conduct? You may
not increase the punitive award above an amount that is otherwise
appropriate merely because Green Leaf Payroll & Business Solutions, Inc.
has substantial financial resources.”
After the conclusion of trial, the jury returned its verdict in favor of
Daniel and Dumpit. In its special verdict, the jury found Dumpit and Daniel
performed work for Green Leaf and that the defendants willfully failed to pay
Dumpit and Daniel. The jury also found in favor of Dumpit and Daniel on
their claims for failure to pay wages, retaliation, breach of contract and false
promise. The jury awarded Dumpit $60,000 in lost wages and $50,000 in
emotional distress and awarded Daniel $84,000 in lost wages and $75,000 in
emotional distress. In addition, the jury found that with respect to Daniel
and Dumpit’s claims, Green Leaf “engage[d] in conduct with malice,
oppression, or fraud.” The jury awarded $500,000 against Green Leaf in
punitive damages, divided equally between the plaintiffs. Thereafter the
court entered judgment in accordance with the verdict.
After judgment was entered, Green Leaf moved for judgment
notwithstanding the verdict, asserting insufficient evidence supported the
punitive damages award. Specifically, Green Leaf argued there was no
evidence concerning Green Leaf’s financial condition that could support the

7
award. Green Leaf also moved for a new trial on the grounds the punitive
damages award was excessive. Daniel and Dumpit opposed both motions.
They argued there was sufficient evidence to support the award, pointing to
Zimmer’s testimony that Green Leaf’s revenues were between $300,000 and
$3[4]0,000 per month, and that the company’s profit and loss statements
were not reliable because the payroll expenses had been manipulated to show
a negative profit to avoid tax liability.
After a hearing, the trial court denied both motions. The court found
sufficient evidence to support the punitive damages award, and pointed to
the experts’ testimony, specifically Zimmer’s testimony concerning the
company’s monthly revenue. The trial court also stated, “the jury received
evidence concerning the company’s financial condition and ability to pay
beyond Green Leaf’s profit and loss statements.”
Green Leaf timely appealed.

8
DISCUSSION
I
Legal Standards
“Civil Code section 3294 provides, ‘In an action for the breach of an
obligation not arising from contract, where it is proven by clear and
convincing evidence that the defendant has been guilty of oppression, fraud,
or malice, the plaintiff, in addition to the actual damages, may recover
damages for the sake of example and by way of punishing the defendant.’
Here, [Green Leaf] does not challenge the [fact finder]’s decision that the
evidence demonstrated [it] was guilty of oppression, fraud, or malice, that
would justify punitive damages. [It] only challenges the amount of the award
and the strength of the evidence considered by the [jury] in making the
award.” (Doe v. Lee (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 612, 618 (Doe).)
“ ‘[O]bviously, the function of deterrence … will not be served if the
wealth of the defendant allows him to absorb the award with little or no
discomfort. [Citations.] By the same token, of course, the function of
punitive damages is not served by an award which, in light of the defendant’s
wealth … exceeds the level necessary to properly punish and deter.’ ” (Doe,
supra, 79 Cal.App.5th at p. 619.) The “most important question is whether
the amount of the punitive damages award will have deterrent effect—
without being excessive. Even if an award is entirely reasonable in light of
the other two factors …, the award can be so disproportionate to the
defendant’s ability to pay that the award is excessive for that reason alone.”
(Adams v. Murakani (1991) 54 Cal.3d 105, 111 (Adams).)
“Our Supreme Court has not prescribed a rigid standard for measuring
a defendant’s ability to pay. [Citations.] Accordingly, there is no one
particular type of financial evidence a plaintiff must obtain or introduce to

9
satisfy its burden of demonstrating the defendant’s financial condition.
Evidence of the defendant’s net worth is the most commonly used, but that
metric is too susceptible to manipulation to be the sole standard for
measuring a defendant’s ability to pay. [Citations.] Yet the ‘net’ concept of
the net worth metric remains critical. ‘In most cases, evidence of earnings or
profit alone are not sufficient “without examining the liabilities side of the
balance sheet.” [Citations.]’ [Citations.] Evidence of a defendant’s income,
standing alone, is not ‘ “meaningful evidence.” ’ [Citation.] ‘Normally,
evidence of liabilities should accompany evidence of assets, and evidence of
expenses should accompany evidence of income.’ ” (Soto v. BorgWarner Morse
TEC Inc. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 165, 194 (Soto).)
“ ‘ “Without evidence of the actual total financial status of the
defendants, it is impossible to say that any specific award of punitive damage
is appropriate.” [Citation.]’ [Citation.] ‘Thus, there should be some evidence
of the defendant’s actual wealth’ [citation], but the precise character of that
evidence may vary with the facts of each case.” (Soto, supra, 239 Cal.App.4th
at pp. 194–195; see also Kelly v. Haag (2006) 145 Cal.App.4th 910, 915 (Kelly)
[“ ‘ “[n]et worth” is subject to easy manipulation and, in our view, it should
not be the only permissible standard. Indeed, it is likely that blind adherence
to any one standard could sometimes result in awards which neither deter
nor punish or which deter or punish too much’ ”].) Additionally, “[t]he
evidence should reflect the named defendant’s financial condition at the time
of trial.” (Soto, at p. 195.)
“Evidence of a defendant’s financial condition is a legal precondition to
the award of punitive damages. [Citation.] We examine the record to
determine whether the challenged award rests upon substantial evidence.
[Citations.] If it does not, and if the plaintiffs had a full and fair opportunity

10
to make the requisite showing, the proper remedy is to reverse the award.”
(Soto, supra, 239 Cal.App.4th at p. 195; see also Kelly, supra, 145 Cal.App.4th
at p. 916 [“A substantial evidence standard of review applies, in which all
presumptions favor the trial court’s findings and we view the record in the
light most favorable to the judgment.”].) In addition, “ ‘[o]ur review of
punitive damage awards rendered at the trial level is guided by the
“historically honored standard of reversing as excessive only those judgments
which the entire record ... indicates were rendered as the result of passion
and prejudice.” ’ ” (Kelly, at p. 916.)
II
Analysis
Green Leaf asserts the punitive damage award must be reversed
because there was no evidence of its financial condition at the time of trial
and because Schenk’s opinions on the company’s value failed to take into
consideration its liabilities. We disagree and conclude the punitive damage
award was based on substantial evidence. While it is true that the most
recent financial information presented to the jury was from eight months
before the trial, this information was not so remote as to invalidate its
accuracy.
In support of its assertion that the financial information presented to
the jury was outdated, Green Leaf relies on Kelly, supra, 145 Cal.App.4th
910. In Kelly, the court found the defendant contractor liable for negligence
and fraud after his workers caused a flood in the plaintiff’s property. In
addition to compensatory damages, the court awarded the plaintiff $75,000 in
punitive damages after finding the defendant had a minimum net worth of
$750,000. (Id. at p. 914.) The evidence supporting the award, however, was
limited to statements the defendant and his sister made to the plaintiff that

11
the defendant owned two valuable properties. There was no evidence
admitted at trial that the defendant still owned the properties, what the
properties were worth, or whether the properties were encumbered by any
liabilities. In reversing the award, this court held that while it was possible
the defendant had “sufficient wealth that $75,000 would serve the deterrent
purpose of punitive damages without bankrupting him, … there was simply a
failure of proof and thus the award cannot stand.” (Id. at p. 917.)
Unlike Kelly, where there was simply no evidence of the defendant’s
ability to pay the punitive damage award, here the jury was provided with
specific detailed evidence concerning Green Leaf’s value and its financial
condition. Specifically, the company’s own valuation expert, Zimmer,
testified his valuation considered the most recent financial information that
was available, including the company’s tax returns from 2018 to 2021, and
financial statements prepared by the company through May of 2022, the year

before trial began.2 As Dumpit and Daniel point out in their briefing before
this court, Zimmer testified that the financial statements provided by Green
Leaf (and admitted into evidence) showed that in 2022 the company was
generating revenue between $300,000 and $340,000 per month and
Rodriguez similarly testified that Green Leaf brought in approximately $4

million in revenue in 2022.3
In addition, the plaintiffs’ expert, Schenk, testified extensively about
his valuation methodologies and how he arrived at a value for the company of

2 Those documents were also entered into evidence.

3 Green Leaf filed two motions to augment the record on appeal to
include its 2020 and 2021 tax returns, and certain financial statements from
2018, 2019, and 2022 that were admitted into evidence at trial. The
unopposed motions are granted.
12
approximately $2.6 million as of the end of 2021. Contrary to Green Leaf’s
assertion, Schenk’s valuation method took into consideration Green Leaf’s
liabilities. Further, there was evidence, which the jury appropriately
accepted, that the company manipulated its financial statements through its
payroll to reflect a negative profit and avoid tax liability. Zimmer himself
testified Green Leaf’s practice of intentionally driving down its profit was
“quite usual for” such a business.
In sum, we reject Green Leaf’s claim that there was insufficient
evidence to support the jury’s punitive damage award. The evidence showed
Schenk used an accepted methodology to value the company at $2.6 million,
the company had revenue of approximately $4 million the year before trial,
and the profit and loss statements showing a lack of profit was a function of
the company’s manipulation of its payroll liability, and not a result of its
liabilities overwhelming its assets. Accordingly, the award of $500,000 was
supported by the evidence before the jury.
Green Leaf also argues the $500,000 punitive damage award must be
reversed because it is greater than 10% of the value of the company, which
Green Leaf asserts was “no more than $560,000.” As an initial matter, we do
not agree with Green Leaf that an award greater than 10% of a company’s
value is per se improper. As discussed, the “California Supreme Court has
declined to prescribe any particular standard for assessing a defendant’s
ability to pay punitive damages.” (Kelly, supra, 145 Cal.App.4th at p. 915.)
“[W]hether a given percentage of net worth is excessive” cannot be distilled to
a formula, rather “each case must be decided on its own facts, considering …
various indicators of wealth.” (Rufo v. Simpson (2001) 86 Cal.App.4th 573,
625; see also Adams, supra, 54 Cal.3d at p. 116, fn. 7 [“We decline … to
prescribe any rigid standard for measuring a defendant’s ability to pay.].)

13
Zimmer’s valuation of the company as no greater than $560,000 was
contradicted by Schenk’s opinions that Zimmer significantly undervalued
Green Leaf, and that the company was worth far more. As discussed,
Schenk’s opinions were supported by Green Leaf’s tax returns, financial
statements, and Rodriguez’s and Zimmer’s testimony about the company’s
substantial revenue in 2022. While the punitive damage award was high, it
was not outside the bounds of reasonableness, and Green Leaf makes no
claim that it was awarded as a result of the jury’s passion or prejudice. (See
Devlin v. Kearny Mesa AMC/Jeep/Renault, Inc. (1984) 155 Cal.App.3d 381,
391 [“there is a range of reasonableness for punitive damages reflective of the
fact finder’s human response to the evidence presented”].)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Respondents are awarded the costs of
appeal.

McCONNELL, P. J.

WE CONCUR:

CASTILLO, J.

RUBIN, J.

14

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.