In re A.A. CA2/5

CourtListener 10662714Calctapp28 de ago. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 8/28/25 In re A.A. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re A.A., a Person Coming Under B338028
the Juvenile Court Law.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 20CCJP03983A)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

R.T.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Kristen Byrdsong, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Christopher R. Booth, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Kimberly Roura, Senior Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
In this appeal from an order establishing a legal
guardianship for R.T.’s (Mother’s) daughter A.A. (Minor), Mother
argues the juvenile court and the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (the Department)
did not fully comply with their obligations under California law
related to the Indian Child Welfare Act (Cal-ICWA). Specifically,
Mother argues the Cal-ICWA inquiry was inadequate because
the Department had contact information for some of Mother’s and
father F.A.’s (Father’s) relatives but did not question them about
potential Indian ancestry.1 We consider whether the juvenile
court’s Cal-ICWA investigation, which included notice to tribes
provided as a prudential matter, was sufficient to reach a reliable
conclusion that Cal-ICWA did not apply.

I. BACKGROUND
A. Summary of Dependency Proceedings
Mother has six children. When these dependency
proceedings commenced, her five older children were under the
jurisdiction of the dependency court in San Bernardino County
and were receiving permanent placement services. Two of the
five older children are also Father’s children. Father also has one
adult child, Kenneth, who has a different mother.
The Department began investigating the family’s welfare in
July 2020 when it was informed Mother and her significant other
engaged in domestic violence in Minor’s presence. That same
month, the Department filed a dependency petition alleging
Minor (then six years old) was at substantial risk of suffering
serious physical harm because (1) Mother’s significant other

1
Father is not a party to this appeal.

2
physically attacked her in Minor’s presence on numerous
occasions, and (2) Mother physically abused two of her five other
children by striking them with a belt. The Department later filed
an amended petition adding allegations that Father had a history
of endangering his other children, failed to reunify with them
after dependency cases were opened, and had a criminal history
that endangered Minor.
When the dependency proceedings commenced, Minor’s
whereabouts were unknown and Mother refused to disclose her
location.2 When the Department eventually located Minor, it
placed her in foster care.
The juvenile court assumed jurisdiction over Minor in April
2021, sustaining all but one of the counts in the petition.3 At a
disposition hearing in June 2021, the court terminated Mother
and Father’s reunification services.
In October 2022, the juvenile court granted Mother’s
section 388 petition and ordered reunification services for her. In
June of the following year, the court again terminated
reunification services and set the matter for a section 366.26
permanency planning hearing.
The court held the permanency planning hearing in May
2024. The court appointed a guardian for Minor and terminated
juvenile court jurisdiction.

2
When Father was first contacted by the Department, he
reported he had not seen Minor in a year.
3
The juvenile court dismissed the count alleged under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (a).
Undesignated statutory references that follow are to the Welfare
and Institutions Code.

3
B. Cal-ICWA Investigation
1. Father’s statement of Indian ancestry,
investigation, and prudential notice
In October 2020, when Father first appeared in the action,
he filed an ICWA-020 Parental Notification of Indian Status form
advising the court he was or might be a member of, or eligible for
membership in, the Choctaw tribe.4 The juvenile court ordered
the Department to investigate the claim and further instructed
the Department (independent of legal requirements) to provide
notice to all three federally recognized Choctaw tribes.
In early October 2020, a Department social worker
interviewed Father regarding the Indian ancestry in his family.
Father said he has Choctaw Indian ancestry on his mother’s side
of the family. Father did not know if any family members were
registered with a tribe. When asked if any other relatives would
have more information, Father said no. He also said the San
Bernardino County juvenile court did not find any Indian
ancestry in prior proceedings involving some of his other
children.
The social worker also spoke with paternal aunt Desiree,
and she similarly reported there was Indian ancestry on her
mother’s side of the family. Desiree said no one in her family was
registered with a tribe, but she was told by her mother and
grandmother that they had Indian ancestry in the Creek tribe.
Desiree’s mother and grandmother were deceased, however, and
she said no other relatives would have more information. During
a later conversation with a Department social worker, Desiree

4
Father was represented by counsel, but he was not present
at the hearing.

4
said her great-great-grandmother Adeline was a member of the
Choctaw tribe. But Desiree explained Minor would not qualify
for membership in the tribe because Adeline was too distant an
ancestor—explaining she (Desiree) was not even a tribal member.
The appellate record indicates the Department sent notices
to twelve Choctaw and Creek tribes. The notice forms included
Minor’s name and the names of Mother, Father, all four biological
grandparents, and all paternal great-grandparents.5 The notices
included the date and place of birth of both paternal
grandparents, as well as the paternal grandmother’s date of
death. It included the dates of birth and death for both paternal
great-grandmothers; the names of paternal great-grandfathers
(with no other associated information); and the date and place of
birth for both maternal grandparents. No information on the
maternal great-grandparents was included in the notices.
The Department contacted or attempted to contact certain
other paternal relatives, but it does not appear the Department
asked them about potential Indian ancestry. The Department
attempted to call paternal aunt Stacie in September 2020 and
March 2024 but was unable to reach her. (The social worker who
called was unable to leave a message either time because her
mailbox was full.) A Department social worker spoke to Father’s
adult son Kenneth once, and also had contact with paternal
cousin Brianna (the daughter of paternal aunt Desiree). The
record also does not reflect the Department discussed Indian

5
The Department had sent an earlier round of ICWA notices
to the three Choctaw tribes, which included some, but not all, of
the information described above. All three tribes were also
included in the later set of notices.

5
ancestry with any of Father’s other minor children, who were
subject to dependency court jurisdiction in San Bernardino
County.

2. Mother’s statement of Indian ancestry,
investigation, and prudential notice
Mother first appeared in dependency court in November
2020. She submitted an ICWA-020 form asserting the maternal
side of her family had Cherokee ancestry. The juvenile court
ordered the Department to investigate.
A Department social worker interviewed maternal aunt
Reshaunda, who stated the family had Indian ancestry on her
mother’s side of the family, specifically, ties to the Seminole
Tribe. She also stated she was attempting to trace the family’s
Indian ancestry.
The appellate record indicates the Department sent notice
forms to six Cherokee and Seminole tribes. The notice identified
the Minor’s name and the names of Mother, Father, all four
biological grandparents, and all eight great-grandparents.
(Though the notices were sent as a result of Mother’s claim of
potential Indian ancestry, the box asking for “Tribe or Band, and
Location” for each maternal relative, including Mother, stated
“Does not apply”; the list of applicable tribes was instead
included in the boxes for the paternal relatives.) The form
included the date and place of birth for the maternal and
paternal grandparents. It included the place of birth of one
maternal great-grandmother but no additional information. The
form also included the names and dates of birth for both paternal
great-grandmothers.

6
3. Additional Cal-ICWA Details and Family
Contacts
An August 2020 report from the San Bernardino County
dependency proceeding involving Mother’s five older children
indicated the social worker in that case repeatedly inquired about
potential Indian ancestry during monthly contacts with maternal
great aunt Gladys and maternal uncle Raymond. Both
consistently asserted they were not aware of any Indian ancestry
in their family or for any of the children. The status report also
represented Cal-ICWA did not apply to any of the five children.
The Department contacted or attempted to contact certain
other maternal relatives, and for those others where contact was
made, there is no indication in the record that the Department
asked about potential Indian ancestry. A Department social
worker spoke to maternal grandmother Ramona a few times
early in the dependency proceedings (she died in late 2021), but
Ramona subsequently blocked calls from the social worker’s
number and purported not to be able to hear when the social
worker called from a different phone number.6 A social worker
also spoke with maternal grandfather Roosevelt once early in the
proceedings when the Department was trying to locate Minor,
but Roosevelt did not respond to subsequent Department
attempts to contact him. The Department had contact
information for maternal uncle Malik, but he did not answer a

6
Maternal grandmother Ramona appeared at one of the
dependency court’s hearings in October 2020. Though the court
spoke to her at the hearing regarding the possibility of placing
Minor with her siblings, the court did not ask about potential
Indian ancestry.

7
social worker’s call in March 2024 and the social worker was
unable to leave a voicemail because the mailbox was full. The
Department was also aware of a maternal great aunt Gerolyn,
but there is no indication in the record that she had any contact
with the Department while this case was pending. The record
also does not reflect the Department discussed Indian ancestry
with any of Mother’s older children.

C. Tribal Responses to the Cal-ICWA Notices and the
Juvenile Court’s Cal-ICWA Finding
Between October 2020 and April 2021, the Department
received responses from nine tribes indicating Minor was not an
“Indian child” as defined by ICWA: the Mississippi Band of
Choctaw Indians; the Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma; the Cow
Creek Band of Umpqua Tribe of Indians; the Poarch Band of
Creek Indians; the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians;
the Berry Creek Rancheria of Maidu Indians of California (the
Tyme Maidu tribe); the Cow Creek Sioux Tribe; the Eastern Band
of Cherokee Indians; and the Cherokee Nation.
Between March and May 2021, a Department social worker
called the eight tribes from which they had not received a
response on six separate dates, and left voicemail messages
requesting a return phone call.

8
At a hearing in September 2021, the juvenile court found
there was no reason to know Minor was an Indian child, and thus
Cal-ICWA did not apply. The court maintained that finding
throughout the subsequent proceedings.

II. DISCUSSION
Mother appeals the guardianship order and argues the
Department’s Cal-ICWA inquiry was inadequate because the
Department did not make inquiry of maternal grandfather
Roosevelt, paternal aunt Stacie, and paternal cousin Brianna, nor
did it make contact with maternal great aunt Gerolyn or
maternal uncle Malik. Mother additionally complains the
Department did not attempt to contact four of Minor’s half-
siblings on the paternal side of the family. The Department
argues its inquiry, including the notices sent to tribes (even
without every demographic field on the notice form completed)
with negative results, was adequate to discharge its Cal-ICWA
obligation—emphasizing it attempted to contact many of the
family members Mother now identifies (and lost contact with
others after they were no longer interested in talking to the
Department). On the facts presented in this case, the
Department has the better argument.7

7
We invited the parties to file supplemental briefs
discussing “whether the version of Welfare and Institutions Code
section 224.2 as amended by Assembly Bill No. 81 (2023-2024
Reg. Sess.) (Stats. 2024, ch. 656) applies in this appeal and, if so,
the effect the amendment has, if any, on the proper disposition of
the appeal.” Mother’s supplemental brief argued the amendment
was relevant only because it establishes the duty to inquire
begins much sooner before placement of a child in temporary

9
Under Cal-ICWA, the Department and the juvenile court
have “an affirmative and continuing duty to inquire whether a
child . . . is or may be an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a); see
also Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a).) Section 224.2,
subdivision (b) states “[i]nquiry includes, but is not limited to,
asking the child, parents, legal guardian, Indian custodian,
extended family members, others who have an interest in the
child, and the party reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the
child is, or may be, an Indian child and where the child, the
parents, or Indian custodian is domiciled.” Subdivision (e)(1) of
the same statute explains “[t]here is reason to believe a child
involved in a proceeding is an Indian child whenever the court,
social worker, or probation officer has information suggesting
that either the parent of the child or the child is a member . . . or
may be eligible for membership . . . in an Indian tribe.” Under
section 224.2, subdivision (e)(2), when reason to believe a child is
an Indian child exists, “further inquiry is necessary to help the
court, social worker, or probation officer determine whether there
is reason to know a child is an Indian child” and such further
inquiry includes contacting (among others) the tribe or tribes in
question. (§ 224.2, subd. (e)(2)(C).) This contact with tribes
“shall, at a minimum, include telephone, facsimile, or electronic
mail contact to each tribe’s designated agent for receipt of notices

custody and because it “applies the inquiry parameters contained
in section 224.1, which the statute previously only explicitly
assigned to the juvenile court, to the Department.” The
Department’s supplemental brief contended the amendment did
not apply to this appeal and would not change its view that
affirmance was required even if it did.

10
under [ICWA]. Contact with a tribe shall include sharing
information identified by the tribe as necessary for the tribe to
make a membership or eligibility determination, as well as
information on the current status of the child and the case.”8
(§ 224.2, subd. (e)(2)(C).)
For our purposes as a reviewing court, we must decide
whether the Department’s and the juvenile court’s discharge of
these statutory directives was adequate to reach a reliable
conclusion about the applicability of Cal-ICWA. (In re Dezi C.
(2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1134 [“The juvenile court’s factual finding
that [Cal-]ICWA does not apply is ‘subject to reversal based on
sufficiency of the evidence. (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(2).)’”]; see also id. at
1141 [a “juvenile court’s fact-specific determination that an
inquiry is adequate, proper, and duly diligent is ‘a
quintessentially discretionary function’ [citation] subject to a
deferential standard of review”]; id. at 1153 (conc. opn. of Kruger,
J.); In re E.W. (2023) 91 Cal.App.5th 314, 323.)

8
When there is reason to know a child is an Indian child, the
Department is required to provide formal notice to the tribe or
tribes in question as provided in section 224.3. (§§ 224.2, subd. (f),
224.3, subd. (a)(5).) Nothing in Cal-ICWA, however, precludes a
juvenile court from doing what the court did here: ordering the
Department to send notices to possibly implicated tribes as a
prudential matter and to aid in discharging its duty to determine
Cal-ICWA’s applicability. (See, e.g., In re P.H., Jr. (2024) 98
Cal.App.5th 992, 996, fn. 3 [“The Department and the juvenile
court may at times decide it is advisable to provide notice to
tribes as a prudential matter even when such notice is not
statutorily required”]; In re D.F. (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 558, 571
[“A suggestion of Indian ancestry is not sufficient under ICWA or
related California law to trigger the notice requirement”].)

11
Taking the maternal side of Minor’s family first, Mother
claimed possible Cherokee heritage and maternal aunt
Reshaunda, whom the Department interviewed, said the family
had Seminole heritage. The Department obtained reporting from
dependency proceedings in another county involving Mother’s
children where Cal-ICWA was found not to apply and maternal
great aunt Gladys and maternal uncle Raymond both denied any
Indian ancestry in their family. The Department had some early
contacts with now-deceased maternal grandmother Ramona
(during which we have no indication Cal-ICWA matters were
discussed), but she thereafter refused to have any communication
with the Department. The Department also made one initial
contact with maternal grandfather Roosevelt (again when we
have no information Cal-ICWA was discussed), but he thereafter
declined to have any communication with the Department too.
The Department attempted to contact maternal uncle Malik, but
he was unavailable.
As a result of the information the Department was able to
obtain, the Department sent notices to the federally recognized
Cherokee and Seminole tribes, and none responded Minor was a
tribal member or eligible for membership. We acknowledge the
notices sent were not fully complete, but they didn’t have to be—
formal notice was not statutorily required here. There was
sufficient information on the notices (names of all parents and
great-grandparents plus some additional identifying information)
that, when combined with the reporting the Department obtained
about Mother’s San Bernardino County dependency proceeding
and the inability to inquire with other maternal relatives who
ceased contact with the Department (see, e.g., In re D.S. (2020)
46 Cal.App.5th 1041, 1053 [social services agency “not required to

12
‘cast about’ for information or pursue unproductive investigative
leads”]), we believe the inquiry made was adequate to reach a
reliable conclusion that no further Cal-ICWA process was
required as to the maternal side of the family.
Turning to the paternal side of the family, Father claimed
he may have some Choctaw ancestry, but he volunteered that the
San Bernardino County juvenile court proceedings did not find
any Indian ancestry in earlier proceedings involving his other
children. Paternal aunt Desiree told the Department no one in
her family was registered with a tribe but she was told by her
mother and grandmother that they had Indian ancestry in the
Creek tribe. Her mother and grandmother were deceased,
though, and Desiree said no other relatives would have
information. Desiree also said her great-great-grandmother
Adeline was a member of the Choctaw tribe, but Desiree
explained Minor would not qualify for membership in the tribe
because Adeline was too distant an ancestor—explaining she
(Desiree) was not even a tribal member. The Department also
twice attempted to call paternal aunt Stacie but was unable to
reach her.9
As with the maternal side of the family, the information the
Department obtained allowed it to send notices to the Choctaw
and Creek tribes identified as a potential source of ancestry, and
none responded Minor was a tribal member or eligible for

9
The Department did have contact (but apparently no Cal-
ICWA discussion) with Father’s adult son and Desiree’s
daughter, but there is no reason to believe they would have
greater insight into any possible Indian heritage than Father or
Desiree themselves.

13
membership. Some of the fields on these formal notice forms
were incomplete too, but there was sufficient information (names
of all biological grandparents, all paternal great-grandparents,
and some additional identifying information) that, combined with
the other evidence developed by the Department and the
unavailability of other potentially productive investigative leads,
we believe the inquiry made was adequate to reach a reliable
conclusion that no further Cal-ICWA process was required as to
the paternal side of the family.

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

KIM (D.), J.

14

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.